Chapter Text
Thorin was furious. This place was abysmal. Full of leaf-eaters and their judgmental looks.
It shouldn’t be a surprise that Gandalf had led them here. His subterfuge being what it was, and the journey being the disaster it has been so far.
The first few weeks had been filled with their irritating burglar sneezing and grousing - constantly complaining about every single thing that one could possibly complain about. And doing so very loudly.
How did such a creature survive until adulthood? Thorin couldn’t understand it.
Master Baggins was soft. He was weak, both in strength and will, and you could tell he’d never had to fight for anything in his life. His perfectly well-furnished home had told Thorin all he’d needed to know about the hobbit.
He spared a thought for the fire and fury that Master Baggins had shown when Thorin had insulted him in his home. It was admittedly a rude thing for Thorin to do, but he had been too exhausted and disheartened to care in that moment.
But that intensity that Master Baggins had shown...where was it now? Where was the fierce little thing that had pointed menacingly right in Thorin’s face and told him off? It showed something like bravery since Thorin knew he was an imposing figure.
Since that moment, though, it had been nothing but nonsense. Thorin had seen the company, one by one, impossibly charmed by Master Baggins. Thorin had rarely gotten involved in personal discussions. He preferred to look in from the outside, as was proper for a ruler.
But he saw them all night after night, sitting around the fire, becoming closer.
Thorin also noticed he was being watched. What he couldn’t figure out is why. He could feel Master Baggins’ eyes on him sometimes. As if he was trying to solve some sort of puzzle.
Thorin was sure that their dislike was mutual. So why, then, did the hobbit gaze at him so? And why did Thorin even care?
Why did he even let his thoughts linger on this? He did not care. He didn't.
What he did care about was the halfling betraying their quest to these elves. And Thorin had just watched him sneak out of the rooms like the thief he was.
Thorin's anger grew, knowing he had to follow Master Baggins to find out what illicit business he was conducting here with the enemy.
Perhaps the elves would take him home, and Thorin could be done with this foolishness. Gandalf might think the hobbit a worthy member of their company, but Thorin knew better. He was nothing but a burden and a liability. Better safe in his armchair with his books than used as a toothpick in the maw of a dragon.
He pushed himself up from the chair he had claimed in the corner and made his way to the door.
“Thorin,” Dwalin grabbed his arm, stalling him. “Where d’ya think you’re going?”
“I’m going to find out why the burglar snuck out of this room like a thief in the night. Did no one else notice he managed to disappear, right under our noses?”
Dwalin looked shocked. As he should, Thorin thought. His personal guard should be more aware of their surroundings. Hobbits couldn’t possibly be that light-footed, no matter what Gandalf claimed.
“No, I suppose I didn’t. But I don't watch him nearly as thoroughly as you do.” Dwalin smirked.
“I beg your pardon?”
“You heard me, Thorin. You watch the hobbit like he’s a threat. Or possibly it’s something else…?” Dwalin let his words trail off pointedly. “Maybe ya think yer being subtle, but I’d wager that some of the others have noticed too.”
“I’ve no idea what you’re talking about, Dwalin.” Thorin didn't.
“Mmhm, sure ya don’t. Well, don’t get too tangled up searching this green nightmare. We’d hate to have to start a war over a directionally challenged king and his troublesome burglar.”
Thorin was glaring. He knew he was. But this - whatever Dwalin was doing, was not amusing.
“I’m sure I’ll be fine. But thank you for your touching concern.” Dwalin just punched his shoulder and rejoined the others.
Thorin walked through the sprawling halls, unsure where he was going - or even what he would say when he found Master Baggins.
Mahal above, this place was even greener than The Shire. Flowers grew all around, every color you could imagine. Vines threaded through shimmering trellises, full and lush, some long enough to dip into the occasional fountain he passed.
Thorin supposed some people could find beauty here. Maybe he could too. If it wasn’t infested with his mortal enemy.
Thorin let that thought move his feet further in this twisting maze. Best be done with this venture so he could rest before they left. After what must have been the tenth corridor he tried, Thorin finally heard voices. Not just any voice: the voice of their burglar.
He put little thought into why he could recognize Master Bilbo’s voice from others.
As he stomped forward, ready to berate the burglar, he was suddenly uncertain what he should do.
Thorin wasn’t used to being unsure.
Slowing his footsteps, he tucked himself against a wall. He could barge directly into the conversation, but what good would that do?
No. No, Thorin would wait here for a moment. Wait to see if the halfling would betray them.
Thorin couldn’t quite make out the other voice at first, but it sounded a good deal like the Lord of this place. Lord Elrond had been...decent. At least while Gandalf was present. Thorin knew better than to trust the supposed kindness of elves, however. He would not be fooled again.
Thorin listened.
“-ou do then?”
“Oh, well! I suppose I do have a fondness for languages indeed. Sindarin is a beautiful language, and I’ve collected quite a number of books written in it. Both histories and poetry. I’m currently attempting to translate one into Westron.”
“Oh? Do all hobbits speak Sindarin?”
“No, no! Other hobbits think me a very strange sort indeed. Interested in other cultures and reading about adventures! The scandal of my very existence is the primary gossip of The Shire, you know? If they could only see me now…” Thorin could hear a soft chuckle.
Thorin waited for him continue. To tell this elf all about their plan to retake Erebor, to betray him as everyone always betrays him.
“I think you are a remarkable hobbit, Bilbo Baggins. I have not met many of your people. But you do credit to yourself, and to your kind, with your brave heart. And your willingness to befriend different races. That’s something that is severely lacking in this world in this age.”
Elrond’s voice sounded...strange. Was that sadness? It couldn’t be; elves didn’t care about anyone other than themselves. Thorin was confused. This certainly wasn’t the conversation he expected to hear when he stormed out of their borrowed rooms.
“My Lord Elrond,” Bilbo said, “Why - I’m sorry, but why is that? I know hobbits are a bit cut off from the rest of the free Peoples of Middle Earth, but surely we all have more in common than not? I can easily feel the tension between your people and the Company. And I know - believe me, I do - that the dwarves may be rough and rowdy. But they have - most of them, anyway - been quite kind to me. And welcoming. More than I expected, really, for how tumultuous our initial meeting was.”
“It is not an easy tale, not so easy to explain, I’m afraid. There are too many centuries. Too many hurts to overcome, it seems. On both sides.”
Thorin was struck dumb. He had never heard an elf admit to any wrongdoing, much less an elf of such high standing and power.
And yet, here was a Lord of a powerful elven realm, telling a hobbit of all people that elvenkind was also to blame for the conflict with the dwarves. This revelation was almost too much for Thorin's brain to process.
“I’ll not press anymore, Lord Elrond. It isn’t my business, anyway. But as I learned from a volatile feud between hot-headed cousins, no resolution to a conflict is possible without both sides’ willingness to try. And I think both your peoples would have much to learn from each other.”
“Remarkable hobbit, indeed.” Elrond’s voice held notes of awe and fondness. Thorin couldn’t help but feel a bit of that, too.
This hobbit, grumpy and irritating as he was, could hold on to righteous anger in the face of an angry dwarven king. But he could also converse confidently with one of the oldest and most powerful elves on all of Arda. About things like compassion and peace.
The halfling wasn’t betraying them. Thorin didn’t understand any of this. How could Master Baggins be so full of contradictions?
“Well, my new friend, would you like a tour of our library? As you are so fond of reading, I thought perhaps it might be a most diverting way to spend your afternoon.”
“Yes! Oh. I mean, yes, thank you. I would like that very much indeed.”
Hearing the voices drawing nearer, Thorin ducked under a table. Thorin, son of Thraín, son of Thrór, was now ducking under tables. How perfectly ridiculous, he thought.
He watched the pair stroll by, thankfully unaware of his presence, before heading back towards the company’s assigned quarters. Who knows how long it would take him to find his way. Because of the twisting labyrinth this place was and not because of Thorin’s supposed lack of direction. No matter what Dwalin said. Or Balin. Or Dís.
Thorin spent the rest of the afternoon in a bit of a daze - surprised as he was by the conversation he had overheard - and it put him off-kilter. He watched over dinner as the hobbit charmed Lord Elrond and seemingly endless number of his people. Thorin watched as Gandalf chuckled merrily at whatever story was being told. He just...he watched. He was quite unaware he was being watched as well until a voice sounded over his shoulder.
“So, what’s going on with the burglar now, Thorin?” Dwalin said as he sat with a thud. “Some dastardly plot I ought to watch out for?” He looked so smug. Thorin wanted to knock that look off his face.
“I overheard Master Baggins having a conversation with our host today.”
Dwalin paused at this, his smirk gone.
“Aye? And do I want to know what they were conversing about?”
Thorin thought about this. Dwalin had agreed that Master Baggins had no place here. He had not been charmed by the hobbit’s manners. Yet. But since it appeared that the little bastard could charm every living thing he had a chance to chat with, Thorin wasn’t sure how long that would last. He wasn’t sure how long he would last either.
“They were discussing Sindarin, books,” Thorin paused, “And the fraught relationship between elven and dwarvenkind.” Dwalin’s eyes would, at another moment, be hilarious. But Thorin was trying to be serious. “It appears the burglar holds positive regard for most of our Company. And he thinks that our races would learn much from each other.”
“Wha-?”
“But most surprising of all, Dwalin - and I swear on the beards of every dwarf in Ered Luin I heard this clearly - was Lord Elrond admitting that elves held some responsibility for the bad blood between our peoples.”
Good. Someone else was slack-jawed at this revelation. Thorin didn’t feel so ridiculous for his reaction now.
“Mahal above, Thorin...I’m not sure what to say to that.”
“Nor I. I hold no love for elves. I am loath to even think it, but perhaps they are not all as terrible as Mirkwood filth?”
Dwalin blinked slowly, turning from Thorin to where Master Baggins still sat with the elves and wizard and just stared.
“I can’t get a good read on this hobbit, Thorin. He’s collectin' the Company members as one might collect treasured trinkets, though not by any deception that I can tell. Why is he here, Thorin? We’ve certainly not had an easy go of it so far. And he seems attached to comfort if his constant grumbling is any sign.”
“It must be for the reward, as I can’t think of another reason one other than a dwarf would risk such peril.”
“Hmm…” But Dwalin said no more. He just continued to watch the scene before him. Until suddenly, Master Baggins’ eyes found them. Thankfully, neither of them jumped like startled pebbles, caught out in some troublesome scheme, but it might have been a near thing.
The hobbit looked surprised to see them staring at him. But after a moment’s confusion, he offered a soft, tentative smile - to the two dwarves least likely to welcome such a thing. And then went back to speaking excitedly to his captive audience.
What was Thorin going to do about this hobbit?
The rest of their stay in the elven realm passed with little fanfare. The dwarves continued to be fed all manner of green things and entertained by dainty music. And if his Company continued to rebel by dancing on tables and being obnoxious, well, Thorin would not tell them how to behave.
They had been forced to escape Rivendell in the wee hours, like common criminals. It had been necessary, of course, but that didn’t help Thorin’s anger. At least the runes were deciphered now. Thanks to Lord Elrond. Disgusting...to be thanking an elf.
The journey would continue on.
Crossing the mountains in this awful weather was going to be treacherous. Thorin silently cursed at everything, and nothing, for the all the trouble they've experienced thus far. The rain beat down on them furiously, thunder and fighting giants fought above. Every step was more dangerous than the last. Until, with a sharp crack, one giant fell and took most of the mountain with it.
In the rush of panic, Thorin didn’t fully process the next few moments. He watched in horror as everything happened so fast. He acted purely on instinct to jump over the edge to save the stranded hobbit, almost falling into the abyss himself.
Dwalin, thinking quickly, grabbed hold of Thorin’s arm to pull him back to the ledge. “I thought we lost our burglar.”
“He’s been lost ever since he left home!” Thorin spat. “He should never have come. He has no place amongst us.”
Thorin knew his words were said more from the panic than anything malicious, but that didn’t mean they didn’t land with the force of a physical blow. Thorin noticed the exact moment they hit Master Baggins, the pain flashing across his face.
Thorin didn’t have time to deal with this. They needed to move forward. Find some kind of shelter for the rest of this wretched night.
It wasn’t until they were all huddled in the cave and nearly asleep that Thorin heard the hushed tones of voices.
It was Bofur and the hobbit. Master Baggins was leaving. Thorin had finally pushed him too far - he had been too cruel. He felt an undeniable pang of guilt in his chest, listening to the conversation in the silence. Bofur was desperately trying to convince him to stay.
Their words were rushed, and goodbyes were said.
Then the glow of the hobbit's elvish blade shined blue in the dark, and the entire earth opened up, swallowing them whole.
The ordeal with goblins was exhausting. But Thorin thought for once that maybe they had a bit of luck on their side because Gandalf showing up was a boon. Thorin would admit that they would likely not have escaped without the wizard's help.
But the hobbit was still missing. Had he fallen further than the rest them? Had he been killed in the skirmish? Or had he seen his chance to run and had taken it? It was what he wanted, after all. To return to his home.
Thorin latched onto that final option with such conviction, not sparing so much as a moment to consider the other possibilities. As his fellow dwarves panicked at Master Baggins’ absence, Thorin let the fire-fueled words fall from his mouth.
“Master Baggins saw his chance, and he took it! He has thought of nothing but his soft bed and his warm hearth since first he stepped out of his door. We will not be seeing our hobbit again. He is long gone.” Thorin finished in a rush. He looked around at the dejected faces before him.
“No. He isn’t.” There was a collective gasp from the company as they turned to face a suddenly present Master Baggins. How was this possible? Always, always, with the surprises, this damnable hobbit.
“Bilbo Baggins,” Gandalf said with a smile, “I have never been so glad to see anyone in my life.”
From the sounds of exhaled sighs and shoulder claps, Thorin could tell the others agreed.
“Bilbo, we’d given you up!” Kili said.
“How on earth did you get past the goblins?” Even Thorin's own nephews were befriending the burglar, Thorin’s own flesh and blood charmed by the impossibility of him.
“How indeed…” At least he could rely on Dwalin to have some sense.
The hobbit laughed, but he looked bedraggled and unsure. Gandalf spoke out, “Well, what does it matter? He’s back.”
Thorin could stand this charade no longer. He would find out now, once and for all, Master Baggins’ motivations.
“It matters,” Thorin said. “I want to know...why did you come back?” He pretended not to notice how softly he spoke the question. He stared at the hobbit, awaiting the truth. To finally understand why he was here with them.
“Look, I know you doubt me. I know - I know - I know you always have. And you’re right; I often think of Bag End. I miss my books, and my armchair, and my garden. See, that’s where I belong. That’s home. And that’s why I came back ‘cause…” he paused, looking around at the faces before him, a gentle smile on his face, “You don’t have one. A home. It was taken from you. But I will help you take it back if I can.”
The hobbit maintained such direct eye contact that Thorin was forced to look down. There was that same fire, the same righteousness Thorin saw back in The Shire. He could feel his eyes glazing over from this unexpected rush of emotion, from that raw and honest confession.
The entire company stared at Master Baggins with undisguised awe. Silence, a blanket over them all.
Perhaps, like Thorin, they also needed to hear this. They needed to hear that someone cared about them enough to fight for them. Someone who had absolutely no emotional stake in this venture.
Thorin had been so foolish. He always experienced the worst in people, so he always expected the worst from people. Thorin couldn’t be blamed for doing so with Master Baggins, could he?
Yes. Yes, he could be blamed. He would have to apologize. Most profusely and in front of everyone. The next free moment they had, Thorin would ask Master Baggins for his forgiveness. And he would offer a braid for his dreadful behavior.
