Chapter Text
ELEVEN:
The first Bilbo knew that there was a problem was when there was a hammering on the door, jolting him from scanning the columns of accounts that he had to check now the rents had come in. It was a job he had been putting off because it was dull and required him to set aside anything else, but with Thorin working hard in the Forge and the pantry well stocked, he finally had no excuses. Until the hammering repeated.
Crossly, he scrambled up and emerged from his study, pattering along the hallway until he reached the door and heard the hammering again.
“I’m here!” he announced as he opened the door, his tone exasperated. Surely nothing could be that urgent…and then he started as he faced a panting and red-faced Drogo.
“Come quickly!” his cousin gasped. “It’s Thorin. There’s trouble…” Eyes wide, Bilbo grabbed his coat from the pegs and slammed the door as he ran out after his cousin, not even stopping to close the gate as they sprinted, helter-skelter, down the Hill and directly to the market. Bilbo glanced at his cousin: Drogo was a solid sort and not prone to any sort of hyperbole, a Baggins to the core…so if he was worried, whatever was happening had to be seriously bad news. He peered ahead an all he could see was a crowd-and horses.
He frowned. Horses? That implied big people…and if there were Men here in the market, that could only mean… Realisation hit him at the same time as his ears heard the clang of metal on metal and the roars of combat. He glanced to Drogo.
“Has someone gone for the Sheriffs?” he asked and Drogo nodded.
“Fosco was with me and he ran for them as I came for you,” he panted as Bilbo nodded and ran ahead, cursing the crowd of Hobbits who were blocking the way and enjoying the show without contributing anything to the scene going on. Furious, he elbowed his way through, earning himself mutters and dirty looks from his neighbours-though these died away when they caught the look on his face. But even his wildest imaginings did not meet the sight that met him as he burst through the line.
Thorin was fighting with a sword-one he had forged for himself, clearly since it looked like nothing he had ever seen in the Shire-his back to the wall of the Forge and facing a dozen Men who were crowding him. All were armed and closing in. Thorin was roaring curses in Khuzdul, the dwarfish language that Bilbo didn’t understand but which sounded incredibly appropriate for the situation. And the Hobbits were watching, some cheering the combat on while Thorin seemed to be fighting for his life. Incredulous, Bilbo turned to the Hobbit next to him-Daddy Proudfoot.
“What’s happening?” he asked, his face shocked as the older Hobbit shuffled his feet and pushed his straw hat back on his greying curls.
“Ah, there you are, Mister Bilbo,” he said cheerily. “I saw Drogo take off as if Lobelia was after him. Well, your dwarf friend was just minding his own business mending me best shovel-I’d bent it trying to lever up some invading roots from Buddleia Greenthumb’s garden, curse her cherry trees!-when these Men rode up. Looking all het up they were, not minding the way. I saw three faunts almost get ridden down without so much as a by-your-leave or apology and they headed straight for the Forge, yelling and drawing their weapons. The dwarf looked up at them-looked like he’d seen a ghost, he did, and slammed the hatch. They surrounded the Forge and started trying to break in, yelling a storm and calling him a slave…” The older Hobbit had the grace to look embarrassed as he said the words.
“He’s not. The Shire doesn’t condone slavery and he was freed,” Bilbo ground out through gritted teeth, not caring how his words were taken. He was looking around for something to use as a weapon. “Why are you all watching?”
“They’re big folk!” Daddy Proudfoot told him simply. “What hope do we have against the likes of them?”
“We have numbers!” Bilbo told him angrily. “Yavanna! These men rode in to attack a free man in the market in Hobbiton! Should we be tolerating this? Accepting this? Just watching?”
“It’s not our business!” Daddy Proudfoot told him. “Though the dwarf has been very helpful to everyone. Never stints to assist when asked, no matter what else he has to do. He’s not a bad sort. But he’s a warrior…”
“And hopelessly outnumbered,” Bilbo growled, finding a suitable stone.
“When they were on the brink of breaking in, he erupted through the hatch, that sword in hand and took them on. He’s wounded three and two have had to drop back. Someone’s going to get killed.”
“If they had wanted him dead, they would have burnt the Forge down and killed him as he tried to escape,” Bilbo realised. “They want him.” Then he saw Thorin take a step forward to block a vicious attack to his right side-and in doing so, he exposed his left. A Man lurched forward, his sword raised-and Bilbo threw the rock, the aim true. The impact slammed into the Man’s temple and he dropped immediately. Two of the men turned to face the crowd, swords levelled at the Hobbits.
“STAY BACK!” they snarled. “This is none of your business.”
The mood in the crowd darkened and more hands snatched rocks. Daddy Proudfoot glanced over and saw Hamfast Gamgee and Indigo Bockleby panting up with their pitchforks, their normally amiable faces twisted in anger. And the Sheriffs were running forward as well. But behind them, Bilbo saw a Man get a lucky hit on Thorin’s sword-arm and as he ducked, another attacked slammed the pommel of his sword on the back of Thorin’s head-and then twice more. Finally, the dwarf fell.
“Cease and desist!” Grumpy Oldwood shouted. He was Sergeant of the Sheriffs and had six Hobbits behind him-and a crowd. Though their truncheons were hardly the weapons of a ferocious defence force and were unlikely to deter these armed and dangerous invaders. After all, mild drunkenness and scrumping were the only real Shire crimes… “Lower your weapons! You are in the Shire and have no right to attack another resident!” The Man facing him gave a sneer.
“This slave?’ he spat. “He’s not a resident…”
“He’s a free man!” Bilbo shouted, walking forward, a stone in his hand. The Men finished binding Thorin with a chain around his neck but hauled an arm forward. Carelessly, they sliced through the bindings he had adopted over his wrists and revealed the ugly brands.
SLAVE.
Bilbo sighed.
“That means nothing because…” He walked into the Forge and found the paper Thorin carried with him. He demonstrated it to the Men. “He’s been freed.”
The first Man snatched it from Bilbo and ripped it to shreds, shoving the Hobbit back. There were angry mutters from the crowd now and the Hobbits were starting to inch forward. More missiles were grasped and the Sheriffs were starting to look concerned. A Mob of Hobbits was rare but they could be ferocious if roused. The Men levelled their swords at the Hobbits, the tip of one hovering mere inches from Bilbo’s throat.
“These say he isn’t,” the leader sneered as his fellows finished roping Thorin’s arms behind his back. Bilbo stared at his friend in shock. Thorin’s face was pallid, blood smeared over his forehead and clotting in his hair from the blows they had used to finally subdue him. Eight of the dozen men were wounded, four of them seriously but the remaining attackers looked very dangerous and prepared to use their blades on the crowd.
“You understand this land is protected by Lord Elrond of Imladris and the Rangers?” Sergeant Oldwood asked them. “You will be hunted.”
“For retrieving our property?” the Man sneered.
“He was bought by Bilbo there and freed!” Drogo shouted, his fists clenched. He had met Thorin and dined with him multiple times: though taciturn, the dwarf had been a decent sort and worked hard. “You have invaded the Shire bearing arms and attacked a resident of Hobbiton. You are threatening our people. It will not be tolerated!” The Man lurched forward and the Sheriffs backed up a step. The others were already mounting, a glance showing Thorin had been thrown across the front of a horse like so much luggage.
“Hand him over!” Bilbo insisted. “By your perverse logic, he’s mine. I paid good money for him. If he is a slave as you claim, he is mine.”
“And yet we’re taking him,” the Man scoffed, flinging himself into the saddle. “Another wants him.” He looked around. “Nice place this. We should visit more often.” And with that, he kicked his mount and the horse accelerated at the Sheriffs. They dived out of the way as the raiders galloped off towards the East Road, leaving the market place in shambles. The Sheriffs stared at Bilbo and Drogo.
“Nothing to see here,” Grumpy announced, trying to disperse the crowd. He eyes trailed over to Bilbo who was shocked, hearing the murmurs of the crowd. There was shock and anger there as well-but mixed in was a definite air of it being “outsiders’ problems” and some rather offensive murmurs that maybe the slave was back where he belonged. It made his blood boil-not only because Thorin had done nothing wrong and had saved eight lives in the fire, a fact conveniently forgotten though it was only a couple of weeks earlier. No it was because his insular and easygoing people had missed the most serious point.
There had been an armed incursion in the Shire and a free being had been kidnapped and taken by slavers. And it was a premeditated and vicious attack, with no regard for the laws of the Shire or the protection that traditionally shielded the Shire from attacks or the officers of the law who had confronted them. It was a serious situation that threatened them all-especially in light of the last words the men had threatened them with.
“Send for the Thain,” Bilbo ordered him. “This is something that cannot be tolerated. We are all in danger.” The Sergeant nodded, giving a stern look.
“I know-and I think he’s already on his way. The men came in through the West of the Shire and I think word got to Tuckborough before they arrived here…” Drogo walked to Bilbo’s side.
“You need to speak to the Thain, don’t you?” he said as the crowd finally started to disperse. Bilbo nodded.
“No one should be kidnapped from somewhere they have been promised safety,” he said grimly. “Isengrim needs to know. Because those men have checked out the Hobbit defences-and found them lacking. Those men are slavers…and if they think they can get away with raiding us, then none of us is safe.”
-o0o-
Bilbo had returned to Bag End only to grab his pack, change his coat and close up the smial before heading out to go to meet the Thain. There was anger, boiling in his chest in a manner that was completely unfamiliar. He assumed it was the Tookish blood in him that was stirred by the events of the afternoon, angered beyond reason by the blatant attack and the complete sneering disregard for the laws of the Shire. And Thorin…Thorin who had come with Bilbo on the promise of safety and a chance to work and earn his way and who had been failed by the Shire. Thorin who had been attacked with no one coming to his defence and who had been beaten unconscious and kidnapped. The image of his pallid face, with blood smeared over his strong features, had made Bilbo feel sick with worry and the memory of his body slung over the horse like a pack made him shudder.
He closed his eyes. The men had been single-minded in their pursuit of Thorin and the final words had given him the clue that this was anything over than a simple matter.
Another wants him.
The fears that had washed over him during the journey back from Bree, when Halford and his friends had accosted them and demanded Thorin’s whereabouts, crashed back in full force. Bilbo had been troubled then by their determination to recapture a dwarf that had been sold legally. Surely if there had been an issue, Halford would have refused to sell. Except he hadn’t…but then they had come anyway,
Almost as if Halford had realised his mistake. And a quibble about price hadn’t been the real reason. No…something more profound had driven him to recruit his friends to come after the dwarf. Or more likely, someone. Powerful, vengeful…and angry.
And Bilbo was sure, now he reran the memory in his mind, that the men had been the same ones who had accosted them on the road. They had believed their tale then…but something had changed. They had tracked Thorin to the Shire-and how had word gotten out?-and then they had chosen to disregard the protections that had warned them off on the road.
Another wants him.
And whoever that person may be…was determined to retrieve Thorin…by whatever means necessary. Even through invasion, force and maybe murder.
His brow lowering, Bilbo wrenched open the door and walked down the path towards his gate…and then he stopped. For coming up the hill was a cart, bearing two shapes. The first was easy to recognise, for Isengrim was in his finest golden waistcoat and a magnificent red brocade jacket with the seal of the Tooks hanging round his neck on a thick red and gold ribbon, sitting on the front board next to the other shape. Bilbo paused and then looked at the other: a tall shape, all in rather ratty grey robes topped by a slightly ravaged tall pointed grey hat. Ageless and wise blue eyes looked over a large nose and a lined face, the wild beard somehow in keeping with the person’s appearance. A gnarled staff was jammed beside him.
“Gandalf,” Bilbo whispered, memories of his childhood washing over him. His mother laughing and smiling with the shape of the wizard, the friend of his grandfather, the Old Took, who brought such amazing fireworks to the Midsummer Party in the Shire… “GANDALF!”
The wizard started and his eyes focussed on the shape of the Hobbit standing at his gate. A smile lifted his lips.
“Well I’m blessed,” he exclaimed. “Bilbo Baggins! Just the person I was coming to see!”
“The person we both were…” Isengrim amended, his bushy brows knotted. “Let’s step inside Bag End, nephew. I think we have much to discuss.” Bilbo nodded.
“We certainly have,” he said and gestured. “After you…”
Then next few minutes were taken up with Bilbo shedding his pack and coat and brewing a nice pot of tea, finding a large glass of red wine for Gandalf and setting up a plate of lemon biscuits, scones with jam and clotted cream, delicate strawberry tarts and cinnamon pastries. Finally, he walked into the parlour, served his guests and sat anxiously in his father’s old chair, a cup of tea clenched in his hands for want of something to do. But he barely sipped the warm liquid as he inspected his guests. Isengrim polished off a strawberry tart and sighed in delight.
“That was worthy of Mother,” he sighed and then caught the edge of Bilbo’s urgent expression. “But you are right to look concerned, nephew. We have a problem.”
“That’s an understatement,” Bilbo sighed and sipped his tea.
“Perhaps you could start by telling us what actually happened,” Isengrim invited him. There was a pause and Bilbo gave a sigh. He was acutely aware of Gandalf’s eyes, observing his every movement and seeming to read his soul. But he opened his mouth and gave a concise but suitably detailed account of the fight from when Drogo hammered on his door. Finally, he sat back, sipping his tea from shaking hands, delayed shock setting in. Isengrim’s face was like thunder and Gandalf’s brows were knotted in consternation.
“This is grave news,” the wizard commented, lighting his pipe and taking a long puff.
“Indeed,” Isengrim said, worrying his own pipe. His eyes turned to Bilbo. “I was concerned that the dwarf would bring trouble-but I never imagined this would ensue.”
“Are you a threat, Thorin? Are you a danger to the Shire-and my nephew?”
“I am bad luck.”
“Nor did I,” Bilbo conceded, his voice still shaky. He was cursing himself for suddenly being overwhelmed but he was aware, as he relived the confrontation, just how dangerous it had been, something he had studiously ignored amid the anger of seeing his friend attacked in the market of Hobbiton and that no one was helping him. “But I vouched for him. You granted him leave to stay-and he should have been accorded the protection of the Baggins name…but they attacked him in broad daylight and kidnapped him.”
“And that is the crux of the matter,” Gandalf said gravely. “These men cared nothing for the protections the Shire is afforded and ran roughshod over your laws. They kidnapped a dwarf in broad daylight and only Bilbo here made any move to fight back…”
“It is not our concern,” Isengrim said automatically-and then winced at the glares he earned from the two others.
“Of course it is your concern!” Gandalf growled, his voice suddenly grim. “These men rode in here, found no real resistance-the dwarf is a far better fighter than you and he was taken down by a dozen men. Nice place this-we should visit more often? That is a threat if ever I heard one!” The Thain sagged, suddenly looking all of his years.
“If they turn their eyes on us, what can we do, Gandalf?” he murmured. “We are no warriors. We cannot hold back deliberate incursions from Men. And if they see us as an easy target, what’s to stop them raiding our borders, taking our young who like to push the boundaries, to visit the Old Forest or travel to Bree or…”
“The Bounders will have to be armed and trained more-the Rangers can help,” the wizard murmured, puffing up a storm and staring at the older Hobbit. “The young must be warned. But the Men must be warned off as well and relearn that attacking the Shire carries a high price…”
“Yet the dwarf was not a Hobbit,” Isengrim murmured. “The Heads of Families won’t be happy at such measures on behalf of a transient!”
“Thorin was no transient!” Bilbo put in hotly, regaining his courage. “He was working honestly to repay me-his desire not any want of mine!-and regain his honour…” Suddenly, Gandalf whipped round and grasped Bilbo’s shoulder, staring deep into the younger Hobbit’s eyes.
“Thorin?” he asked urgently. “You said his name was Thorin. Just Thorin?” Bilbo frowned and shook his head.
“Thorin Oakenshield,” he revealed and Gandalf exhaled with what was relief, closing his eyes and sagging.
“He’s alive,” he murmured. “Thank the Valar.” Both Hobbits stared at him in surprise, wondering what the underlying story was. Clearly they were unaware of his true identity-the identity that Thorin had been notably reticent in sharing with his saviour and which seemed to cause him significant pain.
“You know him, Gandalf?” Bilbo asked as the old wizard nodded.
“Of course I do,” he said easily. “Thorin Oakenshield is the elder son of Thrain, King of the dwarves of Ered Luin and descendent of the Line of Durin.” Bilbo blinked.
“He’s a Prince?” he repeated.
“The Crown Prince,” Gandalf smiled and then his face fell. “Or he was. Three years ago, he vanished after his family was attacked on the road. The rumour was that he was taken as a slave, that he surrendered to save his family from the same fate. And in doing so, he surrendered his honour, his family name, his future. And there are those who seem to be determined to ensure that there is no possibility that he could ever return.”
“Gandalf?” Isengrim murmured, frowning. “What is going on?”
“Thorin Oakenshield is a remarkable dwarf, a warrior of courage and honour and leadership. A Prince who would spend the last drop of his blood to protect his family, his people and his friends. But he is also honest and honourable and would not tolerate political manoeuvring that would disadvantage his people to enrich the pockets of a few. And that attitude earns enemies.” Gandalf’s words were thoughtful.
“Even if you are a Prince?” Bilbo’s voice was incredulous. But it was Isengrim who answered.
“Especially if you are a Prince-or a hereditary ruler,” he said slowly. “In the Shire, we rule by consent, and though the Thain is the head of the most powerful family, we are first among equals, with duties and no real power. A hereditary ruler, especially in dwarf society, has absolute power, is accorded respect by right of birth, irrespective of character of wisdom. So bad rulers can occur and have to be endured…but that earns enemies.”
“And you are right,” Gandalf explained, his eyes pensive and face grieved. “Thorin’s people were originally from the Lonely Mountain, Erebor-far to the East. Erebor was the most powerful Kingdom on Middle Earth, the last of the great dwarf kingdoms. Powerful, rich and secure, their great wealth came from the rivers of gold running through the green rock of the mountain and the gemstones that flowed from the rocks. Their craft was cunning and their artistry unmatched. Thror was King Under The Mountain, secure in his line through his son, Thrain and his grandson Thorin. But Thror’s love of gold became too strong and he hoarded the riches in the treasury, as gold sickness overwhelmed his mind. But that much gold is a grave danger and Thror’s madness not only alienated his neighbours, it summoned a dragon, a fire drake from the north. Smaug. The dragon destroyed the city of Dale that sat at the gates of Erebor and then smashed into the mountain, slaying many and overwhelming the resistance. The dwarves had no option but to flee, driven from their home with only what they could carry and for most, only what they stood in.”
“That’s dreadful,” Bilbo said, his mind supplying the images.
“Thror was mad and Thrain was shattered by the reversal so the burden of leadership fell to Thorin, only a young Prince at the time,” Gandalf revealed. “He was forced to make the hard decisions, leading his people, rationing, allowing those who had kin in other dwarvish settlements to seek sanctuary. And taking the blame for every shortage and hardship when they received no aid or help from anyone. Wandering, starving, beset on all sides, the dwarves did not prosper. Thorin worked wherever he could, earning coin and food to help his people and his family and even when his father and grandfather recovered some of their wits, he was still burdened with duty and responsibility way beyond his years. But he endured and he protected his sister and brother from the cruelties of their road.
Yet Thror had decided that the scattered people should seek another home and his eye fell on Moria, the ancient and first home of Durin’s line. The attack was madness, of course, for Orcs had taken Moria, led by Azog the Defiler, a huge albino Gundabad Orc. Thror was determined and threw everything he had at it. Yet Azog had sworn to exterminate the Line of Durin and he began by beheading the King. Thrain was broken by the sight and fled leaving Thorin to rally the line. He faced Azog alone. His armour rent and weapons scattered, he had nothing but an oaken branch to protect himself. Yet he endured and rallied, cutting off Azog’s arm and driving him back. Thorin rallied the troops and against all reason, the battle was won and the orcs driven back. Yet there was no celebration for the victory for the cost had been devastating. The dead numbered beyond the count of grief and the already diminished people of Erebor were rendered critically vulnerable. Thrain was lost to madness, a state he lingered in for half a year, tended by Thorin’s younger brother Frerin. His sister’s husband was killed, leaving her with two tiny sons. And Thorin was once again forced to lead. So he led them to the Blue Mountains, to areas uninhabited by the dwarrow already living in that areas due to instability and limited resources. The local dwarves did not welcome their kin, making life even harder for the refugees and their Prince but Thorin managed to broker an accord and though the mines were poor, they made a life there.
Yet when Thrain recovered, there was no gratitude to his Heir. He was bitter and angry at the diminution of their fortunes and listened to his Lords, men who were loathed by Thorin as greedy and grasping, who sought to maintain their ease while most suffered and starved. Thorin worked hard to provide, yet the Lords expected to be supported, even though a Prince was willing to offer his sweat and toil to provide for his family. The dwarves traded because they had to, yet attitudes towards outsiders were sour and hostile. Thrain remained in the mountain and used his Heir as his emissary to other lands…not perhaps the most obvious of choices…”
Bilbo smiled. “Thorin isn’t the most…chatty of people,” he admitted. “And though it could be due to what he’s suffered since, I get the strongest feeling that is who he is…”
“And you would be right,” Gandalf said. Isengrim leaned forward.
“So you think that a scheme against this dwarf Prince is why he was attacked, why he was enslaved?” he asked, his lips pulled back in disgust at the idea. Hobbits gossiped and there were grudges and family feuds but no one would ever consider disposing of a rival in such a brutal and callous manner.
“It is certainly a possibility-especially given the brutal indifference to his fate,” the wizard said pensively. “And the determination of those to retrieve him.”
“But the Men they used…will come back?” Isengrim asked. Gandalf inspected him with sorrow and gave a slow nod.
“I fear they will,” he said in a low voice. “These men are ruthless and see sentient life as nothing but a commodity.” He glanced over to Bilbo. “So we have to go after Thorin. We have to get him back…and stop those Men before they hand him over to whoever wants him dead.”
