Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of The Oialëa Series
Collections:
xbxmbxmx fin
Stats:
Published:
2021-02-07
Completed:
2021-06-05
Words:
138,741
Chapters:
14/14
Kudos:
480
Hits:
0

The Rules of The Multiverse

Chapter 10: A Trip Down Memory Lane

Summary:

In which Illyria experiences her past with the jewel that not only caused the pain of her life but brought her new family closer.

As well as this, Elrond chooses to confess to Illyria the truth of who she really was to him.

Warning: will contain violence, hints of torture and mention of death.

Notes:

Hello and welcome back. I just moved back into uni so it's been a bit hectic the entire weekend trying to sort out stuff. Thank you so much again for the kudos and for just genuinely following this story. I would like also say that I only got to keep 69 kudos for 10 minutes which was what I'm really annoyed about smh.

Also, this chapter was rather fiddly to write because of the conversation between Elrond and Illyria, I had to re-write that so many times to get an equal balance of emotion and the humour Illyria has. This is what I got at the end so. :/

Also, I decided to do a quick sketch (no really, this was like an hour to do, it took longer to try and upload this lmao) which you'll get to see at the end of the chapter. Ngl would have to say it's pretty cute. ;)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Elemmírë | Lady of Gondolin

Location: Mouths of Sirion, South Beleriand, Middle Earth [1]

Time: 538 F.A

Fire.

That is all that Elemmírë of Gondolin could see.

Everything was burning, people were burning. Red, black, and gold with the sprinkle of grey as the ash fell and made the waters that were once blue into a murky black. Red was for the blazing flames that danced around them, that touched the skins of those screaming for their lives. Red was the colour of their clothes, for it shone an eight-pointed star as they drew their silver swords into her people’s hearts. Red was the blood that spilt over the ground, staining her hands and clothes – a deep red that could almost match the colour black had the moonlight did not shine above the sky.

Elemmírë rushed down the streets, her duel blades slicing and piercing any that were against her. She tried her best to conserve her power, her light, as she dodged fallen rubble before heading towards the inner city. She knew where they were; knew what they sought here. She bared her teeth and continued, her heart racing as she heard pleas for help. Elemmírë wanted to help them, to stop those that caused them harm.

But the sole reason had been just that. And that was what her friend bared in her possession.

As she arrived towards the larger house situation upon the upper levels of the city, she barged through the doors of once her friend’s home and saw them. The elven princess clutching her two children in her arms. As they realised who had entered, they sighed in relief as the mother approached her and stared at her eyes.

The eyes of pardon.

“What are you doing?” Elemmírë questioned, striding towards her as the elven princess rummaged through the wardrobe before pulling out an ornate box. As she opened the box, she gasped under her breath.

The Silmaril.

Elwing looked up at her, tears sprung in her eyes as she pleaded, “Protect my children, Elemmírë.” She whispered. “Please, for me.”

Elemmírë shook her head and back away. “Then give me the jewel.” She insisted with a murmur, “I have nothing to lose here, Elwing. Not after I just lost my brother.”

There was a moment that they both shared a willing sense of understanding. Both knew their past despite never choosing to speak openly of them. But word and stories can travel in the wind so easily, and Elemmírë and Elwing knew they have lost both their home and families because of the world beyond their control.

And now, it would seem her friend thought she had the chance to play a step in this complicated game.

Elwing gave her a sad smile, squeezing her eyes from tears as she glanced over at her children. “I’m sorry, friend.” She spoke, “But I must do this, it is my duty.”

In a swift moment, Elwing pulled her cloak over her head and took the jewel in her hand. She gave one last look at her children, whispering something in the air before escaping out the door.

“No!”

Elemmírë tried to catch her, but the elven princess was already out amongst the flames. She already knew her friend would never step foot in this place ever again.


Elemmírë glared at the two figures in front of her as she declared, “If you take the children, you’ll have to take me.”

She shielded the two twin elflings behind her body, her swords laid waste far from her reach. She could blind them, or create headaches, but Elemmírë knew it would potentially harm the children if she was not careful.

Instead, she gave into the ones before her. The red-haired one, tall and broad, scowled at her before yanking her from the children whilst the shorter, dark-haired one took each of the children’s hands and bind them together. She could still hear the roaring of the waterfall behind them as the two carried them away, perhaps out of the burning city and towards their host.

They took them in a cart, quietly murmuring to themselves as she kept the twins close to her. Elemmírë would not risk those two alone with Elwing’s children.

A voice asked her quietly, “Elemmírë? Where are we going?”

To her acknowledgement, she turned to find the Peredhel twins stare at her with wide shallowed eyes. She blamed her heart for breaking then, to see such minds that have already been filled with horror and loss. Elemmírë could lie and give them hope, but she was not like that. She may be young for an elf, but she had lived her entire adulthood through war and wandering. And honesty was the only way to seek them a careful transition to the realities of war.

Elemmírë answered him, “We have no choice but to go with the Fëanorians, Elrond.” She saw him begin to tear up. He was thinking of Elwing, wondering where she was. As for Elros, the stronger one in mind only thought of his brother and the elves that sat in front of them.

Elros curled up next to her side. It was uncomfortable, especially with the binds in her wrists, but she managed to allow the two lean against her side. “I miss Naneth, Elemmírë,” Elros spoke.

Not long before the whimpering and cries echoed through the trees. Elemmírë did her best to sing a song to them, but it had yet only reminded them of the songs which their mother sang at night.

The red-haired elf flicked his head to her from the horse and commanded, “Can you quieten the children?”

Elemmírë looked blankly back at him and answered coolly, “You try it yourself, Fëanorian.”


Location: Taur-im-Duinath, East Beleriand, Middle Earth [2]

Time: 538 F.A

They have been with them for almost two weeks. Travelling East towards Taur-im-Duinath. Those that she knew who survived the sacking of the Havens, she wasn’t sure where they fled – indicating them to hide further down the river from the kinslayers. Elemmírë only hoped that Círdan had heard the word of what occurred and would aid her people.

Elemmírë wanted to help her people, so she did all she could to escape the Fëanorians.

Her first attempt was almost successful, had not the red-haired Fëanorian threatened to kill little Elros with a dagger upon his small throat. She almost shared her secret in anger, sensing the energy coarse through her body until she dropped the stolen dagger and silently allowed them to tie her again.

The second attempt was a week later, and she had thought to blind the younger Fëanorian brother, Maglor. Though as she was about to do so, Elrond had found her sneaking out. The little elfling somehow knew what she was about to do and pleaded to her not to kill or expose herself. She had wavered then, feeling reason with the Peredhel twin that she felt guilt growing up her heart.

These boys have lost their innocence, and she was not doing any less to keep their childhood intact.

And so, she agreed with Elrond and felt herself become sombre and isolating. She did what she had promised to Elwing, keeping an eye on the twins, and making sure they were fed enough and sleeping soundly as possible. Elrond had begun to manifest his own sight, always waking up and murmuring about dragons and fires whilst Elros was getting bolder by the moment, questioning the younger Fëanorian that caused the red-haired one angry and the other sadder.

Today, Elemmírë knew from her eavesdropping in the Fëanorians’ minds that food was becoming scarce. Many animals have fled South or East and the forest was not enough to supply the leftovers of the followers of the Fëanorians.

Rationing was worrying her, and all she could do was make sure each of the twins was fed decently – even if her hands were tied. She urged her share to the twins, who shook their heads and told her to eat. Elemmírë smiled softly to them and told them telepathically that she was alright and they shall have what she had left.

When the twins hungrily finished hers, she hid the rumbling of her stomach – finding a shadow over loom her. Dropping down into her hand was a bowl of broth. When she stared upwards, she found the red-haired Fëanorian scowl at her.

He ordered, “Eat.”

“No,” Elemmírë answered.

She could sense his irritation, swearing to the Valar internally before repeating. “You need to eat; you are thinner than the other elleths.”

“I will rather starve,” She spoke with a monotonous voice. The two shared a look, with herself trying not to hear his growing anger whilst her own heart began to go cold.

The red-haired Fëanorian asked plainly, “And what of the children. What will they say when their guardian will fade.”

Elemmírë replied simply, “I am not their guardian.” She was not wrong, she had lost that title after leaving her people behind in Sirion. She was not a guardian anymore.

The red-haired Fëanorian grunted before saying back, “No, but they are what is left of their kin.”

“Who was the cause that?” She questioned, and immediately regretted speaking aloud her thought as the red-haired Fëanorian scowled and strode away.


Time: 539 T.A

A pack of orcs were waiting for them near the boundaries of the forest. Jumping out from the bushes and trees as one hurled themselves at one of their followers and tackled them to the ground. Maedhros was the first one to react, as quick as an eagle swooping to its prey as the orc fell.

That then caused more orcs to scream in, and she quickly took the boys over to Maglor as she unsheathed her duel blades.

“Go!” Elemmírë cried out, sheathing her blades into her hilts and began placing her feet into a position.

Maedhros, son of Fëanor, sliced another Orc down as he staggered back as almost all of them were surrounded. “You are mad!” He yelled out to her.

Perhaps the red-haired Fëanorian was right. Maybe she was mad.

But she would not let them die today.

Elemmírë shouted, “No, but they will die if you do not leave with them!” Hinting about the twins and the injured, Maedhros bared his jaw and began retreating with the rest. Maglor had taken Elros and Elrond as far as possible, as she sensed their presence still in her mind.

And with a short breath, Elemmírë held her hands out and brought a concentrated light upon them, growing larger before she sent it towards the orcs. As the light met them, dozens of bodies flew into the air, the ground beneath them shattering with bits of earth. She stomped her foot into the ground, digging her heel before slicing her arms outwards as a large wave of light expelled from her body and sent more falling before.

Those who were hidden from their ranks in front charged at her and she took a sword out and parried the orc’s blow before blasting them back at another.

There and then, Elemmírë slew the remaining. And the area around them would bring interest as wave after wave of energy followed through.

The Sons of Fëanor and the Peredhel twins would seek her out, panting and exhausted and not an ounce of a bruise or cut from her skin. There Elemmírë stood in a ring of dead orcs laid on her waste.


When the evening arrived, she exited her tent to find all the Followers of the Fëanorians staring at her along with both the Sons of Fëanor. She had finally got Elrond and Elros asleep, aided by Maglor who sung so hauntingly beautiful that even she would fall asleep beside them as well.

Elemmírë lowered her head down, quietly meandering across the camp until she sat as far as possible from the fire, keeping herself hidden by braiding her blonde hair back. Once she was done, she found herself facing the younger son of Fëanor who wore his question on his face.

Finishing tying the ends of her hair, Elemmírë took a deep breath. “You must have questions.” When her eyes fluttered back to him, she found as well Maedhros who stood beside his brother, his taller stature blocking the light of the fire.

Maglor began, “You wield…light.”

Almost a year of hiding within the forest, moving every several days with the Fëanorians and yet it had been now that she was able to have a proper conversation with the two without her lashing at them, Maedhros lashing at her and Maglor almost bursting into tears at them shouting.

She could ignore them and tell them that is was not their right to know of her magical abilities, despite not knowing their origins themselves. She once remembered the elder Noldorin elves hypnotised that light she wielded was possibly equivalent to the light of stars, though they underestimated the young Lady of her brother’s house and would not know her extent until it was too late for them.

However, there was a part in her heart that urged her lips to agree. Both the sons of Fëanor have approached her warily and yet with an of something else.

Respect…or was it fear?

Elemmírë was not sure, but in the end, she had begun the story of her magic. “The story of my power is not as complicated as you think, because even I do not know how or why I received them.”


Elros and Elrond were down by the waters, splashing about and fighting one another as Maedhros and Maglor kept them from possibly going to the deep part of the River Gelion.

She sat on the rocks, keeping an eye on the twins. But it would seem they already had two other elves to sort them out. In her mind, she was feeling warmth in her heart as she suddenly found herself enjoying the comfort each person had. Over a year, the twins and she had begun to lose the discomfort and distrust for the Fëanorians. And it was obvious to the younger son of Fëanor, who looked at the twins like they were his own.

Maglor took a seat beside her several minutes later, soaked up to his calves but never losing the remnants of a smile.

It was then Elemmírë spoke, still eyeing the trio in the riverside. “You are good with them.”

The Fëanorian froze and his voice lowered, “I am guilty. I…”

“Well, one thing to consider: you are a good father,” Elemmírë revealed, true and confident with her words. She turned her head to her right and smiled sadly. “I cannot be their parent, no matter what Elros says.” She remembered the day she heard the Peredhel twin tell her that, and Elemmírë almost froze and fell off her horse. There was no parental love between her and the twins, almost as if she were like more of an older sister to them.

Maglor was alarmed as he asked, “Why do you suddenly not hate us?”

Her eyes stared into his as Elemmírë answered honestly: “Because I see now in your mind that you are hurting.” She continued wryly, “And I tend to protect everyone and anyone. No matter how bloody broken or perfect or crazy they are.”

“You are unlike any lady I have met,” Maglor spoke whilst the corner of lips twitched.

Elemmírë turned away, focusing back on the two boys already pulling Maedhros into the water. How a murderer like them could act so freely when they were technically hostages. But if she would call them murderers, Elemmírë would technically be one after slaying their followers.

She began to realise this ever since her third time in escaping the Fëanorians.

In the end, what did it truly mean when in fact it was all violence in the end? Even their daggers and swords were beautiful until they’re drenched in blood at the hands of their enemies. Their world sought peace, and peace seemed to be driven by fighting. What did it say for them all when the reality was just a big ironic idea?

She straightened herself up and began, “They say I am mad, but that is because elves are so insisted to achieve perfection, forgetting how much the world is unlike that.” Elemmírë professed. “I believe that people can change, no matter Edain or Eldar or Dwarf. And you and your brother; I have seen evidence that even the ones in the darkest pits can survive their demons.”

She knew those demons as she already her own; memories of the fall of her city, the wanderings to Sirion and the sacking. Her hatred of Maeglin to Morgoth and the Balrog who took her brother’s life.

But her’s cannot match the path that Maglor and Maedhros walked upon. A dark and winding path that would never end until their desire for the jewels was complete. However, Elemmírë believed in the changes of their paths, and the first step had been all this time – sparing the sons of Eärendil.

Maglor’s face changed into a haunting look. “I cannot destroy them. They will always be with me.”

There was a moment that she paused. She knew those demons as she already her own; memories of the fall of her city, the wanderings to Sirion and the sacking. Her hatred of Maeglin and Morgoth and the Balrog who took her brother’s life.

But her’s cannot match the path that Maglor and Maedhros walked upon. A dark and winding path that would never end until their desire for the jewels was complete. However, Elemmírë believed in the changes of their paths, and the first step had been all this time – sparing the sons of Eärendil.

It was there Elemmírë spoke her heart.

Her hand went over to his in his knees, and he gazed down before at her face.

“We never lose our demons, Maglor.” Elemmírë told him, “We only learn to live above them.”


Location: Ossiriand, East Beleriand, Middle Earth [3]

Time: 557 T.A

Two figures circled one another.

The first one was an elven lady, or perhaps an elven woman for she had lost that title for many years. In her hand, she carried a silver curved blade – gripped into a position for preparedness as she positioned her feet into a defensive stance.

The other was an elven lord, neither a lord nor anything gentle as a determined look was plastered on his face. He held a similar blade, though longer and less slim. He too was pictured in a stance, though his feet seemed to jump to and throw, eager to leap into the action.

When they both counted to three, the ellon charged towards the elleth. The elleth easily blocked it, swiping her sword back to her body before deflecting another swipe. They moved around the open space of the forest, with the elleth keeping the ellon on his toes.

There was a significant difference between the two. Whilst the ellon attacked at every moment, with growls and grand strikes, the elleth was calm and calculating every movement – almost gracefully dancing around her opponent.

Once she spotted the opening, she ducked underneath and tugged the ellon’s arm under before swiping their feet.

The next thing the ellon knew, the tip of the sword was against his neck. Both were out of breath as they looked at each other.

“I yield!” Elros wheezed, groaning as he was pulled up by her arm. “…Mire, how can you be so swift?”

Elemmírë let go of his hand and winked, “Many years of practice, Elros.” She turned her head around, asking the figure behind her. “Care to join, Elrond.”

The one and only spectator in the forest glade, who had been waiting patiently, stood up to pick up his own sword from his hilt. Elemmírë smiled encouragingly to the other Peredhel twin; she knew that he preferred the library and his learning in comparison to his brother’s practical activities – which she could understand. Not everything was about sparring and fighting and wouldn’t be something she would choose as a pastime.

Not when they were in a time of war. Where fighting was surviving. Elemmírë hated having to expose the twins to violence and self-defence, but she and the Fëanorians knew it was better to show them as early as possible.

And now they were twenty-five-years-old and probably growing to become skilled swordsmen under the tutoring of Maedhros, Maglor and her. Though she knew eventually in another decade or more, even the twins would surpass her own skill.

As Elros walked over to his brother, whispering something in his ear, Elrond gave his brother a look before taking a small breath and returned his eyes to her. “If you wish of me, Elemmírë.”

With a nod, the two began their own dance.


She spoke, “You know at first, I was afraid of you.” The corner of Elemmírë’s lips lifted. “And look at what has become of us.”

They were standing on the platform atop the trees, the moon out so brightly under the canopy that it illuminated their faces. Down below, they watched the Laiquendi elves [4] along with the rest of the Fëanorians. It had been almost two decades since they have been here, seeking refuge with the Green elves in East Beleriand and things were just beginning to stabilise with the Fëanorians and her.

Though whilst she believed it to have been going for the better, the elf beside her believed the latter.

“You are still afraid of me, Elemmírë.” He pointed out, his face returning to his usual expressionless tone.

She wanted to sigh in frustration. Well, yes: perhaps she was still a little fearful for the eldest son of Fëanor, but it was not because of the reasons he believed in.

“No, Maedhros. I’m afraid for you.” Elemmírë corrected, “With Maglor, I believe that the twins can save him…”

Her voice trailed off, trying to figure out the right words before she continued.

Elemmírë spoke, “But you, you’re afraid to be saved. You’re afraid of what lies beyond the demons you possess.”

It was there she remembered the very conversation she had with Maglor, who had shared his own burdens and fears with her with minimal effort. Maglor showed his own burdens truthfully, with sorrow that began to heal with the care and love the twins had for him.

But for Maedhros, his own troubles and fears ran deeper than his younger brother’s. Even after two decades, her own stubbornness to make him open up whilst his own arrogance to push her away only got her to the surface of who he was.

Elemmírë was not sure why she had been trying at all until she realised eventually how much they were beginning to be a part of her.

He clenched his fists, his face anguish as he murmured, “You don’t know what I’ve done. How much blood I spilt.” Maedhros told her, “This Oath will drive me to my death. Look at what happened to my brothers. Maglor is all I have left.” [5]

Looking right up to him despite Maedhros looking away, she whispered, “Not anymore. You have Elrond, Elros and me.”

He shook his head. “You shouldn’t. You were supposed to be hostages.”

Elemmírë could instantly feel his mind going inwards once more, trying to fall into that pit of despair he usually went to when he was thinking too much. Over time, she had realised he had begun doing it less, keeping himself occupied with either the twins or stopping her from being reckless.

So, she did was she always did and took raised her hand to his shoulder. He turned to her and stared down. Elemmírë cut him off, “Hey, that Oath does not define who you are. You still fight it to this day and that is more than what anyone else could do.” She added, “And you feel guilt, correct?”

Maedhros didn’t respond, though his eyes already answered it.

Keeping herself composed, Elemmírë gave an encouraging smile as she spoke confidently, “You are not heartless, Maitimo. I think you underestimate how much good there is still in you.” [6]


Time: 559 F.A

The Laiquendi elves informed her that a party was spotted just on the outskirts of the forest and that concerned her. Elrond was busy in the library whilst she had asked Elros to head there to inform him to follow behind towards the outskirts of the forest. As Elemmírë rode with her horse, she found the Sons of Fëanor’s backs towards her. They seemed to be conversing with someone in front of them.

As she dropped down onto the ground, she strode towards them and found Maglor glancing over his shoulder. His face looked troubled, along with a questionable gaze at her as he mentally asked her where the twins were. After answering his question, she creased her eyebrows.

She asked him and Maedhros, “What is it? What’s wrong?” Though once she arrived, she noticed the elven lord in front of her. Elemmírë voiced out, “Oh. Hello.”

The elf in question was slightly taller than her though not as tall as Maglor and Maedhros, with dark hair with a golden circlet atop his head. He wore dark blue clothes, sewn in the front was a diamond with four silver stars.

When he noticed her presence, his eyes widened before he nodded his head and introduced himself: “Lady Elemmírë. I am Gil-Galad. Son of Orodreth.” [7]

So: this was Orodreth’s son, Grandson to Angrod [8] and therefore kin to her previous king Turgon. Well, he had the appearance from the line of Finwë and the aura he drove was much like any royal person who would be.

Though why was he here?

Turning her eyes to both, Elemmírë asked them. “Maedhros, Maglor?”

Maglor didn’t hide his sadness, answering her first, “He wishes for you to go with them. Back to Sirion.”

Confusion brought her heart to plummet. Over two decades and it was only now that the Noldorin have finally discovered them. She wondered what drove them east, for she knew the Valar and the Vanyar [9] have arrived in the Western shores of Beleriand to tackle Morgoth’s armies. But then she remembered who she was before, before being taken by the Fëanorians along with the twins.

Gil-Galad was here, assuming they’ve been hostages for twenty years when in fact it had been the opposite.

Approaching the two, she looked at each of them and spoke, “But I am happy here, with you. And the boys are happy.”

Maedhros stared down at her, his face stoic but his mind filled with anger and melancholy. “You know you cannot stay, Elemmírë. We…we brought you here, but not freely.”

She pointed out, “I almost killed you three times.”

Maedhros out of surprise twitched his lips. “Both unsuccessful. Elemmírë.” He smiled sadly, “But their path lies with their kin. And yours with the rest of the Noldor.”

Inside her head, she was screaming. Did they not care for what they thought? What the twins would think? The twins, who have been a part of their weird and dysfunctional family was what brought them all together. Their paths have been put together the moment those jewels existed and Elemmírë had grown to believe that this part of her life – her part of healing herself from the ruin of her people – was to aid the Fëanorians away from their troubles.

She kept her voice composed no matter how much she was shaking. “And what of the Oath? Will it continue to drive you?” Elemmírë pleaded, “I can’t let you both drive yourself to madness!”

Maglor answered her with a strained voice. “It is not your path to take. It was ours.” He gulped, “And a grave mistake we took.”

It took Elemmírë to stare at the two, wondering why they agreed to this. But then she saw their minds, how much they were filled with something she had not seen in them the night near the waterfall. There was good and light in them, and the pull of the Oath had lessened in their hearts.

With a shuddered breath, she took each of their hands into hers.

She smiled through her tears, “I would not have met you both if you hadn’t.” Elemmírë asked them attentively, “Remember them, will you? They’ve changed you both more than what you can imagine.”

Maedhros nodded at her, “We will, Elemmírë.”


Location: Sirion, South Beleriand, Middle Earth

More of the boats docked by the shore that morning.

Gil-Galad had informed them that the last host of the elves from Valinor were arriving, and amongst them would be the very elf that had left her with the twins. However, due to the promise he had: Eärendil was not to step onto the very earth of Middle Earth. Instead, she and the twins were waiting at the docks before they would board the boat the twins’ very father would be on.

The moment the main boat which the host of the Valar arrived in, Elemmírë immediately knew as she felt the strength of the jewel and its energy along with the other powerful being next to him.

Eönwë, the banner-bearer and herald of Manwë, had his eyes trained on her as they boarded the boat. She couldn’t help but gaze back before she immediately felt a large force push open her mind. The Ainu was trying to enter her head for some reason, and she creased her eyebrows in question.

Well, he could do so as he pleases; there wasn’t anything she wanted to hide from him other than the anger she had for Eärendil and Elwing.

Elros shared the same anger as well.

Too much that the moment Eärendil asked what happened to them – the Peredhel twin’s fist met Eärendil nose.

Even she jumped in shock at the sudden action, seeing the Silmaril perched on the crown clatter onto the wooden flooring.

However, Elros voice trembled in hatred: “You left us! You left me, my brother and Elemmírë to die! You and Naneth! All for this gem.” He picked up the crown and scoffed before tossing it to Eärendil.

And to Elemmírë’s surprise once more, Eärendil had scrambled up to grab it before it could hit the floor. A sick feeling went up to her stomach as a surge of heat went up to her chest.

Elros continued bitterly, “It was not because of Elemmírë that we survived. And Maglor and Maedhros, they raised us better than what you perceived it to be.”

Everyone was watching now, and she could easily hear every thought everyone was thinking. It was there she intervened, walking over to Elros, and tugging him by the sleeve.

“That is enough Elros.” She murmured to him.

Elros inhaled sharply and spoke lowly, “You are the one that bore us to this world, but you cannot be the father I have chosen.”

Walking off the boat, she mentally told Elrond to take his brother back to their tent. As the twins left, she realised she was left with the young Noldorin King, Eärendil and a maia. Eärendil nose was slightly crooked – only a bit – with blood oozing out as he tried to pinch the bridge of his nose.

Once he had sorted himself out, he had looked at her as if he were seeing two of her. Eärendil asked, “What happened truly, Elemmírë. What has come to your three?”

Elemmírë didn’t change her face, keeping it stoic as she answered, “A lot has happened, Eärendil. Even I have changed. Good or bad, you can give your opinion on that.” Her voice slipped into a coldness that even she felt herself. “But you must understand that our lives were not all good, but neither bad. It is only the jewel in your crown that bears the mark of the reason why you abandoned them.”

With that, Elemmírë kindly excused herself and find the twins. She hoped then that the two have calmed down and hoped there would be no elves getting punched in the nose by their sons once more.


Time: 564 F.A

Elemmírë strode through the paths of the campsite until she saw him on her path. A feeling of betrayal lingering in his voice as he looked at her.

“You’re not leaving, are you Elemmírë?” Elrond questioned her.

Speaking the truth, Elemmírë gave him a sad expression. “I am not wanted here, Elrond.”

That was an understatement. She was getting blamed by most of the elves in the camp for possibly taking the twins on purpose and have slowly driven them into madness by her own grief. What utter nonsense! Elemmírë was grieving to this day but she would never give her grief to them.

Though as much as the elves hated her, they found her to be useful. Or more specifically: her powers and her following. Many of the Edain and the race of men followed not only Elros but also her. She had taught the women how to defend themselves, to pick up their swords and fight. She had aided to heal with Elrond the injured, providing stories to the children as well as the grown men and elves during the evenings.

And three of them told their songs of their time with the Green elves, singing about the trees and the peace of the land. She sang about Gondolin, her beautiful white city that she grew up in.

That was not enough for her to feel how she was not amongst her people. Not now and not when the war was at its peak.

Elrond insisted, “Then I will come back, with you.” He continued, “Elros won’t mind if I leave. He enjoys the company of the Edain. Like you do.”

A small smile formed on her lips, “He has always had the heart of a mortal.” She raised an eyebrow and asked, “Are you sure? You have been marvellous as an advisor to Gil-Galad.”

He showed his own smile in return. “And so are you.”

Elemmírë’s smile saddened as she thought to him, ‘Eönwë does not speak highly of me. Thinks I have corrupted the sons of Eärendil.’

His brows creased in bewilderment, confused. ‘You haven’t corrupted us, Elemmírë. In fact, you’ve always aided us, even in the littlest ways.’

‘You should be with your father.’ She thought to him.

It was there he froze before sighing, ‘He isn’t our father. I…I believe that yes, I can understand where he was coming from and Elros shouldn’t have shown his dislike publicly. But I have already been ripped away from one family.’ Elrond admitted, ‘You and Atar and Maedhros are the only ones that have shown the love a family should have.’ [10]


Location: Ossiriand, East Beleriand, Middle Earth

Time: 565 F.A

The two of them arrived at the campsite, spotting the familiar red hair and the clothing. Elemmírë mentally informed him what she was preparing to do and crept around the camp. Once she was close, she was surprised that the two elves were occupied at the flames of the campfire, their backs in front of her until she coughed.

She slyly spoke, “I heard that a Fëanorian was in these woods.”

Both of them turned around as fast as the rapid rivers, bolting up to their feet as their eyes widened at the sight of her and the elf next to her.

Maedhros was the first to speak. “Elemmírë? Elrond?”

“Hello, Maitimo.” Elemmírë grinned as she looked at him before nodding at the other son of Fëanor. “Maglor.”

Standing beside her, Elrond walked over to Maglor and embraced him. “We’ve come home, Atto.”


A month later since their return, Elemmírë and Elrond evolved back to their normal routine with Maedhros and Maglor. Though as the war continued, peace seemed to have been a little treasure in moments as they moved constantly to prevent the enemy from finding them. They have begun travelling up the river, banding with several Laiquendi elves in protecting the east from orcs.

However, that night, it would something different. Elrond had woken up panting and screaming, beads of sweat upon his forehead as she and Maedhros rushed to his side where Maglor was already next to him.

All he could say through his breath was this. “The dead are coming.”

She and Maedhros gave each other a look before they saw Maglor’s frown.

“Are you sure, Elrond?” Maglor asked.

Elrond looked at them before returning his eyes to Maglor. “I am right, Atto. We must be prepared.”


Time: 568 F.A

After trying to tackle the dead (by which they were controlled by one of Morgoth’s more known commanders: Sauron), most of their party was intact. The warning from Elrond truly helped them to prepare for the ambush, though it did not stop them from being terrified at seeing the dead animated before them.

Seeing other magic and power used by others was an often occurrence for her, but Elemmírë had not seen the dead rise back.

Soon as the wave of the dead was gone, word had come to them that many of the front lines in West Beleriand were struggling. Along with them included Elros. Elemmírë was eager to go, to make sure the other twin would be alright. But in her heart and instinct, it was not her right to go but Elrond.

When Elrond heard of his brother in Falas, Maglor and Maedhros didn’t hesitate but allow him to go. However, he had stopped to ask her if she was coming along.

Instead, she smiled at the Peredhel. “Elros needs help.” She encouraged, “Go to him, Elrond.”

Elrond looked down at her, already having exceeded her height many years ago. He spoke, “I wish you well, Elemmírë.”

“And I to you. Stay alive, will you?” She fought back the tears that sprung in her eyes.

He too soon to show his own and hoarsely replied, “I will.”


Location: Amon Ereb, East Beleriand, Middle Earth [11]

Time: 573 F.A

Treading over to Maedhros and Maglor’s tent, she entered inside and found them standing over the small table – a map of Beleriand drawn out in front of them.

Maedhros glanced over his shoulder and relaxed the moment he spotted her usual red and blue attire and took a step towards her.

Elemmírë eyed the two brothers and questioned, “You would deal with dwarves?” She then saw the two give her a look and she paused, “After what happened in…right, must not mention it.”

She zipped her mouth and pursed her lips. It wasn’t her right to speak about past tidings, especially when dwarves are involved. Elemmírë had only heard of the battle in Doriath faintly by other elves in Sirion, and it had grown her own discomfort at how many can turn against by the jewel. Her own hatred for that jewel overshadowed the hatred the elves around her for dwarves, and she was glad at least the war had given them some source of truce with the Noldor…unlike the Sindar who she assumed would rather fight along with orcs than with them.

When the delegate of dwarves from Nogrod and Belegost arrived [12][13], Elemmírë kept an eye on them whilst keeping herself beside the two brothers. As much as she didn’t hate them, trust was little in war and she made sure to inform the brothers of what the dwarves spoke of in their minds.

What the dwarves did not know they wouldn’t mind.

Maedhros place a marker onto the map and spoke, “We must be able to sweep Morgoth’s legions up North.” He glanced up to them and asked, “You would be able to help us?”


Location: Thargelion, East Beleriand, Middle Earth [14]

Time: 577 F.A

They were outnumbered.

Orcs and Easterlings were filling in as they were surrounded, not only by them but by the landscape themselves. Lake Helevorn [15] was the very point they needed to retake and just as she was about to cut the last Easterling down, a dagger was thrust upon her leg as she toppled onto the piles of bodies.

Hands and arms picked her up and she fought at them as she was tossed up until she felt clawed by two large feet. Her heart lurched as the ground grew further from her.

Elemmírë screamed as she struggled, finding the red-haired figure grow smaller.

She cried to him, “Mae!”

He looked up and his eyes widened. As he began to run, he reached out and shouted, “No! Use your light!”

Elemmírë did not stop until tiredness brought her to unconsciousness.


Location: Angband, Erin Engrin, Middle Earth [16]

Time: 578 F.A

It was the first time Elemmírë would see a Vala up close.

However, it was not the Vala she intended to meet.

Morgoth over loomed her body, seated on his gigantic throne as his eyes bore into hers and went through every part of her mind. He tore through every memory, every moment and dream she had. In the beginning, Elemmírë fought every second of it, keeping him from her own mind no matter how much his servants lashed at her and bled her until she was in her own pool of blood.

However, as the months passed the power of her light was soon lessening – giving Morgoth the chance to see through her mind. Every secret and confession she had was now his and Sauron’s. Every moment she had with the twins and the Sons of Fëanor, her brother and Gondolin.

But Elemmírë did not tell them where they were. That was the only thing she could muster up the energy to hide away.

However, it was not those secrets he wanted from her. He wanted the truth.

The truth even she didn’t know as well.

Morgoth rasped to her, “I offer you something. If you side with me, elf. You will be the most beautiful and powerful being of all Arda.” He added, “A queen.”

Shaking, she rose her head up high and hissed, “I will rather die than choose to side with you!”

“Then you will rot here and watch me kill every one of your kin,” Morgoth told her and instructed Sauron to drag her back to the darkness she was kept in.


Time: 585 F.A

Time was meaningless in Angband.

She wasn’t sure how long it had been she had been captured for she couldn’t even see the sun or moon whether it was day or night. The room – or rather cell – Morgoth’s servants had put her in was not amongst the other prisoners, whom she could sense at the beginning of her time to be begging and pleading somewhere below the ground.

Elemmírë at first was hostile and rabid, doing anything at all means to escape.

However, a year after the other, she began to lose the hope that no one would come for her. She began to beg for her to at least be with her kin, those who were trapped in the hell underneath, but all Sauron did was laugh at her before ordering her body to be taken back to her ‘chambers’.

The fourth year of constant isolation and interrogation was when the experimenting began. She heard from the dark Ainu that Sauron would take her under his wing, she pleaded desperately to ask for the end of her life but the maia only shunned her. He tried multiple ways to analyse her powers, creating false memories in her mind to change her emotions, to see if one thing would catalyse her energy.

There were many cases that Sauron succeeded in forcing her powers to be let out, but it was not enough for the mad lord. He needed to know how and why. Where this light originated.

Two more years and a slither of hope grew in Elemmírë the moment she saw worry upon both Morgoth and Sauron’s faces.

The free peoples of Middle Earth were closing in, and it will come to a time when they would have to surrender. At that point, she didn’t care anymore if she was dead or alive; it only mattered if the two beings would finally be defeated once and for all.

She had been by the window in her cell, keeping her hands bathed into the little light in Angband. As she heard the cell doors unlock, Elemmire prepared herself spiritually before turning around.

However, as she expected either an orc or Sauron at the door – it was someone she had expected.

Elemmire stood up, her legs shaking beneath her as she reached her hand out.

She couldn’t believe her eyes.

“Elrond?” She wavered, wondering if she was hallucinating this all.

His grey eyes were struck with horror, walking closer until Elemmírë was met by his warmth. Tears began to fall down her cheeks as she sobbed uncontrollably on his chest.

‘This cannot be real…’ She repeated in her head as she gazed up and found the Peredhel staring down at her. Her mind began to check through his, and a gasp escaped her mouth at the realisation.

This was him.

Elrond cupped her cheek and whispered, “Elemmírë…It’s me…I’m here.”

She then suddenly panicked and began to shake. Elemmírë begged, “El…Elrond! You shouldn’t be here…”

“Well, I am here.” He said confidently, before eyeing her with the face she had not wanted. Pity. He hid it well enough, but even the darkness didn’t hide how horrified at seeing her appearance.

Elemmírë pushed away as she croakily spoke, “It is no use; the dragon will come. Morgoth wants my power.” She implored, “Please…escape before he kills you!”

And to her surprise, Elrond stood his ground and replied, “I won’t leave you, Elemmírë. Never again.”


Location: Thargelion, East Beleriand, Middle Earth

Time: 586 F.A

When word spread at the success of the Sons of Fëanor and Sons of Eärendil’s rescue of Elemmírë – soon came about of her own actions.

How she blinded Morgoth during their escape.

In honesty, she had only done it in instinct as much of her magic had waned and lost control, causing her to lash out at one final move until they escaped through the armies of Angband and back south to Thargelion.

They began calling her with a name.

Oialëa. The Eternal.

Why so, she wondered. She was no more immortal than the elves were, who looked at her like she had been brought back the dead and seemed like she could snap her bones the moment she sat down. It was her frailty and the condition of her appearance which caused the council of elves to doubt her position. Not only as a lady but as a living person.

At that moment, anger brought her to her feet and silenced the room.

Elemmírë cried, “I am alive! And if you think because I have been shackled and defiled by the darkness that I cannot be standing, you have no right then to say that you fight for the goodness of this world!”


Location: Angband, Middle Earth

Time: 587 F.A

She stared upwards, her hands clinging onto the back of the eagle as she and Eärendil flew across the wasteland and fighting.

The dragon was close, blowing a blaze of fire across the land until Elemmírë felt her own energy burst out from her body.

Fire and light met and clashed into an array of colours. A barrier, stopping the dragon from burning the host of the Valar down on the ground whilst allowing Eärendil to fly closer towards Ancalagon. [17]

But the longer she held it, she could feel her chest bursting out, feeling the pain grow stronger until her eyes grew wide at the flames.

All she remembered was screaming, watching her hands go black before she fell back onto the back of the eagle in shock and anguish.


Location: Ossiriand, Middle Earth

Time: 588 F.A

She could not sleep that night, or for all nights for that matter. Reason was that she had hardly slept peacefully since Angband, afraid at the total darkness as she shut her eyes. She was afraid to dream as well, to hear the dark tapping of boots to the whipping of flames. The screams and howling of the wind were in fact wolves, ripping to shreds the flesh of their victims.

Another was because of her hands. After the death of Ancalagon and the capture of Morgoth and Sauron, the eagles had brought her back to the elves. Almost all of Beleriand had been washed away or sunk under the waters, with East Beleriand (mainly Ossiriand) intact. She knew that many were going to sail then and there to Valinor, and she wasn’t even sure herself if she would be counted amongst them. After what happened, the Valar would not even bat an eye at her request to land back into what had been her home.

Even then, she was a baby when she left Aman, brought along by her brother with Turgon’s host. She had not experienced the light of Valinor such as her brother, and thus her home would always be here. Once had been Gondolin. But now…she wasn’t sure anymore.

After finally becoming restless, Elemmírë stood up – carefully rolling up and grabbing her gloves from the side of her bedroll. She couldn’t bear to look at her hands anymore, scared and burnt red. The healers along with Elrond had done all they could but the breath of the dragon could not mend the hands of The Eternal.

She got up and grabbed her cloak and headed to wander about the camp at night.

It was there she heard several footsteps coming from the southern end. Elemmírë approached the commotion before she gaped at the fallen Vanyarin soldiers down the path. Elemmírë raced down until she spotted the faded red and gold armour.

As she found the two people she had expected, they were running across until she spoke. They spotted her and stopped in their tracks.

“Mae? Maglor?” She wondered. As her eyes glided down, she felt the aura around the pouch in Maedhros’ hand.

The Silmarils.

Confusion, anger, and sadness rose in Elemmírë as she strode up to them and tried to reach out. As she went to hover her hand to Maedhros’ face, he grabbed her wrist gently.

Bright blue eyes met his own pale blue ones.

Elemmírë silently pleaded, wanting to shout at him to turn back and return them. To forget the Oath and the jewels.

However, that was not the case.

Maedhros whispered to her, “I’m sorry Elemmírë.” Letting go of her wrist, he nudged his chin to Maglor who stood so frozen in place staring at her.

After all this time, was their friendship was simply this? Forgotten because of jewels their father made them take the oath with? Elemmírë had thought all this time she and the twins’ influence, their love and family bond would stop the pull.

The Sons of Fëanor gave her one last look before they fled into the night, staring at them as they were lost into the forest.

She heard two pairs of feet rush towards her. Elros questioned her by her side, “What is it?”

All she could say blankly was this. “They took it.”

“Atto wouldn’t...Maedhros would not...They would not just leave us.” Elros’ voiced wavered.

She could sense Elros’ anger whereas Elrond’s own emotion was filled with betrayal. Grasping their hands at each of her sides, all she could do was keep the twins at ease.

Soon, many of the elves already sensed what occurred, with many crying as their friends or family were slaughtered during the night. Someone shouted, “Somebody stop them!”

Another pointed a finger at her and yelled, “It’s her! She allowed them!”

Elemmírë’s heart was pounding, until she found Gil-Galad, Círdan and Eönwë in front of them. She heard Eönwë’s cold tone resonate in her. “Let them go. They do not know the consequences of their actions.”

Somehow, that was when her mind changed. She inhaled sharply before telling the twins in their minds her choice.

‘I have to follow them.’ Elemmírë told the two.

Elrond nodded, “Then we’ll go with you.”


Location: East of Middle Earth

“It is no use! Argh!”

Maedhros yelled in agony, grasping the jewel in his left hand.

Elemmírë was several feet away, trying to approach him. However, as she took a step forward, Maedhros took a step back…closer into the fiery pit of the volcano. She felt his pain, his sorrow. She was doing she can, pleading him to come back and talk this through – to forget about the jewel and to go home.

He was the only one left that knew her, who knew her torment and suffering under Morgoth. The one who brought her back to the light. Maglor had disappeared, causing the twins to feel lost as well. Their own father, the elven lord who took them in and loved them as his own.

But to Elemmírë, Maedhros was her brother. She couldn’t lose another brother again.

“Let go then!” She cried, tears spilling down her cheek as they dried immediately by the heat.

Maedhros’ face was illuminated by the lava below as he took another step back. He whispered towards her, “I cannot…I…this is what I deserve.”

She growled in frustration and cried, “You have fought the oath before because of the twins! Because of me!” Elemmírë begged, “Please, I know you can do this!”

There was a moment in which the two stared at each other.

Elemmírë’s lip trembled as she pleaded, “Maitimo, please.”

There, Maedhros spoke, “I’m sorry…”

Elemmírë raced up to him but was too late. “NO!”

And with the Silmaril, his body fell back off the cliff into the chasm of lava.


Elrond Peredhel | Lord of Rivendell

Location: Dale, Middle Earth

Time: October 2941 T.A

Elrond’s body grew cold the moment he recognised the very energy that expelled from the jewel.

Afterwards, he saw Illyria fall onto the ground, eyes rolling back, which snapped him from the memories and quickly got her back onto her feet. Her eyes were fixed staring towards nowhere, as her hands began to shake, and he quickly knew dreaded what the jewel had done to cause this.

This jewel, the very thing that had brought his own life like this, had returned. Out of everywhere and any time: it had to be this moment. He stayed silent, hoping that Illyria would return from her mind as soon as possible. Arwen had arrived at his side, keeping her head cradled until Illyria’s eyes rolled forward and a gasp escaped her mouth.

He took a step back as he placed her upwards, though watched her shun her eyes away from the jewel with anguish in her face.

Walking over to her, Glorfindel asked her with concern: “Illyria are you okay?”

She glanced down and shook her head profusely, almost in desperation. “Take it away. Please…”

Elrond gazed at her and asked, “What happened Illyria?”

Blue frightened eyes faced him as she whispered, “You know why, Elrond.”

His heart sank and he felt impossibly ten times wearier than mere moments ago. A shadow cast over his mind and Elrond could only watch Illyria race out of the tent and out into the city. Arwen had turned to look at him, her worry crossing her face as she silently asked if she should follow her. Elrond shook his head and thinned his lips.

This was ill news.

“That cannot be possible. They said they were lost in the sea, fire and air.” Thranduil’s gaze was of fury and a tint of shock.

The King of Mirkwood was not entirely wrong. His blood father held the jewel up in the stars whereas this jewel had been lost in the fire chasm which Maedhros died with. The last one on the other hand, well: Elrond wasn’t sure. It was speculated that he had disappeared into Middle Earth and chucked the jewel into the sea – though it had been stories, nothing confirmed by the word around Lindon or Imladris.

Atto…Maglor’s disappearance was what lost his hope. However, it was Maedhros’ own death that caused Elemmírë to lose her faith. They had been so close that they could have been brother and sister if they weren’t trying to kill each other thousands of years ago.

However, what questioned him was how this jewel survived the time and conditions.

Glorfindel’s face hardened as he said, “It did not burn. Not even in the fire.” He continued, “It’s been with the mountain for years.”

Whilst there was a growing air of hostility, Arwen had excused herself to find Elladan and Elrohir whilst he was left to watching Mithrandir’s own silent pondering. The maia must be deeply concerned, for this news of the Arkenstone be one of the three jewels forged by Fëanor.

“I don’t understand, I thought this was the Arkenstone,” Bard spoke with confusion, along with Bilbo Baggins.

Mithrandir darkly murmured, “That, Master Bilbo and Bard - is a Silmaril.”


Illyria Strange | Sorceress of the Mystic Arts...and also Elemmírë Oialëa

When she left the tent, she hid.

It would be too simple to hide in the city, perhaps hide in the most desolated buildings in Dale or maybe sneak into Erebor just to keep her distance from them. Instead, Illyria had sat on the cliff edge – the mountain in the far left whilst the right was the valley heading down Esgaroth. Her feet dangling over the edge as she propped her hands onto the cold stone surface, the snow melting under her body heat.

For years she had learnt as hard as she could to get rid of those memories, and all it took again was that thing.

That stupid pathetic thing.

Illyria didn’t know how to think or feel. Right then, she was buried into her mind, replaying those scenes in her mind which the Silmaril gave her. Her own screams echoing in the large halls as that deep and darkening voice made her spine rigid. How her body sucked in, her ribs showing under the little light there was. Her hair was loose and dirty as strands began to fall every moment.

Her own light clashing into the flames of the creature. The breath of the dragon catching her hands, burning her skin until they were black and charred.

She can still hear his screams along with her screams as the lava rose and bubbled. How the heat was slashing her skin like a sword. Watching him fall before all she could do was turn away before he could hit the surface.

At that moment, she felt someone approach her and knew easily who would come to her. Even if they arrived by her right, she did not move or tilt her head – continuing her gaze up at the moon.

He said quietly, “Here, you are cold.” Sensing something covering her shoulder, Illyria glanced down at her arms and found what seemed to be his own cloak around her.

She quietly murmured, “Thanks…”

Elrond cut off the silence as he spoke quietly, “I know you do not wish to speak of it, but I cannot help you if you don’t speak openly Illyria.”

How was she supposed to speak of it openly? The Silmaril just gave her an entire episodic season’s worth of trauma that she didn’t need right now! Each memory getting worse every time.

Even then, Illyria’s heart made her speak.

Gulping down the bile, she murmured in a dead tone. “I remembered them. Makalaurë and Maitimo.” Her chest panged as those names filled her with pain. “All this time, I knew you so much longer than I thought.”

That was what she was surprised as well, the fact that she knew him way further back in history. She thought that in this universe, she would have met him during the second age or perhaps the beginning of the third age. But instead: they’ve been together for six thousand years. She had known him and his brother when they were just children.

The Havens and Ossiriand.

Illyria was there all this time, because of what Elwing asked her to do.

“She left you with me, and then they came.” She ground her teeth against each other as she curled her fingers. “I was…I was so angry. So, fucking angry at them.”

She was outraged at everyone. Not just Elwing for leaving her with the twins but for Eärendil. And then she was angry at the Sons of Fëanor for leaving them again at the end of the war. After being together, their entire personalities changing because of their influence – they still chose to give in to the Oath.

From Illyria’s view, she could tell Elrond understood how she felt. Perhaps it wasn’t anything new for him, having had to experience the loss as well. Fuck, what about Maglor. She knew even as someone who read it that Maglor had adopted him and Elros despite being hostages.

Elemmírë’s presence had changed the course of the timeline. They would never stay with them for years, having gone to stay with the Edain instead to help with the war in the West. Instead, she had brought them up along with the Sons of Fëanor. She had been the glue to the complicated relationship they all had.

He spoke, “You never spoke about them and the First Age. What happened during the war. None of us did. Not after we lost…we lost them.”

Turning her head to her side, she found him staring out into the landscape. Illyria questioned, “But why now? Why after I saw the Silmaril?”

Somehow, the jewel had made her memories re-surface and that was how she got these old memories. The energy of the Silmaril seemed to resonate along with hers, a similar aura that she wasn’t sure if it welcomed her or terrified her. It was raw and powerful that even trying to put her mind through it, Illyria was scared to shit if it was sentient or something.

She hoped it was not sentient.

Fingers crossed it wasn't sentient.

If this was this world’s version of the Infinity stones, she was going to yet off and find someone to break these mother feckers.

“I am not sure,” Elrond answered truthfully, glancing back down her. “But our past was entwined with that jewel, far longer for you.”

Illyria rose her eyebrows and didn’t complain. She did somehow spend years with a dark lord who had a bucket head for a helmet that held two of the jewels. As well as that, Elrond’s sperm donor had one on his crown too.

She muttered bitterly, “The jewel that united this place, but also divided it.” Illyria snorted to herself and pointed out, “Honestly, elves and their jewellery, we need a better hobby.”

In the corner of her eyes, she saw Elrond twitch his lips making herself feel her stomach flutter at his smile.

Illyria then faced him, turning her body around as she slipped off the ledge and back onto the ground.

Standing beside him, she gazed back onto the landscape. “I also saw you. You and your brother.” Her voice cracked, emotion ruling her mind. “I watched you grow up in a war you shouldn’t have needed to fight in. A war that was fuelled by that pathetic piece of shit. You…you were young. And-“

She could sense her eyes stinging, hot tears against the cold air as she clamped her teeth as felt her lips tremble.

“…Illyria.” He began, though Illyria continued.

“Those years, I was so angry and alone. So many died. My brother, Ecthelion, Eärendil, Elwing and my people…Idril and Tuor left, and I wasn’t wanted afterwards.” Illyria’s voice grew quiet as she murmured lastly, “I guess that was why I almost got tempted by them.”

Elrond asked her, “What stopped you?”

She turned to face him and answered, “You did.” Illyria continued, never leaving her eyes away from his own. “You went to save me. You and Elros when you shouldn’t have. You went on a freaking death journey you knew the chances of coming back was so slim. Why did you do that?”

Swallowing his breath, Elrond gazed down at her as he revealed something she was not prepared to hear.

“Because Illyria, I cared for you more than what you believe it to be.” He professed, “Your light and your passion were what brought me to love you. And I never stopped loving you after Angband.”

Everything around her had slowed down as she felt her entire body freeze at the words.

Did she hear that right?

Elrond closed his eyes, his brows creasing as if he was remembering. When he opened them again, he explained: “When the war ended, I was…afraid. Afraid you would reject my love for you. And many times, I wondered why I came to love such a person who would rather act first than think.” He stared at her as he whispered to her, “But no matter what, I never stopped. My heart was always yours, to begin with. It was only in Imladris which you finally found mine.”

Illyria’s mouth parted slightly, awed at what she heard. He had told her that he had loved her for so long. Longer than even she as both Illyria and Elemmírë had realised.

Oh god, she felt really bad now. Might be the best time to tell him the truth.

So, she tried to intervene as she called to him, “Elrond…”

However, Elrond was somehow determined to get his point across, “And you told me that you loved me, but you were afraid as well. Hearing from the bravest person I knew to be afraid with such a gesture shocked me.”

There goes her heart malfunctioning. Butterflies shouldn’t really be in her stomach either way.

The next bit had then broken not only Elemmírë - but Illyria’s heart.

Whispering to her, Elrond carefully took both of her hands and clasped them into his own. “You may never love me as before, but I am willing to wait for you, Illyria Strange.”

She wasn’t what to say next. What do you say next after that? This elf, Elrond Peredhel had told he would wait for her. He would wait for her to eventually choose if she would love him back or not. Hundreds of years of waiting since her death he found her again, changed and so different.

And even then, he had chosen to wait for her.

Illyria couldn’t breathe, struck not only by his word but by the effects of her guilt and the hidden affection she had for him.

But would he accept her even after waiting for so long?

As her hand began to rub circles upon the back of his hands, gazing up to him as she confessed herself. “Elrond, I know.”

His eyes changed quickly as he echoed, “What?”

Okay, how was she going to explain this? And in the most Darcy Lewis way as possible: Illyria awkwardly summarised it all.

Biting her lip, she nervously smiled back, “I may…and maybe Arwen…have been lying to you. All four of you.” Illyria’s smile relaxed, softly speaking. “I know who you are to me, Elrond.”

He gaped at her. “Is this because-“

“Yes.”

Elrond’s face morphed into guilt, and he opened his mouth to explain, “I-“

She tilted her head to the side and quirked her lips. “You could have told me. I would have handled it.” A sigh left her mouth before she grinned, “But after that…I think I preferred hearing you say all those things.”

Elrond took a deep breath, though his smile never faded away, “I…Elbereth.” He shook his head in disbelief. “You will be the death of me, Illyria.”

She rolled her eyes and spoke, “Admit it, Arwen and I are superior.”

“You spent an entire month travelling with the twins and your brother, how did they not notice?” Elrond asked, wondering as well how she could have hidden the truth.

She looked idly and whistled “I may have just asked them too many questions. Honestly, they are good at it. I wonder where they got it from, hm?”

The question made Elrond chuckle, causing herself to grin back. She was glad that Elrond hadn’t been too mad at her, perhaps understanding for both of their sakes. At least this was alright for them, and they both understood now why they have kept each other’s past behind them.

Illyria simply put it with a shuddered breath, “You’re right. If you did tell me then and there, I would have been terrified. I would have just fully denied it all and left.”

“What changed your mind,” Elrond asked her back, curious at her own side of the story.

With a brave face, Illyria confessed her own. “Liking you…again. I don’t think it’s because of Elemmírë loving you before.” She looked back up to his grey eyes and murmured, “I think…it is real. That even Illyria Strange fell for you.”

That had been a total understatement in the beginning. Or maybe she had been denying it ever since. But she couldn’t hide it anymore. There was a pull to him, much older and stronger than what she intended it be. The longing crush over the elven lord of Imladris was not only because of Elemmírë but it had been hers too. She had liked him as a person, someone who was calm and serene, who would keep those protected and yet act with concern and determination as ever.

Vilya perhaps even fitted his own character that opposed her reckless one.

Illyria admitted, “The reason I never told you as well is that I was unsure if you’d like me because you wanted her back or you’d like me – even I am what I am.”

He raised her hand to him and Illyria hovered it until it cupped his chin. His cold skin under her hand caused her arm to grow numb. His free arm gradually took her in closer, his hand pressing gently on her back.

Their eyes never left each other.

Elrond spoke to her, “You are what you choose to be, melmenya.”

The word had almost caused her to grin more. She was beginning to remember it. The feeling of him around her. The love and the tenderness. The laughter and the dislikes. Illyria had thought it would overwhelm her. Instead, the feeling of her heart to him welcomed her like a wave lapping against the shorelines.

Illyria slowly moved her thumb to rub against his cheek as she asked him, “Then you don’t mind liking a human, Elrond Peredhel?”

A fond smile graced his face as he answered, “I’ve come to be fond of Illyria Ettelëa ever since I found her falling into my arms.”

She said amusedly, “Somehow, I’m always in your arms.” Illyria whispered, “I don’t mind it though.”

There was a moment of silence which they shared for a bit, allowing her to adjust her own worries and mind. A rational part of her told her that in a couple of days, the war would arrive, and the risks of death were imminent. Her time here could be coming to an end. She could be training or meditating or even sulking on her own.

In its place, she would gladly choose this more than anything. Her head against his chest, hearing the gentle thumps of his heartbeat as his arms encased her in an embrace.

The snow falling onto them gently.

She quietly asked him, “Can we stay here longer?”

Elrond answered her, “Of course, melmenya.”


Unfortunately, time was limited for them and Elrond needed to return with the host of Imladris and Lothlorien to prepare. He hadn’t wanted to leave her side then (and so did she, secretly) as they both felt eager to be by each other’s sides as long as possible. But they both understood now that since they’ve kind of resolved the biggest parts of their relationship – she needed to sort out the others.

That was when she arrived at the abandoned houses where the twins and Arwen had been. Before she did enter through, she went through her head and took a deep breath. She needed to do this correctly and probably in her own fashionable way. She couldn’t exactly bluntly put it and forgetting the important bits.

She had thought of surprising them by doing the thing the guy did in Love Actually [18], but you can’t exactly find big, massive cards here in Middle Earth.

In the end, Illyria did it the old fashion way and strode inside finding the trio sitting on the floor with their legs crossed. She pretended to put a concerned strict expression, causing both the twins to rise and hover to her.

Elrohir was the one to ask first, “Lady Illyria, what is wrong…”

In honesty, she didn’t plan at all what she was going to do. So, in instinct, she threw herself at the two – giving them the tightest hug around their torsos.

With a muffled tone, she said, “You are in so much trouble.”

When she pulled away, she was met by Elladan whispering to her, “Nana…you remember?”

She grinned back, “Enough to know you’re both my sons.”

What made her chuckle was Elrohir’s sigh in relief, “Finally, I thought we would have to lie!” He smiled widely at her, “I felt rather rude calling you by your name, Naneth.”

Her body did a little jerk as she inwardly hid the awkward reaction to that. She pointed out, “Again, hearing the word mother when you are both older than me.”

Her sons and daughter (yeah that’s going to get some used to, again) stood around her. However, it was both her sons who clung to her like a limpet. Honestly, they were two grown elves and were clinging to her like they were children.

Welp, they were good body warmers.

As soon as she arrived, Elrond had somehow found them in the following moments afterwards.

“It would seem I have found you all together.” He said with a softened gaze at her and their children.

Arwen walked over to Elrond and folded her arms with a glint in her eyes, “I’m glad you finally told Ada.” She added, “Lady Galadriel and Lord Celeborn have been waiting.”

Elladan and Elrohir froze and gaped back. “You knew?” Elladan pointed at her with narrowed eyes.

“Of course, I knew. Nana and I decided to give you what you deserved, after what you all have tried to evade her questions.” Arwen prompted, causing the twins to go look a little meek.

She winked back at her daughter whilst smirking back at Elrond. He couldn’t say anything, serves him right along with Glorfindel and the twins.

Elladan muttered under his breath, “Alright, perhaps we should have told you when you asked.”


Whilst Elladan and Elrohir went to practice with Arwen on meditating, she finally had some time on her own to think for a bit. She had spent the past hour and a half listening to her children of their stories, of their memories together as a family. Elrond had listened as well, commenting in certain bits as he sat with Arwen whilst she sat between the twins.

“I thought you would be happier to know most of your past, Illyria.” Her brother wondered.

Illyria found that blonde elf taking watch at the highest vantage point, clearly unaffected by the cold as she was shivering like any other human being here. November in Dale and Erebor was equivalent to the Alps or Everest and at least her robes were warming her enough. However, her face could say the opposite as she felt her skin form a layer of frost.

She nudged her left elbow at him and grinned, “Aw, glad that you know my preferences brother.” Sighing aloud, she stretched out and relaxed, “And yes, I am happy. But now I realised how much I meant to someone. Before, just being Illyria: I lost so many important to me for a short time. It is odd to imagine that I have family who lost me.”

Her voice grew quiet, remembering herself how much she had. It wasn’t foreign to her to feel that she meant something to someone, she had her dad for that. Stephen Strange, the man who had accepted her as his own. Then it had been Darcy then Uncle Wong and then Tony Stark.

However, Elrond and the children were in other cases. They had known her before as someone who experiences hundreds of years of sorrow and grief and pain. She came to realise now that the dreams she had that were so painful as a child was her own.

How the Ancient One knew then…Illyria just had to assumed she had foreseen it. Or perhaps she knew something else. She might have to look up to that when she returns.

Glorfindel had a fond smile on his face as he spoke, “I felt like that when I arrived here to Middle Earth. You were the only one that was the happiest to see me. You were practically stuck to me an entire century until Elrond swept you away to Imladris.” He changed the subject and asked, “Speaking of Elrond, you have spoken to him?”

“I have. You are in much trouble for hiding the fact that I’m married!” Illyria exasperated, and it did not help her when Glorfindel grinned wider.

He assured her, “I was only following Elrond’s advice, nésa. Though I am glad you’ve gained the memories you needed.”

With a grim look, she corrected him: “I haven’t regained every memory as of yet.” Illyria elaborated, “And we agreed that we will take it slowly.”

Glorfindel groaned and shook his head, “Oh Elbereth, not again. You said this the last time!”

Her eyebrows rose through the roof as she swatted his arm, “Hey! I can’t be going around kissing elven lords who now have fully grown children!”

“You’re already married!” Her brother exclaimed,

She pointed back, “You mean Elemmírë. Not Illyria.” She gave him a smug look. “Illyria is currently courting an elf.”

Glorfindel rolled his eyes and responded, “I had hoped Illyria would have been less patient in these sorts, especially as a human.”

“Oi!” She gaped. Where did this cheek come from? Totally not from the Lord of the House of the Golden Flower. Lord her ass.

Despite seeming to be annoyed, Illyria heard her brother chuckle before he hugged her at the side.

Glorfindel sighed heavily and said, “I miss you, little sister. But with war looming-“ He trailed off, staring out to the mountain.

Illyria paused for a moment to recollect herself. This was it; the battle was coming and just after she had discovered a family she felt so close to.

When she first travelled with Bilbo Baggins, Illyria didn’t even think of growing attached to anyone. Now she had a brother, a husband, and her children. Not to mention her dad, Darcy, Uncle Wong, Harley, and Morgan.

She did her best to swallow the worries down, tracing her hands down to the pendant Estel had given her. Illyria had decided to wear it now around her neck as a way to feel connected to the little boy who was also part of Elrond’s family. And now was a part of hers.

She glanced up to him and spoke, “We will get through this alive. With my information, hopefully, we can persuade the two races to get their problems aside.”

That information involved a certain hobbit and her own hypothesis. It might work, it might not. Though with Glorfindel already looking like he was stressing out because of her, she was not to reveal anything else her plan she was going to do tonight.

“You are uncertain.” Glorfindel glanced at her as he pointed out.

She did not need to lie about that. “I am. I’m just worried if something does change, how would that affect the future.”

“Don’t think too far ahead, Illyria. Just be content for the present.” Her brother told her, and Illyria decided for once to follow his advice.


Illyria and Elrond

Notes:

[1] - Mouths of Sirion: great delta where the river Sirion emptied into the sea. This is where the Havens are which most of the exiles of Doriath and Gondolin sought refuge. This included Idril, Tuor, Earendil and Elwing.
[2] - Taur-im-Duinath: called the Forest between rivers as it laid between the rivers Sirion and Gelion. A dark gloomy forest that extended south of the Andram.
[3] - Ossiriand: A region of eastern Beleriand bounded by the river Gelion on the west and Ered Luin on the east. A wooded region with many elm trees.
[4] - Laiquendi: Also known as the green elves, were a clan of the Nandor who lived in Ossiriand.
[5] - The Oath of Feanor: A dreadful irrevocable oath taken by Feanor and his seven sons in the city of Tirion to retrieve the Silmarils.
[6] - Maedhros/Maitimo: Maedhros was his Sindarin name and Maitimo was his Quenya Mother name.
[7] - Orodreth: A Noldo and once King of Nargotrhong. Son of Angrod.
[8] - Angrod: Son of Finarfin and was the second oldest of his siblings. He and Aegnor held Dorthonion against Morgoth and were slain in Dagor Bragollach (Battle of Sudden Flame).
[9] - Vanyar: One of the three groups of the High Elves, they comprise most of those who didn't leave Aman and Dwelt near to the Trees of Valinor.
[10] - Atar/Atto: Father/Daddy (don't not like that) in Quenya.
[11] - Amon Ereb: Known as Lonely Hill was a broad shallow sided hill that was of strategic importance as it guarded the eastern passage around the Long Wall of Andram into the southern parts of East Beleriand.
[12] - Nogrod: One of the two dwarven cities in Ered Luin in the First Age.
[13] - Belegost: One of the two dwarven cities in Ered Luin which was followed by Khazad-Dum.
[14] - Thargelion: Flat wooded region of East Beleriand east of the river Gelion and bordering the Blue Mountains. Was the land of Caranthir before his death.
[15] - Lake Helevorn: A deep mountain-shaded lake in Northern Thargelion. Its waters were defiled by Orcs during Dagor Bragollach.
[16] - Angband: A fortified citadel constructed by Melkor in the earliest days of the world.
[17] - Ancalagon: Was the greatest of the winged dragons of Morgoth. Apparently, the dragon was so big it broke the towers of Thangorodrim.
[18] - Love Actually: A Christmas themed Rom-com with that scene that had Kiera Knightley.