Chapter Text
Twenty: Kark û n son of Runlêl
The Fourth Ball had a strange atmosphere that had Bilbo on edge. There had been the unpleasantness that morning with Thrór threatening his granddaughter and his apparently callous disregard for his own lost kin. Hobbits would mobilise their entire family, neighbours and village to look for a lost child and they would not give up until they had succeeded: the miraculous return of the boys, clambering through a crack in the wall of an emerald mine of all things, had merely added to the concerns around the whole incident.
Bilbo felt as if he had seen every dwarf in Erebor already but more and more had poured into the Hall and were lined up to offer their suit to him. The buffet smelled amazing and his suit this evening-a deep blue jacket over a black shirt and trousers with silver waistcoat-was comfortable and light. Master Dori had done an excellent job in outfitting the Shire Royalty and they all looked regal and elegant. Sipping the wine that Kili had brought him, the Shire Prince sighed. Kili had insisted on coming to the Ball so Fili was there was well, collecting a plate of food for his mother and keeping a watching eye on his younger brother, who was waiting to refill the Hobbit’s goblet.
“Anyone caught your eye this evening?” the younger Prince asked, his dark eyes twinkling. He seemed unaffected by his escapade but there was a knowing look in his eyes which made Bilbo confused.
“Should anyone?” he asked. Kili grinned: he and Fili had shared an interesting talk with Dwalin and had agreed that they would do whatever they could for the dwarf who had saved them from being lost in the mountain.
“Sometimes, you find what you’re looking for in the last place you think you would find it,” he commented. “The Crown Princess may look as if she has smelled something that’s been buried for a decade because these are the last in the list of invitees-not noble or the richest merchants or cleverest politicians…but dwarves know that the most unpromising rock can sometimes conceal a treasure behind value.”
Bilbo stared. Kili was the last dwarf he would have put down for philosophy but his words were true. He just hoped that the young dwarf was correct.
“We can but hope,” he commented dryly, handing his empty goblet to the Prince. Kili winked.
“Don’t give up yet,” he said.
The next three would-be suitors were completely hopeless and it was with resignation that he turned to the next dwarf to walk forward.
The dwarf bowed low, straightening up to meet Bilbo’s eyes-and sending a shiver of recognition down the smaller creature’s spine. He knew those eyes-and immediately he began to doubt himself. Maybe he was just so desperate to see his friend amid the disappointment of yesterday and his own uncertainties that he was imagining Thorin in any dwarf bearing a passing resemblance. Sure, the dwarf facing him was definitely the right height and had the same long dark hair-though there were a couple of thin braids from his temples, each decorated with a stunning bead-and he had exactly the correct blue eyes but his beard was full and braided, unlike Thorin’s sadly shorn effort and he was dressed richly.
“Karkûn son of Runlêl, at your service, your Highness,” the dwarf said and oh, it was the voice that he recognised, rich and deep and so familiar.
“Bilbo Baggins, Prince of the Shire,” the Hobbit responded, bowing his head in acknowledgement and hiding the way his heart was galloping. “I will ask you the questions that I ask all comers who would seek my hand. What would you offer to me as a courting gift, Master Karkûn?” The dwarf nodded and thought for a moment.
“You are a Prince and I do not believe that gold or jewels would be necessary for one already in your position. The Hobbits of the Shire are a peaceable people so weapons would insult you, I think. If I was being honest, a true courting gift should be based on a longer friendship so that it can be personalised to your favourite pastimes or activities. But knowing a little of Hobbits, of your love of good food, good company and all that is green and growing in your land of rolling hills and little rivers, I would offer you flowers that would speak to you of my feelings.”
Bilbo stared at him, almost breathless.
“Go on,” he murmured.
“I would make you a bouquet of flowers that tell you of my heart,” the dwarf said, his eyes never leaving Bilbo’s. “I would use daisy for hope, blue hyacinth for constancy, chamomile for patience in adversity, bluebell for humility, aster for devotion, geranium for true friendship and, of course, a red rose for my love.” He paused and then smiled. “And, not forgetting Myrtle-because she brought us together.”
Suddenly it was far too hot and Bilbo had to take a shaky breath to calm himself.
“Why do you want to marry me, Master Karkûn?” he asked in a hoarse voice. The dwarf twitched a small smile.
“Because you are the most remarkable, generous, kind, decent being I have ever met,” he said genuinely. “I had long given up all hope of any affection and yet, you sought me out. You offered friendship despite my lowly station and my unworthiness and somewhere in that stall, my withered heart responded. It fell for a being who was kind and smart, brave and decent and generous to those who did not deserve it. For a being who made so much effort for one so worthless. And it is not gratitude, because that is no basis for a relationship but admiration, respect and love.”
Bilbo stared at him and wondered where this dwarf had been. Thorin had been so carefully controlled-funny and witty, yes but always so carefully closed against revealing his past and his heart. So maybe Thorin was here because he felt this was his one chance to reveal himself. Maybe he was in trouble. He certainly hadn’t been in the stables and no one had seen him. It made the Hobbit all the more worried for him, reckless in coming here when maybe his life was at risk. But to hear the words spoken so boldly and with such conviction made his heart fly.
“And what would you give up for me, Master Karkûn?” he asked quietly. This time, the dwarf did not hesitate.
“Everything,” he said honestly. “When you love someone, you should be willing to give up all else for that love. When a dwarf finds his One, he finds the other half of his soul-and what would you not give for you soul? Where you would go, I would follow. I would leave my home, my friends and what family I could one day claim, my people and my identity. I would be alone among your people if it meant I could be with you because when you find someone that you wish to gift your heart and soul to, you are not alone. Home is not always a place but a person, the One you are meant to be with. So I would give everything up for you, Ghivashel.”
“Bless you,” Bilbo said automatically. The dwarf smiled.
“Treasure of all treasures, your Highness. Forgive my boldness.”
“There is much I would forgive for someone who says such words with such absolute sincerity,” Bilbo told him and then leaned close. “I have a riddle for you, Master Dwarf. What is greater than Mahal but more evil than Morgoth. The poor have it, the rich need it and if you eat it, you will die. What is it?”
The dwarf paused and read the hope and trust in the Hobbit’s eyes. This was his final test.
“It is what I would spare in winning your hand and declaring my love,” he said. “The answer to both is Nothing.”
Bilbo reached out and took his hand, feeling the warmth leaching through the larger grasp.
“Master Karkûn, I believe you are the first person here who has shown an interest in me,” he said quietly. “Regrettably, I must talk to these other dwarves. But I would ask you to take a bite to eat. I want you for the first dance.” Thorin bowed forward, brushing his lips on the back of Bilbo’s hand.
“At your service, your Highness,” he said quietly and stepped away to allow the next suitor to try his luck. From the expression on Bilbo’s face, it would be a futile exercise.
The other dwarves were glaring at him and he acknowledged their hostility with a small incline of the head-but nothing more. He could still recall how to behave like a Prince-it had been bred into him, after all-and in a mountain the size of Erebor, no one could be expected to recognise everyone else on sight. So he got a drink and helped himself to food-he wasn’t so foolish to turn down free food, after all, though he made sure he didn’t eat himself to a stupor. In fact, his stomach was bubbling with anxiety to prevent him from eating much of the delicious spread as he watched Bilbo meet the rest of the suitors and dismiss them with due alacrity. And then he saw the Hobbit sit with two others-presumably his parents-and demolish a heaped plateful of food as it it was a light snack. Finally, Bilbo rose and his eyes fell on the dwarf. The band changed tune from some traditional lay to a more upbeat tempo-and then Thorin saw it. Thrór-whose eyes had been skimming the Hobbit with a possessiveness that had Thorin’s own protective hackles raised-began to rise to claim the first dance with the Hobbit. But Bilbo was already away, speeding from the dais and across the room, dodging between any and all who would intercept him and coming to stand in front of Thorin.
“Master Karkûn,” he said, offering his hand with a smile. “May I have this dance?” There was the briefest of pauses and Thorin took his hand.
“It would be my honour,” he murmured, his throat dry.
And then the Hobbit was in his arms, held close enough to be aware of every inch of his body, yet far enough to maintain the most meagre of semblances of propriety. Thorin felt the faintest of tremors in Bilbo’s hand, meeting his eyes and then everything else was irrelevant as they spun with the music, twirling and swaying and navigating round the dance floor. Behind them, the King had resumed his seat, his face darkened with fury at being thwarted. All eyes were on the pair as they spun across the floor, finally halting when the music ended with a flourish.”
“Thank you,” Thorin murmured, his throat dry-but Bilbo was smiling.
“Oh no, Master Dwarf,” he said with a small smile. “You are my chosen partner this evening.” He looked over to the band and nodded and confused but sensing something had shifted, they struck up another number. And another. And another.
Others joined in on the floor, swirling sedately but Bilbo only had eyes for the dwarf in his arms. Anytime another potential suitor asked for a dance, he was politely but firmly turned down as the Shire Prince made his preference obvious. Soon, the guests were huddled in clustered, murmuring and whispering. Who was Karkûn? What was his profession? How did he know the Shire Prince (for it was obvious this was not the first encounter they had). But everyone agreed that there was no doubt that the Prince had found someone he had decided met his criteria for a suitor and the guests-amid their disappointment-wondered if they would be seeing something more than a few dances.
Time passed and finally, it was approaching midnight. It was the longest that Bilbo had ever tarried in the Balls, usually leaving as early as he could-but this time, he never wanted the evening to end. He knew those eyes and though there had been an attempt to disguise the voice, there was too much familiarity in those rich tones for there to be any doubt. Somehow, Thorin had come to the Ball and offered his heart to Bilbo. And searching his own heart had led the Hobbit to realise that the dwarf was already there, nestled in and waiting for Bilbo to recognise him.
Then had just finished a slow waltz when Thorin bowed and then caught Bilbo’s hand.
“Highness,” he murmured. “Bilbo…this has been the most magical of evenings and my heart is filled with love. I hope and I pray I have not misread this…but may I give you a token of my devotion…a token that you would consider accepting my courtship?” There was no hesitation as Bilbo nodded.
“What do you want to do?” he asked. ‘Karkûn’ smiled.
“I would braid a bead into your hair, as a sign of my suit,” he said softly. Bilbo gave an apologetic smile.
“I fear Hobbit hair does not braid well-though my mother is rather talented,” he admitted. Thorin chuckled.
“Dwarves are skilled at braiding and I believe I am sufficiently motivated,” he admitted, reaching to his own braid and pulling one of the beautiful beads free. Asking with his eyes-and receiving an enthusiastic nod-he gently took the lock of hair behind Bilbo’s ear and deftly put a small braid in, tying the braid in and capping it with a clip as well. The brilliant smile that lit Bilbo’s face was a wonder to behold as he gently raised a hand to touch the bead.
“Oh my goodness,” he murmured and looked up at Thorin.
“It was my mother’s marriage bead from my father,” he said softly. “It was the bead I was found clutching when they rescued us from the cave-in where we were trapped when I was born. She died but lived long enough to give me life. I have kept them in the hope of giving that bead to the one I loved.”
“Thank you,” the Hobbit said in a gentle voice. “Such a meaningful gift is exactly what I would hope for from my partner…”
“STOP!”
The voice of the King rang through the Hall, a roar of rage and malice. “THAT DWARF IS AN IMPOSTER!”
Bilbo looked up and met Thorin’s suddenly worried expression.
“I must go,” the dwarf whispered. “No matter what happens, I love you. Whatever price I pay for this evening, it was worth it.”
“SEIZE HIM!” the King bellowed and guards immediately began to converge on the pair-but Thorin leaned forward and pecked a brief kiss on Bilbo’s startled lips before diving away. The guards were yelling for him to stop as he ducked between shocked rivals and hurdled the now-empty food tables, before he vanished through the hidden door that led to the secret tunnels he had learned in his youth. The door slammed behind him and he was gone.
“SEARCH THE MOUNTAIN!” Thrór roared, his voice icy with hatred. “BRING THAT DWARF TO ME! I WANT HIM FLUNG AT MY FEET SO I CAN LEARN HIS TRUE NAME BEFORE HE DIES!”
“But what has he done?” Bungo asked, his brow furrowed. Thrór turned on him, his eyes pale with madness, a golden sheen obscuring the pale blue colour.
“He dared to steal my dance and imagine he could betroth himself to my Halfling!” he snapped. “Your son is mine. He will marry me and remain at my side forever. But as he has dared to defy me, that imposter must die first.” He swung his arm round and glared at his shocked subjects. “This Ball is over!”
