Actions

Work Header

A Routine Haunting

Chapter 2: Death

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

When Bilbo and Thorin entered the parlor, dripping water onto the tile and leaving wet foot and boot prints everywhere they stepped, there was already a fire crackling in the hearth. They were so desperate to dry off that they didn’t even wonder when or by whom the fire was lit—or why, considering it was summer.

“So much for luck,” Bilbo remarked with annoyance, kneeling on the edge of the carpet before the fireplace.

“At least we made it home,” Thorin responded, joining him.

They stretched their pruny fingers toward the fire, eager to warm themselves up. How they could still feel so cold was a mystery considering they had walked all the way back from the bridge in the hot sun.

Walked back from the bridge. Did they walk back from the bridge? Surely they must have, for how else would they have ended up here, in Bag End? It was several miles from the Brandywine to Hobbiton. They would have certainly dried off in the warm air before they even crossed into Westfarthing. Yet why were they still so soaking wet? And why couldn’t Thorin recall a single moment of time spent traveling between the two locations?

He was just about to mention this to Bilbo when he was interrupted by a surprised yelp. Thorin turned just in time to see the fire licking Bilbo’s fingers. The hobbit snapped his hands back and placed them in his lap, brow furrowed less in pain and more in bewilderment.

“Very strange,” he muttered.

“Bilbo…” Thorin said uneasily beside him.

“What is it?” he asked, and in response Thorin reached down, grabbed Bilbo’s hand by the wrist, and brought it up in front of his face. The index and middle finger were steadily ignited as if two invisible wicks had sprouted from them.

Bilbo gasped, eyes wide, and swiftly blew out the flames with a frantic breath. The result was very unusual. His fingertips were not charred or irritated as one would have expected. There was simply a thin trickle of smoke from the pad of each finger as the flames were extinguished, and then they quickly returned to normal. Except this clearly wasn’t normal at all. Bilbo glanced with raised eyebrows at Thorin, who returned an almost identical expression.

Slowly, Bilbo stood, rubbing his fingers against his thumb and clearing his throat. “Well,” he said, “I suppose we should have something to eat.”

Perhaps it was just hunger that had them feeling so out of sorts. As his father had taught him as a boy, food was a good enough solution to most every problem. Although he didn’t imagine Bungo Baggins had ever been in a situation quite like this.

“Just a moment, Bilbo.” As the hobbit moved into the kitchen, Thorin scrambled to follow him and took the opportunity to ask the question he had been meaning to ask a moment ago: “Do you recall how we arrived here from the river? I cannot remember any of it. Can you? Bilbo?”

Bilbo wasn’t listening to him, distracted as he suddenly was with rummaging through his pockets.

“My ring,” he muttered, and his stomach lurched with the realization. “I’ve lost it. It must have fallen out of my pocket in the river. I’m going back.”

With Thorin still on his heels, Bilbo hurried through the parlor and jerked open the front door. Then without a second thought as to the time of day or distance to the river or how he planned to search it, he darted down the front steps.

“Wait, Bilbo, I think we should...”

Thorin cut himself off for the simple fact that, as soon as Bilbo left the first step, he disappeared. Considering he had rushed out the door in the first place because his magic ring—of which Thorin was aware, although he disliked the way he often caught Bilbo looking at it—was missing, it seemed safe to say this vanishing was caused by a different kind of magic entirely.

No one understood this more than Bilbo, who found himself in a state that was nothing like what he experienced when he donned his ring. At least then there was some indication that he was in the same space as before, blurred and disorienting as it was. In contrast, now, as he assessed his new surroundings, everything was clear, and yet nothing was.

This place was unlike any he had ever visited. There were no trees or flowers, not even hills or mountains, and certainly no buildings or bridges. Although the landscape obviously stretched for miles beyond his vision, he sensed that he could search and search and never meet another living thing. All he could see wherever he turned was sand, a flat plane of yellow until it met the horizon and turned abruptly to blue. There was no sound but that of a distant ticking clock whose second hand seemed to be moving too quickly.

Immediately forgetting his desperation to find his ring in favor of a new desperation to return to Bag End, Bilbo turned around hoping to find the front steps there waiting for him. Instead there was only more sand. This time, however, the ground seemed to be swelling as if to make room for something large that was attempting to emerge. It reminded Bilbo of the way the coins in Erebor shifted as Smaug rose from his slumber. He hoped that was not what was about to greet him, although he found it difficult to imagine anything pleasant surfacing from this landscape.

Indeed, he soon glimpsed, out of the sand and far too close for comfort, the faceless head of a hideous serpentine creature whose mouth looked like a giant grasping claw. Rows and rows of jagged teeth peeked out as it coughed up sand like yellow vomit. It wasn’t Smaug, but it was just as familiar.

“Were-worms,” Bilbo whispered.

The worm made a horrible groaning sound like an enormous pig being slaughtered and menacingly wagged its head—if you could even call it that. Before Bilbo had a chance to decide what to do, he felt a tug on his collar as if someone were pulling him upwards. A second later, he found himself standing once again with Thorin in the doorway to Bag End.

“Thorin, you saved my life. I was—”

“Two hours,” Thorin interrupted, urging Bilbo into the entrance hall and shutting the door.

“Pardon?”

“Two hours. That’s how long you were gone.”

“Two hours?” Bilbo shook his head. “No, that can’t be. It was only a moment, and then you pulled me back.”

Thorin took Bilbo by the arm and guided him into the parlor. He nodded to the window. Night had fallen outside—that is, the outside that was meant to be there, not the one Bilbo had wandered into.

“Two hours,” Bilbo repeated under his breath.

“I must show you something,” Thorin told him. “Come with me.”

He led Bilbo down the hall and into the bedroom, where they stood in front of the full-length mirror that leaned against the wall beside the wardrobe. It looked as it always did, except for the slight difference that this time neither of them were reflected in it. It was as if no one was in the room.

To further prove his point, Thorin retrieved a pine cone from a basket by the fireplace and moved it horizontally from one side of the mirror to the other, bouncing it up and down like a trotting horse. In the image of the glass, it appeared to float in midair.

Bilbo, letting out a series of flustered half-sentences, peeked around to the back of the mirror, adjusted its position, and waved his hand in front of it several times, to no avail.

“And then there is this,” Thorin continued, moving to the bedside table. He picked up a brown leather-bound book with gold engraving and handed it to Bilbo.

“Instructions for the Newly Expired,” he read aloud from the cover, and looked at Thorin with a puzzled expression.

“Is this your book?” asked Thorin.

Bilbo shook his head. “I have never seen this book in my life.”

With a sigh and a hand across his face, Thorin sat on the edge of the bed. “Then it is as I feared.”

Bilbo did not understand their situation well enough yet to despair. “Where did this come from?” he wondered, holding the book up. “This must be someone’s very elaborate practical joke. Perhaps Gandalf is in the Shire and he’s trying to spook us. Yes, that must be it. Don’t you think? Thorin?”

Thorin looked at him with a sober expression. “Bilbo,” he said carefully, and then didn’t continue.

Bilbo stood staring at him expectantly. “What?”

Thorin searched for a delicate way to express what he was thinking. “I don’t think we survived the river.”

Bilbo opened his mouth as if to say something, but closed it just as quickly. He swallowed on a dry throat and moved to sit next to Thorin, still gripping the newfound book with both hands. They both stared silently ahead of them at the reflection of an empty bed and let Thorin’s conclusion wash over them.

Death.

Well, that would certainly explain a few things.


They sat up in bed all night together looking through the book, reading various passages aloud to each other and asking questions to thin air that received no answer.

“How can we be in two places at once?” Thorin wondered. “At the bottom of that river but also here, in Bag End? And why did you disappear when you stepped outside?”

“This is even more complicated than my contract for the quest,” Bilbo remarked, flipping pages in frustration. “Listen to this. A chapter titled ‘Geographical and Temporal Perimeters.’ First sentence reads, ‘Functional perimeters vary from manifestation to manifestation.’ Very helpful.”

“Have you checked for an author?” asked Thorin, tilting the book to examine the spine. “I am beginning to think this is Balin’s doing.”

They laughed softly at that, but it turned sour when they began to consider just how pleased they would be to see Balin at this moment. To see anyone, really, if at the very least their own reflections.

“If we’re dead,” Bilbo posed to break the silence, “then why are we here, in Bag End? Is this even the real Bag End? What I saw outside was not the Shire. It was about as far from it as one could get. And anyway, shouldn’t we be... somewhere else? An afterlife, I mean.”

Thorin hummed. “Dwarves believe that when we die, we go to the halls of Mahal, our Maker, and are reunited with the spirits of our lost kin. But perhaps that is not so. Where do hobbits go?”

“No one has ever been quite certain. It is believed by many that we are related to the Big Folk, and therefore we go to the same place as them, although the proudest among us object to such an idea. I’ve never considered it much, except for a brief while after my parents died.”

“So if these beliefs were true,” Thorin concluded, “if you went with Men and I with Dwarves, then we would be separated.”

Bilbo nodded. “Yes. I suppose so.”

“We should be grateful, then.” Thorin reached between them to where Bilbo’s hand rested on the blanket, and took it within his own. “That we are together, even in death.”

Bilbo smiled gently and rested his head against Thorin’s shoulder. “I just wish we knew for how long.”


Time became unpredictable. Several days could feel as long as one, and one day could feel as long as several. Seemingly overnight, the food rotted in the pantry, the flowers wilted in their vases, and dust accumulated on every surface faster than they could brush it away. They felt a permanent chill which could be cured by neither blanket nor fire nor closeness of body—or rather, of spirit.

There was also the issue of clothing. Specifically, that they were trapped in what they were wearing when they died. They would attempt a change of clothes, but as soon as they took one step away from the wardrobe, they would find themselves back in their old garments, the new ones having been mysteriously returned to their original places. This agitated Bilbo in particular, as he had hoped to spend the rest of eternity in something better than wrinkled traveling attire.

One small mercy was that the garden remained vibrant and well-kept. They couldn’t be sure whether this was because the gardener had been tending it when they weren’t paying attention, or if whoever or whatever put them in this situation simply took pity on them. Either way, it was a singular sign of life for which they were thankful, although they noted the irony that they could only enjoy it through a pane of glass.

When it came to finding an explanation for all of this, they had about as much luck as they did on that bridge. They read and reread the instructions every day, but the book seemed to always be slightly different each time they opened it, and they could usually make neither head nor tail of it in any form. Even when they could, it was never anything particularly useful.

They sat in the spare room one afternoon, Bilbo in his chair with his legs swung over the side, and Thorin hunched over his work table. Bilbo was growing increasingly restless.

“Where are all the other dead people?” he grumbled. “Why is it just the two of us?”

Thorin looked up from the candlestick he was polishing. It didn’t need to be polished, but he’d already polished every candlestick in the house two times each, and he had run out of things to do, so he was polishing it a third time.

“Perhaps this is a reward,” he suggested lovingly.

“More like a punishment,” Bilbo replied, and saved Thorin’s pride by adding, “There’s nothing to eat.”

“Are you hungry?” Thorin asked.

“No,” Bilbo admitted. “It’s terrifying. I’ve never not been hungry before.”

As Thorin was chuckling over that, his attention was drawn to the small semi-circular window, through which he could see something moving on the road outside. He stood and hurried over.

“It’s Bofur,” he said.

“Bofur? Is it really?” Bilbo moved to join him. They could see Bofur standing just beyond the fence. “He must have seen our note.”

Without thinking, Thorin opened the window and leaned out. “Bofur!” he shouted, waving a hand. “Over here! Bofur!”

Bofur ignored him, only stood staring up at the front door. He removed his hat, pressed it against his chest, and bowed his head in respect. He appeared to wipe away a tear.

“He can’t see us,” Bilbo sighed, returning to his chair.

“No,” Thorin confirmed. He watched Bofur replace his hat, nod to himself with a twitch of his mustache, and begin the slow walk back down the road.

“No more use for that ring of mine anyway, it would seem,” Bilbo muttered as he thumbed through the book in his lap to find the appropriate page. “Ah, here.” He read a passage aloud: “‘The living believe they will never die, so they refuse to see the dead.’”

“Believe they will never die,” repeated Thorin, wryly. “That certainly sounds like Bofur.”

His cutting tone disguised the pang of regret he felt in his chest when he saw his fellow dwarf disappear completely beyond the edge of the hill. He had never properly thanked him, and now he would never get another chance.

“If Bofur is outside,” Bilbo posited, “then that must mean this really is Bag End, wouldn’t you say? Unless he’s an illusion too. To be honest, I’m still not convinced this isn’t just one long terrible dream from which we are slow to wake.”

“If it is real, then I suppose Bofur shall inform Erebor of our passing,” Thorin suggested, returning to the table. Then, having paused his polishing for a thoughtful moment, he wondered, “Do you think we had a funeral?”

“We didn’t,” Bilbo clarified. “‘Funerals are for the living,’ after all, as the book tells us.” He scoffed. “I’m beginning to think the entire point of this is to tell us, in the most verbose manner possible, that we have absolutely no control over anything anymore.”

“Well then,” Thorin said, setting down his polishing cloth and moving to continue his work on the map frame, “I suppose there’s no use in worrying, is there?”

If only that were true.

Notes:

Thanks for reading! As always, I'd love to know what you think.