Chapter Text
Chapter Six: Family Matters
“I can’t believe you’re not completely exhausted,” Frerin gasped. Thorin paused, breathing hard, inspecting his brother. His fair hair was decorated with multiple braids that proclaimed him as a descendent of Durin, second Heir to the King, a jeweller, a swordsman, a son and brother, his beard and moustache styled elegantly and braided as well. Little gems decorating polished beads of gold and mithril gleamed in the torchlight as he slowly straightened up and knocked his hood back, a quick glance revealing a warm gold-stitched Durin blue tunic clothing his solid, athletic form. His belt was laden with gold and worked finely, his binders tooled leather of the highest quality and his heavy twill breeches were tailored in the latest style. Even his steel-capped boots gleamed.
“You’re getting fat and lazy, Nadadith,” he said gravely. Frerin dropped his cloak on the dusty deep greenish stone floor and gave a superior sneer.
“I’ll have you know, I’m a Prince of the Line of Durin, drudge!” he retorted and then surged forward, wrapping a fierce hug around his older brother. “How are you?” he whispered. Thorin hugged him back.
“I’ll live,” he murmured as Frerin pulled back to arm’s length and inspected him, his blue eyes lingering on the wound on his cheek.
“Not learned to duck?” he asked teasingly.
“Not grown a third arm…and unwilling to betray my friends,” the elder brother confessed with a wry twist of the lips. “Most dwarves content themselves with yelling-but Mriak thrives on hurting dwarves who aren’t able to fight back.” The Prince grimaced, the hesitant light of the two guttering torches gilding his golden hair, the cold blue moonlight spilling through the narrow vertical slit window paling his skin.
“Mahal, I’m sorry,” he said, the words exploding from his lips. “I should have been there…”
“And done what?” Thorin asked him bitterly. “Mriak is the Captain of the Guard. Why would a Prince step in when he’s beating up a drudge he believes was visiting the Arena and practicing when he had no right to be there.”
“Good thing you were,” Frerin said, walking across to peer through the narrow gap in the rocks and towards the frigid sky. The stars were brilliant and the half moon hung stubbornly low in the sky towards Mirkwood. “Or I would be dead. You saved my life.”
Thorin slowly nodded.
“How in the name of Mahal’s Mighty Hammer did you get there?” Frerin asked. Thorin frowned.
“Dwalin,” he said shortly. “Everyone else was at some military display. Though how you got out of that is beyond my understanding…”
Frerin froze.
“I didn’t,” he said in a low voice, leaning forward to rest his head against the cold stone. “No one told me-or the boys. Let alone informed me to tell Bilbo. But somehow, word has got round that I told him and he decided not to go. That he decided to go on the ride and persuaded us to truant the King’s big welcome gesture.”
“When I heard you and the boys talk him into it-and persuade him to go without an escort,” Thorin said, folding his arms across his chest.
“Again, he’s being blamed,” Frerin muttered.
“By who?” Thorin demanded. “Because I know no one else was actually there.”
“Who do you think?” Frerin asked him angrily, spinning to face his older brother. “Amad!”
Thorin grimaced.
“You know, it shocks me that no one has yet cottoned onto her consistent pattern of behaviour,” he said coldly. “She lies about things she has no actual knowledge about, turning public opinion against someone, then manipulates the Royal Family into doing what she wants.” He glared at his brother. “So what is her endgame, Frerin?”
“She’s claiming the Prince owes Erebor his life for the lives of the Patrol who died due to his inconsiderate and reckless decision to go riding,” the blond Prince admitted reluctantly.
“As opposed to you owing them your life,” Thorin pressed. Frerin scowled.
“They would have been fallen on by the orcs anyway-since they were literally within sight of our ambush when they turned to aid us,” he said. “They would not have got away. But more died to save us.” He paused. “And in the end, you and the others made the difference. But you saved me and Bilbo personally.”
“It wasn’t much of a disguise,” Thorin conceded.
“It was good enough for someone who wouldn’t know your eyes,” his brother told him. “Though you are taller than the average dwarf and you carry yourself like a warrior…”
“Despite being the lowest menial in the mountain,” Thorin muttered.
“Yet you outfought everyone,” Frerin told him. “Mahal-whatever training and practice you’ve managed has worked because you still have more skills than me-than anyone in the Royal Line!”
“Dwalin,” his brother conceded. “He’s a hard taskmaster.”
“I’ll do what I can to get him promoted,” Frerin promised. “I know Balin would love it…though Amad seems to be able to persuade Adad to promote people I’ve never heard of ahead of him…” Then he sighed. “She seemed to have her sights set on Bilbo marrying someone here.”
There was an awkward silence during which Thorin felt his stomach lurch.
“You?” he said, his voice uneven. Frerin gave a bitter smile.
“Good way to secure an alliance, don’t you think?” he replied. “And force the Halflings to bind themselves and much of their agricultural output to Erebor. It gives us all the power.”
“You have to tell the truth,” Thorin hissed, lunging forward and grabbing his brother’s arm. “You cannot be party to this.”
“I’m not…”
“You are,” the former Prince snapped. “Because you know the truth and aren’t contradicting the lies.”
“You don’t understand!” Frerin yelled. “If I make myself a target, Sigin’Adad may disown me as well!”
Thorin blinked and stared at him, recoiling as if scalded.
“And that means so much more to you than telling the truth about a visitor you persuaded to go out on a ride, talked out of an escort and then almost got killed who is being forced to marry and remain here, losing his home forever?” he sneered. “What kind of King do you think you would ever be if you are so cowardly that the possible loss of your privileges-knowing Bergilde would never let her precious Golden Prince be set aside anyway-is more important than being a decent ruler? Do you think Durin would abandon an ally and friend to lies and deception and allow him to be traded like a slave?”
“I’m not like you,” Frerin retorted.
“I’m nothing special,” Thorin told him hollowly, turning away in disappointment. “Just a stupid fool who believed that his brother cared about anything other than himself. Who believed that his Prince would stand up for the truth rather than sitting back and enjoying the fruits of his mother’s lies, deception and manipulation. That you would not watch Bilbo taken from his family and home just in case you upset a mad King and his spineless and voiceless Heir!”
Frerin lurched a step forward, his fists clenched.
“You say that anywhere but here and you lose your head,” he hissed.
“Then you’ll have to kill three quarters of the mountain,” Thorin told him sharply. “It’s not hard to see. When the King dies-and death comes to all, one day-then Adad is patently unfit to rule. Either the Council does its job and makes him abdicate so you become King or they are bought and paid for and Thráin becomes King-with Bergilde pulling the strings and ruling the mountain through him. And if that day comes, I will be killed as a rival to her son.”
Frerin stared at him.
“I won’t allow it,” he murmured.
“You can’t be there,” Thorin reminded him. “And if you are not watching, do you believe your orders will be carried out-or will they be forgotten in favour of a few whispered words from that witch you call Amad?”
He knew he’d said too much when Frerin balled his fists and his face fell into a glower that would have melted steel.
“Because I know how cruelly she treated you, I will let that pass, this once,” the golden Prince snarled. “She is my Amad.”
“And she manipulates, lies and plots,” Thorin told him simply and shrugged. “Or I would live in the Royal Wing and would still be Heir to the Crown Prince. I would know my nephews not by sight but as the two mischievous young dwarrow my sister describes to me when she can remember she has a second brother and has the time to act on it. I would not live in a tiny cupboard, shivering in the cold and eating scraps. I would not be beaten and shamed and treated like dirt by dwarrow who only serve their own interests, not those of the Kingdom.”
“You know she threatens to have you killed?” Frerin said suddenly, all the fight oozing from his form. His shoulders slumped and he looked as defeated and despairing as Thorin felt. “When you were exiled, Dis and I went to Adad to plead for you. To tell him that she was wrong and it was lies. But she stopped us and said if we spoke up, she would make sure you died, disgraced and shamed and broken.” Swallowing, Thorin stared at him.
“And how is that different to what is happening now?” he asked quietly, his voice jarring with its neutrality. He was burning with rage inside but his voice didn’t sound as if it was his. “I am disgraced and shamed. I am abused and beaten on the whims of those who are clearly in the favour of her coterie.” Frerin turned away again.
“She said she would kill you if I spoke up,” he repeated.
“And if I said that I will not let her use me as a pawn in her game?” Thorin asked. “That I will not let a threat against me corner a visiting Prince who has shown me naught but kindness and force him into marriage with someone of her choice?”
Frerin gave a bitter laugh.
“You ask me to betray you again?” he asked. “I should have spoken up straight away and made Sigin’Adad hear me! I didn’t-and now you are lost. If I speak up…”
“You do what I would have,” Thorin told him. “Frerin, you are my brother. You are raised to be a King in the future. I know the training you got because I received it too-remember? I know what Fundin and Balin will have told you. I know the history and the legends that you will have been told. I know the laws you have been forced to learn. Now you have to make the choice I made. You can be the Heir to the Crown Prince and do what you must or you can be a coward and a disgrace to Durin the Deathless, our ancestor. If I die, then I will face Mahal and know I died because you acted in the best interests of our people.”
“If he marries, if we get an alliance…”
“How would anyone ever trust Erebor again?” Thorin asked him sharply. “They come to negotiate a routine contract and the son is trapped into marriage, forced to stay as what? A hostage? With food as the ransom, to be paid every year until he dies? What do you think any potential trading partner will think of that?”
“He will have choice,” Frerin replied, his voice shamed. “There will be five Balls, great events where every eligible dwarf will be presented to the Shire Prince for his perusal…”
“And who decides what is ‘eligible’?” Thorin asked shortly. Frerin walked forward and sighed.
“Every dwarf of age who has not found his One or is married,” he said. “Balin announced it. Amad was furious because it meant that Bilbo would have to meet hundreds of dwarrow-many of them not noble-born.”
“And yet she is going to make sure that he chooses you,” Thorin murmured. Frerin grasped his arm.
“Adad went on a patrol-he was away for four days,” he said in a suddenly low voice. “When he came back, he was different. Happier, sharper-as if the fog had lifted. He was overjoyed to see us…but he asked where you were. If you were training or at lessons. He didn’t recall what had happened. Amad looked furious. And then she brought him ale, watching him drink with a small smile…and shortly after, he stopped asking, stopped looking so bright and became…himself again.”
“She drugged him,” the older brother murmured, his eyes swinging up to look worriedly into Frerin’s eyes. “She is drugging him.”
“Dís and I made sure we collect food from the kitchens,” he assured them. “We never drink anything that she has been near.” Thorin nodded.
“Tell the truth,” he advised his brother. “Own your mistakes. It will win you far more approval than it loses. And Mahal knows, the Royal Family needs someone that the masses can look to. It isn’t the King and it isn’t Adad. It must be you.” He sighed. “You and Bilbo still owe your lives to the Patrol and Dwalin. I don’t think he will pull out of the Balls but he will have the option to leave rather than be held as a hostage and forced to wed.” Leaning forward, he gently rested his forehead against his brother’s. Frerin sighed.
“Be safe, Nadad,” he murmured. “I haven’t given up hope of altering your fate and giving back what is rightfully yours.” Thorin managed the barest hint of a smile.
“Be careful,” he murmured. “She won’t be happy. But you know what you have to do.” Frerin pulled back and nodded, then grabbed his cloak and wrapped it around his shape once more.
“I do,” he said. “Wish me luck!”
Thorin watched him vanish down the stairs, the heavy fall of his boots receding into the distance as he headed back down to the Royal Wing.
“Mahal be with you,” he murmured and turned to make the long trek down the the stables once more.
-o0o-
Breakfast was awkward in the quarters of the Royal Family where the Bagginses were dining with their hosts. Bungo was extremely guarded, pausing after any comment was addressed at him and answering with all the consideration of a diplomat in a bear pit while Belladonna was bright and cheerful but very vague in all her answers. Bilbo hunched over his food, refusing to engage with the Royal Family and angry that they had lied about him and placed him in such an invidious position.
Thráin remained quiet, nodding pleasantly and leaving the conversation to his wife, who seemed to exult in twisting the knife over Bilbo’s supposed dereliction of duty and comparing him unfavourably to her own dutiful and hardworking son. Dís carried the conversation easily, supported by Fili and Kili who were telling a ridiculous story about how Kili had gotten three servants lost on their was to the Royal Wing. Bilbo listened, sighing. The pair were inveterate pranksters and what they were describing was amusing…but also a little cruel. Hobbits did not have servants in the way other races did-the Bagginses cooked all their own food as proper, respectable Hobbits did and Belladonna’s green thumb was fabled in Hobbiton and Bywater-though they recruited helpers for special occasions. Hamfast Gamgee and Holman, his father, helped Belladoona with her vegetable patch and watched things while the family were away on duty and various relatives and neighbours helped when they had official guests but payment was more of a thanks rather than a formal contract, and often took the form of food, gifts or promise of returning the favour. Hobbits couldn’t imagine being bound to serve to someone for all their life with no hope of promotion…and especially if they were being messed around by spoilt Princes for fun.
Belladonna leaned close.
“If you looked more disapproving, my love, we may have to declare war,” she murmured under her breath as he looked up from his sausages, startled. He hadn’t realised his face was betraying him so badly.
“Sorry, Mum,” he replied as softly. Hobbit ears were far superior to those of dwarves, which couldn’t be as sensitive with their proclivities for shouting, hammering metal for hours on end and hacking away at rocks. “I-I just can’t trust them and don’t want to say anything that they could twist and lie about.” His mother sighed, her hand gently resting on his arm.
“I know, my love,” she reassured him. “Just…oh well, you won’t smile. Just try not to frown quite so much…”
“I’ll try, Mum, but I…” he began but he was interrupted as Frerin rose to his feet and cleared his throat. Everyone looked up, except Thrór, who bisected his egg without even acknowledging his grandson had demanded the floor.
“I am sorry to interrupt, your Highness, but I feel that we need, here and now, to dispel some misinformed and malicious rumours that threaten the integrity of our House and the success of our trade talks with the Shire,” the golden Prince said. There was a pause and even Thrór stopped cutting, though he continued chewing. Bergilde inhaled sharply but Dís sat back and nodded, understanding what her brother was planning.
“What rumours?” the Crown Prince asked, his hooded eyes looking up. Thráin appeared unconcerned, reaching to refill his ale as his son’s sharp blue gaze swept the table.
“The entirely unfounded rumours that Prince Bilbo chose to absent himself from the welcome display and insisted on an afternoon outside the mountain without escort,” Frerin announced. Bilbo’s head snapped up and he focussed on the other Prince. Fíli and Kíli stared at their Uncle as well-the Hobbit guessed that they were unaware of the rumours swirling around the Mountain. As the Hobbit watched, the young Princes leaned together, both whispering urgently. “Majesty, Adad-the suggestion was mine. The decision was mine. And I persuaded him that it was safe and that we would not need an escort because my nephews and I would be able to protect him-and that our flanks were safe. I was wrong on all counts.”
“It doesn’t excuse his delinquency in missing the Display…” Bergilde began but Frerin smiled thinly.
“However, as my Lady Amad forget to tell either me or my nephews about the display, I was unable to inform Prince Bilbo and thus none of us knew about the display until we were informed by the rescuing guards,” Frerin said calmly.
“I am sure…” Bergilde began but Fíli cut in.
“No, Sigin’Amad-you did not,” he confirmed.
There was a frosty silence as the dwarrowdam glared at the young prince, her cold glare hateful.
“I’m afraid he’s right, Amad,” Dís added. “The boys and I arrived before Frerin and I was here until they left. You never mentioned a word. And while I admire our Hobbit guests, I am certain they do not have the same powers of foresight as the weed-eaters.”
“Even though they share the same pointy ears,” Thrór commented crassly, chewing his egg. “No mind. The boy still owes us his life.”
Though it would not have been imperilled if we had been told that we had somewhere else to be, Bilbo thought, biting his lip to stop himself saying something.
“Dís, speak to Balin and issue a pronouncement that the Royal Family apologises for the scurrilous rumours which have wrongfully cast aspersions on the character of Prince Bilbo,” Thráin announced, his voice heavy. “Ensure that it is clear that the error was ours in not communicating the invitation to him. And that he was persuaded to leave the mountain by my son, who deeply regrets his foolish actions and the deaths they caused. The Royal Family will personally fund pensions for the dependents of all those killed in defending the Princes and Prince Bilbo on that ill-fated trip.” Bungo looked up.
“Prince Thráin, King Thrór-we thank you for clearing up this injustice,” he announced carefully. “The vicious and unfounded attack on my son threatened to poison negotiations. Now at least we can move forward with honesty and openness.” Unconsciously, Bilbo felt his eyes slide over to Bergilde, who was glaring at her son…and at Fíli. Dis was whispering hastily in his ear and the younger Princes rose, then bowed to Thrór and excused themselves. He glanced over to Belladonna, who was stirring her tea thoughtfully, giving every impression that she had not noted the exchange…apart from the slight nod she granted her son.
“But surely you will still honour your debt to the people of Erebor and offer your hand,” Bergilde said brightly, her smile as fake as the supposed goodwill behind it. Her raven hair shifted over her shoulders, the many beads gleaming in the lights. Belladonna looked over at Bilbo.
“While I honour those who saved their Princes and I who were imperilled through no fault of mine, I will not commit to marrying and remaining here,” Bilbo announced. “That would be tantamount to claiming that I am now a vassal of Erebor, which would be an act of war.” Thrór looked up at the hard tone, his sheened eyes surprised at the challenge. But Bilbo continued, his tone firm. “I am grateful you all take such an interest in my future but I will only pledge my hand to courtship if I meet someone with whom I feel a connection. Otherwise…” He looked up and met Bergilde’s pallid eyes. “Otherwise, I will not wed.”
“Agreed!” Thrór announced as he stood. Everyone rose to their feet in respect. “Shouldn’t be much of a problem, then. Frerin is as fine a dwarf as you could want to meet-I’m sure when you get to know him better, you’ll realise he’s the One.” Then he swept out, followed by Thráin and Bergilde. Frerin followed, looking as if he was going to his own execution…but Dís tarried for a few moments. She bowed to the Shire Royalty and then walked closer.
“Do not worry,” she said in a low voice. “You will not be forced to wed-I will make sure of it. And if you do need to leave in a hurry, I can arrange that as well. My only price would be that you take my sons with you. Away from this place and those who would harm their own kin for personal advancement.” Bilbo stared into her blue eyes and read her cool determination-but also a hint of fear. He nodded, feeling a sudden feeling of familiarity. He blinked.
“Princess-whatever you need our help with, we will do our utmost,” Bungo said quietly and then watched as she swept out. He stared at his wife. “I knew it was a mistake to take this third term. This is definitely the last. Whatever are we in the middle of?” Belladonna took his hand.
“The worst type of trouble,” she murmured. “A family feud. Be prepared to get out at a moment’s notice, my dear. These things can get fatal.”
