Chapter Text
Twenty Six: The Cuckoo Unmasked
“Maybe I should tell you the story,” Balin suggested. “A story both you and your Hobbit Prince helped uncover.” He looked around. “Once you looked, there was a pattern. But the trick is knowing there is a pattern there to start with!”
“I hardly see…” Verizul argued but Thráin raised his hand sharply.
“Speak, my friend,” he said. His gaze glanced over to Dwalin, who was hovering protectively by Thorin. “I have always trusted the sons of Fundin, son of Farin. I know your line serves the Crown with utmost loyalty and honour.” Galdalf leaned slightly on staff as the King resumed the throne and his younger children stood at his side. Bergilde drew her self up indignantly, her face cold. Thorin stood, facing his family with Balin at his side.
“It began over a hundred and seventy years ago in the Orocani Mountains,” Balin said clearly. “There was a coup and a more ambitious and cruel branch of the Royal Line took over the Blacklock Clan. Many dwarrow died in the fighting and a number of refugees fled. Some even came here, to Erebor, and were welcomed.
The new rulers eyed the Lonely Mountain with envious eyes, for Erebor was-and is-the greatest and richest dwavish kingdom in Middle Earth. And looking, they saw an opportunity. For King Thrór, for all his power and arrogance had but one child, one son who could be ripe for marriage and falling into the arms of a Blacklock who would turn him to their cause and place her own offspring-Blacklock offspring-on Durin’s throne. So a plan was hatched, a long, long game that started with placing a suitable candidate in Erebor to meet and catch a Prince. So she was sent, claiming to be from the Iron Hills rather than from the Orocani and a noble claimed her as his daughter, pretending she had been with kin rather than an imposter.
But while they had planned, the Crown Prince had met his One and had married her to the joy of the Kingdom. It looked as if all the planning was for naught-but the conspirators had no sympathy for a happy ending and set to work to undo the Prince’s happiness. So they set a trap and when the Princess was visiting the mines, they caused a collapse designed to kill her.”
Thráin gave a low groan and Bergilde clamped a hand around his wrist, ostensibly in comfort.
“You hurt the King with your spiteful words,” she hissed.
“And yet they carry no emotion save what you yourself put to them, your Majesty,” Gandalf commented mildly, fishing his pipe out of his bag and clamping it between his teeth. He bowed his head mockingly.
“Causing a collapse? Preposterous!” Bergilde’s voice was shrill.
“Yet true,” Balin said mildly. “Three days ago the tunnel to the Crystal Cavern collapsed. It was not a natural collapse either, the fall caused by a flash flame that was placed in the roof. That was obvious to anyone with much stone sense. But Thûn, President of the Mining Guild, could sense that the reason the collapse was so catastrophic was because it had collapsed before. That was the tunnel where Princess Fris had died-but that collapse, too, had been caused by an explosive in the roof. It was an assassination…”
“And what proof do you have?” Mriak sneered.
“The stone sense of the President of the Mining Guild told him-and thus me-that there were fractures in the roof that were old and dated to the previous collapse. The pattern of fractures could only be from an explosion. Two others with strong stone sense confirmed this.”
Bofur nodded, being one of the two. The second was, of course, Thorin. Balin gave a grim smile.
“So yes, a collapse was engineered to kill the Crown Princess and clear the way for the Blacklock agent. But there was a complication: the Princess Frís did not die immediately and alone, she gave birth to a son, Thorin, who survived.”
Bilbo stared at the dwarf he thought he knew, his mind whirling. He had known that Thorin had been holding back some of his story but he had never guessed his life had been so tragic. And how silly and superficial Bilbo must have sounded to a dwarf who had suffered such terrible losses. The Hobbit wondered why Thorin had even bothered hiding his contempt for Bilbo. He would surely never wish to continue with any sort of betrothal now with such a silly, inconsequential little Hobbit!
“Thráin mourned his wife and raised his son, Thorin, the last precious part of his wife and his One, the other half of his soul. Her death was a terrible wound for the Crown Prince and he wished only to spend his time with his son and recall his beloved wife. He never desired to wed again.
But that would not satisfy the plans of those who had already killed for their scheme. Over the years they had been planting other agents and the one posing as the father of the candidate for the Crown Prince’s hand began to whisper in Thrór’s ear. Every few days, it would be mentioned: that there was but one Heir and he had but one Heir. It would be too easy for the Line of Durin to go extinct. So finally, Thrór decided his son would remarry and bullied and threatened until his son complied. And after some vicious manoeuvring, Lady Bergilde was proposed.”
“That is utter slander!” the Queen sneered. “And worse, treason. I hope you can back up your words, Adviser, lest you lose your head for such insolence…” Balin gave a tight smile, his eyes serious and cold.
“My father, Lord Fundin, witnessed the manipulations of Lord Goffi and Lord Thyrun for almost two years until the King finally agreed with their incessant pushing,” he said. “Thyrun’s ‘cousin’ was promoted to Steward on my father’s death and continued the same line of self-serving suggestions, manipulation and distraction.” Verizul glared but the white-haired dwarf glanced at his King and saw Thráin nodding.
“I wished to remain faithful to my Frís,” he admitted.
“I do not have proof then but I know now that your Majesty was fed herbs, potions that manipulated your will and kept you compliant and subservient to your wife,” Balin pressed on. “It had been noted by Prince Frerin and myself that when you were away from home, you were a different person-much more as we recalled you-until your spouse brought you meat and ale to welcome you. Then you just…stopped. Stopped asking, stopped talking, stopped smiling, stopped showing any initiative, drive or willingness to be a Prince of the Line of Durin. There had been rumours of sorcery or some other dark arts but the explanation was much more prosaic: you were drugged. For many years. It came to light when she tried the same trick on the Shire Royalty. But Hobbits have exceptional palates and could smell the drugs in their teas and refused it. Queen Belladonna spoke to me and we obtained samples of the food and drink brought to the Royal Family and that left on the table. There was no drug in the food delivered but the food served to your Majesty was tainted with a potion of nine herbs that flattened your will and suppressed any initiative, original thought or resistance.”
“All lies!” Bergilde said superiorly.
“The samples were analysed by Healer Oin son of Groin and by the herbalist Menky son of Venky. The results were conclusive. And my agents in the Orocani found that such a potion was indeed known among a sect known as the Id-Uzrâk among the Blacklocks.” Bilbo looked up and frowned. Gandalf leaned close.
“It means the Masters,” he explained in a low voice. “Those who master the will and lives of others.”
“They have long been whispered as an abomination against the Seven Fathers but they exist,” Balin said. “They work through the shadows, placing their people in positions of power and controlling key opponents using drugs and intimidation. They took power in the Blacklock Clan of the Orocani in the coup. And once their agent had married the Crown Prince, it was time to produce her Heirs-Blacklock Heirs to oust the Line of Durin-and then take power herself. Over the years, it was easy to whisper in the ear of the Crown Prince and slowly promote those she wanted into positions of power-the Steward, the Captain of the Guard, the Chief Spy, the Master of Laws, the President of the Trade Guild. All of those dwarves do not come where they claim to have and investigations have tied them back to the Orocani and the Blacklock Clan. This has been a slow invasion in all but name.”
Dis stared at him in horror. There had been a lasting enmity between the Blacklocks and the Longbeards for four thousand years.
“But how…?” Balin gave his avuncular smile.
“The key to uncovering a pattern is to know there is a pattern to be uncovered in the first place,” he said enigmatically. “I long suspected my father’s death was not natural. The concerted moves to oust me by the Queen and the desire to promote someone unsuited but sycophantic to her were all clues. The fact that dwarves far less skilled were promoted over my brother in the Guards were another. I was already looking East. But the last clues were when the Hobbits warned of drugging and Thorin protected a Healer who was treating an old dwarf who had been a refugee from the Orocani, who had recognised the Crown Princess and her cronies. I spoke to her at length.”
“The word of an old embittered servant who resents being removed for her own incapability!” Bergilde sneered. But Balin gave a pitying smile.
“I never mentioned her background or name,” he reminded her. “How would you know of her unless you and your allies were behind the assassination attempts?”
Filli leaned towards Kili.
“Busted,” he murmured. Thráin rose, suddenly fired with purpose as he rose and walked to the shabby shape of his older son. For a moment, Thorin looked into the King’s eyes, seeing regret and sorrow at how he had been manipulated, how he had failed his son-and then Thráin grasped his shoulders.
“My son,” he said warmly, before pulling Thorin into a fierce hug. “I can never atone for my foolishness and neglect.”
“Adad,” Thorin murmured, feeling the arms tighten around him. Thráin was not as hearty as he remembered-still in the prime of life but trembling slightly and breathing hard. “It was not your neglect.” Reaching up, the King rested a hand behind Thorin’s neck and pulled his head forward for their foreheads to meet in a tender embrace.
“My Inùdoy,” Thráin murmured wearily. “How I have missed you.” His hand slid round as he pulled back to caress the red scar on Thorin’s cheek and the bruises from Mriak’s blow. “How I have failed you.”
“Adad, you could not have known,” the former Prince murmured, his heart breaking at the loss and grief in his father’s voice. “You were lost after the loss of your One-and that made you vulnerable to such machinations. The King should have known that to force you to marry again was an evil. Leave the blame to those enemies and traitors who plotted and acted this whole intrigue. But in this conspiracy, you are innocent-as are my Namad and Nadad. They did not do anything wrong.”
“But we did,” Thráin announced, looking up into his son’s starting blue eyes. “And I can right this wrong now.” He raised his voice. “I, Thráin son of Thrór son of Dain, King Under The Mountain hereby reverse all edicts of King Thrór relating to my eldest son, Thorin. I recognise him once more as a son of the House of Durin and as my eldest son and Heir. I name him Crown Prince and restore all the rights and privileges commensurate with that position. This is effective of this moment!”
There was a shocked silence as everyone stared at the King-before Frerin cheered and the younger Princes whooped. But before they could move a step to congratulate the reinstated Prince, Mriak moved and grabbed Bilbo, hauling him back with a sword to his throat and standing by the furious Queen.
“NO!” Bergilde screamed. “Look, I tried to do this nicely and keep casualties to the minimum but you just wouldn’t die. So now I have to be direct. You cannot be allowed to be the Crown Prince-that belongs to my son!”
“But it was never mine, Amad,” Frerin said honestly, looking over to his older brother. “It was always Thorin’s and we all knew it. Only you demanded that I be pushed ahead of Thorin. He’s far better suited to ruling-he knew more of and felt more for Erebor than I know even now. I don’t want it. He will be a great King!”
“NO!” she snapped. “You will take the Throne after your Father and rule as I command-or this little halfling loses contact with his head.
“Please-no!” Thorin said immediately, raising his hands slightly to show he was unarmed. “Bilbo is innocent. And you harm him, you harm Erebor…”
“From the words of that wizened old goat, you would believe I don’t have that in mind,” Bergilde hissed. She grabbed Bilbo and shook a knife from her sleeve, the purplish blade resting against his throat, her grip painfully tight on his shoulder. “Now you, my beloved, will denounce that servant and disown him once more-and then you, Thorin son of no one, will step off that walkway and die once and for all. My son will be King of Erebor! Or you lose the Hobbit and Erebor loses its food and allies!”
Thorin stared into the wide eyes of Bilbo. The Hobbit was struggling but Bergilde was strong and she had enough leverage to keep him where she wanted him. And Bilbo was his friend, his Betrothed, the other part of his heart-he was sure of it now. He could no more watch him die that raise a hand to him. He took a step back.
“Adad…Majesty…please…” he said, moving to the very edge of the drop. “Please say the words. Frerin will be King. I know he is trained and will be a good King. You must protect Bilbo. You must make sure he is safe.”
The King stared into the blue eyes that mirrored his own and gasped.
“He is your One,” he murmured. Ashamed, Thorin nodded. But Thráin’s expression held only understanding.
“I would give my life for him,” he said without hesitation. The King turned and started to walk towards his wife.
“I know what it is like to live without your One, the heartbreak of losing the other part of yourself,” he murmured. “And I am sorry, Inùdoy, my Naddan. I am sorry that I can never truly apologise for the wrong I allowed to happen. But maybe…this can atone…” And he threw himself at Bergilde, grabbing at the knife and holding it away from Bilbo’s throat a fraction. Thorin raced forward, grabbing for the Hobbit…and in the melee…all toppled over the edge and into the depths…
