Chapter Text
The school week dragged on like a slow-motion car crash. Every time Steve saw Billy across the cafeteria or down a crowded hallway, he felt the sickening tug of a tether he hadn't realized was holding him upright. The contrast was maddening. By night, they were two people who had shared the most intimate, vulnerable hours of their lives—the silence, the quiet, the shared coffee, the trust. By day, they were caricatures: the golden boy of Hawkins and the town’s resident nightmare.
Steve sat in the back of Mrs. Wheeler’s history class on Wednesday, staring at the back of Billy’s head. He found himself cataloging the details he shouldn't know: the specific way Billy’s neck tensed when he was annoyed, the way he picked at the fabric of his jeans when he was anxious, the exact shade of blue his eyes turned when he was about to start a fight.
*I’m losing my mind,* Steve thought, his pencil snapping under his grip.
He was obsessing over the silence. That moment in the kitchen—over breakfast, seeing Billy finally let his walls come down for a second, had become a loop in his brain. He couldn't shake it. He kept replaying the scene, analyzing the tension in Billy’s shoulders, the way he had braced himself against the counter. It hadn't looked like hatred. It hadn't even looked like apathy. It had looked like someone trying to hold back an ocean with a single hand.
But was the ocean the hatred, or was it the friendship?
After class, Steve found himself cornered by Tommy H. and Carol near the water fountain. They were laughing about some prank they’d pulled on a freshman, their voices sharp and jarring.
"You've been weird all week, Harrington," Carol noted, her eyes narrowing as she leaned against the lockers. "Like you’re somewhere else. Did Nancy finally text you back or something?"
Steve forced a laugh, his cheeks aching from the effort of the facade. "Just tired, Carol. Late nights."
"Too late?" Tommy nudged him, his voice dropping into a lewd suggestion. "Find someone new to play with?"
Steve felt a spike of genuine, violent anger. He wanted to swing. He wanted to grab Tommy by the collar and slam him against the locker just to see if he’d stop talking, stop assuming he knew anything about Steve’s life. The thought of Billy being grouped into Tommy’s crass little world of "playthings" made Steve’s blood boil.
"Leave it alone, Tommy," Steve said, his voice dropping into a dangerous, low register that made the other boy blink.
"Whoa, easy, Stevie," Tommy held up his hands, laughing nervously. "Just asking.”
asking."
Steve turned and walked away, his heart hammering against his ribs. He felt trapped. Every interaction felt like a performance, every conversation a minefield. He was fighting two wars: one against the school’s suffocating expectations, and one against his own brain, which refused to stop mapping out ways to get back to the safety of the his home.
He ducked into the library to escape the crowd, hoping for a few minutes of peace. He rounded a bookshelf and nearly collided with someone.
Billy.
They were in a narrow aisle, surrounded by rows of dusty reference books. The sudden proximity hit Steve like a physical wall. Billy looked tired—his hair was slightly disheveled, and there were dark circles under his eyes that hadn't been there a few days ago. He looked like he hadn't slept either.
"You’re following me," Billy said. It wasn't a question. His voice was a harsh whisper, stripped of the bravado he wore in the hallways.
"I didn't know you were in here," Steve defended, though his heart was racing. "I was just hanging out."
Billy stepped forward, closing the distance until they were almost chest to chest. The smell of his shampoo—the same one Steve kept in the upstairs bathroom—was faint but undeniable. Steve felt his throat tighten.
"Stop it, Steve," Billy said, his eyes scanning Steve’s face. He looked frustrated, his jaw working as if he were trying to swallow words that didn't want to come out. "Stop looking at me like that."
"Like what?"
"Like you're waiting for something," Billy hissed. "Like we’re still in that house. We’re not. You need to get your head straight, or you’re going to blow both of us up."
"I can't just flip a switch," Steve said, his voice trembling. "I can't go back to hating you when I know what’s under the tough guy act. I know you’re not what this town says you are."
Billy’s expression shifted, a flash of something so pained and vulnerable passing through his eyes that Steve reached out, his hand hovering mid-air. He wanted to touch him. He wanted to grab the lapel of Billy’s jacket and shake some sense into him.
Billy caught his wrist in mid-air. His grip was firm, electric. He didn't push Steve away, but he didn't pull him closer, either. They stayed like that, locked in the narrow aisle, the air humming with the weight of everything they couldn't say.
"If you don't stop," Billy whispered, his voice dangerously close to Steve’s ear, "they’re going to break you, Steve. And I can't be the reason for that."
He let go of Steve’s wrist and walked past him, leaving Steve standing alone in the library, his skin burning where Billy had touched him.
