Chapter Text
Gandalf kept to his word of only paying the Durins a visit for a few hours, and then he was on his way again.
Dís managed to corner Thorin in his room after Gandalf left, but only for a moment. Dinner was almost ready and the family would all have to congregate in the kitchen for the meal.
“I know how you feel about Bilbo,” Dís said. “You don’t need to deny it, brother. I can see it in the way you’ve been acting. You think you can hide it by not saying anything, but I’ve known you my whole life. I can tell something’s changed in you.”
Thorin didn’t respond. Dís carried on anyway. She knew she was hitting the mark with him, even if he refused to admit it.
“Why don’t you try picking up the piano again? It’s something that really means a lot to Bilbo. I feel like you were on the right track. Think about how happy he’d be if he comes back and sees that you’ve been sticking to it while he was gone.”
Thorin still didn’t respond. Dís made her way to Thorin’s door. “Come on, it’s almost time for dinner.”
***
Thorin hated it, but Dís was right. He was falling for Bilbo, and he had been for longer than even he had realized. Had it always been that obvious?
Forcing himself to accept these feelings, he decided he would take her suggestion. He would try his hand at piano again. What would he have to lose at this point? And if Dís was going to say anything about his lack of finesse on the piano, it would be in a light, teasing way as they always did to each other. It was nothing out of the ordinary. It was a safe space for him to do this.
The worst thing that could happen was that he wouldn’t have to play for Bilbo, and Bilbo would never have to know about any of this.
“First let’s see how much you even remember about playing in general,” Dís said. She and Thorin met in Bilbo’s room. Most of his stuff was still here, save for the bag’s worth of things he packed to take with him back to the Shire for the time being, so it wasn’t like he was gone forever, but the room was somehow a shell of its former self without Bilbo’s physical presence to fill the space leftover in his absence.
“That’s probably nothing,” Thorin said. “It feels like it’s been too long since I actually sat down on this bench and tried to play.”
“That’s because you sucked at it when you first started and you never put in the work to get much better. Maybe a bit at first just to impress Bilbo, but you have to keep consistently putting in that effort to actually get somewhere. Now you have the chance to actually do that—and you know I’ll make sure that happens—but before we can do anything else I have to hear how bad you are.”
“Fine,” Thorin sighed. He flipped through the book to find the piece he had been working on with Bilbo for so long, the one he had never been able to progress past because it was too much, even if it was considered rather “easy.”
He could only remember how to play the first few bars of it, and even that was a struggle to get through as his hands twisted around themselves trying to remember which keys corresponded to which notes. It didn’t take long for him to feel like he had knotted up his fingers badly enough that he couldn’t keep going.
Dís didn’t look surprised at this disheveled attempt at playing. She seemed to expect this much from Thorin, which he found reassuring.
“Hopefully jogging your memory about the basics will help,” she said, pushing Thorin to the side of the bench so she could take a seat next to him and they could both fit. “It will help to review everything, and don’t worry about forgetting a lot of stuff. I wasn’t expecting a masterpiece from you right off the bat. You’ve had enough on your mind lately.”
Dís went over all the basics that Bilbo had once taught Thorin, going over everything thoroughly. She wouldn’t move on from one concept to the next until she was confident he understood it. Thorin thought it helped that she used the piece they had open on the stand in front of them as the backdrop for contextualizing all of the explanations. Once she finished, she made him try playing one hand of the piece again, but she helped him along the way to make sure he at least made it to the end this time.
“You’re going to need a lot more practicing, but I think you’ll be able to get better enough to play for Bilbo,” Dís assessed once they made it to the end of the piece. “You know you’re going to have to put in that work if you want this badly enough.”
“What do you have in mind for me to do exactly?” Thorin asked. By this point, this was going longer than any of his lessons had with Bilbo. She was serious about making him grind out all the work.
“Well, I wanted you to try your hand at the next movement of this sonata. Turn the page and look. It’s not that hard. With enough practice I’m sure you’ll be able to play it. You won’t be a virtuoso, but it’ll sound decent enough and I’m sure Bilbo would appreciate even that much.”
With some skepticism, Thorin turned the page to see what Dís was talking about with this next movement. It looked intimidating.
“It goes a lot slower than the first movement, so it’ll be reasonable enough for you, if that’s what you’re concerned about.”
That didn’t seem like enough reassurance for Thorin, but there was no point in trying to protest. He let Dís take the lead. She first played through the piece for Thorin so he would have an idea of what it was supposed to sound like when it was “performance ready,” and as he sat and listened, he thought about Bilbo and felt more determined in the resolve that he was going to do this for Bilbo’s sake.
***
As the days passed Dís continued to hold Thorin accountable to consistently practicing. She was a lot more diligent about it all than Bilbo ever was. Bilbo seemed a bit more relaxed in comparison to Dís’s strictness, but it was because she was invested in getting Thorin to see this thing through. He understood it was for his own good and she wanted him to be happy. There were still some days where he dreaded having to go into Bilbo’s empty room—It’s just the guest room as long as he isn’t here, he would remind himself all too often—and sit at the bench and play back the same measures of music over and over again. But there was a motivation driving all of this, and his determination to succeed took hold over every other conflicting feeling.
Days turned into a few weeks and even when he was away from the piano, the thoughts of Bilbo continued to permeate through everything Thorin did. It was like reliving the day after he had left over and over again, like a broken record stuck playing the same beats without anyone there to fix it. He found it compelling enough to stick with practicing piano consistently, but in the rest of his life, it became more and more of a stressor.
In the rest of the house, life went on like normal, or whatever bit of normal could be picked up for the time being. Everyone understood their time left in this house was temporary and soon they were going to all move to Erebor to settle into their new home and help Thorin through the transition he would have to undertake as part of his ascension to the throne.
In the meantime, while they were still in this house in Ered Luin, Dís was not going to let him slack on this. It was just as well because every time he started to think about his uncertain future as king, it all started to feel too overwhelming for him. It was too separate from his present, the quiet life in Ered Luin he had always known, to reconcile the two. Even going south to Erebor felt like a pause in his normal life, and that returning to Ered Luin was the permanent decision, rather than the temporary reality it was.
He wasn’t sure how they were going to move out of Ered Luin, what that process would be like. But it seemed that Fundin was the one taking care of it behind the scenes, in the times off where he wasn’t busy at work. Bearing that responsibility himself meant that would be one less thing for Thorin to worry about in his ever-crowded mind.
As days turned into weeks, everything began to blend together and the biggest marker of the passage of time was the progress Thorin was making in learning the piece Dís had set forward for him. He was impressed that he was making any progress at all, and he knew he had to owe it to Dís for being such a brutal force of a teacher.
“You have to admit that Bilbo was a good teacher, too,” Dís told him one day at the end of a particularly exhilarating practice session. “I know you never gave him the credit he deserved.”
Thorin sighed. “Just because you’re right doesn’t mean you have to rub it in.” Dís laughed and playfully punched his arm.
“I’m glad I’m making this much progress,” Thorin mused. “I hope Bilbo will be proud of me for managing to do this.”
“Of course he will be.”
