Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Lives Long Past

Summary:

Excerpt:
The being who opens the door, for they could not be a Halfling when they are so different from their peers, meets his gaze steadily. Their eyes are the only thing Thorin can focus on; a brilliant green, golden flecks surrounding the pupil as age beyond this creature’s years are reflected back to him.

 

But beyond that there is something familiar, something that makes Thorin’s chest ache as he remembers the body Dwalin had cradled as he apologized to Thorin again and again for his failure. They’re the same eyes he’d stared into every afternoon for sparring since he was a pebble, the eyes that had hovered above his own in protection as dragon fire raged around them, the same eyes he’d seek out when the days began to weigh on him, the same eyes he’d pictured darkening or turning away from him were he to ever confess one of his deepest secrets, and the same eyes he’d seen dim and lifeless as he lost his only chance to ever tell them of his regard. He knows those eyes, but he does not know the creature they’re attached to.

 

 Bilbo has been reincarnated since the beginning of Arda, this is the only time he's remembered.

Notes:

Hello! This is just a little story idea I had. I hope you enjoy! Thank you for reading.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

When Thorin knocks upon the door of Tharkûn’s recommended burglar, and honestly what was he thinking recommending a Halfling, it is not opened by some scared and cowering little waif of a creature like he’d expected. The being who opens the door, for they could not be a Halfling when they are so different from their peers, meets his gaze steadily. Their eyes are the only thing Thorin can focus on; a brilliant green, golden flecks surrounding the pupil as age beyond this creature’s years are reflected back to him.

But beyond that there is something familiar, something that makes Thorin’s chest ache as he remembers the body Dwalin had cradled as he apologized to Thorin again and again for his failure. They’re the same eyes he’d stared into every afternoon for sparring since he was a pebble, the eyes that had hovered above his own in protection as dragon fire raged around them, the same eyes he’d seek out when the days began to weigh on him, the same eyes he’d pictured darkening or turning away from him were he to ever confess one of his deepest secrets, and the same eyes he’d seen dim and lifeless as he lost his only chance to ever tell them of his regard. He knows those eyes, but he does not know the creature they’re attached to.

“Thorin, I would like to introduce you to Bilbo Baggins. Bilbo, this is-”

“Thorin Durinson.” The Halfling interrupts, eyeing him up and down as his Company begins to gather in the doorway to his left; all of them watching their host with weariness unbefitting of such a small creature.

At the front of them all is Dwalin and Balin, watching the Halfling with a sadness that tells him they feel the same way he does about the one who stands in front of him. That there is something familiar about the being in front of them.

And the creature somehow knows his name as well, albeit his old one. Thorin turns his attention back to him, he has never met this creature and his name would not spread amongst Halflings; not this one. “How do you-”

“We have met before.” He interrupts, shrugging and turning away before Thorin can speak again. “There’s food prepared, as long as your Company has not eaten it all.” He pushes past the now sheepish Company as they turn away from Thorin’s now annoyed gaze to head back into the kitchen behind the Halfling, only Balin and Dwalin stay.

Thorin clears his throat and calms his heart, his mind racing as he mentally shakes off his unease. “I trust you informed him of our purpose here?” Thorin asks the Wizard, already knowing the answer; the Halfling couldn’t know him any other way. He focuses on the annoyance he’d felt earlier, pushing old memories to the side.

Tharkûn sighs, hesitating.

“He did not.” Balin cuts in, interrupting before the Wizard can speak.

Thorin turns to the brothers.

“The Half-” Dwalin cuts himself off, “Hobbit wasn’t told we would be coming.”

Thorin raises an eyebrow at the correction before he turns back to the Wizard. “You said you found us a capable burglar.”

Tharkûn huffs. “And I have.”

Thorin scoffs, anger overtaking his mind at the mockery he has been faced with. “He’s little more than a grocer. A halfling-”

A knife shoots past Thorin’s head, making him instinctively step back, reaching for a weapon as his eyes seek out his assailant.

The Halfling stands there, hand still outstretched. He holds Thorin’s gaze with a glare before he lowers his arm and exhales roughly; and Valar that’s familiar as well. “I am a Hobbit.” He sends a glance to Dwalin, who does not meet his gaze. “If you cannot address me without insult you can see yourself out.”

Thorin swallows and nods, looking anywhere but his damned eyes; instead his eyes fall to his hair, the same curl as the original owner of those eyes, and only a little shorter. “My apologies.”

The Hobbit stares at him for a long moment before nodding, his voice unreasonably fond for some reason when he speaks. “Bring the knife when you come to the table.” He turns and enters the silent dining room that should not be as quiet as it is with nine Dwarrow occupying it.

Thorin’s heart gives a lurch in his chest and he looks to Dwalin and Balin.

Something must show on his face for Dwalin lowers his voice and tilts his head. “You’ve noticed, haven't ya?”

Thorin doesn’t answer as he reaches for the knife that had embedded itself in the wall next to where he’d originally stood. It’s a dinner knife, not even a proper throwing or hunting knife like he’d expected. When he pulls it out he sees just how deep it was, nearly to the handle. He stares at it before he clears his throat.

“Explain Wizard.”

Tharkûn huffs and clears his throat. “Bilbo is not the Hobbit I remember. When I recommended him as a burglar I was unaware of certain,” The Wizard hesitates, “circumstances.”

“What circumstances?” Thorin asks, his voice nearly shaking.

“He is changed. Now aged far beyond any mortal’s years with knowledge no Hobbit could know.”

“Stop speaking in riddles.” Thorin demanded, annoyance rising to replace his confusion. “Who-What have you hired to my Company?”

“I do not know.” The Wizard admits, annoyed. “I had thought to ask,” he swallows, annoyance giving way to mischief in his eyes as he continues, “if I had not felt his story is not one to be told without an audience that he seems to know.”

Thorin huffs, shaking his head. “We have never-”

“I did not tell him your name, Thorin Oakenshield. I did not have to, for he already knew it, and with it a great deal about you;” Tharkûn fixes him with a look, “though he knows only the Son of Durin, he does not know he who carries a shield of oak.”

Thorin swallowed down his arguments, turning back to Dwalin and Balin.

Balin stares at him for a long moment before sighing. “The lad seems familiar with us.”

“Too familiar.” Dwalin adds, glowering; though Thorin can see guilt there too, familiar after the many times Dwalin had caught him looking at a pair of hair beads after Azanulbizar.

Thorin considers this for a minute, “Is he a danger to my men?”

Tharkûn huffs. “I do not believe so, unless you prove to be a danger to him.” He nods to the knife Thorin still holds. “Or you insult him.” He turns with a smile on his face as he steps into the dining hall, the Company greeting him cheerfully; but quietly.

Thorin turns to Balin and Dwalin.

The brothers stare back.

Thorin watches them quietly for a long moment, both of them uneasy; but they wait for his judgement. Thorin swallows before sighing and turning to enter the dining hall, finding his Company sat around a long table, the Halfl-Hobbit with his back turned to them as he works at something in front of him set on the only other table at the far end of the room, the chair on the opposite head of the table also empty as the Wizard has settled in a corner.

He keeps eyes on the Hobbit as he sits. There is nothing of any real note, though Thorin notices how clothed he is. It’s warm in his home, yet he wears long trousers and long sleeves as if he’s cold. The Hobbit reaches up, into a cabinet; from which he pulls a bowl and small loaf of bread on a tray. He turns and places it on the table, staring across the table at him. “Do you have the knife?”

Thorin blinks at the question before nodding, throwing it on the table, the Company now dead silent as they watch the exchange between the two.

The Hobbit nods. “Pass this down.” He hands the tray to his youngest sister-son, who takes it and passes it without a complaint or quip.

“The Hobbit knocked him on his ass earlier.” Dwalin says under his breath as he sits next to Thorin.

Thorin glances at him.

“Lad did deserve it.” Balin says as he takes the other side.

Thorin nods, accepting the tray as it’s passed to him, noting the absence of the knife as he digs in, his Company staying silent as he eats, out of the corner of his eyes he can see what seems to be an empty pantry.

He casts glances at his Company, all of them seeming to be well fed, a few of them with crumbs left in their beards. He doesn’t comment as he continues eating until Balin clears his throat.

“What of the meeting?” He catches Thorin’s eye. “Will they aid us?”

Thorin swallows heavily, having forgotten about the news he would have to give his kin, “They say this quest is our own.”

Groans and sighs meet his statement, and as he looks up he sees the Hobbit has paused.

“What of Dáin?” Dwalin asks.

Thorin shakes his head. “Our cousin will not be joining us.”

Even more groans and sighs fill the room.

“Is there any good news?” Glóin asks from further down the table on his left.

Thorin clears his throat. “Dáin tells me Smaug has not been seen since the attack. The Men of the Lake say he is dead.”

Excited whispers surround him, voices raising in volume until a snort cuts through them, all eyes turning to their host as he continues on with whatever task he’d set himself to.

“If you wish to add something to this discussion Hobbit,” Thorin made sure to stress the word, “then speak.”

Their host pauses before placing something heavy down and turning. He looks over them all before he answers. “Smaug is not dead.” He turns back around, picking up what Thorin now realizes is a large knife as he goes back to his previous task. “Unless someone has snuck into Erebor to slay him then I can assure you Smaug is as he was all those years ago, if only in a deep sleep now.”

Most in his Company scoff. “And you’re a Dragon expert are you?” Bofur asks.

The Hobbit shrugs, keeping to his task instead of turning. “I know more about them than any other in this room.”

They scoff again, voices raising in disagreement. “Haven’t even seen a Dragon!” “Little Hobbit…” “Child of the West…”

Their host turns, the giant knife in his hands, quieting the Company. He stares at them for a long moment before he deposits it behind him without taking his eyes off them. “Dragons shed once a century, during the wet season.”

Thorin watches as eyebrows raise, he glances over his left shoulder watching the Wizard as he stares at the Hobbit, not interfering though his eyes are furrowed. He looks and meets Thorin’s eyes.

“The gestation period for a dragon egg is fifty-eight years, seven months.” The Hobbit continues.

Thorin looks back to him.

“Until they turn five-hundred and fifty-two they grow feathers instead of scales.” He reaches into a drawer and pulls out a smaller knife, going back to what he’d been cutting, grabbing two bowls and settling at the table as he continues speaking. “Among nestmates it is common to catch each other on fire while playing.”

He pulls a strawberry from one bowl and begins quartering it after stripping the green from the top, which he lays to the side. “The typical adult dragon has thirty-seven individual spikes from head to tail.” He drops the quarters in the other bowl before he looks back up at them. “Should I keep going?”

Thorin meets his eyes, familiar mischief reflects back to him.

“How do you know those things?” Ori asks, voice quiet.

The Hobbit picks up another strawberry, hitting away Kili’s hand with a glare before he turns back to Ori. “Experience.”

The Wizard clears his throat now, standing. “And that is the issue Bilbo, though I had hoped to question you with a smaller audience you have spoken far more than you should.” He fixes the Hobbit with a searching look. “A Hobbit should not have knowledge of such things.”

Their host smiles. “You are right.” He continues quartering, picking up speed quickly as he answers. “An ordinary Hobbit should not know such things, but I am no ordinary Hobbit.”

“And why’s that?” Thorin asks.

Their host shrugs, finishing off the last of his bowl and standing, “Because I was not always a Hobbit.”

“You look like a Hobbit.” Glóin says.

Their host ignores him, setting aside the bowl of cut fruit as he instead reaches for a bundle of dried herbs hanging off of the table he worked at. “I have lived many lives, in many kingdom’s and homes.” He says gravely. “None of them were ever the same. From the highest King, to the lowest slave; I have lived as them all.”

Thorin scoffs unconsciously, the rest of his Company looking more annoyed or confused with the Hobbit than anything. Complaints rise again, the Company scoffing as they speak to each other.

“If you do not believe me then why can I tell you about the old guard shifts in Moria, the Grey Mountains, and Erebor?”

The Company quiets again.

“Why can I tell you in painstaking detail the process of working with mithril?” He undoes the bundle and sorts them. “Why can I tell you everything you would need to know about maintaining and heating the main forges in Moria? Hobbits have no reason to know that, not when it’s a closely guarded secret of every Dwarrow Kingdom.”

“Coincidence.” Nori offers, his eyebrows furrowed.

“You lie.” Glóin demands, fury blazing in his eyes.

The Hobbit turns again, abandoning his work. “Perhaps telling you in your own language is enough.”

“Bilbo Baggins,” The Wizard begins, still standing though he now looks troubled, “you are far more than you appear.”

The Hobbit shrugs. “I do try.” He tilts his head. “Have you figured me out yet, Wanderer?” A smirk twitches at the corner of his lips. “Unless you prefer your actual name, Olor-”

“Bilbo Baggins!” The Wizard interrupts, scolding but his eyes are wide.

“How do you know Khuzdul?” Balin asks, ignoring the Wizard as his silent shock quickly turns to outrage. “Outsiders can not learn-”

“I learned it as every Dwarf does.” The Hobbit says, interrupting him. “But you must know your tongue was not always a secret. I can remember having lessons in it when I was a young Elf before the First Age.”

Tharkûn sits heavily, the back of his chair hitting the wall. “That is why you are familiar.”

The whole Company turns to him, watching as the Wizard keeps staring at their host; though his eyes also seem far away as if he’s seeing something they can not.

There is a long moment before Tharkûn blinks and sighs, looking at the Hobbit in wonder. “Now that I know where to look I can see.” He huffs. “You have lived far too many lives since I last saw you as a child Atacinus Took.”

Their host huffs a laugh. “You would be the one to remember the first time I was ever a Hobbit.”

The Wizard doesn’t reply immediately, instead he stares at him for a moment longer. “But that was not the first. Once you were Elhaelion, son of Elhael. The one heralded as hero after being struck down at the age of forty-eight in defense of a young Elrond during an attack.”

The Hobbit nods, satisfaction gleaming in his eyes. “Elrond became a great Lord.”

Tharkûn continues. “Also Berthon, great hunter of the Greenwood under Oropher, killed with Glorfindel by the Balrog in the Echoriath.”

Bilbo nods again with a fond sigh. “I warned Glorfindel he would get us killed.”

The Wizard doesn’t pause. “Another life as Rulek, only son of Nafek. You were the first Stone Lord of Moria. Dead at the age of sixty-seven after a mine collapse caused by your advisor’s negligence.”

The Hobbit nods again. “We could do this all night.”

Tharkûn huffs and shakes his head. “Nearly a thousand lives, some heralded, others forgotten; yet you remain the same.” He narrows his eyes at the Hobbit. “Why?”

Bilbo huffs a laugh. “I had hoped you could tell me.” He sits at the head of the table with the herbs, all neatly sorted in front of him. “Eighteen years ago I was a normal Hobbit, then I come of age and everything came back.”

“You mean-”

“I mean everything.” The Hobbit interrupts the Wizard as he pulls down the high collar of his shirt, revealing a brand mark; large and ugly, but faded in a way that should be impossible, making it nearly ineligible. “I have scars from battles fought before the first age that still ache and pull like new wounds.” He says, pulling his collar back into place. “I have tattoos in a language no one speaks anymore and now that I remember I want to know why.”

He directs his full attention to the Wizard.

Tharkûn opens his mouth to reply-

“I don’t believe it.”

Thorin looks to his right, at Dwalin as he scowls darkly at the Hobbit.

The Wizard clears his throat, “Master Dwalin-”

“Do you remember Folvam?”

Thorin freezes, watching as Dwalin’s face visibly falls at the Hobbit’s question. He turns his head back to Bilbo, something clicking in his mind as his confusion turns into horror.

“He turned fifty-five a week before the march on Moria’s gates.” He stands and turns away from the table as he speaks. “He fought with you when none of you had any right to be on that field, and you would not have been on that field if it were not for the desperation for you to get one victory at the very least after a string of losses that stretched you far too thin.” He swallows and clears his throat turning back and meeting Thorin’s eyes. “I died with the number eighty-five on my lips, though I know I missed one in my counting giving me eighty-six in total had I just kept my damned head straight.”

Thorin stares back at him as the silence stretches thin, a ringing in his ears as he’s brought back to that field made muddy with blood as he clutches a body to his chest.

“You lie.” Balin speaks on Thorin’s right, his voice shaking.

It’s enough to break Thorin out of his memories.

“I wore a sparrow’s feather at the base of my neck in remembrance of my mother because my father had made her a sparrow broach as a courting gift.” The Hobbit doesn’t falter, giving another answer to an unasked question. “She never took it off and the last time I saw it was the morning Erebor fell as she ushered my younger sister to her lesson while I headed to the ramparts.”

Thorin’s eyes close.

“How dare you?” The dishes in front of him clatter as Dwalin stands and slams a hand on the table as he yells “Making a mockery-”

“I mock no one!” The Hobbit yells back, next to him Thorin hears Dwalin sit back down heavily, all fight having left him almost immediately. “I have no idea what is going on any better than you! I wake up one day and I have scars from wounds I never survived and memories that speak of some greater goal I never accomplish. You know better than any in this room that I speak the truth! You are only afraid to admit it!”

He pauses, making Thorin finally open his eyes and look up. A familiar fire blazes in the Hobbit’s eyes as he takes a deep breath, steadying himself. He meets Thorin’s eyes and grimaces before he opens his mouth again, his eyes turned to Dwalin.

“Just as you were afraid to admit the buckle on your left bracer broke the night before we marched on Moria.”

Thorin glances at Dwalin, watching as his face slackens.

“You used an old leather strip to tie it as you asked me to watch your left side just in case it threw you off during the charge.”

The Hobbit pauses, a hesitation that makes Thorin feel like he is stepping up to a high ledge, the drop below him gaping and dark as he leans forward against his will-

“And it did. I died stopping a blade from piercing your heart.”

-and falls over the edge.

Dwalin stands suddenly, out of the room, and the home before anyone can say a word; the sound of the front door slamming shut echoing through the house.

Bilb-Folvam sighs.

Thorin looks back to him, he stares right back at him, defiance in his eyes until the Wizard speaks again.

“This changes many things.” Tharkûn stands.

Folvam scoffs. “This changes nothing.” He shakes his head and turns from Thorin to regard the Wizard. “If it was meant to then we would not be here. Erebor is still the goal, that is the reason you came.”

“Folvam-” Balin starts.

“No.” The Hobbit interrupts him. “Not Folvam, not anymore.” He turns away from the Company, back to the cutting board on the table against the wall.

“Bilbo-” The Wizard tries.

“My sitting room is clear,” the Hobbit interrupts, “when you want to rest head down the hall, there are plenty of rooms for you all.” He reaches for a knife, “Before we leave in the morning I want to review the contract you will have me sign, I have no doubt there will be many adjustments to be made.” He reaches into a bowl to pull out an apple. “Make yourselves welcome as you see fit.”

The Company all stare for a long moment before they turn to Thorin, all of them waiting on his word before they move.

Thorin doesn’t know what to say or do. He’s never felt like this, drained completely as if his own life has left him. Even after long days at the forge or travelling between cities with little rest he has never felt so drained, but he nods all the same.

Immediately the Company stands, all of them filing out as quickly as they can. His nephews pause before they too leave. Only Tharkûn and Balin stay behind.

The Hobbit doesn’t seem to care, slicing and coring the apples without a care.

Balin shifts and stands, patting Thorin on the back. “I’ll go look for Dwalin before he gets himself in trouble.”

Thorin nods distantly, listening to Balin’s shuffling as he heads out, the door shutting behind him firmly.

The Hobbit doesn’t seem to notice or care, continuing on with his apples as Thorin and the Wizard sit in silence.

Which is broken when Tharkûn sighs. “Bilbo-”

“I have no answers you want.” The Hobbit cuts him off. “I am nearly as lost as you.” He huffs. “You staring at my back will change nothing.”

The Wizard huffs back and stands.

“The key to my study is hidden on the right, in the third lantern from the door.” The Hobbit glances over his shoulder when Tharkûn pauses. “You will not find the answers you want there.”

The Wizard sighs and continues, his footsteps disappearing further into the house. In the next room over he can hear the Company speaking to each other, all of them incredibly quiet.

The Hobbit turns back around, continuing with his slicing.

Thorin continues to stare, not quite sure how he should feel. Folvam stands before him, even though he’s no longer a Dwarf Thorin can't deny his familiarity. There’s no doubt in his mind, but it’s nearly too good to believe. He studies the Hobbit, watching every little movement and trying to find something to convince himself he’s wrong, but there’s nothing. This is truly Folvam, reincarnated somehow, the Valar having answered his pleas; but still he can’t believe this is truly his lost One.

The Hobbit sighs. “Your glowering did not move me a hundred years ago, it won't move me now.”

“You died.” Thorin says, his voice as wrecked as he feels.

The Hobbit places the knife down as he dumps the apple slices into another bowl. “I did, but I have died many times.” He turns to Thorin, weary and sad. “And just like the others my death had a purpose.”

“You knew you would die.” Thorin accuses, his voice nearly a whisper.

“That is not how this works.” He smiles at him apologetically before he turns back to the cutting board. “I never know until either a split second before, or as I lay there dying after it is far too late to save me.” He chuckles, voice lowering as he picks up another apple. “Believe me if I knew before I would have said something.”

Thorin takes a breath, “I mourned you.”

He pauses. “I am sorry,” he glances back over his shoulder, “it is never my decision.” He drops his knife and sighs before turning around. “But all the same I am sorry. I-” He cuts himself off nervously. “I had hoped that you would forget me.”

“Forget?” Thorin asks incredulously, standing slowly. “How could I ever forget you?” He scoffs. “Folvam you were-”

“No.” The Hobbit interrupts, swallowing and shaking his head as he turns back to the chopping board. “Bilbo. I am Bilbo now.” He picks up his knife and continues with his apples. “I am not Folvam.” He shakes his head, his voice quieting. “I can not be him, not again.”

Thorin swallows, sitting back down slowly just as the Wizard enters again, huffing.

“Find what you were looking for?” The Hobbit asks, a smirk in his voice.

Tharkûn scoffs. “You know very well I did not.”

The Hobbit laughs.

“You should not be laughing.” Tharkûn sits heavily, pulling out his pipe and packing it before lighting it. “You die without reason, no pattern-”

“Necessity.” The Hobbit interrupts. “The reason is necessity. Sometimes you kill off a pawn to save the queen.”

The Wizard pauses, pulling his pipe away and staring at the Hobbit.

The Hobbit continues. “My deaths are a necessity. Without them the events that needed to pass would not.”

Tharkûn pauses for a moment. “Each has a purpose.”

“Right.” The Hobbit agrees. “My past lives all lived out their purpose, and now I have to live out mine.”

“You know your purpose?” The Wizard asks, sounding hopeful.

Bilbo shook his head, putting the last of the sliced apples into the bowl. “I know my death, that’s enough.”

Tharkûn leaned further forward. “And what is your death?”

Bilbo turned around and smiled. “Fire.”

Thorin swallowed heavily, throat suddenly dry as his breath freezes in his throat.

“But-” Bilbo cut through his thoughts, “-not Dragon Fire. This fire will be born of the earth, and the world around me will burn before it consumes me.” The Hobbit sits down at the other head of the table, before continuing with a glint in green eyes as he continues. “A volcano.”

“The only volcano you will find is in Mordor.” The Wizard says dismissively, shaking his head.

Bilbo chuckles tiredly, pausing the Wizard as he smiles wryly at Thorin with a mischievous gleam in his eyes. “And isn’t that exciting?”

Notes:

I hope you enjoyed! It's a little unedited but this story was just for fun so I hope no one was too disappointed. I might continue, but not at the moment. Thank you for reading!

Also! If you read any of my other stories they are on their way! It's just difficult for me to write between school and work. Thank you for your patience.

Series this work belongs to: