Chapter Text
Billy can count on one hand how many times he has been humiliated.
Because well, Billy Hargrove doesn’t do humiliated. He’s way too confident and self-assured for that. Too good at reading people. Too good at staying in control. He can brush off the worst of the worst, except for possibly two situations where no matter what, Billy couldn’t save face.
The first time had been the night he almost left roughly four years ago. He’d had a backpack full to the brim slung over his shoulder and his shoes in hand, creeping up to the front door to avoid making noise.
And then: “Where do you think you’re going?”
Billy flinched as Neil’s voice shattered the silence he’d been using as cover. He’d stood there, frozen, feeling like a bucket of ice cold water had just been poured onto his head. But he hadn’t made it all the way down to the front door without some kind of courage pumping through his veins, so he’d turned around to face the man looming in the hall, half obscured by shadows.
Opened his mouth and said, he doesn’t even know why he’d said it, but he’d said: “I’m going to see Mom.”
And Neil had laughed. Billy had never heard him laugh before. Not once. Loud and carefree like this had been the funniest thing in the world. Like Billy had been the stupidest kid in the world. Neil didn’t even raise his hand at him that night. He’d been in too much of a good mood. Full of so much mirth that he’d handed Billy his first beer that night. It hurt more than when Neil used his belt, so Billy never tried to leave again. Never asked about his mom again, either.
The second time had been back in California, long before Hawkins. He hadn’t been popular there. Not at all, actually. More like… tolerated. The guy people watched, not the guy they followed. There’d been a party and Billy decided he’d show up. Decided he’d own the night. Decided Billy Hargrove was a name everyone would know. Except, it had gone better in his head. Not a single person went along with it, giving him odd looks instead. They’d laughed at him, pointing out that he was trying too hard. He’d left that night knowing people won’t forget the name Billy Hargove, but not for the reasons he wanted.
The third time is always the worst. And this, this right here, is Billy’s third time, humiliation creeping up the back of his neck. And compared to the other two, it’s actually not that bad. So Steve had made him think they were gonna hook up and instead set him up to be the laughing stock? Big deal. Billy has dealt with more creative pranks or whatever this is supposed to be. Has probably dished out worse himself.
But maybe it’s not the situation he finds himself in. Not at all. Maybe it’s who. Because it’s not just any boy pulling the rug out from beneath his feet, it’s Steve Harrington. It’s Steve who had been stringing him along and Billy doesn’t even know when it started. Was it earlier, by the pool? Was it earlier, outside the record store? Had it been earlier still? And those thoughts only send Billy further down the rabbit hole, wondering which parts had been real and which hadn’t, or if anything had been real at all.
And maybe it hits so hard because he likes Steve. Of course he does. He wouldn’t be dating him in the future if he didn’t. And even if this Steve is not his Steve, he’s still Steve. He’d been wrong about Steve.
“Oh shit, California really bought it,” Tommy sneers, jabbing one of the guys standing next to him with his elbow.
“What the hell is all this?” Billy demands, turning to confront Steve.
Steve doesn’t move to get up. No, he just sits there, unphased that Billy had just rounded on him, face furious. Like Billy isn’t boxing him in between his desk and the wall again.
“It’s a joke, man. You really thought -?” Steve cuts himself off, huffing out an amused little laugh. “Come on.”
“And what’s the punchline?” Billy bites out, not amused. Not one bit. “Think really carefully about your answer.”
“Right here,” Tommy declares.
Billy finally tears his burning gaze away from Steve, settling on the polaroid photo in Tommy’s hand, held up high like a grand prize.
“You got it?” Steve laughs, finally standing up from the desk and squeezing past Billy. “Let me see,” he demands, outstretching his hand for the photo.
Tommy brings the photo down to his eye level, brows pinching together as he takes a proper look at it. “Not much to see,” he huffs, handing it over.
Billy intersects and snatches it right out of Tommy’s hand.
As it turns out, ‘not much to see’ is an understatement. There is nothing for Billy to worry about. There is a white glare over Billy’s face in the photo, making it so that he can’t be distinguished, the rest of his body blurred and distorted in such a way that not even the type of button down shirt he’s wearing can be made out.
It’s part of the rules of his special ability. Billy is physically there, but at the same time, he isn’t. Not in an official way. Not in a way that could be physically kept - no records, no nothing. The past can’t keep Billy, so it will always correct itself. Will always make it like he was never there to begin with.
Even the memories of this night will fade fast. Steve, Tommy, and the rest of these people won’t remember the boy that just appeared one night. The boy from California. The timeline will erase his impact, no matter how big or small.
That reality should be comforting, and it is, to an extent. All this, including the humiliation that would have made Billy start counting three fingers, will fade until it basically ceases to exist. After these 24-hours are over, the only one who will remember this happened is Billy. So really, it’s actually not that bad at all.
That thought comforts Billy for all of half-a-second.
“Why is it so bad?” Steve asks from where he is brazenly looking over Billy’s shoulder.
The anger and the hurt flares red hot, the picture reduced to a crumpled mess as Billy tightly closes his fist around it. And it’s not that Steve is suddenly standing too close or even that he’s looking over Billy’s shoulder after the stupid joke or whatever he just pulled, it’s the disappointment on his face. Disappointment that the camera glitched and didn’t capture the moment Billy realized Steve had been playing him all night.
Billy turns around, bumping Steve’s chest with his shoulder and forcing the other boy to take a step back.
“Guess the camera doesn’t like him,” Tommy jeers, looking far too smug.
It takes everything in Billy not to cross the room and wipe that smug grin off Tommy’s face. So instead, he channels his anger into something else. Without hesitation, he unceremoniously rips the polaroid in half.
“Oh he’s mad, mad,” Tommy taunts, clapping his hands together in glee.
“Wait, hold on,” the guy with the camera laughs, bringing the camera back up and having the audacity to point it directly at Billy again.
The flash catches Billy’s hand as he lunges for the camera, snatching it right out of the guy's hand. Billy pivots and hurls it right out of Steve’s open window in one fluid motion. It soars in the air for a couple of seconds before the sound of it plunging into the pool below with a loud splash reaches their ears.
A collection of reactions ranging from surprised gasps to amused guffaws immediately follows.
Steve is the first to lean out the window, looking down at the pool below, “What the hell?”
“Oh shit, did that hit someone?” Tommy cackles, rushing over to the window as well, the others following suit.
They all stick their heads out the window next to Steve, watching as the camera sinks to the bottom of the pool. The confused murmurs of the party guests below can be heard rising over the music.
“Right in the pool,” one of the jocks comments.
“Nice aim,” the cheerleader adds.
Steve shakes his head as he steps back from the window, one brow quirked up as if Billy is the one taking things too far. “You need to relax,” he huffs, not so amused anymore. “We were just having fun,” he adds, brushing past Billy as he makes way out of the room.
The door to Steve’s bedroom is already open, a crowd of teens already packed around the doorway. Billy hadn’t even heard it open, much less noticed the additional eyes watching it all unfold. The teens crowding the door move aside, letting Steve step through, turning their gazes back onto Billy, waiting to see his next move. It’s a spectacle to them. Everything is.
Billy huffs and marches out of the room. He’s done with being the spectacle of the night, but he’s not done with Steve. Not done with any of this. King Steve won’t remember the details of this night, but Billy will, and he’ll be damned if he lets anyone pull a fast one on him. Billy’s pride won’t let any of this be peacefully. It’s not how Billy Hargrove is built.
“You can’t take a joke, huh California?” Tommy calls out after him.
Billy ignores him as he squeezes out the doorway and into the crowded hall, but no one is moving out of the way. No, if anything, they’re all looking at him like they’re waiting for the encore. Billy has to literally shoulder his way through, shoving people aside, and he can’t imagine Steve having to do this. Billy is proven right when he glances over the balustrade and catches sight of Steve already making his way down the stairs. He’s moving without any kind of restraint at all, the teens of Hawkins moving aside for him. Making way for their king.
By the time Billy makes it downstairs and out the sliding door into the backyard, Steve is already standing by the pool. Someone had already gotten into the water, retrieving the camera and handing it up to Steve.
Billy hopes it belongs to him. Hopes it had been expensive too. Or even better, hopes it belongs to his parents. Oh what Billy would give to be a fly on the wall to hear whatever bullshit excuse Steve comes up with to explain why the camera went for a swim.
And, well, because Billy is still pretty damn livid, he walks right up to Steve and smacks the camera right out of his hands, the device clipping the corner of the concrete before splashing back into the pool.
“What the hell, man?” Steve scowls, eyes narrowing at Billy.
From the corner of his eye, Billy sees the guy in the pool obediently move to retrieve the camera again. He can also see the crowd packing in closer, sensing the fight brewing. Well, since they're so hungry for an encore, Billy will give them something to see. He’ll also make sure to give King Steve something to be properly disappointed about.
“Plant your feet,” Billy demands.
And Billy doesn’t know what’s so amusing, cause he’s sure his expression and his tone conveys he’s not fucking around, but the scowl on Steve’s face eases into an expression akin to glee, mouth twitching into a half-smirk.
“Why?” Steve asks dismissively, planting both hands on his hips.
Billy steps closer, bringing them chest-to-chest, but it’s nothing like before. Nothing like those times Billy has closed the distance between them. No, this time, Billy is seething.
But Steve either doesn’t realize Billy is confronting him or he doesn’t care. It will be a mistake on his part. A big one. Nothing painful, of course, because Billy has already promised to never lay hands on Steve again, even if this is technically before he made that promise. Billy can still shove him around a little. Can still knock King Steve down a peg or two at his own party. Can still knock the first sense of humility into him.
Steve tilts his head, honey-brown eyes taking in Billy’s rigid shoulders and puffed out chest. “What is this? You want to fight?” he asks, like it’s not obvious.
“Plant your feet,” Billy repeats, no less demanding as before. “I won’t tell you again.”
And something in Billy’s tone must have come across properly this time because Steve’s brows furrow, lips pressing into a thin line as he seemingly ponders his next words.
Then Steve opens his mouth and mutters, “You look like you want to fight me.”
And out of every possible thing Steve could have said, Billy would have never guessed that.
Steve’s gaze trails the rigid lines of Billy’s shoulders before flickering down to the way his hands are balled into fists at his side and adds, “But you said if someone looks like they want to fight me, they don’t.”
Billy freezes, caught off guard by Steve reiterating the words.
Steve leans forward a little, voice pitching even lower as he asks, “So what do you want?”
And maybe Billy shouldn’t have let his guard down, even if it’s Steve. And maybe he really should have expected it, but he’s not ready for Steve to reach out and shove at his shoulder. Because if he had been ready, that measly little shove wouldn’t have forced him to take a step back, which wouldn't have resulted in the ground suddenly disappearing from under his foot. As it is, Billy’s whole weight careens off-balance and his body lurches sideways, plunging straight into the pool.
Billy only has a second between the cold water rushing up to meet him and suddenly being submerged to realize that Steve had taken in everything he’d had said, but not in the way Billy had thought. The answer becomes crystal clear then: there hadn’t been anything real at all.
Billy hears the laughter ringing out, sharp and cruel, before he even surfaces.
“King Steve!” is being chanted over and over, mixed in with mocking laughter as the teens are more than entertained by the encore they had been waiting for.
Billy barely hears any of it. It’s background noise to Steve still standing there, arms crossed over his chest, looking down at him.
“Guess you were hoping for option two,” Steve shrugs, half-smirk firmly in place.
Billy curses under his breath and wades forward, grabbing the edge of the pool and hauling himself up.
But Steve isn’t standing there anymore. He’s already turned away and joined the merry crowd. And it’s not even that he’s running or anything because through the bodies, Billy catches sight of him, head thrown back in peals of laughter. He doesn’t spare a glance back in Billy’s general direction. He’s already entertained by something else. Already entertained by someone else. The king has already moved on and Billy isn’t worth watching anymore. He stopped mattering the moment he stopped being entertaining.
That realization settles deep in the pit of Billy’s stomach and it does nothing to stop his shaking fists. He takes a menacing step forward but freezes mid-stride, feeling that familiar prickle creeping up the back of his neck, signaling the end of the 24-hours. Billy only has a few seconds to get out of sight lest he pull a vanishing act right in the middle of a party.
And he could just stand here and disappear in front of everyone, just simply fade out of existence, but his ability is something he’d rather keep to himself. So he turns on his heel and trudges towards the back gate, slipping out and leaving King Steve’s party soaking wet and humiliated.
Billy keeps on walking until he’s on the street, the tingling sensation at the back of his getting stronger and stronger. He keeps walking.
We wouldn't be together if I were still King Steve.
Steve had been right. They wouldn’t be together if King Steve was still ruling Hawkins High when Billy arrived. Because now he knows, without a shadow of a doubt, that he would have hated King Steve with every fiber of his being.
The tingling works its way down his spine now, each step feeling lighter and lighter as the 24-hours come to an end, his body starting to fade out of existence in 1983. Just like all the other times before, the noise around him muffles until it subsides completely. Then the color starts to dissipate, slowly evaporating into tones of grey and black until a different shade of colors starts to bleed in. Gone are the streets of Loch Nora, the walls of the attic taking shape around him until he’s finally standing back in his time, dust and a cool draft welcoming him back.
Billy blinks, his senses snapping back to him. He finds himself standing in the attic, still holding the polaroid photo in one hand, the yearbook open to a random page in the other. And even though his hair and clothes are dry now, he still feels a chill wash over him. It takes him a second to shake off the feeling, still feeling like he’s in 1983 instead of 1985.
The feeling of deja-vu has never lingered this long before. Since using his ability causes him to mentally check out for no more than a minute or two, he usually never feels like he’d been gone longer than that. But this time, Billy feels like he had been gone for 24-hours.
And yes, Billy did spend that time with King Steve. Had been there to hold him up during the keg stand record and had been there after to hear him laugh. Had been there when Steve led him up to his room. Had been there when Steve pushed him into the pool, but usually, returning to his time severs the connection cleanly. Not this time. This time, it lingers, settling into his bones.
Billy has to physically shake his head, forcing himself to re-center. And once he feels like he’s got a proper grip on himself again, his gaze drops down to the photo. What had been so tantalizing before now feels so flat, devoid of any enchantment. Since the moment Billy had found this photo, he’d been captivated by it, but now he doesn’t feel the warmth radiating off it anymore, even with the bonfire casting the photo in warm hues, silhouetting King Steve from behind. And that smirk, that smirk King Steve had directed at him various times during the span of those 24-hours, just feels cold and hollow now.
Billy tucks the polaroid into the crease of the page and flips the yearbook shut.
That’s the end of that. It should be that simple. It should feel that simple.
“You still alive up there?” Steve’s voice calls up from below.
Billy jolts, momentarily forgetting that he is standing in Steve’s attic. His response comes out as an automatic, “Yeah,” and he hates how his own voice sounds strange to him.
And maybe Steve hears it too because not even a minute later, he’s climbing back up, head and shoulders now in view as he asks, “You ok?”
It’s Steve, his Steve, with his longer hair and softer eyes. His brows are pinched in genuine concern, making Billy wonder if his voice had sounded stranger than he originally thought.
“I said yeah,” Billy reiterates, a little more forceful this time.
“Ok,” Steve says slowly before adding, “I was telling you to come downstairs.” The frown on his face twitches up into an amused little smile, “I think the dust up here is getting to you, man.”
Not a smirk. The thought dawns on Billy. The last time King Steve had been looking directly at him, he’d been standing at the edge of the pool, arms crossed over his chest, smirking down at him.
“What?” Steve asks, pulling Billy back out of his thoughts.
The question makes Billy realize that he’s just been standing here, staring at Steve. He shakes his head, “Nothing.”
Billy keeps standing there anyway, watching the way Steve’s brows furrow and the way his honey-brown eyes look him over. The mannerisms are the same. Of course they’d be. It’s the same person with the same face.
“Ok, so, come downstairs,” Steve repeats, motioning for Billy to follow him.
Billy drops the yearbook back into the box before walking over to the attic hatch, following Steve back down into the hallway. Billy automatically moves towards Steve’s bedroom, pausing when Steve calls out for him from the stairway.
“C’mon,” Steve gestures with a wave of his hand before he proceeds to descend down to the first floor.
Deja vu hits him again and Billy sighs, but he follows, trudging down the steps. At least this time they’re going downstairs, not up.
Billy’s brows pinch together when he notices how dark downstairs is, the lights in the house switched off for some reason. He follows Steve into the dining room and freezes in the entryway. The lights in the dining room are also switched off, the only source of light coming from the candles on the cake sitting on the table and the kitchen light.
Steve is standing by the table, a warm smile on his face, the light from the adjacent kitchen illuminating him from behind.
“Oh,” Steve says and he pivots towards the kitchen, smacking the light switch off.
Now the only source of light are the candles, the flames flickering beside Steve. For a moment it reminds Billy of the firelight from a bonfire, of a boy standing with one foot planted on a cooler, a keg right beside him and a crowd surrounding.
But this Steve standing in front of him isn’t surrounded by a crowd. Isn’t looking at something past Billy either, he’s looking right at him.
Billy glances down at the cake and then back up at Steve, “What’s this?”
“Your birthday,” Steve answers matter-of-factly, like it should be obvious.
And yeah, it is, but Billy hadn’t told Steve that today is his birthday. Because this year Billy is turning eighteen and it’s the first year his 365th day won’t be spent in California, but in Hawkins, Indiana. And it’s also the first year in a while where he didn’t spend it alone, but that doesn't change the fact that his birthday is still bittersweet. Doesn’t change the fact that Billy had kept the date to himself.
“How did you know?” Billy asks.
“Max,” Steve smiles.
Of course it would be Max.
“When did you even set this up…” Billy trails off before he’s nodding to himself. “Right, straightening up.”
Steve grins sheepishly, one hand coming up to rub at the back of his neck as if embarrassed that Billy had figured it out.
And as Billy watches Steve drop his hand back down, opting to fiddle with his sleeve now as he nods towards the cake, Billy knows without a shadow of a doubt that this Steve - the one who planned a small surprise and is shyly smiling at him - is his Steve. And it’s not fair that Billy had gone chasing the shadow of a myth, not when King Steve is best left in the past. Not when this Steve is the one who made it. Is the one who is worth it. Is the one Billy loves.
Steve shifts his weight from one leg to the other, muttering out a quiet, “You look like you want to fight me.”
Billy blinks, caught off guard by the words yet again. His gaze immediately darts back to Steve, searching his face. And he finds nothing but genuine confusion. None of the cruelty that had been on King Steve’s face.
And then Billy realizes how it must look from Steve’s point-of-view. Billy silent in the entryway, posture stiff, just staring at him after Steve had sprung this surprise on him.
The laugh that bubbles out of Billy then is real and full of joy. And once he’s able to catch himself, he finally walks into the dining room, but he doesn’t move towards the table. No, he moves towards Steve. Steps in close enough that he can clearly see the way the flames from the candlelight dance across Steve’s pretty features.
“Maybe I just want to kiss you,” Billy suggests, the corners of his lips easing into a soft smile.
Steve blinks up at him and for a second there it looks like he’s having his own moment of deja vu. But then he laughs and playfully asks, “That so?”
And Steve doesn’t just stand there. Doesn’t let Billy be the only one to close the distance between them. He steps closer, meeting Billy half-way, and leans in first, pressing his lips to Billy’s. The kiss is soft and sweet, almost too sweet, and everything Billy had needed.
It takes Billy a moment to register that the kiss is sweet because Steve faintly tastes like frosting. Like cake frosting.
Billy laughs as he pulls back, “Why do you taste like frosting?”
Steve’s face flushes and he immediately gestures towards the cake, “Can you blow out the candles now?”
“Did you stick your finger in the frosting?” Billy asks, one brow quirking up in amusement.
“Billy, the wax!” Steve reaches for the cake and slides it closer, pointing at it a little too emphatically. “The candle wax is going to get all over the cake!”
“You did, didn’t you?” Billy laughs, watching Steve sputter, face practically glowing now.
Billy lets Steve trip over his own words, enjoying the moment way too much, before he finally leans over and blows out the candles.
The past is where the good things are.
Billy had always believed that. And he still does. His mom is in the past.
But there are good things in the present too.
Billy believes that now, because this Steve is in the present. The one that is better than the myth of King Steve. The one that grew beyond that version of himself. The one that exists because time moved forward.
So yeah, there are good things in the present too.
