Chapter Text
Seventeen: Trapped
The all-encompassing roar of the collapse had finally died down, leaving only the coughs of the dwarf Princes and the creak of settling stone. Fili glanced around but saw nothing, the air still thick with dust.
“Kee?’ he asked, his voice hoarse. “You there?”
“Yes?” came the gruff reply, his brother sounding lost. “What happened?”
“Collapse,” Fili said and wriggled from under the protective grasp of the stablehand. “He knew. He got us out of there.” There was a groan and Thorin shifted his position, releasing the young princes and pushing himself up to a sitting position.
“I was born down here,” the stablehand said, his voice curiously even. “There was a collapse. My mother was trapped and she went into labour, alone. She was badly injured and though I was born safe, she died before we were dug out. They found me in her arms, clutching her bead.” There was an awkward pause. “I remember the fireflies.” The young princes looked up and saw the twinkling shapes in the darkness. In fact, there were enough of them to cast the faintest of lights that outlined the three dwarves.
“Wow,” Kili commented, glancing at his brother. He could see Fili’s profile and read the concentration in his features. “Sorry-we don’t even know your name. I’m Kili son of Dís daughter of Thráin.”
“I am Fili, son of Dís daughter of Thráin,” the elder Prince added. The stablehand sighed.
“Thorin,” he said. There was a pause.
“You don’t offer your father’s name?” Fili challenged him. Unseen in the near-darkness, Thorin gave a wry smile.
“You don’t offer yours?” he retorted, his deep voice amused. There was an awkward pause.
“Our mother is of the Line of Durin, granddaughter of the King,” Fili told him sharply.
“And your father?” Thorin asked them. “Does he not deserve acknowledgement as well?” There was a pause. “You are Princes of the Line of Durin. Everyone knows that. Does your father not even earn his name being recalled by his sons?”
There was a pause and then Kili shifted position.
“He’s right,” he said. “I mean, I know Adad died but he should be honoured by his sons.”
“Then why do you not offer your father’s name?” Fili asked, his voice edged with anger. Thorin inspected him, his eyes acclimatising to the darkness quicker. It was plain the lad was proud of his heritage and hadn’t appreciated the challenge: pride was the curse of the line of Durin.
“I have no name or family to offer,” Thorin told him plainly. “I am dishonoured and disowned.”
“The reason for no braids,” Kili put in. “And your short beard.”
“Why?” Fili asked him suspicious, the scrape of boots across the floor telling Thorin that the lad was retreating from him-and pulling his brother back. At least he was showing some glimmers of sense-unfortunately about an hour too late.
“There was an accident,” Thorin said quietly. “I injured a noble during training. Despite it being an accident and the noble speaking for me, I was cast from my family, my beard and braids cut and forbidden from ever wearing them again or ever leaving Erebor.” There was a pause.
“That’s not right,” Kili put in. “If that was the case, we both would have been disowned about a hundred times. We injure each other all the time.”
“My brother’s mother was determined that I was evil that she would stop at nothing to have me removed,” the older dwarf said and levered himself up to his feet, His head was still swimming and his legs felt wobbly. He was certain he had cracked ribs as well and his throat was dry as sandpaper: depressingly, there was nothing he could do about any of that. But above him, he could see the faint lights of the fireflies, leading deeper into the mountain. “We can’t stay here. The tunnel may well be unstable and it would take them days to dig us out-even if they knew we were here.”
There was an awkward silence.
“No one knew you were here, did they?” Kili asked him thoughtfully.
“Some people did,” Thorin corrected him. “And they intended me to die here. Though whether the collapse was natural or…assisted is difficult to say.”
“Why do you say that?” Fili asked him seriously.
“I felt something-like a snap, a brightness in the stone that shouldn’t have been there,” Thorin said, frowning, trying to process the memory. “It may have been a flash-flame.”
“We received a note telling us to come down here,” the older Prince murmured, his voice wary. “Our Uncle never showed and we decided to start exploring before he arrived.”
“If he knows you are here, he will have them digging,” Thorin assured them.
“I am not sure he does,” Fili said quietly.
“I brought Frerin down here with Dwalin when we were much younger,” Thorin murmured. “It was like a Rite of Passage-before Adad found out. He was very displeased.” He stopped as the boys stared at him.
“You knew our Uncle when you were younger? And Dwalin?” Kili’s voice was urgent and carried a hopeful edge. Hearing the unknown dwarf was a former companion of Frerin and Dwalin was a source of relief for Kili and more suspicion for Fili.
“I did,” Thorin admitted. “But it was a long time ago.”
“What did you do?” Fili demanded. Thorin turned away, a painful tug in his chest reminding him that once they got out, these two would go back to being in the Line of Succession while he would be once more nameless and on the radar for being murdered. He began to walk in the direction the little trail of fireflies led.
“I’m going to the caverns,” he said quietly. “There is more light there and there is moisture. The caverns are natural and that means there is the chance that there could be another way out.”
“Why should we trust you?” Fili asked him.
“Why should you not?” Thorin asked him halting. “I was left here to die. I was disowned for an accident and never given a chance to ever redeem myself. Yet I have made no move to harm you or anyone.”
“Then answer me this,” Fili demanded. “Why would anyone want to kill you?”
“Because I am a loose end,” Thorin told him bleakly. “A potential problem for their plot. So I need to be eliminated before they make their move.” Then he walked off. Kili followed but Fili grabbed his arm.
“I don’t trust him,” he said in a low voice. “He’s not telling us the truth.” There was a pause.
“No-he’s not telling us the whole truth-but he hasn’t lied,” Kili corrected him, his light tone slightly more serious than usual. “And your treating him like an enemy isn’t helping. He saved our lives, Fee. That has to count for something.”
“Anyone would do that,” the older Prince said stubbornly.
“But anyone didn’t. Thorin did!” Kili retorted. Then he sighed. “I don’t think he’s been treated well. You said he’d been beaten. He was left tied up here. From what he says, he might have been left there to die. If we weren’t here, would anyone even bother excavating the cave-in?”
“You know the answer as well as I do,” Fili said more softly. “But no one is disowned for just a simple accident…” His younger brother gave a small, bitter huff of laughter.
“I could imagine it in our family,” he pointed out. “And the King’s judgements grow more erratic. It’s not that much of a stretch…”
“You’re right,” Fili acquiesced. “Okay-let’s go after him. He’s obviously got a better stone sense than we have and he’s been down here before. But keep your weapons to hand. If he tries anything, no matter how sorry you feel for him, if it’s a choice between him and us…” Kili shook his hand off but he didn’t argue, instead pacing after Thorin, deeper into the mountain. Shaking his head, Fili followed him.
-o0o-
It became obvious to Bilbo that Thorin wasn’t coming. He had come to the stables and when it was clear the dwarf wasn’t there, he had sent a couple of runners to locate him, as he had before. But this time, there was no success and after a fruitless hour Bilbo packed away the little lunch he had brought and headed back.
It wasn’t that Thorin was busy-Yavanna, he had missed more than a couple of meetings because of his additional duties with the visiting Elves (who had rudely refused to go and were insistent on coming to the next Ball as well) and Men of Dale. No, it was because he had been looking forward to seeing the dwarf, to asking him how his day was and listening to his rich voice, commenting dryly on Bilbo’s silly, fussy narrative. And there was a part of Bilbo that was a little concerned because he had seen the nasty look in the stable master’s face when he had come across Thorin and Bilbo talking and suspected that Thorin’s absence may not have been entirely coincidental. He had come the day before and had apparently ‘just missed him’. Now he was not so sure…
There was a rumbling crash and the lower part of the mountain shook. Not a dwarf, Bilbo still realised something serious had happened and he headed towards the source of the sound, a cloud of dust rolling up from the lower level. Dwarves were running and yelling and despite being jostled and bumped, Bilbo went with them, insanely seeing if there was any help he could offer. There were miners milling around and rather agitated guards who seemed to be trying to keep everyone back-in fact Dwalin grabbed him and pulled him back before he could get lost in the crowd.
“What are you doing here, your Highness?” he asked gruffly, his dark eyes narrowed with anger. “This is no place for gentle folk.”
“What’s happened?” Bilbo asked in puzzlement. “Everyone seems concerned…”
“Tunnel collapse,” the warrior explained, not releasing the Hobbit. “Old tunnels to the abandoned mines have gone down. There was a rumour someone was seen going in before they collapsed so we don’t know if anyone is trapped or if they are alive…”
“Can you take the risk?” Bilbo asked. But Dwalin gave a small jerk of the head towards the crowd, where a shape with a hat that Bilbo realised was Bofur was hovering around the entrance.
“Bofur has a strong stone sense,” he explained. “Though I’d appreciate it if you didn’t share that knowledge. He can see if he can sense how long the collapse is and if there are any alive in there.” There was a small gasp and Bilbo stared at him.
“That’s amazing…” he murmured and then he nodded, his face falling into a serious expression. “But of course, I will respect your secrets, Master Dwalin. You have my word.”
“Aye, that should be good enough,” the warrior accepted.
“And there is nothing I can do?” the Hobbit Prince checked. Dwalin sighed.
“If there is someone alive, we will dig for them,” he explained. “If not, we will mourn and leave them to the stone. The tunnel has collapsed before, killing the Crown Princess…”
“Oh…I am sorry,” Bilbo murmured, recalling the story he had been told. “Maybe it should be left now.” Then he looked up. “I hope no one is trapped but I am sure you will not leave them if there is any hope…” Dwalin nodded.
“Dwarves are stubborn,” he reminded the Hobbit. “Where there is the slightest hope, we will not give up.”
“And I can do nothing,” Bilbo sighed.
“Pray,” the powerful dwarf said grimly. “Pray that if anyone is in there, they aren’t trapped in an air pocket and can hold out until rescued.”
-o0o-
They had been walking for what seemed like hours, stumbling over the uneven floor that sloped downwards and was littered with rocks and abandoned props and tools. Killi had tripped twice and hit his arm on an old mattock, cutting his elbow. Fili was surprised at how silently Thorin moved but he guessed the older dwarf had been down here before and knew how to walk in the gloom without falling flat on his face. A small corner of his mind suggested that his careful footsteps could be related to the fact that people disliked him enough to kidnap him, beat him up and leave him to die and a shudder ran down his spine that had nothing to do with the clammy darkness or the rather alarming creaks and groans that resonated through the unsettled rocks as they recovered from the sudden collapse. He hoped that Kili wasn’t thinking the same dark thoughts because his brother was bright and warm and didn’t need to be burdened with such grim reality. Mahal knew, there was enough swirling around the Royal family anyway. But as they walked on, his imagination also supplied the images of a younger Frerin and Dwalin, sneaking down here alongside a younger version of this dwarf, with his brilliant blue eyes and raven dark hair, just so they could boast how brave they had been.
The stablehand paused and halted at a fork in the tunnel, waiting for the young Princes to catch up. He was dealing with a hammering headache and numerous bruises all over his body and he was hungry and thirsty but every protective bone in his body told him that he had to find a way to get the young Princes-his nephews-out of this mess. Escaping from the unstable tunnel that was contributing to his thunderous headache was only the first step. Somehow, he needed to locate a way out of the caverns as well.
“When will you be missed?” he asked, his voice hoarse. Kili shrugged.
“Dinner,” he guessed. “Until then, we can get away with hiding.”
“And then…”
“The entire mountain will be turned upside down,” Fili said even. “But you knew that, didn’t you?”
“Your Highnesses, you are the Heirs, third and fourth in the Line of Succession,” Thorin said grimly. “Your Amad is a determined dwarrowdam and she would tear Erebor apart with her bare hands if she needed to in order to find you.”
“You know her?” Kili asked.
“Her reputation precedes her,” Thorin said and turned to the wider tunnel. “It’s not far now.”
“Are you sure about this?” Fili asked him directly. “Won’t they be calling for us?”
“The tunnel is blocked for a long stretch,” he reminded them. “There will be water down here.” Then he walked on for a few hundred yards and then paused, for a pinkish light was shining softly ahead of them. The young Princes stared at the outline of their companion, seeing his features soften with memory. “Come,” he said and walked into the cavern.
The Princes followed and then stopped, their eyes wide and mouths open with shock. They were in an enormous space, the equal of any of the great halls of Erebor, though the walls were not the polished deep green stone that characterised the kingdom. No, here the dark stone was studded with huge crystals of purple and pink, their multifaceted shapes melding and abutting each other so the entire wall appeared as a knobbly armour. Above their heads, there were still the faint stars of the fireflies, fluttering amid the gentle wash of light that filled the cavern. They turned and saw the other walls were similarly studded with crystals of all sizes, from tiny crystals smaller than a fingernail to monsters as large as a dwarf’s chest.
“Mahal,” Fili breathed as Kili just stared. Thorin gave a small smile at their wonder and then limped off deeper into the cavern. Desperate to continue staring at the incredible sight but not wanting to lose sight of him, the Princes followed until he reached the far wall and the welcome sound of water dripping down. As they watched, he crouched down and found a little trickle of clear water dripping through. It was icy and a little gritty but it tasted pure and Thorin took a long drink and scrubbed his face before beckoning the boys forward. Achingly he stood up and peered around as they drank. Then Kili looked up at him.
“What now?” he asked. Fili stared.
“The truth,” he decided, narrowing his eyes at the strange dwarf. “Who are you?”
Thorin stilled. “Thorin,” he said.
“That’s not a name,” the elder Prince said bitingly.
“It is my name.”
“It’s the name of a King,” Fili told him. “King Thorin was son of Thráin, son of Náin, son of Durin the Sixth. He died about seven hundred years ago. No one uses the names of the Line of Durin…except the Line of Durin.” Kili stared and elbowed his brother in the midriff.
“You’ve actually been paying attention?” he hissed. “I thought you promised…” Fili rolled his eyes.
“Someone had to keep Balin happy and it is just family history-like learning about what your great great grandfather used to eat for breakfast…”
“Except it’s our great great great great great great grandfather,” Kili reminded him.
“Ha! I knew you’d been paying attention!” Fili told him triumphantly.
“Hey-Amad asked me to pay attention and I hate it when she makes that upset face,” the younger Prince complained.
“Don’t hear you complaining when you pull the puppy eyes on Balin and get out of lessons or training,” Fili grumbled.
“You’re only jealous because you can’t do it and never get off lessons,” Kili told him smugly.
Thorin felt his muscles tense because he had missed this, the bickering and easy camaraderie that came from having a brother as close as one could be. From having an ally, a defender, a friend who would never abandon you, no matter what life threw at you…
…except his had. Not completely but enough that Thorin was alone and had been for far too long. Even Dís, who had made a determined effort to meet secretly with him had been more distant over the last few years-though with this pair of rascals to keep an eye on, he could understand why. But it hurt that his family was just there-and yet a few stolen moments in secret was all he could claim. And these boys had never met him. They didn’t know who he was and he had been a coward in hiding his identity-maybe to protect them. Maybe to protect his own battered heart from any more pain.
Yet someone had made sure they were there, at the mine at the time it collapsed. A crime designed to bury Thorin once and for all and dispose of two boys either to punish Frerin or Dís for standing up for Bilbo-which sent another sick shudder through Thorin’s gut-or because they were inconvenient. And he knew the only person in Erebor who would consider such an assassination justified.
“So give us your name.” Fili and Kili were facing him shoulder to shoulder, their faces determined. They were trapped in the cavern-a place of wonder but deep under the roots of Erebor. There was water but no food and no one even knew they were there. He nodded and made his decision. These young dwarves deserved to know the truth-and make of it what they will.
“My name is Thorin son of Thráin son of Thrór,” he said. “I am your Uncle.”
