Chapter Text
Frodo stood petrified outside the spare room as an eerie fog crept through the space beneath the door. He had heard some very unusual sounds on the other side, as if part of the hill itself were splitting away.
Once he got his wits about him, he fled, leaving the key behind on the floor. He may have possessed the jaded demeanor of one much older than his years, not to mention an unnatural interest in all things morbid, but at the end of the day he still was only a tween, and just barely that. Believing in ghosts was one thing; actually witnessing them was another.
Without thinking, he headed for the closest thing to a parent that he possessed at the moment, although it wasn’t the ideal choice. Otho was in the study, having been asked by Lobelia to round up the books for auction. He was pacing from shelf to shelf assessing what tomes were there and looking very glum about parting with them.
“I saw something,” Frodo said when he entered the room, out of breath.
“Frodo,” Otho said disapprovingly as he shut one book and opened another, “you should be helping with the auction. Your mother would be very upset to find you idling in the house when there’s work to be done.”
“She’s not my mother,” Frodo pointed out instinctively. “But you don’t understand. There are ghosts in this house. I saw them.”
“Oh, none of that silliness now,” Otho tsked, having listened to Frodo’s macabre musings before. “There’s no time to be telling spooky stories. Out you go, then. Back to work.”
With that, he ushered Frodo out of the room and closed the door.
Frodo sighed and considered his options. Either he could allow the Sackville-Bagginses to discover the ghosts’ existence on their own, in which case it may be too late for them—and very likely for him as well, by association. Or he could confront the ghosts himself and perhaps earn their trust before they did anything too ghoulish. Enough trust to get the answers out of them that he had been so desperate for since his parents’ death.
He decided the second option was best, even though it practically made his teeth chatter. He took a deep breath and started back across the house to the spare room. It was there he discovered Lotho bending over with great effort to pick up the key that had fallen out of the lock.
“Stop,” Frodo ordered, hurrying toward the older hobbit as he straightened up, key in hand. “Give me that.”
“Why should I?” Lotho taunted, holding it out of reach.
“Because you don’t want to go in there.”
“And why not? What are you hiding in there?” Lotho narrowed his eyes. “Oh, I know what it is. It’s bigger in there, isn’t it? Bigger than my room. You’re trying to get away with having the bigger one to yourself. Well, I’m not falling for it.”
He moved to unlock the door, but Frodo was faster than him. He slipped his ring onto his finger and grabbed the key from Lotho’s hand before he knew what hit him.
“Hey!” Lotho cried as Frodo shoved him aside.
He stuck the key in the lock himself and slipped quickly into the room, shutting the door and locking it behind him.
Lotho pounded on it. “I don’t know what evil magic you’re doing, but Mother won’t stand for it!”
Frodo heard Lotho move away, calling for Lobelia all the while. He slipped both his ring and the key into his pocket and turned to look around the room.
Well, this place certainly didn’t look haunted. It was nothing like Frodo imagined a ghostly space would be—certainly not what the books he read described, or what his Brandybuck cousins teased him with. Whatever sinister fog he had glimpsed earlier had dissipated, leaving in its wake what looked to be simply a room like any other.
Of course, the detail which most obviously made this room so decidedly unghostly was the total absence of the ghosts themselves. Perhaps they had no malicious intentions after all. Or perhaps they were just lying in wait until the right moment.
Frodo walked the length of the table at the room’s center, glancing at the various tools strewn across it, until he reached a map mounted in a hand-carved wooden frame. His ran his fingers across the shapes—acorns and oak leaves, it looked like. The map itself was an interesting sight, with the image of a bright red dragon peeking out from beneath smudges of dirt.
Bilbo’s quest to slay the dragon had been the talk of the Shire upon his return. According to gossip, he had presented a contract which detailed all sorts of peril, including the distinct possibility of being burnt to a crisp by a scaly fire-breather. Most brushed it off as the ravings of “Mad Baggins,” as they took to calling him. Frodo had often wished for the opportunity to talk to Bilbo about his adventures and learn the truth. Perhaps he might still get it.
On the far wall Frodo spotted what looked to be a chalk outline of some sort, although he couldn’t imagine what it was for. Nearby, a cozy-looking armchair was host to a book lying open and pages-down on its seat. Frodo picked it up and examined the title.
Instructions for the Newly Expired.
He guessed that didn’t refer to expired vegetables.
There was another knock on the door then, this time by Lobelia. “Frodo? Are you in there? You had better get out here this instant.”
Frodo held his breath and dared not move.
“He’s in there, Mother,” he heard Lotho say. “He took the key and he disappeared, just like last time.”
“Oh, not that again,” said Lobelia. “My darling, you shouldn’t believe those ridiculous things that boy tells you. It’s making you see things that aren’t there.”
“But I did see it, Mother. He has magic.”
“Come along and let’s get you an early luncheon, shall we?”
“But Mother—”
Their quarrelsome voices became smaller and smaller. When he felt confident they were gone, Frodo collapsed into the chair with the book in his lap and began to read.
Bilbo and Thorin had made it past the fog and were currently standing in a place both magnificent and intimidating.
It was a vast hall, its marble floor as smooth and opalescent as a calm sea, with columns the size of ancient tree trunks that seemed to stretch as far as the clouds above. They walked uncertainly forward, their footsteps making no sound on the floor.
Pools of light, as if from the sun but softer, lit the space. Within one of them stood a cluster of figures. Bilbo and Thorin approached them, and as they grew nearer, they noted that they were of all different heights, a mixture of Elves, Men, Dwarves and Hobbits, at least a dozen in total. As they grew closer still, a new realization dawned—that these people were very much dead.
They could deduce this not simply because they could imagine no such eerily peaceful place being inhabitable by the living, but because they wore the proof of their demise as if it were part of their wardrobes.
There was a golden-haired elf with no fewer than three arrows lodged in his chest. A dwarf appeared to have been strangled by his own lengthy, braided beard, which had been tied like a noose around his neck. A woman bore a dark hoof print on the side of her face. Then there was the hobbit, a grey-haired fellow who was red and swollen nearly beyond the scope of his clothes with bee stings.
“Togo Toadfoot,” Bilbo said, half in surprise and half in greeting.
The hobbit did not acknowledge him. None of the dead did. They merely stood there in silent patience.
“He cannot hear you,” came a brusque voice from nearby.
They turned to see a podium which appeared to rise like a lustrous crystal from the floor. There stood an elf dark of hair and stern of face. Open in front of him was an enormous tome with gilded edges, and behind him were several gaping archways adorned with diaphanous curtains which blew outwards as if from a gentle and constant wind beyond.
“Are these the halls of waiting?” asked Thorin.
“No. This is where the spirits wait before passing into the halls of waiting,” the elf said, as if it should be obvious.
The halls of waiting for the halls of waiting. And life may as well be referred to as the halls of waiting for the halls of waiting for the halls of waiting. Which period of waiting Thorin and Bilbo were currently in they could not say.
“Will they always be like this?” asked Bilbo, gesturing to the gruesome figures surrounding them.
“No,” said the elf. “Their spirits will cast off the garb of death when they move on, each through a different passage, one for each of their kind.”
“So it is true,” Thorin marveled.
“Now that so many of your questions have been answered,” the elf said, “you must answer one of mine. Who are you, and why are you here?”
“I think the better question is, why aren’t we here? Or at least, why haven’t we been?” Bilbo wondered, and when, in response, the elf merely stared at him without amusement, he cleared his throat and got on with the introductions: “I am Bilbo Baggins of the Shire. This is Thorin, Son of Thráin, of the Line of Durin.”
“Ah, yes,” the elf said, with a measure of recognition. He turned to a page in his book and dragged a slender finger down its length until he reached what he was looking for. “He has been expecting you.”
“Who has?” asked Thorin.
“Mandos, of course.” The elf took several stately strides across the floor and held aside the curtain of the center archway. “You may step this way.”
Thorin and Bilbo moved hesitantly toward him and slipped through the open space.
Bilbo turned before he continued and addressed the elf one last time: “May I ask your name?”
“Fëanor,” said the elf, and closed the curtain.
Bilbo stood gobsmacked, the pages of his mother’s Elven history texts flashing through his mind.
“Bilbo,” Thorin said behind him. “Shall we move on?”
“Hm?” Bilbo shook himself from his trance and turned around. “Oh, yes, of course.”
They began the walk down a long, dimly lit corridor whose walls were lined with richly woven tapestries. They depicted scenes of various subject matter, featuring Elves, Dwarves and Men, hunting and mining and fishing, in battle against dragons and ruling over kingdoms. No two were the same, and they were so large they looked as if they would have taken a loom the size of a mountain to create, if not hours and hours of handiwork.
At the end of the corridor was a figure seated on a throne. Even from such a distance, he appeared enormous, and he only grew more imposing as Bilbo and Thorin drew closer. He did not speak until they were near enough to see his onyx hair and severe brow. When they heard him, they had to take several steps backward, for his voice was ground-shaking, and it echoed in every corner of the space.
“I have been expecting you,” he boomed.
Once he had recovered from the force of the sound, it was Bilbo who replied first, nervously. “Yes, so we were told. It is an honor to meet you… sir.”
Mandos glared at him, not speaking.
“Er, we were wondering…”
“I know,” Mandos interrupted. “I know all.”
“Right. Well, then…”
Mandos was silent again.
“Can you help us?” Thorin questioned impatiently.
Mandos tapped two of his fingers—which happened to be the same in length as Thorin and Bilbo were in height—on the arm of his throne. “Where shall I begin?”
Thorin and Bilbo glanced at each other.
“At the beginning?” Bilbo offered. “That is, the beginning of this. This being our deaths, of course.”
Mandos sighed, and they felt it against their faces.
“You drowned. That much you already know. I know you know. What you do not know is that you were to be summoned to my halls, as was always intended. But the process was interrupted, and the plans changed. I received knowledge that Aulë and Yavanna desired that you not be separated. Aulë being, of course, your creator”—he nodded to Thorin—“and Yavanna, his wife, being fiercely protective of your kind.” Here he nodded to Bilbo. “They admired your devotion to one another, and took pity on you. It was cruel, they claimed, to keep you together through the hardships of war, only to separate you over such a frivolous twist of fate. So the judgment was made to stay your entry to my halls and allow you to remain together in Arda.”
“Like Beren and Lúthien,” Bilbo said in hushed wonder. “Thorin, we’re like Beren and Lúthien.”
Thorin looked at him blankly, clearly not understanding who those people were. Bilbo would have to explain later.
“That is a rather bold comparison,” Mandos pronounced with a curl of his lip. “You are still dead, after all.”
“Are you saying this is a reward?” asked Thorin.
“If you prefer to think of it as such,” Mandos permitted. “Strictly speaking, in most cases it would be referred to as a curse. But a curse endured in the company of one you love may be considered a reward, if the alternative is undesirable.”
“Will this be forever?” asked Bilbo.
“My judgment is one hundred and twenty-five years.”
Bilbo and Thorin frowned at that, understanding that at the end of that time, they would have to be separated. On the other hand, they felt rather sick to their stomachs—or would have, if it were possible—over the prospect of spending that time in the presence of the Sackville-Bagginses and their descendants.
“I see your minds,” Mandos declared before they could say anything, “and I am approaching the subject. You have been attempting to expel the living inhabitants of your home. This was to be expected. You were unrelenting in life, and so you are in death. Especially you, Thorin, son of Thráin.”
His tone had enough derision in it that Bilbo had to restrain Thorin from charging forward and... Well, exactly what he planned to do wasn’t especially clear to either of them. Spit on the Vala’s boulder-sized foot, perhaps.
Mandos ignored it. “If you must take action against them, I suggest you alter your methods. Consult your instructions.”
“We’ve had a bit of trouble there, actually,” Bilbo said. “Rather inconsistent, that book.”
Mandos placed his hand to his temple in frustration. “It is not my finest work, to be sure. And yet, your circumstance is not one to be granted often, and I must say you have been very unappreciative,” he added irritably. “But if you truly cannot bear it, all I can tell you in counsel is to begin simply. It is no use to maim yourselves and each other if the living cannot witness it.”
Bilbo considered this. “What about this person in the advertisement we found? Pryf—”
“Silence!” Mandos bellowed, almost knocking them off their feet. “You must never utter his name. He is not to be trusted.”
“Who is he?” Bilbo attempted carefully.
“He is a spirit outside of my judgment. I have no place for him in my halls, and so he wanders homeless about Arda. As of now, he has taken up residence in your map.”
“In the map?” Thorin repeated, incredulous.
“Yes. And if you possess wisdom, there he shall remain, until he tires of you and moves on. He can only affect the living if he is summoned thrice by his name. I advise you strongly not to do so.” Mandos straightened up. “Now, if I have answered all of your questions, I must command you to depart my halls.”
“I wonder,” Bilbo rushed to mention, “if it was Yavanna who kept our garden so lovely? I would very much like to thank her for it.”
“Have you so little faith in your own gardener?” Mandos wondered. “Not every mercy is a gift from the Valar.”
With that he waved his hand, and in an instant they found themselves in a new place entirely.
This was nothing like the halls they had just visited. It was claustrophobic and gaudily decorated and blindingly colorful. Every surface, from the walls to the floors to the furniture, was covered in the image of flowers.
“Where are we?” Thorin sneered.
“I don’t know, but it’s dreadful,” replied Bilbo as he took it all in. Then, after a moment: “Wait... Oh, no. No, no, no, no.”
“What is it?”
“This is… Oh no, it can’t be.”
“What?” Thorin asked more urgently.
“This is Bag End,” Bilbo informed him.
Indeed, it was. They were currently standing in what appeared to be the parlor, based on the view out the window. And yet that was just about the only obvious sign that this was even the same place. Gone were the warm tones and comfortable textiles of the Bag End they once knew. Instead, it felt as if they were standing inside one of Lobelia’s ridiculous hats.
“How long were we gone?” asked Thorin in amazement.
“Long enough for all of this to happen,” Bilbo estimated. “Ugh, there are flowers everywhere.”
“You like flowers,” Thorin attempted, knowing full well there was no defending this monstrosity.
“I like them when they’re growing in the garden, or sitting in a vase on the windowsill, or embroidered on a pillow or two here and there, not plastered over every surface of my home.”
He collapsed onto the sofa and was nearly swallowed whole by stiff ruffles. Thorin sat down beside him. They were silent for a moment, taking in the horror that surrounded them.
Finally, Bilbo spoke: “This won’t do. This won’t do at all.”
He stood up and walked into the hall, which was bedecked with portraits of Lotho that were far too flattering to his complexion.
“Where are you going?” asked Thorin, moving to follow him.
“To find some sheets,” Bilbo said over his shoulder.
