Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

What does it mean to be you?

Summary:

“Do we embarrass you? Do our differing bodies hurt your little eyes?” That was definitely a sneer.

“Why you-! I have no qualms with you Oakenshield, but do not begin to comprehend the ways in which I feel!” Bilbo’s fists clenched hard enough to whiten his knuckles. He hated the way his voice cracked towards the end, but this dwarf had no right. No right to say such things, when he had been nothing but polite and kind to these people!

The dwarf gave a short pause before giving a great sigh and settling on the riverbank beside him.

“It is not us that you are embarrassed by, is it Master Baggins?”

Notes:

Welcome to a new series! This isn't my first attempt at writing Tolkien fanfiction, but its certainly the only one posted. I've fallen into the rabbit hole that is bagginshield once more, and now I have this. It's going to be a part of a series I'm working on- one with one major story. They can be read independently of each other, but I would probably recommend reading them all when they eventually get posted. Other than that, I just kind of wanted to explore Dwarven culture and some of Hobbit culture since its such an important part of the universe. Uh this came together fairly quickly, which is pretty cool! I just kinda thought about how Dwarves might see gendeer and my brain went: "OO DO IT" and so I did.

Work Text:

Bilbo scurried through the underbrush- hoping to avoid any prying eyes. The grass squelched beneath his feet, mud matted his unkempt curls. He needed to bathe, but those ruddy dwarrow had no decency! They wanted, nearly insisted, him to bathe with them. No way in all the green hills would Bilbo Baggins bathe with a gaggle of rowdy dwarrow! Oh no, Bilbo Baggins was perfectly content to wash by himself. Especially when...when he looked like this.

He detested it. This mismatched body of his. His mind declared one thing, but his body presented another. Bilbo didn’t quite comprehend why Yavanna had built him so. His mother had insisted that the Valar always did everything for a reason, even if that reason did not make sense to any other but themselves. Or were in fact, good reasons. But they were made. And Bilbo would have to live with it. No matter how he despised it, there was nothing he could do to fix this...patchwork of a hobbit.

But Bilbo knew who he was, he was a man. No one could tell him otherwise. They had tried, on many occasions, but failed. Look at him! Still a man, even if only on the inside. He didn’t dare think of what the dwarrow would say about him. About his discrepancies. Would they poke and jest as his cousins had done? Oh sure, they were wonderful company, most of the time at least, but even after all these months, Bilbo didn’t feel safe. Although it was unlikely he ever would. His body brought stares and whispers everywhere he went. Even in the towns of men, granted it was frequently directed at his size rather than his sex.

But this time he was alone. There would be nowhere to run if things became too much, nowhere to hide. They were a long way away from the Shire, and even if he did try to run he’d likely die before he even stepped foot on those grass hills. So he hid. He kept his body out of sight, his washings, though infrequent as they were, were done in private. Had Bilbo been born...correctly he may have joined them. But as it was, Bilbo was condemned to a life of secrecy. At least he could hide it here. Everyone in the Shire knew what he was, though by no wrongdoings of his parents. It simply happened. Hobbits were gossip hounds, any news- no matter how small and irreverent- wormed its way through the village.

But no matter. Bilbo was content, really. It was fine, he didn’t even particularly want to bathe with the company. They were bold and boisterous in ways Bilbo thought only possible in faunts. But these silly dwarrow surprised him on the daily.

As a dip in the riverbank came into view, Bilbo tugged off the remains of his vest and threw it aside. Then stopped and picked it back up, folded it neatly, and placed it back on the ground. No use going around acting like some grump of a dwarf. He shuffled off the rest of his clothes and laid them with rest. Now barren, Bilbo finally looked towards the water. It wasn’t terribly deep near the river’s edge, but it still came up past his thighs. He could easily dr-

Deep trotting footsteps and a booming voice called out from beyond the river’s edge. “Master Baggins!”

“Gah!” Bilbo let out a scream in terror as he folded in on himself- his body now fully submerged under the water. A large hand curled around his waist and hoisted him from his watery grave.

And there before him, in all his barren glory was Thorin motherfucking Oakenshield. Oh, Bilbo was going to kill that bloody dwarf!

“What in the Valar are you doing, put me down you great fool of a twig!” Bilbo thrashed against the dwarf’s great grip- little fists pounding against the other’s own.

“Twig!?” The king sputtered. “Why you little…” Thorin did as told and dropped Bilbo onto his rump. The cold mud below dirtied and clung to his wet skin.

Bilbo wrapped his arms tightly around his exposed body. He couldn’t let Thorin see. It was not befitting of a King, despite Thorin’s rather...brutish manners.

“What in Arda do you want? I came out here to bathe in peace, Mister Dwarf.” Bilbo seethed between clenched teeth. Honestly, the nerve of this dwarf!

Whether Thorin reacted to Bilbo’s ire, he didn’t see. He was busy burying his head between his knees- protecting his chest from view.

“Do you see yourself above bathing with us? Are we too lowly of creatures to associate with?”

“What no! That’s not it at all!” Ugh, this dwarf would be the death of him. Truly, how can someone be so self-centered!?

“Really? Then why are you all the way of here, Master Baggins?” Thorin’s voice held a certain disdain to it.

“What does it matter to you? I just want to wash alone, is that a crime?”

“No, but to a dwarf, it is incredibly rude.”

“Well I’m not a dwarf now am I? You’ve made that perfectly clear.” Bilbo shot back.

“No you are not a dwarf, but you are in the company of them. Surely you do not think so lowly of us as to shun us? I ask again, are we not enough for you, Master Burglar?” Thorin leaned in close, his hot angered breathe was hot on his cold body. Bilbo didn’t like the look in the king’s eyes. It was almost...dejected.

“Do we embarrass you? Do our differing bodies hurt your little eyes?” That was definitely a sneer.

“Why you-! I have no qualms with you Oakenshield, but do not begin to comprehend the ways in which I feel!” Bilbo’s fists clenched hard enough to whiten his knuckles. He hated the way his voice cracked towards the end, but this dwarf had no right. No right to say such things, when he had been nothing but civil and kind to these people!

The dwarf gave a short pause before giving a great sigh and settling on the riverbank beside him.

“It is not us that you are embarrassed by, is it Master Baggins?”

Bilbo’s head whipped around to face the other. His mouth gaped at the man beside him. How in Arda did he come to that conclusion...not that he was mistaken.

Thorin let a huff of breath before rising to his feet. “Come, I do not wish to sit in the mud any longer.” He held out his hand, but Bilbo did not take it- nor did he look up. “Bilbo.”

At the sound of his name, one that was rarely uttered by this great clod of a dwarf, Bilbo shifted his gaze upwards. But he kept his eyes very clearly off of Thorin’s naked body.

“Fine, sit in the mud then.” Thorin waved him off and wadded into the water. He went far deeper than Bilbo could ever muster the courage for. It may have only come up to his chest on the dwarf, but it would have left but his little head if Bilbo wandered in. Hobbits were not made for water. Despite this, Bilbo felt awkward sitting alone on the bank, and Thorin was right: the mud was gross.

Carefully, Bilbo stood- his arms strategically placed to conceal his extremities. Out of the corner of his eye, he could see Thorin rolling his own.

“You needn’t cover yourself. We dwarves have no shame.”

“Clearly…” Bilbo muttered under his breath. Gradually, he made his way into the water. Shivers fell down his spine as the cold water touched his skin.

“Is it so dissimilar in the Shire? Do you not bathe with each other, or do you do as men and find offense at nakedness?”

“No...we do not bathe together. Though we’d likely all drown, hobbits aren’t made for water. Thorin do you have to be so far out? What if you fall?”

“You needn’t worry about me. I can swim just fine.” Thorin dunked his head under the water- his graying hairs splayed throughout the water. As he rose, he gestured towards the other. “Can you not?”

Bilbo shook his head, still trying to cover his body from Thorin’s gaze- not that the dwarf seemed entirely interested in his form. Which was a relief...although perhaps a bit disappointing. “No, hobbits generally just sink.”

Thorin gave a brief hum before moving closer to Bilbo. The water rolled down his smooth skin in tendrils of beads. Bilbo couldn’t help but stare.

Thorin shifted and met his eye, a lip quirked in amusement. Bilbo turned away and began to wash. He did his best to keep his body covered, Thorin may be alright with it but Bilbo was not. He was not at all prepared to show his bareness to a king. Especially not one he’d be traveling with for many months more.

Water splashed around him as Thorin wadded closer. Bilbo simply went deeper- even if the idea of water touching his neck was more frightening than the trolls and orcs they had faced.

“Mast- Bilbo quit that. I have told you twice now. I am not ashamed nor am I disgusted by whatever lays beneath your hands. You needn’t hide from me, any of us.”

“It’s...different for me.” His voice was muted against the sound of the flowing current.

“How?”

“Don’t make me say it.” Voice enough fainter now, nearly a whisper.

“Bilbo-”

“I’m not right!” Bilbo couldn’t help that short yell that escaped his tongue.

Somehow, Thorin knew exactly which buttons to press to rile the poor hobbit up. Despite this, he reared back at the sudden outburst- his brows furrowed at the phrase. Like he didn’t quite understand. Surely by now, the dwarf could tell what he hid beneath the water.

“I-” he hesitated for a moment before gesturing towards the shallow water near the bankside.

Heat flushed through his cheeks, but Bilbo waded towards the towering dwarf. Thorin flopped down into the water- barely deep enough to cover his...area- and rested against a smooth rock. He gestured openly for Bilbo to follow.

Cautiously, Bilbo kneeled down into a relatively shallow area- although it still came up to his hips when sitting.

“Bilbo, you are an idiot.”

“Excuse me?!”

“You heard me. You’re a fool. But that’s alright most of the others are as well.” He paused before continuing on. “Surely you do not truly believe you were born wrong?”

“Thorin, why wouldn’t I? You see this-” he gestured widely to his now exposed chest.

“Yes, I seem them, and? What does- oh. Oh. Bilbo, no.” Thorin moved closer towards the hobbit and placed a hand on his shoulder. “Your body is not wrong. How could you think that?” It was odd to see Thorin genuinely confused. He truly didn’t understand.

“Because-! I’m a man, and this-” He gestures towards his chest “is not...is not of a man.”

“I will never understand this Mannish thinking. They are simply body parts. Some have them some don’t, it is not wrong to have them. Nor do they define your being.”

“It’s not Mannish thinking, it just is. How can you look at these and think any different?”

Thorin huffed and leaned back against the stone behind him. He seemed unable to answer, or at least unsure of how to respond. He opened his mouth to speak multiple times but said nothing.

“See? It’s not right.”

“No- that’s not. I suppose from your perspective it may as well be. We dwarrow think differently, however. We do not have...gender in the same way you do, or man does. It is not the roles of a man or women, it is...a way of life in a way.”

Bilbo turned towards the dwarf- he was reclined against the rock, but his body was stiff and cross. He was angry...or at least uncomfortable.

“When Mahal made us, he did not intend, nor does he, to control our lives. He gives us life and then we live it. We are in control of the life we lead, and from that life, we have developed ways of expressing our gratitude- through our craft and through ourselves. How one does that is different for each dwarf. And for some their presentation is important, for others, it is simply a state of being.” Thorin worried a small pebble between his fingers as he spoke.

Bilbo heard the words, yes, but he did not understand them. He was instructed by the other hobbits that the life they were blessed with was the life they would lead. A man would be a man and a woman would be a woman. There was no...switching.

“When you think of a man, what do see?”

Bilbo stopped to think. What was a man, aside from the obvious? “They’re strong and protective. They till the fields and mill the wheat. They...well they’re just men! I don’t know.”

“Dwarrow do no see it as such, for there is no man. Man is...well it’s a mannish concept. Simply created to divide the ‘males’ and ‘females.’ Because that is what humans do, they separate and categorize. That is not to say that men and women are wrong. It is how they live and see themselves. I have no qualm with that, but to think of yourself as wrong for simply being born one way is… it’s cruel.”

“You...I don’t understand, how do you not have man and woman? What else is there?” Bilbo just couldn’t understand, sure other cultures were different. This was a fact of the world, but man and woman? That was a point of continuity. Why change it?

A small part of him went giddy with curiosity- what else was out there?

Thorin paused a moment, the stone having gone still in his hands. “It is difficult to put into words. I may speak common but Khuzdul is my tongue. I am unsure of how to explain it without the words of Mahal. But I shall try.”

“There is no man or woman because there needn’t be. Your...tools do not define your being. You do. There is no need to separate ourselves into categories because we are all different. There is no possible way to do so, and what would be the point? What meaning does a word we made up have for the...complexity that is being alive? Yes, there are, I suppose one would call them base genders if you must, but really they’re just there for our children to grow off of. We teach our children young to explore your being- who you are as a person and a creature. How do you wish to explore others? Those sorts of things I suppose. But as we grow we take that base being and turn into something bigger and better something more personal.”

“The bases just morph? What even are they?”

“I do not think they can be translated into common, but it essentially comes down to the protector, the creator, and the scholar.”

“So, your jobs are your gender? How does that work?”

Thorin laughed heartily at his answer, though Bilbo wasn’t sure was so funny- he was quite distracted by the booming sonance that left the dwarf. Thorin very rarely laughed only fond snorts when his two nephews were being particularly rowdy.

“No, no it’s not like that. I’m sorry I do not know how to explain it. The words in my tongue have meaning beyond the definitions. Let me put it this way: it’s like a stew.”

Bilbo stopped in his tracks to turn towards the dwarf. “I’m sorry?”

“Stew! It’s like a stew. Everyone has a stew of some kind, but all the ingredients are unique. One dwarf might have a hearty stew full of meat, while another might have a lighter stew with mostly vegetables- more of a soup really. But you know what I mean. We eat the stew we like the most, no one wants to eat stew they don’t like.”

“What on Earth does that have to do with gender jobs.”

“..Gender jobs..” Thorin chuckled under his breath in fondness. “The ‘gender jobs’ are the stew bases. If you don’t know how to make a stew or just want a basic stew to hold you off until dinner, then you can get a basic stew. But if you know what you want, then you can change it to your liking. So it’s like stew!”

“That...actually makes a lot of sense.”

“I knew I would get you with the food metaphors,” Thorin smirked.

Bilbo simply rolled his eyes, it was surprisingly easy to talk to the dwarf when he wasn’t being a grump of a king. Despite the pleasant air, unease still sat low in Bilbo. So what if dwarf gender was like stew, as odd as that was to say, Bilbo was not a dwarf. He was a hobbit, and in hobbit eyes he was wrong. He had a vagina and therefore should be a woman.

But he was not.

Nor was he a protector, a scholar, or a creator. He was simply a...well actually he didn’t really know. When he thought about it, the only reason he thought of himself as a man was because there was no other option. He was in no way shape or form a woman, but was he really a man? Did he really make his stew or did he merely take some leftovers and announce them his?

“So...what does this make me?”

Thorin reached out and gently cupped Bilbo’s cheek, his blue eyes piercing through his soul. Yet it was not painful but kind. “You are...whatever you want to be. If that is a man, then you are a man. If that is something else, then that is what you are. You needn’t a word for either; you can simply be. You needn’t describe yourself to others, or yourself, you can simply exist. I merely needed to explain that you could never be wrong because of the parts you were given. They may help define you, yes, but they do not make you. Only you can do that. Only you and your experience can shape your soul. That is what my Amad- my mother- told me once when I was very small. It stuck with me even after all these years.”

“It’s a good saying.”

“Indeed.”

The pair sat in comfortable silence for several minutes, simply observing the world around them. As they sat- as they existed- Bilbo began to think.

Yes, for now, he was a man, but the future was uncertain.

 

Series this work belongs to: