Actions

Work Header

Reverberation

Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The first few weeks out from the Shire are largely uneventful on the sensory front, much to Bilbo’s relief. He doesn’t know if he can handle anyone else’s pain or hunger or exhaustion on top of his own. Though he’d done his best to make provisions for the trip he is utterly unprepared for this type of excursion. He’d had almost the entire evening to write letters and close the house and pack his bag, and, initially, Bilbo thinks that he’d packed decently. Well, except for the unfortunate lack of a handkerchief. He has a bedroll and blanket, waterskins and a small knife, soap and a darning kit, a small travel journal and some charcoal to write with. He has one of his mother’s precious hair clasps to ground him if he gets trapped in an echo; a few changes of clothes, his sturdy animal hide working gloves, and his only remaining pair of stuffed woolen gloves tucked away in his pack for when they go over the mountains.

He wears the animal hide gloves at all times and the dwarrow don’t seem all that interested in his odd choice of fashion. They likely dismiss it as yet another of his hobbitty quirks. Bilbo doesn’t correct their assumption.

Nevertheless, the adequacy of his personal supplies doesn’t prepare Bilbo for the grueling monotony of their daily travel. Or the deep muscle aches from keeping his mount for hours without rest. Or the chill of being soaked through to the skin from that week of non stop rain. Or the random bruises that show up from placing his bedroll in an unfortunate spot on the ground.

Nor does it stop the itching sensation in his palms or the twitching of his fingers, deprived of impressions for the longest time he can remember. In the Shire, at least, he has the freedom of walking around Bag End barehanded, the gentle wisps of his family’s echoes so integrated into his perception of home. On the road it’s not so simple. He takes his gloves off in private when washing up in nearby streams but otherwise keeps his hands hidden away even during sleep. He is already an outsider here. He doesn’t want to risk his companions’ inevitable disgust or fear or rejection if he picks up an impression with them watching. He won’t risk Thorin telling him to leave.

When the muscle aches become too much, he recalls the exhaustion Dwalin had felt during the battle his axes had shown him and knows that, in comparison, his own aches are nothing. The sensation of Balin’s perseverance sustains him during the days and nights of wet and cold. Fíli’s and Kíli’s determination to prove themselves keep him from complaining about his bruised, tired, and often hungry state. The company starts the journey quietly, if not so secretly, poking fun at the soft gentlehobbit who’s never lived rough in his life. But as the weeks go on Bilbo earns their grudging respect for how well he adapts to their travel conditions. It’s more than he expects.

Sometimes, when his doubts threaten to get the better of him, when he truly starts wondering “What am I doing here?” and “Is this really worth it?” Bilbo closes his eyes and experiences again the ever clear sensation of Thorin’s longing for home. It makes the itching feeling in his hands flare up, his hands and mind wishing he could immerse himself in the impression anew. Despite how it makes the craving worse, Thorin’s echo is the most helpful in keeping him committed to this path, so he turns to Thorin’s echo most often. He re-feels the sensations before he goes to sleep and they follow him into his dreams.

He looks around their campsite for the evening and sees Gloín caressing a small locket, sees Orí concentrating on writing in his journal, sees Bifur quietly whittling a block of wood, sees Norí fiddling with a throwing knife. Bilbo wonders what impressions they all are leaving behind.

 


 

One night Balin tells them the story of the great Battle of Azanulbizar. It sounds absolutely dreadful and feels horribly familiar. As he's done so many times already, Bilbo closes his eyes and recalls the strain of swinging great battle axes over and over with no end in sight and without knowing it he quietly murmurs, “as if there lay before us an endless sea of darkness, churned to a froth by greed and obsession, waves of orcs steadily washing away our defenses, and our prince standing tall, our only hope of stemming the tide.”

Balin has fallen silent but Bilbo is so immersed in the memory of the echo that doesn’t notice until he opens his eyes and finds the group staring at him. Dwalin’s eyes spear through him and freeze him in place and he realizes abruptly his mistake. The words are poetic, something of Bilbo’s own creation he'd composed during the monotony of their travel, but the feelings that his words invoke—those, well, only someone who’d been there could know that sort of desperation well enough to paint such a picture. The words are his own, but Bilbo knows that he has spoken aloud feelings that Dwalin, and probably Balin, too, only ever acknowledge in the privacy of their minds.

Bilbo hastily breaks eye contact and prompts Balin to continue the tale. When he hears the ending, Thorin taking up his grandfather’s battle against Azog and emerging victorious, his looks up to find Thorin standing on the ridgetop. He studies him for a moment and, in his sharp profile and steady bearing, can see why his companions believe that Thorin holds the only hope for their people’s future. Why a warrior such as Dwalin follows Thorin through the horror of battle and beyond. 

Bilbo’s eyes wander away from Thorin and catch on the eponymous shield at his side. He wonders if the shining prince of the tale had felt worthy of the heroism bestowed on him. Or if, something whispers quietly in the back of Bilbo's mind, he’d felt like a frightened child thrust into a role he was too small for.

 


 

Bungo’s books on far away places and Ages-old magics don’t hold any stories about abilities like his. Bilbo knows because he thoroughly checks them during many long, sleepless nights in his tween years. And then checks them again, just to be sure. Strongly felt or long-held emotions leave lingering impressions in objects, that much Bilbo figures out from tactile explorations done in secret away from his parents’ attentions. Harder materials seem to retain echoes for a longer time than softer materials, and those echoes are more detailed. But where does the ability come from, and why only him?

Because it doesn’t take Bilbo long to understand that his parents don’t feel waves of foreign emotions rush through them when they touch objects with their bare hands. Nor do any of his cousins be they Bagginses, Tooks, or otherwise. But it takes Bilbo far longer to realize that even if he has these additional insights, the people around him do not particularly want to hear them.

The things he senses are not always pleasant—in fact, more often than not they are downright terrible—but when he senses something he thinks is helpful he tries to share it. The impressions are permanently etched into his mind as clearly as the first time he feels them, although their impact on him lessens with time. If he is stuck with them anyway he might as well do some good, he thinks. 

At least, he does until the strange looks and mutterings become too much, and one too many partners stands him up for an outing, and too many people give him a wide berth in public, and his parents admonish him yet again for taking his gloves off. For all that his mother is an adventuress and his father loves exploring the world through his books and maps, they are terribly incurious about Bilbo’s ability. At times they seem almost fearful. 

Bilbo resents it and eventually just keeps what he senses to himself. After all, why would anyone want to know that a birthday gift had really been given with the blush of new love? What could someone possibly gain from knowing that a bowl full of innocuous-looking mushrooms actually contained the variety that would cause severe stomach cramps and is revenge from someone who felt socially slighted?

Why would his kind mother want to know that by purchasing that necklace years ago, she’s helped a desperate father buy medicine for his children?

No, Bilbo thinks bitterly one day as he pulls on yet another pair of gloves. How could his knowledge be helpful at all?

 


 

He catches Balin watching him sometimes with an evaluating look in his eye. Usually the looks coincide with Bilbo slipping up and feeling a new impression, or getting too lost remembering an old one, or accidentally sharing information about his companions that he shouldn’t know. Bilbo would come back to the present time and notice Balin quietly observing him. Under Balin’s considering eye he smooths his facial expression back to normal from whatever the new impression had twisted it into and fights to steady his breathing. He knows he’s been less careful than he should be.  He’s been getting those looks from Balin since they’d left the Shire.

Balin’s look never holds a question for him, or a demand, or an accusation. Balin never asks about whatever it is that causes Bilbo to tense or grind his teeth or clench his fists or, one time, spasm so hard that he trips over his own feet. Balin doesn’t take Bilbo aside after the tale of Azanulbizar to ask how Bilbo had known what it had felt like to survive the slaughter. Bilbo is fairly sure he’s even seen Balin intercept a few of the others—most especially Dwalin, Thorin, and Gandalf, too, once—when Bilbo had been sure that he’d be called out after one of his episodes.

About two weeks into the journey, before he’s totally acclimated to the hardship of travel, Bilbo is just overwhelmed by the tiredness and the aches and the hunger and the cold. His patience and geniality is worn thin and he snaps at Kíli for some silliness or another. He immediately apologizes to the lad and removes himself from the center of their campsite to regain his balance. He grabs his mother’s hair clasp on his way to the edge of the clearing, takes off one of his gloves, and simply focuses on the faded echo of his mother’s light laughter love. He doesn’t know how long it takes him to regain a sense of stability, but when he opens his eyes Balin is sitting there next to him.

Unlike those other times, Balin isn’t looking at him now, though Bilbo supposes that he’d been able to look his fill while Bilbo had been lost in the past. Balin just looks up at the sky and quietly tells Bilbo that some dwarrow are gifted by Mahal with the stone sense. That they can feel the shape and eddy of the earth around them. How the stone sometimes whispers its secrets to those that can listen and how it tells of hidden gems or veins of precious metal. That, very rarely, the stone whispers of the lives of people laid to rest beneath, of others who had passed through, of those who had done great deeds within.

He’s known a few who were stone-touched, the old dwarf says, though none since Erebor of old. He can still recall what someone looks like when hearing stone whispers. Not once does Balin look at him during the soft explanation, but Bilbo feels terribly exposed nonetheless. He panics and stammers some sort of “Really? How fascinating, thank you for sharing, must be getting to sleep now” and flees to the relative safety of his bedroll.

Bilbo is scared of the possibility that Balin knows something about all of this. He’s long since given up trying to learn about the origins of his extra sense. Surely if it is something so common and normal and good then one of his books would mention it. And in his experience, no one ever reacts kindly to Bilbo’s gift if they suspect he has it. At best they do him a kindness and ignore any strange happenings. At worst...well, he’s lucky that hobbits aren’t terribly violent, but being shunned in public is nevertheless not a pleasant experience. Even his parents had preferred for him to keep his hands covered at all times so they didn’t have to think about their son’s oddity.

In any case, the stone sense that Balin had described doesn’t sound exactly the same as what Bilbo experiences—he later touches a boulder near where they’re camping and doesn’t feel anything at all and feels a bit silly afterward. But Bilbo figures it’s better to be cautious than be expelled from the group for something he can’t control. 

But the days pass and Balin doesn’t bring up stone whispers or Valar-gifted senses again. He redirects other people when they begin to get curious. Balin doesn’t demand explanations or treat Bilbo any differently than he had before and so Bilbo slowly relaxes around him. Maybe Balin doesn’t know after all. Eventually Bilbo feels comfortable enough to ask questions about dwarven culture and traditions and about the construction of Erebor and Khazad-dûm. He marvels at the great feats of engineering needed to build a thriving underground kingdom and it’s Bofur who chimes in with more information about the stone-touched, how it’s because of their gifts that dwarrow of old could safely hollow out the mountain caverns and mine the deeps for wealth. It’s Fíli who mentions that the stone-touched often hold advisory positions of great importance within the guilds and the royal court and Orí who expounds on some of the more famous examples of such. Even Thorin briefly enters the conversation by fondly mentioning that old Khifar, his grandfather’s advisor, had brought shards of folded stone and sparkling gems and had spun fantastic tales from the stone whispers that had made a young prince laugh.

Later that night, when the stars are out and Bilbo can’t sleep, he quietly gets up from his bedroll and joins Thorin on watch. In a hesitant voice, he asks Thorin what stories old Khifar would tell. Thorin, perhaps feeling more nostalgic than usual and therefore more talkative, tells of the bit of quartz that saw a dwarfling struggling with the design for her first sword who learned to swallow her pride and ask for help from her elders. A clear blue agate spoke to the advisor about young love, about two dwarrow who’d started at odds but through time and patience came to know and love each other beyond an appreciation for a fine beard. This Thorin says with a sideways look and a little smirk at Bilbo, and Bilbo struggles to contain a blush as he smiles back. A fine beard or finely combed tufts of foot hair—ah, the things that attract the youthful eye. He very studiously doesn’t think about whether Thorin’s beard might feel fine and soft and doesn’t draw a comparison to how he and Thorin started their acquaintance.

But after that bit of shared amusement Thorin looks up at the stars and continues in a more serious tone. A chipped piece of common basalt had absorbed the blood of warriors and told of the folly of glorifying battle. That one Thorin hadn’t understood until much, much later, as he’d stood alone among the fallen. A thousand-layered gneiss, Thorin recalls, had spoken of its origins deep within the roots of the mountains, its many layers shaped by the fires of Mahal and hardened under pressure. An ancient piece of dolomite from the banks of the River Running, ordinary in appearance save that had been worn entirely smooth by time, whispered of the cool rivers that carve away at stubborn stone with their persistence, persevering and succeeding where the strong but chaotic rush of floodwaters fails. 

The last one Khifar had shared, Thorin says in a hush, had been a sparkling green geode. Khifar had spoken of greed and obsession and lust and how they bring about death and ruin. How a good leader is generous with wealth, how he never hoards it or hides it away for himself, and how he uses it to improve the lives of all of his people. There’d been a world of warning in his story, Thorin recalls, and a week later the dragon had come and Khifar hadn’t escaped. 

Lessons all, Thorin says with a huff of rueful laughter, disguised as stories to keep the attention of an impatient youngling. Lessons that are based in stone-whispers, yes, but that had been tailored to guide a young and brash and, admittedly, obstinate prince along the path toward leadership.

It’s the first time they sit like this, quietly talking in the dark of night under the stars, but it’s not the last. Bilbo sits and he listens to Thorin’s stories and shares some of his own, eventually, though his adventures seem far more lonely and less grand in comparison. What Bilbo has isn’t the stone sense, not precisely, but he hears through Thorin’s tales how the stone-touched are accepted by their people and thinks, wistfully, that it must be nice.

 


 

Holman Greenhand teaches young Bilbo how to garden. The old hobbit shows him how to mix the soil and compost to feed the plants, explains how the roots need air to breathe just as much as the leaves do, instructs him in how to prune and trim to encourage flowers to grow, teaches which plants need a gentle touch and which ones he can be firmer with.

Holman gives Bilbo a pair of sturdy animal hide gloves for the job. For once, the gift of gloves has nothing to do with keeping impressions at bay, though they do that too, as much as it’s about cleanliness and protection from thorns. Holman wears them, too, and so does his young nephew Hamfast Gamgee who sometimes joins them. Everyone around him wears gloves, which makes him feel less out of place. And on the occasions he needs to take them off to feel the texture of a leaf or pinch a stem between his nails he doesn’t pick up much of anything from the plants themselves. Plants, much like people, don’t retain echoes. Another reason he’s always happy being out in the garden.

It’s a peaceful activity, something everyone can do any nearly everyone does, and Bilbo doesn’t feel quite so out of place when he’s out here. And one summer afternoon when Holman goes inside for a cold drink of lemonade, distracting his mother from her anxious watch over him through the kitchen window, if Bilbo surreptitiously slips off one of his gloves and touches the well-worn handle of Holman’s garden trowel and feels

roots as deep as the old Party Tree keeping him planted in the Shire, devotion and loyalty and quiet and firm resolve, calm and sure and steady, deep and abiding love of the earth, home home home

Well. If he’s done that against all his parents’ warnings, then he just as quietly slips his glove back on and gets back to work, content.

Notes:

Alright folks, things are starting to happen on the interpersonal front! Things will start to pick up on the plot front next chapter. In case you missed it in the tags, this is following the movies' timelines, not the book, because, well, Bagginshield ;)

Behind the scenes note: Old Khifar is a nod to my favorite fictional psychometrist, Quinlan Vos, who inspired me to torture Bilbo with an obscure magical ability. Thanks Quin!

Thanks as always to all you lovely folks for reading <3