Actions

Work Header

Blood and Iron

Chapter 22: Chapter Twenty Two

Chapter Text

TWENTY TWO.

 

 

“Ah. I was expecting you a bit earlier actually.” Isengrim’s voice was vaguely amused as he sat back in the high wing-backed chair and inspected the visitors. Thorin straightened his back as he faced the Thain, his face neutral but anxiety fluttering in his chest. The best parlour of the Great Smials was warmed with sunshine and a tray with a nice hot pot of tea, fine gilded bone china cups and saucers, a coffee walnut cake and a pile of tea plates were all sitting on the polished walnut coffee table. Balin, Dwalin and Bilbo were seated in a loose semi-circle facing the Thain, flanking Thorin. Only Bilbo held a cup of tea while Dwalin was casting unsubtle glances at the cake, though he remained stony and motionless at the end of the line.

 

“I was informed by Master…Bilbo…that it was considered ill manners to visit someone before Second Breakfast,” the dwarf explained slowly, choosing his words carefully. “He was very insistent that I should not offer insult to you by disturbing your early morning for something that was not a life and death emergency.” Isengrim sipped his tea then placed the cup down with a slight chink of porcelain in the silent room.

 

“He is absolutely correct, as I would expect of a Baggins,” he noted thoughtfully. “Though, of course, the person who hammered on my door after dark last night was crying riot, insurrection and blue murder.”

 

“What?” Bilbo’s voice was unmistakeable and he frowned as his Uncle nodded.

 

“I was treated to a late night visit after supper and close to bedtime by Lobelia who was insistent that I send the Sheriffs out to arrest Thorin for his unprovoked murderous assault on her person which was apparently witnessed by half of Hobbiton!” the Thain commented dryly, helping himself to a slice of cake.

 

“That lying…” Bilbo hissed as Thorin took a shaky breath and squared his shoulders, lifting his chin. He forced his impassive mask back into place.

 

“I assure you that there was no assault, no murderous intent and what I did was certainly not unprovoked,” he said coldly. “Lord Isengrim-that foul women felt that she had the right to trespass in where she was not welcome. She assaulted me with her weapon-twice-and insulted me, my race and Bilbo in every conceivable manner. She threatened to incite her fellow Hobbits against us and have us and Bilbo driven from the Shire. So I snapped her umbrella and lifted her by the scruff of her neck. And then I dumped her on the road like the trash that she is. There was ample provocation. There was no assault. And I believe that most of the Hill witnessed the confrontation.”

 

“Hamfast Gamgee and Violet Underroot of Bagshot Row and at least Letty and Gervaise Greenthumb of the Hill were hanging over their fences to watch the show,” Bilbo put in. "If you wanted to call the Sheriffs, they could easily verify Thorin's statement. And mine. And the others. We all saw and heard what went on.”

 

Isengrim raised an eyebrow but his expression remained cool.

 

“They wouldn’t credit the word of a dwarf,” Thorin said quietly, squaring his shoulders and trying to keep the pain from his voice. “No race but our own credits dwarves with any worth. Driven from our home, spurned like rabid wolves, ostracised by our own people, blamed for Azanulbizar despite our crippling losses, treated like animals as our women and children starve and freeze and are taken by disease and wild animals. ‘Everyone knows’ that dwarves are dirty and vicious and thieves and beggars. But no one but our own kind see the woman nursing hungry babes, see a couple slowly dance under the moon as they celebrate an anniversary, see friends laugh about a fire, sharing jokes and songs…or watch family mourn another infant life cut short due to lack of food or warmth or simple medicine. Dwarrow are seen as little more than animals, despite the fact we create the most beautiful things and finest weapons on Arda, despite the fact we love but once and are devoted to our spouses and families for all our long lives, despite the fact we do not prosper except in our rightful homes. My people are slowly dying, year by year our numbers dwindling. Fewer dwarflings are born and not all survive, female offspring are rarer still and many of my people never find our Ones, yet we still fall to murder or disease or war. Mahal treats his creations hard and we can only pray that in the future to come, when the world is remade, that our lot will be kinder than it is now. And that other races will finally believe that we have the right to exist as much as they do.”

 

Bilbo blinked, his eyes blurred with tears at the words, spoken with a quiet passion and despair that tore his heart. He knew his own people had endured hard times in their wandering days though they were centuries behind them and he wondered if his self-absorbed and definitely self-satisfied neighbours even considered how lucky they were. Everyone knew that Elves were blessed, the chosen of Eru, the Firstborn. Men, the Secondborn, were determined and inventive. They lived brief, fierce lives and bred and spread across Middle Earth with passion and curiosity. But no one ever mentioned the dwarves except with a sneer on their lips and disgust on their tongue. So many misconceptions, so much prejudice, so much sorrow…

 

“That’s not true,” he found himself saying in a thick voice. “I believe you. I know you. I would do anything I can to protect you and make sure you are given a home and safety and warmth. I know you are a brave, decent, honourable person-as much as any of my own people.” There was a soft noise of surprise as Thorin looked at him, his eyes filled with shocked gratitude at the immediate defence.

 

“But in the end, my friend, your Thain will so what he must to protect his people and the security and peace of the Shire,” he said, his voice despondent. “And though she is loathsome, your Lobelia Sackville-Baggins is not the only Hobbit in the Shire who dislikes the presence of myself and my people. So though she is prejudiced and cruel, she speaks for a proportion of your people. And I cannot expect Lord Isengrim to risk dissatisfaction among his people for a handful of refugee dwarrows. So though she is the author of this conflict, we will be asked to leave to preserve the peace of the Shire.” Bilbo opened his mouth. “And it is right, Bilbo. Any leader must put the needs and concerns of his own people above the welfare of strangers and outsiders. It is the way of the world and my people know that all too well.”

 

“But it’s not right,” Bilbo protested. “Lobelia is a vicious witch who just wants to drive me from my home. She hates you because of me.” Thorin gave a grim chuckle. 

 

“If I did not have Hobbit feet, curly hair and no beard, I would never be acceptable in her eyes, no matter if I lodged with the most respected of families,” he sighed.

 

“You are,” Isengrim said sharply. “There is no family more respected than the Baggins. Not the Sackvilles-oh no, they are definitely an inferior twig on the Baggins family tree. And the head of the Baggins family is Bungo’s Heir.” He nodded at his nephew.

 

“Bilbo?” Thorin murmured. The young Hobbit’s shoulders slumped.

 

“Maybe not so respectable now,” he sighed. The Thain lifted his chin and absently picked a walnut from the top of the coffee cake.

 

“You asked your guests to adhere to Hobbit conventions regarding visiting while one of our own disturbed me at bedtime for a matter that is quite frankly ridiculous!” he said in a suddenly angry voice. “I have endeavoured to be as fair and even-handed as I could but this is completely beyond the pale…” Thorin sat up straighter, expression leaving his face and took a small breath, as if waiting for the order for his own execution. 

 

“Uncle…”

 

“I will dispatch the Sheriffs to take statements and of course, they will do their duty as they see fit,” the Thain decided. “They can then report to Adelgrim who will be acting as magistrate in this matter. He will determine the correct penalties for those involved…all of them.” There was a dangerous smile on his lips. “Though, as outsiders, you would not be aware that there are penalties for behaving like a boorish intruder and a bad guest in Hobbit society.” Balin and Dwalin shared a surprised look. “I’ll have Pondo Uffington come and take statements from all those in your smial as well as those witnesses you named later today.”

 

There was a pause. Thorin swallowed.

 

“We are permitted to stay?” he checked as Isengrim crunched through his walnut half and reached for his tea. He frowned slightly.

 

“Of course, Thorin Oakenshield,” he replied as if it was a stupid question. “Why would I renege on my vow to grant you sanctuary in the Shire when you have done nothing wrong?”

 

There was an awkward silence.

 

“Because everyone else does,” Bilbo said quietly. “Because being cheated, treated poorly and driven out are what they expect because that is all they have encountered.” There was a slight clatter as Isengrim almost tipped over his (almost empty) cup. 

 

“I fear you are correct, nephew,” he said heavily, glancing at the three watchful dwarves, sitting stiff and tense on their seats. “And I am sorry that they cannot trust us enough to believe us. When I make a promise, I keep it and by Yavanna, I will keep this one.” He rose achingly and walked to stand opposite Thorin. Then he offered his hand. “Thorin, you are safe here as long as I am Thain. You and your people are granted the protection of the Shire. And if you-any of you-have any further issues with Lobelia, I want to hear of them. I will not have her disgrace the reputation of the Shire for hospitality with her groundless prejudice and vicious antics.”

 

Thorin took his hand, closing his larger, calloused grip around the old Hobbit’s hand.

 

“Thank you, Thain Isengrim,” he said honestly, feeling disorientated. Never had the difference between Hobbits and Dwarrow been so stark! His own people would have driven out a Hobbit associated with such trouble, no matter the rights or wrongs of the matter…and that caused a huge jolt of shame to curl in his chest. “I have no words for such generosity…” Isengrim grinned, his eyes twinkling like a mischievous faunt.

 

“Ah-but that’s the absolute key to being a Hobbit-generosity,” he told the dwarf in a low voice. “A virtue my nephew demonstrates in absolute abundance.” Then he returned to his normal voice. “Now, I believe you were about to introduce me to your kinsmen?”

 

-o0o-

 

“What are my options?” Lobelia’s shrill voice was like the scratch of nails on a blackboard in the wood-panelled and traditional offices of Hugo and Iago Proudfoot, Attorneys-at-Law (Hobbiton) Ltd. Otho sat at her side, his dumpy and comfortable shape topped by a mildly dissatisfied jowly face and clothed in overly ostentatious salmon pink waistcoat and aqua blue dinner jacket that clashed rather unpleasantly. Lobelia was in a mango and lemon silk brocade dress with lace, beading and bows that gave the rather unwanted impression of an explosion in a haberdashery. Iago Proudfoot, the senior partner, sat back behind his desk and steepled his fingers.

 

“Well, you could always take out a restraining order against the dwarf to prevent him harassing you any further,” Iago suggested, sitting back. His dark eyes were intelligent and calculating as he watched the couple. He, as everyone else, knew about Lobelia’s desire to steal Bag End from her cousin, its rightful owner, and had already guessed this was another plot to disadvantage the young Hobbit. Lobelia perked up.

 

“So I can prevent him from going to the Market, the Forge, Bag End…” she began spitefully but Iago sighed and rubbed his forehead. Lobelia always gave him headache: she was simply managing it much quicker today.

 

“You cannot bar him from a public place nor his place of work,” he told her firmly. “Only the Thain can banish him from public spaces in the Shire and I doubt you would get the popular support you wish. And as Musskin Snowmane has handed the Forge over to him, you cannot bar him from his own property.”

 

“And Bag End?” Lobelia hissed.

 

“Bag End is not your property!” Iago told her sharply, wearying of her vindictiveness. “He is a welcome guest of the owner and the only person who can bar anyone from there is Bilbo Baggins, the legal owner.”

 

“But it should be MINE!” Lobelia snapped.

 

“Well, it isn’t!” Iago told her coldly. “You’ve exhausted every legal avenue through a variety of groundless and frankly insane arguments and you have been banned by the Shire Court from ever litigating for the ownership of Bag End ever again.” In fact, the person most likely to be prevented ever entering the place again is you, he thought as he shuffled the papers on his desk. “You can only restrain him from coming to your property or Otho’s place of work. And I must say, Lobelia, that if you wish to avoid seeing the dwarf Thorin, then you should avoid going to places where you know he will be-such as the Market, the Forge or Bag End.”

 

“But…”

 

“You have NO legal right to enter Bag End-and when you tried to push past the dwarf to enter, you lost legal protection,” Iago told her bluntly. “In fact, with my knowledge of dwarvish customs, I am only surprised that you still have all your limbs still.” She glared at him. “Of course, you may visit the market but you must not approach the dwarf. You should not approach the Forge-there are alternatives that I suggest you use.”

 

“Bywater? Bree?” Lobelia snarled.

 

“If the dwarf was not here, then you would be using them anyway,” the lawyer told her flatly. “I am afraid those are your only legal options.”

 

“Here,” Lobelia said suddenly, her eyes narrowing. “I can send Otho to collect my orders from the Forge. I can avoid those disgusting creatures in the Market. But there shouldn’t be no punishment for that wretched creature. And if the Shire is afraid to deal with him, I need to find those who will not be.”

 

Otho made a small grunt and looked unhappy but said nothing. Iago sat forward.

 

“Speak plainly, Lobelia,” he said.

 

“I want you to write me a letter,” she said waspishly. “To the King of the dwarves in their local kingdom…”

 

“The Blue Mountains,” Iago interjected, his eyes never leaving her face.

 

“I want you to demand what crime he committed to be put into slavery and outline that he is a violent, vicious criminal who needs removal from our lands,” she said cruelly. “And I want you to request that the King sends guards to take this criminal back to their land and dispose of him.” Iago sat back and stared at her.

 

“Lobelia, you do not have the authority to invite the guards of a foreign kingdom into the Shire to kidnap one of their citizens,” he told her, aghast. “That is almost treason.”

 

“But not quite,” Lobelia spat. “Are you going to do it or not? Because I am certain I can find another lawyer to do it for me…”

 

“You do and I will turn you over to the Sheriffs myself,” Iago threatened.

 

“What about lawyer-client privilege?” Otho asked slowly, his eyes inspecting the older Hobbit.

 

“You both know that is null and void where the security of the Shire and a direct threat to the legal authorities in the Shire is concerned,” Iago told her sharply. He glared and Otho subsided, his comfortable shape slumping. Weak and hen-pecked, his role was very much as provider and cheerleader rather as a force in his own right. Making a quick calculation, Iago laced his fingers across his ample middle. “Lobelia, I will write the letter-at five times my normal rate. I will approve the wording, not you. There will be no mention of any welcome or invitation of any foreign forces to the Shire. You will inquire about his history and inform them of his current transgressions. And then they can decide if they wish to retrieve him or not. But with my wording, you will in no way be culpable for any outcome. All you have done is sent an enquiry to the local dwarvish authorities and informed them of the actions of one of their citizens.”

 

Lobelia sat forward and gave a ghastly smile.

 

“Do it,” she said.

 

-o0o-

 

“May I present Balin, son of Fundin, lately Chief Adviser to King Thrain of Ered Luin and Dwalin, sin of Fundin, former Guard Captain of Ered Luin,” Thorin said evenly, introducing his cousins in turn. Isengrim met Balin’s eyes-twinkling with humour and a glitter of intelligence-and nodded, knowing this was the dwarf he needed to talk with at length. And then he looked at Dwalin, who was scowling at the Thain, his arms crossed over his massive chest, the tattoos on his head and arms alien and exotic. Twin axes were crossed over his back, the light gleaming off wickedly sharp edges.

 

“You are the cousins that Thorin spoke of with affection and concern,” the Thain commented. “You are both very welcome.” Dwalin grunted.

 

“I knew he’d been hit over the head one too many times,” he commented gruffly as his brother’s smile grew strained. Thorin looked pained. Isengrim suddenly burst out laughing.

 

“I believe that there are more similarities between our races than we realise,” he guffawed. “I can hear at least three of my two dozen cousins saying something very similar!” Bilbo nodded. 

 

“Adelgrim and Prim would definitely say the same about me,” he piped up as the three dwarves untensed very slightly. The Thain gave a smile. 

 

“Master Balin-I believe you and I need to have some discussions about the situation in Ered Luin,” he said amiably. There was an awkward silence as Balin’s face hardened and he snatched a glance at Thorin.

 

“Lord Isengrim…you have to understand…” he began, his brows dipping as he saw no reaction from the former Prince. “Thorin! I…” 

 

“Balin-these are my allies and they deserve to know the perils on their borders-especially as it may impact on them since I am here,” Thorin told him sternly.

 

“And you know the wishes of the King, the conventions of Council…the very ways of our race!” the old Adviser hissed. 

 

“I told you at Bilbo’s that I would not deny him honesty about our home-and that courtesy extends to the Thain,” Thorin insisted. There was a frosty silence.

 

“Ach, laddie…” Balin sighed, his tone disappointed. “You know, if I am asked if you have betrayed secrets, I will have to say…”

 

“Say what, Balin?” Thorin growled, his eyes flashing with anger. “What secrets? That my father’s mind fades more each day, his sanity ebbing with the cursed madness that haunts my line? That the Council-all venal, spiteful, ambitious dwarrow-are manipulating our hollow king to promote their own interests and enrichment, to isolate us so they can cling to monopolies while our people lack essentials, just so their coffers can swell? That my place as Crown Prince has been given to my brother without any real opposition from Frerin, who always said he would rather die than accept the responsibility? That no one-not one of my kin, my Lords, my people-would authorise a mission to retrieve me when I surrendered to save my family from slavery? That my capture was no chance event and that the dwarf who had me enslaved sent his men to find me when I was released so that I could be slain and my body dumped in the wilds for animals to gnaw, never to know the embrace of stone? That someone-probably someone very powerful and senior in our court-wants me dead? And that if that person finds me, they will try again and that will bring danger to the Shire?”

 

The Adviser pressed his lips together in an impatient look.

 

“I see my lessons in diplomacy still haven’t sunk in,” he said shortly.

 

“Or maybe you should recall that diplomacy is a polite way of saying ‘lying’,” Thorin retorted. “And that is unacceptable to those on whose generosity we depend. We always complain that we are treated shoddily by other races, lied to and treated as inferior. Yet you ask me to treat our Hobbit hosts in just such a way. I am not about to shout our politics from the Market Place but the leader of the Shire and the Hobbit to whom I owe my life deserve nothing but honesty.” Balin blinked. Occasionally, Thorin surprised him.

 

“Aye, there is that,” he commented and sighed. “Lord Isengrim, I am happy to discuss the current situation in Ered Luin with you-though things do change, which is why I am here. And I would appreciate that our words are only shared with your most trusted and discreet counsellors.” 

 

“Isengrim,” the Thain said with a smile, turning to the younger brother. “I am no Lord, nor a King…”

 

“You fill the job of one," Dwalin commented gruffly. “May as well take the title as well.”

 

“Though Hobbits set little store on such titles, as we have little care for gold and gems,” Isengrim replied cheerfully. “Food, family, a merry song and a gathering filled with laughter and love are the things we value above all.” The big warrior nodded.

 

“Aye, there is that,” he commented.

 

“Captain of the Guard?” the Thain asked and Dwalin stiffened, his face closing.

 

“Former.”

 

“I suspect your abilities and skills remain commensurate with that position, since I would guess your removal from the post was politically motivated,” Isengrim said, staring disconcertingly into Dwalin’s eyes. The warrior suddenly felt as if he was facing his elder brother at his most astute. “We have a few Sheriffs, who police by consent, and the Bounders, a small border force who are very lightly armed and superficially trained. I wonder…” Dwalin arched a bushy eyebrow.

 

“Yeh want me to train ‘em up?” he asked dryly. Isengrim nodded.

 

“I suspect even a little advice from a warrior such as yourself would be invaluable to our unwarlike people,” he admitted. “And any assistance you and your companions could offer in the event of an attack would be gratefully received.”

 

“All dwarrow are warriors,” Thorin confirmed. “We will fight for our allies and to protect those who have welcomed us into their homes.”

 

“Lobelia’s in trouble then,” Bilbo murmured, causing Isengrim to smile…and Thorin as well. 

 

“Two others accompanied Balin and Dwalin,” he continued. “They remain at Bag End. Nether are kinsmen to us but instead those dear to an agent of Balin’s.”

 

“And their removal here is necessary?” Isengrim asked, frowning. Balin sighed and nodded.

 

“The same Lords who probably arranged for Thorin’s removal have no qualms in taking hostages or in removing family as a means of control...or punishment. Dori is a tailor, a sensible and caring dwarrow who raised his younger brothers from when the youngest was but a babe-in-arms,” he revealed. “He is also extremely strong and skilled in combat if required. Ori is his youngest brother, an apprentice scribe who is under my tutelage. He is a pleasant and kindly young man. Neither will cause any trouble: in fact, I rather feel Dori will feel quite at home here. Especially if the selection of teas I noted in Master Baggins’ pantry were to be believed…” Isengrim resumed his seat and drained the last drops of tea from his cup.

 

“Then they are very welcome…and any more that you feel need to be here for safety,” he said after a moment’s consideration. “If things are getting crowded, I can find other accommodations for extras close to Bilbo’s home. I just as to be kept apprised of how many dwarrow we have in Hobbiton. Just in case Lobelia chooses to bend my ear once more.” He winked. “Doesn’t look good for the Thain to be learning things from a complainant when I should be ahead of that woman and able to answer any objections she has in light of full knowledge.”

 

“Understood,” Thorin said, feeling exhausted by the release of tension. The more he saw of the Thain, the more he respected the Hobbit and briefly wished that men of his calibre were in charge in Ered Luin, rather than the venal, treacherous specimens that currently ran the place. He shifted in his seat and unconsciously, his hand brushed against Bilbo’s. For an aeons long second, he didn’t know what to do…whether to snatch his hand away would be insulting or welcomed…but Bilbo glanced up, smiled and pressed his hand deliberately against Thorin’s before calmly withdrawing and resting it back on his lap.

 

“Thank you, Uncle,” the young Hobbit said cheerfully. Isengrim nodded.

 

“Now, I think we could maybe have a quick overview of how you are all going to occupy yourselves in the Shire…” he said and smiled. “After we’ve all had some cake…”