Actions

Work Header

and I will follow you into the dark

Chapter 5: The Mountain

Summary:

They've reached the Halls of Aulë. Now what?

Chapter Text

           It wasn’t a secret door.

           Bilbo was almost put out by this. He’d come all this way, expecting to find the most secret of all secret Dwarvish mountain doors, and the fact that the door was standing right there as plain as could be was almost a disappointment. Though the shape of the rocks around it had cleverly hidden the entryway from view from most angles, when they followed the path to approach it straight on, the archway through the stone became quite visible.

           And it wasn’t even locked! Though the great stone door was heavy, the two of them pushing as hard as they could managed to shove it open a crack, just enough for them to slip through.

           The great door swung shut behind them, and they were plunged into absolute darkness.

           A hand landed on the top of his head, and Bilbo let out a strangled shout of alarm, the sound echoing in the stifling blackness.

           “Apologies, Master Baggins,” came Tauriel’s voice from above his shoulder, and he relaxed minutely. He grabbed her hand and guided it to his shoulder.

           “Can’t see a damn thing,” he grumbled. “Now where do we go?”

           “That,” came a voice like rolling thunder, “is up to you.”


           Thorin was in his workshop when he felt a small tug beneath his heart. He paused, setting the hammer down. A death? None of his relatives were ill, that he knew of, and Erebor had been enjoying a period of well-earned peace and prosperity. He frowned. Perhaps he had been working too long.

           Then the tug came once more, and suddenly, he knew.

           Bilbo?!

           He tore off his smithing apron, setting aside his work, and raced to the Halls, heart thundering in his throat. Kíli was already there when he arrived. Their eyes met, and Thorin saw his own desperate hopefulness reflected in his nephew’s eyes.

           One by one, the old Company trickled in, a mixture of excitement and confusion. Balin and Fíli were first, and they knew enough not to ask any questions. The rest had no such restraint.

           First came Ori and Nori. “Bilbo’s here?” exclaimed Nori, and Ori shushed him. “But he’s not a Dwarf!”

           Fíli rolled his eyes. “Obviously! They’ve been trying to get around that –“

           “They?”

           “The Elf my brother’s so fond of, she’s coming too –“

           “What?!”

           “Why’s Bilbo here?” That was Oín, calling from across the hall as he jogged towards them.

           Fíli glared at him. “He’s coming with Tauriel to find a way in –“

           “Will you all SHUT UP BACK THERE?!” Thorin roared.

           There was blessed silence, for a moment, and then –

           “Brother? Why are you here?” Frerin poked his head into the hall.

           He groaned.


           Tauriel’s hand tightened on Bilbo’s shoulder. “Who are you?” she called into the blackness. “Show yourself!”

           “You would do well not to speak so harshly, when you have entered these Halls uninvited,” the voice answered from all around them, echoing in the darkness. “You are no children of mine.”

           Bilbo heard a sharp intake of breath from the Elf at his shoulder. “Quite sorry to impose,” he said. “We didn’t know how to go about scheduling something in advance, you see. I wouldn’t normally drop in unannounced.”

           There was silence. Then a faint rumble, like rocks falling in a cavern. Was that a chuckle? Emboldened, Bilbo took a step forward, reaching out a hand. “Bilbo Baggins, pleased to meet you. And I assume you are -” the owner of this establishment? “- the one we’ve come to speak to?”

           The rumble came again, louder this time, and the very floor shook with the great being’s laughter. An enormous, gnarled finger placed itself in Bilbo’s hand. He shook it.

           “I am the Maker, He who the Elves call Aulë and who the Dwarves call Mahal, and these are my Halls you have entered.” The hand pulled itself away. “I know well who you are, Bilbo Baggins, aye, and Tauriel o Calentaur, for your names have been spoken to me many times of late. Yet you are not my children. I cannot see into your hearts, for I did not make them. And so I ask: for what reason have you come to my Halls?”

           “For love of a Dwarf,” answered Tauriel, the same words she had spoken in Elrond’s study so long ago.

           “And you, Bilbo Baggins?” the voice asked.

           Bilbo took a deep breath, then nodded. “I was told this is where Dwarves go when they die. Well, I’m here. I’d like to speak to Thorin Oakenshield, please.”

           The voice sighed, a gust of wind sweeping through the cavern. “It is not so simple, I’m afraid. Any decision you take here will be irreversible.”

           “Then I have one question for you first,” Bilbo said. “In dreams, I have spoken with Thorin many times. Were those dreams real? Was that really Thorin’s spirit I was speaking to?”

           A thousand hammers struck as one. “Yes.”

           Bilbo nodded to himself. “Then I want to stay here.”

           “Are you certain, both of you? There is no sunlight nor a single green growing thing in this lightless place, and you do not find joy in craft like my children.”

           “I am certain,” said Tauriel.

           “I ask again, are you sure?” the Vala asked. “You would give up your immortality to live among a people who have warred with your own for centuries. Though you have some allies here, many will not take kindly to your presence. You will never see your kindred again, nor any other Elf. Are you prepared to live among a foreign and likely hostile people, in dark, lifeless halls, from now until the end of the world?”

           “I –” The Elf fell silent. “I do not know,” she said finally, her voice troubled. “Had my spirit remained in Middle Earth, I would have stayed among the trees of Greenwood with my kindred until my soul faded into the earth. There is nothing for me in Valinor – a few friends may come over the water, as the last of the Elves leave Middle Earth, but that is not enough to hold me here. Yet I cannot return to Middle Earth, for the last of my kind will be coming here soon enough. And to be honest, the Elves of this place are as strange to me as the Dwarves. To stay here, in these Halls – at least I would have Kíli.” Her hand tightened on Bilbo’s shoulder. “I must admit that the prospect of spending an eternity here is… daunting, but it’s better than the alternative.”

           Bilbo felt the weight of Aulë’s gaze turn to him, and he shrugged. “At least this way I’d have some clue where my soul was going to go in the end. And I’m a good bit more certain of my reception than Tauriel.” The lack of greenery was going to be depressing, but he had a suspicion he might be able to set up some sort of greenhouse. The dwarves could do wonderful things with lights…

           “I see.” The Vala let out a breath. “I am not Mandos. I am a Father and a Maker, not an Arbiter. Perhaps I could do as I have described, and seal your souls away in my domain for all eternity – yet I do not know if you would thrive here, nor if my children would thrive, and that is my primary concern. Yet neither am I inclined to leave things as they are, for you are not the only ones who have suffered under the separation of the afterlives.”

           The air was silent for a while. Then Aulë spoke. “These Halls, like the Halls of Mandos, exist in a space between Life and Death. They are neither fully subject to the laws of matter, nor entirely free from them. As they are on the same level of reality, so to speak, it is possible to create a path of sorts between them.” He paused, and Bilbo felt his frown. “It is difficult to speak of this in mortal tongues.”

           Bilbo tilted his head. “So you’re saying we can have visitation rights?”

           This time he wasn’t startled by the thunderous roar of the Great Smith’s laughter, though it shook the very floor beneath his feet.

           “Yes, precisely!” Aulë exclaimed, his great booming voice echoing all around them. “I will have to discuss it with Mandos, of course, but it would simplify things a great deal.”

           The Vala was silent, then, though Bilbo could have sworn he heard the echoes of voices all around, too faint to make out. Just when he was starting to wonder if they had been left alone in the dark room, he heard a rumble from above.

           “That was—unexpected,” came Aulë’s voice at last. “It seems Namo’s siblings have both taken interest in this little puzzle. It was not so difficult to convince him as I had thought.”

           Bilbo blinked. “You can do it, then? Create a back door between the two afterlives?”

           “Yes,” the Vala said. “Now all that remains is the question of your mortality, little Hobbit. Unlike your friend here, you will not stay long in the Halls of Mandos before departing this world entirely.”

           “Is there no way for me to give up my immortality?” Tauriel asked.

           “You are no half-Elf,” Aulë said, not unkindly. “Your immortality is not yours to give.”

           “Wait a moment,” Bilbo said suddenly. He felt their attention shift to him, and he crossed his arms. “It seems to me that Tauriel here has a bit too much life, and I have a bit too little. Can’t you just… mix them up? Give me a touch of her immortality, I give her a bit of mortality, and we end up nicely in the middle just like the Dwarves?”

           There was silence. Again came the faint echo of voices, the rustle of leaves, the roar of the sea, the rattle of bones. Then Bilbo heard a sound like a pebble falling onto stone. Then another, and another, until the whole Mountain shook. “An unorthodox way of putting it, but that would be the basic principle, yes,” said the crashing rocks. The roar subsided, the echoes swallowed up by the darkness. “Although your estimate is slightly off.”

           Bilbo let out an involuntary squeak as that huge stone hand plucked him off the ground and lifted him up in the air. “Hmm,” came a faint rumble. Though Bilbo still could not make out anything in the darkness, it felt like he was being examined closely. “Yes, I do believe that will work.”

           After a moment, the Vala set him gently back down. He stumbled a little, still disoriented from the sudden displacement. “I’m afraid it will not be immediate, however. You will live for a while longer. Walk aboveground, in the sunlight, among all those green growing things that you will find not in my Halls.”

           “Must we wait?!” Tauriel protested.

           “Patience, child,” the Great Smith chided gently. “You must learn to live for yourself. Not for your people, not for your beloved, but for your own sake. You must learn how to live when there is no greater purpose driving you.” A pause. “As for you, Bilbo, I suspect you have unfinished business yet. There is knowledge to be sought, vegetables to plant, Elves to pester with endless questions.”

           Bilbo snorted. “That’s true enough. I’ve plenty of other things to do in the meantime, I’d rather not die right away.”

           “Very well,” said Aulë. “Then I will carve away a sliver of your immortality, Tauriel, and fold it into Bilbo’s soul, until it has the strength to stay in this world after the body has failed.” He paused. “I should warn you, this will forge a permanent connection between your souls. You will be bound to the same fate. Additionally, Bilbo, you will probably live a bit longer than you otherwise would, although I would be surprised if it added more than a decade or two to your lifespan.”

           “So how will this work?” Bilbo asked. “Will I just show up back here when I die?”

           “When you die, both of you will appear in the Halls of Mandos,” he answered. “Remind him of our arrangement, and he will show you the way to my Halls. From there, you may consider yourselves free to travel between the two Halls as you so choose. Should you consent to bind your souls together, Tauriel, you will give up your ability to be re-embodied, and never again will you walk among the living until Arda is remade. In return, Bilbo’s spirit will reside in our Halls until the end of time. Is this your will?”

           “Yes,” said Tauriel. She sounded very certain.

           “Mine as well,” Bilbo said when he felt the Vala’s gaze on him. The prospect of sharing a soul with an Elf he’d met only twice was a bit odd, but by this point he felt like he knew her quite well (for there was nothing like a shared adventure to get to know someone). In any case, Bilbo felt there were far worse people to be spiritually bonded to.

           “Then let us begin,” Aulë said. “This will feel a bit strange, I’m afraid –”