Chapter 1: On grief
Chapter Text
A few weeks after arriving in Valinor, Bilbo Baggins began to feel young again.
Not all the way, mind you. He was still nothing like the strapping young Hobbit who had raced out his front door huffing and puffing to go on an adventure all those years ago. Nor was he aging backwards, for even the light of Valinor could not reverse the flow of time. But there was a spring in his step that made him feel like a Hobbit of a modest eleventy-five, and he was no longer so prone to nodding off at inopportune times or losing his grip on reality. When he asked Lord Elrond about this curious happening, the Elf smiled and said simply that the land of Aman healed many things. He was still mortal, he had not lost the Gift of Man, but the day of his passing was perhaps a little further off.
Though they were nothing like the gardens in Hobbiton, Bilbo found himself spending a great deal of time in the gardens of Lórien. There he wandered aimlessly among the silver willows and yew trees, letting the birdsong and frogsong wash over him and carry his mind to peace.
As the old Hobbit’s mental acuity returned, strange memories began to drift into his awareness. Memories of what might have been – or perhaps, what had been? The memories were not troublesome (far from it: indeed, in them he glimpsed a lifetime of love and companionship such as he had never truly known in life, though they were shadowed always by some ache of separation), but they… niggled at him.
Bilbo frowned.
“The gardens of Lórien are thought to ease all troubles.” A soft voice emerged from the trees behind him. “Yet you do not seem to have found peace.” Bilbo turned his head to see an Elf in a grey cloak approaching his bench. She inclined her head. “May I sit?”
He looked her up and down. Though her appearance would escape his memory soon after they parted, he would find himself remembering the profound grief in her eyes, and a face shaped by sorrow. “Pardon my saying so, but neither do you. Seem to have found peace, that is, Lady...” he trailed off.
S he smiled, though the sadness never left her eyes. “You may call me Núri.”
He nodded, and shifted to make room on the bench.
For a time, both gazed out at the water, where the willows dipped their branches to glitter in the everlasting twilight. A gentle breeze laden with the smell of cedar and yew drifted closer, and the water trembled lightly with its passing.
“What is it that troubles you, Ringbearer?”
He shook his head. “I don’t rightly know,” he said crossly. “It’s only dreams. I don’t know why I’m bothered by it.”
The Elf tilted her head. “Dreams have power here,” she commented idly, still looking at the pond.
Bilbo let out a harrumph sound. “I’m nearly certain they didn’t start here, though,” he said. “If my memories are to be believed, the dreams have been going on for years now.”
She shrugged, cloak rustling from the liquid movement. Bilbo pursed his lips. He felt as though he were on the cusp of some great realization, if only he could remember. “Oh, confound it all! Enough about me. You seem to have plenty of troubles yourself, my lady, no need for this old Hobbit to go unpacking his baggage onto you.”
The Elf smiled sadly. “I do what I can to ease the burdens, Ringbearer, for grief shared is grief lessened. I weep for all those who would shed their tears in silence, for the sorrows which would pass unacknowledged in this oft-cruel world, for all the sadness that has been and has not yet been and may never be.”
A frog let out a loud chirp and hopped into the water. Bilbo watched the ripples fade away. “Pardon this old Hobbit for his bluntness, but that doesn’t sound like a very healthy way to live.”
His comment seemed to startle a laugh out of her, the sound spilling bright and clear from her lips. At last, she shook her head. “It is my nature, I’m afraid. Do not trouble yourself on my behalf, young one, for I am stronger than you know.”
He chuckled a little at that. “I haven’t been young for a very long time, lady. But I suppose that’s all relative to you.”
They sat in silence for a while. For a moment, Bilbo could have sworn he felt the ghost of a hand on his shoulder. He leaned into the imaginary touch of that broad, calloused hand, his mind filling in the details – the sturdy warmth of the body, the slight tickling of the beard against his face, the faint tang of metal and smoke – until he realized what he was doing, and shook his head to clear it. His eyes filled suddenly with tears. “Oh, I wish – blast! If wishes were fishes…”
He felt a gentle hand on his shoulder. It was not the warm, solid hand of his imaginings, but it was real, if ironically far more light and ghostly. “This is a land of dreaming, Ringbearer,” the Elf said, soft and gentle. “You may wish freely here.”
His hands clenched. He didn’t know why he was so affected all of a sudden. “But it hurts so, my lady,” he whispered around the lump in his throat. He looked up, and saw nothing but kindness in the stranger’s eyes.
Bilbo took a deep breath, steadying his shaking hands. “I wish – I wish we had more time together,” he admitted finally. He swallowed. “Once – once I would have cursed his name until my lips turned blue, for the hurt he did to me and to his people. How the very pride and strength and will that I – that I loved so much turned sour, turned to arrogance and brittleness and greed.” He closed his eyes. “But in the end – he came back.” His eyes opened again, and they were clear and unclouded by age or grief. “It was dragon-sickness, it was the madness that had taken his father and grandfather before him that made him turn against me, and yet he won against it in the end! And I was hurt, and angry, and betrayed – but in time, I would have forgiven him. We would have built something new and lovely and good… But he died, and I couldn’t forgive him for that.” He chuckled bitterly. “Oh, I think I hated him as much for that as for the madness, to be perfectly honest! I couldn’t bear that he fell. He was supposed to be good and strong and wise and just, he was supposed to be everything I wasn’t, and I couldn’t bear that he failed us. How awful of me!”
The hand stayed there, on his shoulder, in quiet reassurance.
He sighed, leaning back against the bench. “I don’t know when I figured all that out,” Bilbo said. “I suppose it just took time for me to sort through that whole confounding mess of feelings. But the other day – it was years ago, now, back when I was in Rivendell – I realized that I wasn’t angry anymore.” He shook his head. “I had been angry because he wouldn’t admit his weaknesses, but I had mostly been angry because he had weaknesses, and that’s just not right. Everyone has weaknesses, I know, it’s not fair to…” He trailed off, lost in thought. “But once the anger was gone, all that was left was the grief.” He let out a breath. “No wonder I dream about him.”
“In many ways, grief is the hardest pain to bear,” the Elf said. “The mind will twist itself every which way to transmute sorrow into anything else. But a wounded heart is like any other injury – if left untreated, it will fester and infect everything it touches. To heal a buried grief requires peeling back layers of scarring to reach the sorrow underneath.”
Bilbo nodded thoughtfully. “I suppose you’d be an expert in that, lady.”
Part of him couldn’t believe he was telling all this to an Elf he had only just met. But something about her invited him to tell her all his troubles. And wasn’t it better, to spill his heart out to someone he would likely never meet again? There was something freeing in confiding in a stranger.
He sighed. “So now we’re back to the beginning. I wish we had more time together. I loved him, I’ll probably always love him, and I forgive him. But it’s too late, and he’s gone forever.”
The Elf looked up as a nightingale hopped from branch to branch. “No soul is gone forever,” she said, watching the bird flit into a hollow at the base of a cypress tree. “And certainly not here.”
Bilbo blinked. “I suppose that’s true.”
He once again had the maddening sensation of a thought just out of his reach. He worried at it for a time, but when nothing came to mind, he eventually gave up. Perhaps the thought would come back if he just let it be for a while.
In the meantime, here he had a perfectly comfortable bench, and all the time in the world to rest. Bilbo leaned back in his seat, clasped his hands across his lap, and let the birdsong and frogsong carry him to sleep.
Thorin Oakenshield watched his beloved with his heart in his throat. Did Bilbo’s waking self know? Was there anything he could do?
Bilbo’s dream self popped into being next to him, and he turned to the Hobbit with questions in his eyes. Bilbo opened his mouth to answer – then his eyes widened, staring in shock at the scene on the bench before him.
“What is it, dearest?” Thorin asked. All he saw was the old Hobbit asleep on the bench, the grey-clad Elf sitting next to him.
“You’re – you’re no Elf,” Bilbo squeaked to the figure on the bench.
:Indeed I am not:, came the amused response. Her voice sounded like the deep tolling of a mourning bell, like a thousand voices wailing in grief, like the silence of a tomb and the rain on a deserted battlefield.
He gripped at his Hobbit’s shoulder, resisting the urge to kneel. From the way Bilbo’s legs shook, he could tell his love was doing the same.
“I suppose I have you to thank for all this, then?” Bilbo asked. “My dreams?”
The great head shook, the grey folds rippling with the motion. :Not I, little Hobbit. The wanderings of dreaming minds fall solely within the domain of my brother, Irmo, in whose gardens you now find rest.: Those two great eyes turned to Thorin, and he shuddered to glimpse the unbearable sorrow that flowed from them. :It was Aulë who was the first to meddle by granting his creation the Gift to reach the sleeping mind. My brother merely strengthened that thread, allowing one particular sleeper to reach back.:
“Then – what is your role in all this?” Thorin asked, recovering his voice. “Why are you telling us these things?”
:My role is that which it has always been:, came the answer, the whisper of wind over empty ruins. :To weep for what is lost, to counsel the grieving, to bring strength out of sorrow… and perhaps, to grant some small measure of mercy.:
Chapter 2: Travelling arrangements
Summary:
Bilbo asks for directions, and makes a new old friend along the way.
Chapter Text
When Bilbo woke, he was alone on the bench. He frowned. He could have sworn he’d dreamed about something important, if only he could remember. He remembered… the glimmer of stars, the ripple of water, a familiar presence beside him… but try as he might, he could not fathom the meaning. With a groan, he heaved himself off the bench and tottered off to find his pony.
Time never seemed to pass normally in Valinor. The ride from the gardens of Lórien to his little cottage outside of Tirion ought to have taken days or weeks. But a couple hours after setting out from Lórien, here he was, setting a kettle to boil as he sank into his recliner. The first few times he had made the journey, some Elf always insisted on accompanying him, and he smiled a little to think that even here he was still Old Mad Baggins (though the Elves were much nicer about it than the Hobbits back home!). These days they seemed content enough to let him wander on his own, although no doubt there was always a pointy ear or two hiding behind the nearest tree.
The next day, after finishing off a cup of tea and the last scone from his second breakfast, Bilbo set his saucer down decisively. “Right, then,” he said, to no one in particular. He stood up, tidied up from his meal, and made his way out the door.
He hadn’t even reached the white walls of Tirion when he passed an Elf in the road. “Excuse me, sir!” he called out in clumsy Quenya. He’d been getting lessons from one of the Rivendell Elves, although they spoke a different dialect from most of the Elves here.
The Elf tilted his head. “Yes, Ringbearer?”
“Where do Dwarves go when they die?”
The Elf’s eyes went wide. He said something that Bilbo didn’t understand, then repeated it, shaking his head when Bilbo’s confusion became apparent. “My apologies, Ringbearer. I do not have the answers you seek.”
Bilbo sighed. “That’s alright, then, thank you very much.” He tipped his hat at the Elf and continued on his way.
The Elves of Rivendell – or as they called it here, Imladris – had for the most part ended up in Tirion, the city of the Noldor, upon their arrival in Valinor. They tended to keep to themselves, for they had been sundered from their Amanyar kindred for many ages, and many did not even speak the same language. The arrival of their Lord had been an occasion for great celebration, for it was not long after he first set foot in the city that Elrond found himself once again host of all those seeking refuge.
The passengers of the White Ship had been gladly received by the Lady Celebrían, daughter of Galadriel and wife of Elrond. In her halls the new arrivals found warm welcome, and there they dwelt for a time, recovering from the long journey. But soon enough, Bilbo’s heart longed for a home and garden of his own, and so he was built a lovely little cottage to the west of the city. And Lord Elrond had his own task, for many of the halls of Tirion had long lain empty, and the Elves of Rivendell now set about creating their own House from the shells of the old. Still, the passage of time meant much less to an Elf than to a Hobbit, and Elrond seemed content enough to dwell with his wife and stepmother in the House of Finarfin for the time.
“Greetings, my friend!” Elrond said with a smile as Bilbo poked his head into the room he had refashioned into a study. “I trust you are doing well?”
Bilbo waved his hand in dismissal, tottering over to the chair the Elf had gestured to. “Oh, I’m well enough, well enough. No, I’ve got a question for you, I’m sure you know the answer, it’s the sort of thing you would know –”
Elrond laughed. “You are surrounded by the wisest minds of Arda, and you come to me? Old friend, I think you value my wisdom too highly.”
Bilbo shook his head crossly. “I think you value it too low, but that’s besides the point. I don’t know any of those other people, and I know you’ll tell me what you can.” He leaned back in his chair, fidgeting a little, then took a deep breath. “Where do Dwarves go when they die?”
Elrond stood, and came to rest his hand on the old Hobbit’s shoulder. “Ay, mellon nín,” he said softly, and Bilbo couldn’t stand the look of pity and understanding on his face. He wanted to brush the hand off angrily and storm out. He wanted to burst into tears. He did neither, gritting his teeth and looking defiantly up at the Elf. “Dwarves are the creation of Aulë, who they call Mahal, and it is in his Halls that they find rest,” Elrond answered. “But the living cannot pass into his halls.”
“Where are they, then?” Bilbo insisted. “The Halls of Aulë?”
The Elf sighed, pulling his hand away to stand near the window, looking out at the white city. “It is not so simple, my friend. The very nature of time and place are different here. I cannot tell you the path, nor how long it will take, nor whether you may reach it at all, for all this is subject to the will of the Valar.”
“But –”
Before Bilbo could say anything, a strange Elf burst through the door, stumbling to a halt in front of them. Her hair was red, her clothes green, and in her eyes was a dreadful intensity that dimmed only slightly in trepidation as she realized what she had interrupted. “Pardon the disruption,” she said, only a little bit out of breath. She spoke Sindarin, with a heavy Mirkwood burr. Bilbo thought she looked familiar for some reason, though he couldn’t quite place it. “I was told this is where I could find Lord Elrond?”
Elrond’s eyebrows raised. “Indeed, here I am. I don’t believe I’ve had the pleasure of your acquaintance, Lady -”
“Tauriel,” she answered with a deferential nod. It was the gesture of a soldier, not a lady. “Captain Tauriel of Greenwood, although I’m afraid that title holds no relevance here. Still, I can’t see myself as any sort of lady, so Captain it is.” As she spoke, Bilbo noted how she slowed her breath and relaxed her stance, as though reminding herself to be calm.
Elrond nodded, and gestured for her to come inside. She did, hovering awkwardly inside the door. “Very well, Captain Tauriel. And what brings an Elf of Greenwood to my home?”
She took a deep breath, and fixed him once more with that burning gaze. “I need to know how to get to the Halls of Aulë.”
Bilbo almost fell out of his chair. That’s where he knew her from! “You’re the Elf who healed Kíli!” he exclaimed. “And – you’re trying to get to the Halls of Aulë too?”
Those bright green eyes met his own. “I am,” she said, then paused. “Wait, why does a Hobbit want to go to the Halls of Aulë?”
“Why does an Elf?” he responded with a touch of irritation.
She tilted her head. “For the love of a Dwarf,” she answered simply. Bilbo spread his hands and she sucked in a breath. “Ah. I see we have more in common than I thought.”
Elrond let out a weary sigh. “As I was only now saying to Bilbo, I cannot tell you the way,” he said. “The way to Aulë’s domain is shaped by the will of the Valar, as are all paths in this place, for time and place are far more malleable here than they are beyond the Sea. And if you should arrive, what then? Only the dead may enter those halls, indeed, and only souls of Aulë’s making! Even the Valar cannot brush aside the places ascribed to us by Eru Ilúvatar so easily.”
Tauriel glared at him, chin raised. “I should think you would recall that an exception has been made before, Elrond Peredhel.”
He pinched the bridge of his nose, as though holding back a headache. “My grandmother Lúthien Tinúviel convinced the Lord of the Dead to release her love from his halls, yes. Lúthien Tinúviel also rent Sauron’s tower stone from stone, tore his soul from his body, and sent his master Morgoth into an enchanted slumber deep enough to pluck a Silmaril from his brow. Unless you are half-Maia, you would do well not to measure what is possible from what Lúthien has done.”
“Mandos is known to be utterly implacable, but Aulë is not,” Tauriel argued. “The Dwarves say that he loves his creations greatly. If it is what Kíli’s heart desires, perhaps he would see fit to grant our wish.”
Elrond raised an eyebrow. “Would he be able to grant it? The Dwarves are under his domain, but you are not. You are not even half-Elven, you have no way to lose your immortality. And Bilbo is neither Elf nor Dwarf. When the day of his passing comes, he will have no choice but to depart from this world entirely.”
“Well, I’m not dead yet,” Bilbo said, and the two Elves turned to him as though they’d forgotten he was there. “And we won’t know until we try it. A fool’s errand it may be, but there’s not much else for this old fool to do around here anyways.”
Tauriel turned to him. “Truly?” she breathed, green eyes wide. “You swear it?”
“No oaths!” barked Elrond. They stared at him, and he quieted. “I have seen too many oaths gone sour,” he said. “If you will make this journey, you will do it of your own free will, or not at all.”
Bilbo made a harrumph sound. “Yes, yes, of course,” he said, waving away Elrond’s concern. “But I will go with you. I would have done it anyways, if you hadn’t shown up.”
Elrond sighed. “If you two truly cannot be persuaded out of this madness, I will tell you what I know, for fear you might go wandering around all of Aman.”
Tauriel and Bilbo both looked to him with bright eyes.
“The Halls of Aulë are to the north of the Gardens of Lórien,” he said.
They waited.
Elrond spread his hands. “That’s what I know. Go to the Gardens of Lórien, turn northwards.”
“Well that’s not much help,” Bilbo grumbled. “But I suppose it’s better than nothing.”
Chapter 3: Into the Gardens
Summary:
Bilbo and Tauriel set off on their way to the Halls of Aulë.
Chapter Text
The journey to Lórien was no different than usual for Bilbo. It rather reminded him of his first few visits there, accompanied by some concerned young Elf, although Tauriel was much more pleasant company than his erstwhile caretakers. Unlike them, she didn’t hover, or make pointed comments about taking breaks. Quite the opposite, in fact – when they first headed out from Tirion, the Elf had brought her horse up to a clip so fast Bilbo found himself bouncing painfully on his pony to keep up. He had to remind her he wasn’t as young as he used to be. “And there’s no reason to hurry, now, your Dwarf won’t be getting any older.” She had smiled at that, humor clouding out some of that intensity from her eyes, and slowed her horse down to a brisk walk that didn’t jostle Bilbo’s old bones quite so much. What a bizarre turn of events, for a Hobbit to lecture an Elf on impatience!
Not far from the entrance to the Gardens, they were interrupted by a series of unusually loud and persistent birdcalls. They paused for a moment. “Ouch!” said Bilbo. “What was that?” Something had fallen on his head!
Tauriel bent down to pick it up. “Looks like a letter,” she said, handing it to him. A large bird landed on the ground next to them, peeping insistently.
“A letter!” Bilbo exclaimed. He opened it. “To those who would seek the Halls of Aulë…” He trailed off, and fumbled in his bag for his spectacles.
“What is it?” Tauriel demanded.
“Follow the path to the center of Lórien. You must not fall asleep, or venture off the path, for past the outer ring the Gardens are perilous indeed. Once you have reached the place where Sleep meets Death, look to the North. After that, you are on your own, for I know not what comes next.” Bilbo paused, adjusting his spectacles. “The bird will pass on a second letter, which I would request you not to open. Should you succeed in attaining the Halls, please see that it reaches its intended recipient. The bird is a gift, should the recipient choose to accept it. I wish you safe travels, and the very best of luck.”
He looked at the bird, which hopped up to him clumsily with an odd whirring sound. His jaw dropped. “It’s made of metal!” He peered closer. Tiny bronze feathers slid against each other as the mechanical bird tilted its head. He’d never seen anything like it, not even among the Dwarves of Erebor.
It did indeed have a second letter fastened to its leg.
Tauriel stared. “It’s so lifelike,” she said, her voice awed. She reached out a reverent hand, and the construct flew up to it, chirping repeatedly as she untied the letter. “Is there a signature?” she asked.
Bilbo squinted at the missive. “Tel-pin-quar? Tyelpinquar? I think it’s Tyelpinquar.” He scowled. “Hard to tell, it’s such an old form of Quenya. Do you recognize the name?”
Tauriel frowned. “It sounds slightly familiar, but I’m not sure.”
“What about the other letter?” he asked.
She shook her head. “It’s addressed from the same name, Tyelpinquar. I don’t know who it’s addressed to. There’s something that might be a name, but it’s written in Dwarvish, I can’t read it.”
“Khuzdul,” Bilbo corrected absently. “Hand it over, I can read it a little. Did you know, the runes were originally Elvish? Elrond told me about it. Fascinating! Oh, but your people stopped using them ages ago, it’s no wonder you can’t read it. How old are you, anyways?”
“Master Baggins,” she said reproachfully, passing the letter over.
“Oh, pardon me, I know one should never ask a lady her age. Doubly so if she’s an Elf, I suppose –”
“Master Baggins!” she exclaimed. “The letter!”
“Oh, yes, of course,” he said, shaking his head. “Forget my own head next. Right.” He squinted at the runes on the back of the letter. “Now, that’s an N sound, I believe, and that one there is A, and… Oh, it’s been such a long time. N-A-R-Ü- no, there’s only the squiggle on one side. N-A-R-V-I. Yes, that’s right. Narvi. Now, why does that sound familiar?”
From his place at his beloved’s side, the shade of Thorin Oakenshield's eyes were wide in shock. “Narvi?” he said aloud. Neither Hobbit nor Elf noticed, though the mechanical bird looked straight at him and peeped. “Why would the legendary smith of the Second Age be receiving a letter from some Elf?”
As they approached the Gardens of Lórien, Tauriel’s face grew tense and grim. Her eyes flicked warily to and fro, as though expecting enemies to leap out.
“What on earth has gotten into you?” Bilbo asked.
The Elf looked at him with surprise. “We’re nearing the Gardens of Lórien. We should be on our guard.”
Bilbo squinted. He saw nothing but the familiar mists and trees of Lórien. “The outside is safe enough, my dear. Lovely place for a nap. There’s no need to worry until we’re a bit further in, no use getting all twitchy just yet.”
“Do be careful, âzyungel,” Thorin said softly. “The Elf has the right idea.”
They didn’t hear him, of course.
“That’s my Tauriel!” exclaimed his nephew, though the pride in Kíli’s voice was tempered by worry. He, too, was anxious to see this through.
Thorin had known better than to keep this development from his nephew. The moment Tauriel had burst into Elrond’s sitting room, he’d raced off to grab Kíli as quick as his feet could carry him. The two had been watching over their loves ever since, although after the first few hours Fíli had forced them to switch off watches long enough to eat. “I’ll let you know if anything happens, I swear. But I’m not going to let this be like the time with Gimli all over again, that was bad enough when it was just you, uncle.” Now, though, they were both well-rested and fed, and it would take an army to pull them away now that things were getting interesting.
(Well. An army, or his grandmother. But Hrera was fortunately occupied.)
The Elf and Hobbit had just made it through the eastern gate of the Gardens of Lórien. They had said farewell to their mounts, for the Gardens were no place for a pony, and now they made their way forth on foot. So far, all was well. The grass was cool in the shade of the cypress trees, their footsteps landing silently into the soft dirt. The air was silent but for the sighing of the willows and the occasional birdcall, heavy with the scent of poppies and pine. Bilbo felt a deep calm settle in his bones. It was this tranquility which had called him to seek out the Gardens time and time again, searching for a peace of mind that not even Rivendell could bestow.
As they pushed deeper into the Gardens, the sense of calm grew stronger. Bilbo felt as though his mind were moving through thick honey, his eyes struggling to stay open. He had never ventured this far in the Gardens – even when he’d started to wander in this direction, the various attendants had always shooed him away. Now he supposed he knew why.
The various Elves and Maia kept their distance this time, as though sensing their intentions. After Bilbo caught himself nodding off for a second time, he decided this simply would not do. He started talking to his companion, though it felt almost blasphemous to break the perfect silence of the Gardens. Tauriel seemed startled at first, and perhaps a touch irritated, to be nattered at by an old Hobbit, but she seemed to catch on quickly enough, and allowed the full force of her formidable personality to enter the field. Bilbo was particularly impressed by the strength of her opinions on mushrooms. He learned far more about the agricultural exploits of the Mirkwood Elves than he had ever expected to know. They had just started talking about tea customs (a matter upon which Bilbo considered himself quite the expert) when the landscape… shifted.
It was a gradual change, at first. The flowers grew a little brighter, the birdsong a little stranger, the branches curling into odd shapes. Bilbo began to notice strange lights in the distance, bobbing and weaving through the trees, only to disappear as soon as he took a closer look. Animals passed to and fro across the path, creatures that looked almost like the sort he was familiar with, but not quite (for one thing, squirrels usually only have one tail!). The birds grew louder, until the air shook with riotous squawks and cheeps and chatter that sounded almost like words but were completely unintelligible. Fog swirled about their feet, multicolored lights staining the mist with rainbow hues, and flowers nearly as tall as Bilbo turned to face them as they passed.
They continued talking all the while, the conversation taking on a forced banality as the world about them grew stranger. He regaled her with tales of his adventures, and some of the more entertaining antics young Frodo had gotten up to. She told him about the time when, as a young Elfling, she had fallen asleep high in a tree, oblivious to her mother’s increasingly frantic calls, only to wake when a squirrel missed his jump and landed on her chest.
In this way they passed the time, as the colors and cacophony swirled around them, until it was all they could do to put one foot in front of the other on the reassuringly solid dirt path. Bilbo had the distinct sensation once or twice of walking in the company of his Dwarf friends, although the moment he looked around it went away. Strange silhouettes curled around them, figures that looked like familiar faces only to resolve into a tall tree trunk or an odd rock. They continued on. The chaos grew louder and brighter with every step, visions and sounds appearing as from the strangest of dreams, until all at once –
Silence.
Bilbo took a step forwards, out of the thick swirling mists that had surrounded them. Stretched out before them was an endless expanse of nothingness, a flat plain of black sand lit only by the dim twinkling of stars overhead.
All was quiet. All was still. There was no wind to stir the sand, no chatter of birds. Nothing but darkness and silence.
Tauriel stepped out from behind him with a soft shift of sand underfoot and stared wordlessly at the landscape around them. Bilbo found himself intensely glad of her company, all of a sudden. It was good to have another living soul beside him.
“That’s what it is!” he exclaimed in a whisper. It felt wrong to make noise in this place. Tauriel eyed him curiously. “We must be the only two living creatures in this place.”
The Elf’s eyes widened. “Where Sleep meets Death…”
“Now to find the road North,” Bilbo said, with a confidence he didn’t entirely feel. Surely he would know if he had died? No use fretting about it, in any case.
Tauriel looked upwards, towards that eerily clear night sky. “The stars are the same here,” she said quietly. “I know the way.”
Bilbo nodded, and followed her into the night.
Chapter 4: From Blackest Night
Summary:
The road goes ever on and on...
From the land of dreaming to the land of death.
Chapter Text
“Kakhuf inbarathrag!” Thorin thundered. “Where are they?!”
Kíli said nothing, his face white. They had followed Bilbo and Tauriel every step through those surreal Gardens. As the surroundings had grown ever more chaotic, the world around them had grown fainter and fainter, until with one final step they had been torn away, reeling, into the whirling galaxies of Gimlîn-zâram. Try as they might, the pool would not reveal their loves again.
“We have to keep trying,” Kíli whispered. “We have to –”
“Oh, no you don’t!” came a shout from the door. Thorin turned to look. Fíli was marching into the room with a decidedly stern look on his face. “You’ve been in there for hours. I don’t know what happened, but you’re not going back in that pool until you’ve taken a break.”
Thorin took a breath, ready to argue. Then he looked at Kíli. He winced. His nephew did look worse for wear. His face was pale, his eyes bloodshot, his whole body seemed to sway on his feet.
“But-” Kíli protested.
Thorin sighed. “Your brother’s right, Kíli.”
Fíli blinked. “What?”
He gritted his teeth. “We’ve been trying to find them again for hours, and it hasn’t gotten us anywhere. We won’t be of any use if we’re exhausted.”
His nephews both stared at him.
He scowled. “What? I can be sensible sometimes.” He made his way towards the door. “Besides, your mother would kill me if I let you pass out on your feet.”
Fíli led them to the nearest of the great dining halls, where Ori was already sitting, just finishing up his meal. He raised an eyebrow at Thorin, then filled up a plate for each of them. Thorin scowled, but said nothing. At least Ori wouldn’t try to get him to talk about it.
“Tell me what’s going on.” Fíli had no such compunctions.
Thorin sighed, and let Kíli do most of the explanation.
About halfway through, Ori got up and left. When they finished, Fíli frowned. “So the Mirror just… stopped working? And you don’t know why?”
“Don’t you think if I did, I would be doing something about it by now?” Thorin snapped. Fíli held his hands up. He was half tempted to pay a visit to his Maker – Gimlîn-zâram was Mahal’s creation, after all – but he wasn’t sure he wanted to admit the reason Bilbo and Tauriel were making their journey.
As he was lost in his thoughts, Balin came into the hall. Fíli brightened, waving him over. “Balin! You might be just the Dwarf we need!”
The old Dwarrow chuckled, filling up a bowl. “I heard you three might be in need of some advice.” He sat down and began to eat.
Fíli nodded. “My uncle and brother here were watching Bilbo and Tauriel in Gimlîn-zâram, and all of a sudden it flung them out of the vision, and they couldn’t get back.”
“It wasn’t sudden,” Thorin said. “Not at first. The surroundings started to look less and less real with every step, until all at once it disappeared.”
Balin nodded thoughtfully. “Where were you, when it happened?”
“The Gardens of Lórien,” Kíli said quietly. “On the path that would eventually lead them here, at least according to Elrond.”
Balin raised an eyebrow, and Kíli raised his chin as if in challenge. Then he stroked his beard, giving the matter some thought. “Well. Gimlîm-zâram allows us to see into mortal world, yes? I could not use the Mirror to peek on you in your workshop. I would assume it wouldn’t allow you to see into the Halls of Mandos, either.”
Thorin sat straight up in alarm. “Are you saying you think they’ve died?” he demanded.
Balin shook his head. “Steady now, Thorin. No, I don’t think they’ve died.” He frowned. “You say they are journeying to these Halls?”
Thorin nodded tersely.
“Then I think the fact that you can no longer see them in the Mirror means they are succeeding,” Balin said simply. “You said the landscape around you grew fainter as you journeyed on? It seems to me that means they were successfully leaving the mundane world, bringing them closer to this one.”
Thorin blinked. Somehow that had never occurred to him.
“But what if something happens to them? And what if you’re wrong?” Kíli asked anxiously.
Balin shrugged. “Not much you can do about it either way, is there?”
Bilbo did not know how long they had been walking through the emptiness. He felt no weariness in his body, though they had surely been walking for many hours without a pause, and the urge to sleep that had come upon them in the Gardens had long passed. He knew only that after a long while, the featureless expanse around them was gradually obscured by fog, swirling about their feet as they walked.
They kept moving. As the fog thickened, Bilbo began to see the silhouettes of tall trees around them, taller than the very oldest pines in the Old Forest back home. He imagined even the tall Elf beside him felt dwarfed by those towering trunks. The black sand beneath their feet became hard dirt. Though the air was quiet and chill as the grey hours before the dawn, it was not the unnatural stillness of before. A bird called loudly, and they both jumped, then laughed, so glad they were to hear the signs of life around them. A ray of weak sunlight trickled at last through the trees, and Bilbo could not help but pause for a moment, turning his face to the light.
The path continued onwards, and the sun became a more frequent visitor, painting the mist with beams of gold. Birds called out to each other across the woods, echoing in the morning quiet. Pale leaves of green peeked out shyly from behind the trees, trembling in their sunny spotlights. As the last of the fog was burnt away by the rising sun, Bilbo breathed deeply in relief, letting the verdant scent of moss and earth fill his lungs with life. They had made it through the night.
Deeper into the woods they went. The trees there seemed old beyond measure, blanketed in brilliant moss that almost glowed in the light that pierced through the canopy. Great trailing beards of lichen hung from their huge branches, blowing and swaying in the breeze. Ferns rustled as animals scurried about in the underbrush.
The trail led them to a clearing at the base of an enormous oak, with great knobbed branches that twisted out far above them, and a trunk so massive the arms of five men could not span it. Shafts of sunlight filtered through the tree-roof to dance with shadows upon the ground. It felt as though they had stumbled upon some ancient and long-forgotten temple; even the animals were quiet here. A small stream trickled between its massive roots.
The Wood-Elf reached out to lay a reverent hand on the mossy bark, before snatching it back with a look of awe on her face. She murmured something in Sindarin, bowing deeply. Bilbo watched her bemusedly.
“This tree is –” Tauriel struggled to find the words. “It is the father of the woods, you could say. This forest is – it is the forest from which all others sprang. And this oak is the father of them all. It is a great honor to be in its presence.”
The Hobbit nodded thoughtfully. “I don’t know much about forests, or where trees came from. But it seems to me that the trees here are very beautiful, and very old, and I am glad to have walked beneath their branches.”
Just then, as they left the clearing, there came a horn-call, clear and deep. It echoed through the woods, shaking the trees and driving the birds from their branches. Then came the thundering of hooves, beasts crashing through the underbrush. An enormous stag burst across their path, great hounds baying at his heels. Bilbo turned to Tauriel, questions in his eyes, and then –
the Huntsman arrived.
Bilbo froze. Hobbits, as a race, held perhaps some things in common with the sorts of small mammals that spent their days being hunted by large beasts, and it was this aspect of him which took over in that moment.
He remembered only the vaguest of impressions, in the end. Of a great white steed towering far overhead, its gold-shod hooves stamping on the mossy dirt. Of a pair of antlers, stretched out above him so high as to nearly brush the canopy. Of amber eyes like a wolf’s that seemed to pierce through him and pin his very bones to the earth. Those eyes – that turned to the Wood-Elf beside him. The mighty head nodded, once, as if in recognition.
Then the pale horse reared up, and the Huntsman thundered past them in pursuit of his prey, his host of spirits fast behind. All at once, Bilbo was overtaken by a rush of wild energy, the urge to run and chase and kill. The next thing he knew, he and Tauriel were racing behind the Huntsman, running along beside the host of wild spirits that followed in his wake. He had never before felt such a frenzied need to run, to feel the wind on his face, feet pounding into the earth. His aging, frail body felt like it had been left behind in the Garden of Dreams, for now he was racing without pause for breath, faster than he’d ever run in his youth. He kept pace somehow with Tauriel, who seemed as transformed as he, eyes wild with bloodlust. Through the woods they ran, over fallen logs and trickling streams, never stumbling over stones or running out of breath. From time to time they passed what seemed to be shades of Elves wandering between the trees, though they showed no sign of noticing their passing. One or two of the faces seemed familiar, and Bilbo spared a fleeting thought to wonder if the Elves they passed were in the world of the living, superimposed onto the ancient woods through which they traveled.
At last they stumbled out of the woods into a vast field. The white stag was running far ahead, great hounds barking at its heels. The Huntsman drew his bow. An arrow flew – and the stag fell.
The Hunt dissipated as they gathered up their kill and returned to the forest. The wildness that had run through the old Hobbit’s veins suddenly disappeared, and he stumbled to a halt, staring at the sea of grass spread out before them. At the other end of the vast field of waving grain there rose a tall mountain.
Bilbo sat down on a rock in the shade of the trees, weariness finally catching up with him. Out in the field, the midday sun beat hot overhead. Tauriel stepped up beside him, gazing out at the mountain beyond.
“Do you suppose this is it, then?” Bilbo asked after a while, when his feet had stopped their aching and his head had stopped spinning.
The Elf squinted at the sun overhead, then shook her head. “I cannot tell how far we have been, nor in what direction we have traveled, not from the position of the Sun, and the nature of the Hunt is disorienting enough that I do not trust my memory.” She bit her lip. "Although I suppose there is one thing I can try." She reached a reverent hand to the trunk of the nearest tree, closing her eyes. Bilbo watched curiously.
After a few minutes, she took her hand away. She sat down shakily on the rock beside him. “It is here,” she said at last, slowly, each word falling unhurriedly from her lips. “The trees speak of a place to the South where the Sun does not shine. And there are none of their kin in the Mountain, only the quick folk of stone and axes, and their Maker, He who is bound to the Green Lady.” She closed her eyes for a few breaths, some color returning to her face. She smiled crookedly at Bilbo’s concerned expression. “It is not usually so, ah, intense as this, speaking to the trees. Or listening, rather, more than speaking. But I do not know these woods as I do my own, and the trees here are… very old, and very powerful.”
“Like speaking to, oh, I don’t know, Lord Elrond, rather than your fellow guardsmen,” Bilbo suggested.
Tauriel smiled. “That is an apt comparison, I suppose. Though even he is not so ancient as these trees.”
Bilbo nodded, then stood. “Well. Nothing to it, then. Just a nice flat field to cross, and then a Mountain to get into.” He paused. “I wonder if it’s got a secret door? Dwarves do like their secret doors. And I’ve some experience opening secret doors into mountains.”
They began making their way through the field of waving grain. The sun beat hot on their backs. Bits of grass and seed stuck to their sweaty skin as they passed. Bilbo could only just see above the grass, if he stood on the very tips of his toes and craned his neck as far as he could. Far off in the distance, they saw what looked like enormous blossoming trees moving about, bending down like farmers tending to the fields.
They trekked onwards well into afternoon. The wind traced rippling paths through the sea of gold, insects and birds filling the air with buzzes and chirps, mountain looming ever larger in the distance. At long last, the grass faded away, and they stood before the rocky cliffs of the mountainside.
“Now what?” Bilbo wondered aloud.
Tauriel raised an eyebrow at him. “Aren’t you an expert in secret Dwarven doors?”
He huffed. “There was a path, last time! We had at least some idea where the door was, if not how to open it. This door could be on the other side of the mountain for all we know!” He kicked a pebble in annoyance. “You had a better vantage point, back there. See anything that looked door-shaped?”
The Elf shook her head. “From a distance, all I could see was rock and cliffside. That’s all I can see from up close, as well, in all honesty. I have not the skill to distinguish one rock from another.”
“Wait a minute.” Bilbo squinted up at her. “Aren’t the Halls of the Elvenking in Mirkwood underground? Sealed by magic stone doors, even?”
She shifted under his gaze. “That’s different.”
Now it was Bilbo’s turn to raise an eyebrow. “Of course.”
They split up, wandering around the base of the mountain. The light turned golden as the Sun wandered into evening, bathing the rippling grass in soft amber. At long last Bilbo, scrambling over a rocky ridge, spotted something.
“A path!” he shouted to Tauriel across the ridge. “Look there! A path, in the grass!”
Down in the field, the waving grain had parted to reveal a winding path leading straight to a side of the mountain. As the two hurried to follow it, they heard the faintest echoes of strange voices on the wind.
“My love,” came a voice like a thousand hammers ringing on stone, like the crashing of rocks in the deep, like the echoes of marching footsteps in a cavern. “Did you have to lead them straight to my doorstep?”
Bilbo and Tauriel exchanged looks, then started walking faster.
“They’ve been trying so hard, the poor dears.” This voice sounded like the sigh of grass in the wind, like the creaking of branches, like the rustle of fruits swollen to harvest. “I’ve always been fond of Hobbits. And it’s so untidy, to leave all these sundered lovers wandering about.”
The first voice sighed, air pumping through a hundred bellows.
“They’d have found the way eventually, my dear,” the grass whispered gently. “This just sped things along a little.”
Chapter 5: The Mountain
Summary:
They've reached the Halls of Aulë. Now what?
Chapter Text
It wasn’t a secret door.
Bilbo was almost put out by this. He’d come all this way, expecting to find the most secret of all secret Dwarvish mountain doors, and the fact that the door was standing right there as plain as could be was almost a disappointment. Though the shape of the rocks around it had cleverly hidden the entryway from view from most angles, when they followed the path to approach it straight on, the archway through the stone became quite visible.
And it wasn’t even locked! Though the great stone door was heavy, the two of them pushing as hard as they could managed to shove it open a crack, just enough for them to slip through.
The great door swung shut behind them, and they were plunged into absolute darkness.
A hand landed on the top of his head, and Bilbo let out a strangled shout of alarm, the sound echoing in the stifling blackness.
“Apologies, Master Baggins,” came Tauriel’s voice from above his shoulder, and he relaxed minutely. He grabbed her hand and guided it to his shoulder.
“Can’t see a damn thing,” he grumbled. “Now where do we go?”
“That,” came a voice like rolling thunder, “is up to you.”
Thorin was in his workshop when he felt a small tug beneath his heart. He paused, setting the hammer down. A death? None of his relatives were ill, that he knew of, and Erebor had been enjoying a period of well-earned peace and prosperity. He frowned. Perhaps he had been working too long.
Then the tug came once more, and suddenly, he knew.
Bilbo?!
He tore off his smithing apron, setting aside his work, and raced to the Halls, heart thundering in his throat. Kíli was already there when he arrived. Their eyes met, and Thorin saw his own desperate hopefulness reflected in his nephew’s eyes.
One by one, the old Company trickled in, a mixture of excitement and confusion. Balin and Fíli were first, and they knew enough not to ask any questions. The rest had no such restraint.
First came Ori and Nori. “Bilbo’s here?” exclaimed Nori, and Ori shushed him. “But he’s not a Dwarf!”
Fíli rolled his eyes. “Obviously! They’ve been trying to get around that –“
“They?”
“The Elf my brother’s so fond of, she’s coming too –“
“What?!”
“Why’s Bilbo here?” That was Oín, calling from across the hall as he jogged towards them.
Fíli glared at him. “He’s coming with Tauriel to find a way in –“
“Will you all SHUT UP BACK THERE?!” Thorin roared.
There was blessed silence, for a moment, and then –
“Brother? Why are you here?” Frerin poked his head into the hall.
He groaned.
Tauriel’s hand tightened on Bilbo’s shoulder. “Who are you?” she called into the blackness. “Show yourself!”
“You would do well not to speak so harshly, when you have entered these Halls uninvited,” the voice answered from all around them, echoing in the darkness. “You are no children of mine.”
Bilbo heard a sharp intake of breath from the Elf at his shoulder. “Quite sorry to impose,” he said. “We didn’t know how to go about scheduling something in advance, you see. I wouldn’t normally drop in unannounced.”
There was silence. Then a faint rumble, like rocks falling in a cavern. Was that a chuckle? Emboldened, Bilbo took a step forward, reaching out a hand. “Bilbo Baggins, pleased to meet you. And I assume you are -” the owner of this establishment? “- the one we’ve come to speak to?”
The rumble came again, louder this time, and the very floor shook with the great being’s laughter. An enormous, gnarled finger placed itself in Bilbo’s hand. He shook it.
“I am the Maker, He who the Elves call Aulë and who the Dwarves call Mahal, and these are my Halls you have entered.” The hand pulled itself away. “I know well who you are, Bilbo Baggins, aye, and Tauriel o Calentaur, for your names have been spoken to me many times of late. Yet you are not my children. I cannot see into your hearts, for I did not make them. And so I ask: for what reason have you come to my Halls?”
“For love of a Dwarf,” answered Tauriel, the same words she had spoken in Elrond’s study so long ago.
“And you, Bilbo Baggins?” the voice asked.
Bilbo took a deep breath, then nodded. “I was told this is where Dwarves go when they die. Well, I’m here. I’d like to speak to Thorin Oakenshield, please.”
The voice sighed, a gust of wind sweeping through the cavern. “It is not so simple, I’m afraid. Any decision you take here will be irreversible.”
“Then I have one question for you first,” Bilbo said. “In dreams, I have spoken with Thorin many times. Were those dreams real? Was that really Thorin’s spirit I was speaking to?”
A thousand hammers struck as one. “Yes.”
Bilbo nodded to himself. “Then I want to stay here.”
“Are you certain, both of you? There is no sunlight nor a single green growing thing in this lightless place, and you do not find joy in craft like my children.”
“I am certain,” said Tauriel.
“I ask again, are you sure?” the Vala asked. “You would give up your immortality to live among a people who have warred with your own for centuries. Though you have some allies here, many will not take kindly to your presence. You will never see your kindred again, nor any other Elf. Are you prepared to live among a foreign and likely hostile people, in dark, lifeless halls, from now until the end of the world?”
“I –” The Elf fell silent. “I do not know,” she said finally, her voice troubled. “Had my spirit remained in Middle Earth, I would have stayed among the trees of Greenwood with my kindred until my soul faded into the earth. There is nothing for me in Valinor – a few friends may come over the water, as the last of the Elves leave Middle Earth, but that is not enough to hold me here. Yet I cannot return to Middle Earth, for the last of my kind will be coming here soon enough. And to be honest, the Elves of this place are as strange to me as the Dwarves. To stay here, in these Halls – at least I would have Kíli.” Her hand tightened on Bilbo’s shoulder. “I must admit that the prospect of spending an eternity here is… daunting, but it’s better than the alternative.”
Bilbo felt the weight of Aulë’s gaze turn to him, and he shrugged. “At least this way I’d have some clue where my soul was going to go in the end. And I’m a good bit more certain of my reception than Tauriel.” The lack of greenery was going to be depressing, but he had a suspicion he might be able to set up some sort of greenhouse. The dwarves could do wonderful things with lights…
“I see.” The Vala let out a breath. “I am not Mandos. I am a Father and a Maker, not an Arbiter. Perhaps I could do as I have described, and seal your souls away in my domain for all eternity – yet I do not know if you would thrive here, nor if my children would thrive, and that is my primary concern. Yet neither am I inclined to leave things as they are, for you are not the only ones who have suffered under the separation of the afterlives.”
The air was silent for a while. Then Aulë spoke. “These Halls, like the Halls of Mandos, exist in a space between Life and Death. They are neither fully subject to the laws of matter, nor entirely free from them. As they are on the same level of reality, so to speak, it is possible to create a path of sorts between them.” He paused, and Bilbo felt his frown. “It is difficult to speak of this in mortal tongues.”
Bilbo tilted his head. “So you’re saying we can have visitation rights?”
This time he wasn’t startled by the thunderous roar of the Great Smith’s laughter, though it shook the very floor beneath his feet.
“Yes, precisely!” Aulë exclaimed, his great booming voice echoing all around them. “I will have to discuss it with Mandos, of course, but it would simplify things a great deal.”
The Vala was silent, then, though Bilbo could have sworn he heard the echoes of voices all around, too faint to make out. Just when he was starting to wonder if they had been left alone in the dark room, he heard a rumble from above.
“That was—unexpected,” came Aulë’s voice at last. “It seems Namo’s siblings have both taken interest in this little puzzle. It was not so difficult to convince him as I had thought.”
Bilbo blinked. “You can do it, then? Create a back door between the two afterlives?”
“Yes,” the Vala said. “Now all that remains is the question of your mortality, little Hobbit. Unlike your friend here, you will not stay long in the Halls of Mandos before departing this world entirely.”
“Is there no way for me to give up my immortality?” Tauriel asked.
“You are no half-Elf,” Aulë said, not unkindly. “Your immortality is not yours to give.”
“Wait a moment,” Bilbo said suddenly. He felt their attention shift to him, and he crossed his arms. “It seems to me that Tauriel here has a bit too much life, and I have a bit too little. Can’t you just… mix them up? Give me a touch of her immortality, I give her a bit of mortality, and we end up nicely in the middle just like the Dwarves?”
There was silence. Again came the faint echo of voices, the rustle of leaves, the roar of the sea, the rattle of bones. Then Bilbo heard a sound like a pebble falling onto stone. Then another, and another, until the whole Mountain shook. “An unorthodox way of putting it, but that would be the basic principle, yes,” said the crashing rocks. The roar subsided, the echoes swallowed up by the darkness. “Although your estimate is slightly off.”
Bilbo let out an involuntary squeak as that huge stone hand plucked him off the ground and lifted him up in the air. “Hmm,” came a faint rumble. Though Bilbo still could not make out anything in the darkness, it felt like he was being examined closely. “Yes, I do believe that will work.”
After a moment, the Vala set him gently back down. He stumbled a little, still disoriented from the sudden displacement. “I’m afraid it will not be immediate, however. You will live for a while longer. Walk aboveground, in the sunlight, among all those green growing things that you will find not in my Halls.”
“Must we wait?!” Tauriel protested.
“Patience, child,” the Great Smith chided gently. “You must learn to live for yourself. Not for your people, not for your beloved, but for your own sake. You must learn how to live when there is no greater purpose driving you.” A pause. “As for you, Bilbo, I suspect you have unfinished business yet. There is knowledge to be sought, vegetables to plant, Elves to pester with endless questions.”
Bilbo snorted. “That’s true enough. I’ve plenty of other things to do in the meantime, I’d rather not die right away.”
“Very well,” said Aulë. “Then I will carve away a sliver of your immortality, Tauriel, and fold it into Bilbo’s soul, until it has the strength to stay in this world after the body has failed.” He paused. “I should warn you, this will forge a permanent connection between your souls. You will be bound to the same fate. Additionally, Bilbo, you will probably live a bit longer than you otherwise would, although I would be surprised if it added more than a decade or two to your lifespan.”
“So how will this work?” Bilbo asked. “Will I just show up back here when I die?”
“When you die, both of you will appear in the Halls of Mandos,” he answered. “Remind him of our arrangement, and he will show you the way to my Halls. From there, you may consider yourselves free to travel between the two Halls as you so choose. Should you consent to bind your souls together, Tauriel, you will give up your ability to be re-embodied, and never again will you walk among the living until Arda is remade. In return, Bilbo’s spirit will reside in our Halls until the end of time. Is this your will?”
“Yes,” said Tauriel. She sounded very certain.
“Mine as well,” Bilbo said when he felt the Vala’s gaze on him. The prospect of sharing a soul with an Elf he’d met only twice was a bit odd, but by this point he felt like he knew her quite well (for there was nothing like a shared adventure to get to know someone). In any case, Bilbo felt there were far worse people to be spiritually bonded to.
“Then let us begin,” Aulë said. “This will feel a bit strange, I’m afraid –”
Chapter 6: The Next Adventure
Summary:
After some soul transmutation, the weary travelers get to pay a short visit to some old friends. Then Bilbo ropes Gandalf into an adventure (oh, how the tables have turned!)
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
“What’s taking so long?” Kíli whispered. All the members of the old Company, those who were not still living, had gathered in front of the door, as well as some of Thorin’s family who had shown up when word got out.
"I don't know," Thorin said tersely.
"Do you think they're alright?" Fíli asked.
"I don't know."
"Do you think maybe Mahal isn't going to let them in?"
"I don't know!" he growled.
The hall was blessedly silent for a moment, and Thorin closed his eyes.
He opened them again when he heard a loud bang. Fíli had picked up a hammer from his belt and swung it against the door. “Knock, knock!” he shouted. “Let us in!”
“What are you doing?” Thorin hissed.
“What I do best,” Fíli said cheerfully. “Being incredibly annoying in the hopes of getting what I want.” He grinned, and gestured for the others to join him.
Thorin blinked. “Actually, that’s not a bad idea.”
Though the old Hobbit still could not see a thing, he heard an odd gasp from the Elf behind him. Before he could ask if she was alright, he was interrupted by the most peculiar sensation. The taste of green filled his mouth, and he saw (not with his eyes) a vast being towering above him, felt (not with his body) the heat of the forge at his back. A mighty hammer raised to strike – he cringed, waiting for the impact – was struck, and everything went soft, running together like honey. Memories, some strange and some familiar, flickered through his mind faster than thought, as the great hammer struck again and again. A sky more full of stars than he had ever seen – clang! – baking a seedcake with his mother, gentle sun filtering through the window – clang! – running breathlessly through the woods, long hair streaming behind him in the wind – clang! – dwarves tossing plates about his dining room – clang! – slipping through the halls in the dead of night, to speak with the prisoner who ensnared his capturer – clang! – scrambling over piles of gold, the heat of dragon-fire on his neck – clang! – weeping over the body of a beloved dwarf – clang! – weeping over the body of his beloved dwarf – clang! – facing down the Darkness poisoning the woods, only for his body to crumble away in the face of an ancient evil he thought had been destroyed – clang! – the ring, the ring, his precious, beautiful ring – clang! – waking up in an unfamiliar land, far from the trees he called home – clang! – waking up in Rivendell, bathed in golden sunlight – clang! – until it all swirled together with the taste of starlight and green, and he was plunged into cool darkness.
He opened his eyes. He couldn’t recall closing them. “Well.” He coughed, trying to clear his throat. “Did it work?”
A pause, then –
“Yes,” said the Elf and the Vala at the same time, though Tauriel’s voice was nearly drowned out in the great rumble of the Smith’s.
“I am quite pleased with my work,” Aulë said. “I had not shaped Elven or Hobbit souls before; as it happens, they are somewhat more pliable than I am accustomed to, which made the task almost simple.” Bilbo raised his eyebrows at that. Then he frowned. Up ahead, he could have sworn he heard a muffled shout.
He looked around, which was entirely unhelpful in such a dark cavern. Then the shout came again, accompanied by a banging noise.
“I suppose I should be letting you two go –” the Vala began to say, before another bang echoed through the hall. He sighed. “Oh, alright. You can say hello first.”
A door at the far end of the room swung open, light pouring in, and a pile of dwarves tumbled in, falling one on top of the other.
“Get off me, you big dolt!” “You’re the one who fell over!” “It’s not my fault everyone was -”
“Kíli!” Tauriel breathed. She ran to the door. Kíli, somewhere in the middle of the pile, managed to extricate himself in time to meet her. She picked him up in an enthusiastic embrace, spinning him around, and they laughed.
Bilbo smiled, making his way to the door a bit more leisurely. Thorin was at the back of the pile, and Bilbo reached out a hand to him. “We have got to stop meeting like this,” he remarked with a straight face.
“It is rather reminiscent of our first meeting, isn’t it,” Thorin said, unable to stop smiling. Then his face filled with remorse. “Bilbo, I -”
“A little help here?” grumbled Oín from underneath Thorin.
Bilbo sighed and helped Thorin up, freeing Oín. “The rest of you can sort yourselves out,” he said. “Give us a moment first.”
He pulled Thorin a little ways off, towards the back of the room.
“How much do you remember?” Thorin asked.
“Right now? All of it, I think,” Bilbo answered quietly. “Before coming here, only bits and pieces.”
“Stop apologizing and kiss ‘im already!” Fíli shouted from somewhere in the pile.
Thorin glared, and Bilbo turned beet red. Then Thorin turned his gaze to Bilbo, eyes softening. Bilbo felt at once acutely off-balance, very small, and very warm.
"How long do I have you for?" Thorin murmured.
"Not long," Bilbo said softly. "For now. Then forever, in a few years."
Thorin leaned in close, and Bilbo felt almost dizzy. He couldn’t quite believe that this was real, that they could touch and not pass through each other, after so many years of interacting only in dreams. Then Thorin pressed a soft kiss firmly to his lips. It was a quick thing, chaste and fleeting, though he tried to impress each detail into memory: the silky brush of his beard, the softness of his lips, the faint tang of metal and sweat.
Part of him was disappointed at such a chaste gesture; the rest of him was relieved that Thorin knew him well enough not to go further when they had an audience. Even such a simple gesture of affection was nearly too much for Bilbo to take. He buried his face in Thorin’s chest, and felt strong arms wrap around and pull him close. He breathed in deeply. He did not say, I missed you – Thorin knew that. He did not say, I love you, because he knew that too. Instead, he shut his eyes, and let himself feel at peace for the first time in decades.
After a long while (not long enough), he stepped back and looked around. Kíli and Tauriel were – well. Bilbo averted his eyes, his face growing hot. The other dwarves, meanwhile, seemed to have sorted themselves out, and were waiting around impatiently.
“Come over here and say hello!” Fíli cried.
Bilbo smiled and hurried over. About half the Company was there, and he was glad to see them, though gladder still to see that some were missing from their ranks. He exchanged joyful hugs with each in turn, as they bombarded him with questions and excited commentary.
“So you’re an honorary Dwarf now, are you?”
“More like an honorary Elf, but –”
“You’re here to stay?”
“I will be! Not yet, though –”
“What do you mean, an honorary Elf?”
“What do you mean, not yet?”
“I always said our Burglar could find his way into anything!”
“So glad to see you, my lad!”
“Kíli, stop snogging your Elf and come say hello to Bilbo!”
Kíli glared at his brother, but came over and gave Bilbo an enthusiastic hug. Tauriel drifted closer, though she kept her distance.
“Is the Elf staying, too?” Nori demanded. Tauriel shrunk back.
“That’s up to her, I’d say -”
“What do you mean, the Elf’s staying?!”
Tauriel’s face shuttered closed, and Bilbo huffed. “We’ve got visiting rights, alright? And Tauriel’s lovely, anyone who has a problem with her has a problem with me!” Kíli shot him a grateful look.
Ori raised his eyebrows. “Honorary Elf, you said?”
“We had to do some soul stuff, see, so I’ll be able to stick around after I die -”
“What about being an honorary Dwarf?!” That was Oín.
“Oh, I’ll make him an honorary Dwarf,” Thorin rumbled, and Bilbo blushed.
“Ever the peacemaker at the expense of our stiff necks, I see,” Balin commented with a smile. “It’s good to have you back.”
Bilbo heard a quiet chirp from his pack. “Oh!” Suddenly he remembered the message. “That’s right, I have a message and a gift for someone here… Narvi?”
The room went quiet for a moment. “Narvi?” Fíli repeated. “Why would you have a message for –”
Bilbo rummaged in his pack and pulled out the little bird and its message. “This little critter flew right up to us when we were on our way. The message is addressed to Narvi.” The dwarves all peered at the odd creation, which tilted its head with a soft whirring of gears and chirped. “Apparently the bird is a gift. I take it you know who they are?”
Thorin nodded.
Bilbo felt the world begin to shift around him. “Take it,” he said, handing the bird and the message to Thorin, who took them carefully. “Make sure it gets to them.” He looked to the others, then back to Thorin. “Don’t worry, I’ll be back.”
Then they were standing outside of the Mountain in the middle of the field. Only there was something different about it. It wasn’t the Mountain anymore, just another mountain. The wheat field was simply a meadow, no strange blossoming trees moving about in the distance, no whispering voices among the grass.
Bilbo felt – not quite his age again, indeed, the bit of elvishness had left him somewhat rejuvenated, but he felt the aches and pains of an aging body once more. One that had gone considerably too long without food or sleep, he noticed abruptly. He sat down on a rock and pulled some lembas out of his pack. Wonderful stuff, Elrond had insisted they take some. He found one slice was enough to feel quite comfortably full, though Tauriel had rather boggled at the sight for some reason.
They were alone in the field.
Well, almost alone. Not far off, in the waving grain, Bilbo saw a grey figure. It shimmered when he squinted at it. Perhaps this should have alarmed him, but instead of fear, the figure felt almost… familiar?
“Hello there!” he called. Tauriel stared at him like he’d grown two heads, and made as if to shush him. Then the grey figure swept into view, swirling mists forming into a cloak and hat, and Bilbo grinned. “Gandalf!”
The wizard blinked at him. “Bilbo Baggins! What in heavens are you doing here?”
“Just making some social calls,” he replied. “Say, I don’t suppose you could help us make our way back to Tirion?”
Gandalf frowned. “That’s a long ways off.”
Bilbo smiled. “Well, we’d best get going, then, don’t you think? It’ll be an adventure!”
Notes:
And that's it! I hope you enjoyed this! I might write an epilogue or something at some point, since I think it would be fun to write about them showing up in the halls of Mandos and going "hey don't mind us we'll just be going over here"... or to explore how Tauriel and Bilbo settle in with the Dwarves... but this is it for now!
