Chapter Text
Everyone was dumbfounded by the abruptness of Gandalf’s departure. He gave no warning in advance that something came up and that he would have to leave. He just up and left.
It didn’t ease Bilbo’s nerves about going into the forest at all. He was already nervous enough, not knowing what to expect in the forest, but knowing he was going to be on his own with all the dwarves didn’t make him feel any more comfortable. At least with Gandalf they would have a wizard on their side.
That seemed to explain why he had been in such a rush for them all to leave Beorn’s cottage that morning, but even harboring this information, the whole situation didn’t sit right with Bilbo. What kind of “sudden emergency” warranted leaving them at this crucial moment in the quest? After all, he said that the trek through this forest would not be easy. His advice to stay on the path seemed straight-forward enough at face value, but knowing Gandalf, there was some layer of trickery hidden in such a simple instruction and Bilbo did not like the idea of getting lost in the expansive forest that lie ahead. Gandalf said if they got lost they would not be able to get out, but even if they could, how long would it take them to find any way out?
In that moment Bilbo thought it best to take the lead. Who else was going to take charge? Thorin was the de facto leader of the group, but he seemed focused on something else. But, not wanting to take away from Thorin’s focus, Bilbo followed his eyes and realized that Thorin was looking straight into the eyes of an elf who had just appeared out of the section of the forest to the right, from Thranduil’s property. He had long light hair and if his eyes were a fire they would be ablaze across everything in sight. This must be the Thranduil that Thorin so deeply detested.
“What are you doing here?” Thorin growled. “Shouldn’t you be in your mansion admiring your jewels, or whatever it is you do?” Then, in a much quieter voice, he mumbled something in Khuzdul. Bilbo didn’t understand what he said, but whatever it meant, it had to be harsh. Thorin wasn’t one to mince words.
“No, I cannot,” Thranduil said, “because your family has claimed ownership over the jewels my family so covets from the mines, so we do not have anything to admire. I’m here because I thought I heard footsteps on my property.”
“We aren’t on your property. Don’t you think I would remember where your property line ends, after you threatened to hunt my siblings down if we set foot on your property ever again?” He took a few steps forward and then stopped, pointing to the ground. “This is where your property ends. And, as you can see, I’m not on your property so you can’t do anything to me in the name of trespassing.”
Thranduil ignored him. His eyes moved past Thorin and scanned the rest of the Company. “You do not travel alone.”
“Impressive, he seems to be quite aware of his surroundings,” Bofur whispered behind Bilbo, quiet enough that only those around him could hear.
“Do you think you can take back the Lonely Mountain and your family’s estate from Smaug? Surely you realize that Smaug is too cunning to see through any plans to oust him. That’s how he has made it this far as a thief. That’s why nobody has been able to stop him.”
“That is none of your business,” Thorin said, raising his voice as his temper flared more.
“I suppose I should stand aside now, so I can let you go off to your inevitable doom down that path.” He turned away and disappeared back into the thick forest, leaving Thorin red in the face with fury.
He turned back to the Company and began to shout more in the language that Bilbo didn’t understand. Though he couldn’t decipher a word of it, he could tell whatever Thorin said including a lot of cursing and some unkind words towards Thranduil. After seeing Thranduil’s calm but rude demeanor, Bilbo couldn’t blame him for the resentment Thorin harbored against him.
“We need to keep moving,” Balin implored. “We won’t want to stay in the forest too long. We should try to get out to the other side before nightfall. That forest doesn’t look welcoming during the day, so it will only be worse during the night.”
Thorin grumbled, but went along with Balin’s suggestion. “We need to keep moving,” Thorin repeated the instructions in a louder voice so everyone could hear.
As he started to move forward everyone followed. They walked at the same steady pace until they made it to the edge of the forest. Then they stopped, hesitation creeping in. None of them knew what to expect and that fear started to hold them back a little bit. This was one part of Middle-earth none of them were familiar with.
This forest looks sick, Bilbo thought. Not exactly the most welcoming sight you want to first see.
Bilbo, thinking about how important this quest was to Thorin, decided to take the first brave step forward. This was not the time to let doubt creep in. They were so close to Erebor. All that was stopping them between this point and the estate was this forest and they were going to conquer it one way or another.
Thorin moved to join Bilbo in entering the forest. Out of the corner of his eye Bilbo thought he saw Thorin crack a small smile at him. Bilbo’s heart skipped a beat at that sight and he beamed as they entered the forest.
The forest was dark as night. If they hadn’t just woken up a couple hours earlier, Bilbo might have actually believed that it was nighttime already. When they walked in they were already on the path, much to Bilbo’s relief. He knew he wasn’t going to get Gandalf’s words of warning out of his head anytime soon. Stick to the path.
And stuck to the path they did. It was a long trek across this seemingly never-ending forest, along this faint path outlined in the dirt. It was a small line of cobblestones, wider than one person’s width, but not wide enough for two people to fit across. The exception was for Bombur, who was large enough that he took up most of the path’s width on his own. They stuck to the single-file line down the path, heeding Gandalf’s advice every step of the way.
Bilbo didn’t know exactly where they lost track of the path along the way, but they somehow managed to do it.
“Where’s the path?” Dwalin had asked as he looked over Thorin’s shoulder. Bilbo was a bit further back, and being a head shorter than Dwalin, knew he wasn’t going to be able to see it for himself, but he had no doubt they were lost.
“We need to keep going, and find the path,” Thorin said. He had been at the front of the line this entire time, and this entire time he kept a steady eye on the steps in front of them, making sure they were made of the same stony pattern and did not fade into the dirt. But not even that caution was enough to save them in the end, it turned out.
“We need to accept it,” Dori said after what felt like at least several minutes of circling. “We lost the path. We’re lost.”
“We can’t be lost!” Fíli cried out.
“Don’t you get it?” Bilbo grumbled, looking around at the others to gauge how everyone else felt about the situation. “We’re going around in circles.”
“Fíli’s right,” Thorin echoed. “If we’re lost then we aren’t going to be able to get out, are we?”
“You remember what Gandalf said,” Bofur answered. “If we lose the path, then we’re going to be lost in the forest and there won’t be any way for us to get out.”
“We should try splitting up,” Kíli suggested, “and surely at least one of us will be able to find the path again. We can holler when one of us finds the path.”
Thorin seemed desperate enough for any suggestion that he was willing to go along with Kíli’s proposition. Bilbo, on the other hand, thought it was completely absurd. Even if someone could find the path again, how would they be able to guarantee they wouldn’t lose each other along the way? But it wasn’t his decision to make, and Thorin had the final say. Though his tone made clear his begrudging attitude towards the proposition, Thorin declared they would split up.
They divided into two groups. Thorin, Bilbo, Bofur, Fíli, Bombur, Dwalin, and Glóin continued moving in the same direction they were already going in. Meanwhile, Kíli, Bifur, Ori, Nori, Dori, Balin, and Óin went in the opposite direction.
For as far as Bilbo could see, there was nothing different laying ahead in their path. It was more and more of the same trees, the same rocks, and the same landscape. It looked as though the forest was never-ending in their direction. Bilbo assumed that it would be more of the same in the opposite direction. He remembered looking at the forest from the outside; it was expansive in all directions and who knew how they would be able to find a way out without being able to find the path again.
This went on for several minutes before Dwalin threw his hands into the air out of frustration.
“We really are lost!” He moaned.
“We need to keep moving,” Thorin hissed.
“You have to admit, though, this isn’t a good idea,” Dwalin said. “We’d be best if we stuck together.”
But they had no choice but to keep moving, so that was what they did. After several minutes they somehow managed to travel in a circle, for they bumped into the other half of their company.
“How did we end up here?” Fíli asked. “You all went the other way!”
“We’re lost, and we’ve been lost for quite some time,” Balin said, “and there’s certainly no denying it now.”
“What are we going to do now?” Kíli asked. On instinct, everyone turned to Thorin.
“Why don’t we try to figure out where we are first?” Balin said.
“How exactly are we going to do that?” Thorin retorted. “Do you think we’re going to launch our burglar into the sky, up past the trees to see what direction we’re going in?”
That was exactly what they ended up doing.
It wasn’t by Bilbo’s choice. He wasn’t fond of heights and he especially wasn’t fond of the idea of climbing up these tall trees to see over the top of them.
But it wasn’t like they were going to give Bilbo a say in the matter, because what other choice did they have?
Once Bilbo climbed to the top and stuck his head out from the leaves, his first instinct was to take in a deep breath of the fresh air. At this height it was crisp and refreshing, so much more comforting than the stuffier air in the confines of the forest. He looked beyond the tops of the trees to figure out how far away from the other side they were. To his surprise, it was not as far away as he thought it would be. He glanced behind him; they had made a decent amount of progress from the other side. If he had to hazard a guess, he would have assumed that they were at about the halfway point.
“I can see the mountain!” He yelled. “We’re almost there!”
Bilbo enjoyed one serene, but brief moment at the top of these trees, admiring the skyline, before the world came tumbling down and Bilbo was falling back down to the ground below. He landed on top of a pile of leaves. It was a softer landing than landing directly on the ground would have been, but partially-crunched leaves dug into his skin through his clothes and that feeling was bugging him.
Reorienting himself, he stood back up and saw the dwarves all around trying to figure out where they were based on Bilbo’s account. Bilbo was impressed that they were able to hear him yelling from all the way above the trees. He was a far way up and he didn’t know if his voice would travel down.
“We need to keep moving,” Thorin said once he saw Bilbo back on the ground with them, and so they continued to move forward as a group.
Then Bilbo swore he heard a rustling sound coming from the trees nearby, making him jump. They had not encountered any wildlife up until this point, so he raised his guard. No one else seemed to notice, but something did not feel right and Bilbo was apprehensive.
The noise seemed to subside after they took a few more steps. If Bilbo were one to let his guard down, he would have thought he imagined the noise. But he didn’t let his guard down and he spotted something stir in his line of vision. It was hard to make out from the distance, but the spot multiplied and moved closer and Bilbo got a good, clear look of what it was: a bunch of spiders closing in.
A bunch of spiders is just what we needed, Bilbo thought dryly as he wondered how they were going to get out of this.
But he didn’t think of a solution fast enough, for the spiders moved in and the world went black.
***
When Bilbo opened his eyes, he realized that he was far above the ground. The spiders had woven everyone into their own individual cocoons, Bilbo included. He didn’t have to think about what would come next.
Bilbo could not move his limbs under the restrictions of the web, but he still retained his ability to see, even through the web that covered his face. He remained still for a moment to observe the spiders moving around the web, but when they turned away from him he began to fidget. He realized that he could move around a little bit in the web. It was only just for a little bit, but he was determined to use this newfound knowledge to his advantage to get them all out of this situation. He inched his hand towards the scabbard on his waist. In capturing everyone it seemed that the spiders did not think to remove their weaponry. A certain weakness that would come back to pay the price.
Bilbo slipped the sword out of the scabbard. He moved only in careful motions as he sliced his way out of the web, making sure he wouldn’t alert the spiders to the fact that he managed to escape. As he cut himself free, he assessed the situation. The rest of the Company were spread out across the web, so there was no way Bilbo was going to be able to cut all thirteen of them free without making enough noise from jerky motions—after all the web wasn’t easy to move in, and he wasn’t as familiar with it as the spiders, putting him at a distinct disadvantage—that would alert the spiders to the fact that he cut himself loose from the web they wrapped him in. The only way out of this would be cutting away at the web that held them all up among the trees. He looked down. It was a long way to the ground, but it was a risk he would have to take if any of them would be able to get out of the situation.
He rolled onto his side slowly. Time was of the essence, but it was not his top priority. Making sure he wouldn’t be heard by the other spiders was a more urgent matter. With his right arm extended, he began to slice away t the web around him. As long as he covered as much surface area as he could in his immediate range, he would be able to destabilize the very foundation of the web.
His careful calculations worked. After a few seconds of dicing and slicing the web, it eventually fell apart and succumbed to gravity, bringing down all of the thirteen cocoons and the spiders with it. Bilbo was lucky that the ground below turned out to be a softer landing than he had expected.
Then the spiders began to attack Bilbo, but he was ready with his sword still in hand. He plunged the sword into the first one lunging itself at him.
“It stings!” The spider screamed. “It stings!” It fell into a crumpled pile on the ground. Bilbo waited until he was sure the spider was dead before pulling his sword out.
That was enough to scare the other spider off in the other direction, not wanting to suffer the same fate. Bilbo did not let his guard down for at least five seconds, just in case it turned back around or another set of spiders showed up. Once he thought the coast was clear, he let out a sigh.
“Sting,” he muttered to himself, recalling how Balin told him about the naming of swords. “That’s quite a nice name. Yeah, Sting it is.” With a moment of assured safety, he looked over the sword, admiring the craftsmanship that went into its making. Then his mind turned to Thorin, and how Thorin also possessed a sword of Elvish make found in the troll caves, another thing they had in common.
Lowering the sword, he stood still to brush the leaves off his shoulders as he contemplated what was next. He didn’t put the sword back in its scabbard. He wasn’t going to let his guard down until they were out of the forest. He didn’t know how they were going to be able to get out, but that was the next worry he would focus on after they dealt with the spiders.
Apparently the fall from the high-up web had been enough to restore consciousness to the dwarves. Bilbo watched as they all began to struggle their way out of their webbed traps. He was relieved to see all of them recuperating with no apparent injuries from the web besides the initial drowsiness of being back on their feet. Most of all he was relieved to see Thorin get back up and wipe away the last of the web stuck to his sleeves. Thorin was tough so no doubt he would survive this, but Bilbo still felt reassured in the comfort of knowing the dwarf’s safety.
“What just happened?” Ori asked, looking around at the others for guidance.
Nobody had the chance to answer his question, though, for this moment of recovery was short-lived. The rustling sound from earlier came back, but this time Bilbo knew what it was. More spiders were coming.
“Run!” Bilbo commanded to the others.
They ran and the sound of scuttling legs trailed behind them. It sounded like the spiders were moving slowly, for the sound of movement sounded faint, though consistent. Bilbo thought maybe they would have a chance of getting away. He didn’t know how they would be able to, not without the path in their line of sight, but there had to be a way somehow.
They ran and ran, not thinking about where they were going. In this moment, their immediate survival mattered more. They kept running until they heard Kíli’s scream.
Bilbo stopped in his tracks and spun around on his heel, his hands tightening his grip on Sting. He held the sword up and scanned the vicinity to comprehend what was going on before he jumped into the action.
One of the spiders must have jabbed at Kíli, for he now lay on his side on the ground, clutching his right leg. The rest of the Company had the same idea as Bilbo to draw their swords, for now the remaining twelve had launched themselves at the spiders, engaging in such a strong attack that they were successfully turning the spiders away.
With the spiders taken care of, Bilbo ran to Kíli’s side, Sting still secure in his hand.
“What’s the matter?” Bilbo asked him, scanning his body for any external injuries. “What happened?”
“One of the spiders nearly stabbed me through the side. I managed to just get away because I kept running, but I ended up tripping and landing on my ankle.” Bilbo then noticed that Kíli was sitting on top of an enormous root sticking out of the ground. It stuck out high enough that Bilbo could imagine it would be easy to trip over, especially considering Kíli had been running for his life, not caring too much about such little details like a root sticking out of the ground. The fall would have been enough to sprain his ankle.
Bilbo looked up and saw Fíli running to his brother’s side.
“What happened?” He yelled, his tone a bit frantic, in a protective, brotherly sort of way.
“I’m pretty sure he sprained his ankle,” Bilbo said, trying to keep his tone level.
“We have to get him out of the forest. How are we going to get out?”
“I think I know how,” Thorin said as he crept up behind his nephew. He pointed to a spot behind Bilbo. Bilbo turned and realized that it was a bit of the path peeking out from underneath the leaves. How was it possible? Was it merely a hallucination? But how could it be a figment of his imagination if Thorin saw it too?
“Come on, then,” Bilbo said. He moved to join Fíli at Kíli’s side. The two of them helped Kíli to his feet and, with one man on either side of him, they began to walk with him to the path. Bilbo looked over his shoulder and saw the rest of the Company following behind them. Thorin must have noticed the path earlier and pointed it out to the others already.
Sure enough, by some stroke of luck, they managed to find the actual path again. The path was not wide enough for Bilbo, Fíli and Kíli to all walk alongside each other, but they had no choice. They all walked in a line together, with Fíli and Bilbo staying off the path; Kíli needed the level ground the path provided the most out of the three of them. Somehow they were able to keep track of where they were, even without walking directly along the path. It was no doubt because they were holding onto Kíli, who made sure to stay on the path. Bilbo wasn’t sure what kind of magic made it so this would happen, but he was grateful for it. They had already been through enough.
The path stretched on for several minutes longer and then finally a glimpse of the outside sky crept in between the branches of the trees, lighting the last stretch of the path to the end of the forest.
When they reached the end of the path, Bilbo heaved a sigh of relief, grateful to once again be in the outside world, with the sun shining on his face. It was nearing sundown now, but the sun stood a little ways above the horizon. Who knew how much daytime light would be left, but it was certain to not be a lot more. They had a few hours left until it got dark if they were lucky.
“We need to find somewhere to settle for the night,” Thorin commanded to the others. “We can’t cover much ground right now with Kíli injured. We need a night’s rest, and then we’ll keep moving in the morning.”
No one protested Thorin’s commands. They continued walking, walking in no particular direction. They weren’t going to move towards Erebor. They wouldn’t be ready to defend themselves against Smaug with one of their own injured. No, they had to find a safer spot, sticking to the outskirts.
After a little ways, they stopped. They were all exhausted from the walking and subsequent fighting in the forest. Thorin figured it fair enough for them to take a short break to rest and regain their breath and strength.
“But we can only stop for a few minutes,” Thorin said, “and once we get moving again we aren’t going to stop until we find somewhere to set up camp, alright?”
Bilbo and Fíli found a soft spot in the ground to set Kíli down.
“Thanks,” Kíli managed.
“How does it feel?” Fíli asked.
Kíli opened his mouth right as Thorin approached the three of them.
“I’d like to speak to our burglar alone for a moment,” Thorin said.
Heart beginning to race, Bilbo stood up and Thorin led him a ways away from his nephews. Bilbo heard Kíli begin to speak, though they were far enough away that he didn’t understand a word Kíli was saying to his brother.
“I wanted to say thank you,” Thorin said, his eyes shining as he looked down at Bilbo. He wasn’t smiling, but his expression beamed in the way Bilbo had only seen after Bilbo saved him the last time. “I don’t know what you did to get rid of those spiders, but whatever you did saved our lives. And you helped Kíli get this far.”
The corners of Bilbo’s lips turned up. “It’s the least I could do for you after you’ve let me stay on this quest for this long. It’s felt like you’ve had many an opportunity to be rid of me, I who is little more than just an assassin to you at the end of the day, and yet you let me stay because you know I support your cause. It has been an honor to be on this quest with all of you.”
This brought a smile to Thorin. This was one of the few times Bilbo had seen him smile. It sent his heart doing backflips. Thorin had such a beautiful smile and the fact that he only saved it for the most special of occasions made Bilbo feel all the more important.
“You really are an assassin, though.” It wasn’t a question, but Thorin must have still been grappling with the new information from the other day.
“Yeah. That’s why I was prepared to fight off that warg while you were unarmed. I also fought the spiders to get us out of there just now. I’ve been trained to get out of sticky situations quick. Just because I haven’t been so forthcoming with it doesn’t mean the skill hasn’t always been there. And I will use those skills to continue to protect you all as best as I can.”
“I guess there’s always been more to you than meets the eye.” He put one hand on Bilbo’s shoulder.
Bilbo tried not to gulp, even though he desperately wanted to swallow the lump growing in the back of his throat.
They maintained eye contact for a second and then they both broke it at the same time to look back over at Fíli and Kíli. A chill hit Bilbo’s shoulder as he felt Thorin slide his hand off.
“I ought to go make sure those two don’t cause anymore trouble,” Bilbo said, and the two men laughed.
“We need to keep going,” Thorin said. “Make sure they’re ready to go.”
The two parted and upon returning to the soft spot in the ground, Bilbo repeated Thorin’s instructions. A few feet away Thorin was corralling everyone else.
Bilbo knelt down to help Kíli get to his feet and then, slow step by step, the three of them returned to rejoin the rest of the Company.
From there they kept moving forward and they didn’t stop until they saw a parked van appear out of nowhere. It was parked alongside a river—since when was there a river out in this part of the country? Thorin had never mentioned there being a river out here, nor had they heard the sound of running water as they walked this way. It was a black van, nothing like the white van they left at Beorn’s house, but it looked like it was larger than their van, hopefully giving for enough room for all fourteen of them to share with a little personal space to add.
“I don’t think we should go there,” Balin said. “I don’t have a good feeling about this.”
“What other choice do we have?” Thorin questioned. “I’d hear you out if you had another proposition, but there is nothing else in sight and we need to try this, seeing as it’s our only option.”
They made their way towards the van. Bilbo wasn’t sure if they were merely checking it out to see if they could sleep there for the night or if Thorin actually meant to steal it. Whatever his intentions were, Bilbo shared Balin’s sentiment. Along every step of the way Bilbo felt uneasy about straying too far out of his comfort zone. Of course, attacking spiders wasn’t one of those things, but he drew the line at stealing a random van parked outside of the forest.
Everything felt like it was going to work out until they got closer to the van. Thorin peered into the window closest to them to see if there was anyone inside. It appeared that the van was empty, but they all jumped when a man came out from the other side of the van.
“What are you doing?” The man asked. “Thieves, I see?”
“No, and who are you?” Thorin grumbled.
“This is my van. I’m Bard of Lake-town. You’re from Erebor, aren’t you?”
