Chapter Text
FOUR:
The weather was grey and overcast as the wagons rolled down a long shallow slope, the long grey-green grasses of the low downs waving in the cool northerly breeze. The expanse of the Eastern Road stretched away, down into the shallow valley and up the next long hill, heading almost directly west. The Shire lay a few days away, nestled in its warm and sheltered dell, known only by the gentle inhabitants. Barius was whistling cheerfully and Bilbo was singing along, a familiar Hobbit country song that stretched to about seventy verses that any Hobbit should know by heart. The others were also whistling and spirits seemed to be high.
Thorin was dozing in the back of the wagon, exhausted by his night shift guarding the party. When they had woken, the Hobbits had expressed surprise that he had maintained a vigil all night but he had merely nodded and prowled like a caged wolf as they had drifted away to complete their morning washes and get breakfast. The dwarf had helped as much as he could, harnessing the ponies and gathering spare firewood for the evening before they left-but he had been shocked that the Hobbits had insisted he eat before they left. He had observed that Hobbits were fond of their food but what he hadn’t completely understood was that they were relentlessly generous and very poor at accepting a refusal. His own pride at having so little to contribute was scourging him mercilessly-he felt his meagre contributions hardly covered the food they were determined to ply him with-but he found it was easier to accept the hospitality. Especially when Bilbo asked.
The Hobbit-clearly the youngest of the party-was the person who determinedly spent the most time with the dwarf and Thorin wasn’t sure what to make of him. Outwardly, he appeared like a normal Hobbit-softly plump, neat and fastidious and amiable. There was a kindness in his features and the way his honey coloured hair curled around his face was attractive but Thorin could read nothing but friendship-and some naivety.Though as he observed, he gathered that Bilbo was alone, embraced by his family but still a little aside. The gentle jibes about being considered ‘weird’ were clearly a more serious matter than they sounded and sometimes, Bilbo went quiet and pensive after an exchange. Respectability, it seemed, was as important to Hobbits as Honour was to Dwarrow. Musing over the conundrum, he drifted off into a peaceful sleep.
He woke as Bilbo landed by him and rested a hand on his shoulder. He tensed as the smaller creature leaned close.
“I don’t want to worry you but there are men on horses closing,” he murmured. “They’ve been following for a couple of hours, gradually closing. At the top of the last rise, we had a look back. I think one of them is Halford.”
Thorin tensed, his eyes widening and he swallowed.
“Do you have any weapons?’ he asked grimly, eyes hardening.
“Simple pocket knives only,” Bilbo replied, his eyes widening. Sighing, Thorin shook his head.
“It won’t do,” he said and took a deep breath. Bilbo leaned closer.
“What are you worried about?” he asked. “What is happening?” Slowly, Thorin sat up.
“My former…employer…cares little for the law,” he said slowly, his voice hard with hatred. “I cannot be sure if he was there at the original attack or not but he deals with slavers. Is friends with slavers.” His hands fisted. “I suspect he decided he had let me go for too low a price-and maybe wishes to get his livelihood back…”
“You think he’ll attack us to steal you?” Bilbo hissed. Wincing, the dwarf nodded.
“Kidnap,” he corrected baldly as Bilbo blushed.
“Sorry-I didn’t mean…” he began, his eyes filled with shame at the term that had implied their passenger was less than a person but Thorin managed a grim half-smile.
“You may not be inaccurate-because that is what Halford believes,” he reminded the other grimly.
“But you’re a free man!” Bilbo protested as Thorin nodded then raised his still-banded wrists.
“What is easier to ignore? A piece of paper tossed casually in a fire or the brands on my flesh and the steel shackles around my wrists?” he asked, his tone bleak. But Bilbo’s face hardened in anger.
“No-that will not do!” the Hobbit declared. “You are our guest, our friend and we will not allow this man to treat you like this.” He looked up at Barius. “Keep going as if nothing is going on. But we have no passenger. He left us just outside Bree and headed south…” The other Hobbit turned his blond head and gave a single nod.
“You shouldn’t take any risks for me,” Thorin advised him. “These Men are violent and ruthless. You are unarmed and an easy target.” Bilbo crouched lower.
“Some Men attacked a Hobbit caravan eight years ago,” he revealed. “Five Hobbits were taken. The Elves of Rivendell and the Rangers hunted them down. The Hobbits were returned within two weeks. the Men who hunted them were all slain.” He took a slow breath. “We help any who ask us-or who need it-because we are protected, by Yavanna’s Grace, by the kindness of others. Risks must be taken because we cannot allow ourselves to stand by and let people be hurt.” He stared into Thorin’s eyes. “You will be safe,” he promised. “Now lie down and I’ll hide you among the goods. They won’t search our wagons.”
“Bilbo…”
“Trust me,” the Hobbit pleaded and finally, Thorin nodded, allowing the smaller creature to carefully pack the goods around him, concealing his meagre possessions around him and ensuring the wood he had gathered was also strewn carefully across his concealed shape. Finally, Bilbo casually tossed his jacket across the hidden dwarf before clambering back besides Barius.
The Men were closing now, the thud of their hooves loud and rhythmic amid the quiet of the afternoon. The Barrow Downs were rolling to either side of the road, the location isolated and spooky but the Hobbits handed around a paper bag of raspberry nougat as they were overtaken. Adalgrim and Barius pulled the wagons to a halt and waved a cheerful greeting.
“Afternoon!” Adalgrim greeted. “Where head you?” The Men wheeled around the wagons, eyes sweeping over the four Hobbits. Halford was among them, his face devoid of all pretence of civility.
“Where is he?” he demanded. The Hobbits stared, eyes wide and faces carefully confused.
“Who?” Barius asked. The Man loomed closer.
“The dwarf!” he spat. Bilbo frowned.
“May I ask why you seek him when he is no longer in your employ?” he asked politely. “I didn’t get the impression you were friends…”
“I was cheated!” Halford spat. “I let him go for too low a price…”
“A fair price,” Adalgrim reminded him. “Negotiated in front of three witnesses. And on a legal contract signed in quadruplicate-a copy of which is lodged securely with the Bree Council to ensure the sale was legal.”
There was a pause and the other Men shared a glance with the former smith. It was clear the tale they had been fed differed from the version these Hobbits were offering. There was a moment and then Halford adopted a sickly expression that was meant to appear reassuring and failed miserably.
“I meant no offence, little masters,” he said swiftly, the tone obsequious. He-as his companions-knew that the trade between the Shire and Bree was valuable and if anything befell the delegation, he would be hunted by the Men of Bree-as well as the Rangers who passed through the area and made sure everyone was aware that the Shire Hobbits were under their protection. “I just regret my friend Thorin and I parted on poor terms. I confess I was a little the worse for wear and I may not have been as generous as I owed him.”
I think you were more than generous with your insults, your cruelty and your fists, Bilbo thought, his face neutral.
“Do you know where he is?” a second man asked. His face was rugged and cruel, a poorly-tended beard wild over his chin and neck. Adalgrim gave a regretful sigh.
“We offered him passage to the Shire but he refused,” he explained. “I think he was angry.”
“He’s a rude and unfriendly creature,” Halford told them smugly.
“We offered friendship but he wanted to leave,” Flambard added, his soft voice thoughtful. “He wanted to make his own way in the world…”
“Prideful,” Halford condemned to grunts of agreement.
“Maybe he just misses his home and family,” Bilbo offered sympathetically. “A very hard wound to deal with. Especially since he said he wasn’t able to return because…he had lost his Honour.” There were snorts of derision from the Men.
“What would animals like that know of Honour?’ the second man sneered. “They’re just brutish creatures, with no more emotion or concept of decency than a pig.” Bilbo felt himself tense with fury at the cruel dismissal and he couldn’t imagine how Thorin felt at hearing such savage condemnation of his qualities as a sentient being. In fact he was amazed at the self-control the dwarf was showing in remaining absolutely still and silent at such appalling abuse.
“When he decided to leave, we gave him food and wished him good fortune,” Barius sighed. “I hope he finds what he is looking for on his road ahead. I hope he finds happiness and peace…” There were nods from the other Hobbits and the Men shared a look.
“So where did he leave you?” Halford demanded. Bilbo shrugged.
“A few miles outside Bree, where the south road heads away,” he explained. “We parted ways there and then we headed home.” There were a pause as the Men rode around the wagons and then Halford nodded.
“Thanks for your help, little masters,” he sneered. “So you see? You paid for that ungrateful troll and all you got was nothing. He spurned your help and left you with empty purses and a sour taste in the mouth. Maybe you should think twice before interfering in other people’s business! Especially with dwarves!” The last word was spat and then the horsemen wheeled away and galloped back east, along the road in search of their quarry. Barius clicked his teeth and the wagons set off at an appreciably faster pace, wheels clacking as they sped down the slope eager to put more distance between themselves and the encounter. Adalgrim cast Bilbo a calculating look and the younger Hobbit gave a helpless shrug.
“What was that?” Adalgrim hissed as Bilbo sighed.
“I don’t know,” he admitted, though his gaze drifted to the concealed Thorin. A nasty suspicion came over him that there was a deeper connection between Halford and the dwarf that he had understood, that there was a darker history there. But then he squashed the suspicion. Faced with the foul spectre of Halford, it was easy to let your imagination plumb the depths of depravity and be seduced that everything he touched was as corrupt and disgusting as he was…but he couldn’t. He wouldn’t believe that the noble, proud dwarf had allowed the Man to make him anything other than his worker in the Forge, a source of income that more than supplied the man’s needs.
So why were they so desperate to get him back?
There was a pause and slowly, Thorin emerged, moving the jacket and branches aside carefully until he was staring up at the Hobbit. The anger flashing in the crystal blue eyes and the expression on the dwarf’s face had Bilbo scooting back, watching the solid shape sit up and shuffle back until he was sitting back against the side of the cart.
There was an awkward silence and Bilbo knew a Hobbit would be talking by now-but Thorin was far more self-possessed, close-lipped to the point of surly and clearly someone who was not prone to sharing his thoughts and worries with anyone else. And maybe, having been treated as no better than a piece of equipment for over three years, he had learned to be withdrawn and hold his tongue…but Bilbo got the strongest feeling that this was who Thorin was. There was something very controlled about the man facing him-but an overwhelming sense of sadness.
“I’m sorry he said those things,” Bilbo offered. Slowly, Thorin looked up and his brows furrowed.
“You did not say them. Nor did you agree with them-in fact, you defended me to those pursuers,” he pointed out in his deep voice.
“But it must have been hard to hear such things said unfairly about you,” the Hobbit offered. There was a pause-and then Thorin sighed.
“It was nothing that I haven’t heard on a daily basis for the last three years-and intermittently, for years before…” he reluctantly confessed. He caught the Hobbit’s expression. “Even before this, I sometimes needed to find work among the villages of Men, to help support my family, especially when we travelled,” he slowly said. “Men view my race as inferior, no matter how skilled we may be with metal and gems. They scorn us and cheat us. And when we have to take such work, we are always the last in line, always the first to be cheated or let go. And insults are the currency of any communication with them.”
“You don’t deserve it, do you?”
Thorin gave a small, wry smile.
“Actually, I do,’ he admitted bleakly. “I gave up my Honour by surrendering. And though it was no choice, I couldn’t allow my sister and her sons to be taken. They are our future.”
“So why you?” Bilbo asked.
“I was the head of the family travelling,” he reluctantly revealed. “It was my responsibility. Men aren’t attracted to our women, save as a novelty. My sister-sons are young and have long lives ahead of them that don’t deserve to be ruined by slavery. I was the obvious choice. I have skills that could be used. I have a brother who could take my place as my father’s Heir. And I have no mate to miss me, no One to grieve my loss. I was the only choice.”
“That must have been hard,” Bilbo sighed. After a moment, Thorin nodded.
“I knew, when I stepped forward, that I was losing them forever,” he said, his voice gruff with emotion. “Being taken as a slave, dragged fighting and resisting into chains, could perhaps be forgiven. But bargaining to surrender for others, to voluntarily stand forth and give away everything I was-even for my kin-well, the dishonour is irretrievable.”
“That’s stupid!” Bilbo exclaimed. “If anything, what you did was braver and more honourable! You stepped forward, giving yourself up to shame and slavery to protect and free people you loved. How-how could anyone see that as dishonourable? It’s a heroic sacrifice!” Shaking his head, Thorin stared at his knees, his hands fisting in frustration.
“It is our way-particularly for one of my line…” And then he clenched his jaw. He had said too much, betrayed himself…but Bilbo harrumphed, as if he had ignored the words. The Hobbit hadn’t, of course-merely filing the information for a later date-but he could recognise when their passenger wasn’t keen on talking about something clearly so painful.
“Can you tell me a little about your family?” Bilbo tried, and saw him tense. “Nothing secret or personal, of course! But you have a sister and brother and nephews. Could you maybe tell me what they are like? You must miss them horribly and sometimes talking about the people you love, recalling their smiles and antics can help keep their memory close.” He offered a small smile. “My parents died two years ago in a terrible sickness. In the space of two days, we went from a family of three to me being…alone. But I was fortunate because I have those around me who can remind me of who they were, of their foibles and smiles and the sayings that we all laughed over. And their memories help keep them alive and make the loneliness a little less hard to bear.”
Thorin looked up, shock leaking into his eyes. He hadn’t considered that this Hobbit, who seemed so calm and welcoming, could be nursing such sorrow. And though he was surrounded by extended family, the loss of those nearest and dearest to him must have been a devastating blow. Slowly, he nodded.
“I am sorry for your loss,” he said awkwardly. Bilbo offered a watery smile.
“And I for yours,” he said quietly. “But while there is no hope left for me, your family still lives. And where there is life, hope remains.” He sighed. “You cannot give up. Nothing is impossible.” Thorin shook his head.
“Try dealing with dwarves,” he warned the Hobbit darkly.
“I think I have to defer to your experience,” Bilbo conceded cheerfully. “Though if they are all as stubborn as you, I suspect it must be a very frustrating experience.” There was a pause and Thorin found a tiny smile lifting the corners of his mouth.
“You have no idea,” he sighed. The Hobbit shrugged.
“I don’t want to make you do anything you feel uncomfortable with,” he explained. “But we Hobbits cherish our families-and I have many cousins, lots of them young, and thinking on their antics when I am feeling alone warms my heart. Of course, it may be different among your people and I don’t mean to pry…but you must love your nephews very much to sacrifice so much for them.”
“I do,” Thorin admitted, folding his arms across his chest. “Both of them are…mischievous. Yes, I think that is the most diplomatic way of putting it.” He gave that small smile again. “Fili is the elder with Kili five years his junior. And together, they act like a pair of children, egging each other on and teasing and pranking others-though they are older than I was when our home fell and I found myself responsible for all our safety. They don’t know that burden and I would never wish such weight to be placed on ones so young and free-spirited. Dis indulges them, though she keeps them in line as well-well, she keeps us all in line…” His voice softened. “And they always bring laughter and joy to any room they enter.”
Listening to the rich voice, warmed with pride and affection, Bilbo felt his own heart warm as just for a few moments, he glimpsed the true Thorin hidden deep under his mask and felt a kinship to the dwarf. He had no clue what would lie ahead but he vowed, deep in his own heart, that he would do everything he could to help regain Thorin’s family.
No one deserved to lose their family for the crime of saving them.
