Actions

Work Header

Back in My Right Place

Chapter 2: Rivendell

Chapter Text

Sam looks at the warmth infusing Frodo's features and tries desperately to convince himself that it's the color returning to his master's face, and not just —as he knows it to be— the firelight from the hearth dancing its glow over him.

This is their fourth night in Rivendell, and still Frodo shows no sign of waking. Sam has held his hand through the long nights, and it has been cold, icy cold, however much Sam clasps it between both of his own and tries to rub a little warmth into it. Sam cannot be torn from this room: Gandalf has tried, yes, and so has Elrond, to drag him away from Frodo. They say he has to rest, but the chair by Frodo's bedside that Sam has stubbornly spent the nights in is rest enough (despite the protests of his neck and upper back); they say nothing will change just because Sam is there, but Sam refuses to believe that. How could he?, when Sam knows that if he were ill, Frodo's presence would make all the difference. Because Sam cannot stand the thought of Frodo waking to find no one there— or, worse, to find Sam not there. He can't quite decide which would be worse.

Still, Sam thinks, he looks peaceful. That much Elrond's magic has been able to do: he no longer looks pained like he did in those terrible days after Weathertop. Sam could hardly stand to look at him then: his face was contorted always in agony, and every step he took hurt. To see him like that and be unable to help him, to do anything to ease the pain even a little, was almost the death of Sam. But he stayed strong for Frodo, and he'll do so still. He'll stay strong until Frodo wakes up, despite how strong the temptation of despair is. But Sam won't crack, no. He's a Gamgee, and he's made of sturdy stuff, and he won't cry. Not though his very eyes prickle with tears he keeps barred, that threaten to break through the dam every time he lays eyes on Frodo.

Frodo. He's dressed in white: Elrond took him out of his dirty, tattered clothes for Sam to bathe him gently, with a sponge, and then gave Sam a simple white shirt to dress him in once clean. He looks saintlike amid the pillows and blankets of the bed Elrond disposed for him, but altogether too small— the bed is elf-sized, and Frodo, curled as he is in his sleep, looks small, oh-so-small in it, so small Sam sometimes fears he's shrinking. It doesn't help that the rest of the room is huge as well: the bed stands in the middle, imposing as an island between waves, and the room is sparsely furnished aside from the hearth facing the foot of the bed and the few chairs that Gandalf and Elrond occupy every time they check in on Frodo, their stern faces troubled. Sam feels small too when he sits in those chairs and looks at the room around him. But he feels smallest when he looks at Frodo and realizes there is nothing he can do for him but wait.

A rumor of voices comes from behind the high doors, which are thin and arched at the top. As it gets closer, Sam makes out a shrill voice and a gruff one, which sound a lot like they're... arguing? Merry and Pippin? Sam thinks, but no: one of the voices is much too low to belong to either of them. And one of the voices is much too high to belong to either Gandalf or Elrond.

Sam needs not wonder too much more, though, because suddenly the slender doors burst open and in marches Bilbo with Thorin not too far behind. For a moment, they seem to take no notice of Sam.

Thorin is in the course of a complaint: "...don't understand why we must wear the elven robes. What's wrong with our furs, eh? It's just because they're dwarvish, isn't it?"

"It's a question of respect, Thorin," Bilbo scolds him, his voice rising to the feverish pitch that Sam knows as a sign of his anger (or, at the very least, his exasperation). "They welcome us into their home, they give us clothes to wear, and you're whining?"

Sam notices their garments then: they, like Frodo and himself, are in white. Thorin, however, has slung a thick warg-fur vest over his own white robes, and if Sam knows him well, it was in defiance of Elrond and the Elvish customs, and likely the reason why he and Bilbo are going at it as they are right now.

"It's much too light," Thorin whines, shifting the heavy vest more comfortably over his shoulders. "But by all means, Bilbo, if this is your way of telling me that you do not like the dwarven raiment and prefer these cloths , then just tell me—"

Their bickering is cut short then as they finally seem to spot Sam. "Sam-lad," Bilbo says, the endearment rushing out of him like a breath, and he goes to hug Sam, whose eyes have watered at it. No one but Bilbo calls him that, and though he wouldn't want it any other way, he's missed it. The old hobbit squeezes him for an instant and then draws him away to hold him at arm's length, watching him. This gives Sam a chance to examine Bilbo as well: his hair is all white and wispy now, with none of the gray from eleven years back left behind. His face is even more wrinkled, but the spectacles perched on his nose are the same, and Sam is overcome by the contradictory illusion that everything has changed but nothing has.

"You've grown," Bilbo remarks. "You look stronger, and tanner. Hardened. Oh, my dear Sam, has it been that hard a journey?"

Sam's eyes water again and he can't speak for fear that his voice will come out cracked and dissolve into sobs. It hasn't been all bad, the journey, but he can't think favorably on it so long as his Mr. Frodo is still on that bed. That is where Bilbo's attention turns now, to his nephew shrouded in blankets a few feet away from the door, and the kind expression he's given Sam morphs into one of concern.

"It's a good thing we were coming," says Thorin, who also forgot the silly spar over furs as soon as he laid eyes on Frodo. The dwarf looks older too, the lines on his face deeper and his thick beard streaked with gray, but he is still the imposing King Under the Mountain that Sam was so afraid of as a lad.

"Yes, as always, Gandalf proves the wiser," sighs Bilbo. He turns to Sam to explain: "He told us your party was due in Rivendell soon, and we were heading over from Erebor to surprise you all when you were here. But you beat us to it."

"We had to hurry our pace, on account of Mr. Frodo's injury and all," Sam ekes out, the words finally taking shape on his tongue. His responsibility to Frodo, once again, overtakes his own vulnerability, imbuing him with the strength he needs to talk about these things. "Strider, and then the Lord Glorfindel. We came quick."

"So Elrond told me," says Bilbo. "Were you there when it happened, Sam-lad?"

"Aye," Sam says, his voice choked with the terrible memory. For a moment, he thinks —or maybe half-wishes— that Bilbo is going to scold him for not doing anything to prevent it, for being unable to keep this nightmare from befalling Frodo. But Bilbo doesn't do any of that. Instead, he engulfs him in a hug again, and this time a tear does manage to slip past Sam's defenses.

"How awful it must have been for you," Bilbo says, soothingly, and then Sam is surprised to feel a hand on his shoulder that can only belong to Thorin. The dwarf has never shown him outright affection before. "I'm glad you were there," Bilbo continues. "I know that, wherever he may go, nothing bad can happen to Frodo so long as you're there."

Although Sam knows that that's a lie —look at Frodo now, for heaven's sake—, he feels better just hearing Bilbo say it. They stay in the embrace for a moment longer and then break away, all turning to Frodo on the bed simultaneously.

"Can we approach him?" it is Thorin that asks. Sam nods, and the three of them stand near the bed. Sam takes Frodo's hand as he has for the past three days (more for his own comfort than Frodo's, he admits) and Bilbo peers out at Frodo from behind him, keeping his hands around Sam in reassurance. Thorin stands at the head of the bed and places a hand on Frodo's forehead, feeling the unnatural cold of his skin through his curls. "How is he?"

"Better, now," Sam says, squeezing Frodo's hand. It is his right hand, not the one along the left shoulder where the wound is, but it feels just as cold. "He couldn't move his arm for anything before. It was that herb as Strider gave him, at first, and then Lord Elrond's magic. There was a splinter, is what he said. He removed it and Mr. Frodo's looked better since, but he's not woken."

"Perhaps that's best," Bilbo sighs, looking over his nephew and thinking that he looks peaceful despite it all. Maybe that's the one good thing to come from this too-long sleep. He looks up at Sam, whose eyes are quivering with budding tears and whose upper lip is pursed in an attempt to keep himself from crying, and asks: "Will he live?"

The phrase sparks a memory of a long-past evening at Bag End in Sam's mind, from Mr. Bilbo and Thorin's last visit, when Sam sent a post-hobbit out to meet them with the news. "Yes," he answers, not as a certainty this time but as a wish, a prayer.

Bilbo's own question seems to have spurred the same memory in him, and he smiles sadly as he watches Frodo. "And to think we were so worried about a few bad mushrooms," he muses. "What I wouldn't give to have mushrooms be our biggest problem now!"

The three of them look over Frodo for a while longer, each thinking the worst and hoping for the best. Elrond's magic is advanced, but so is the evil in a Morgul knife, and if even a splinter has wrought this much damage, none of them wants to think of the very real possibility that Frodo might not wake after all.

So Sam does what he knows best, what comforts him whenever he feels even slightly uneasy: be useful. "I'm going to give Mr. Frodo his bath now," he decides, letting go of Frodo's hand and breaking away from Bilbo and Thorin to go to the fire. By the hearth rests a small pail of water with a cloth and a sponge beside, kept warm by the fire. Frodo doesn't need a bath, really, but Sam needs to do something with his hands other than hold Frodo's, or else he might break despite his better efforts.

Bilbo smiles to see Sam busying himself with Frodo, an all-too-familiar scene that reassures him that Sam, worried or not, is good old Sam after all. Something about the scene comforts him, because however false Sam thinks it, Bilbo truly does believe that so long as Sam is beside Frodo no harm can come to him. So he gets out of the way.

"Thorin and myself will be outside. Will you be joining us for dinner?"

He knows the answer even before Sam shakes his head. There is no way Sam would leave Frodo, not if —as Gandalf says— he has spent every waking moment of the past three days tending to his master. He'd have to be dragged away to do it, and by Gandalf and Elrond both at least.

"We'll bring you back something," Thorin says, and Sam is again slightly taken aback by the affection the dwarf is displaying toward him today. Thorin brushes his hand once more along the hair on Frodo's forehead and then leans over to press a kiss to his forehead, which is just as cold as it was when he first laid his hand on it. He mutters something in Khuzdul before he rises and joins Bilbo, who is standing by the door to beckon him out. The two of them give Sam a smile that they hope transmits confidence, before disappearing through the door to the courtyard outside Frodo's room.

Sam watches the doors swing shut and ignores the pang in his stomach, which has reared its head at the mention of dinner. He brings the pail from the fire and pulls up the tall chair beside Frodo again, setting the pail on the little table by the bedside. Carefully, he undoes the buttons of Frodo's shirt to clear his chest. From the thin brown curls that line his chest, the ring glitters out from its chain around his neck, and Sam curses it even as it gives him its seductive golden wink. He tries not to rip the thing from Frodo's neck, the thing that’s to blame for causing him this much harm already, and toss it into the fire. Instead, he focuses on the task at hand: bathing Frodo. Sam won't undress him, no, there's no need for that, but he'll rinse off with the sponge the cold sweat that beads on Frodo's skin every so often. He likes to think it makes Frodo feel better— and even if it doesn't, it makes Sam feel better to do it. He dips the sponge into the warm water and gently, delicately, begins to dab Frodo's forehead with it.

Through the solitary arched window that looks into the room from the courtyard, Bilbo and Thorin watch Sam as he begins to wash Frodo. They both look away almost in unison, feeling as if they are intruding in something quite private just by watching. Instead, they turn to the twilight-blue sky over Rivendell, seen from the balcony the courtyard finishes in. The eaves of the tall trees sway in the night breeze, which is sweet with the distant sound of lyres and elvensong. A feast is being prepared, no doubt, and even through his worry Bilbo's hobbit nature wins out.

"I don't suppose Elrond will have commissioned more of those splendid little fruit tarts for dinner this time," he sighs, yearning for the dessert of last time he and Thorin visited Rivendell, a trivial memory that has nonetheless withstood the years.

"Dinner?" Thorin says, disbelievingly. "A Baggins through and through, I see, if you're thinking of dinner at a time like this."

"Well, what else am I to think about? Frodo won't be made better by it, and Sam is with him. And we're in Rivendell, Thorin dear— of course dinner is bound to be foremost in my thoughts."

Thorin mutters something about Elvish food, that Bilbo can't quite catch but knows his husband well enough to distinguish. "Oh, you liked the little tarts too, don't pretend otherwise."

Thorin neither admits nor denies it, but instead scans the scene of splendid Rivendell before them through narrowed eyes. The words fall from his mouth in time with the sense of déjà vu that pervades him. "I never thought I'd be back here."

"In Rivendell?" Bilbo says, somewhat dully, though his gaze has turned to the scenery as well. "I should hardly have thought Elrond would've let you back in, after how ghastly you were to him that first time."

"He was in luck. I was worse to Thranduil," Thorin says, scowling.

Bilbo laughs softly and places a hand on Thorin's shoulder, his thumb rubbing the thin white cloth affectionately. "But do you like it here?"

Thorin wavers in his answer before deciding to be honest. "It is not my favorite place, that I will confess, and it still stirs some animosity in my heart. You must recall that Elves, to my people, are not synonymous with wonderment as they are to yours. Lord Elrond is kind, and the place is beautiful—"

"And the food is marvelous!"

"—and the food is marvelous, yes, but I might have been satisfied with just the one time."

Bilbo knows what that means. He steps closer to his husband and rests his head against his shoulder. He is too short to rest it on top, but he leans against the top of Thorin's wide arm. "Thank you."

Thorin puts an arm around Bilbo's shoulders, drawing him closer without moving him from where he leans against him. "It is I that should thank you, my love. I know this place is where you yearn to be. You claim to have outgrown the Shire, but your heart still belongs to the high trees and rushing streams, to the soft songs and light beauty of the Elves. That is not something that Erebor can give you, and yet you choose to live there with me."

"You waited for me," Bilbo says, softly. "All those years I stayed in Bag End with Frodo. You might have demanded that I come to play consort in your court, as I should have, but you waited and stood the distance and the years."

"It was you I was waiting for," is all Thorin says, and is all he needs to say.

They stay in silence, leaning into one another, before Bilbo speaks again. "You know, Sam spoke something of that to me on our last visit to Bag End, eleven years ago. He said he felt guilty about the fact that I stayed rather than go to the Mountain with you straightaway."

Thorin chuckles lightly, that small laugh containing more affection for Sam than he has ever let on to him or to Bilbo. "Ah, Master Samwise should learn not to think himself an inconvenience. But, all the same," and now he tilts his head to look down at Bilbo, "are you glad you stayed?"

Bilbo looks at Thorin, who has aged finely but aged nonetheless, and can only imagine just how much older he looks than when they first met. He answers, though, without hesitation. "Yes. I'm glad I stayed. I had my time with Frodo, and I got to live out the end of my love affair with the Shire before it became a drag. And now I have my time with you."

Thorin looks forlorn. "But it will not be a long one."

Bilbo knows what he means. Thorin has never said it, but the uneven pace at which they have aged —Thorin slowly and imperceptibly, Bilbo rapidly and obviously— has become a painful testament to their different lifespans. Bilbo isn't meant to have lived quite this long as it is, but Thorin may very well go on for a few dozen more years if he is as long-lived as his forebears of the Line of Durin, if he reaches 300. And he likely will— he has already exceeded, after all, the 250-year mark most dwarves reach, and he is still in excellent condition.

Bilbo sighs and looks away. "It will be however long it is meant to be. It is no use wanting for more." His hand drops from Thorin's back and seeks his hand, which is just as big as both of Bilbo's put together. "Besides, we wouldn't have had that time anyway. You were busy rebuilding Erebor in the years after the war, and that would've kept you from me. But we have time now," he says, and squeezes Thorin's hand. "Fíli's taking on more and more duties by the day, and he'll make a fine king. Which means you and I can have the years to make fine husbands for one another."

"If Fíli doesn't fumble it too badly. Having Kíli for a councillor is already unwise enough," Thorin grumbles, but his beard has shifted with what Bilbo knows is a smile underneath. Bilbo smiles as well. Thorin lets his thoughts linger for a moment on his beloved nephews, and finds them turning to Bilbo's own. "Aren't you more worried about the boy?"

"'The boy' has hit fifty, Thorin."

"Exceptional avoidance of the question, master burglar."

Bilbo sighs and knows he can't scurry away from a proper answer any longer. He looks straight at Thorin. "No, I'm not more worried. I've been worried about a blade once before."

The intensity with which Bilbo's gaze bores into him is enough to make the phantom pain flare up at Thorin's midriff, and he swears he can feel the scar throb. He knows then that it is the same memory in Bilbo's mind as in his own: Thorin stretched on a cot in a tent after the battle, wrapped in a bandage soaked through with red, and Bilbo kneeling at his side weeping what he thought would be their last goodbye.

Bilbo pushes through the painful memory and continues. "And you came out the other end just fine, didn't you? Well, Frodo will too."

"How can you be so sure? It wasn't a Morgul knife that threatened me."

"Because the boy is even more stubborn than I am," Bilbo says, laughing softly. "Besides, he has plenty of reasons to cling to life.

Then they both turn back toward the room in which Frodo lies. Through the open window, they can see Frodo's bed, and beside it, Sam holding his hand as he tends to him.

"Yes," Thorin agrees, his eyes firm on Sam. "Plenty of reasons indeed."

Inside the room, Sam has finished washing Frodo. "There, there, Mr. Frodo," he mutters as he does up the buttons on his shirt again, before deciding that they're better left undone so he won't sweat quite as much again. "All clean."

He tosses the sponge absently back into the pail and takes it back to the hearth, setting it down where it had been. While he is there, he decides that he can stay away from the bedside for just a little longer if it means he can poke some life back into the fire. He grabs the long iron poker and prods the fire with it, shifting the logs to increase the airflow and expose more of their surface to the flames. Satisfied, he sets the poker back against the wall and dusts off his hands on his trousers.

And then he hears it: a voice, so soft and distant that he's almost convinced he's imagined it, coming from behind. It is his name it calls. "Sam?"

Sam whips back around to look at the bed, heart thumping in his chest. "Mr. Frodo?"

But the voice does not pipe up again, and so Sam rushes to the bedside, already thinking he's imagined it in a spell of wishful thinking. And sure enough, Frodo still looks asleep, his position unchanged from where Sam left him. Sam tries to quell the disappointment in his chest, but he doesn't get very far, because Frodo gives a little cough and his eyelids flutter slightly. "Sam, is that you?"

His voice is weak and shaky, but to Sam it sounds like glory and trumpets. "Yes, Mr. Frodo, it's me," he says, grasping Frodo's hand between both of his own (as he has through all of these horrible days) and pressing it to his chest. "It's your Sam."

"I thought it might be," Frodo says, and through the drowsiness in his voice Sam thinks he sounds happy. "I don't suppose Strider would've been one to hand-bathe me, after all."

Sam lets out a laugh that sounds almost like a whimper, and then do the tears rush to his eyes again. This time, he doesn't stem their flow: he lets a couple run down his cheeks, overjoyed as he is.

"Sam, where am I?" Frodo asks, his voice wheezy.

"Rivendell, Mr. Frodo, sir," Sam says, internally berating himself for not having explained all of that before Frodo had to ask. "In a room in Lord Elrond's house. Have been for the past three nights and three days. He found a splinter in your shoulder, sir, and took it out, but with you asleep all the while." He does not say what they all feared: that that might be the sleep of death, because Frodo's awake now, he's awake , and it's almost too good for Sam not to pinch himself to check if he's dreaming.

Frodo pauses and, brows furrowed, considers this. "So we did cross the Ford, after all."

"Aye, that we did."

"Ah," Frodo says, burrowing deeper into the thick pillows under him. The movement sends pain shooting up his left arm, and he winces as he feels his shoulder throb. Sam's heart is wrung to watch the pain that streaks like lighting across his master's face. "All this for a splinter?"

"It seems as much," Sam says. Frodo's hand is still in his own, still pressed to his chest, and though Frodo has made no attempt to free it, Sam wouldn't want to risk it adding to his pain. He lowers Frodo's arm gently and sets it back on the bed, but doesn't let go of his hand. Suddenly, he notices the change he has been waiting for, so subtle it has almost eluded him. "It's warm," he mumbles to himself. Frodo looks at him quizzically. "Meaning your hand, Mr. Frodo. It has felt so cold through the long nights."

He strokes Frodo's hand gently with his thumb, and Frodo's face loses some of its anguish as he does. "I'm still dreadfully cold," he mutters. For a moment, Sam is tempted to pull back the covers on his bed and climb in beside him, wrap himself around him like he did the last time Frodo was sick and shivering, and use his own heat to warm him up. They could fill up that big bed proper, the two of them, and then maybe Frodo wouldn’t look quite so small. But as much as he longs for it, he doesn't want to overstep his line. Instead, he remains kneeling at Frodo's bedside, holding his hand— holding his hand, always the constant.

He doesn't think to call Elrond, or Gandalf, or any of them for that matter. Part of him knows this moment belongs to him and Frodo alone, and would do nothing to disturb it. So he disobeys Elrond's command to send for him as soon as Frodo stirred —Samwise Gamgee, disobeying an Elf!— and cherishes his being alone with Frodo, when even just his waking is almost too large a happiness for Sam's chest to hold. "I wish I could do more for you," he whispers, overcome with emotion.

Frodo stays silent, and Sam thinks he is simply letting the platitude dissipate. But Frodo is pondering, and there is nothing dismissive in his eyes when he meets Sam's. "How about a kiss?"

Sam's breath catches in his throat. Of all the things Frodo might have said to him, he never believed that might be one of them. Because Sam knows what it is like to kiss Frodo: he has kept the memory close to his heart since that night by the hearth, has turned it over in his mind in the lone nights when he found himself yearning. But Sam is decent before all other things, and however much he's longed for it, he hasn't done or tried anything with Frodo since that last time he was sick. So he blushes furiously as he tries to wave it off. "You're delirious, Mr. Frodo."

"And why should I be?" Frodo protests. There is strength returning to his voice, and his eyes are just as intense as they remain on Sam. "A kiss from you put me back in my right place last time, Samwise Gamgee. Why should it be any different this time around?"

This really is happening. Sam pinches his thigh surreptitiously and feels the sharp prick confirming he's not dreaming. Frodo really is on that bed, looking straight at him, and asking him for a kiss. "You mean it?"

"Yes," Frodo says, not even a second of hesitation. "Yes, I mean it, Sam."

Still holding Frodo's hand, Sam leans in as Frodo shifts his head slightly upward on the pillow. Sam lets his lips brush against Frodo's before they meet fully, and then it is better than he knew, better than he remembered, because Frodo's lips are fitted between his and moving, because Frodo is, eleven years later, kissing him. So much is the same: the crackling of the hearth, Frodo ill in bed— and yet so much is different, because Frodo has asked him for a kiss this time, asked Sam to kiss him just after coming back to life. Sam kisses him as if trying to put the life back in him: warmly, tenderly, his senses drinking Frodo in. 

Frodo doesn't move: he keeps his hand in Sam's and stays where he is on the bed, devoting every ounce of his frail energy to the kiss. The last few days have been so bleak, and Frodo has lived half in shadows. To be kissing Sam appears to him more lifelike than anything else: the tickle of Sam's hair as it brushes his face, leaning over him as he is; the smell of Sam, like sawdust and sandalwood, lingering despite anything the Elves have put him in; and above all, the soft weight of Sam's lips on his, coaxing him back to the living, bringing him back from the dead. It is all so real, Sam is all so real, and Frodo thinks he may have died after all, to be sharing in such bliss as he is.

Sam is the one to pull away this time, worried that he might be keeping valuable breath from Frodo, but again the edge of his lips linger by Frodo's, as if in tangible reassurance that he's still there, still real, and not going anywhere.

Frodo never opened his eyes through the kiss, and they are still closed as a smile crosses his face, again sleepy. With a contented sigh, he sinks back into the pillows and nestles into the bed. One of his hands goes under the pillow, and Sam knows that that means he's about to go back to sleep. He tries to come back to himself, away from the glee he still feels, and resume his duties at Frodo's bedside. He begins to rise to pull over the high-backed chair once more, but Frodo's hand stays him. His plea comes as a mutter, and would be lost between the thick covers to anyone but Sam. "Stay?"

And then Sam knows his right place to be beside Frodo as he longs to be, more strongly than ever before, and he smiles. He smiles because he knows he will pull back the covers, slide into bed beside Frodo, and curl around him, and —what's better, what's best— Frodo will want him there. "You don't even have to ask."