Actions

Work Header

Each Comfortable Day

Chapter Text

The bed in Bilbo’s best guest room was as high of a standard as his own, bearing a soft mattress that Thorin sank right into at night, and could barely bring himself to wrench away from in the morning. The only thing that could drag him up and out of bed was the inviting breeze spilling in from the slightly open circular window that brought in the fresh, floral scent from the garden outside. Today, it was accompanied by the snipping of shears. Thorin forced himself up, stretched, and sidled over to the window. He pushed it open and leaned out into the morning sun.


Bilbo was prodding at a rose bush with a pair of pruners and cursing under his breath at the spotted yellowing leaves and wilting flower heads. Hobbits might have a love for all things that grow, but those things did not share an equal love for Bilbo. Thorin had come to learn that Bilbo was not a great gardener and that this was another popular talking point for the residents of Hobbiton. Down at the market, he had often heard scathing remarks regarding the state of Bilbo’s flowers, all spoken with an air of smugness that their wealthiest neighbour was falling short in the botanical department.


At the squeak of the window’s hinges, Bilbo turned and greeted Thorin with a good-morning. They bickered lightly over whether Thorin was up late or Bilbo was up unreasonably early. Bilbo won, of course. After all, it was already ten. Thorin blamed it on the excessive comfort of the bed, which Bilbo met with a satisfied grin and then went back to gardening. Bilbo took great pride in being a good host and Thorin took every opportunity to let him know he was an excellent one.


Thorin watched him lazily, propped up by his elbows as he tried to rid himself of the sleepy cloud still heavy on his brain. His mind drifted back to the night before, sitting on the floor and listening to Bilbo’s story. With that thought, the faint silhouette of last night’s dream returned to him. Though he was unable to pinpoint any specifics of the dream, he vaguely recalled a hooded figure, hauntingly white, and an uncomfortable feeling of guilt.


“Isn’t it a bit early for deep musings?” said Bilbo, catching sight of what must’ve been a somewhat tense expression on Thorin’s face.
“Sorry. Would you prefer I fill the silence with inane chitchat?”
“I wouldn’t mind that, actually. It’s too quiet. I’m used to Frodo’s babbling while I do this. The Gamgees took him into school today - nice of them.”


At the mention of Frodo, another part of the dream rushed back to him. Frodo had been standing right before the figure as it glided closer to him. Thorin had tried to call out but he couldn’t make a sound. The figure had eventually swallowed Frodo up in blinding white light, and Thorin could do nothing to stop it.


Upon this new recollection, he felt a little foolish for letting Bilbo’s story - a story he told to his young nephew - impact him like this. On the other hand, Thorin couldn’t shake off his apprehensions, especially with mid-years day just around the corner.


“The creatures cloaked in white,” Thorin started, hoping he sounded conversational.


“What about them?”


“Do you think they’re… uh… that they could be a threat?”


Bilbo put down the shears and looked up in surprise. “Er… I’m not sure. I certainly felt that way at the time but I was very young, remember.”


“But are the Shirelings safe now? You said that each year you see at least one scared out of their wits.”


“I…yes, but… I haven’t heard about anyone actually going missing. At least not in my lifetime.”


When Thorin’s look of concern did not leave his face, Bilbo continued. “I’ve told that story to half the children in Hobbiton, and they were all terrified. If it’s spread, then I’ll have put off a whole generation from ever wanting to go near those things. Hobbits don’t tend to seek out danger. There’s the odd few, of course, myself included. And my mother, and a few other Tooks. Suppose that sort of thing runs in the family.”


Thorin forced himself not to dwell on it and mentally shook off his unease. A cabbage white butterfly landed on a pink peony underneath the window ledge. It peacefully flexed its wings for a while, until a red admiral chased it away into the still blue sky.


“Are you going to stand there watching butterflies all day or come and help me,” said Bilbo, exasperated, snapping Thorin back down to earth. He might’ve sounded irritable but the way he beckoned made it more of an invitation than a command. Thorin sighed in mock resignation and left the window to make his way outside, hearing Bilbo shout “Grab some breakfast on your way out,” as he went.

Their morning floated calmly by, like the white clouds above them. Thorin joined Bilbo in his attempts to save the plants that had just “decided to die” on him. Some time passed in comfortable silence, some Bilbo filled with gossip about a neighbour who was allegedly selling baked goods using a recipe stolen from a family in Frogmorton. Bilbo had a knack for getting you hooked on any story, no matter how dull it was, and Thorin was fully invested. Hobbit drama was always hilariously pointless, and it was a nice change from being bombarded with things that actually mattered, such as the likes of finances and laws.


Midday came surprisingly fast. They stopped to take a break, and Bilbo went inside to squeeze some oranges and put together some sandwiches. Thorin sat down on the newly cut lawn, running his hand back through his hair in an attempt to air out his scalp, made far too hot from the sun. When Bilbo returned, he was carrying a dozen sandwiches on a tray, a jug of orange juice, two glasses, and a wide-brimmed straw hat. He set everything down on the grass apart from the hat, which he dropped onto Thorin’s head. “Should help with the sun. I can imagine it’s quite a pain with that thick dark hair of yours.” Bilbo adjusted the hat until he gave a satisfied hum, then sat down too. Apart from stopping the sun from heating Thorin’s hair up, it also kept the bright rays out of his eyes.


Thorin either hadn’t realised how hungry he was, or the sandwiches were especially delicious because when he bit into one, he was overcome with the urge to demolish all six at once. He resisted, however, and forced himself to take his time and appreciate the sweet cranberry sauce and creamy brie. Once he had washed them down with a glass of orange juice, Thorin lay back on the grass with his hands behind his head, pulling his hat over his face to block out the sun. He lay there peacefully for about twenty minutes, listening to the birds twittering and savouring the mild breeze until Bilbo prodded him. “You’d better get going.”


Thorin pushed his hat off his face and squinted at Bilbo. “What do you mean?”
“Frodo. He finishes early on Fridays, remember?”


“Oh right, yes.” Remorsefully, Thorin forced himself off the grass and headed out of the garden gate.


However, he didn’t have to go all the way to the school, as he spotted Frodo in a huddle with three other boys at the lake’s shore. As Thorin approached, he saw that Frodo was with Sam and two other boys that he didn’t recognise, and all four of them were whispering excitedly. Frodo noticed Thorin and broke away from them.
“Hi,” said Frodo, “you were late so I walked with Sam and my cousins. That’s Merry,” he pointed at the boy with overgrown sandy hair next to Sam, “and that’s Pippin.” He pointed at the redhead, who was a little shorter than the rest of them. They both grinned and waved.


“What was all the whispering about?” Thorin asked as they walked back the rest of the way.


Frodo’s eyes were gleaming with an innocent mischievousness that reminded him of Kili when he was little.


“Can you keep a secret?” said Frodo. Thorin nodded. “You can’t tell Bilbo.”


“I won’t,” he said, thinking that Frodo’s secret would be some sort of surprise or harmless prank he had planned for his uncle.


Frodo lowered his voice despite no one being near enough to overhear and said, “Me, Sam, and my cousins are going to go looking for a mid-year’s monster.”


Thorin stared at him. Hadn’t Bilbo said that his story had terrified all the children of the Shire? But then again, this was his nephew. “Why would you want to do that?”


“Merry said he saw one last year but was too scared to go near it alone, so we’re all going together.”


“But... it could be dangerous.”


“Bilbo’s done loads of dangerous things.”


“I wouldn’t look to him as a role model.”


“You won’t tell him, will you? I don’t want him to try and stop us.”


Thorin’s brows furrowed. If anything bad happened to Frodo, it was on him. But at the same time, he didn’t want to spoil Frodo’s fun. If Bilbo was right about the creatures, the worst that would happen is that they’d all get a nasty fright and never want to go looking for it again.


“No,” he said, making up his mind, “I won’t tell him.”


Frodo beamed. “Thanks, Thorin!”


He exhaled defeatedly. A responsible adult he was, indeed.


*


The next day, Thorin went for a walk through the forest, hoping to stumble across any sort of clue that might allude to the monsters already being there, or maybe something that showed the way to their lair if they had one. Unfortunately, there wasn’t anything of the sort. The forest was dappled with golden afternoon sunlight, and the blue sky above was visible in large patches amongst the rustling treetops. It was hard to believe that it might be hiding something frightening. He picked his way through the overgrown edges of the forest until he was out of it. The trees had been sheltering him from the mild wind that blew today, which was very welcome after yesterday’s heat.


A shock of gold among the long grass outside the forest caught Thorin’s eye. Looking closely, he saw that it was the back of a little girl’s head, with her hair tied up in pigtails. Thorin scanned the area to see if he could spot anyone who might be her parents but saw no one. Upon approaching he could see what she was doing more clearly - mechanically ripping out fistfuls of grass with chubby little fists. She heard Thorin and looked up, studied him for a second, and then went back to her destruction.


“You’re too well hidden in this grass. Your parents may not be able to find you.”


“I don’t need parents,” she said stoutly, “and I don’t need boys either.”


“Boys?” said Thorin, repressing a smile at the abrupt mention.


She nodded. “They won’t let me join in their game. They said it’s too dangerous for a girl. Well, I don’t need them anyway. I’ll go by myself.”


Dwarves didn’t hold these sorts of unfair views about girls and boys. They all knew that Dwarrowdam were just as fierce as Dwarrow. It was often speculated that their recklessness in battle is what made their population drop so low. Thorin crouched so that he was on a level with her and asked, “Do you know anyone else who might want to play that game?”


“No,” she said sadly, “they’re my only friends.”


“Hm.” Thorin thought, then said. “How about we go and find these boys and tell them off for being mean?”


“They won’t listen. They’re boys.”


“Very true,” said Thorin solemnly. He tried a different approach. “If it’s a dangerous game, they’ll need someone to protect them and make sure they don’t get hurt,” said Thorin.


The girl blinked in surprise. “I can’t do that. They’re a year older than me. And taller,” she said.


“From my experience, it’s the little ones that pack the worst punch. Metaphorically,” he added quickly, “don’t hit people - if you can help it.” The girl giggled and stood up, brushing the shredded grass blades off of her checkered dress. “You lead the way,” said Thorin, rising too.


As she walked Thorin down a dusty track skirting a tall cornfield, he learned that the girl’s name was Rosie Cotton. Eventually, they reached a glade walled by weeping willow trees that whipped about with the wind. Thorin parted the branches and stepped through. Four boys were at the other side, sword fighting with sticks. Thorin only had to see that head of curly black hair to know that it was Frodo, his two cousins, and Sam. This made things a bit awkward - he was going to give them all a harsh lecture about inclusion, but now that he knew who they were, that didn’t sound like the best plan. Frodo wasn’t his child, but he also wasn’t a stranger’s child.


It was only when he got near that he saw how much smaller Rosie was. Even Pippin, who was the shortest boy, was about half a head taller. Still, this was no better of a reason to exclude someone.


“I’ve heard,” said Thorin, fixing them all with a stern glare, “that some boys have been leaving this girl out of their game.” The four boys looked sheepishly up at Thorin. He lowered himself a little so that he did not tower over them as much, then addressed Sam and Frodo. “I didn’t expect this of you two.”


“We’re really sorry, Rosie,” said Frodo, and he did sound sorry. “We didn’t want you to get hurt or scared.”


“I won’t get hurt or scared. I’m tougher than you think.”


“She’s almost your age,” said Thorin, “if the game isn’t dangerous for you four boys, then it's fine for her too.”


“But it is dangerous, Mister Thorin!” said Sam earnestly, “We’ve all heard Bilbo’s story.”


Bilbo’s story? Did that mean this was about…


“The mid-years monsters,” said Thorin, grimly. He should’ve known. They all nodded. He met Rosie’s gaze - she was looking expectantly at Thorin, waiting for him to continue defending her. Beginning to feel very uncomfortable with the fact that he had advocated for a child even younger than Frodo to be included in their potentially very risky quest, he stayed silent, unsure whether or not to firmly discourage this whole idea.


“See why she can’t come?” said Merry.


Yes, he did see. But then, none of them should really be going in the first place! Despite Bilbo’s air of complacency about the creatures, Thorin now felt more uneasy than ever about letting them go ahead with their plan.


“Thorin said you’ll need protecting. That’s my job, isn’t it, Thorin?” said Rosie.


“Well-”


“We don’t need protection from you,” said Pippin, “You’re a year younger than us.”


“I’m four reading levels above you, Pip!” she retorted fiercely.


“Books won’t help you fight the monster.”


“We’re fighting it now?” asked Sam, nervously.


“Enough. No one’s fighting anything,” Thorin said firmly. “And certainly not by yourselves.” Their heads swivelled up to look at him again. “I’m coming too. We all go together or not at all.” This seemed like a good compromise to Thorin. He would be able to supervise them and especially keep watch over Frodo without spoiling their adventure too much.


“But the monsters won’t come out if there are adults around,” said Merry.


“Only if they see them coming,” said Frodo. “It’ll be good having Thorin with us, just in case it is really dangerous.”


Frodo, Sam and Pippin all looked to Merry - the apparent ringleader. “Alright, fine. If he promises not to scare off the monster when we’re hunting it. Or tell our parents.”


Thorin gave his word that he would keep himself hidden and keep their secret from their families, and that seemed to satisfy Merry. On the ground at Thorin’s feet lay a fallen twig. He picked it up and handed it to Rosie. Proportionally, it was the perfect size for a sword. She took it happily and brandished it playfully at Pippin.


“I’ll see you all tomorrow evening, then,” said Thorin, and he left them to their fun. Only once he had left the glade did the reality of what he was doing hit him. Leading children to a creature that preys on them? No - supervising children as they go and hunt for a creature that preys on them. That didn’t sound much better, either. If only Erebor could see their king now...


*


That evening, Frodo, Sam, Bilbo, and Thorin were back in their usual place by the hearth, listening to another one of Bilbo’s stories. Tonight, he had been requested to recount the battle. Bilbo entertained them for while with his rendition of things. He always emphasised Thorin’s heroism, while depicting his fight with Azog, which caused Thorin to shift uncomfortably. It felt a bit false, this version, leaving out a lot of the messy parts that Thorin remembered all too well.


“I have a question,” said Frodo once Bilbo had finished. “Why was there a war in the first place?”


Bilbo looked over at Thorin, who met his eyes for a moment before Thorin dropped his gaze to the floor.


“It’s… complicated,” said Bilbo, “There’s lots of factors that go into it.”


In very watered-down terms, Bilbo explained some of the events that had caused the war. He made it seem as though the Elves and Men wanted more than their share of the Mountain’s treasure, and that the fight broke out due to miscommunication. Thorin wasn’t sure whether it was better or worse that he left out everything about the Arkenstone and the gold-sickness. Since Bilbo had trusted Thorin with Frodo for the last few weeks, part of him wanted Frodo – and Sam, who spent a lot of time in his company now too - to know, so that they could at least make an informed decision as to whether or not they still felt safe around Thorin.


The version of events Bilbo told seemed to satisfy Frodo and Sam, and they kept discussing it all the way to the front door when it was time for Sam to leave. Thorin stayed in the sitting room while Bilbo said goodnight to Frodo in the hallway. Not really knowing why he had lingered, Thorin left for his bedroom.


Bilbo caught him just as Thorin reached his door. “You alright?” he asked, looking concerned. Thorin nodded without meeting his eye, to which Bilbo immediately shook his head. “I shouldn’t’ve indulged them.”


“I’m fine.”


“Clearly.” Thorin made to turn into the bedroom but Bilbo held out a hand and said, “Look, I know you need time to work through things, but I wish you’d stop blaming yourself. It’s getting very tiresome.”


But Thorin was resolute. “I will not allow myself to forget what I have done. To do so would be an insult to those I have harmed.”


“I'm asking you to forgive yourself. I forgive you, everyone does,” said Bilbo, desperately.


“You shouldn’t-”


“Don't tell me what I can and can't do, Thorin."

 

“You might forgive me, but my kingdom... my people-”


“Your people are grateful to have a place they can call home. They know what you did for them, everything you went through, they understand.”


“What good is a home if it’s not safe? If your King is volatile and blind? Bilbo, I led dwarves into war over a fraction of treasure. I sat and watched as they were slain for that cause. And you - I tried to…tried…”


Bilbo rolled his eyes. “Tried to kill me over a shiny rock whilst under the influence of dragon sickness, yes.” Bilbo put a great emphasis on the latter part of the sentence.


"Even when the worst of the sickness had passed, I made terrible judgments from a place of greed. What’s to say I won’t make the same mistakes again?”


"You have no faith in yourself and that's far worse than making mistakes," Bilbo said sharply. He wasn't angry, but he gave Thorin a stern look. "You've got to move past this, Thorin." Then he softened a little. "When am I allowed to love you again, hm?”


Bilbo didn't wait for an answer. He turned and walked briskly down the hall and into his own bedroom without looking back, leaving Thorin sickened with himself.