Work Text:
For lack of a better word, the return journey is comfortable.
Now, by any standard of a respectable hobbit, it wouldn’t be. Bilbo’s clothing, while no longer missing buttons or torn by snaggles of thorns or claw marks or anything of the sort, is mismatched, a size too big for him, and all in all of awful fashion. He’s also carrying all of the things any respectable hobbit would not carry, starting off with Sting.
But there are no Orcs, no Wargs, no Goblins. There is no pervasive fear of having to check behind his back, no worry about being attacked, or captured, or lost, or hungry, or thirsty.
But there’s also no song, no tales around a crackling fire, no too-loud laughter. No quiet conversations, set apart just a few paces from the crowd, with a comfortable and steady presence that Bilbo has grown accustomed to as a constant in these past few months.
Of course, there’s Gandalf, and the wizard is fine company. Bilbo suspects that without him, he would’ve been starting conversations with himself out-loud in less than two days.
Their first stop, as they travel through Mirkwood, is the Woodland Realm.
Thranduil proves a decent host, and drinking his wine and eating his food is a lot less stressful now that it’s being freely offered. There’s much more of it too, and a comfortable bed to sleep on.
That, Bilbo does. The Wood Elves are of good humor, all silvery laughter and graceful movements, but Bilbo had retired from the feast early, citing fatigue. It’s not exactly a lie.
The bed is almost as comfortable as his own back home, in Bag End.
Yet, for some reason, Bilbo tosses and turns. It’s too soft. Too plush. There are too many pillows, the blankets are velvet and comfortable and it’s wrong. His body has grown far too familiar with the barely passable cushioning of a flimsy bedroll, of using anything he could get his hands on as a pillow. He’s grown used to sleeping around with thirteen obnoxiously loud dwarves, and now Bilbo is small and alone in a room that could hold fourteen but only houses one.
How—absurd. How incredibly absurd. Bilbo closes his eyes, darkness replacing the green canopy that he had been staring at, and wills his mind to slow down.
Sleep finally comes, but not until Bilbo drags a bundle of blankets onto the ground to sleep somewhere more familiar.
***
Thorin is brooding.
Quite frankly, this is one of the moments where Bilbo thinks that he must have some right to brood, because he’s been stuck behind the bars of the Elven dungeons for over a fortnight, if his calculations are anything to go from.
It had taken him time to find where Thranduil had locked him up. As opposed to the rest of the dwarves, he had been separated, taken to the lower dungeons, where light did not filter through the high ceilings.
And now, Bilbo sees him: the faint downpull of his lips, the way lines crease between his brows.
After ensuring that there are no guards around him, he takes off his ring. Feeling a burst of childish and immature excitement, Bilbo peers around the corner and holds up the keys, daring to let them clank against each other. “Thorin.”
Thorin’s reaction is very much worth it. His head snaps up, gaze searching until he meets Bilbo’s. He doesn’t smile fully, but the corners of his lips curve upwards, and his blue eyes brighten. It’s an expression that very much softens his features, and Bilbo’s heart, treacherous thing it is, does such a routine in his chest that would put the best dancer in the Shire to shame.
With a large stride, Thorin approaches the bars of the cell, his fingers wrapped around them. “Master Baggins,” he says in a hushed, low voice, surprise and relief and delight all unbidden before he seems to compose himself. “You found us.”
“Yeah,” Bilbo replies. Thorin’s gaze is so bright, and it occurs very suddenly that he’s the reason Thorin seems so pleased. The words start to tumble out until Bilbo doesn’t even know what he’s saying. “Yeah, but you were—well, you were the hardest to find. The rest of the Company is up there. I’d prefer to never wander around in Elvish dungeons for so long ever again, thank you very much! Even if it is better than the goblin tunnels.”
He unlocks the cell, and Thorin steps out.
For someone who has been stuck in confinement for such a long time, he still looks unfairly put together. Confident in his movements, in his words, so much so that Bilbo feels a little offended.
“Lead the way, Master Baggins,” Thorin is saying.
Bilbo shakes himself out of his stupor. He’s glad that sunlight doesn’t reach so far down in these parts of the dungeon, because then he’d really have no excuse for staring.
“Right.” No, that’s not a shake in his voice. Not even a bit. “This way, Thorin.”
***
Mirkwood’s gnarled trees and unrelenting canopy finally gives way to the plains. It is not long before they travel before Beorn’s house comes into view.
The shapeshifter welcomes them with enthusiasm. There are little tales to regale him with this time, at least not ones that he doesn’t already know.
The meals they share are still hearty, even if it is only the three of them. Bilbo likes it better here than Mirkwood—the elves may be graceful and lovely, but there is a certain coldness to their polite greetings, a careful distance. One that does not exist with Beorn, and it lessens the ache of empty spots just a little bit more.
Night is different.
Bilbo lays awake, sleep twisting out of his grasp like a slippery fish.
He’s arranged his bedroll near where he slept the first time. Beorn is out, patrolling their surroundings, and Gandalf has slunk off to who-knows-where, leaving Bilbo effectively the only one in Beorn’s home.
It’s not so much the fear of safety that steals sleep from him; rather, it’s the emptiness.
The last time they were here, it was the fourteen of them attempting to lay down their bedrolls in a fashion that was conservative of the somewhat crowded space. Thorin had been beside Bilbo, although when Bilbo was woken in the middle of the night by a very loud snore from Dwalin, Thorin was no longer in sight—bedroll ruffled and indicative of his previous presence.
He twists and turns and tries not to think of how it was like the last time they were here.
He falls asleep dreaming of it.
***
Bilbo does not know if this is friendship, or acquaintance, or camaraderie. All of the descriptors seem to fall just a little bit short of Thorin Oakenshield.
It’s not exactly friendship, because until a couple of hours ago, Thorin had made it clear that he thought Bilbo had no place in his Company. There lies no sea of misgiving between them anymore, but what remains to grow is still to be seen. They’re not exactly acquaintances, because all of Bilbo’s acquaintances are treated with distance, but polite distance. Thorin is not, and has never been, the definition of polite. Camaraderie seems wrong, too, because trust cannot be built in a day, especially not with a race as secretive and wary as dwarves.
Whatever it is, Bilbo finds himself outside, the night air blanketing coolly over his shoulders. At the edge of Beorn’s garden, Thorin sits on a rock, gaze fixed beyond. Brooding, no doubt.
He glances over his shoulder, having heard Bilbo.
“Master Baggins,” comes the greeting.
After a moment of indecision, Bilbo joins him at the rock.
“I recall Gandalf telling us it is best we stay inside,” Bilbo says.
“I am doubtful wandering a few feet from the house will make much of a difference.”
“Well,” Bilbo replies. “I suppose it will likely not! What are you doing out here, Thorin?”
Thorin’s blue eyes turn to the sky again. Silence spans between them, and Bilbo wonders if he has perhaps overstepped. Thorin had talked about repaying a life debt, but perhaps that extended only to grand gestures, ones that mirrored what Bilbo had supposedly done. Perhaps Thorin was waiting for the next time Bilbo was the one who got hit by a mace, chewed and thrown by a Warg, but not before nearly being baked to death in a tree—perhaps then he’d jump in and save Bilbo’s life (if he wasn’t dead already). Perhaps this new, tentative not-friendship-acquaintance-camaraderie does not extend to casual conversations, or late-night-inquiries.
Or maybe it does, because a moment later, Thorin heaves half of a sigh and says, “I could not sleep.” He tilts his head, gaze catching Bilbo’s. “And what of you, Master Baggins? Why did you wander out here in the middle of the night?”
“Dwalin’s snoring woke me up. Good grief, he is loud. I shall reconsider the placement of my bedroll tomorrow night.”
There’s an unfamiliar noise, somewhere between a huff and a growl. Surprised, Bilbo looks at Thorin, only to witness the faint upwards lift that tug at the corner of his lips.
“Are you laughing?” he asks, thoroughly shocked.
“I am, unless you Shire-folk have a different name for it.”
Yet another moment passes before Bilbo properly registers that Thorin is jesting with him.
It’s strange, it’s new, but it’s not unkind; it’s not bad. In fact, it’s rather nice.
They don’t talk about what happened with the Orcs, or what Thorin said on the Carrock. The conversation is light for as long as it’s held, and when they taper off to silence, Bilbo finds it more companionable than it is awkward.
When he retires again, he decides that he can definitely cross out acquaintance, and consider friendship or camaraderie.
He also picks up an acorn from the ground, under the tree he and Thorin had been sitting under. It rests in his pocket, so light that it becomes forgotten, for a little while.
***
No goblins ambush them in the mountains this time. During the most foul storms, Gandalf has them stay and shelter as the rain and wind mourn loudly outside the entrance of the cave.
The two of them sit, warm and dry and safe, in a cave that holds no danger of goblins, and Bilbo tries his very hardest (and fails) not to think about how miserable the mountain-trek had been on the way to Erebor, how many times he had nearly died, and also how Thorin had saved him when he had been dangling off the side of the cliff.
Then he wonders what would have happened if he really did manage to leave that time, if Bofur had not stopped him. Would he have gone to Rivendell, then back to his hobbit-hole, none the wiser? Would he have heard one day of Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain’s death, and felt distant sadness in passing—or would he even have known?
Bilbo and Gandalf cross the Misty Mountains, then stop at Rivendell. The stay is lengthier this time, with no grumbling dwarves who object at the very thought of lingering at an elvish dwelling for longer than they need.
Bilbo is well-fed. Well-treated. Welcomed. He smiles, he talks, and he tries his very best to ignore the weight of a small acorn in his pocket, which should not feel as heavy as it does.
Gandalf departs as they reach the borders of the Shire. The wizard is off with his well-wishes and meaningful words about magic rings, leaving Bilbo to complete the last leg of his journey alone.
He comes back to find his belongings auctioned, having to fight for the legitimacy of his identity, and the growing premonition that all his silverware has been vacated from their rightful containers. In a flurry of indignation, Bilbo momentarily forgets about everything but the fact that his home is being ransacked and yes, he’s very much alive, thank you very much, and he is still the legitimate owner of every item of his that is being carted off—but that anger, blissful in its thoughtlessness, dissipates all too soon.
“Who is Thorin Oakenshield?” the auctioneer asks him while peering at the contract, and the world stops again before Bilbo remembers he is yet to answer.
Minutes or hours later, with the crowd in front of Bag End dispersed, Bilbo steps through the doorway, into his home, for the first time in a year.
He stares.
And stares.
Later on, he would admit to himself that the emptiness doesn’t all come from the fact that Bag End has effectively been robbed of a good two-thirds of his belongings. But right now, it’s an easier alternative to accept. Yes, that’s all that it is—what’s left of his furniture is ajar, there is dust everywhere, and oh, would you look at that—the pictures of his parents are askew on their respective spots atop of the mantle.
This is his home. It has always been. Bilbo had promised Thorin that he would help the dwarves reclaim their home, because they didn’t have one, and he knew how valuable it was… yet now, what was once full of warmth and familiarity feels cold and deserted. His place of comfort has become nothing more but beams of smooth wood, of refined craftsmanship, yet nothing more. Just a lingering memory of fondness. Bilbo looks upon the pile of books that have been spared during the robbing, at his armchair that held little worth that wasn’t sentimental, and he does his utmost not to think of Thorin’s words as he bled and bled and choked out the last of his breath to apologize to Bilbo.
Slowly, Bilbo puts down his pack of belongings. He breathes in, coughs a bit at the dust. Then he sets to work.
***
Most of the Company are drinking, or they have drank so much that they’re passed out.
Thorin is no exception, even if he apparently handles his ale with much more grace than the rest. Which really isn’t that high of a standard to surpass.
Bilbo finds him on a balcony, one that faces the direction of the Lonely Mountain. The light of a lantern spills from the room behind them, illuminating them just enough for him to tell the faint flush across Thorin’s face.
“Master Burglar!” he exclaims in a volume that makes Bilbo startle. Then he grins, and Bilbo decides to focus on the fact that this means that Thorin is definitely very drunk, because Thorin doesn’t hand out smiles freely, much less smiles as wide as this. And Bilbo definitely does not think about how much he likes seeing Thorin smile. “I hope you have enjoyed yourself tonight! I believe you have not had such a large meal since you left the Shire, and I know you are constantly hungry.”
Bilbo waves a hand. “I drained Thranduil’s stores dry when I was hiding in his halls, believe me. It’s a shock that the elves didn’t notice anything missing.”
Thorin booms a laugh. “Very good, Master Baggins!” He’s become even louder, and Bilbo decides to hush him, festivities or not.
Sighing to himself, he holds out the reason he had come to find Thorin.
“Water,” Bilbo tells Thorin when he peers at the mug with a hopeful look. “It’s not more ale, mind you, don’t go looking so excited. You’re drunk enough as it is.”
To his relief, Thorin accepts the water. He raises it in a toast. “To you, Master Baggins!”
If being toasted with a glass of water is what makes him drink it, then so be it. Bilbo pats Thorin’s arm. “To me, yes, yes,” he echoes.
Thorin becomes quieter after he finishes the water, gaze sliding back to the silhouette of the Lonely Mountain—distant, but closer than they’ve ever been.
It’s a comfortable silence, one that they haven’t indulged in for quite some time.
When Thorin speaks again, his voice is quieter, his words a bit less ale-laced. “The last I saw Erebor, the dragon had already destroyed so much of it. I can only imagine that the worm has not left it better for wear.”
Thorin doesn’t talk about this often—or, really, at all. Bilbo peers at him. “What was it like before?”
“Grand.” The reply is almost immediate. It’s a short, almost plain word, for all of its meaning, because Bilbo is certain that Erebor can’t be contained in so little. Not from how he’s heard the other dwarves talk about it. Then, after a moment, Thorin seems to find the need to elaborate. “There is nothing quite so regal as dwarvish architecture, Master Baggins, and Erebor was the peak of its splendor. And the treasure…” His eyes clear. “But I must also say, the architects and engineers were ingenious in other ways also. Every habitable space within the mountain was heated during the coldest of winter, and we always had running water. Our dining halls could fit hundreds. It was a fine place to grow up in.”
To Bilbo, home has always been small and cozy. Sure, by hobbit standards Bag End was quite large, but it was never empty or imposing. He was so certain, when first hearing about Erebor, that he would feel no tug of homeliness for it, before the dragon or not. Hobbits were not suited for cold stone and treasure hoards. Hobbits liked their warm, comfortable smials; they liked gardens and flowers. And while Bilbo may not be the perfect embodiment of hobbit ideals (if this adventure is any proof of that), he’s not entirely insane.
But hearing Thorin talk about it with rare, melancholic fondness, and Erebor doesn’t seem so cold after all.
“I—I would have liked to have seen it,” Bilbo admits, and he’s surprised how the words slip out, easy as breathing, because a few months ago, they would’ve been a lie. Now, it’s the simple truth.
“I will rebuild it,” Thorin replies, but the fierceness in his voice no longer makes Bilbo jump. “When we defeat the dragon, I will remake Erebor into a home for all dwarves again.”
He shifts his body away from the mountain, so that he and Bilbo are standing face to face. Eyes bright, expression earnest—Bilbo is struck with the fact that he does not see Thorin Oakenshield so open like this very often.
“I would like to show you,” Thorin says, “what it was once like, and what it can be. Would you stay until then, Bilbo?” A moment of rare, rare hesitation. “Winter will be fast-approaching after Durin’s Day. Perhaps it would be safer as well if you made your return journey after the lands thaw?”
There it is again, the way his heart stutters with impractical hope at that offer. But the acknowledgement of it as foolhardy does little to change his mind. Bilbo does his best to fight down the smile, but ultimately accedes to defeat, reasoning that Thorin is probably still too drunk to take much of a note to it. “I would like that.”
***
There is no grand splendor of a rebuilt Erebor. There is no restoration of the great halls, of once-mighty architecture, because Bilbo leaves before he can see any of it.
Funnily, Balin had said the same thing as Thorin once did when Bilbo set off on his journey home.
“Winter is approaching fast, Master Baggins,” he says. “I would not advise you to travel in such weather, even with the wizard by your side. Are you certain you do not want to stay at the mountain until spring?”
Bilbo had smiled and told him that he really ought to get home.
(It’s for the best that he refrains from telling Balin he doesn’t want to witness the way Erebor is transformed from dragon-marred ruins to a grand kingdom if Thorin isn’t the one overseeing it. It’s for the best that Balin doesn’t know that Bilbo had once agreed to stay, until spring and perhaps longer, but he can’t quite bear to anymore.)
Now, Bilbo fixes Bag End, intent on returning his home into one of comfort. He buys back as many of his auctioned belongings as he can. He dusts his hobbit-hole once, twice, three times, until everything is clean and tidy just how he likes it.
He goes into his garden and spends an entire day weeding the tangles that have run wild into flower patches. He fills his pantry with his favorite foods; cooks meals for himself that tastes infinitely better than cram. He sleeps on his warm and soft bed, and more often than not, Bilbo dreams.
Thorin, eyes clouded from the gold-sickness, unhearing to any semblance of sound advice. But there are moments of kindness and clarity even in that cruelness, like when he had smiled at Bilbo after seeing the acorn laying behind his unfurled fingers. It’s a ludicrous hope, but it’s hope all the same, and—
—and then he’s dangling over the ramparts again. The sheer drop beneath his feet is nothing that a vest of silver-steel or a magic ring can guard him against. The only thing stopping him from falling is the grasp Thorin has on his collar, but his eyes are full of cold fury and hatred that Bilbo is certainhe will let go at any moment. Gone is the dwarf who had promised to show him a rebuilt Erebor, bright eyes and earnest words. Instead, Thorin snarls curse after curse at him, the poison in his voice seeping into his skin until Bilbo begins to think that perhaps Thorin really does mean each and every one.
His fingers scrabble against Thorin’s wrists, useless, and Bilbo knows no amount of excuses or reasons will reach him, because he betrayed Thorin and now he is about to—
—die. Thorin is dying.
There is a puddle of blood beneath him. A wide and gaping wound cut through his armor. His next breath is a shudder as it passes Thorin’s lips, and his chest heaves from the effort of such a miniscule action.
A hundred times Bilbo dreams this dream, a hundred and one times he relives this ending.
“Go back to your books,” Thorin rasps, and only later does Bilbo realize that those are his words he had said to Thorin so long ago, now echoed back to him, because Thorin had remembered all this time. “And your armchair.” There is a smile, stained with blood, and it means all the things Bilbo doesn’t want to have to hear. The grip around his arm squeezes once; goes lax. “Plant your trees. Watch them grow.”
Bilbo writes, rather than reads. He has plenty of comfortable places to sit that aren’t his armchair.
There is plenty in his garden that needs tending to, rather than planting that acorn which sits in an untouched box on his mantle.
It’s a ridiculous thought, because Thorin Oakenshield is dead, but some stupid, foolish part of Bilbo’s heart thinks that if he doesn’t do all the things Thorin told him to do, then he’ll still have a piece of him left.
Because if he reads his books, if he sits in his armchair, if he plants his trees—then it really will be the end.
***
A month passes. Two. Bilbo recreates his old schedules. He pretends that he does not—definitely does not—feel like an intruder in his own home. He pretends that what was once peace has not become loneliness. He ignores the acorn on the mantle and the ache in his chest.
Halfway into the third month, he receives a letter from Balin. The old dwarf tells him of the rebuilding of Erebor, overseen under Dain. It’s a slow process, but a steady one nonetheless. Balin tells him about the rest of the Company, and Bilbo wonders if Balin had also thought about the three names that were missing from the list when he wrote and sealed and sent this letter.
Bilbo writes back. He tells Balin about the tomato plants in his garden, about the strawberries that are beginning to ripen. He complains about his mother’s silverware that seems to have dwindled in size, but he still can’t find where the rest of it has been sold (or stolen) off to.
Teatime is at four, he signs off, and laughs a bit at the memory. But none of you dwarves have ever been about punctuality, and you will be welcome any time!
So another season passes, until it has been exactly a year since Bilbo had left the doors of his hobbit-hole, and ran past the borders of the Shire.
Perhaps a small mercy, that the edges of grief dulls. Memories become less vivid, even if they still feel striking as ever when Bilbo recalls them to the forefront of his mind.
He dusts his armchair when he cleans his smial, even if he does not sit on it; he rearranges bound and unbound books on his shelves, although they’ve become one and the same—unread. He spends hours and hours in his garden like he always has done, even if the joy of watching his seedlings sprout and grow is muted, even if the softness of blooming petals feels frail.
Rumors drift around Hobbiton, now and now again. A respectable hobbit, he used to be, Mister Baggins, Bilbo will hear once in a while. Until he ran off with a group of dwarves on an adventure and came back all the odder!
There is no doubt, comes the answer sometimes, he is Belladonna Took’s son, alright.
And so time passes like this; painfully slow on some days, and quicker than blinking during others. Until Bilbo has lost Thorin Oakenshield longer than he has known him.
It’s on a day when the skies are bad-tempered and thundering outside the windows that Bilbo resolves himself into dusting the mantle. With a sweep a dash too careless, he sends the small box atop of it tumbling down.
Feeling rather cross, Bilbo sets his feather-duster down in order to retrieve the box. It has clattered open so that the contents inside have spilled out. The little acorn is nowhere in sight.
He bends down to peer underneath the legs of the table. When it’s not there, he crawls around to the other side of the room.
Now more concerned than cross, Bilbo pushes aside a chair.
Awfully silly to be so worked up over an acorn, he thinks as he gets more worked up. He doesn’t even have the courage to plant the damn thing. Maybe it’s some sort of indignation too, because—well, he’s always been good at doing the exact opposite of what Thorin Oakenshield wants him to do. Like giving away the birthright of the king to an army of elves and men. Like keeping the acorn he’d picked up in the garden with Thorin inside a shoddy box on his mantle instead of planting it in his garden and watching it grow.
Bilbo sweeps over half of the room near the hearth, to no avail. The acorn is nowhere to be seen.
He sits on the floor, quite undignified for any hobbit, blinks very quickly, and sniffs. It does little to cease the sting in his eyes.
Of course it’s not all he has left of Thorin. There’s the mithril vest, for one, even though it lays at the top of a closed chest that Bilbo cannot bring himself to open. But when Thorin gave him the mithril vest, he had clasped Bilbo’s shoulder in a near-painful grip and hissed insidious doubt and suspicions of the exact dwarves who had risked their lives for this quest. But that acorn…
A truce. A piece of clarity. A promise, or perhaps a request. That acorn was his first genuine conversation with Thorin, as it was the first real smile of Thorin’s inside Erebor. And it was Thorin’s last words to Bilbo, and he knows full well that he had said those things for Bilbo’s sake, not his own.
With another sniff, Bilbo resumes his search.
It’s a few minutes later that he spots the small shape against the side of the hearth, coated in a fine layer of dust after taking a tumble through it. Bilbo retrieves it, sneezing in the process, brushing it clean.
The Arkenstone had barely fit in his palms, but this is small; small enough so that if he closes his hands, his fingers will envelop it out of sight.
“It’s a poor prize to take home to the Shire,” Thorin had said, but his eyes had been fond as the stormy haze of gold-sickness thawed into clear, familiar blue.
“One day it’ll grow,” Bilbo had responded. “And every time I’ll remember everything that happened: the good, the bad, and how lucky I am to have made it home.”
Bilbo had been confident in his answer, then, but that was before he knelt next to Thorin Oakenshield’s dying body and watched a different haze creep over blue eyes. That was before the thought of home had been poisoned with something as insidious as loneliness.
“What if it won’t grow?” he asks aloud to no one in particular.
Thorin would think him very foolish indeed. They were thirteen dwarves and one hobbit traveling halfway across Middle Earth to kill a dragon who ended kingdoms and empires. A what-if of doubt clearly didn’t do anything to stop Thorin. Really; nothing could stop him.
And it’s then that Bilbo knows—if he had the chance to remake his choice, if he could rewind time all the way back to that moment, he would’ve still followed Thorin and his Company out of his door. Even if he couldn’t change any loss, switch any outcome, spared himself any pain—he still would have done the exact same thing.
Bilbo cups the little acorn in both palms. He has no need to treat it with such delicate care—the acorn has survived Mirkwood, a trip down the river in barrels, a dragon, and a war. A tumble from the mantle is hardly going to do anything to it that hasn’t been done already (waterlogged, charred, potentially stabbed at).
Struck with a sudden wave of determination, Bilbo rises to full height. He crosses his sitting room, down one hallway, and retrieves a small shovel from his box of gardening tools. Then he throws open the door to his garden.
The downpour hasn’t eased up. Perhaps it’s become a little more violent.
Bilbo squints at the skies, but he decides that he’s gone through far worse, and steps into the rain.
(“Goodness gracious,” Bilbo says to Thorin, after Thorin had finished the fourth in-depth, ale-jumbled description of Erebor, “you’re telling me that there're no gardens at all?”
“It is a mountain of rock, Master Baggins,” Thorin says solemnly. “No, there are no gardens. Would you like a garden? I shall make you one.”
“I don’t—” Bilbo sputters around the words for a moment before gathering his composure. He sniffs and lifts his chin. “I think you are sorely overestimating your competency in this regard, Master Oakenshield. It is not as simple as making a garden as you wish to. There are many details and knowledge you must need to have in order to let a garden flourish, and excuse my assumption, but I do not think you are well-versed in the art of gardening!”
“Hm.” Thorin contemplates. “Then will you make me a garden?”
“You are incredibly drunk,” Bilbo marvels, rather loose-lipped himself now that he’s convinced Thorin will have a vague recollection of their conversation at best tomorrow morning.
Thorin is beginning to frown, so Bilbo reaches over and pats his arm. “Yes, Thorin, I will help you grow a garden in Erebor. I’ll have you know that the tomatoes I grew won prizes every year! A garden will be no problem for me, even if the mountain is made out of rock.”
Seeming to be satisfied, Thorin nods at that, a half-smile playing on his lips. Bilbo tries (and fails) to ignore the syrupy warmth spreading inside his chest, a pleasant sensation like the first sip of cider, a balm against the cold wind.
A garden, in Erebor.
A garden, for Thorin.
He can work with that.)
But this is Bilbo’s own garden that he kneels in, and he does so by himself. The rain is still relentless—really, it must have become heavier, because each droplet is a pinprick against exposed skin and the reading-robe he’s wearing is entirely, uncomfortably drenched. His eyes are stinging a bit, and Bilbo thinks that all this water must be making them smart.
Still, Bilbo finds an acceptable spot in his garden, one that will have enough room for something as large as an oak tree, even if it is only an acorn that fits inside his closed fist right now.
With the spade, he digs a small hole. The dirt and mud is a bit more difficult to work with in this kind of weather, but it’s only a few minutes later that Bilbo deems it ready.
He holds onto the acorn for a moment more. The rain has sloughed any remaining dust clinging onto it, making the surface seem slightly shiny.
Thorin was right; it is a small prize indeed.
But Bilbo has never had a use for gold, for jewels. He is a hobbit, and hobbits have always valued the simplicities of safety, of gardens and growth, of home, above all else. And Thorin Oakenshield had been all of those things. No grief, no mourning, no loss, changes that.
Bilbo lays the acorn down at the bottom of the pit, then covers it back up with the dirt and mud he had scooped aside.
Then he returns home (mopping up the rain that has leaked through his open door), and waits for it to grow.
