Actions

Work Header

Blood and Iron

Chapter 33: Chapter Thirty Three

Chapter Text

Thirty Three.

 

 

Bilbo glanced around the tiny room he had been left it. It was little more than a closet-or a pantry. There was room to lie down, a pitcher of water and some hard waybread that Prason had referred to as ‘cram’ which tasted approximately like rock but at least filled his very empty stomach for a little while. He was grimy and aching and cold and wished that he was home-but he was also surprised to realise that he understood much of what was going on, because against his expectations, many people spoke Westron.

 

He had expected the dwarves to use their Secret sacred language, Khuzdûl, in everyday life and the fact those here didn’t was a bit of a surprise. He knew that Thorin spoke the language effortlessly and had been responsible for teaching his nephews and that Dis and Balin spoke it easily and naturally-though they had been asked by Thorin not to so they didn’t exclude their host from the conversation. But it had never struck him, though it probably should, that the rest of the Company didn’t speak Khuzdûl at all, either between themselves or even as curse-words (which they tended to use rather liberally, much to the chagrin of his Hobbit sensibilities). And Ori had told him that he was being taught Khuzdûl by Balin as part of his scribe training-so clearly it wasn’t universally spoken among many of the ‘normal’ dwarven families in Ered Luin. But that could perhaps be to Bilbo’s advantage as he heard steps approach and the sounds of voices.

 

“Where is he?” The voice was gruff, commanding and sounded very business-like. There was a pause and the sound of heavy, familiar steps closed.

 

“Regrettably, my Lord, I was seen by the Prince’s men and he demanded to see the Halfling himself,” the voice of Prason said, an unfamiliar respectful tone. 

 

“Have you forgotten who you work for?” the stranger growled, bristling with anger.

 

“Of course not, my Lord,” Prason said smoothly, his tone calculatedly even. “I am fully aware that my allegiances are solely to you and the Council you lead. But while the Crown Prince remains as the official and legal leader of Durin’s folk in Ered Luin second to the King, then I am bound to obey his direct commands, for fear of losing my beard or my life.” There was a grunt that could have been an acknowledgement of the dwarf’s words or simply and dismissal that the unseen Lord didn’t care about his servant’s fate s long as he followed his master’s orders to the letter.

 

“See he is not harmed and bring him to me the moment that fool has finished stroking his ego,” the Lord hissed. Heavy footsteps retreated and there was a pause before Prason’s steps approached. Bilbo retreated to the far corner of the little closet and blinked as Prason opened the door.

 

“You have an appointment,” the dwarf snapped, reaching for the Hobbit. Bilbo cringed back.

 

“Aren’t you worried your master will realise you are two-timing him for the Prince?” he asked pointedly. “We both know what you said was a lie-meaning you’re playing them off against one another. What do you hope to gain?” The dwarf grinned through his beard, his eyes cold and expression predatory.

 

“Advancement and the favour of the ruler-and whether it is the Crown Prince or Farag-which will make me rich and influential,” Prason said. “I’m not allowing some Morgoth-damned Halfling derail my plans when I am so close. So you will keep your mouth shut. Otherwise…well, both my patrons are powerful and dislike other races. Do you think Hobbits make good slaves? Perhaps I will suggest it…if I find my future prosperity compromised. I could make a killing selling your people. Literally.”

 

Bilbo allowed himself to be jerked forward and hauled out through a door concealed in the stone panelling, glancing around the smooth passageway with the embedded crystals in their little lanterns in the walls, casting a warm amber light that showed even this secret way had been finished with some care.  From what he had read and heard from his friends, the dwarves who had sought sanctuary in his home, he would have expected nothing less, but it made him wonder how typical they were compared to Prason and his colleagues, dwarves who would attack a peaceable land that knew nothing of their internal problems or arguments. Were most dwarves as callous and warlike or were they the exception? 

 

Prason jerked him forward and he almost stumbled, surreptitiously trying to straighten his shirt and fasten his waistcoat. He ran a swift hand through his tousled chestnut curls, suspecting he looked a fright and not in any way a fair representation of his race. And then a curl of anger tightened in his chest. He was only here to be any sort of representative of the Shire because he had been kidnapped, taken from his home by force by this would-be assassin. And though he would be polite and perfectly pleasant, as any Hobbit should be, he would never forget that the people he was dealing with were the enemy, evil dwarves who sold Thorin into slavery and oppressed the people of Ered Luin.

 

He almost missed Prason pressing two places on the wall and a perfectly edged door sliding almost soundlessly open to reveal an elegantly-appointed chamber. Bilbo paused and found himself shoved in, the door closing behind him. The chamber was twice as high as a normal room, the golden-grey stone walls polished to a high shine, gold-framed lanterns attached an intervals along the walls, along with maps, a case of volumes of dwarvish books and a wide stone desk, comfortable chairs behind and before it. A fire danced in the magnificent fireplace covered with carvings of dwarves fighting and a cabinet on the side was topped with flasks of wine and ale, heavy silver goblets laden with jewels waiting for use.

 

“So this is the Halfling,” a voice said, not as deep as Thorin’s familiar tones but carrying a hint of the same emphasis and accent-very different to those of the rest of the Company and Prason. A shape walked forward from the far side of the chamber, the solid shape enswathed in a rich deep red tunic embroidered in gold with hints of mail underneath and a cloth of gold shirt. A heavy chain hung around his neck, the gold gleaming in the plentiful light. The dwarf was tall, almost Thorin or Dwalin’s height and stockier in shape, His face was handsome with an elegant beard braided stylishly with beads and clasps and a moustache that was also braided. His long hair was golden, several shades darker than Fili’s, ands eyes were Durin-blue, though the shape was closer to Dis’s than Thorin’s. He wore a light circlet of gold studded with sapphires. “He looks like a grocer.”

 

The indignant Baggins part of Bilbo reared its head and had him bristling internally at the insult. He knew his father would be mortified at the words but though he was young and inexperienced, Bilbo listened. He had heard the description of things back in Ered Luin, of the way the rich treated the poor, of the doubts about the Crown Prince and the treachery of the Lords and he had watched the caution of Balin and Dis as they had spoken of their home. And he could still recall sitting with his Grandfather, the Old Took, who had ruled the Shire for half a century with wisdom, humour and political savvy that he had passed on to all of his descendants. 

 

So Bilbo bowed low to Prince Frerin, son of Thrain, son of Thror, affecting a respectful look.

 

“Your Highness,” he said. Frerin walked around him and inspected him with a look close to a sneer.

 

“He looks soft,” he commented. Bilbo hazarded another look at the Prince. Frerin’s eyes were a much paler blue than Thorin’s and lacking in the expressiveness that the former Prince’s eyes held. Frerin’s eyes were flatter, harder and seemed far colder.

 

“He tried to resist, Highness, for all the good it did him,” Prason reported. Bilbo bit the inside of his cheek to prevent himself retorting a reply.

 

“Highness, anyone would resist an intruder in his home, armed and hostile,” he said, his tone still neutral. Frerin snorted.

 

“Spirited. I suspect I understand what my brother sees in him,” he scorned. Bilbo’s head snapped up and his brown furrowed. “Oh don’t play the innocent, Halfling! My brother’s proclivities are well known in the family. Our Grandfather never realised all his fine talk of wanting to have control over his own heart was nothing more than him refusing to marry a decent dwarrowdam and do his duty to the family in producing Heirs…”

 

Not that you seem to have done that either-though you seem to have been granted a free pass while everyone else is falling over themselves to criticise Thorin. I wonder why?

 

“Thorin has been nothing but a perfect gentledwarf to me,” Bilbo said firmly as the Prince gave a small, crooked smile.

 

“You are fond of him as well,” he said coolly. “I understand his looks may be considered attractive to the lesser races-though to us, he is plain, if not unfortunate in visage. It’s only his station that earned him any offers.”

 

“Friends do not care,” Bilbo said quietly.

 

“You should!” Frerin snapped. “You align yourself with a dwarf who is the worst of us, a failure and a coward.”

 

“I doubt he is a coward…” Bilbo began but Frerin grabbed him by the arm and was suddenly in his face, his eyes flashing with hatred.

 

“He is if I say he is!” he roared. Bilbo stiffened, shocked by the abrupt change in the Prince’s demeanour, the rage and hatred flickering across his face, so similar and suddenly so different to Thorin’s. Bilbo found himself dragged across the room and flung into a chair, his side impacting painfully against the arm. Gritting his teeth and trying not to reveal his discomfort, he squirmed until he was seated more comfortably, regretting it was a dwarf-sized chair that was just a little too high off the floor for him. Frerin paced back and forth.

 

“You know-everyone is always talking about my precious, perfect, wonderful brother!” he spat, “Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thror. The Hero of Azanulbizar. The brave dwarf who led our poor, displaced people across Middle Earth. The selfless Prince who surrendered his freedom to secure the freedom of his sister and sister-sons. ALL. A. LIE!”

 

Bilbo cringed back, shocked at the hatred Frerin was spitting. His face was red and eyes dark with rage at his older sibling. Never having had any brothers of sister, Bilbo couldn’t understand the reality of sibling rivalry, though he had observed it in cousins and neighbours. In his heart he would have loved a sibling to share his triumphs and woes and to ease the crushing loneliness after his parents had died: he would never have soured his love for a brother or sister with jealousy or hatred because he had known his parents’ hearts contained more than enough love to overwhelm a dozen children.

 

“You know my brother is a failure-a rank, abject failure?” Frerin hissed, leaning close. It took all of Bilbo’s will not to shrink back but remain still, facing the Prince with equanimity. “Oh, he was always the favoured child, the firstborn son of the Crown Prince and spoiled rotten by everyone, from the King down to the lowliest servants!” Frerin said. Bilbo remained silent, recalling Thorin’s quiet words of pressure, of expectation, of eyes looking at him with hope and belief in his potential and future. Of the weight of pressure he felt throughout his life, always needing to meet their highest standards and feeling the disappointment if he wavered even for a second. It was very much at odds with Frerin’s words. And he knew who his heart believed.

 

“When the dragon came, my perfect brother was just coming back from patrol and he gave the warning,” Frerin sneered. “The Kingdom was in chaos but my brother never wavered. He had them slam the doors closed and he led the guard, ready to repel the invader. There was a moment of silence after Smaug raked the ramparts with flame, searing most of our lookouts from existence and then the doors reverberated with the impacts as he threw himself against them, using his weight and his flame to finally break in. The guard charged, led by my brother, but they failed. Utterly and wretchedly, they were swept aside as nothing, crushed underfoot and tossed aside. My brother should have died then, amid his failure to protect the mountain and stop the beast but he lived to see the dragon vanish deeper into the mountain.”

 

I doubt any dwarf could have stopped him, Bilbo thought silently. A fully grown dragon, the greatest calamity of our time, intent on seizing the gold of Erebor and already inside the mountain.  As far as I understood, once he was inside, the battle was lost.

 

“Oh, he ran after it and dragged the King back, crying and cursing him for making him leave the Arkenstone which Grandfather had dropped when Smaug reached the Treasury,” Frerin sneered. “He saved the King but lost the stone that grants our line Lordship over all Seven Families.”

 

Hardly his fault but that of the King, Bilbo thought quietly.

 

“I had to save Dis but our mother and grandmother were trapped by the rockfalls when the mountain shook from the assault,” Frerin said coldly. “Thorin was already out, pushing the King and Adad away from the mountain and organising the escape…”

 

“It was a terrible tragedy,” the Hobbit said and for a moment, Frerin looked at him without anger…but then his face closed once more.

 

“My precious brother didn’t hesitate to seize control,” Frerin said with hatred. “He led us away. from our lost home while the dragon was still making his nest. The Elves turned us away from their borders, the Men pleaded their own losses and did nothing for their Dwarven allies, driving us into the Brown Lands away from our own people. A few slipped away to the Iron Hills but they rest stayed. The King was crazed and lost, our Adad was floundering in misery and grief and my brother acted like a King, dragging us through hardship and starvation and hunger as we sought for our most basic needs. We sent out to the other dwarf clans but no one would help. So we travelled as a ragged vagabond people, starved and rejected and cheated by Men. And my brother, my perfect brother, cut his beard in piety at the loss of our people and home and went out to work himself to earn coin for food. He was a Prince and he humbled himself, shaming our line!”

 

“He served his people,” Bilbo said quietly.

 

“They are meant to serve us!” Frerin yelled, his eyes narrowing. “The workers brought in coin and food for the caravan and the Royal Family were fed first, as we should.”

 

“And Dis?” Bilbo asked. The Prince stared at him.

 

“I might have known she would go to him,” he spat. “When she wed that nameless nobody she claimed was her One, she stopped being Royal Family She took her chances with the rest of the rabble-her and her wretched spawn.”

 

“Your nephews. Fili and Kili,” Bilbo found himself saying.

 

“We could have married Dis off to secure an Alliance, maybe even better Halls than these miserable holes,” the Prince sneered. “But she insisted on following her heart, not her duty. And my brother supported her, persuading Adad and the King. They approved it-eventually. But I don’t. I will have my own Heirs, born of a noble dwarrowdam rather than tainted with the blood of  some worthless miner.”

 

Bilbo said nothing, hearing the voice replete with loathing. How had no one seen this? How had his family not noticed the seething jealousy and hatred within the second son? A sick sensation was bubbling in his stomach now, a very uncomfortable feeling for a Hobbit.

 

“So Thorin fed them as well, garnering the plaudits of the common dwarves while the King planned his next plan,” Frerin sneered. “Our people were wanderers, homeless and poor. Many died from cold and starvation and disease. And the King and Adad decided to go to Azanulbizar and reclaim Moria for our people. Thorin urged caution and the King called him a coward. He was shamed-even by his own kin.”

 

“But I thought he still fought,” Bilbo asked. Frerin wheeled away, pacing to the fireplace and staring at the flames.

 

“He did,” he said with anger. “Despite speaking against the plan, he was not banished by the King. Thror demanded the Line of Durin led by example, meaning his son and his son’s oldest son fought.”

 

“But not you,” Bilbo realised. Frerin spun and his eyes were filled with fury.

 

“They wanted me to stay safe, to remain with the woman and infirm and young pebbles so there was still a King if they all died,” the Prince snapped. “They denied me my chance of Honour, my chance to show that I was braver than my brother, more skilled and more tactically astute than my brother. But instead, I was forced to stay behind.”

 

Bilbo watched him silently, his eyes following the Prince as he paced.

 

“And of course, my hero brother managed to turn the King’s terrible tactical decisions and his own incompetence into a legend!” Frerin spat, turning towards him. “Khazad-dûm was occupied by our ancient enemies-an enormous host, led by Azog the Defiler. The White Orc had sworn to wipe our line out. He killed the King, beheading him. Adad was injured and my brother faced the monster. He lost his sword and he lost his shield and he fought the enemy with a damned branch. His own incompetence left him helpless and somehow it’s become a legend! He managed to get a sword and kill the damned orc but it was a disaster. Three quarters of our army was slain, we didn’t regain Khazad-dûm and the King was killed. Adad was traumatised and injured so my brother gave the order to burn the bodies, in violation of all of Mahal’s edicts. Our poor people deserved stone and he burnt them like trash. And they called him a hero and named him ‘Oakenshield’ for his incompetence and betrayal!”

 

“While you stayed at home, leading your people and caring for them,” Bilbo murmured. 

 

“And then he came home, leading our people and glorying in their adulation,” Frerin spat. “We ended up coming here, taking these inferior holes as our Halls and having to deal with greedy and manipulative Lords who wanted to use the Crown for their own aggrandisement. And my beloved brother played to the crowd, working with the witless common dwarrow here to help in mine collapses and when plagues came through and even working in the villages of Men to get more coin when times were hard. No one cared that I supported our Adad and waged a campaign to win the hearts of the people. I am the Golden Prince!”

 

Bilbo stared at him and considered his options.

 

“So why did you arrange for him to kidnapped?” he asked. 

 

There was silence and then Frerin started laughing. It wasn’t a nice laugh but a cold, calculating, cruel laugh. Bilbo felt chills down his spine as the Golden Prince hunkered down to look into his eyes.

 

“You figured it out, hmm?” he asked coldly.

 

“Really, there was no one else,” Bilbo said quietly. “There was no one else who really gained out of it. The Council of Lords maintain their influence-and I would not expect you or your sister or father to be easily manipulated. Lord Farag seems to be playing off against the Council and his agent is secretly working for you. You are the only one who gains really from Thorin’s slavery.”

 

“And why shouldn’t I?” Frerin roared. “I am a true Son of Durin. I don’t show off, I don’t associate with inferiors, I will rule with benevolence but a fist of Mithril. And I will rule those manipulative Lords, not the other way around…”

 

“But he is your brother,” Bilbo said quietly, his eyes inspecting the Prince’s face for any signs of regret, of humanity, of any emotion except shining ambition.

 

“And how sweet was it to hear of his captivity,” Frerin said coldly, rising and pacing to pour himself a cup of ale. “You know, my agents got the plan wrong? I told them to ambush the group and kill my brother and the guard. They were to capture Dis and the boys and then I would give the order and they would be released. I would be lauded for saving them and all would mourn my brave but lost brother. Except the Men got greedy and they took Thorin as a slave. I had to prevent the guard going after him-fortunately the Lords wanted him gone as well. It was easy to have him shamed, disowned and exiled, irrevocably leaving the Crown Princedom to me!”

 

Bilbo felt sick for Frerin was smiling now.

 

“And it was amusing to hear of their progress, of how hard they had to work to break his will,” he said as Bilbo recalled the scars he had seen. Not spying-no, not at all-but when he had arrived, especially as he began to trust the Hobbit, Thorin had accidentally granted a flash of his wounds as he had changed, always swiftly concealed. It was clear he was ashamed of the scars, for they were not honourably won and hearing Frerin exult over them turned his stomach. “And beaten and branded and abused and broken, he finally gave up. The Hero of Azanulbizar, the beloved Crown Prince and son, gave up, broken. I had him destroyed. They sent me reports, thinking I wanted to know of his continued existence instead of his death…but it was amusing to hear of his degradations, of the abuse and brutality they put him through. So against my will and in violation of my orders, they kept him for profit because he was a good slave…but in the end, I had to send my agents to kill him. And even then, they never returned.” 

 

The Prince inspected the Hobbit.

 

“Did you hear anything about that, perchance?” he asked mildly, his mien unsettling. The rapid switch between raging and reasonable was making Bilbo’s head spin. He nodded.

 

“There was a scuffle in the Shire-in Hobbiton,” he admitted. “Terrible business. The Rangers and the Elves were most angered at the incursion into the Shire which is under their power. Lord Elrond and the Chieftain of the Dunedain are sworn to protect our people-by War if necessary. They rescued Thorin. He came to the Shire to recover.”

 

“And you met him,” Frerin said in a singsong voice. “And you befriended him. And he befriended you.”

 

“I…”

 

“I have agents in the Shire-and informants,” Frerin told him bluntly. “They reported that you and he are inseparable. That you have housed him and defended him and clothed him. That you were close to him.” The Prince leaned close. “And he is close to you. And I know my brother. No matter what befell him, what degradations and torments he suffered, he is loyal. And if he believes he cares for you, he will brave every danger, risk every peril to rescue you-knowing that he faces death. And he will come.” Frerin walked forward and grasped his shoulder, leaning forward to the mad blue eyes staring Bilbo’s own.

 

“So you see, Master Baggins-all I have to do is keep you like bait in a snare, waiting for my heroic, stupid brother to blunder into Ered Luin and surrender his life for you. And he will. And when I finally execute him, there will be none to oppose the true King of the Longbeards.”

 

Taking a deep breath and swallowing hard, Bilbo stared boldly back, recalling what Gandalf told him after they rescued Thorin.

 

Dragon sickness is a strange illness, where dwarves feel extreme attraction to gold and precious jewels. It has afflicted the Line of Durin for Centuries-especially King Thror. But sometimes, dwarves can suffer the madness not for gold or gems but for power and control…

 

“Maybe you believe that, your Highness,” he said quietly. “But I have seen Thorin do whatever needs to be done and come through every time. He has survived what would have killed a lesser dwarf.” The defiance in Bilbo’s eyes plainly accused Frerin of the deficiency. “He has saved my life more than once. He is my friend and the most honourable and brave being I know. I know he will come because I know the kind of dwarf he is. But if you believe that you can defeat Thorin Oakenshield, then you are truly insane.”

 

The blow snapped his head back and his cheek felt numb. Frerin was stalking away, gesturing to Prison, who had remained motionless by the door.

 

"You should realise who is going to win,” the Prince breathed, his eyes wild with fury. “I could be kind to you. My brother is a loser, a coward and a naive fool. He will fail you just when you need him. I won’t, Halfling. I will be a generous master and you shouldn’t fear me.” Bilbo blinked, resting a hand against his scarlet cheek. 

 

“You can spin whatever lies you dredge from the depths of your envy-raddled brain but the truth is that you will always be lesser than him!” Bilbo told him evenly. “Whinging about his achievements when you have none yourself just makes you pathetic rather than noble. I would respect you more if you had made an effort to try to match him-but instead you want to take him down. Yet I can tell you that you will always be second to him! And I am his friend-to the bitter end.”

 

“Take him away!” he snarled. “Keep him safe. He is not to escape-or I will shave and behead you myself! My beloved brother is coming for his Halfling friend and we don’t want to disappoint him! After all, Thorin has come all this way home to die for his little Halfling-and I am not about to disappoint him!”