Actions

Work Header

What The Daylight Forgets

Chapter 5

Notes:

depression has won again

Chapter Text

The high of the natural twenty didn’t last past midnight. By the time Steve finally dropped Dustin off at his house, the adrenaline had completely bled out, leaving behind a heavy, bone-deep exhaustion.

The next morning hit with the same bright, unrelenting heat. Steve spent the first four hours of his Saturday shift at Family Video mechanically rewinding VHS tapes and staring out the front window. The bitter taste of yesterday's thoughts about Billy had faded into a dull, background hum, replaced by a strange, hollow quiet.
Around two o’clock, the bell above the door chimed.

Steve didn’t look up immediately, adjusting a stack of comedy releases on the counter. "Welcome to Family Video, let me know if you need help finding—"
"Hey, Steve."

The voice made his hands pause. He looked up, blinking against the glare of the sun through the glass. Nancy Wheeler was standing on the other side of the counter. She looked exactly like Nancy always did—neat, put-together, wearing a light blue button-down shirt that looked crisp despite the mid-afternoon humidity. Her hair was pulled back, and she was holding a small stack of library books against her chest like a shield.

"Oh. Hey, Nance," Steve said, dropping the tapes onto the counter. He offered her a quick, practiced smile. "What’s up? Looking for a movie, or just stopping by to make sure Mike didn’t break my car last night?"

Nancy didn't smile back, though her expression wasn't angry either. It was just careful. It was the face she wore when she was trying to figure out the right way to say something difficult.
"Mike said you drove them to Lucas's," she said softly, stepping closer to the counter. "Thanks for doing that. I know they can be... a lot."
"Yeah, well. Henderson is a master negotiator. Pretty sure he threatened to hex my hair if I said no," Steve joked, rubbing the back of his neck.
The silence that followed was heavy. It wasn't the volatile, sparking silence he’d shared with Billy in the gym, or the comfortable, chaotic noise of the kids. It was just empty. A vast, awkward distance between two people who used to share a bed, a bedroom window, and a terrifying secret.

"Steve," Nancy started, her fingers tightening around the spines of her books. "Do you have a minute? To just... talk?"
Steve glanced around the empty store. Robin was in the back room eating a sandwich, and the only customer was an old man in the western section who had been staring at the same John Wayne tape for twenty minutes.

"Yeah. Yeah, sure. What's on your mind?"
Nancy looked down at the scratched wood of the counter, tracing a grain line with her thumb. "I’ve been thinking a lot about... everything. About last year. About the night at the Byers' house, and Jonathan, and... us." She took a breath, looking up at him with clear, searching eyes. "I feel like we never really finished the conversation. We just stopped. And I wanted to see how you were doing. If you were... okay."

Steve looked at her. Really looked at her.

He waited for the familiar twist in his stomach. He waited for the sharp, aching pang of regret that had haunted him for months after she called their relationship bullshit in that drunken bathroom. He waited for the desperate, pathetic urge to say whatever he needed to say to get her back, to fix it, to return to the safety of being the boy who loved Nancy Wheeler.

But nothing happened.

The space inside his chest stayed entirely flat. He looked at the curve of her jaw, the serious line of her mouth, the sharp intelligence in her eyes, and all he felt was a profound, distant appreciation. Like looking at a photograph of a place he used to live, realizing he didn’t remember the street names anymore.
I don't love her, the realization hit him not with a crash, but with a quiet, undeniable clarity. He hadn’t loved her in a really long time. It wasn't because of Jonathan, and it wasn't because she had hurt him. It was just... over. They had survived a monster together, and they had held onto each other because they were drowning, but the tide had gone out. The girl standing in front of him was a stranger he cared about, a ghost from a version of his life that didn't exist anymore.
"Steve?" Nancy asked, her brow furrowing slightly at his silence. "Are you alright?"
"Yeah," Steve said, and for the first time in months, the word didn't feel like a lie. He let out a soft, genuine breath that was almost a laugh. "Yeah, Nance. I'm okay."
"Are you sure? Because if you're still angry—"
"I'm not angry," Steve interrupted gently. He leaned his forearms on the counter, looking at her without the defensive armor he usually wore. "I'm really not. I think... I think we were trying to force something to work because the rest of the world was falling apart. And it's okay that it didn't."
Nancy stared at him, her eyes widening a fraction. She was smart—smarter than him, always had been—and he could see the exact moment she registered the shift in him. The tension in her shoulders suddenly dropped. The defensive guard she always kept up around him began to thaw.
"You really mean that," she murmured.
"I do," Steve said. "You and Jonathan... you make sense, Nance. You always did. I was just too stubborn to see it.”

A small, tentative smile finally broke across Nancy's face, a real one that reached her eyes. "Thank you, Steve. That... means a lot. More than you know."
"Don't worry about it," Steve said, tapping the counter cheerfully. "Just make sure Jonathan keeps his camera away from my good side if he's taking pictures for the paper."
Nancy let out a short, startled laugh, shaking her head. "I'll tell him." She took a step back toward the door, looking lighter than she had when she walked in. "I'll see you around, Steve."
"See ya, Nance."

The bell chimed again as she left, entering the bright, blazing afternoon heat.
Steve stood behind the counter for a long moment, watching the empty glass door. The hollow feeling in his chest wasn't gone, but it didn't feel heavy anymore. It felt clean. A blank slate. He had spent so long defining himself by who he was to other people—Nancy's boyfriend, Steve, the babysitter.

He pulled a fresh tape from the return bin, dropping it into the rewinder. As the machine began to whir, a sudden, intrusive memory flashed in his mind. Not of Nancy, but of the gym floor. Of the heavy, suffocating heat, and the intense, furious blue of Billy Hargrove's eyes looking down at him, demanding something Steve
didn't know how to give.

Steve’s fingers tightened on the plastic tape casing. The bitter irritation was there, sure, but beneath it, a strange, uncharted static prickled against his skin.

He didn't love Nancy. He was completely, entirely free. And for some reason, looking out into the blinding, empty afternoon sun, that freedom felt a whole lot more dangerous than it had five minutes ago.