Actions

Work Header

Blood and Iron

Chapter 20: Chapter Twenty

Chapter Text

TWENTY.

 

Something had changed. It wasn’t obvious because Bilbo was always a perfect host, caring for his guests as if he was their mother rather than a Hobbit making room on his smial and his life for a quartet of exiled dwarrow, but Thorin knew. 

 

After the Thain had given the dwarrow his blessing to remain with the conditions he had set out, Thorin had finally felt a tiny flicker of hope and relief run through him, as if a crushing weight had been lifted very slightly from his shoulders and the fear that they would be run from the Shire without provisions, weapons or hope of a destination was pushed aside…for now. Thorin was under no illusion that he was safe but for the moment, life seemed much less precarious than it had been. Naturally, his family had seen his relief and had responded, embracing him and welcoming back into their embrace as if they were back in Ered Luin once more, back in the rooms that Thorin had visited so often that he almost lived there. The boys had grown up so much in only three years and they had endless tales of their exploits and of the mischief they had gotten up to. And listening to them excitedly sharing their tales, interrupting each other and finishing each other’s sentences, he had felt the warmth of home blossom in his chest once more. He had smiled, laughed and shaken his head in disbelief that these two young dwarrow could really cause so much chaos-but the pained look in Dis’s eyes confirmed that they may exaggerate a little but that the substance of their stories was true. And in all honesty, he couldn't get enough of it, couldn’t wait to spend time with the boys who were in all honesty more sons than nephews. 

 

They had settled rapidly into a new routine, despite his lingering wounds from his kidnapping. In the morning they rose, breakfasted and headed down to the forge to start work on whatever commissions they had for the day. Kili would usually man the hatch, dealing cheerfully with the Hobbits, most of whom seemed to have adopted him as in need of serious mothering while Thorin and Fili did the hard work. And once he was free, Kili joined them or ran errands or whatever the others wished him to do. His skills at blacksmithing were definitely inferior to theirs but he was a dwarf and willing to do whatever he had to. But he was also far better at negotiating in the Market and could charm any faunt who came to have a stare at the strange dwarven smiths. Sometimes, Bilbo would come along and bring food for lunch but once he came and found them eating pasties from the Market, he had stopped coming.

 

Once the work was done, they headed to the low meadow with Dis joining them for weapons practice. The boys and Dis had brought their own weapons from Ered Luin while Thorin had made himself a sword among the first few things he had forged-carefully adding the costs of material to the debt he owed Bilbo, for he could not, in good conscience, expect the Hobbit to provide him with that on top of the other generosities that he had shown Thorin. And sparring with the boys, correcting their technique and honing his own skills against his sister-herself a vicious and relentless fighter-made him imagine that he was almost back home. But as he and Dis parted, both breathing hard after an especially vigorous battle, she had fixed him with her piercing gaze.

 

“Your Hobbit doesn’t like us,” she said without preamble. Catching his breath and flicking his hair off his face, he stared at her.

 

“What makes you say that?” he asked. She snorted and sheathed her sword.

 

“The way he looks,” she commented. “He serves breakfast and then retreats, listening to us. He scuttles around like a servant, snooping. He makes dinner and never says a word. He leaves the house without explanation and returns without a word. He is watching us, brother and though he wrote to me to alert me to your continued survival…I don’t know what to make of him. His welcome seems very different to the way he behaves now.”

 

Every instinct was screaming for Thorin to leap in and defend his friend…but the truth was that he had noticed something off in Bilbo’s behaviour as well. He could understand that Dis would be suspicious of anyone she didn’t know, given that she was fresh from the political pressure cooker of Ered Luin, and her judgement was usually swift and harsh. Yet he held his tongue because he had been away from the cut and thrust of dwarven politics for three years-and his judgement had never been the best. Quick to anger, self-assured and brave, he was an archetypal dwarrow Prince and subtlety was not his strong suit. Balin had spent decades telling him that his diplomatic skills were minuscule at best and needed work and that above all, he should think before speaking. It seemed that all it took was three years of slavery, abuse and cruelty to get that last lesson into his rock-hard skull. So he bowed his head and walked up the hill, deep in thought as his nephews continued their discussion of which of them was more awesome at swordsmanship.

 

Bilbo was cooking when they returned and Thorin waved the boys to wash up while Dis returned to her rooms to prepare for dinner as he walked into the kitchen. Bilbo glanced up and there was a vaguely relieved smile on his familiar face as he looked up from where he was peering into the oven.

 

“I’ve made a mutton cobbler,” he said. “With creamy mash and root vegetables. Will that be alright?” Thorin nodded.

 

“Your food is always delectable, Master Baggins,” he said, inspecting the young Hobbit facing him. Bilbo had never given him any reason to doubt him-so why should he allow Dis’s words to affect him so much? Why should he trust the impressions of a few days over the kindness and generosity of weeks in Bag End? But it was so tempting to rely on his family, to want to protect them from a potential threat, from the faceless villain who had condemned Thorin to life in chains. Unconsciously, he wrapped a hand round his wrist, the brand and burns concealed once more under the leather straps he had salvaged. Bilbo closed the oven and sat back on his heels.

 

"Is something wrong?” he asked seriously, his eyes concerned. “I can see it in your face, Thorin. I hope you know you can trust me…” Unbidden, Thorin grabbed a chair from the kitchen table and sat down, his shoulders slumped.

 

“We will not impose on you any longer than we need,” he said flatly. “As soon as I have a few more coins, we will find somewhere else to stay.”

 

Unsure what to say, Bilbo blinked, his eyes widening in what could only be hurt before he composed himself. If he hadn’t been looking for it, Thorin would have missed the brief expression and the immediate erection of the calm facade. 

 

“There’s no need for that,” he said quickly. ‘I said you were welcome here as long as you wanted-and I meant it.”

 

“And my kin?”

 

“My offer extended to you all-as Isengrim said,” Bilbo told him quickly. “I don’t mind you being here at all. I…” And then he closed his mouth and clambered to his feet, wiping down the kitchen surfaces unnecessarily. But Thorin shook his head.

 

“Clearly our presence here displeases you,” he said firmly. “Because since they arrived, your behaviour has completely changed.” Bilbo glanced up.

 

“Oh?”

 

“My sister has spotted it-and I have noticed as well, Master Baggins,” the dwarf pressed on. Bilbo stiffened and gave an exasperated exhale.

 

“Bilbo,” he said tightly. “My name is Bilbo. I have asked you as my friend to call me that. And you did. You even went as far as to name me your friend when Lobelia visited the forge.” He sighed. “I might have guessed it wouldn’t last.” Now Thorin was frowning.

 

“Speak plainly,” he said, more harshly than he had intended. Bilbo’s shoulders slumped.

 

“Having seen my awful relatives at their worst, seen how they tried to turn half the town against you, is it any wonder you decide to spend all your time with your family?” Bilbo said and then gave a small smile. “Not that I blame you. You missed them so much. It must be nice to catch up, to share all those times you missed, to speak your own language again…”

 

Thorin stared at him as he scuttled off in the direction of the pantry and then covered his face with his hands. He had been speaking Khuzdul to Dis and to the boys. It was instinct, familiarity, the ability to express himself so much more precisely and honestly than in Westron. His grandfather and father had always insisted that they speak the secret language in the family home when he knew many families used Westron in all aspects of their lives. Some of the Broadbeams of Ered Luin didn’t speak any Khuzdul at all but the Longbeard Royalty, the descendants of Durin the Deathless, were scrupulous in maintaining their mastery of their ancestral tongue.

 

And Bilbo couldn’t speak or understand Khuzdul. Thorin may have mentioned the language was secret and that outsiders were not permitted to learn or understand it. The language had been gifted to them by Mahal himself and to share it with a non-dwarrow was unthinkable…especially to the more conservative of Lords and Scribes among his people. Abruptly, Thorin rose and followed Bilbo, finding him pulling a fresh loaf from the bread bin in the cool corner of the pantry. In fact, the Hobbit jumped as Thorin entered the space and backed up a pace, his face determinedly amiable though his eyes looked alarmed.

 

“Master Baggins…Bilbo…” Thorin began and took a deep breath, advancing until he was within a few feet of the Hobbit. “Do you feel…excluded by us?”

 

Bilbo’s eyes widened and then he shook his head so urgently that Thorin knew he was lying.

 

“Of course not,” the Hobbit gabbled. “It’s only natural you would want to spend time with your family-especially since you have been separated so cruelly from them for three years. No one has been particularly kind to you and so it must be a relief to be back with them. It’s completely normal to want to talk with them…”

 

“…in Khuzdul,” Thorin realised. 

 

“Which I know is a secret language and honestly, your sister keeps glaring at me whenever I’m in the room and you’re talking in your secret language so I don’t want to be a poor host and eavesdrop. So I leave and give you your privacy. I mean, it must be something private for you to be using your secret language.”

 

Thorin thought back to the boys’ tales of their exploits and pranks, their squabbles and jokes and realised that basically nothing that they had been talking about could have been considered secret or private in any way. It was nonsense, the discussions every family has over breakfast, the family jokes and comments on their day and arguments and nothing to be sensitive about. Except they had spoken in a language that specifically excluded their host from participating and because Bilbo had felt sorry for Thorin’s isolation and glad that his efforts in getting his family back had worked, he hadn’t spoken up. Thorin was very certain that being a good host didn’t include being excluded from every conversation in his own home, that it didn’t mean being reduced to a servant and a ghost in his own home when it was only due to his generosity that his guests were permitted to stay in the Shire at all. And the sudden realisation shot through Thorin with an enormous side-order of shame and embarrassment.

 

“No,” the dwarf said. Bilbo blinked.

 

“Um…no?” he asked.

 

“No,” Thorin repeated, moving a little closer and looming over the Hobbit. Bilbo was looking up into his face, seeing his features set in a stern expression that caused the younger creature to half-raise the wholegrain bloomer in his hand like a shield. “There was nothing in our words that was secret or private or in any way needed you to withdraw. My sister was not discussing state secrets: she was relating Kili’s efforts in practicing with his bow that ended up pinning Lord Gurth’s cloak to the walls of the Assay Office.” He sighed. “Bilbo…Master Baggins…I fear that you have been misused. My family and I have been thoughtless in the extreme and rude to an extent that I believe that even Mistress Lobelia Sackville-Baggins could not match.”

 

Bilbo stared up into his face.

 

“Oh,” he said quietly.

 

“My family automatically spoke in Khuzdul because our family-unlike most-uses it as the common language within our home. My sister and I were raised with Khuzdul as the only tongue we spoke when we were young though we learned Westron later. The boys however were born in a household where their father did not speak Khuzdul so they were raised speaking only Westron. But as sons of…our House, Dis and I made sure they learned Khuzdul. I taught them Khuzdul. And whenever I came round, we would converse in our ancient language to ensure their skills were up to the level they needed to be for their…future positions.”

 

“I know you are a Prince, the son of a King,” Bilbo said, his tone a little snippy. There was hurt in his eyes now, at hearing that he had been excluded from their conversations by thoughtlessness on the part of his guests and that Thorin was still dancing around the truth. “You don’t have to pretend who you are. I won’t tell everyone else but Gandalf told me your story.” His eyes glittered. “I thought that maybe you trusted me to be honest. I thought that maybe I had convinced you that I mean you no harm. That I am your friend. But it seems that a mere Hobbit just isn’t good enough to be included in your conversation when you have your own people around.” 

 

“Bilbo, I…”

 

“No.” Bilbo took a step forward and glared at him. “Now will you please step aside? The casserole will burn.”

 

“Bilbo…I must apologise…” Thorin said but Bilbo took another step forward and then slipped past.

 

“What difference will it make?” he asked in a weary voice. “It’s all secrecy and obfuscation with you, isn’t it? You left a lot of very important facts out of what happened to you and who you were. You are suspicious and quick to anger. As soon as your family arrives, you spend all your time with them and even at meals, you make sure I am excluded from any conversation. You are welcome to stay here, Thorin-I promised you that. But I’m not going to feel like a stranger in my own home and I would ask for some basic manners.” And then he headed into the kitchen. Thorin stared at the floor, wondering how it had come to this. No matter his intent, he had hurt Bilbo and made the generous and kind Hobbit feel that his friendship was being spurned. Then he turned and stalked out, walking wordlessly through the kitchen and into the parlour, yelling for his family in Khuzdul. He needed to have a discussion.

 

In the kitchen, Bilbo watched him go with a feeling of resignation. Really, he should have kept his mouth shut and just tried to put up with the situation with good grace. After all, he knew what it was like to be isolated after the death of his parents and the way many of his family treated the slightly odd young Hobbit. Bilbo had spent many days, alone in his Smial, surrounded by memories like echoes of happiness slowly being buried under years of dust and loneliness so he could empathise with Thorin’s plight. And the dwarf had been gruff and very private but he had slowly been opening up to the Hobbit, spending time sitting with him in the evenings, talking about his family with love and pride and giving a precious window onto who Thorin had been. But since his family had arrived, Bilbo hadn’t spent more than a few minutes with the dwarf and he found himself mourning the loss of his friend. And he spent a lot of time berating himself for wanting something that clearly was not his to claim: Thorin was his own person but Bilbo already thought of him as a friend and as such, he had gotten used to seeing the sturdy shape around the smial, of sharing a smile and maybe a few words. But as soon as his family had returned, Bilbo found himself relegated to the sidelines. Even on the few times when Thorin had turned to Bilbo and opened his mouth to speak, one of the others had swiftly spoken up and Thorin had turned back to them and answered in his own language. 

 

“You’re being very silly,” he muttered as he lifted the casserole out of the oven and placed it on the cast iron pot stand, checking the seasoning and glancing at the table. He had laid five places but found his appetite had quite vanished. “And why would he want to spend time with me anyway? I mean, it’s not like the rest of the Shire has made him welcome at all! He must be glad he has his own people to talk to and maybe discuss how pathetic and strange we seem to him. “ He set the bowl of creamy, buttery mash onto the table a little harder than he had intended and headed back for the vegetables as the voices in the parlour grew louder and louder. Thorin and Dis were having an animated discussion that almost certainly sounded worse because it was in Khuzdul and Bilbo swiftly carved some bread and set that and a pat of ice cold butter on the table before he glanced up-to see Fili and Kili sidling rather sheepishly into the kitchen. The voices, if anything, had gotten louder.

 

“Mister Boggins,” Kili began, his expression mildly subdued. Bilbo rolled his eyes.

 

“It’s Baggins not…” he began and then he sighed. “What does it matter? I’ve told you a dozen times and you never bother…” Fili stared at his brother and elbowed him hard in the side. Before the younger dwarf could protest, the golden-haired dwarrow stepped forward and bowed.

 

“Mister Baggins,” he said carefully. “It’s become very obvious that we have treated you discourteously and have rewarded your amazing generosity with feelings of exclusion and unhappiness.” Bilbo stared at him.

 

“Amad and Uncle Thorin are having an argument about it,” Kili explained as Bilbo stared towards the parlour. The two adults were bellowing at one another now and sounded like they were an ace from declaring war on each other.

 

“That was not my intention…” he said hurriedly as the young dwarves both stepped forward and bowed deeply.

 

“We know,” Fili said honestly. “I think we were just so relieved and happy to see Thorin again that we forgot that you couldn’t understand us. And Mahal, that sounds awful and really wasn’t meant like that.”

 

“Amad insists we speak Khuzdul when Uncle visits because he’s far the best of us at it,” Kili said, his dark eyes embarrassed. “And when we found him, Amad kept giving us that look she has and we just…acted like we did at home…”

 

“I think we never even considered that we were excluding you,” Fili added. “It was rude and it was wrong. Thorin has insisted we all speak Westron here so that you do not think we are talking about you behind your back or not inviting you to join the conversation.” He shoved Kili gently. “And while we need the practice, we are here in this lovely cosy Hobbit Hole because of you. Uncle is alive because of you. And it’s clear he holds you in high regard.”

 

“Why are they arguing?” Bilbo asked, his stomach dropping. Did Dis not approve of friendships beyond her own race? Was his act in contacting her to try to find Thorin’s family going to lose him Thorin’s friendship? Kili rolled his eyes.

 

“Amad being Amad,” he sighed dramatically and collapsed into one of the seats.

 

“Our Amad is a Princess and sometimes she acts like one,” Fili translated. “She is pretty smart and good at assessing people but she’s not very good at admitting that she has made a mistake. She’s also very stubborn.”

 

“Though maybe not quite as stubborn as Thorin,” Bilbo murmured. They stared at him. “He survived three years of slavery. And he was treated very badly. Even when I met him in Bree, he was still refusing to compromise who he was. And his…the man who was holding him as a slave…was very cruel to him.” Fili sat next to his brother.

 

“Do you know what happened to him?” the older brother asked quietly. “We have tried asking him but he won’t say. He just…goes quiet and ignores the question.” Bilbo sighed.

 

“It really is his story to tell,” he explained to the young dwarrow, wiping his hands on a tea towel. “What I do know, which I suspect he wouldn’t mind me saying, is that he never gave up hope of returning home, that he never surrendered and always acted as a decent and brave dwarf. They kept him alive, I gather, because he was a very good smith and he never compromised his standards. And he was the proudest, most stubborn person I have ever met from any race.”

 

“And have you met many races?” Fili asked him, his blue gaze appraising.

 

“Men, Elves, Hobbits, Wizards and now dwarves,” Bilbo revealed. “And Thorin is definitely the most stubborn.” There was a loud slam and the sound of steps entering the room.

 

“No, I just lost that position to my sister,” Thorin said wearily. He bowed. “Bilbo-I am sorry. I truly had not realised what was happening until we spoke. And my sister-who is suspicious at best-is refusing to acknowledge that we are the ones who caused your behaviour to change. I may have pointed out that it was her insistence that her sons only spoke Khuzdul to me that is the root of this. Maybe it was helpful when they were little pebbles but now, they are not that far from adulthood and they can choose what language they wish to use. Especially since our use of Khuzdul excludes our most gracious host.” He frowned.

 

“Oh thank Mahal,” Kili said quickly. “It was almost like being at school the entire time. Amad scowled at me every time I fumbled.” He glanced over at Fili. “You’ve always been better at it than me…”

 

“It’s in those lessons Balin kept giving me,” Fili complained. “Honestly-did you have to study with him as well?” Thorin nodded and slowly walked to settle at the table.

 

“If anything, he’s going easy on you,” he admitted. “Bilbo-please sit down. You have made this delicious-smelling meal and we would be fools to let it go to waste.” The Hobbit looked confused.

 

“But Dis…?” he asked, glancing in the direction of her room. There was a pause in which the three dwarrow exchanged glances.

 

“We can save her some,” Fili suggested, lifting the lid from the casserole. “Mahal, this smells…”

 

“…amazing…” Kili finished, salivating. “I am never leaving here. Ever.” Bilbo smiled and swiftly dished up portions, making sure the boys had vegetables along with their mash, though both complained. Thorin gratefully accepted his portion and glanced at his host.

 

“Bilbo…” he began but the Hobbit managed a smile. 

 

“Eat,” he advised. “Few things make hobbits happen than meals-especially meals that are appreciated by their guests.”

 

“And afterwards, we can do the washing and tidying up,” Thorin said firmly. “While Bilbo takes a well-earned rest in the parlour. After we have finished not destroying the kitchen…” He cast a baleful look at his nephews. “…we will join Bilbo and you two can explain just what mischief you may possibly get up to so that he can look out in case you stop being on your best behaviour.” Bilbo stared at him. “I am their Uncle but I am under no illusion that they will remain the model Princes they are trying to be at the moment.” The Hobbit gave a small smile. 

 

“I have plenty of nieces and nephews and I think that now I am warned, I can keep a closer eye on this pair,” he replied. “Now maybe you could tell me about your day…?”

 

The meal passed very pleasantly. Partway through, Dis joined them, her face controlled and shoulders taut but she managed a stiff apology to Bilbo before she fell upon her food with relish. And notably, everyone spoke Westron so that everyone could understand the conversation. And as he watched, he noted that the dwarves used Khuzdul terms for each other-Nadad, Namad, Amad-but otherwise used Westron terms. The main course was followed with a strawberry and cream pavlova which could not have vanished faster if a group of hungry Hobbits had fallen on it. Finally, replete and grateful, Thorin had dragged the boys to do the washing up while Dis had tidied the table. Embarrassed, he had jumped up but the Princess had been adamant: they had been remiss and unpardonably rude and they owed Bilbo amends. And also, they should help in cleaning up. The Hobbit was an excellent cook and a generous host: dwarrow were not created to sit idle and it reflected poorly on them that they had sat back and essentially treated Bilbo like a servant. She had paused then and offered a low bow of apology.

 

Walking thoughtfully towards the parlour, Bilbo had jumped as he heard an urgent hammering on the door. Recalling his growing dislike of people who did not use the doorbell, he walked slowly towards the door. It was gloomy and dusk was falling. Without really thinking, he opened the door and faced the largest dwarf he had ever seen. 

 

The massive shape glared at him, fists bunched and balding head caught by the pinkish light of the sunset. He was wearing armour and had two large axes slung across his back. He leaned forward and growled at Bilbo:

 

“Where is Thorin?”

 

Bilbo fainted.