Actions

Work Header

This Too Shall Last

Chapter 5

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo’s stomach was pleasantly full, and his mind so much more at peace after the restful break at Master Beorn’s. His pony trotted along as Bilbo hummed a tune from his childhood. The Company also seemed far more at ease after their brief respite. What healing a good meal and a safe place to rest could provide. Bilbo tried hard to focus on the last few days because he very much didn’t want to think of the ominous growth looming in the distance.

Thorin had surprised Bilbo while at Beorn's. For someone who spoke so rarely, Thorin sure did have a way with words. It was one hell of an apology. Thorin wanted to be Bilbo’s friend, and Bilbo was happy with that. Truly he was. But Bilbo, in the deepest part of his heart, couldn’t help but want more. And maybe - just maybe - one day Thorin might too. Because Thorin had made an effort to walk with Bilbo around the gardens everyday, and he asked all manner of questions. It was just...Thorin seemed genuinely interested in hobbit culture; he was certainly curious about the hobbit flower language. Bilbo thought of his jonquils and lamented the fact that he had no way to preserve them other than his memory.

There was just a glowing ember of hope starting to bloom in Bilbo’s chest - powerfully insistent - that maybe Bilbo could have more than friendship with Thorin.

Yes,Thorin was a king and a warrior. And Bilbo? Bilbo was neither of those things. He wouldn’t even know where to begin courting a dwarf at all, much less a king. A simple hobbit did not belong in Thorin’s world. Best not think about that right now, though, seeing as they were about to enter the darkest, most diseased looking forest Bilbo had ever seen.

So Bilbo refused to think about it anymore. No more for the rest of the journey. Or at least the next half hour.

Gandalf said his goodbyes as they reached the edge of Mirkwood. The dwarves were furious at the notion that they would have to travel through this nightmarish hellscape without their wizard? And Bilbo agreed.

But nothing to be done for, Gandalf would do as he would do. And they could do this. Stay on the road, Gandalf had said. Do not leave the road. They could do that.

They didn’t do that.



 

The first few days in the forest weren’t too terrible, actually. Everyone was doing their utmost to keep spirits up. Dori was showing Bofur how to fix one of the ear flaps on his ridiculous cap.

Fili and Kili were telling off-color jokes and imagining all the ways they would spend their treasure - each idea more ridiculous than the last. Gloin and Dwalin were working off their anxious energy by sparring regularly. Bifur, Bombur, and Nori (an unlikely combination, Bilbo thought) talked about something in Khuzdul - quite animatedly and with many interesting hand gestures. Ori drew in his journal. And Balin and Oin watched the entire circus with a mixture of fondness and exasperation.

Only Thorin sat apart from the group, his thoughts clearly heavy. Bilbo had asked him on the second night why it was that Mirkwood bothered Thorin so much. The story was even more heartbreaking than Bilbo had imagined. How could that bastard elf - a king and leader, more ancient than most lands in this world - how could he turn away from the suffering of an entire people? They weren't responsible for the actions of their king. They weren't responsible for the dragon. Honestly, if Bilbo knew nothing else about the Elvenking, that would be enough to despise him.

But Bilbo also couldn't overlook the sick forest - the dying forest - decay and rot all around them. And it wasn’t a natural death. This was an evil that had been allowed to spread and devour the land while its leader did nothing. Bilbo’s heart fell more and more with every twisted tree and darkened bush. He was a child of Yavanna. Bilbo wanted to help this place, but he knew he couldn't.

 

 

Those first few good days turned into a few not-so-good days, which turned into many bad days that then turned into quite a lot of worse days. The company was running out of food and water. But more worrisome than that was the realization that they were running out of hope. Conversation dwindled to a trickle. Smiles disappeared. Even their reliably happy Bofur, Fili, and Kili had all fallen into a dour mood.

How much more of this would they have to bear?

 

 

 

Apparently, much more. What followed was one disaster then another and another. Spiders and missing dwarves. Warrior elves and deep dungeons. And an almost absurdly tall Elvenking that made Bilbo want nothing more than to climb to deliver a swift bop to his nose.

It was after a few days spent in the dank dungeons that Bilbo had finally thought of a possible way to get them out. Thranduil wanted treasure, so Bilbo would give the king his share of the treasure from Erebor. Bilbo remembered Thorin and Thranduil yelling at each other, and he shuddered. Well, no,Thorin wouldn’t be happy about it. But as a full member of the Company, it was Bilbo’s to do with as he pleased. And Bilbo cared naught for treasure, anyway.

And as long as the dwarves didn’t hear Bilbo talk about treasure so dismissively, he would be fine. Probably.

 

 

Bilbo requested an audience with the Elvenking. He wanted to first ask to speak to Thorin, hoping he hadn’t totally misread the situation, and that his plan might save them all.

The Elvenking’s chambers were beautiful and imposing. Just like the king himself, actually. Beautiful and evil, Bilbo reminded himself.

“Halfling,” Thranduil said, haughtiness dripping from every letter, “I have been informed you requested an audience, but I fear I cannot understand why. My answer has not changed. Your leader will honor his family’s word and return what is rightfully mine, or you will all stay in my dungeons and rot. As I find it difficult to imagine that Thorin, son of Thrain, will do such a thing, we have nothing further to discuss.”

Good gracious, this pompous ass sure loved to hear himself talk.

“First, your majesty, my name is Bilbo Baggins, not ‘halfling’. I am not half of anything. Second, I came to request that you grant me a meeting with our leader. I believe I have a solution to the present problem, but I need to speak with him first.”

"A solution to the problem?” Thranduil asked. “Surely, you are not so foolish to think you can change the mind of a dwarf.”

Bilbo clenched his hands. “I have already changed the mind of a dwarf. Many dwarves, in fact. Just because you do not see my value - or theirs - doesn’t mean that it isn’t there. They are all of them worthy of respect and kindness. Especially since we have done nothing wrong to you, other than walking on the road that happens to run through your forest.”

That was perhaps a bit too far, but Bilbo’s temper was flaring at the flippant dismissal.

“My, you certainly are spirited, halfling - ”

“Bilbo. My name is Bilbo.” Oh, he was fit to be tied. This was not going to end well.

Thranduil glared at him.

“These dwarves are not your friends. Dwarves care for nothing, save their gold and gems. And they will show you this sooner than you think. But I could offer you your freedom, halfling, if you tell me the reason you are in my forest.”

Damn all the stars above, again with the ‘halfling’?

“You’re wrong,” Bilbo said, pointing his finger at the Elvenking much as he did all those months ago to another ill-mannered king.“These dwarves are my friends. They are kind and brave, honorable and loyal. And I will not abandon them for my own freedom. So I suppose if you will not let me speak to my leader, then I’d like to return to my cell now. I’ve had quite enough of you and this conversation.”

The great Elvenking gaped, likely not believing that such a small creature would dare speak to him in such a way. Bilbo didn’t give one whit what this self-important elf thought of him, though. And Bilbo’s silver tongue had turned to cold steel, so there was nowhere to go from here but down anyway.

Thranduil looked past him, and Bilbo turned around to see the members of the Company staring at him. They looked confused and more than a little stunned. Oh. They had heard all that, then. Bilbo could feel his cheeks burning...

“Well, halfling, I must say I’m surprised. A feat not easily done, I assure you. I brought your companions here to show them that I could turn you against them. But it seems I was wrong. And I do not admit that often.”

Bilbo stifled a snort. Yeah, he doesn't expect Thranduil ever admits to being wrong.

“Very well, then,” Thranduil said, waving his elegant hand. “Speak to your fellows. Depending on your offer, I will consider rescinding my sentencing.”

The king ordered them to be taken to a suite of rooms down the hall from his own chambers. Bilbo was so confused by the last fifteen minutes, honestly. What a mad kind of whirlwind the entire world was turning out to be in comparison to The Shire.

 

 

Barely a half second after the elves had locked the door Bilbo found himself rushed by a swarm of hairy dwarves.

“Oh, ya feisty burglar, we knew ya loved us!” Bofur shouted.

“Bilbo Bilbo Bilbo, just what are we going to do with a friend like you?” Kili reached over and pinched Bilbo’s cheek - and, no, that was just about enough of that.

“Alright, off, you lot! Give Master Baggins a moment to breathe.” Balin pulled on Bilbo’s hand to remove him from the scrum of now pouting dwarves. “Lad, that was some mighty fine talking you did there. I never expected to see anyone cow the great Thranduil Oropherion.”

Balin was smiling at Bilbo, kind and sincere, but Bilbo felt embarrassed by all this attention. “I lost my temper a bit back there. Not very mannerly behavior for a hobbit, terrible business. I apologize that you had to see that.”

“Apologize?? Bilbo, that was brilliant!” Fili grabbed his shoulder gently. “You have stones made of mithril, Bilbo. Standing toe to toe with a millennia-old leaf-eater in his own home and telling him off? Masterful.” Bilbo didn't know what mithril was but he supposed it sounded good enough coming from Fili.

“I would like a moment to speak with Master Baggins,” Thorin said sternly, inclining his head towards the other room. Bilbo followed, slightly nervous at Thorin’s tone.

Thorin shut the door behind them and gestured to a chair by a large window.

“Master Baggins," Thorin said, "How is it you always seem to find some brilliant way to save us every time things look most hopeless?”

“Oh, well, I just wanted to speak to you, is all. And I knew out of all of us I had the best chance of getting an audience with the bastard.” Thorin smirked at Bilbo's harsh words of Thranduil. Just like he expected he might.

“What did you want to speak to me about?”

“To be honest, it was a little selfish on my part. I wanted to see if you were okay.” Bilbo lowered his eyes before continuing, afraid of what he might see on Thorin’s face. “But I also wanted to propose a way to get us out of here.”

“Go on.”

“It seems that Thranduil only wants the treasure. And if are successful in retaking the mountain then I will have treasure. Mounds and gobs, if what you've all said is true. I’d very much like to bargain my share to buy our way out of here.”

Anger replaced shock on Thorin’s face. Drat! Had Bilbo pushed too far? Was this a terrible idea?

“Master Baggins, I cannot let you give our gold to Thranduil. I will not allow it.”

“Now wait just a damn minute! I very certain from your own contract that it would be my treasure if we take back the mountain. So I reckon I can use it however I like. And I’d like to use it to leave this place. I prefer to not rot in a dungeon if it’s all the same to you."

“You do not know what you ask of me, Master Baggins.” Thorin’s face looked tormented.

“It’s just gold!" Bilbo was losing his temper again. Perhaps the lid hadn’t been put back on tightly enough after the kerfuffle with Thranduil. “I’m not asking for the entire mountain. Just enough to buy our freedom. And possibly their help with the dragon...” Bilbo added.

“What on Arda makes you think they will help us with the dragon?” Thorin looked less tormented and more confused.

“Treasure, Thorin. Treasure makes me think that.” Bilbo said, “If what you said is true, then there’s an obnoxious amount of it under the dragon, who is himself currently under the dragon. Hence the help needed. If this could help, then I don’t really understand what the issue is.”

“The issue," Thorin spat, "Is that dwarven gold and jewels do not belong in the hands of elves! It is not theirs!”

“Would you listen to yourself? These are our lives you’re talking about! Would you really let us stay here forever over some sparkling rocks and shiny metal? Over a century and a half feud? I understand you're still angry - and I don't blame you, of course - but I don’t want to die locked in a cell, Thorin. I want to feel the sunshine on my face again. I want to reach the mountain and defeat the dragon and see you all returned home.” Bilbo was pleading now.

Bilbo needed to make Thorin see reason. He had to. Without much thought, Bilbo reached out to take Thorin’s hand in his, mustering up all his courage and conviction and as he looked into Thorin’s eyes. “Please, Thorin. Please do the right thing. This quest is important to you. And we have all come too far to not see it through. I know it’s hard to let bygones be bygones...but don’t let the past keep you from the future. Don’t let Thranduil destroy any more of your dreams.”

Bilbo could feel a small tear slip down his face, but Thorin looked wrecked.

“Bilbo…” Thorin was squeezing Bilbo’s hand just a hair this side of too tight, a questioning look in his eyes. “Okay.”

“Okay?” Bilbo asked, hardly able to believe what he’d just heard.

“You’re right. I do not want to let my pride harm our mission, or our companions,” Thorin paused, “Or you.”

Oh...

Wait a minute.

“You just called me ‘Bilbo’.” This was probably not the right thing to be thinking of, but it was the first thing that registered to Bilbo’s brain.

"I - I did. Is that - is that unacceptable?”

“What? No! It's - it’s fine. Just...you’ve never used my name before. It’s quite nice, actually. You should do so more often. If you like, I mean.”

Thorin’s soft smile...oh, mercy.

“Then I shall continue to do so, Bilbo.” Thorin gave Bilbo’s hand one more squeeze. “However, I believe we should discuss this plan of yours with the Company so we might decide our next move.”

Bilbo missed Thorin’s hand immediately. He wanted more. Dammit.

 

 

Talking to the Company went about exactly how Bilbo thought it would. They all grumbled and shouted, but eventually they saw reason. They couldn't stay here, no matter how much their anger didn't want to work with Thranduil. Now all that was left was the rest of the plan.

Talking to Thranduil was exhausting, irritating, and altogether complicated. Elves loved to use a hundred words when a dozen would do just fine. After much back and forth, and a few heated remarks, Bilbo offered a plan that would at least reasonably please both parties. Thranduil would get his desired White Gems, as well as a share of the treasure. In exchange for this, the Company would have guaranteed safe passage to Erebor, and assistance within the mountain, as deemed reasonable by a party of his most capable warriors.

The Company readied to leave Thranduil’s halls almost immediately after the talks, waiting by the front gates impatiently. Presumably to put as much space between themselves and the Elvenking as possible. Twenty-five elves joined the Company’s ranks. The elven warriors looked unearthly and powerful.

And very, very grumpy. The dwarves were no better, really. They all looked like someone put something unpleasant in their socks.

Only Bilbo - and for some unknown reason, Kili - seemed unbothered by the elves’ presence. Best not to worry about it too much.

Thranduil’s son, Prince Legolas, was leading their unlikely group, followed by the Captain of the Guard. This should make the journey safer, at least, if not particularly pleasant. Bilbo was still happy with the current events. Yes, he was pleased. Even if had to deal with a dozen or more sour faces for the next few weeks.

He just hoped they would find common ground. Eventually.

Notes:

Thranduil is such a jack ass. Don't get me wrong; I don't necessarily think he's a villain like some do (he might have been doing what he thought was best for his people after Smaug), but he's still a turd. And he deserved to get verbally slapped by a tiny angry hobbit. Bilbo's like, "Gimme a step stool because I have some things to say."

I also think Thorin would have been so much more reasonable than canon. He's not the type of leader who would let his people rot in their enemy's dungeon because of his pride. (Okay, maybe he'd keep them there for a few days because of his pride, but not too long.)