Chapter Text
The invitation arrived on a Tuesday, printed on cheap cardstock and shoved into every single locker in the hallway. It was Tommy H.’s grand, self-important declaration: End of Year Bash. The Lake House. Everyone Invited. Midnight Bonfire.
By the time Steve reached his locker, he already saw three of them crumpled on the floor like discarded confetti. He picked his up, his heart sinking with the weight of the social obligation.
Billy was leaning against the lockers three feet away, reading his own copy with a look of profound, lip-curled disgust.
He caught Steve’s eye, his expression shifting from annoyance to a sharp, silent, and entirely private question.
"Looks like we’re invited to the main event," Billy drawled, his voice loud enough for the nearby juniors to hear, vibrating with a practiced, antagonistic edge. "Think you can handle a whole night of Tommy’s company without losing your mind, Harrington?"
Steve scoffed, tossing the card into his locker with a casual flick of his wrist. "I’d rather drink battery acid. But I guess I have to show up, if only to make sure he doesn't burn the whole place down."
"Don't worry," Billy said, his eyes glinting with a hidden, jagged amusement. "I’ll be there. I wouldn't miss the chance to watch you try to act like you’re having a good time."
It was the perfect, unspoken cover. The entire grade would be there—three hundred kids scattered across the lake house property, a massive, unmanageable crowd that ensured no one would be paying attention to anyone else.
By midnight, the air was thick with the scent of pine, charcoal, and the collective, frantic sweat of teenagers who had finally tasted the freedom of summer. Music blared from speakers rigged up on the deck, a thumping, bass-heavy track that rattled the ribcage of anyone standing near the fire. Tommy H. had decided a massive, grade-wide game of "Capture the Flag" was the only way to unify the chaos, and the woods were currently filled with the sounds of shouting, crashing branches, and the occasional shriek of someone being tackled into the mud.
Steve had spent the night playing the part—the Fuckboy of Hawkins, holding court, laughing at the right moments, and nursing a beer like it was a lifeline. But the performance was exhausting. He slipped away from the bonfire, moving into the dense, cool shadows of the tree line. He wasn't planning on wandering far, just enough to catch his breath, when a low, rhythmic whistle cut through the darkness.
Steve froze, then turned, a genuine grin breaking across his face as a figure detached itself from the gloom.
"You look bored," Billy’s voice came out of the shadows, low and amused.
Steve exhaled, his shoulders finally dropping. "Tommy has everyone convinced this is a tactical military operation. I think he’s actually taking it seriously."
"He’s an idiot," Billy said, stepping into a sliver of moonlight that broke through the canopy. He was wearing his denim jacket, the collar turned up against the night air. "I’ve been watching him from the tree line for twenty minutes. He’s currently trying to lead a charge against a group of freshmen who are just trying to find a place to make out."
Steve laughed, the sound easy and unforced. "I’m glad I’m not the only one who thinks this is a disaster."
"I wasn't playing," Billy said, closing the distance between them until he was well within Steve’s space. He leaned against a tree, crossing his arms over his chest. "I was just waiting for you to realize that being the 'best in show' is a full-time job that you should have quit hours ago."
"I know," Steve said, his voice softening.
They settled into the dirt at the base of a large oak, a comfortable, quiet sanctuary shielded by the thicket. For the first time all night, the frantic energy of the party faded into the background.
"So," Billy started, kicking at a pile of dry leaves with the toe of his boot. "How's the life of the party holding up? Still got that reputation to maintain, or can we actually talk?"
Steve let out a short, self-deprecating laugh. "It’s a performance, Billy. It’s always a performance. I just… I don’t know. I’m tired of the noise. I’m tired of people assuming they know who I am just because I have a specific haircut and a car."
"They don't know shit," Billy said, his voice dropping into a register that wasn't for public consumption. "They look at you and they see a trophy. They don't see the guy who actually has a brain in his head." He paused, looking at Steve with a rare, candid intensity. "I remember you at the start of the year. You were so desperate to keep it all together. It was exhausting just watching you."
"I was a mess," Steve admitted, picking at a loose thread on his jeans. "And you? You came in here like a fucking thunderstorm."
Billy let out a sharp, genuine laugh, the kind that reached his eyes. "Yeah, well. California wasn't exactly a picnic. I had a lot of rage, and nowhere to put it. When I got to Hawkins, I thought being the toughest guy in the room was the only way to keep people from getting too close."
"It worked," Steve teased. "You terrified everyone."
"Mission accomplished," Billy smirked. He grew quiet for a moment, tracing the bark of the tree. "My dad... he didn't care much about what I was doing, as long as I wasn't being a disappointment. But he never asked about what I liked, or what I was thinking. Just wanted me to be a winner. I got tired of winning for him."
Steve shifted, leaning his shoulder against Billy’s. "I get that. My parents are always at work. They think if they buy me the right things, they’re being good parents. But they don't actually see me. They haven't really looked at me in years."
"That’s why you collect people," Billy said, his voice unusually gentle. "You’re always trying to build a family out of whoever is around. Even the kids, right? The little ones."
Steve smiled softly, looking up at the canopy of leaves. "They’re a handful, but they’re better than the people I grew up with."
Billy chuckled, shaking his head. "You're a weird guy, Harrington. But I guess I like it." He shifted the conversation with a sudden, playful smirk. "Speaking of people, I heard a rumor today. Something about you and... who was it? Carol? Back in, what, sophomore year?"
Steve groaned, burying his face in his hands. "Oh, god. Don't remind me. Carol was a nightmare. She was obsessed with status. She only dated me because I was the 'King' and she wanted to be the Queen. It was all appearances."
"And the others?" Billy pressed, clearly enjoying the discomfort. "I’ve seen the list. It’s pretty long."
"Shut up," Steve said, shoving his shoulder, but he was grinning. "It wasn't that long. And most of them were just... empty. It was like dating a mirror. They didn't want me; they wanted the idea of me."
"And now?" Billy asked, his voice dropping, the playfulness replaced by something deeper, more searching.
"Now?" Steve looked at him, his gaze steady. "I’m not interested in mirrors anymore."
Billy reached out, his fingers brushing against Steve’s jawline, his touch lingering. "Good. Because I’m a lot of things, Steve, but I’m definitely not a reflection."
He pulled Steve closer, his thumb tracing a slow, rhythmic circle against his skin. The distance between them vanished, the tension of the evening resolving into something soft and intimate. They kissed—slow, deep, and unhurried—a stark contrast to the shouting and the bass thumping in the distance.
"We should probably get back," Steve whispered after a long while, though he didn't move.
"In a minute," Billy said, his arm hooked around Steve’s shoulders, grounding him. "Let them look. Let them wonder where the enemies went."
Steve laughed, resting his forehead against Billy’s shoulder. The summer felt like an endless, open field, and for the first time, he didn't feel the need to race toward the finish line. He was exactly where he wanted to be.
"Capture the flag?" Steve teased, his voice muffled against Billy’s neck.
Billy pulled back just enough to look him in the eye, a slow, genuine smile spreading across his face. "I think I already did."
They stayed in the dark for a few more minutes, savoring the silence, before they eventually separated. They slipped back toward the bonfire at different times, with enough distance to remain unnoticed. As Steve stepped back into the ring of firelight, he saw Tommy H. looking around, annoyed.
"Where the hell did you go, Harrington?" Tommy grumbled, shoving a lukewarm beer into Steve’s hand. "You missed the best part of the game."
"Just needed some air," Steve said, his voice easy, cool, and perfectly composed. "It was getting a little too loud in there."
He took a sip of the beer, his eyes scanning the tree line. He couldn't see Billy, but he didn't need to. He knew exactly where he was, and he knew that as soon as this ridiculous, loud, performative night was over, they’d be heading home. Thank fucking god.
