Chapter Text
TWENTY FOUR.
"Have you noticed anything different about Uncle?”
Fili looked up from where he was sitting on the floor by the fire in the parlour, polishing his swords and inspected his younger brother. He could still remember when they were deemed old enough to start practicing with actual blades-Kili had been the limiting factor then, he recalled, since Amad and Thorin hadn’t been sure for the longest time the younger Prince wouldn’t accidentally stab himself as a joke. And to be honest, Fili hadn’t been sure his younger and far less responsible self wouldn’t have joined him in the mischief-if only to see if they could frighten Amad. Both of them knew that they wouldn’t be held responsible for any damage, only their Uncle, who had accepted the responsibility in training them.
He paused. When you soberly reflected on their thought processes, it sounded absolutely despicable. He and Kili still worked as a double act-bantering, arguing, scuffling, pranking-but they at least had something of a sense of responsibility, born of necessity in the pressure cooker of Ered Luin politics and the ice-cold of the family. Other dwarrow clans were warm and welcoming, treasuring their cousins and young as much as siblings and parents but the direct Line of Durin was a strange family, blighted by misfortune, political manoeuvring and madness. Fili was old enough to know that his great-grandfather, King Thror, had been mad as a box of rubble, consumed by the Dragon Sickness that had never relented even after the Lonely Mountain and Kingdom of Erebor was lost to the dragon. His grandfather was, by all accounts, also afflicted, his mind wandering and often as lost as a young child, needing guidance from those who ruled through him as a dwarf of straw. Even Uncle Frerin, who had been so much fun when they were younger, had become distant and cold, refusing audiences and never contacting his nephews. Only Thorin had been a constant.
“What do you mean by different?” he asked, switching cloths. Like any warrior, he always carried what he needed to maintain his weapons, all superb quality for they had been forged by Thorin for his sister-sons as they needed them. Crown Prince he may have been, but he never shirked his duty to his family. When their Adad had returned to the stone, Thorin had stepped up, standing by his devastated sister and promising that he would do his best to ensure they never wanted for anything. So he had been there when they were ill, when they needed bedtime stories and weapons lessons, he had taught them Khuzdul and Westron, told them of their history, taught them of their duties as Princes and what they owed their people. And while people around them saw nobility or Royalty as a free ticket to take, Thorin’s lessons had always been about service, duty and honour.
Fili frowned and rubbed a little harder to buff the blade to a brilliant shine. There had been times before they reached Ered Luin, when they were wandering and still scorned that Amad had told him about, when the nomadic Ereborean refugees had suffered. No one would offer them a place to stay permanently and they had been driven off by force more than once. Food was often scarce and many had lost dwarflings and pregnancies due to severe hunger. Fili shuddered: he had been sensitive enough to read the unspoken sorrow in his Amad’s eyes as she had spoken of their wanderings and he knew then that somewhere on the road, a younger brother or sister had lost their battle even before they had the chance to first breathe. Their father had hunted and he knew that Thorin and a few others had worked as smiths, accepting abuse and being cheated all for enough coppers to bring bread and a little other food in. If he concentrated, he could recall hunger, recall crying as his stomach hurt even as Thorin had fed the meagre contents of his own food bowl to the little Princeling. Even after they had finally reached Ered Luin, times had been tough as they established their colony amid unproductive rocks and poor quality seams so there was a desperate shortage of food in the mountain. There hadn’t been enough work, nowhere near enough fo everyone and somehow, the lack had affected the Princess and her little sons. Not the King, of course, nor his fat and well-fed Lords but the weakest and youngest-supposedly the most precious members of the community-had been left to starve. Everyone was hungry but it had been Thorin who had gone out to work, to earn money for food from the villages of Men. Thorin alone of the family when Frerin was equally capable of work. Amad had repaired clothes and made trinkets for sale but she was limited by caring for two young boys. It had struck him then and it struck him now: why had it only been Thorin?
Kili shrugged. The younger Prince could recall hunger as well, for things had been precarious. When there was an illness among the villages of men or crops were poor, they did not trade or had no surplus to sell and the dwarrows starved. The divisions in society sharpened into acute focus then and Kili, though outgoing and cheerful, was no fool. “He seems…lighter.”
Fili hummed as he sheathed one of his swords and moved to the other. Thorin had taught them how to care for their weapons, explaining with a reverent tone how their blades would save their lives, that they were the last ally against an enemy orc or goblin and most importantly, you could not rely on an ally if you treated him badly. And then he had shown them Deathless, his sword that he had maintained with devotion since he inherited it. The blade was keen, the edges perfect and ferociously sharp and there was not a spot of rust, corrosion or dirt anywhere on the weapon. He recalled touching the sword respectfully, Thorin’s larger hand hovering to ensure he didn’t harm himself on the edges.
“Lighter?”
Kili looked up, his dark eyes thoughtful.
“He always seemed so weighted down by duty and responsibility back home,” he said slowly. “Whenever anything needed doing, it was always Thorin that did it. Whether it was leading a scouting party to track down Orcs or travelling to the Grey Mountains or the Iron Hills or dealing with complaints from miners and artisans, he always did the hard jobs.”
“Sigin’Adad was the King. Is the King. He could not ride out and lead raids,” Fili pointed out.
“Nor should the Crown Prince,” Kili argued suddenly. “That’s why we have Generals and Captains of the Guard. Even younger brothers.” He gave a cheeky grin then but resumed his serious expression instantaneously. “But Sigin’Adad and the Council charged Thorin with doing everything. Every hard task and dangerous mission. And they seemed ever more angry when he succeeded.” Fili nodded.
“You know they call home ‘Thorin’s Halls’?” he asked his brother, switching cloths again. “Not Thrain’s Halls. Thorin’s Halls. Because Uncle Thorin was the one who was always there, always doing what needed to be done. If there was an accident, Thorin was the member of the Royal family who went, helping and reassuring or offering condolences. If there was unrest, Thorin was sent to quell it. When the Third Shaft West collapsed, Thorin went in with the miners and helped dig the miners out. He paid for the medicines and even gave money to the families until they could work again. They made him do everything: in response, the people see him as the only one doing anything. The King is invisible, the Council is hated and the guards…” He looked up. “The guards aren’t trusted.”
“You really think someone back home arranged for the attack?” Kili asked him quietly.
“Two days earlier, Thorin had sent a raven to inform the King that we were almost home,” Fili said slowly. He had been mulling the news over since they arrived at Bag End. “It would not have been a secret from the court where he was and what route he was likely to take.” He chewed a lip. “You know they refused to send a larger escort? Sigin’Adad said that speed and stealth was likely a better protection than a large column of guards protecting his heirs.” Even to his own ears, his voice sounded bitter. Kili nodded slowly.
“Uncle smiles here,” he said quietly. “You’ve seen, haven’t you? He smiles. I never thought we would ever see him again, let alone smile like he did when we were young.”
“He’s not smiling for us,” Fili pointed out. Kili gave his sword a final rub and then sheathed it once more.
“No-but he's smiling for someone,” he replied. “Before he was…taken…he always looked so grim. Even when he was round visiting Amad, he never smiled. But here…well, he looks like he’s home. He knows his way around the kitchen, he helps Bilbo, he smiles and jokes. He made it clear to Balin and Dwalin that he’s given his allegiance to Bilbo. You saw him while we were practicing?”
“Um…no…” Fili replied. “I was trying not to get cut into small pieces by Amad.” Kili chuckled.
“Serves you right for trying to cut up your poor baby brother,” he teased his brother. “I was only having to deal with Dwalin…” He shuddered-and then he sighed. “Uncle offered to teach Bilbo.”
“Really?”
“He whittled them wooden swords and gave him a lesson-you remember the most basic exercises we used to do when we first learned? And then he stood behind Bilbo and guided his arm through them. Twice. He looked rather red afterwards…” Kili’s eyes were sparkling.
“It may just be gratitude and friendship,” Fili pointed out, not wanting to crush his brother's enthusiasm but equally, not wanting to misread the situation. “I mean, Thorin has been through some really hard times. He's been a slave…and treated really badly. Bilbo rescued him and offered him a home and hope. He's defended Thorin against his own people…” Kili winced.
“Lobelia,” he muttered.
“But I guess she won’t be the only one who doesn’t want one of those ‘thieving dwarves’ in the neighbourhood,” Fili reminded him.
“But that’s it,” Kili interrupted, fishing for his quiver and starting to inspect every arrow in turn, checking the fletching with an expert eye. “Bilbo. He’s generous, brave and kind. And I don’t think anyone has been kind to Thorin for a long time.”
They fell silent with the only sound being the gentle swish of Fili’s cloth.
“You’re right,” the older Prince sighed. “Thorin sometimes looks at Bilbo…like Adad looked at Amad.” Kili frowned and the older brother grasped his shoulder reassuringly. “Sorry. I know you never really knew Adad. I only have memories…a few and faded, like old manuscripts…but that look was very clear, every time he came home and looked at Amad.”
“I’ve seen Bilbo watching Thorin,” Kili admitted. "There's that little smile when he sees Uncle come in from work, the way he almost lights up. I don’t think he even realises he’s doing it…but he is. I mean he’s so kind to us all and makes us so welcome…even Dwalin has settled in and appreciates his plate of biscuits when he returns from whoever he’s training.”
“Amad is still suspicious…but then, she’s always suspicious,” Fili agreed. “But I think she’s mainly upset because we’re exiled because it’s not safe. She knows what the Council was planning for her…and us.” The smile vanished from Kili’s face and he nodded, his eyes shadowed.
“She and Thorin, Balin and Dwalin have lost two homes now,” he murmured. “One to a dragon…and one to dwarrow who are as bad as one.” Fili clapped him on the shoulder, hating seeing the shadow in his bright and cheerful younger brother’s eyes.
“Kee-we’re together here and the Hobbits have given us safety,” he reminded his brother. “Bilbo is the best host and seems to have adopted us.” The younger brother gave a small grin.
“He gets flustered whenever we call him ‘Uncle Bilbo’,” he pointed out.
“Which is why it’s fun,” Fili agreed. “But Thorin can never go back. In fact, if they knew where we were, he and Bilbo would be in real danger. I think he may have accepted that finally he has no chance to return…and that instead of spending his life in the service of the dwarrow of Ered Luin, he can maybe seek happiness for himself.”
“So we may possibly end up with a real Uncle Bilbo?” Kili asked, his enthusiasm infectious. Fili forced himself to remain the voice of reason.
“We’re talking about Thorin here,” he reminded his brother. “Thorin who would put himself last in any consideration. Thorin who would ignore his own heart because we are here and need looking after. Thorin who would manage to be an idiot if it disadvantaged himself because he never thinks he has any value. Doubly so since he is disowned and has had everything he was born to be taken from him.”
“I’m not sure Bilbo is much better,” Kili admitted. “He’s snatching little looks at Uncle but he seems almost afraid to say anything.” He chewed his lip. “I think he’s seen as a bit of an unusual Hobbit and maybe…he doesn’t have that many friends? Maybe he doesn’t want to put Thorin off?”
“He lost his parents suddenly only a year ago and he’s been alone since,” Fili mused. "None of his neighbours or family have come round since we arrived…except the gardener.”
“Hamfast,” Kili added. “He seems to like Bilbo. But you’re right: no one else seems to be that friendly. We’ve seen the Hobbitwives in the market and they keep bringing us food but they barely exchange a word with him when he’s shopping.”
“Yet he came flying down the hill and laid into Lobelia when she starting shouting at you and Thorin,” Fili noted. “And they supported him then…” Kili’s face fell as a horrible thought struck him.
“Do you think we’ve harmed Bilbo by being here?” he asked urgently but Fili shook his head.
“If they aren’t friendly towards him, it’s not new because he would be more upset,” the older Prince guessed and then he sighed. “I guess we haven’t made things better for him…”
“Among his own people, maybe…but I don’t think us being here has made him unhappy,” Kili said and ran his hands through his hair. “I get the impression he really enjoys our company. He seems to like cooking for us and is treating us…like family.” And then he flopped back onto the floor, staring up at his brother. “We need to help him.” Fili slid down and lay beside him, staring at the whitewashed gently curved ceiling of the parlour.
“You mean you want to give him and Uncle a little…push…” he guessed. Kili laced his hands behind his head and sighed.
“You’re going to be the voice of reason and tell me it’s a bad idea,” he said but Fili grinned.
“No…I was about to say that Uncle deserves to be happy and Bilbo as well,” he said. “Just promise me that neither of us will own up to anything if Amad finds out what we are doing.” Kili sat up, shocked.
“Amad always knows when we’re scheming,” he said. “And you know she would disapprove. Bilbo’s not a dwarf and…” Fili dragged him back down.
“Do you want Uncle Bilbo or not?” he asked. “Because I do. And I want to see Thorin happy.” Kili nodded and lay back.
“At least you can protect me from Amad,” he sighed.
-o0o-
“Master Bilbo?”
The Hobbit looked politely at the hesitant voice, a smile crossing his face. Ori, the younger brother of Dori, was standing at the door of his study as he checked his accounts, totting up the rents that were being paid into his accounts at the Bank of Michel Delving. And from his rapidly expanding knowledge of dwarves, Bilbo could tell how young he was, his voice hesitant and polite, the bright naïveté in his eyes refreshing. Somehow, Ori had maintained his enthusiasm and openness that the others had long lost, taken from them by necessity as they endured the harsh treatment that the world seemed to deem dwarves deserved. They all developed thick shells to protect themselves against the hurts of their lives but Ori-and Fili and Kili-hadn’t developed theirs yet and Bilbo found himself warming rapidly to the younger dwarves because of it. Of course, he liked Balin because the old diplomat was incredibly friendly, interesting and reminded the Hobbit of his late grandfather, the Old Took. And Dwalin was polite and helped chop wood or accompany Bilbo to the market to ensure he was safe-especially since he realised that the Hobbit was a generous and thoughtful baker who never hesitated to have fresh fruit or hazelnut biscuits waiting for him when he came home. Dori was pleasant though wary, having found work in a haberdashery and being able to talk for hours on different teas to a delighted Bilbo. And Thorin…
Bilbo paused. Thorin had been treated more harshly than anyone and had every right to withdraw and be hard and reserved…but he had lowered his guard around the Hobbit in a way that had Bilbo delighted and flustered all at once. Thorin had been good to his word and had trained with the Hobbit every day, gently correcting his mistakes and encouraging the light-footed Hobbit to use his speed and agility. Bilbo was not as strong as a dwarf so he needed to use what advantages he had in terms of speed to fight. His grip was more assured and his handling of his wooden ‘sword’ much less clumsy, testament to the hours Bilbo had spent before the dwarves woke in practising. And every time Thorin offered a small word of praise to his friend was a personal triumph for the hobbit.
“Can I help you, Master Ori?” he asked. The young dwarf blushed.
“It’s just Ori,” he said. His hazel eyes were bright and his russet hair neat but decorated only with a few braids. “I-I was wondering if I could borrow some of your books?” Bilbo blinked and laid his quill down, gesturing to the overfilled shelves that lined his study.
“You are welcome to read any-though I would like them back,” he said honestly. “My father started the collection and I have carried on. I am afraid I’m a rather unusual Hobbit and I love maps and histories and tales of far off lands.” Ori nodded, his hand gripping a leather-bound notebook to his chest. His hands were-as ever-enclosed in knitted fingerless gloves and his slightly sagging knitted tunic rustled as he moved. Hesitantly, he approached the nearest shelf and lifted and green leather-bound volume with gold lettering on the spine.
“This one is in Elvish,” the young dwarf said. Bilbo nodded.
“I speak and read a little Elvish,” he confessed. “I suspect my accent is horrible but my mother was friends with Gandalf…” The dwarf looked up from his inspection of the first page and frowned.
“Gandalf?”
“The Grey Wizard? Surely you must have heard of him?”
“Tharkun?” Ori asked and Bilbo recalled the name Thorin had used.
“I think your people call him that,” he admitted. “The Elves call him Mithrandir.”
“I wonder what his real name is?” Ori said without thinking and then looked up, appearing slightly ashamed at the words. But Bilbo chuckled.
“It’s a good question and one that I have considered myself,” he admitted. “I suspect we will never know because though he claims he prefers Gandalf-to my face-who knows what he says to other races? He’s generous in his interference and very mean with any actual answers about his motivations or his true thoughts. My mother was a friend but she saw him as I do. Yet he was a good friend to her through her adventuring and he took her to Rivendell, where she met the Elves. They taught her basic Elvish and gave her some books. When she returned, she continued to meet them at the borders of the Shire and continued her studies. She used to take me along-it was a way to stop me wandering off on my own, trying to find them. And she exchanged letters with Lord Elrond for years until her death. He sent her many of these books-including the one you hold in your hands.”
Ori started and almost dropped the book.
“My brother always tells me that I should concentrate on my studies-I am hoping to become a Scribe and Master Balin has kindly agreed to be my Master-but I have always wondered about the Elves,” Ori admitted slowly, almost stroking the book. “I mean, I know the King and the Crown Prince say that Elves are our enemies, that they did not help us when Erebor was attacked but there are also stories that they have made great works, that they have done incredible deeds. And just as many speak so ill of Mahal’s children without knowledge and assume we are all the same. then why should an entire race be deemed to be evil when there is evidence to the contrary.”
“I’m not the best person to ask, since I may be biased,” Bilbo confessed, then rose and fished a slim volume from the bookshelf to his left. “This is a translation of that book that I have made into Westron. It may be easier to understand.” Ori’s eyes flicked down to inspect the rich green leather cover.
“I do not speak or understand Elvish,” he confessed. “Though I would like to learn…” Bilbo slipped the second book into his hands.
“And I would be very happy to teach you what I know,” he offered honestly. “It’s a pleasure to meet someone who appreciates a good book as much as I do.” Ori glanced up with a brilliant smile.
“Will you? Oh, I cannot possibly express how happy that makes me…” he gushed as Bilbo smiled then sat down, gesturing to the other chair.
“No time like the present,” he said as Ori eagerly settled next to him.
-o0o-
Bofur, son of Bolkur, was walking back towards the home he shared with his cousin, his brother and his brother’s family when he heard a small sound behind him. A miner with an unexpectedly strong stone sense, he drifted to his left, a hand brushing the wall as he briefly extended his senses to try to ascertain who else was there.
One dwarrow, walking unevenly.
He hefted the mattock on his shoulder and continued on, not breaking his stride. He was a generally amiable dwarf, well-known in the settlement especially for his ever-present hat, fond of ale and taverns and singing rather raucously, but he cared for his family and worked hard to support them all. His cousin, Bifur, was wounded from Azanulbizar and though he worked, his beautiful and innovative toys brought in much less than if he had been fit to toil in the mines. Not that even that work paid as well as it should-somehow, the Lord on the Council seemed to blame the miners for the fact the seams were poor in precious metals as everyone with half an ounce of stone sense knew already-and paid less than the going rate for iron and copper. The fact that the current copper seam was laced with mercury just made the yield lower and Bofur and his fellow miners were penalised.
So the last thing he needed was some dwarf tailing him and trying to steal what few coins huddled in his purse. Bombur, his younger brother, was worried because his youngest-a little girl named Milia-was sickening with something and they needed to afford a trip to the healers. So he listened hard as he turned the corner into the narrower way towards his home and heard the steps stumble closer.
In a second, Bofur had turned, the mattock swinging round to pin against the dwarf’s neck, pressing him back against the uneven stone wall, swathed in shadows. Bofur leaned close.
“What do you want?” he asked, his dark eyes glittering. His voice was tense. The other dwarf shifted and his eyes flicked up.
“No trouble,” he said gruffly. The hood he wore shadowed his face and something tickled Bofur’s belly. He glanced down to see a knife pressed firmly enough against his flank. But as he glanced, he could see a darker stain in the other dwarf’s side, the slit edges of his nondescript tunic clean from a knife-thrust. Bofur backed off and pulled his mattock away.
“You’re hurt,” he said, his voice concerned. The strange dwarf gave a humourless chuckle.
“I’ll live,” he said, tucking the knife away into a sleeve. Bofur looked up and his hand caressed the rock, his eyes closed for a second.
“Four dwarves approaching, running,” he said with a frown. “No one runs round here.” The strange dwarf’s head snapped up.
“Go,” he said urgently. “They’re not after you.”
Bofur drew back-then grabbed the dwarf and hauled him along. Though he resisted and cursed softly, he didn’t actively pull away as Bofur dragged him into a niche that he had known since he was a boy, invisible to those who didn’t know it was there. Pressed close to the strange dwarf, he didn’t need to tell the other to remain quiet as the steps closed and then thudded to a halt mere yards from their hiding place.
“Where is he?”
“He headed this way-hoping to hide among the rats and the miners…”
“Not that there’s much of a difference.” The laughs that followed were cruel.
“He can’t stay here for ever. When he emerges, we’ll have him.”
The steps moved away. Bofur rested his hand against the rock, feeling them retreat.
“You don’t sound too popular,” he murmured.
“No. I’m not.”
Bofur glanced at the passageway.
“They were in the colours of Lord Brago,” he added.
“Were they?”
“What’s going on?” the miner asked. The other dwarf gave a slight shrug.
“Nothing you should get involved in,” he advised honestly. “Forget you ever saw me.”
Bofur suddenly grinned, clapping him on the shoulder.
“Now that would hardly be a neighbourly thing to do,” he commented, offering the stranger his mattock. “My family don’t have much but I’m sure every ancestor we have would be yelling at me if I turned away a fellow in need. The healer’s coming anyway so you might as well come and be patched up when he checks over little Milia’s cough. And my brother makes an amazing goulash that I’m sure we can stretch to feed another mouth. It may even not contain rat…”
“You don’t know what you’re getting into,” the stranger told him though his lips quirked briefly at the invitation. Bofur pulled back the hood and crammed his hat over the strange dwarf’s reddish hair.
“You can tell me on the way,” he said amiably as they emerged into the silent passageway. “It’s not far now. Bofur, son of Bolkur.” The strange dwarf slung the mattock over his shoulder and fell in step beside him.
“Nori,” he said.
