Chapter Text
Eleven: Plots and Plans
“What is a cuckoo?”
Thorin had greeted Bilbo and the Hobbit Prince had cheerfully chatted through the events of his day while sharing a selection of meat pies and little raspberry and peach pastries that were astonishingly tasty. The Hobbit had admitted that he had asked permission from Bombur and had baked them himself in the kitchens-partly because they were his father’s favourite and partly because he wanted to give Thorin something he had made himself. Touched and certain that the Hobbit didn’t understand the importance and meaning of such a gesture, Thorin had devoured the offering with gratitude, savouring every bite. Thorin had reluctantly left his place beside Bilbo and was half-heartedly brushing Myrtle, since Kirgun was on the prowl and had been in an unnervingly cheerful mood. To Thorin, that usually meant something bad for him so he was determined not to give the stable master any reason to target him while not wasting his time with his friend.
“You don’t know what a cuckoo is?” Bilbo’s tone was surprised. Thorin chuckled.
“I’m a dwarf. I live in a mountain. The only birds I see are the Ravens in the Rookery when I occasionally get sent up there to help clean it out,” he reminded the Hobbit. “A fragrant task I seem to get assigned more often than average. But I heard someone mention the term and I wondered if you could explain?” Looking up at him, Bilbo nodded easily.
“Sorry-I keep forgetting that not everyone comes from the Shire,” he admitted. “We spend our time as faunts out in Yavanna’s woods and fields, seeing Her creatures doing what She programmed them to do… though I’m not sure that cuckoos weren’t twisted by Morgoth at some time in the past.”
“They’re not good birds then?” Thorin asked, turning his attention to Myrtle’s tail. She nickered slightly.
“Dear me no,” Bilbo revealed, watching him. He was favouring his left shoulder but he still cut a fine figure as he methodically brushed the tail with long, even strokes of the brush. “Cuckoos are monstrous. They do not build nests. Instead, they sneak in and lay their eggs in other bird’s nests. Each one preys on a specific other bird and to do that, they produce an egg that looks just like the eggs of that species.”
“Camouflage,” Thorin murmured.
“The parents incubate the egg but the cuckoo egg is designed to hatch before the host bird,” Bilbo continued. “And when it hatches, it proves itself a monster. The newborn chick-blind and bald-systematically hoists the other eggs on its back and manoeuvres them so they are pushed out of the nest. They fall to the ground and smash. If there are any chicks already hatched, they are dispatched to their doom the same way. Finally, the cuckoo chick is alone and it feeds on all the food its foster parents can get to it, eating enough for an entire clutch. It grows monstrously large, so large it cannot fit in the nest and its tiny foster parents wear themselves to exhaustion raising a chick ten times their size that killed their own children to take their place. Once it has sucked them dry, it fledges and leaves them with nothing.”
There was a pause for a few moments that was broken only by the sounds of the brush strokes.
“Truly a monster,” Thorin murmured and sighed. “I know what she means now.” Bilbo stared at him and then saw the dwarf shake himself.
“Are you alright?” he asked and for a moment, Thorin longed to tell him everything, longed to have someone that he could explain himself to and who could listen without scorn to the disaster that was his life. But then sanity gripped him once more and he knew that Bilbo would be polite and kind but would draw away from a dwarf who had been cast out of his family because, no matter what Thorin said, he had to have committed a truly heinous crime to deserve such dishonour. So he nodded and offered a small smile that Bilbo found terribly sad.
“I am well,” he said automatically and then he sighed because he owed the Hobbit more than his usual excuse. “It reminded me of a story I heard, of a Prince who lost his home when his father remarried and his stepmother falsely accused him of trying to harm her children, his siblings.” Bilbo ironed, his eyes thoughtful.
“Surely his father would know his son, would protect him?” he asked, imagining how heartbroken he would feel should Bungo believe an accuser over him. And how upset he had felt for the short time his parents had been fooled by the rumours spread by…well, probably the Crown Princess Bergilde. Fortunately, his parents had stood by him and Frerin had stood up for him as well. But if that hadn’t happened… “That’s horrible,” he added. Thorin nodded, his eyes pensive and then he forced himself to raise his impassive mask. Bilbo saw the change and felt upset that his friend didn’t feel able to trust him enough to speak what was on his mind. But he gave a small smile to reassure his friend: by the time he left Erebor, he was determined that Thorin would trust him enough to tell him whatever had made him look so sad. Because in Bilbo’s opinion, no one-least of all Thorin-deserved to look so bereft and he was determined to do what he could to ease his sorrow.
-o0o-
“I need a favour.”
He knew he was taking a real risk, trespassing into the administrative corridor, because Balin son of Fundin was an adviser to the King and could be joined by a senior member of the Royal Family in any minute. Yet he knew what he had to do and he had promised. No matter what he had lost, he would not lose his personal honour because he had never surrendered it. No matter what had been done to him, he remained a son of Durin. So he huddled in an alcove, cringing back away from the passersby until he saw the shorter shape of Balin, his long white beard and short hair familiar. the adviser glanced up at the tall shape at his side and his eyes twinkled, though his voice was guarded.
“You’re taking a chance coming back here, laddie,” he commented. Thorin bowed his head.
“I do not come on my behalf,” he explained. Balin inspected him, then beckoned him into his office, locking the door carefully behind him.
“We should be safe for a short while,” he said, gesturing to the seat opposite his desk. “So tell me what you are asking for, Thorin, and I will do what I can.” Nodding, the drudge took a seat and stared at the adviser.
“Have you had a report of any deaths?” he asked pointedly. “Especially among the guards?” Balin pursed his lips.
“No-though I would expect those to the brought to my attention,” he admitted, his tone hardening. “Should I have?”
“There were three guards who died last night,” Thorin explained. “Because I killed them. In a fight. One was called…” He frowned, “Codun. He’s one of Mriak’s.”
“And how did you get into a fight…?” Balin asked, making a couple of notes.
“I was called by a…mutual acquaintance,” Thorin explained without preamble. “There was an ambush that was designed to kill a healer-Uribet daughter of Oin.” Balin grunted, his eyes narrowing.
“Where was this?”
“Down Below-the Eighteenth District,” Thorin explained. “After first bell.” Balin stared at him. “They were waiting for her and planned to kill her. Because four dwarrow don’t hide in the shadows with naked swords wanting to talk.” The adviser’s face lost all emotion.
“Is she safe?”
“Yes,” Thorin replied firmly. “They aren’t. Three are dead. One was unconscious. I suspect their friends may have found them. But they were guards.”
“Why Uribet?” Balin asked. Thorin frowned.
“I believe she heard something that she was not meant to,” he said in a low voice. “You have heard of a dwarf named Padma?” If anything, Balin looked even more perplexed.
“A sad story-she had served the Royal Family for well over a century and she became unwell and was dismissed,” he revealed. Thorin scowled. “Our future Queen felt that she had outlived her usefulness.”
“That is no surprise,” Thorin muttered. “Loyalty, honour, a willing heart-all things the Line of Durin used to value. But no more, it seems. She is living in poverty and cared for by the healers out of the goodness of their hearts. But she is hunted because she may have seen or heard something. I ask for her. She needs to be taken to somewhere safe, where she will be protected and honoured and given the retirement she deserves. But they must not know…” Balin stared at him.
“You don’t ask for anything easy,” he commented.
“If it was easy, it may be even within my paltry means,” Thorin admitted. “Maybe Dwalin could look into it who is missing.” Then he paused. “And find out what you can about Padma. I know she came from the East. And she said when she was feverish that there was a cuckoo in the Rookery.” Balin frowned. “Bilbo told me that cuckoos are murderous birds whose young murder and evict the offspring of the birds whose nests they invade and exploit. She must have seen something that put her in mind of that.”
“Or it could be the ravings of a delirious mind,” Balin pointed out.
“Though why would you kill for that?” Thorin’s tone was dark. “Someone considers her a threat. I beg you…she does not deserve to die alone in such mean circumstances.” He dropped his voice. “I believe my mother welcomed her to Erebor and accepted her service. If I can do nothing else, I have to try this.” He looked up. “At least speak to Uribet and Oin. They will confirm what I have said.”
“Why?” Balin asked him, his eyes narrowing. “You have nothing. Except, it seems, the friendship of a foreign Prince. Does he know who you are?” Thorin looked away.
“No. Nor will he. There is no future there,” he said hollowly. “Not for me.”
“Yet the Prince goes for a walk every day and returns looking happier,” Balin noted. “You seem to be a friend that he desperately needs. But there can never be something more. Not while the King’s Edict holds sway.” Thorin nodded then looked up.
“Will you help me?” he asked bluntly. Balin sat back.
“Yes,” he said without hesitation. “Because something is gravely wrong. Deaths among the guards that are covered up? Ambushing a healer-kin to both of us? Persecuting an old woman?” Balin fixed his piercing glare on the former Prince and inspected him. “I am the Adviser to the King and the Crown Prince and I hate not knowing everything. Yet it seems there is a conspiracy going on right under my nose.” He nodded. “At least I know who to trust-and who not to.” He rose.
“Thank you,” Thorin murmured and walked to the door.
“Laddie?” Balin called, causing the tall dwarf to look back. His shabby tunic and bruises were a shame upon Erebor and that moment, Balin decided that it was time he took a stand. He would have words with Dwalin and the brothers could take their own actions. “Take care. If any survived, they will have recognised you and that puts you in danger.”
“I’m always in danger,” Thorin muttered then bowed. “Thank you, my Lord. I apologise for taking your time.” He even closed the door quietly behind him as Balin stared at the stone. Absently, he opened the bottom drawer of his desk after unlocking it with a key he carried around his neck. Carefully, he drew out a thick burgundy ledger stuff with missives and papers and rested it thoughtfully onto the desk. He fished out a new sheet of parchment and rested it on the ledger.
“What have you uncovered?” he murmured and started making a list of his new responsibilities.
-o0o-
“I have a plan.” It wasn’t the usual statement that Bofur came out with but the fact he was sober when he said it caught everyone’s attention. They were collected in the kitchen that evening, relaxing after preparing an obscene amount of food for the second Ball. This time, roasted meats, stews and a myriad of sweetmeats had been prepared and were being served to the guests as they waited to be presented to the Hobbit Prince. The usual staff had cleaned up and gone home but Bombur, his family, the Ri family. Oin and Uribet and even Dwalin were seated at the table enjoying the finest quality ‘leftovers’ that Erebor could provide. There was ale as well, though everyone knew not to get too rowdy: the guard would overlook a friendly gathering if they were just snatching a bite before bed after work but a full blown party would attract unwanted attention, even if Dwalin was present.
Bifur glanced up and rolled his eyes.
Never a promising start, he commented in Iglishmek as Bombur laughed.
“Your plans do often leave something to be desired,” he noted, swallowing his potatoes.
“Like an actual plan,” Nori put in, draining his cup. “Good nosh, Bombur. Thanks.” The chef inclined his head, blushing modestly.
“Seems a shame to just feed it to the pigs,” he commented. “If it’s fit for a King, then it should be worthy of my friends and family.” Dori raised his cup of ale and Dwalin grunted his gratitude, chewing on a leg of mutton that was succulent and delicately spiced. Ori and his daughter winked to one another and clanked their cups together, toasting just both being alive.
“Anyway, this plan of mine,” Bofur continued, grinning broadly. “Who isn’t here who should be?”
Everyone stared at him for a long moment.
“Thorin,” Ori realised. He glanced over at Oin, who nodded.
“All of us, in one way or another, are connected to him,” he commented. “He saved my daughter.”
“And my brother,” Ori added.
“He helped us save the Princes,” Bifur added in slow Khuzdul.
“He never fails to assist when we are busy,” Bombur added.
“He got me out of a pickle with those three guards and that Stonefoot hustler…” Bofur admitted. And then he paused. There was another reason, one closer to his heart and longer ago but which had solidified his friendship for the dwarf. Maybe fifty years earlier, when Bofur was a little more rash and the King had been insistent that they needed to accelerate mining, a number of new tunnels had been opened. For dwarves like Bofur-who was a miner because he enjoyed the thrill but who also enjoyed the quieter pleasures of toy making-it had been a lucrative time. And on that day, he had been down a new tunnel with Bifur and eight others when Bofur’s stone sense had gone off like a klaxon and he had only had time to grab his cousin and dive before the roof had fallen in.
The two had heard the cries of dying dwarves, the ominous creaks as the tortured stone, weakened by the collapse, threatened to crush their tiny air pocket. And there were so many yards of fallen rock that Bofur had resigned himself to dying in the tiny tomb.
But he hadn’t died. Every able bodied dwarf had been co-opted into the rescue, even the menials who were used to clean and move the trash. But among them had been Thorin, gifted with the powerful stone sense of the Line of Durin that had lain dormant because he had never been allowed anywhere near the mines where it could be of use. But among the rescuers, he had argued that there were still survivors, reaching out with his senses to detect the faintest vibrations set off by the beating of two living hearts amid the tomb. The senior miners had argued about the safety but guided by an unerring sense of where was safe, Thorin had taken a small group of miners and led them through to the adjacent tunnels-weakened and declared unsafe by the President of the Mining Guild but safe enough for the driven Thorin. And they had carefully and determinedly tunnelled through to precisely hit the little air-pocket that was becoming fetid and barely able to support the two injured dwarves within. Thorin had pulled Bofur and Bifur out himself mere moments before the roof finally gave way and crushed the tiny space out of existence.
Bofur would never admit to anyone except perhaps Mahal that he had made his peace with death and that being pulled out alive was the finest moment in his life and he had never felt such gratitude before or since. He was badly injured but Thorin had carried him to the healers and seen him carted off along with his cousin. Bifur had been thankful as well, sharing words of friendship with the Prince that his subsequent injury had erased forever. But the last thing he recalled was that Thorin had been arrested, grabbed by furious guards as the Guild President of the Miners had spat at the drudge who had dared take miners for his own rescue attempt, making the officials look slow and incompetent. Of course, no one spoke about what had happened afterwards but Bofur guessed it hadn’t been pleasant. After all-what were the lives of two common-born dwarrow to the bruised pride and challenged authority of the President of the Guild of Miners? And the worthless drudge who had proven the experts wrong to save two lives?
“When the shop opened he helped move all the stuff in, even though he had other duties as well,” Dori murmured, snapping his attention back to the room.
“Especially when those thieving bastards from Akon’s crew decided to steal your shipment of silks and brocades,” Nori said slowly. “I thought I could handle it. I couldn’t. He got me out in time and I was able to dissuade them from following through their plan…”
“Or that rumour about kidnapping Ori because he wasn’t of high enough blood to work in the Adviser’s Office,” Dwalin finally offered. “No one in the guards took it seriously and I wasn’t not going to get any answers. He went and spied on them for me. He was inconspicuous enough to get close…”
“You tell yourself that,” Nori scoffed.
“He found the ringleader and talked some sense into him,” Dwalin retorted sternly. “Before I arrested his sorry carcass.”
“My point is…that he has helped every one of us over the years,” Bofur interrupted. “Anytime anyone asks, Thorin will step up. The only people who give him a hard time are the stable master Kirgun, the guards…”
“Don’t count me with that bastard Mriak,” Dwalin grumbled, scoffing honey cakes.
“…and people who seem to have been paid to make his life a misery…”
“But why?” Ori asked, frowning. Probably the smartest of the dwarrow, it didn’t make sense that anyone would take enough of an interest in a mere drudge to launch a concerted effort to make his life miserable. Bifur looked up and met Dwalin’s eye. The balding warrior shook his head slightly.
“A long time ago, he crossed the wrong person,” he said cautiously. “He was shamed and cast out of his family.”
“He never talks about it,” Bombur admitted.
“But he deserves more.” Bofur’s voice was fired with enthusiasm.
“Many people do,” Dori pointed out. “But what’s your plan?” Bofur glanced over to his brother and Bombur shrugged.
“My son has been called to fetch him for the stables a couple of times,” he revealed. “For the Halfling Prince.”
“They’ve met there every day for the last five days,” Nori put in. “The Halfling brings a bag of food, they both eat and they talk.”
There was silence as everyone stared at the thief.
“What? It was unusual for a visiting noble to go to the stables so often, I thought there may be something in it.”
“There is,” Dwalin said in a gruff voice and sat back, folding his arms across his broad chest.
“The Prince always seems happier in the negotiations after he’s returned from his walk,” Ori said slowly. “You think…?”
“I think we’re all getting far too far ahead of ourselves,” Uribet cut in sharply. “A few visits by the Halfling to the stable and suddenly we’re assuming…what…?”
“Friendship,” Bofur said. Bombur nodded and even Dori pursed his lips. Nori sat back and looked shifty, causing his brothers to think he knew more than he was letting on.
“A Prince and a drudge,” he commented. “Bedtime stories for pebbles. I can hardly see the nobles who are lining up to court the Prince being happy at that news.”
“So my idea was that we arrange for him to go to the Ball, to be treated like the dwarf he truly is and allow the Prince to see him not just as a drudge but as he deserves,” Bofur said.
“And what then?” Dwalin asked sharply. “He dances with the Prince? He eats good food, fit for a King. And then he goes back to his rags and that little cupboard he sleeps in, surviving on scraps and unkindness. How will that make his lot any better?”
“He doesn’t have anything to wear in any case,” Oin pointed out, sharing a quick look with Dwalin. He could understand the sentiments behind the offer but all he could see was hurt coming Thorin’s way.
“And he’s shamed,” Dwalin repeated. “He wears no braids and would be ejected if he arrived.”
“Changing yer appearance isn’t that hard,” Nori cut in. “There’s a sort of putty you can put in to change yer nose and cheeks…”
“And his beard…”
“Look-I make toys,” Bofur reminded him. “So does Bifur. And we’d have a lot of bald warrier figures if we didn’t have fake hair. I can make him a beard and a wig if needed. Dori could make him an outfit that is fit for a Prince. Nori and Ori could make sure he’s on the lists and gets into the room. And beyond that…it would be up to him.”
“Word has it that the Halfling isn’t impressed with the options given him so far,” Nori put in, making Dwalin wonder how exactly the thief knew. “Maybe he would appreciate a chance to choose a friend rather than a stranger?”
“I would ask him first,” Oin murmured. “And be thoughtful what you say. Pity would hurt him more than a knife to the gut…” Dwalin raised a bushy eyebrow. “His pride is almost all he has left.”
“No,” Bofur said determinedly. “He has friends. He has done so much for so many over the years. Maybe it’s time something was done for him.”
There were cheers and excited chatter as the dwarves all enthusiastically backed the plan-all but Dwalin and Oin. The cousins shared a look: there was only one snag.
If Thorin was caught at the Ball by the King or Crown Princess, then he would almost certainly be put to death.
