Chapter Text
SIX:
His eyes snapped open and for a long moment, he lay still. Disorientation whirled around him and he struggled to recall where he was. Somehow, he was in a real bed, a blanket draped over his body with warm early sunlight leaking through the gaps between the embroidered curtains. He could faintly hear the dawn chorus, the sounds of birdsong soaring in the garden. But there were no other sounds.
No breathing.
No creak of leather, of someone moving predatorily around him.
No fear of sudden sounds, of sudden pain, of blood and burns and swallowed cries.
No clink of chains as he moved.
He sat up, throwing the blanket off and swinging his legs round. Bilbo had fussed and worried the previous evening, making enough food to feed half a dozen. A luscious chicken pie with potatoes, greens, gravy, cauliflower cheese, bread and apple pie and cream for dessert had rendered them both replete and for once, Thorin had relaxed. However, Bilbo had refused to allow his guest to help with the washing up and instead, Thorin had sat by the fire, at a loss what to do. The hobbit had continued his rambling monologue, apologising, offering more food, books, a pipe… clearly being a host was a serious business in Hobbit society. Until finally, Bilbo had sat down in the parlour, clearly frazzled and exhausted and had rested for a short while, trying to read but clearly unsettled before both had finally turned in.
The truth was that Thorin felt completely unbalanced. Until that fateful night, he had been in control of his destiny. Not completely, because he was still a subject of his father, King Thrain, but he had been the Crown Prince and a trusted emissary of his people. Never shirking any task, always doing what was necessary no matter how hard or menial, his life had been mapped out from the moment of his birth…until he did what was necessary and sacrificed it all. There had been no question, no need for any hesitation but it was only as he was hauled away that the immensity of his predicament had struck him. He ceased being a dwarf, a Prince, a member of the Line of Durin…and became less important than a piece of equipment, than a hammer or chisel or lathe. And they had made sure he understood his situation. No matter what he silently promised to himself, he had railed against his treatment and he had struggled to retain what shreds were left of his honour, his own self-worth. And they had delighted in stripping that from him, piece by piece.
He rose, pulled his boots on and quietly opened the door. There was no sound, not even the sounds of snoring, but he moved as quietly as he could, walking through the silent hallway until he found his way to the front door-and then he quietly opened it. Taking a deep breath of the fresh morning air, he stepped out onto the front step and folded his arms across his chest. Below the Hill, Hobbiton was spread out, green meadows and a big field with a magnificent tree interspersed with cottages and Hobbit holes. Flowers were everywhere and the little lanes wound their way through the idyllic landscape, the blue sky still blushing with the recent dawn. It was the kind of land that Thorin had never even considered visiting, a land that dwarves barely even knew existed and would never seek out of choice. His people didn’t value the beauty of growing things or greenery: their eyes were fixed on the solidity of rock and stone and gems, on the works of Mahal rather than the children of Yavanna.
Quietly, he walked down the little garden path from the door and found a neat bench, perched by the gate and he slowly sat down. A few days earlier, he would not have believed if someone had told him he would be sitting in the Hobbits’ Shire, away of Halford and declared a free man. A few days earlier, he had been less important than the smith’s tools, scarcely a beast to be fed the minimum to keep him alive and capable of working and definitely a toy to be casually abused for whatever slight or fun his owner thought justified the wounds.
His fists creaked as they tightened and he stared down at the steel bands, still tight around his wrists. The Hobbits…Bilbo…had bought his freedom and given him the papers to declare him free but as of now, he still wore all the trappings of slavery. The bands, the brands, the scars…he shook his head. Maybe he could cut off the steel bands and maybe he could conceal the brands but the scars…they were his to wear and own until the end of his days. No matter how shameful or undeserved, he had to live with them, own them as a part of his past that he could not run away from or deny. But the scars would always mark him as shamed, as devoid of honour and irrevocably sundered from his family.
He leaned forward, elbows on his knees and hands clasped in thought. If he had any sense, he would work for a few weeks, earn enough to buy some supplies and clothes and maybe a weapon…and then he would leave. There was a possibility he could find work as a smith elsewhere, the the villages and towns of Men, maybe south…Rohan or even Gondor would appreciate his skills, though he would be an outsider in a land of Men. Or he could head East, to the Brown Lands and beyond to Rhun and Harad, though their attitudes to dwarrow were even more brutal. And in their lands, he knew he could be targeted and ostracised. In fact, he was sure in the East, his status as a slave could be a used against him and where maybe, he would be forced back into servitude. Perhaps-and he cringed even as his mind raised the possibility-he could travel back to Esgaroth, to work in Laketown and stare at Erebor, his lost home. Maybe that was fitting, a lost dwarf living in the shadows of the lost kingdom, dying a little day by day as his soul withered and finally crumbled to ash. Or he could stay here, in this land of soft creatures, wedded to their comfort and food and flowers, a land of respectability and predictability where outsiders were viewed with suspicion and where maybe he could find a home. A land where his rescuer seemed desperate to prove that not everyone in life was cruel and prejudiced. A land where he would spend every day longing for the comfort of stone and missing his family and people.
But that would be the case everywhere. In truth, he couldn’t go back to any dwarf settlement because he would be recognised, no matter that he used a false name and kinship. Sooner or later, someone would put his face with the name of the shamed Prince and then… He closed his eyes. Being driven from the company of his own people, being spurned as devoid of honour would be as painful as the whips and brands they had used to subdue him. And they would know, just looking at him, that he was worthless. He wore no braids, for they had been severed when he was enslaved, handed to his sister as if he had died. The look of pain in her blue eyes had stabbed him worse than any knife but he had lifted his chin as her hand had closed around his hair and he had stolen one last look to fix in his memory as he had been hauled away. Deep in his chest was a desperate longing to replace the braid, to reclaim his identity as a dwarf of Durin’s line and proclaim that he was a free dwarrow…
Then he stared and felt his eyes unfocus. Before him, he could see the days after his capture, wracked by fear for his family’s safety and the terror that they had been taken despite his sacrifice. He had been searching for some way he could escape from his fate, clinging to a few shreds of hope, notwithstanding that he had surrendered, and he had done everything he could to escape, to break out and get away from the slavers. Given no choice but to offer himself for those he loved and had sworn to protect, the Prince had never intended to just accept his fate. Outnumbered and shackled, his chances of success had been slim but he was a dwarf and he was as stubborn as the mountains themselves. A son of the line of Durin, he had fought in Azanulbizar, survived Azanulbizar and he was determined these callow, cowardly Men would not cow him. No matter what he had done, he would not accept captivity and he would never cease seeking his freedom.
But when he finally escaped, making a break into the wilds as he had been transported, they had pursued him like prey for far longer than his worth as a slave would have justified and when they had recaptured him after a long and exhausting hunt, he had been chained and dragged back to their base, then hauled before the other caged slaves. And then they had punished him. Again and again and again until they had feared they would kill him before he bowed his head. So he was sold among the men, used as a smith for profit and treated worse than a diseased cur. He was moved every few months, beaten frequently and starved to deny him the energy to even try to escape. Except…he had still tried. For all his mantle of acquiescence, he had never surrendered and he had sworn that he would never accept his lot. They wouldn’t do anything to him that removed his value to them as a slave, as a blacksmith who could make good quality weapons and tools but they could brutalise him and as he passed from one master to another, his hope had waned. Halford had been far the worst, violent and cruel and vicious. And finally, starved and isolated and surrounded by comfortable, respectable people who clearly did not care that he was treated worse than a cur, that he was a slave amongst them, he had felt something give. Because there was no hope, not any more. He would never be accepted back among his folk, the Men would never let him go and his every escape attempt had only earned him worse and worse brutality.
But just as he had felt his resistance finally crack, the Hobbit had come to Bree. Treating him like a real person, asking inconvenient but humane questions, checking he was well when he had no right or reason to even care…and rekindling the last guttering flickers of his hope. And miraculously, he had rescued Thorin where no one else had cared or bothered. Suddenly, there was something more than years of shame and dishonour and pain. Suddenly…he was free.
“Couldn’t sleep?”
He started and half-turned, his eyes wide with a flash of anxiety that was instantaneously suppressed. He really hoped that Bilbo hadn’t seen the expression, cursing that he had been thinking over his years in slavery. Usually, he had the memories firmly buried but Bilbo’s silent approach had caught him unprepared. He was usually vigilant but Hobbits were very light-footed and Bilbo was on his home territory.
“Strange bed,” he mumbled. But Bilbo leaned forward, pushing a hot mug of tea into his hands, his eyes concerned.
“I’ve put some honey in there for you,” Bilbo told him, swirling his own mug thoughtfully. “Because you hardly look like you’ve slept at all.” Thorin ducked his head, waiting for something worse but there was nothing forthcoming. Taking a sip of the hot, sweetened liquid offered him a chance to recompose himself before he looked up.
“I’ve learned to sleep lightly,” he confessed slowly. Bilbo nodded and sipped his own tea, gazing down the road.
“Looks like it’s going to be a fine day,” he commented. “But still a little early to visit Musskin Snowmane. Maybe around second breakfast…or at least after First.” Thorin frowned.
“How many breakfasts do you have?” he asked slowly. Bilbo gave a wry smile.
“It didn’t really show it when we were travelling but Hobbits usually eat seven meals a day,” he explained, giving a nod to underline his words. “First breakfast, second breakfast, elevensies, luncheon, afternoon tea, dinner and supper. Though sometimes we skip supper or just have a light snack.” Thorin shook his head.
“How…could any creatures eat so many meals?” he murmured.
“Hobbits,” Bilbo admitted and patted his comfortably round middle. “I’m considered a bit of a lightweight, to be honest. But if we aren’t fed enough, we lose condition and sicken. It’s the way we are, I’m afraid. And don’t get me onto faunts-they eat about three times as much as a grown Hobbit…” Then he looked at the dwarf. “And you look as if you could do with a few more meals. if you don’t mind my comment.”
Thorin pressed his lips together and ducked his head to sip his tea. He was well aware he had been starved, that he was far thinner than he should be and though his stomach growled at the thought of breakfast, he was still wary enough not to let himself get hopeful that his situation would remain good. Something would ruin it…something soon.
“I would appreciate breakfast,” he conceded. “And then I would like to inspect the forge. If I am to stand any chance of earning enough money to repay you for your kindness…and to offer me a chance of a future.” Nodding seriously, Bilbo sipped his tea once more.
“I don’t need repaying, you silly dwarf,” he murmured. “But if it makes you feel better…” Thorin gave a firm nod.
“It is important,” he said slowly and then rose to his feet. “More than you appreciate, I guess. I will not fail you, Bilbo.” And with that, he walked back into Bag End.
-o0o-
There was a barely-coiled tension running through Thorin as he endured the morning rituals of cleaning up, breakfast and tidying up because he needed to see where he would be working. Of course, for Bilbo, it was just a routine morning and he bustled and fussed as much as he had the previous night. In deference to Thorin’s desire to get going, he made a packed second breakfast for them both of savoury cheese and bacon scones, sausage sandwiches and a flask of cinnamon coffee and and they left as soon as he thought the older hobbit would be up to receiving visitors. From what Thorin could understand, there was a strict social rule regarding when it was polite and appropriate to accept visitors and which visitors could visit when and that transgressing the rules wouldn’t garner him anything in the way of acceptance or assistance. It seemed in some ways, Hobbits were as rigid and complex in their social matters as dwarrow.
It was a beautiful morning, the sun beaming down through a cloudless cerulean sky, the smell of cut grass and roses wafting on the still-cool breeze. A cuckoo was singing in the distance, the two-tone call cutting through the trills of the songbirds and the distant faint chittering of the swooping martins in the sky, picking off the early insects. Bilbo was smiling, the sunlight warming his face and gilding his curls as they walked down the road towards the town. He gestured to the field to his right, the large solitary tree in full leaf.
“That’s the Party Field,” he explained. “Where we hold the Parties, really.” Thorin raised an eyebrow. “And the Midsummer Gathering, weddings, birthdays, Yule, Harvest…” He looked up at his companion and his hazel eyes were sparkling. “It has to be big because we have large families and extended families. Any party inevitably involves a large number of guests-and their families, random faunts, neighbours, aunts you don’t speak to, relations you haven’t seen for years, people you didn’t invite and several you never would…but no one would send them away unless they were really foul to you or another guest…because being a Hobbit is all about being welcoming, hospitable and enjoying good food, good drink and good company.” Thorin stared at the path ahead and scowled.
“No dwarf would dream of attending a celebration he was not invited to,” he said stiffly, imagining how his father, his family would sneer at such a breach of protocol. “And the dwarf found to commit such a dishonour would be removed without hesitation.” Bilbo studied his face with a thoughtful look and nodded.
“Your people are very serious, aren’t they?” he guessed and Thorin nodded slowly.
“Stone and rock are unforgiving,” he said. “Rules and laws must be obeyed or there will be chaos…or disaster.” Then he paused and a faint light softened his eyes. “But we are not without the ability to have fun or laugh or enjoy ourselves. Family is everything. Friends are treasured. Comrades are honoured. And most of us, when relaxed, are good company…” Then he sighed.
“And you think you can never have that again?” Bilbo asked but Thorin’s face had closed down.
“My people are unforgiving as well,” he said tonelessly. “We are made of stone and carry grudges and slights as long as the mountains stand.” He sighed. “No one can hold a grudge as well as a dwarf.”
“Though some of the Bolgers of Harbottle could give them a run for their money,” Bilbo mentioned, still smiling. “There are branches of that family that aren’t talking to one another for something about a goat that happened about five generations ago…” They walked a few yards as Thorin inspected Bilbo surreptitiously.
“Maybe…some of your people could give my people competition,” he said quietly as Bilbo nodded.
“Hobbits are stubborn as well-but being that intransigent is pretty unusual-which is why everyone is surprised,” Bilbo confirmed. “That and the fact the Shire runs on gossip. A family feud is just part of the landscape that you have to remember when drawing up guest lists for events…” He shrugged.
“It seems our people are not that different after all, Master Bilbo,” Thorin murmured, nodding as they reached the foot of the Hill. “Though we may seem close-lipped regarding our home and customs with outsiders, gossip is the lifeblood of society in any dwarvish community.” His lips twisted in a bitter smile. “Making my situation all the more hopeless. Because no one would ever forget and any newcomer would find me described to them as ‘that honorless coward who surrendered to slavery without fighting’. No one would explain why-or if they did, it would still sound like an act of cowardice, of dishonour. Those not there would rather my sister and her young sons were captured and dragged into slavery and that Dwalin and I died fighting for them…rather than one make a sacrifice so that the other four could go free and safe.” He stared stonily ahead for a few paces, breathing hard as the pushed back his anger. The hobbit could read that he was furious and he wouldn’t have blamed his friend if he had yelled or screamed at the hypocrisy and callousness of such gossips…but Thorin was determined to maintain his control. Outwardly, at least.
“I am sorry,” Bilbo said quietly. “That your people would view your actions in such a way. I cannot pretend to understand the way dwarfish honour works but if honour means that your people would rather than women and children were enslaved when it could be avoided, even by such a selfless sacrifice at high personal cost…there is something wrong with your concept of honour.”
“They would say I knew what I risked when I stepped forward,” Thorin said bleakly.
“And did you? Really?” Bilbo asked him directly. They had ground to a halt and Thorin turned to face him. “Because any brother and uncle here would not hesitate to step forward and do whatever was needed to rescue their kinswoman and faunts.”
“Faunts?”
“Children,” Bilbo told him impatiently. “Children are considered precious and are loved and indulged in Hobbit society-no matter of you have one or twelve…” Thorin choked.
“Twelve?” he exclaimed, eyes shocked.
“My mother was one of twelve,” Bilbo explained. “And though families that large are unusual, five or six are pretty commonplace…”
“While you are an only child,” Thorin noted. The Hobbit shrugged.
“Not for want of trying or wishing,” he conceded. “But I was all they got…” The wistful edge to his voice was almost instantaneously gone and Thorin almost wondered if he had imagined it-but recalling how Bilbo had shared the loss of his parents with him, he knew that the presence of a sibling would have eased the loneliness the young Hobbit had undoubtedly suffered after losing his parents so suddenly.
“My people are not blessed with such fecundity,” he revealed slowly. “Only a third of the population is female. Children are infrequent. One is a blessing. Two is a joy. Three…is exceptionally rare. More…are so infrequent that such mothers are afforded unusual status.”
“So you have a sister,” Bilbo murmured and then he saw Thorin wince. “And…you mentioned a brother?” The dwarf nodded.
“I am the eldest. It is my duty to protect them-as I always have,” he said stiffly, his face closing again. Bilbo sighed.
“You mother must have been honoured,” he offered gently but Thorin shook his head.
“She died shortly after birthing my sister, her youngest,” he said stiffly. “Dis does not recall her at all. Dwarf births are frequently difficult and hers was..unendurable. I never blamed anyone for her loss-though Frerin was not kind to his baby sister for many years. Her arrival deprived him of his status as ‘the baby’ and the privileged indulgence that granted him. And she was a girl, making her even more special. I was the oldest and the Heir.” He shrugged. “I apologise. You cannot be interested in my ramblings. Is it far to Master Snowmane’s home?”
“Only about five minutes’ walk,” Bilbo answered, resuming their amble. They walked for a few moments and then he glanced up at Thorin, who seemed to be brooding. “Are you alright with this?” he asked, his tone hesitant. Thorin glanced over at him. “I mean…ever since we met, I have been interfering in your life and I can’t help wondering if I snatched you from Bree only to put you in a forge here in the Shire. I-I don’t want you to feel you have to do anything. You know you can say no, don’t you?”
There was a pause and then Thorin nodded.
“I am aware of that fact,” he said.
“And you know there would be no repercussions?” Bilbo checked.
“I am aware of that fact,” Thorin repeated. Bilbo huffed in exasperation.
“I just don’t want you to feel demeaned by being a smith,” he said as Thorin stopped and stared at him. Bilbo sighed and ran his fingers through his hair. “I mean, I am certain you have far more skills than are required to mend ploughs and agricultural tools and maybe shoe the ponies and make knives and cooking equipment and…” He sighed again. “I don’t want you to feel you have to do this if you don’t want to…” Then he stopped and realised Thorin wasn’t walking beside him. He turned round and looked at the dwarf. “Thorin?”
“Building and creating are what my people were designed for by Mahal,” the dwarf told him incredulously and then he swallowed. “And yes, working for others, especially in the forges of men, is never a personally rewarding experience because Mahal’s children are always scorned, demeaned and cheated by Men but the act of creation, of crafting is still one that lifts a dwarf’s soul. And while it is not crafting great works or making beautiful jewellery or exceptional weapons, it is honest toil and better than much.” Then he shrugged. “What else can I offer? I could toil in your fields, though in truth I know little of agriculture, probably less than one of your faunts. I can use my strength to lift and carry, to perform menial tasks, I could offer to help protect your borders since I do possess some skill in fighting-though I have no weapons or armour now.” He shook his head. “Your offer was the best I have been given for…some time and your generosity matches the offer. I will tell you if you offend me or the work is not to my liking, Master Hobbit-on that you have my word.”
Bilbo smiled and gestured to a blue door to his left.
“We’re here,” he said as Thorin walked to his side. But the door opened as they knocked and a white-haired wizened Hobbit looked up at them and smiled.
“I’ve been expecting you,” he said cheerfully. “The Thain wrote me yesterday and to be honest, I was gladdened that someone is taking over the forge. It’s been empty too long and I would love to be able to work more but…” And then he held up his hands, the knuckles swollen and fingers twisted with arthritis. “But I am glad to see you, Master Dwarf! Someone skilled who loves metal is the perfect successor. I am just sorry I cannot work any more for I fancy I would learn much from you!”
And Thorin gave him a small smile, recognising the honest welcome in the words. Musskin Snowman insisted on taking them down and unlocking the place himself, the clumsiness due to his disease emphasising the truth in his words. And then he handed the key to Thorin. The dwarf walked in and sighed. There were cobwebs and dirt everywhere, though the tools were all wrapped carefully in an oiled rag to preserve them and the place had been ordered-maybe not to dwarf standards but ordered nonetheless-and there was the potential that he could work well in this place. He nodded.
“I have a list of suppliers and merchants if you wish,” Musskin offered. “I can bring them down later…”
“I would be most grateful,” Thorin told him, already calculating how to tidy and reorganise the place and the older smith nodded. “I’ll be back before lunch,” he called and hobbled out, quick for one his age as Bilbo looked over at his friend and grabbed a sandwich then left the basket for a midmorning snack.
“So will I,” he promised as Thorin looked up, pointing meaningfully at the basket. “I’ll bring you luncheon…” And he raised a finger as the dwarf opened his mouth to protest. “No self-respecting Hobbit would leave his guest without a midday meal, Thorin! Especially if he was planning to clean out the entire forge by himself… And eat that second breakfast as well!”
“And you called dwarves stubborn,” he commented. And then he met Bilbo’s eyes. “Thank you, Master Baggins. I am truly grateful.” Bilbo smiled and turned away, leaving Thorin to his work.
