Chapter Text
EIGHT:
Lying in his bed, Thorin stared at the ceiling and found his hand toying with the braid. The meal had been excellent and he felt replete and relaxed, completely clean and accepted by Bilbo. Conversation had been simple and easy, not touching on anything controversial and Thorin wondered if he made Bilbo uncomfortable. But Bilbo had given no sigh that he was shamed by association with the dwarf…though a treacherous voice reminded Thorin that the situation may change if word of his status as a former slave came out. Surely that would be enough to drive the Hobbits to ostracise him and Bilbo to cast him aside.
His hand curled into a fist and yanked hard on the braid as a groan thickened his throat. In Mahal’s name, what was wrong with him? It seemed his mind was conspiring against him and calculating ways to ensure his world came crashing down. But in his heart, Thorin knew that his peace was fragile, that his happiness would only be transient and that soon enough, the ephemeral hope he was feeling would be snatched away in the cruellest manner possible.
A jagged sigh shuddered through him once more. He was deluding himself if he believed that he would be accepted by the gentlefolk of the Shire but the calm confidence and welcome of his Hobbit friend was preventing him from relinquishing all hope that he couldn’t be tolerated. Bilbo had been determined to welcome him and support him…and Thorin was coming to realise that the Hobbit was gently stubborn in his determination to help him. And he couldn’t deny that having someone actually pleased to see him was a rare pleasure.
He toyed with the braid again. He had no beads, no sign of his allegiance or family or craft but he had claimed his identity as a dwarf…because that was patently obvious. He was a dwarf: even the Hobbits of the Shire could testify to that and though he had sacrificed the most important parts of himself for his kin, he had a right to act as a dwarf. He was not sharing the secrets of Mahal with outsiders, he was not teaching anyone Khuzdul or betraying secret knowledge: no, he was merely adopting the most basic external trappings of being a dwarf. By Mahal, he was still a dwarf and though others had decreed he was unworthy, there was no reason he could not still adhere to the customs and rights he had earned by his birth and the almost eighteen decades of his life. And who was there to protest? No one except Thorin himself…and he was the one deciding to take this step. So he closed his eyes and tried to relax.
His eyes snapped open and he realised it was morning. Sometime, in the midst of his mental self-flagellation, he had fallen into a dreamless and restful sleep, soothed by the silence and safety of the Hobbit’s home. But he couldn’t delay this morning, for he had tasks to complete and a newly-rejuvenated sense of purpose. Leaping up, he hastened to wash and dress in his cleaned and patched tunic and headed into the kitchen to find Bilbo already frying up bacon, eggs and bread for a hearty breakfast. It seemed that the Hobbit had already realised that Thorin, for all his privations, couldn’t handle the multiplicity of Hobbitish meals. A good breakfast, a meal at lunchtime and a solid dinner were sufficient and Bilbo was smiling as he dished up a groaning plate packed with enough meat to satisfy even the most suspicious dwarf. Offering a grateful smile in thanks, Thorin had tucked in, the little voice still warning him that this was all going to collapse sooner rather than later. But he cleared his plate, snatching small glances over at the Hobbit, who was sipping his tea and eating his own breakfast more slowly.
“Did you sleep well?” he asked as Thorin paused to sip his tea. He swallowed.
“Much better,” he admitted and then he sighed. Immediately, the Hobbit paused, his eyes focussing on the larger shape opposite him and tilting his head in thought. It was something that Thorin had noted on a couple of previous occasions: Bilbo was very sensitive to shifts in mood and thoughtful in how he proceeded. Perhaps Thorin should have felt insulted that the Hobbit felt the need to handle him cautiously but he found a tiny flicker of gratitude that the other treated him with the consideration due to any other sentient being.
“Thorin?” Bilbo asked quietly. He sipped his tea again. “Is there something worrying you?”
Many things-none of which you can do anything about, Thorin thought but laid down his knife and fork. Girding himself and pushing down his damnable pride-which was kicking him hard even as he tried to open his mouth-he nodded.
“I…I…” he began, looking as if he was swallowing a lemon. He took a shuddering breath. “I apologise, Master Baggins but I find…I have a problem.”
“Speak,” Bilbo invited him, his eyes serious. “I hope you know that I am your friend and that I want to help you get back on your feet.”
Thorin fisted his hands, the steel bands gleaming accusingly around his wrists.
“It’s about the Forge,” he ground out.
“Is there a problem?” Bilbo pressed.
There was a long silence and finally, Thorin nodded, his eyes glittering with shame.
“Thorin, I didn’t set you up to fail,” Bilbo told him urgently. “Tell me what I can do and I will do it. I know that you will do what you promised. I trust you-because everything you have told me and shown me about yourself has proven that you are worthy of trust.”
The simple words were like a blow and it was all Thorin could do not to show how much the words had scourged him. The truth was, of course, that Bilbo had nothing but what Thorin had told him…and Thorin could be a craven liar. Yet the Hobbit had made his determination and was according Thorin complete trust on almost no evidence. It only redoubled the dwarf’s absolute resolve to repay every penny that his saviour had spent.
“I need to buy metal and coal,” he admitted reluctantly.
“That is no issue,” Bilbo told him but Thorin raised a hand.
“It will be,” he sighed. “Master Baggins, I must ask that the goods are bought in your name…because no one from Ered Luin would deal with me. They would not sell to me or even acknowledge my existence.” Eyes widening, Bilbo chewed his lip.
“Then use my name, Thorin,” he said. “I can accept your deliveries or…”
“Or I may ask Master Snowmane,” Thorin murmured. “I am already far too deep in your debt…”
“This isn’t a ledger where we tally every last copper,” Bilbo retorted tartly, his eyes concerned. “Thorin…I am your friend and I will help you every way I can. So use my name and ensure you have what you need to make a go of the Forge. I will provide whatever you require.”
Exhaling in relief, Thorin turned back to his plate.
“Thank you,” he murmured, his voice gruff with embarrassment, shame stinging the last remnants of his pride. “You need not concern yourself, Master Baggins. I will repay you. On that I swear.” Smiling as he watched the dwarf clear his plate, the Hobbit gave a small smile. He had already realised that Thorin was a dwarf who valued his personal honour highly and his word was something he would stand by-even at the cost of his freedom.
“I know,” he said.
-o0o-
Bilbo took Thorin to the study and left him to write his letter in peace. The trust was gratifying and as the dwarf settled in the chair at the desk, he felt a flutter of apprehension along with shame. But he gathered up the quill and in clear though angular Westron, he wrote a request for the supplies he needed in the name of Master Bilbo Baggins. If he used dwarvish terms for the supplies and measures and was perhaps more specific than a non-dwarf, then he hoped it would be forgiven because he knew exactly what he required. Adding vague pleasantries, he signed in Bilbo’s name and folded the letter into an envelope. Then he reached for another sheet of paper and quietly wrote a price list of common requests, modifying the options in line with what Muzzy and Bilbo had told him about requirements of a smith in the Shire and what Muzzy had mentioned he had previously charged for his services. Of course, his prices were less than half of what Halford had been charging, because the man had been a disgrace and a swindler but he reckoned that he would still be clearing enough to pay the rent for the forge, cover supplies and start to save for necessities…and his debt. In fact, he was smiling as he finished the sheet and rested the pen down.
Bilbo was baking when he left, a smudge of flour on his cheek and his eyes sparkling with cheerfulness as he waved his guest goodbye. Thorin nodded, clutching his letter and price list and heading off down the hill at a good pace. Muzzy Snowmane intercepted him before he even reached the forge, his eyes twinkling as he took the letter and promised to post it before lunch while Thorin headed into the Forge. Fumbling to unlock the door, he methodically lit the forge and watched the flames start to burn, the familiar heat leaching into his body and briefly reminding him of the warmth that had permeated Erebor-before the dragon came. For a long moment, he stared into the flames and replayed that day in his memory, the flames reminding him of all those who had been lost in the attack before he shook himself. And then he turned to the tools and reached for a saw.
The steel bands on his wrists stared at him accusingly and as he stared at the metal, images flashed back, of his battered and bloody shape, beaten beyond endurance because it had been the only way that they had been able to subdue him to drag him for banding. Halford had done the deed, the man’s vicious face twisted in sadistic enjoyment as they had hauled him forward. For other slaves, they hammered the bands cold around the slave’s wrists but for Thorin, for the dwarf who had caused them so much effort, the metal had been hot. And though dwarves were hardy and resistant to burns, that protection was not unlimited and red glowing iron had exceeded it easily. He could still recall the hideous burning, the appalling pain as the metal had closed and the jerk on his arm as the smith had plunged his hand, wrist and the metal into the water to quench the metal. His knees had buckled and he had sagged, his head bowed as the steam had hissed while the metal cooled. Halford had kicked him then, sneering at his ‘weakness’ and laughing in his ashen face. And then they had dragged him up to band the other side. He had fought more desperately then to no avail…and the second time, he had screamed. But the band had gone on all the same, his skin burnt and scarred under the steel bands as they hauled him away to be sold for the first time.
Blinking, he rested his wrist in the anvil, gritted his teeth and started to saw at the band. It had to come off, had to be removed before he could even start to imagine he had any hope. So he sawed away, ignoring the fact that the tool was getting closer and closer to his own flesh…until he felt the give. Breath catching in his throat, he adjusted the saw and made a second cut before he was finally able to wrench the band off and fling it across the Forge, landing in the furthest corner. And finally, he looked at his naked wrist, staring at the deep, scarred red burn across the soft underside of his wrist and softly touching the puckered skin. Turning his hand over, the back was less scarred but branded to underscore his status and he cringed at the stark letters before his face hardened. Determined, he turned to his right wrist and began to saw away, eyes narrowed and concentrating solely on the mechanical action rather than any more thoughts. He clenched his fist as he sawed and his saw slipped, slicing the skin but he readjusted and completed the cut. And finally he was free.
He paused as he prised the band off his wrist and exhaled shakily. The slice was shallow and bled sluggishly and he tied a rag over the wound automatically, knowing that Bilbo would worry. Searching round the back, he located the scraps of leather than Muzzy had kept for binding and repairing handles and he methodically wound them over his wrists, concealing the scars and the brands. He missed his vambraces, missed the solidity of his armour, his chainmail and his leather. The clothes he wore were those he had left from his capture, the boots solid and comfortable, the leather breeches sturdy and tough and the tunic in Durin blue the last thing he had left reminding him of his birthright and his family.
Turning back to the Forge, he checked the flames and then gathered up the remains of his slave bands, dumping them in a crucible to melt over the flames. He wanted them gone and they represented resources he could use towards his future. And then he heard a rapping on the hatch. Frowning, he opened up-and found himself face to face with the appalling she-Hobbit, Lobelia. Today she was in a garish lemon yellow with lime green ribbons and a huge wide-brimmed scarlet hat with green ribbons. Her eyes glittered with annoyance.
“Tardy,” she condemned as he frowned.
“I have yet to actually open, Mistress Hobbit,” he commented, scowling at her.
“I hardly think you were granted the tenancy to sit on your rear and snooze away the day!” Lobelia sneered, dumping a pile of pans and implements on the counter. Thorin blinked. “I need this work doing.” The dwarf folded his arms across his chest and scowled at her.
“It depends what is required as to whether I can accommodate your request,’ he said slowly, his tone flat.
“I don’t see why…” she interrupted but he stared at her coldly.
“The Forge has been unoccupied for many months and is lacking raw materials,” he interrupted shortly. “While I am certain I can mend the dents and dings in your pans and sharpen the knives and shears, I am uncertain whether I possess the materials to repair that kettle.” He gestured to an ugly copper kettle that seemed to have a huge hole at the junction of the spout and body. “I am willing to undertake the tasks I can complete now or I am happy to wait until I can complete all your commissions at the same time, Mistress Hobbit.” Her eyes glittered in anger.
“I knew Cousin Bilbo would have chosen some defective lazy dwarf rather than a competent businessman,” she sneered as he stiffened. Maybe hearing such vile things about himself was getting so familiar the words barely hurt. If he persuaded himself hard enough… But hearing this vicious harpy attack Bilbo, who had offered him nothing but generosity and kindness stung Thorin and he found his temper rising. Deliberately, he lifted the pans and dumped them back in her arms.
“I presume you prefer to make the trip to Frogmorton,” he said tightly, watching her face redden in anger.
“Are you rejecting my work?’ she spat. He stared flatly at her.
“I believe you rejected my terms, Mistress Hobbit,” he reminded her shortly. “I can do no more. The Forge was not even open for business when you demanded I take your work. In that case, I can only presume you wish to utilise another smith.”
Lobelia stared at him, her mouth gaping soundlessly and face scarlet with a mixture of anger and embarrassment. She glanced round at the other hobbits who had paused to watch her.
“See?’ she spat, looking for support. “This nasty dwarf has refused to serve me!”
“It sounded like you insulted him, Lobelia,” Daisy Overbrook commented, her lips pursing as she stared at the older Hobbit. “He sounded like he was being honest about what he could do.”
“And you did hammer on the hatch until he opened up,” Periwinkle Redleaf added, nudging her friend. “Have you changed your mind?” Lobelia flattened her lips and scowled, then dumped her pans on the counter once more.
“Fine,” she spat. “Have the pans and knives done by teatime!” Thorin gestured to the price list, thumb-tacked to the wood.
“I would advise you confirm you are happy with the pricing schedule-to forestall any further...misunderstandings,” he told her as she glanced at the list-then shrieked.
“Have you seen this?” she spat. “Look at this? It’s outrageous! This dwarf is completely swindling us with his sky-high prices that…”
“That are almost exactly those you paid Master Snowmane,” Thorin told her tightly. “And half those charged in Bree. Again, if you find them too expensive, there are other options to service your metalwares…” Periwinkle peered over Lobelia’s shoulder.
“And these are cheaper than you pay in Frogmorton anyway,” she pointed out. Daisy burst out laughing.
“You know, Lobelia-if you want a discount, you actually have to be nice to people rather than insult the person you want to do you a favour!” she scoffed and nodded to the dwarf. “Do hurry up! Other people may want to speak to the smith as well!” Glaring at the women and then back at Thorin, Lobelia contented herself with a loud snort, grabbed her basket and stalked away, haranguing the elderly Hobbit who was selling a selection of delicious-looking breads in the Market Place adjacent to the Forge. The two female Hobbits watched her go with identical exasperated expressions on their faces.
“I apologise for Lobelia,” Periwinkle sighed, her blue eyes filled with exasperation. “She isn’t a typical Hobbit. She’s just…”
“Difficult,” Daisy finished. “Daisy Overbrook, Master Dwarf. I am aware that Lobelia knocked you up before you were open. Are you taking on work or should we come back another time?” Thorin took a deep breath and then shook his head.
“I would guess that I am now open,” he admitted, casting around and finding an old scrap of paper and the stub of a pencil, tucked behind a hammer. “How may I help?” The two Hobbits shared a look and then began to explain what they wanted. In the end, Thorin was commissioned to make them new cake tins and sets of knives which they explained they wanted before the Harvest Baking competition. Nodding without understanding, he carefully explained the probable delays due to lack of good quality metal but the women were happy to wait. After noting down the commissions-and Lobelia’s orders, along with agreed prices-Thorin finally turned to the cookware and began to sharpen the knives.
Bilbo dropped off a packed lunch of cheese, pickles, cold meats, seeded bread, a small flask of beer and a lemon curd tart and lingered while Thorin ate, glancing around the Forge and nibbling a cheese and tomato sandwich he had brought along.
“I heard Lobelia had been here again,” Bilbo commented, his eyes drifting over the solid shape of the dwarf. As expected, Thorin stiffened.
“She does seem to view me as a personal affront,” he said at length, his eyes drifting to her pans which were still awaiting fixing.
“I suspect the fact that you have anything to do with me may be the problem," Bilbo offered but slowly, Thorin shook his head.
“I believe she dislikes me on my own merits,” he replied dryly. “But she is availing herself of my services-however unwillingly.”
“She’s definitely doing that to annoy you,” Bilbo commented, taking another bite of his lunch. “I know you can take care of yourself but she is very conscious of her social standing. She’ll call you all sorts of names but the merest mention that her name could be bruised will have her backing off…for a while.”
“I will bear that in mind,” the dwarf said. Bilbo paused then fished in his basket, drawing out a small blue notebook, a neat leather-bound volume which was almost in Durin blue. Smiling, the Hobbit handed it over and watched the former slave open his mouth to decline the gift.
“I bought you this,” he said. “Well, you seem to like blue-and I hoped it would be useful to keep track of orders or stock or whatever…” He blushed slightly. “Um…well, I hope it's useful anyway…” His hand closed on the book-something small and simple and unexpected-and he nodded.
“Thank you,” he said, his voice gruffer than normal. His reward was Bilbo’s brilliant smile.
After Bilbo had gone, claiming it was laundry day as well, Thorin turned back to the pans and the handful of other repairs he had picked up, carefully noting the work in the book before he forgot. Then he turned back to the work and made sure that he completed everything to a high standard-not that he would ever give less than his best-but the trust shown in him by Bilbo and the other Hobbitwives made him want to prove Lobelia’s cruel words wrong.
But once he had finished the tasks for the day, he turned to the molten iron, some which he had poured into simple moulds, making simple clasps. It was very basic metalwork that all dwarrow were taught when they were small dwarflings since every dwarf needed to be able to make his own beads-and those for his One. And while he had no honour or name any more, he was a dwarf and strangely, the words of Lobelia made him more determined than ever to reclaim what he could of his identity. So he made four simple clasps, inscribed only with the symbol of Erebor and fastened two of them to his braid with a shaking hand. Something inside him was screaming at him, reminding him that he had given it up for his family and he had no right any longer to call himself a dwarf. But he stared at his naked wrists, bound in scraps of leather to conceal his shameful brands and clipped the metal around his hair.
I am Thorin son of Thrain, son of Thror, called Oakenshield of the line of Durin. I am the Heir to Erebor and the exiled Erebor dwarrow in Ered Luin. And Mahal forgive me, I will not let them take away my knowledge of myself. My family and people may have disowned me but I have been welcomed here and I will do whatever I need to stay here and repay Bilbo. And maybe…feel like I have a home once more.
Then he heard the sound of Lobelia’s screech across the market and he sighed, then turned back to his work.
