Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

By Fireflies' Glow

Summary:

Bilbo ponders whether he's meant to be on this quest. He accidentally finds Thorin whilst trying to not bother (avoid) the others in Rivendell's garden. The two figure out they may not be as different as they thought.

Or: A fic based off that scene Richard Armitage talks about where Thorin talks to Bilbo about his upbringing amongst the fireflies in Rivendell. It was sadly never released, even in the extended edition, so I made it myself. And now it's gay.

Notes:

This concept is from a scene that was never released theatrically or in the extended edition where Thorin confides in Bilbo about how he was raised. The scene starts just before the extended edition's scene where Bilbo (and later Thorin) overhears Gandalf and Elrond debating whether Thorin can be trusted not to fall to goldsickness.

Richard Armitage talks about what could have been had it been added into the final versions in this interview:
https://www.theonering.net/torwp/2013/11/25/83283-shakespeare-performance-capture-and-getting-back-on-stage-richard-armitage-talks-to-theonering-net/

Work Text:

Rivendell’s magnificence only extended into the evening, after the last light of day passed over the mountains surrounding it. Streaming waterfalls cascaded over the cliffs below, leading into rivers and streams down past the elven borders. Dusk crept up on Eastern skies in parallel to the setting sun until the moon above followed its path, high into the sky. Where there was sunlight cast into the water, silver moonlight now shone upon its surface. Bilbo had never seen an evening so beautiful in all his years. 

The beauty of Rivendell had so captured him that the hobbit had spent nearly all his time wandering about the kingdom. While his dwarrow companions dined together, Bilbo explored the main halls of Rivendell. The hobbit was quick to continue his self-guided tour just after Thror’s map had been translated. There was no doubt that Bilbo had fallen in love with the Valley of Imladris. He had to see as much as he could before their journey picked up once more.

At least, that was his excuse to distract from the real reason he had put distance between himself and the others. In truth, he did not feel welcome at their table. Bilbo was acutely aware of his outsider status to the dwarves; he may have been a contracted burglar of this company, but the hobbit knew he was still viewed as little more than a burdensome stranger without any experience of the larger world. The worst part was that he couldn’t blame them.

It was no secret he was inexperienced. What he had in his skills of gardening and baking (the best cakes from scratch in the Shire, you see), he lacked in the practical adventuring repertoire of sword fighting and travelling across Middle Earth. He was a Baggins of Bag-End, after all. Such respectable hobbits didn’t just up and leave on journeys with strange dwarves who ate his pantry stock.

But then, Bilbo supposed he wasn’t a respectable hobbit anymore. He had left that title behind as soon as he grabbed his signed contract and rushed out of his rounded door all that time ago. He was now a member of a perilous quest to slay a dragon and reclaim a dwarven kingdom. However, the title of “adventurer” didn’t seem to belong to him either. 

Another rounded corner of the path led Bilbo back where his exploration had started in the gardens. He hadn’t meant to come this way again, but it seemed his feet had started wandering on their own when the hobbit became lost in doubt. Bilbo didn’t mind. 

The gardens of the elves were some of the most enchanting in all of Middle Earth. Hedges encircled the area, trees sprung up their lanky limbs that seemed to welcome all who ventured there. It was well-kept, organized, and filled with flowers of colors he’d only ever seen in books. The reflections seemed to glow by moonlight as well, transforming into translucent blues, purples, and greens. Bilbo used to daydream about places like these from reading his books, wondering what it would be like to live in a place where such beautiful things could grow. Lord Elrond’s offer of staying in Rivendell, permanently, returned to his mind.

“Master Baggins,” came the rough voice of Thorin Oakenshield somewhere off to the side. It pulled the hobbit from his thoughts in surprise. Bilbo’s head turned to see that the gardens had already been occupied by said dwarven king, who sat upon the backless, stone-carved bench alone. He held an expression that Bilbo could not place. At least it was not a glare or look of disdain toward him like usual. “I was beginning to think you’d run off. You made quick leave after reading the map. You weren’t at dinner, either.”

“You’re right. I was...” The hobbit shifted to his other leg. The words didn’t find him. He certainly didn't want to explain that he didn’t think himself welcome in their company, and exploring didn’t seem much like a Baggins pastime either, so Bilbo’s sentence hung unfinished. “I didn’t realize someone else was here. I expect you wish to be left alone, I’ll take my leave-”

“The others are resting,” Thorin said before Bilbo could take a step back. His gaze turned away from the hobbit and back to the open trees. “I couldn’t find sleep.”

“So you came here?” 

Thorin bowed his chin in a nod. The halfling recalled many sleepless nights of his own being comforted by the fresh air found in his garden back home. He allowed himself to wonder if this was something he and the dwarf had in common.

“I never took you for a lover of nature," Bilbo said.

Perhaps on better terms, Thorin might have seemed amused. “I assure you I am not. The gardens just happened to be far enough away from the sounds of Bombur’s snores.”

“I see. It is rather peaceful. In the gardens, I mean.”

“Indeed.”

Moments of silence stretched between the unlikely pair while the two admired their surroundings, even if Thorin wouldn’t admit to elvish work capturing his attention. Bilbo remained awkwardly at the steps of the garden where he was first stopped. He didn’t mind standing since Hobbits had more resilience in being on their feet for long amounts of time, but to Bilbo’s surprise, Thorin made room on the bench beside him. 

The halfling’s lips twitched in figuring what to say, if he should he say anything at all. Finally, he decided that he ought to try and test the waters. If Thorin was offering him a place to sit, he would take the opportunity and see where it took him. The Tookish part inside told him that this could be his chance to reconcile their strained first impressions. Bilbo walked over and took his place at the far end of the bench.

“I have my own garden, back in Bag-End,” he started. The silence became too heavy to hold any longer. “You might have seen it when you arrived that first night. It’s certainly not as impressive as this, but then I’m just one hobbit compared to many elves. Besides, it has all the flowers I really need, all of my favorites. The Shire has perfect weather for my hydrangeas best of all.”

The dwarf didn’t speak as he watched him ramble. Bilbo didn’t think Thorin much the type for listening about gardening techniques, and therefore spared the details, but a quick glance over to the dwarf proved that he was, indeed, listening. Still silent as ever, but this was a bit different. The exiled king seemed at peace for once. Like he was grateful to hear of a hobbit’s silly affinity for plants instead of a dragon to slaughter and a mountain kingdom to reclaim.

It was a sight Bilbo found himself having trouble looking away from. He willed himself to focus on the fireflies gathering around the bushes instead. 

“Gardens were not to be found in the mountain.” Thorin’s voice softened at the mention of his old home. He always regarded the Lonely Mountain with careful, almost protective thought. Bilbo’s eyes settled back on the dwarf and clung to every word. “Nothing grows underground. No grass or soil to grow it, and there was no sunlight. The light from the great forges were all we needed.”

“No sunlight at all? Did you never go outside?” Bilbo asked. He had known dwarves were the type to mostly stay underground, but such a concept still seemed so foreign to him. Hobbits were known to spend practically all of their time outdoors, and there was light everywhere he could remember. Thorin shook his head.

“Dwarves in that time were born into the darkness of caves. We were used to seeing rock instead of sky, and I was no different. From the moment I could walk, my time was devoted to training, watching my grandfather as he ruled so I could one day take his place. Learning of the kingdom and its people. How to protect and serve them. Everything a young prince must know.” Thorin's eyes cast toward the ground as he hunched over, deep in thought. It seemed a painful memory sprung from his words without his meaning to. “There was no time for anything but such duties.” 

Regret held in his eyes. The hobbit knew its familiar, ice-cold grip.

“There was little I knew of the world outside of Erebor’s halls, and that’s how it would have stayed were it not for the snake residing there now,” the dwarf finished with bitten words. Bilbo shifted uncomfortably.

“I’m sorry to hear it.” 

“I have no need of your pity.” Thorin’s words were without malice, and filled with shame. Like he believed he did not deserve sympathy. Like this horror was his fault, somehow. He shook his head, adjusting his seated position. “Especially from someone who knows a very different life.”

“Actually, it doesn’t sound completely different.” 

The dwarf’s taken aback look was all Bilbo needed to continue.

“I mean, I certainly wasn’t an heir to a kingdom, but in the Shire you didn’t go much of anywhere else. Sometimes to Bree if you were the type, but that would get you odd looks from the rest of Hobbiton, and by no means were you considered the respectable sort. In fact, I’m sure by now I’ve probably been declared mad beyond all reason by going off on adventures with strange dwarves and a wizard.”

The light brown curls framing Bilbo’s face bounced when he chuckled. Thorin found himself wondering why he noticed this. 

“Hobbits simply don’t care much for learning what lies outside the Shire's border. We don’t get visitors, and we don’t do any visiting of our own. So...I suppose in that regard, I understand not knowing much else but what expectations you’ve been born to.” Bilbo smiled hesitantly. It was a smile simply meant for Thorin in that moment, reserved for his eyes and his eyes alone. The dwarf, startled by its intimacy, looked away.

“I see both our clans have deemed us mad, then,” Thorin said, clearing his throat to hide the sudden topic shift.

“How do you mean?”

A glare tugged at Thorin's lips. “The other dwarrow leaders called our quest a fool’s death sentence. I made mention of it at your table, but in truth they did not use as- encouraging - words as I led the others to believe.” The words of mockery bounced back bitterly to the forefront of his mind. His eyes narrowed at the hobbit. “They believe we won’t make it alive to even reach the mountain. It is why we take on this task alone.”

Bilbo’s mouth twitched in thought again. “Well,” he began, “Perhaps they’re right.”

Thorin’s shock bubbled up instantly, paired with a list of insults in Khuzdul that he had half a mind to repeat from the aforementioned dwarrow council. The hobbit knew that look and raised his arms in defense.

“What I mean to say is, yes, perhaps you won’t reach the mountain, perhaps that’s how we’re fated to finish,” Bilbo took a breath, calmed his nerves despite the death-glare at the other side of this bench, “But it is still a noble cause to see through the end. And I know each of those who’ve followed you this far would agree. Anyone who doubts you hasn’t got the courage to see it as such.”

Thorin’s eyes softened. He looked down at the smaller creature, such a curious thing by anyone’s standards. A hobbit of the Shire, fond of books, green gardens, and the comforts of home, and yet it is he who has remedied Thorin's doubts of his birthright. 

“...Thank you.”

Bilbo simply nodded. Even if he himself wasn’t fit for this journey, he truly did hope these dwarves would succeed. They’d all lost so much when their home was taken from them. Especially Thorin. Thorin Oakenshield, who’d braved unfathomable death and destruction and still stood up against an almost impossible task. And here he was, thanking a small hobbit for mere words. 

Their lives could not be more different. Still, they were familiar. 

A soft, shining glow from the middle of the garden grove brought their attention away from one another. Dozens and dozens of fireflies had snuck their way closer and completely surrounded the pair on the bench. Their patterns blinked and glimmered for all to see, with shimmering water nearby to exemplify the view. Thorin, surprisingly, was the one captivated most. His cobalt blue eyes shimmered from their reflection as they trained on the light.

“Perhaps you were right about us being raised too differently,” the hobbit mused. A smile tugged at his lips as he watched the king become a prince again. “I don’t remember being so enthralled by the nightly fireflies.”

Thorin chuckled. A small, but genuine, bout of humor. Honestly, it almost shocked Bilbo into the next age.

“Forgive me. I suppose I just never stopped to notice them before. Not in all my journeys across Middle Earth.” His smile lingered. Bilbo’s brightened. 

They held such a gaze for some time in comfortable silence. At first meeting, Thorin had sized up the simple hobbit for a commoner, unfit for the wilds of the journey the company had planned to cross. And perhaps that was still the case. Only time would tell if Bilbo was truly a loyal member of this quest, but for now, they had this moment to share.

That is, until Gandalf’s voice was heard passing along the bridge mentioning the dwarven king by name.