Work Text:
Merry pushed through the ornately carved wooden door into a darkened room. He wished the elf that sent him had given better directions - it felt like it had taken him half the morning to find his way here. "Mister Bilbo?" he said softly. There was no response, but from the adjacent room he heard heavy breathing. Stepping into it, he spotted a white mop of disarrayed curls with a single bead-capped braid woven into it. The elderly hobbit was slumped in a sunbeam next to the open windows so common in Rivendell. A writing table stood nearby covered in parchments, though a thin film of dust lay over it. The brilliant sunlight filled the rest of the small suite of rooms in shadows, leaving the ornate furniture as mere lumps in the darkness. Peering down at Bilbo asleep, Merry realized with a shock just how old the other hobbit was. He always remembered Bilbo as being his parents' age, young and vital (though rumor in the Shire had it that he had looked the same for fifty years). Merry knew the source of that unnatural youth now, though he rather wished he didn't.
As he turned to go, a tart voice behind him said "Leaving already? But you've only just arrived! Besides, I sent Aelir for you ages ago." He turned back to see Bilbo peering up at him, sharp birdlike black eyes as bright as they had ever been. "You needn't think I'm asleep, my boy," the old hobbit huffed.
"Oh no, sir, never," Merry replied, fighting back a grin and seeing with relief that Bilbo was doing the same. "An elf came and got me, Mister Bilbo, and told me..." Bilbo waved an aged hand irritably, interrupting him.
"Yes, yes," he sighed, "but please stop with the 'Mister Bilbo', my boy. You make me sound as though I were quite above myself, and I assure you that's not the case. Just call me Bilbo. And sit down!" He gestured at the chair angled to join him. "Hurts my neck, craning up to see you. Good heavens, since you came back you're twice as tall as the entire house of Brandybuck stacked foot to head. Never seen a hobbit so tall! Best not ever wear boots like a Marish Stoor, my boy, or they'll think you're one of the Bree-men that got lost." Merry scoffed, delighted to be on familiar ground. He had missed speaking with people from the Shire, and Bilbo was... well, he had been a fixture of Merry's childhood. "Sit, sit!" Bilbo continued faux-crossly. "Have some tea, won't you? They just brought the pot and it's quite good, lovely taste in teas Elrond has. And there's scones as well, my own recipe!" The aged face grew sad for a moment, like a cloud passing over the sun, before brightening again with a determinedly pleasant look. "I didn't make them, of course. It's a bit difficult for me to stand in the kitchen for too long these days. Hips hurting, don't you know."
Merry nodded, mouth full of the same scones he remembered from a thousand childhood trips to Bag End to see Frodo. "These are wonderful!" He enthused, quickly amending his statement with "Not a patch on yours, of course, but it's clearly the same recipe." Decades of persiflage return as if by magic, as easily as Gandalf called light, and he was forced to wonder how. With all I've seen and all that's happened, Merry mused, how can I just sit here and eat scones and talk of nothing like nothing has changed?
"Too kind, too kind," Bilbo said, peering at him. "None of that brooding now, I know that look and I don't like it. I won't have it." Grimacing, Merry sat up straighter. He was forced to remember just how eerily perceptive the old hobbit could be. Bilbo took a bite of his own scone and chewed for a moment before sipping his tea. If not for the overlarge furniture, they might be in any smial in the Shire, the younger hobbit realized. At that point, Bilbo sighed and set his cup down with a clink. Oh dear, Merry thought. Now I'm for it. That was quick, too. He was so busy racking his mind as to what business he could possibly have left unfinished with Bilbo, Frodo or Bag End that he almost missed the next statement. "I'm afraid I've called you here on a rather personal matter. Some might even say an intrusive one, so I suppose I should apologize in advance." In the language of the Shire, that was the equivalent of a declaration of war. Merry's internal alarm ratcheted up to its highest level.
"Now Mist... I mean, Bilbo, I apologize for whatever I..." Bilbo's cracked laugh rang out loudly.
"Hush!" he said, still chuckling. "I didn't call you here to talk about my geraniums." Merry felt his face flushing; he had always suspected the older hobbit of knowing what happened to his garden, but... by the Green Lady, it had been thirty years! "No, I'm afraid it's worse than that." ... Worse? Dark eyes caught his and held them, and Bilbo's face was sympathetic. "I apologize again, but there's no way to say this kindly, though I assure you I would if I might. Young Merry, you've had your heart broken since I last saw you, and terribly so. The pieces of it are rattling around in your chest, plain as day. At least, plain enough to me. Tell me about who it was and what happened." This... was the last thing he had been expecting. Damn, and the tears were starting already. He was suddenly furious at Bilbo, furious at, well, at everyone, really, for making this situation exist. A soft, withered hand patted at his. "I'm so very sorry, my boy, I know this is a horror, but there's a very good reason I mention it, I promise." Merry stood up, throwing off Bilbo's hand.
"How dare you," he began, voice breaking. Of all the conceivable things Bilbo might have wished to speak of, Merry would never have come if he had suspected it might be that. "I don't wish to speak of... of... anything you think you know! Good day," he turned and Bilbo's voice rang out behind him with the same eerie authority Gandalf had at times.
"Sit down, Meriadoc Brandybuck, and stop being a fool." His rear was in the chair before his mind could stop it, years of conditioning coming to the fore, though he glared venomously at the shrunken figure opposite him. "I assure you, I know the signs because I see them in the mirror every day. We know our own kind." The impact of that settled in the room like a leaden blanket, leaving Merry too shocked to even contemplate his own pain. Old Bilbo had... but... when...? Black eyes watched his face, took in the shock, and Bilbo had the nerve to chuckle. "I thought that might get your attention. That's not a bit of news that ever made it to the Shire, now is it? And I'll thank you to keep it that way." A pert expression crossed the lined face as he took a sip of his tea. "But yes, my stories of my adventure were not entirely... complete, shall we say. Not," he muttered bitterly, "that it made any difference to the story in the end, or to anyone but me. So," he said more loudly, "there's a reason I wear this," he flipped the braid at Merry that the younger hobbit had assumed was an elvish affectation, "and why the dwarves who came from Erebor for Elrond's little conference bowed to me. Yes, I loved a dwarf. He died. Now... what happened to you?"
"I... you... wait," Merry stammered. "You can't just... and then say... but it..." Taking a deep breath, he was glad he was sitting down because it meant he didn't need to pick himself up from the floor. Most hobbits only loved once; some had follow up relationships, but everyone Merry knew of had... someone. Bilbo had always been considered The Strangest Hobbit Ever for various reasons, some of them better than others, but his refusal to even entertain a single suitor was legendary. And now, all this time, he had been... "You were mourning!" He finally burst out, causing Bilbo to sigh and nod. "But... but you never said!"
"Well of course I never said," Bilbo snapped. "And just how would that have gone in Hobbiton, hmm? 'Oh, Mad Baggins wasn't always alone' - oh don't look at me like that, boy, I know what they said about me! - 'no, actually he fell in love with a dwarf, if you can believe it, and then the blighter died right away! Left him mopey ever since.' No thank you, I'd prefer to be the one hobbit who never felt anything than be 'poor old Mad Baggins', and let them all put that in their pipes and smoke it!" Bilbo harrumphed irritably, and the sound was so familiar that Merry had a brutal and overpowering sense of déjà vu that left him disoriented.
"But..." the young hobbit was grasping at the straws of sanity by this point. "I remember... it wasn't one of the two young dwarves who died, was it? I always felt so sad for them in your story. You mean you..." Bilbo harrumphed even louder, glaring at him.
"No, of course it wasn't Fili or Kili, they were still practically children! Good heavens, thick as a plank you are, for all your mum's famous cleverness! No, it was Thorin, the king! He... he wasn't supposed to die," Bilbo said in a thick voice. "Look at me, old fool that I am, eighty years later and still choked up about it. No, he... well, it wasn't like we really had time to do anything formal, was it, being on a journey as we were, and then, well, I've told you how chaotic things got once we reached the mountain, and then... then he was dead, and I came home, and that was the end of it." Withered fingers toyed with the silvery bead at the end of his braid. "That was the end of it for him, anyway. Just for me it never really ended."
"I'm... I'm so sorry, I had no idea," Merry babbled. "So was that bead his or...?" Bilbo's eyes cut to him, and what Merry saw in them froze his tongue in his mouth.
"Yes," Bilbo stated in a quiet, steely voice. "The dwarves are a secretive people, and I cannot tell you much without being forsworn. But he spoke of our... love..." he sipped his tea convulsively, hand trembling as he set down his cup. "To his sister. Fili and Kili's mother, that would be, to you. She brought me this bead and told me how to wear it, but... well, hardly something I could do in the Shire, was it? So I kept it safe, but when I came here..." the old hobbit peered out the window at the gardens, lined face limned in the golden sunlight and white hair glowing. "Well, when I came here, it didn't matter, and I was tired of pretending I didn't still love him. To the dwarves, we were married or as good as, so they see me as his social equal. Bit preposterous," Bilbo forced some brightness into his voice, as false as paper flowers. "Treating me like a king. But," he turned to Merry, and now it was obvious that was as much as he was going to say. "Enough about an old fool, and all this reliving of days gone. Tell me about the one who took your heart, and what happened. I promise not to judge, and I've told you a story no living hobbit knows to prove it. Who was it?"
"Oh," Merry murmured. I refuse to cry, he thought to himself. I will not. "I... well, we have two things in common, I suppose. He wasn't a hobbit, and he was royal, after a fashion." Bilbo's soft 'ah' of surprise was like a knife in his side, somehow. The clink and rush of pouring tea signaled the refilling of his teacup but Merry was lost in his own mind already. "You met him, I suspect. He was the son of the Steward of Gondor." He paused, thankfully sipping his tea. "He didn't comport himself very well during the time that he was here. Of course I had no idea at the time he would ever..." he trailed off. Bilbo, for his part, burst out laughing, and Merry wasn't sure whether to thank him or throw his scone at him.
"I understand, good gracious me do I ever," he snickered. "Thorin was impossibly rude for the whole first part of our trip. Called me names, sneered at me, the lot. I'd have spit in the eye and kicked the shins of anyone who told me how things would work out in the end."
"Well, yes," Merry said with a grin that surprised himself. "Exactly. But when we left here he, I don't know, he sort of took me and Pip as his charges. Would have done with Sam and Frodo too, I s'pose, but you know how Sam is, and Gandalf was hovering over Frodo like a hen with one chick, so..." Bilbo laughed again.
"Aha!" the old hobbit exclaimed. "Now we get the real story! Yes, Gandalf is exactly like that, my boy, to the life! How often did he decide he knew best and lead you off into some hair-raising and ridiculous situation, only to leave you when things got bad, then show up again when they seemed worst?"
"Only once," Merry said, wishing he could be as cheerful about it, "but... that once was enough, I think. Anyway, Boromir would play with us and taught us the basics of how to fight, he was just... he was kind, so very kind, and I felt myself..." damn it, he thought, and here are the bloody tears. "I fought it," he whispered wretchedly. "He was a man, and a noble, twice my size and from far away from anywhere I'd ever known or thought of. I fought so hard."
"We do fight, don't we?" Bilbo said softly, eyes unusually compassionate. The soft old hand returned, patting his arm. "Doesn't help, though. Not in the end."
"No, not in the end," Merry said softly. "We... well, you heard what happened in Moria. I've never been that terrified in my life. I think that may have been the only time Boromir was scared the whole time I knew him. That giant flaming thing, the balrog, it was... it was like everything bad in the world, every bad dream you ever had, just rolled up and brought into the daytime to see you. You could feel it... knowing you, and you knew it not only understood you, but it hated you, and it would know just how to hurt you the worst." Bilbo nodded, though Merry thought there was no way he could understand, not really.
"The Ring was like that, sometimes," Bilbo said quietly, leaving Merry agog once more. "It would tell you the thing that it knew would hurt you the most, just to feel you squirm and fret. It loved misery, loved it like a drunkard loves ale. I always knew it was lying, though," he said with a funny little smile.
"How?" Merry asked. He had never imagined Bilbo would ever speak of any of this, but if he was... well, if he was, there was a question he had held since the beginning of their long quest. "How did you resist? Just having it for a few years almost killed Frodo, but you... you had it for almost seventy years, Bilbo. How did you...?" he didn't even know how to phrase the question, just waved his hands and hoped the older hobbit understood.
"Well, I don't wish to speak about that, and that's not what we're discussing right now," Bilbo said archly, making Merry's gut sink a bit. "But," the old hobbit continued, "since we happen to be talking about some related things... I always knew it was lying because the thing it knew would hurt me most was to convince me that Thorin never loved me, not really." A twisted grin flew across the withered face, showing traces of the young hobbit he once was. "And I knew with all the heart of me that that was a lie. And so all the rest had to be lies as well, didn't they?"
"Yes," Merry whispered. "Yes, they did."
"I hate what it did to Frodo," Bilbo replied just as quietly. "I hate it with all that's in me. If I had it to do over," he clutched at Merry's sleeve, "I'd take myself there to throw it in the fire myself, old as I am. Maybe I'd fall in too, but nobody would miss an old baggage like me, and I'd die a thousand times over to destroy the thing that hurt my boy so badly." His face was a mask of desperate love, and Merry felt his heart break, just a bit, imagining the old hobbit here worrying while Frodo suffered so much.
"I know," Merry said. "We all know, Mister Bilbo. Bilbo," he corrected, rolling his eyes, "It all worked out for the best in the end, though, and now the thing's done."
"'For the best in the end'," Bilbo parroted mockingly, scoffing in scorn. "That's what we always said in the Shire. Bollocks, the lot of it. Utter rubbish and poppycock. Many might think Thorin's death was for the best in the end, too, wouldn't they?" Fierce black eyes met Merry's. "After all, he was gold-mad before the battle, wasn't he? Nobody knew what sort of king he'd be. And then Dain took the throne, the great and mighty Dain Ironfoot, the fierce warrior, the great king, the noble... oh the noble whatever you wish! And maybe it was what Erebor needed," he ended bitterly, "but it came at the cost of a hobbit's heart and soul, that triumph of Dain's, and no cake nor thank-you card is sufficient for that, let me tell you. I suspect you understand all too well, my boy," he said to Merry, grimacing. "I would imagine, based on the stories I've heard, you know exactly what I mean."
"Yes," he half-sobbed. "Yes, I'm very afraid I do." He took a deep breath and held it, willing the tears to stop. He was getting rather good at this, he'd found, and Pip helped him deflect others when he needed a moment. "Boromir was... the Ring tried to get him. Oh, it tried so hard. He was already pretty miserable, deep inside, so," he shrugged, not knowing how to complete the sentence but Bilbo nodded as though he understood. "He was all caught up in duty and honor and what was right, but when we could manage to sneak off together, just for a bit, he was... he was different," he murmured sadly. "He was everything. So handsome and golden, and he said I was the only one that could get him to relax and just, well, just put it all down for a bit, I suppose." He laughed in spite of himself. "Bit of a scandal, really, the things we got up to in the woods, filthy as we were, but I suppose you understand that as well. You stink, he stinks, everything stinks, but somehow... somehow it's all still alright, because it's him."
Bilbo grimaced. "You're luckier than I was," he said. "At least you got that much. Thorin and I never managed to, well, seal the deal if you'll pardon the rudeness and the common expression. Dwarves are far nosier than human companions, almost as bad as hobbits, and once everyone had an inkling of what was going on, well..." Bilbo gave a tiny smile. "We wouldn't have five minutes alone to kiss without subterfuge and teasing, let alone anything," he cleared his throat, "more." Merry felt his heart go out to the older hobbit even more. He missed Boromir terribly, but... imagining not having those few sweet memories, at least... what a horror.
"I'm... I'm so sorry again," Merry said, feeling foolish and (for the first time in quite a while) lucky.
"Pah," Bilbo waved it off. "Just as well, really. I have long suspected if I knew, truly knew, what I was missing, I wouldn't have been able to move forward. Glorfindel - who you may not have met but very much should - assures me I will have the option to see him again after, well," he drew a finger across his neck and laughed like a faunt. Merry laughed too, appalled and amused in equal measure. Same old Bilbo! "And I have to believe him, being as he's the only person around who's been and come back from that particular journey." He took the last scone off the tray, placed it on Merry's plate with a flourish, and refilled his tea with the dregs of the pot. "But, speaking of journeys, there's a reason I am dragging this story out of you and telling you mine, I'm afraid."
"Ah," Merry said dumbly. He had almost forgotten that Bilbo had indicated that. "What... do you need something from the Shire? I will send anything that..." Bilbo cut him off.
"As if I would need anything I couldn't have sent for! No my boy, you shan't get off that easily I'm afraid." Bilbo sat for a moment, mouth working and eyes turned down towards his lap. "It's Frodo." Of course it was, Merry thought. It was always Frodo.
"I promise to take the very best care of him I can, Mister Bilbo, you know that..." Merry started before Bilbo glared at him, and he had to admit, that was a glare to fear. His own father would be proud of a glare that strong. He cringed in his seat and (as was intended) shut up.
"Now if you're quite finished trying to tell me what you think I meant to say, I'll thank you to hush and let me say it," Bilbo said acidly. Merry nodded meekly, and the tiny harrumph indicated that he had gotten off light this time. "As I was saying," an arch look at Merry, which he took without comment, "I have thought about heartbreak a great deal. I know it, I know its ways, I know its tricks and its lies and its temptations. You will find, young Meriadoc, that there are temptations in misery; to just sit and brood is not so terrible, you will discover, when you have something so worthy to brood about. To hide away, to let life pass you by, to not go anywhere or do anything because none of the twitterpated morons you might be forced to encounter understand how you have suffered... that's a path that many have taken. It doesn't end well. Take it from me," Bilbo said, clasping Merry's hand in his own, "it doesn't end well at all. You reach the end of your life old and bitter, out of touch and abandoned by everyone around you because you hid from them until they forgot you were there. Oh no need to look like that, that wasn't what I did no matter what you may think I'm thinking," Bilbo chuckled, "... but it was a close call. If not for Frodo, I was well along the way to that sort of end. You need something to live for. And..." Bilbo took a deep breath, "Frodo will as well."
"Frodo?" Merry was stunned, not sure what the conversation was about suddenly. "Is he...? What do you mean, has he lost someone?"
"He will," Bilbo said grimly. "I've watched him for years. I know my boy. The Ring hollowed him out and the only person to sustain him was the only person who's ever sustained him. Sam Gamgee. But Merry," black eyes worthy of a crow bored into his, "Sam doesn't love Frodo the same way Frodo loves Sam. Sam loves Frodo in the same way that a sunflower loves the sun. He loves him like a loyal soldier loves his king, like a dog loves his master. Not," he sighed, "like a man loves his wife... or husband." Merry felt something inside of him shift, just a little, and suddenly the veil over his eyes was lifted. He had grown up with these hobbits, known them since they were tiny faunts rolling about on the grass, but the truth of what Bilbo was saying shook him to his core like lightning. Oh, his mouth said soundlessly. Bilbo nodded. "Now you see. And Sam will go back with him, and he will live with him, and he will tend to him, and he will worry about him and care for him until Frodo dies of old age... but Sam won't give him what he wants, what he needs most. Sam will marry someday, and Sam will have children, and Frodo will pine and sicken because it won't be with him and Sam won't know why."
"Oh," Merry managed to say. "Oh Green Lady of Flowers, Frodo..." Bilbo nodded twice, harshly, looking like a king passing judgement.
"Frodo needs someone who understands, someone who knows that it is possible to be heartsick and still go forward, still live and (if life is kind) even love again, after a fashion. Many manage. I never did, but he might. You will, I think." Merry fought to object but Bilbo spoke over top of him. "Not right away, of course. You still hurt too much for that. But... I won't be there for him. No, not a word about it, I know how old and decrepit I am, Meriadoc Brandybuck, and if you tell me some nonsense about how young and hale I look I shall hit you with this teapot! I won't be there for him... but I want to know that you will. Because you know how it feels, you know the endless sucking wanting of something that isn't there, and you can help him. Will you do that for me?" Merry nodded; what else could he do? "Good," Bilbo sighed, leaning back in his chair and looking very tired indeed. "Good. Well, I misspoke a bit there. There's no reason to do it for me." Sleepy dark eyes nailed Merry to his seat one more time. "Do it for him. If you ever cared for him, Merry, do it for Frodo."
"I will, Bilbo. I swear it. As long as I'm around, I'll... I'll do what I can." Bilbo nodded, seeming as though he was already falling back asleep. The sun had moved on as their discussion continued, taking the streaming light away from their chairs and making the breeze feel cool through the open sash. "Poor Frodo," he said.
"Yes, poor Frodo indeed," Bilbo sighed drowsily. "It's horrible to feel such things. Quite, quite horrible. But poor you as well, to see someone who will feel such things soon and be helpless to stop it. I'm sorry, my boy, but..." the old hobbit shrugged, looking shrunken and tiny now, hardly recognizable as the same person with whom he had been speaking. "I had nobody else to ask. I'm sorry for your loss, Merry. I hope, like Glorfindel says, you see him again, and together you can have the joy that life robbed you of. It's not fair..." Bilbo slurred, clearly falling asleep. "Not fair at all..."
"No it isn't," Merry murmured, tucking a coverlet nearby over the tiny snoozing form in the other chair. "It's not fair for me, it's not fair for you, it's not fair for Frodo. Sleep well, and I hope you get to spend forever with your Thorin as well, Mister Bilbo." The room was still as he let himself out. He braced himself to go into Frodo's room and act cheerful; no need to get ahead of ourselves, he thought sourly. And maybe Bilbo was wrong, after all. He knew better, though. He recognized the signs all too well now that they had been pointed out to him. A vision of Bilbo speaking rose up in his mind saying 'we know our own kind'. Indeed we do, Mister Bilbo, he sighed. Indeed we do. Pushing his grief back down into its usual bundle out of the way, he moved down the corridor towards the healing rooms.
