Actions

Work Header

Foul or fair are in the eyes of others

Chapter Text

He hadn’t expected to find anyone in the river that crossed Beorn’s lands, but Dori was there, doing her braids.

“I’m sorry,” he said, slightly awkward. They all had seen each other in more than intimate situations along the road, but Dori was always so proper that finding her slightly clad and with part of her hair undone felt somehow forbidden. “I’ll leave you to it.”

“No need,” Dori replied without pausing in her braiding. “I don’t mind the company.” She arched an eyebrow. “Unless you wanted to be left alone? I am nearly done.”

Thorin pondered it. In all truth, he had gone to the river looking for intimacy, as much as fresh water; huge as Beorn’s house was, the Dwarves in his Company seemed to fill it to the brim. The one hobbit was more discreet, certainly, but every time he laid eyes on him Thorin remembered how he had saved him from Azog, and he was filled with regret at the thought of the way in which he had treated him before. Therefore, he might be the one he wanted to avoid the most.

Dori wasn’t noisy, thought, and his feeling for her weren’t as complex as those he harboured for their burglar, so he didn’t mind her presence there.

“Don’t bother,” he decided, beginning to take off his clothes. The Dam shrugged at this, and she continued to work on her hair.

As he had imagined, Dori didn’t say anything and let him be while he got in the water and began rubbing off sweat with a sigh of relief. The summer heat was at its peak, he thought; the next weeks of march would be hard. Perhaps the elvish wood would provide some protection against it -but again, it probably wouldn’t be worth it; if half of what he had heard about Mirkwood’s danger was true, he would rather walk under a scorching sun and on burning sands that through its trees.

By the time they were done with the wood they would be close to Lake-town, though, and weather would not be so hot; some weeks later autumn would start chasing them, and Durin’s Day with it…

“Would you like some help with your hair?”

Thorin blinked, surprised at having had his thoughts interrupted, before he turned to look at Dori. The Dwarrowdam had finished doing her braids, and she sat on the same spot he had last seen her, with her clothes still only half on and an air of polite curiosity.

“My hair?”

“It’s not properly taken care of, my lord. If you want, I could brush and oil it for you.” She paused, hesitant. “Braid it too, if you would like me to.”

Goodness. She had said it nonchalantly enough, but Thorin felt far more heated now that he had before taking the bath. Brushing and oiling another Dwarf’s hair, not to mention braiding it, might not be inherently sexual, but it was definitively intimate; it was only performed with members of you family, friends or bed partners. Dori was of Durin’s line, even if distantly, and of course, at this point of the quest he was very close to considering her a friend, but she was so stunning that he was under the impression his mind and body were going to stray towards other scenarios, if he allowed her to touch his hair.

Still, she had offered, and she was right. His hair was not properly taken care of, and while it wasn’t something that merited vanity, plain as it was, he should at least try to make it look befitting to a king.

“I would be honoured,” he formally agreed, so he left the river to sit where she pointed him to, in front of her.

Dori and his brothers were in the habit of maintaining their hairs with the biggest care; he knew he was putting his mane in the best possible hands, and he was indeed not disappointed. The Dam brushed him delicately, making sure not to pull; the rhythm of the brush was sort of hypnotic, actually.

It had been years since he had allowed anyone to comb his hair, except for his closest family, and his sister and her sons were all too restless and impatient to make the experience as pleasant as it could be. Dori did, though; she didn’t mind spending as much time as necessary undoing each tangle with soft and dexterous movements, before she carefully and meticulously oiled each strand. When she took again the brush and let it run through Thorin’s hair the king shivered with contentment, enjoying the touch of the teeth against his scalp and the way his mane moved over his skin.

“You have finally relaxed,” Dori observed. “Good. You looked awfully tense for someone who was having a bath.”

Thorin let out a humourless chuckle.

“I was,” he admitted. “It’s just… I never thought the quest would be easy, of course. Just such a trip has some dangers attached, not to mention the dragon awaiting at the end of the road. But now orcs are behind our trail, which worries me, and elves know of our quest and oppose to it, which I find rather unsettling. And on top of all that,” he added through clenched teeth, “I just found out that the defiling scum is alive, and we nearly lost our burglar when he had to rescue me from him. It’s…”

“Very frustrating,” Dori completed for him. Thorin nodded in agreement with a heavy sigh. “But you must remember that we are safe here,” she continued as she began to braid Thorin’s hair. “It would be wise to use that time to heal, and I don’t just mean our wounds. Our minds need rest too, and yours more than most. The crown sits heavily on any brow.”

“I don’t wear any crown,” he grunted, unhappy at the reminder, but Dori tutted in reproach.

“Your crown is made of losses and blood,” she replied while she finished his braid and put the beads on it. “It’s shaped by grief and responsibilities. That makes it a heavier burden than any metal, and it also honours you more than it.”

That was… unexpected. He wouldn’t admit it, but he was very moved. Dori was the embodiment of politeness, certainly, but her praises were sparse, and therefore he greatly valued the compliment she had just delivered. He blinked away tears while she relocated on her knees, so she could braid the other side of his head, and only when he had swallowed the lump in his throat did he answer.

“Thank you, Dori. I really appreciate it.” With her hands occupied in his hair and her body still partially uncovered, he didn’t really know where he could grip her affectionately. He finally settled for her elbow. “You have a gift for words, and for comfort too.”

“Pay it no mind,” she replied with a soft smile. “You revealed yourself to the goblins to spare Ori their tortures. That’s more than enough to earn a praise, I think, and some comfort with it.”

“That was common decency,” he affirmed, because it was.

“Perhaps it was decency, but I wouldn’t call it common.” Having finished with the braids, Dori oiled her hands again and put them on his beard; Thorin closed his eyes in order to enjoy the feeling of her fingers running through his chin, regretting, not for the first time, his habit of keeping it short in mourning. Just some more weeks, he thought in consolation; either he would be dead or Smaug would, and then he would again be deserving the name of a Longbeard. “Did you ever think that, if the dragon hadn’t come, we could have done this much earlier?”

“Humm?” he opened his eyes again, disconcerted. “Conversing for comfort, you mean? Or braiding hair?”

“Both, actually.” Dori’s eyes were fixed in his beard, apparently, although Mahal knew there wasn’t much to look at. “But perhaps I presume.” Thorin must still have looked confused, because she added, “did you know I trained with my mother, before we lost our home?”

“Ah,” he said, finally understanding. “Yes, I supposed I did, but I had forgotten.” He hadn’t forgotten Dori’s mother, that was for sure, and neither her mother or her grandfather -all of them incredibly alluring, as the line of Ri tended to be, and most of them sought out by kings and princes, when they wanted a professional in their beds. He had likely heard about Dori having apprenticed with other members of her family, but he had always known her as a merchant. They were all now what the dragon had made of them, after all. “I’m sorry,” he said, though, because he probably wouldn’t be pleased if someone forgot his craft only because he had worked as anything that would keep his family fed. “I don’t think we met, back then. I would remember you, I have no doubt.”

He hadn’t said it just to make up for his lack of memory -he would have. As a matter of fact, if he had seen even a glimpse of Dori when he was still a lad, he would have lost his mind. In any case, Dori smiled, either at the hinted praise or at the apology, so he hadn’t offended her with any.

“Oh, you didn’t know of me, but I knew of you,” she replied. “I sometimes saw you in the streets or the guild festivities, and my mother took me to some of the palace ceremonies. If I close my eyes, I can still see you standing next to you grandfather, or walking besides your sire.”

“Well, I wasn’t much of a sight,” he said, which was a euphemism. He had been as young as Kíli back then, and not better blessed when it came to looks. At least he had been tidier, he supposed. “I was a prince ugly enough to have merited some story in which I was cursed by a wizard, only to be turned beautiful by the kiss of a maiden.”

That made her laugh.

“Well, I am not maiden,” she declared. Her hands were still in his beard, he realized, and that, combined with her words, made his pulse quicken. Was she insinuating…? “And I would say you grew up much better than what your youthful looks would suggest. But if you are interested, you could still get a kiss… and perhaps something else.” One of her hands went to his chin; she took it firmly and looked him in the eyes with far more promises in hers that Thorin had dared to hope. “A taste, if you want, of what we could have had if we had never lost our mountain.”

*

“Hum… Dwalin?”

“Aye?” The warrior looked up from where he was sharpening his axe, smiling at Bilbo. “Do you need anything?”

“Well, no, not need, but I am curious about something,” he admitted.

“Let’s see if I can help you with that.” Dwalin patted the ground next to the spot he was sitting in. “Come on, join me and ask.”

“All right.” Bilbo did as instructed. He thought for a moment in the way the quest was changing him, for he would have never done such a thing some months ago -the dust!-, and now he regarded such gestures as the most natural thing in the world. But he should try not to digress, because this conversation was going to be awkward enough without it. He cleared his throat and focused on the matter he wanted to adress. “See, I am curious about… beauty.”

“Beauty?” The other frowned, clearly confused. “If you want to talk about art, you’ll do better to seek my brother, or Ori perhaps. Unless we are discussing tattoos, of course; I am quite knowledgeable in those.”

“It’s not about art or tattoos. Well, I think so,” he added, because at that point he wasn’t sure of anything. Maybe tattoos were crucial, after all. “I meant to ask about… you know… attractiveness.”

“Ah!” Dwalin’s lips twisted in a smirk. “Is this a juicy gossip? Do you have the hots for someone, Bilbo?”

“No, no!” He shook his head in denial, blushing. He kind of did, to be honest; he had always thought Thorin attractive, but now that the King actually smiled at him from time to time he found him utterly devastating. “It’s just… what Dwarves seem to find beautiful is very different from what hobbits like.”

“Really?” Dwalin frowned. “Are you like Elves, that find us all hideous?”

“No, it’s not like that.” Bilbo decided not to point out the fact that Dwarves didn’t seem to find Elves attractive, either. “It’s more like… well…” He tried to put his ideas in order. “You all seem to agree that Dori and Bombur are the most attractive among the Company, don’t you?”

“Well, that depends,” Dwalin said, pensive. “Canonically speaking, Dori would be considered really beautiful, that cannot be argued against. The matter of who’s most attractive is more personal, though -most Dwarves would say it’s Bombur, but you never know what might appeal to someone.”

That was true, and it made Bilbo harbour some hopes.

“And what about men?”

“Humm?” Dwalin frowned. “What about them?”

“You mentioned our two Dwarrowdams, but who’s more attractive or beautiful among the men of the Company?” Bilbo clarified.

The warrior still seemed confused, though.

“I don’t understand, Bilbo. Do hobbits distinguish between male and female beauty, then?”

“Do hobbits… well, certainly.” Bilbo blinked, surprised. “You don’t? Is that what you are saying?”

“Certainly not. Why would we? What’s the difference?”

“Well, they don’t… look the same,” Bilbo said, hesitant. Did they? Now that they thought about it, he hadn’t really noticed Bombur and Dori were female until they had introduced themselves as such.

“But they do,” Dwalin insisted. His frown deepened. “Are you like Men, then, that make a terrible fuss about people’s parts?”

“I’m… rather afraid that we do,” Bilbo admitted, although he didn’t want the conversation to take that path. He had been informed months ago that Dwarves didn’t go looking into other people’s pants to try to impose the gender they thought they must have, and he had long learned to live with the concept. Nori’s skills with a knife and his nasty temper certainly held one’s tongue for as much time as it took to learn to respect what one didn’t understand. Still, the matter remained a little bit confusing for him.

“Well, I guess bearers and sires do look quite different among Men, and I suppose the same happens among hobbits,” Dwalin admitted. “Although what that might have to do with one’s gender’s beyond me. In any case, Bilbo, we don’t distinguish between one or the other -men, women or those who are neither all have the same curves, the same limbs, the same beard. And they are beautiful, or they are not.”

“All right,” he said, scratching his nape. He tried to imagine explaining this to his neighbours in the Shire, and failed miserably. In any case, and going back to his primary interest, the point was that he didn’t have to ask about who else he might have to compare himself to, if he wanted to know about his attractiveness by Dwarf’s standards. “So… you mentioned the same beard, didn’t you? I have been meaning to ask about that. What’s with hair and beards?”

“What’s with…” This was clearly being a very confusing conversation for Dwalin. “Isn’t it obvious?”

“It certainly isn’t!”

“Well, you don’t have any beard,” Dwalin acknowledge with some hesitancy. “Nor do hobbits, as a rule. Perhaps you don’t consider them as beautiful as we do.”

That would be an understatement -hobbits, as a rule, saw beards as unkempt, barbaric, and worse of all, un-hobbitish. After months with his companions, Bilbo didn’t share that view, but he couldn’t say he understood the Dwarves obvious awe for them.

“I think we don’t,” he admitted. “But I take that’s a key point when it comes to beauty, then? Hair and beard?”

“Certainly. Mithril hair, in particular, like Dori and my brother have, is considered the most beautiful. Some value golden hair, too, either because it reminds them of the metal or because of its rarity. In all honesty, I’m still half convinced that Fíli is in this world because Dís was smitten as soon as she saw his father’s hair.” He suddenly smiled. “Although I am personally drawn to red hair, more than any other kind. Metal’s beautiful, but fire’s what gets you warm, if you know what I mean.”

Considering the way he eyed Nori’s hair and beard, he knew what fire he was referring to, yes.

“I think I do.” Bilbo tried to mask his disappointment. Gold, mithril and fire. Apparently, brown or black didn’t deserve a mention when one discussed beauty or sex appeal. “But it’s not a matter of colour, right? Abundance is also important.”

“Certainly! If possible, one would like to bury their face in a lover’s beard or mane.” Dwalin seemed very enthusiastic about that activity. Well, Nori did have a lot of hair; perhaps they did that. Better not to think about it, probably. “Brushing and braiding their hair is also very pleasurable. And the brush of a beard or a mane against the skin, that’s just…” He closed his eyes, as if thinking of the feeling, while Bilbo’s heart sank. “It’s indescribable.”

“I see,” he mumbled. Damn, that was definitely something he couldn’t do. “But you don’t all keep your hair or beards long, thought” he pointed out. “You, for instance, shave your head.”

“Ah, well.” Dwalin chucked, caressing his scalp. “I’m not much to look at, you know. My tattoos, though… they get me more attention than my sorrowful hair ever did, honestly.”

“Because tattoos are… also beautiful?”

“Yes, of course.” The Dwarf eyed him dubiously. “I guess hobbits don’t do those, either?”

“You guess right,” Bilbo replied. Hobbits’ opinion on tattoos was even worse than the one they had on beards, actually. “Is that why you wear them?”

“No, not only; they also symbolize a number of things.” Dwalin smiled. “But they do help, and Mahal knows I need it.”

“You are not considered handsome, by Dwarfs standards?” Bilbo asked. He would have never dared to inquire such a thing, months ago, but his companions had taught him bluntness, and indeed, Dwalin heartily laughed.

“Well, I’m getting better with age,” he judged with a huge smile. “I was lucky enough to break my nose years ago, and the facial scars make some people turn. My strength keeps on growing like any other Dwarf’s, and as I said, the tattoos get some attention. But when I was a lad of Fíli and Kíli’s age, I was as ugly as the two of them.”

“Right.” As a matter of fact, he was still wrapping his mind around the concept that Thorin and his nephews were considered ugly by his Companions. The idea was beyond him. “So, hum… facial scars make you more attractive, as do the tattoos and muscles, and a crooked nose also helps.” Dwalin nodded in agreement, and Bilbo’s heart sank. Great. He had none of those; he must be as incredibly ugly as the King apparently was. He had a last card to play, though, and he asked quite desperately, “but there’s fat, right? Don’t you like that, too?”

“Ah, aye.” Dwalin smiled appreciatively. “Round bellies, stout thighs, plump asses, chubby hands… we like all of those. As I said, each Dwarf might find different things attractive, but there’s a certain consensus that those elements are considered… enjoyable.”

Finally! Bilbo sighed, relieved, at this confirmation that there was at least some element in his physique that Dwarves would find attractive. He had always been found deliciously round among hobbits, who viewed those traits under the same light, so maybe he wasn’t absolutely abhorrent, after all.

But Dwalin quickly crushed his hopes on that matter, too.

“It’s such a pity that you have thinned during our quest,” he pensively remarked. “I remember how you were when we supped at your house… all plump and chubby; my brother and I commented that it was quite a pity that you lacked a beard, because otherwise you could have been rather handsome.” He looked him up and down. “But this journey has been harsh on all of us, I guess. Try to make use of your rest here, Mister Baggins; it looks like you need it.”

Yes, the Dwarves had taught him bluntness, alright. Even more than he could stomach, sometimes.

“I think I’ll do that,” he sighed, getting on his feet. “I’ll go see if Beorn has more of that excellent honey of his. Thank you for the conversation, Dwalin; it has been… enlightening.”

Yes, enlightening. At least now he knew that, no matter how ugly the King might be thought by other Dwarves, he was ten times uglier. And therefore, he likely didn’t interest him at all.

Well, it didn’t matter, did it? He had started to find Thorin attractive, that was true, or better, more attractive than he did before. All right, terrible attractive, perhaps. But that wasn’t relevant. After all, he had always lived in the Shire, where laying with your own sex was frowned upon; he was more than used to finding other people attractive and not acting on it. He would just do the same in this case, and with time, surely, his lust would pass.