Chapter Text
At first Bilbo didn’t know how to respond to Balin’s proposition. Of course he had been curious about Thorin and his life, since the dwarf was so private about his own feelings, but he was even more so curious about why no one was willing to talk about it either. But he wasn’t sure how to broach his questions or if he should have at all. It felt like a secret he wasn’t allowed to be part of.
Until now.
“Alright.” Bilbo blinked.
Balin didn’t skip a beat. “Thorin comes from the line of Durins. The Durins have always been a mining family, but the family business really started to pick up with Thrór, Thorin’s grandfather. He was the one who built the Erebor estate into what we know it as now. He established the estate where it was because it was right at the foot of the Lonely Mountain, a mountain that dwarves had not explored before. Long before we settled in the Lonely Mountain many of our kin mined in the mines of Moria, which you already saw. Over the years the dwarves migrated more to Erebor because it was the perfect opportunity and Thrór was rather lucky to strike it so rich with the business there. Dwalin, Óin, Glóin, and I are all descendants of the line of Durin so that’s how we know Thorin and got into this business. But many more dwarves flocked to Erebor when they saw how prosperous the business was, which only made it flourish even more.
“It was Thrór himself who found the Arkenstone in the heart of the Lonely Mountain. It’s a majestic jewel, the perfect representation of the success the Durins have seen in their endeavors.
“Life was normal for Thrór at that point, as it was for the subsequent generations. Thrór had a son, Thráin, and Thráin had three children, all of whom you already know. Thorin, Frerin, and Dís. Thorin’s mother died when he was young, but other than that it was a happy time for the family until Smaug came.
“Smaug was an infamous name in Middle-earth, but until this time he had only ever committed petty crimes. He gained his reputation because it was impossible for anyone to know where he would strike next. He’s always operated alone and that makes it easier for him to get around without anyone spotting him. The Arkenstone was a tempting target for Smaug because it also lay atop a large hoard of gold. Smaug somehow managed to get past the estate’s security system and into the house. Thrór and Thráin were not equipped to put up a fight against Smaug by the time any of them realized what was happening. Thorin made sure he got them out of the house. Thorin, barely of age himself at this point, took charge over his siblings. I wasn’t there, so I don’t know exactly what happened, but the three of them were separated from Thráin and Thrór.”
“And Thráin and Thrór,” Bilbo started. “What happened to them?”
“We don’t know what happened to them after they were separated from Thorin. By Thorin’s account, he never saw them again and we haven’t been able to find any bodies, so it’s like they just vanished. I suspect they had gotten into some sort of accident, for neither of them was in a sound state of mind as this was all unfolding and they were grieving the inevitable loss of their wealth, but we have no way of knowing that for sure because we have never found a wreckage of any sort. I don’t think they got very far, if I’m being honest. But it’s not like we can go looking around the estate for a wreckage, so we just don’t know for sure.
“The rest of us, the miners, were residing in Ered Luin on the other side of Middle-earth, far, far away from the destruction facing Erebor. It was fortunate for them that they could take refuge in Ered Luin with us, and we were of course happy to take them in for however long they needed to stay. But this was the opportune time of year for Smaug to strike against Erebor. It was the off-season for the miners, so most of us went back to our homes in Ered Luin. This meant that Erebor would be more vulnerable without so many dwarves to defend it. It was just the three generations of Durin. I still wonder why Smaug didn’t attack Thrór and Thráin that day. From Thorin’s account, they were delirious with the idea of losing everything they had worked for and they surely would have tried to put up a fight against Smaug. And Smaug is no pacifist either. He’s known to be violent.”
Balin paused, gathering his thoughts. Bilbo let him take his time. This was a lot to unload so he understood Balin would have to think hard through all of it.
“But what stuck with me the most, Bilbo, is that there was something rather kingly about the way Thorin handled the immediate urgency of the situation. He has always been a natural-born leader, but this confirmed that in my mind. He saved his siblings’ lives that day. After hearing of that experience I knew he is one I would follow, very much as if he were my king.”
Bilbo’s expression softened upon hearing the story. Hearing this perspective gave Bilbo some empathy for Thorin’s position.
“This is more than just ownership of the property to him,” Bilbo contemplated. “This is about his family.”
“Dís made sure Fíli and Kíli grew up hearing about how their uncle managed to pull through the danger of that situation and save his family as best as he could. Loyalty is everything to Thorin. He would do anything to protect the good of his family and even for the good of all the dwarves and their families under his grandfather’s employment. He thinks he has the best chance to take back Erebor and restore it to its former glory. He has been able to muster this company of dwarves to risk everything for this journey because of loyalty. We are all loyal to Thorin so he is loyal to us, too. He has done well by all of us so many of the dwarves think this is the best way to return the favor.”
“Why have they been so secretive about it, though?” Bilbo asked, trying not to think of what he was also keeping from them.
“It’s simple, really. Thorin doesn’t trust easily. Not after the way he watched his family lose everything so quickly. The others follow his suit out of respect, really. I don’t understand why they have to keep it so quiet from you—whether Thorin likes it or not, you’re as much a part of the Company as they all are—but Thorin isn’t quick to trust, so the Company isn’t quick to trust.
“You should get some sleep now. I’m going to need some sleep before Bofur will wake me up for the second watch.”
***
Bilbo awoke the following morning as Kíli stood over him, shaking him awake. It was still dark out, but the first glimpse of dawn broke across the horizon. This sunrise tinted the sky with a faint orange hue, paving the way for what was bound to be a clear day.
Most of the dwarves were already awake at this point. Fíli and Kíli appeared to have the task of rousing those were still asleep.
Bilbo rose to his feet. He didn’t sleep well, not with the weight of everything Balin told him gnawing away at him. Somehow the idea of sitting packed into the van all day only made him feel more exhausted. It would be no short drive the rest of the way down the Misty Mountains to the Gap of Rohan where they promised to meet Gandalf when they set off from Rivendell.
The drive of the previous day from Rivendell to Moria had been tolerable enough since they followed the road in a straight line down alongside the Misty Mountains. The road started to curve more as they moved farther south into the territory of Dunland. Bilbo caught a glimpse of the sign denoting the northern border into Dunland outside, but he didn’t know for sure how big it was because he never saw a sign saying they were ever leaving Dunland.
But they must have crossed the border out of the territory and towards the kingdom at Rohan at some point, for Thorin finally pulled the van off the main road and found a suitable spot to park.
“This should be where Gandalf said he’d meet us,” Dwalin said from the passenger’s seat, examining a map in his lap.
Everyone got out of the van and it didn’t take long for Bilbo to spot Gandalf. The gray wizard made his way toward the Company.
“I see you all made it in one piece,” Gandalf said. “That was the hard part of the drive. Driving north on this side of the mountains should be a lot easier.”
“We already had one flat tire on the way to Moria,” Thorin said.
“Well it’s a good thing the roads tend to be better-maintained on this side of the Misty Mountains, then, isn’t it?”
“I suppose it is,” Fíli said, cracking a smile.
“It is already past midday so you shouldn’t plan to go much farther today. The sun will set before you know it and you will want to rest up as we approach the last stretch of the journey. I will follow you and stop where you think it’s best to make camp for the night. But don’t go too far north.”
Thorin nodded. “I will need to fill the gas tank first and then we will set off again. You all can stretch your legs while I fill up the tank. It’s going to be a few minutes.” He pulled a tank of gas out of the trunk of the van and moved to fill the van with the gas.
Bilbo kept to himself during this break in the journey, grateful for the quiet moment of stasis. Gandalf was busy talking with the other dwarves.
After a few minutes, the trunk slammed shut and Thorin beckoned everyone back to the van. Once everyone was back in the van and the engine started to rumble again, the journey continued from there.
***
Thorin drove the van north for a few hours before he grew weary. Gandalf had been right that they would need to find a suitable spot to camp for the night. Thorin parked the van on the outskirts of the first forest they encountered along the road north.
“This is Fangorn Forest,” Gandalf told Bilbo while the dwarves unpacked the supplies they would need to set up camp. The two of them were off to the side while the others were the ones setting up everything. Knowing Thorin it would be easier for him if they stayed out of the way and let the dwarves handle the manual labor.
“You say that as though there is a problem with that,” Bilbo said. “Is there a problem?”
“Not necessarily. The problem would be if you tried to go into the depths of the forest. You won’t know for sure what you’d find in there. It is nothing that should be of concern to you so long as you all stay on the outskirts of the forest right here.”
Through the rest of the day and all the way through sundown, all was well with the Company. It was not until they had eaten dinner and stoked a fire that something felt wrong.
It started off as a stirring among the trees. It was loud enough from a distance to make Bifur and Bofur both jump.
“What was that?” Thorin hummed, rising. His body language made it clear that he was going to scope out the scene by himself, which filled Bilbo with a sense of dread. Something was wrong. This was not like the troll attack, something sudden that caught them by complete surprise in the dead of night.
Walking toward the trees, Thorin pulled Orcrist from his belt. Thorin’s intent to scope out this threat alone was clear and all the dwarves seemed to accept that. But Bilbo did not accept it in such stride.
A large figure jumped out from the shadowy cover of the trees. It was large and its howling reminded Bilbo of a wolf, but it did not look at all like a wolf.
“A warg!” Thorin yelled to the others. Bilbo had never heard of a warg, but he could tell it was a foe rather than friend. Seeing the visual of the threat itself only filled Bilbo with a greater sense of urgency to intervene. He had been chosen as the fourteenth member of this Company, so it was about time he live up to that role. It would be reckless to let Thorin take this warg on alone.
Without another thought, Bilbo pulled his own sword out of its scabbard and dashed forward, approaching the warg at as speed it was too slow to anticipate. Bilbo didn’t weigh the consequences of what he was doing, just that the Company and especially Thorin were in danger and he had to protect them as best as he could.
He swung his sword at the warg three times as he ran to startle the beast. Only the third blow was close enough to land on the warg’s body. Up close the warg was enormous, making Bilbo feel smaller than ever. But the blow hit the warg hard enough to stun it, surprised that it had been hit at all. Thorin took the distraction as an opportunity to slice at the warg. This attack was enough for the warg to relent. It backed back into Fangorn, accepting its defeat at the hands of this dwarf and hobbit.
Bilbo looked up at Thorin and saw his eyes shining with an intensity Bilbo had never seen before. They maintained this transfixed eye contact, barely registering the other dwarves and Gandalf clamoring over to make sure they were both okay.
“We’re not injured,” Bilbo reassured the others, breaking his eye contact with Thorin and snapping back into reality. He had just attacked the massive beast with his sword as his only defense.
Gandalf heaved a sigh. He was still looking at Bilbo as the dwarves crowded Thorin to verify Bilbo’s word. Thorin, however, was still staring at Bilbo.
“Why did you do that?” Thorin asked, out of breath. “Are you mad? You could have gotten yourself killed!” Bilbo noticed he didn’t speak with the air of hostility Bilbo had come to expect from him. He sounded like he was concerned.
“I’ve been thinking about it,” Bilbo started. “I’m the fourteenth member of this Company, so I feel it’s my duty to protect all of you. Look, Thorin, I know you doubt me and that you always have. But I know you have lost a lot in your life, and that’s why you’re on this quest. Meanwhile I have Bag End and yes, I do miss my books and my armchair dearly. That’s home to me. But you don’t have a home, so I want to help you take your home back if I can.”
Thorin paused. “When we first departed from the Shire, I expected you would give up and turn around at the first sign of any hardship. I thought you wouldn’t be up to the task and you wouldn’t care about seeing it to whatever end, no matter the price you would have to pay along the way. Never have I been so wrong.” Thorin moved away from the dwarves, toward Bilbo with open arms. He pulled Bilbo into a tight hug.
This caught Bilbo off guard. He hadn’t expected such a sharp change in Thorin’s demeanor, but he couldn’t deny this was a lot better than unfriendliness. He never realized the full extent of the height difference between him and Thorin until now. Here he was, his entire body enveloped in Thorin’s embrace. In a slow motion he wrapped his arms around Thorin to return the hug. Though the hug initially caught him off guard, he felt more reassured by the time Thorin pulled away.
Thorin looked over Bilbo’s body to make sure the hobbit had no visible injuries, even though he had been here to witness the skirmish up close and he could see that the warg never touched him or Bilbo.
“How did you manage to fight off the warg?” Thorin inquired. “I did not expect a hobbit of the Shire to wield a sword so well. It’s as if you’ve held a sword your whole life.”
Bilbo paused, holding his breath. He exhaled through his nose and then spoke, trying to keep his voice steady. “I have, actually. I’m an assassin.”
