Chapter Text
In the conference room behind the throne room, they gathered to consult: Thorin, Dwalin, Balin, Fili, Kili, Tauriel, Legolas, and Bard.
Fili spoke first, “Bilbo should be here.”
Tauriel said softly, “I asked this morning. He says he has nothing to contribute.”
“We don’t need a Hobbit’s opinion on how to protect our mountain,” that was Dwalin, of course. Thorin didn’t approve of the remark, but as King, he must think like a king, not like a spurned and sulking lover. Dwalin was within his rights to opine.
“Why would Orcs march in winter?” Kili asked. “It’s a miserable time to be out looking for trouble.”
“They’re hungry,” Balin guessed. “Our alliance has been successful, and prey for hunting has grown scarce.”
“Can we tell who their target is?” Thorin asked.
“Not yet,” Legolas replied. “My father’s communications with Elrond simply indicate an army of at least a hundred heading in the general direction of Mirkwood, Dale, and Erebor. Knowing what we know of Orcs, however… they rarely venture into the forest. Not since they met such defeat when your company first passed through, nearly three years ago.”
“Dale is virtually unprotected,” Bard worried quietly.
“And there is still a fair amount of … gold here in Erebor,” Fili said, with a reflexive glance at his uncle. He had never quite overcome his unease when mentioning the G-word.
“So what are they after, meat or gold?” Dwalin asked rhetorically.
Bard shot him a glance, not liking to be referred to as “meat.”
“Which is easiest?” Came a voice from the vaulted doorway, and they turned to see Bilbo slip through and approach, tugging at the edges of his green velvet jacket, pulling it close against the chill.
Most of the group inhaled in pleased surprise, but decided quickly, via shared glances and rigid postures, to act as though his joining the Council was merely a matter of course. It did not escape their notice that Bilbo made eye contact only with Bard and Legolas.
“Orcs who are hungry will take the easiest path: that’s Dale. It’s easier to kill and eat than to kill, gather gold, buy, and then eat,” Bilbo finished briskly.
“And Dale is more difficult to defend,” Tauriel added.
“Should we… “ Kili kept an eye on his uncle as he carefully felt his way, “should we… evacuate the humans into the mountain?”
Thorin did not react badly and Bard was inhaling to thank the dwarfs for the offer, when Bilbo spoke again. “If you do, the Orcs will just occupy Dale and eat all your livestock, horses, food, everything. Getting it back will be like… well, they still control Moria, don’t they?”
“We could take it back,” Dwalin growled, darting the Hobbit a resentful look.
“Yes,” Fili said. “If Dale is hard to protect against outsiders, once we are the attacking outsiders, it will be no more easy for the Orcs to defend against us… right?”
“You are forgetting,” Thorin said in a gravelly hush, as if he were afraid that the sound of his voice would send the Hobbit scurrying back into retreat. “The difference between the normal occupants of a city—civilians, half of whom are women and children—and an army. If we do bring the humans here, we should bring their livestock and horses too… anything edible…”
“Then we’ve effectively put the meat and the gold all in one place.” Balin warned.
“Erebor has far fewer entrances than any other stronghold, including Moria,” Dwalin asserted.
“Well…” Bilbo paused, “it has one nice, new, bright green one that you can see from the path to Dale,” he said pointedly, finally darting a glance at Thorin.
The Elves and Bard looked as if this was merely an irritable remark, but the dwarfs all grew wide-eyed and still.
“He’s right,” Kili said after a tense moment. “The few other entrances we have besides the front gate are camouflaged. You could stare at the mountain all day and not see them. But that door—“
“Might as well paint it red,” Bilbo agreed with mock cheerfulness, but his lips were thin and his eyes did not settle on anyone now.
Thorin rested his elbow on the table and his face in his hand. Yes, he had truly made a mistake this time. On every level.
“Alright, look, we have time,” Fili said. “This army is still days away, yes?”
Legolas nodded. “Yes. To the best of our knowledge.”
“Let’s just pile rocks in front of that door. They won’t see it if they aren’t looking for it.”
“Aye, that might be best,” Balin said, toying with the beads in his beard.
There was an uncomfortable pause.
“Wait,” Tauriel told them. “What if we wanted to ambush the Orcs in an easily controlled area? There are many places to hide out on the mountainside. And if they are focused on that door, believing it to be an easy entrance…”
“They’d sent at least a fraction to charge up the mountain, and we could cut them down as they come.” Fili suggested hopefully. “It would draw them away from Dale.”
“How can we ensure they are drawn to it?” Bard asked doubtfully.
There was a long pause.
“Well… that could be easy,” Bilbo said calmly. “I still have my red jacket. I could lead them like a fox leads hunting dogs. I’ll do my special Orc-attracting Hobbit dance,” he added lightly.
“No!” Thorin said automatically.
Everyone looked at him for a moment, and then, clearly dismissing his objection, turned back to Bilbo.
“Is there really an Orc-attracting Hobbit dance?” Kili asked wonderingly.
“Oh yes.” Bilbo answered with a trace of a smile. “It’s called Oh dear, I seem to have dropped my handkerchief down between the rocks, I am completely unaware of your presence, and look how nice and juicy my backside is. They’ll be up the side of the mountain, mouths watering, in a trice, I assure you.”
The dwarfs all scowled. The elves both smiled. Bard looked embarrassed. But Bilbo was curiously at ease. Orcs frightened him, of course, but not the way they frightened the others. To others, they were the creatures of nightmares, otherworldly and mysterious. To Bilbo, they were all too familiar. Violent and dangerous, ugly and brutal, but very much lacking in mystery. They were oppressors, and he bore them a grudge, frankly.
