Chapter Text
To think they would pull this again. To think he fell for it. Reiner stared at his captive and sighed. Instead of Historia, Armin Arlert was glaring back at him. Reiner reached out and took the wig from Armin’s head.
“Armin,” he sighed. Armin squinted his eyes.
“Hi, Reiner.” Oh the arrogance. Despite his angelic blond hair and pretty blue eyes, Armin seemed feistier than Reiner could remember.
“We are not stupid, you know. We knew you’d be back and try to kidnap the princess,” Armin said, and he smirked. He smirked! Reiner frowned, wondering which one of the two was captured here, but right, after double checking he noted it really was Armin who sat tied up before him.
“Only for her to be taken to safety. It was a promise to Ymir,” Reiner responded, trying his best to hide how Armin had caught him off guard.
“She does not want to, this is her home,” Armin said.
“A home that’s going to be destroyed,” Reiner growled. Ugh. There was no use to quarrel like this. It had been a messy mission, if only he hadn’t been so reckless in his titan form and snatched Historia the moment he saw her, Reiner could’ve given her a second look to discover it wasn’t really her.
“Well alright. Let’s not waste your visit then,” Reiner said, looking around the abandoned house where he had taken him, in a village that was already destroyed by titans long ago.
Armin struggled against his bonds; Reiner had tied him up quite sloppily, but even if Armin was to escape, Reiner would make sure to transform and catch him again.
“Besides Historia, there is one more person we are after. You know who it is, and you are going to tell me where we can find him,” Reiner said.
Armin rolled his eyes. “As if. I don’t know where Eren is, and if I did I wouldn’t tell you. You’ll have to kill me,” he said. Reiner frowned. This little brat really had grown an attitude over the years.
“Why, what’s stopping you?” Armin asked. Reiner was still taken aback, but he sighed and flashed a bit of a forced grin.
“I have no need of killing you since you are going to tell me the truth,” he said.
“How? Are you going to torture me? Feed me to the titans? Didn’t think you would have that in you.” Reiner smirked.
“Torture indeed. Just wait until I’m done with you, we’ll see how confident you are by then,” he said, and he grabbed Armin’s arm and pulled his struggling body towards him.
“H-hey! Let go - WAh!” Armin cried when Reiner pinned him down while letting his hand travel a bit to his side where he started to squeeze.
“Are you still ticklish, Armin?” Reiner asked, unable to hide his own enthusiasm as he smiled while digging his fingers into Armin’s twitching torso.
“GAh! O-of course I’m still- wahah! Rehehei-Reiner! This is- whahaha!” Armin was all of a sudden a lot less cocky, and way more giggly. Reiner grinned while he continued to wiggle his fingers against those weak spots. Memories of tickle fights and tickle tortures during his early years at the cadet corps flashed before him.
Tickle fights he had often seen Armin lose against people like Eren and Jean. Reiner was thankful he remembered.
“HAha! J-johohoke’s on you! I wohohon’t tehehell you!” Armin laughed, squirming underneath him and fighting against Reiner’s persistent tickling moves.
“Joke’s on me but you are the one laughing hysterically,” Reiner commented dryly. No way could he ever hurt Armin. Kidnapping him by mistake was the biggest error ever, but if he could manage to get Armin to at least spill some beans on Eren’s whereabouts then he wouldn’t have to look back too shamefully on this whole encounter.
“Y-you cahahan’t keep tihihickling me fohorever ahahaha!” Armin squealed, and Reiner softened at the sight of his bright smile and the sound of that sweet contagious laughter.
"If it were up to me, I’d tickle you forever Armin,” Reiner said, cringing at how cheesy that must’ve sounded rather than the sort of threatening thing a villain would say. He wanted to play the villain, but Armin was messing with his head and he sighed.
“Are you really not going to tell me anything?” Reiner grunted, flipping Armin on his back and clawing mercilessly at those slender ribs.
“AHAHA! Nohoho hahaa!” Armin was tough, but Reiner was too. So he continued to tickle him. At one point Armin jerked so heavily (his underarms were extremely ticklish Reiner discovered) and he rolled to the side. But Reiner caught him swiftly and simply moved the tickling from his upper to his lower body, now attacking his hips and thighs with firm squeezes as well as wiggling fingers.
Armin was going berserk and he squealed. “EHeheheh! R-Reeheheiner! Ahahah!” he laughed, and encouraged by his pleas, Reiner even took off his shoes and started to tickle his feet with quick scribbles all over his sensitive soles.
“Yes, Armin? Got something to tell me?” he asked. Armin shook with each hysterical laugh that escaped him and he nodded.
“Hehehehe saha-sasageyo!” he cried, and Reiner froze, his fingertips that grazed Armin’s bare feet ever so softly stopping in their tracks as well.
“What?” he asked.
“S-sasageyo,” Armin panted, gasping for breath. Reiner stared at him in shock. Sasageyo was the safeword they would use during the brutal tickle wars as young cadets. Back then, Reiner had never tickled Armin directly, but he witnessed others doing it until they would surrender like this.
His fingers curled against the soft bottom of Armin’s foot, making him twitch and giggle. “That’s... Your only safeword would be to tell me where I can find Eren Yeager,” he explained to a very exhausted Armin.
“Is that really not something you can tell an old friend?” he asked. Armin was still breathless when he looked at him, their eyes locking.
“I’ll never tell you, Reiner. Not unless you come back to us,” he said, determination in his eyes, and Reiner had to admit he swayed for a bit, just for a tiny second. Right then the sound of approaching horses could be heard; ah, he should’ve known they would come looking for Armin.
“Sorry Armin, I can’t,” he sighed, and he released Armin’s feet and finally left. He waited for Armin to shout at the others that Reiner was getting away and that they should catch him, but no such thing happened.
“Sasageyo,” Reiner murmured while he hastily distanced himself further, and he sighed. He didn’t find out where Eren was, and he failed to capture Historia, but that surely wasn’t too bad of a trip down memory lane. He smiled. They were some of the best memories he had.
