Chapter Text
At the bottom of the Carrock the group spends a few hours slowly trudging along before they find a river in which to wash up. As the young ones bound off into the water with happy yells and loud splashes, Bilbo quietly removes himself to a more secluded area downstream. His feet are torn and filthy from the mountains, his clothes are smeared with grey ash from the fires, and the rest of him is liberally splattered with black gore and red blood.
His hands, too, display traces of the battle, covered in scrapes and cuts and bruises, dirt and blood and ash from burnt brush. They’re in far better shape than the rest of him, but without his hide gloves he wonders how long that can last. He feels an irrational sense of loss for one of the few pieces of home he’d had left with him, now lost on blood-soaked soil. He tries to shove the emotions away as he kneels at the riverbank to wash the blood and ash off of them.
The impressions are changing. When he thinks back to the impressions he’s carried since childhood and even those few Shire ones he’s collected as an adult, they’re mostly just feelings he’s picked up. Big feelings, few good and mostly bad, but very few thoughts or images had been left behind. Certainty he’s never picked up skills from an object, but that’s undoubtedly what had happened during the fight.
Maybe it comes from all the time he’d spent attuning himself to his sword’s echo. Back up in the mountains he’d gone over the impression repeatedly until it had felt familiar, like stepping into a place visited long ago but never forgotten. During the fight He’d fallen into the echo so easily and had fallen deeper than he ever had before. He has no idea why.
And when he’d held Thorin’s shield....Thorin feels everything intensely. Bilbo knows this, has known it since the Shire, but this is different. He puts the heartbreak and loss and loneliness aside for a moment to try and analyze what he’d felt. He’s chilled to realize that the echo is practically a stream of consciousness. His mind and Thorin’s mind had been one. Everything Thorin had thought, they’d both thought, everything through his, their, desperate last-ditch confrontation against the pale orc who’d killed the king.
He shivers at how deep he’d been lost in that impression, too. It isn’t just the sword and his familiarity with it. It can’t be, not with how blended his mind had felt with the impression of Thorin’s shield. Do the sword and shield pull at him more, do they echo more intensely, because they were imbued during a time of great change? He knows that he’s certainly changed and perhaps that’s why the echoes resonate with him.
Or, he grasps at a stray thought, or, perhaps it’s not that the objects pulled him in. After all, something else did happen while he was deep in the mountains. He remembers the shadowy world of invisibility brought on by the ring, the wind and whispers that had buffeted his mind. How strained he’d felt after taking it off, as if the shadows hadn’t wanted to let him go. Maybe, he wonders very, very nervously, he hadn’t gone so deep because he’d been pulled into the echoes of the sword and shield, but pushed.
A twig snaps behind him. Bilbo whirls around in a crouch and reaches towards the sword on his belt with hands that still drip with river water. Thorin holds up his hands in surrender, or maybe apology, and Bilbo releases his tension more with a small smile.
“Your reflexes have improved, Master Baggins,” Thorin says with a relaxed grin.
Bilbo shifts his hands away from his sword and settles back into a more comfortable position. “Well, it had to happen sometime,” he says with a small shrug and a rueful tilt to his lips. “Besides, I’m hardly the same untried hobbit you met in the Shire.”
Thorin’s smile fades at that. He looks regretful, like Bilbo has lost something precious without knowing it. Thorin opens his mouth to reply, maybe to apologize for leading Bilbo into danger, but then his eyes shift down to where Bilbo’s hands fidget with the frayed hem of his jacket. “I don’t believe that I’ve ever seen you without your gloves.”
Bilbo forces his hands into stillness. Drat. “Oh,” he says, “I suppose not.” He aims for casual and fails miserably. He silently wills Thorin not to press farther.
Thorin, stubborn dwarf that he is, doesn’t let it go. His eyes remain on Bilbo’s hands. “I’ve seen a few hobbits before I met you, in Bree and in the northern Shire provinces. I don’t recall that such attire is common among your people.”
Bilbo curses in his head. Why would Thorin pay attention to hobbit fashion? “You’re...right,” he admits. “It’s not terribly common. Or, well, not common at all, really. Just me, I suppose,” he adds, rambling, “I’ve worn them since I was a child and I’ve just...gotten used to them. I hardly notice them anymore.” What a lie that is.
Thorin stays silent for a long moment and just looks at Bilbo. He seems to be weighing something in his mind. “What did you say to him, back there?” Bilbo is confused and it must show on his face. “Azog. When I was just lying there. When you stood before him, protecting me, you said something to him.”
“Oh!” Bilbo scrunches his nose in thought. “Right, yes, I remember. I told him that he couldn’t have you, I think.”
Thorin’s eyebrows rise. “In Sindarin,” he said after a beat.
“What?” Bilbo asks, startled.
“You said it in Sindarin. I may have been mostly unconscious but I can recognize the elven language when I hear it. You never told us you could speak it,” Thorin prompts.
Bilbo is very confused and more than a little worried. He doesn’t speak Sindarin. He’s never spoken Sindarin. Except apparently he had. He knows that he had, somehow, drawn on the echo imbued in his sword to help him fight, but had he really been in it so deep that he’d spoken another language without knowing? He doesn’t know. None of this has ever happened to him before and it’s very disturbing. He tries to school his face back to nonchalant and cobble together a believable explanation. “I don’t, not really. I must have, um, read it in a book,” Bilbo offers up, hoping Thorin will buy it.
Thorin is clearly not convinced but for once he doesn’t seem suspicious. He looks like something has been settled in his mind. He waits silently as if hoping Bilbo will explain more, but Bilbo knows he’d only be digging himself deeper into a hole, so he says nothing. Finally Thorin walks forward to where Bilbo is still kneeling at the river’s edge and settles right in front of him. Thorin extends a hand out to him. “May I?”
“What?” Bilbo asks, thrown off kilter again by the non sequitur. This is becoming far too common when he talks with Thorin and he doesn’t know if he likes it. Another lie, but he clings to it fiercely.
“Your hands,” Thorin clarifies. “May I see them?” His expression is open and very earnest. It’s a good look for him, but Bilbo stamps down on that thought.
Bilbo must have hit his head during the fight because the question makes no sense to him at all. He stares at Thorin’s outstretched hand in confusion. Thorin wants to hold his hand? When is the last time that anyone had touched his hands when he wasn’t wearing his gloves? He can’t recall a time as an adult and thinks that it must have been sometime decades ago during his childhood. Thorin’s request is so odd, and surely that’s the only reason Bilbo places his hand into Thorin’s.
Thorin’s hand is warm. It’s mostly clean and still slightly reddened from what must have been a rough scrubbing with silt and sand, but it’s warm against Bilbo’s river-chilled skin. Bilbo watches, mesmerized, as Thorin swipes his thumb across Bilbo’s knuckles once, twice, three times, and then reaches with his free hand to catch Bilbo’s other one. Now both of Bilbo’s hands are trapped and Thorin is peering at them intensely, seeming to catalog each scrape and bruise, torn nails and swollen blisters, the deep tan lines on each of his wrists.
Bilbo shivers. His palms, never seen, never touched, are sensitive to every callus on Thorin’s hands, every patch worn rough by sword and hammer. Like with all living creatures, Bilbo picks up no impressions from touching Thorin himself but he does feel the occasional echo of Thorin’s strength loyalty honor duty from the rings on his fingers. One is imbued with a faded impression of a father’s pride and has since been colored by a son’s love.
Thorin seems transfixed with this new undiscovered part of Bilbo. He’s no longer content simply holding Bilbo’s hands but is exploring, softly rubbing across his knuckles, tracing the fine bones along the backs, rubbing rough fingertips across his palms and all of it steals Bilbo’s breath. “So soft,” Thorin murmurs, “so smooth. I had thought, perhaps, that there had been an accident, some disfigurement or scarring, or perhaps a medical condition that afflicts only your hands. But no,” he continues with soft wonder, “you keep them covered for a very different reason, don’t you? A remarkable reason, and yet they are untouched. Unmarred. A dwarf’s life is written on his hands. Every scar and mark and callus and line tells the tale of his journey. And yours...yours can tell so much more. Why keep this part of yourself hidden away?”
Bilbo fights his way through the haze of sensation and focuses on Thorin’s words. Thorin thinks he knows. He’s seen Bilbo struggling, reacting, throughout the journey and, like Balin had, he interprets Bilbo through the lens of dwarven history. But it’s not… he’s not…it’s not what he thinks it is.
Bilbo wants to tell him, longs to tell him. He needs Thorin to understand and to believe him and accept him, oddity and all. But he can’t bear the idea that Thorin might look at him differently if he knows that what Bilbo has is not that lauded gift of Aulë’s. Bilbo can’t bear the thought that he might lose Thorin’s respect and admiration and what he dares to label affection that, despite its newness, he already craves more of.
So Bilbo won’t tell him, not yet. He twists his hands and weaves their fingers together and meets Thorin’s surprised gaze. “Ask me again when this is all over,” Bilbo says, squeezing Thorin’s hands once and releasing them. “Ask me at the end of this journey and I will tell you.”
Bilbo doesn’t talk about his strange additional sense. No one in the Shire talks about it, but Bilbo is sure that at least some people must know. His parents know, of course, but they never ever bring it up to him. They like to pretend that Bilbo is just intuitive, observant, emotional. Perceptive, they say to assuage curious neighbors. Sensitive.
He’s sure that Hamfast suspects there’s something out of the ordinary about him, but Bilbo is equally sure that Hamfast will never ask him about it or spread gossip or treat Bilbo any different than before. It earns him Bilbo’s everlasting appreciation.
Most of what Bilbo sees is centered around pain anger grief darkness. So few strong impressions of light happiness love that he treasures each and every one. He thinks, he hopes, that it’s not a reflection on himself, that it’s not some innate darkness within his soul responding to similar darkness in the world.
He chooses to believe that negative emotions are more easily imbued than positive emotions. That the mind remembers pain fear sadness out of an instinctive desire to protect itself from harm. That so few people open themselves up to transcendent joy and unconditional love that those impressions are, on the whole, rare.
He never feels his own impressions, only those of others. He chooses to believe that’s just how it works, that the gift doesn’t let him pick up echoes of himself. That if someone else has a gift like his they could feel Bilbo’s echo like he would feel theirs. That years of feeling other people’s emotions haven’t scraped out all of his own and left him hollow.
On the coldest nights during that terrible winter when sleep refuses to claim him and dark echoes replay with perfect clarity over and over and over in his mind, he fears that his beliefs are built on a lie.
Beorn’s home offers a welcome chance to rest and recover, if only for a few days. Bilbo sleeps and eats and walks through the gardens. Through a lot of effort he finds a sheep willing to bring him a spare pillowcase from which he can make some simple gloves. After what happened with the sword and shield he’s not taking any more risks than he has to. Especially if it is the ring pushing him deeper into an echo than he means to go.
Somehow Dorí has kept hold of a few needles and spools of thread and lends Bilbo the supplies before excusing himself to deal with...something. Dorí doesn’t specify, but based on the resignation on his face it’s probably some nonsense or another of Norí’s. Bilbo leaves him to it, happy for the privacy to take care of this task without anyone asking him just why it is that he needs the gloves. Dorí’s needles are well-used and well-loved and they send Bilbo gentle waves of
steady steady through and pull, through and pull, don’t rush, keep it even, this is a good commission, his majesty is generous, through and pull, through and pull, this might be enough for Orí’s apprenticeship, steady, Norí won’t need to take another job this month, calm, focus, just keep moving forward, an honor to have his majesty support my craft, through and pull, through and pull
as he sews up two very crude, but serviceable, gloves. These gloves won’t last nearly as long as the ones he’d left the Shire with, but they’ll work well enough to do some actual sword training with Thorin this afternoon.
Dorí has been an enigma to Bilbo throughout the journey: one part protective brother, one part refined manners, one part ferocious warrior, one part lower class striving for more. This calm and steady and quiet dignity shows Bilbo the truest sense of Dorí’s character he’s had so far, of the pure strength and perseverance at his core. And woven in the background of his life had been Thorin and his quiet, unobtrusive generosity toward a struggling family. It’s a softer side of Thorin than he’s seen before and it’s quite enticing. Bilbo suspects he will need to draw on the memory of this echo in the weeks to come.
Bilbo’s life would be so much easier if he didn’t have his extra sense. There are certainly times that he laments knowing more than he should and times that his mind feels strained by the foreign emotions he’s gathered over the years. Without a doubt this journey across the world would be easier if he could be open and honest with his companions.
But in the deepest dark of Mirkwood he slips off his gloves on a whim and takes the offered locket from Gloín’s hands and feels
his wee lad’s laughter and excitement at getting to try out his da’s axe for the first time, still so tiny, a shining star, the best thing he and his wife have ever crafted together, his wife and son, his two greatest loves, his precious son, the bright hope of the future
wash through his mind. Yes, his life would certainly be easier if his hands didn’t bring him flashes of sadness and pain and grief and despair, glimpses of a person’s darkest innermost feelings. But then he gets impressions like this and Bilbo thinks, perhaps, he’s better for having it.
Death, Bilbo comes to learn, changes how an echo feels. In the years following the Fell Winter of his twenty-first year, Bilbo becomes well-practiced at recognizing the hollow hollow gone far away feeling left behind by a person who has died. He often grieves during those years that he hadn’t thought to buy three pairs of woolen gloves that autumn instead of just the two. The Fell Winter is hard on all the residents of Bag End, but most especially on his father.
They’ve all been chilled and hungry and wasted thin, but Bungo develops a deep rattling cough in the final two months of the winter. Bilbo gives his father his woolen gloves to try to keep him warm enough that the sickness won’t take him. But it is too little and too late.
Bilbo knows that the woolen gloves had brought Bungo some small comfort at the time, but now he selfishly wishes that he hadn’t given them up at all. Not because he’d been cold, though his other gloves are practically useless for keeping warm. But the three of them had been trapped in Bag End without outside contact anyway, so Bilbo had simply done without gloves for the most part. For those two cold months Bilbo had re-familiarized himself with the impressions that his father had left all over Bag End. Now his home is filled with ghosts.
Bungo had built the smial with his own two hands as a gift to his beloved Belladonna. His love and dedication is imbued in every panel of wood, every window pane, every candleholder. The kitchen and dining room hold his father’s dreams of raising a passel of faunts with his wild-spirited wife. His favorite pipe carries the deep contentment of a comfortable settled life, of the happiness at holding his son on his knees in front of a warm fire while his wife weaves for them an old hobbit folktale. And Bungo’s study, one of the first places that Bilbo remembers sensing with his hands, feels the same now as it did then, with a far-reaching love of exploration moored by the safety of home.
Bilbo, without gloves for the first time in nearly two decades, had soaked up every impression of his father that he could and had relished the deeper understanding of his more reserved parent. As a child, people had said that he was most like adventurous Belladonna, but that winter had given Bilbo the understanding that he is more like his father than he’d previously thought. A wellspring of emotion and feeling hidden beneath a placid surface.
Which makes it all the more heartbreaking when, a few months after the frost brakes for good, every impression of his father turns hollow and cold and begins fading away.
His mother is a shell of herself after his father dies. Bilbo isn’t much better but he tries to be, for his mother’s sake. When his mother is in the sitting room or kitchen Bilbo sneaks into his parents’ bedroom and drags his fingers along the waistcoats still hanging in his father’s wardrobe, so similar to Bilbo’s own style but with a more refined sense of propriety. Although not ostentatious like some relatives, Bungo had been proud to be a Baggins and able to provide for his wife and son. When the hollow impressions on Bungo’s clothing fade mere months after his death, Belladonna finds Bilbo frantically rifling through piles of jackets and shirts and trousers without his gloves on, desperately searching for the lost feelings. His mother rushes to him after he collapses in defeat and holds him as he sobs in renewed grief.
When he finally recovers enough to go around and touch the maps, the pipe, his father’s chair at the dining table, he is relieved that his father isn’t completely gone yet. Bilbo cries again when he can no longer feel his father in maps and books. He develops the habit of sitting in his father’s armchair, bare hands on the armrests. He keeps the habit even after he can’t feel anything remaining.
Belladonna doesn’t get better over the following few years. Her spirit fades along with Bungo’s echoes. Those years are the only time Bilbo recalls his mother openly asking about his gift. As she ghosts around Bag End in the evenings, she hands him something of his father’s and asks Bilbo what he feels. He is as gentle as he can be, and sometimes he has to lie when he feels little or nothing of Bungo left in whatever his mother picks. Bilbo never can tell if his words help or hurt.
Bag End feels like a motley mixture of Belladonna’s light and laughter—nothing fresh, all leftover from years past—and Bungo’s hollowed out love. The sensory contrast begins to make Bilbo feel sick. The one time he tries to sense his mother’s beloved comb set again, his favorite impression of her, the
bright blush of new love, pleasurable feeling of her husband combing out her curls after a long day, bubbling joy of holding her giggling son in her lap using the same comb on his fine hair
that he’d always felt is now shaded with
never again, he’ll never hold me again, never make me laugh again, never, oh by the stars how I miss him
He starts wearing gloves full time around the house.
The hardest part of sneaking around the Elvenking’s palace isn’t the lack of sleep or the hunger or even the ever-mounting despair at finding his companions an escape route. It’s the ring.
The shadow world of the ring is just as horrible as he remembers. He’s constantly battered by icy wind and terrifying whispers. Invisibility leeches the color and softness and warmth out of his world and replaces it with cold, hard, gray. It’s useful, no doubt, but he hates it.
He uses the ring for a week straight before he can’t take it any longer. He wedges himself into a dark corner of a rarely patrolled area and rips the ring off of his gloved hand. Color instantly returns and he sucks in a few greedy gasps of air. Warmth is slower to follow. It’s nighttime and the palace is quiet so he thinks he can risk sneaking around without the ring on for a few hours.
His palms itch fiercely. He’s been protected from impressions for the whole week and now his hands crave the additional stimulus. It makes no sense to him. In his younger years he’d gone for months sometimes without a new impression, and even at the start of this quest he’d gone for longer than a single week. He’s never had this problem before, never needed to feel an impression like this. But the itchy, crawling sensation grows stronger until he just gives in and takes his gloves off. As he feels his way around the empty corridors he realizes that it’s a very good thing that there is no one around because oh, the impressions slam into him with force. He’d suspected before, after the fight with Azog, that the ring somehow pushes him far deeper into echoes than he normally goes. His instinct had been correct.
It’s as if being immersed in the shadow world of the ring scrapes all his psychic nerve endings raw and every echo after that grates across his senses. It reminds him of how he’d felt in the aftermath of that first horrible impression when he was young, his perception blown wide open. He’s picking up faint echoes from nearly everything he touches, from the walls and floors and doors and doorknobs, objects that, ordinarily, shouldn’t carry an impression for very long. With the ring’s shadow not far removed from his mind, Bilbo senses them all. And all of it carries a faint note of death even though he’s sure that most of the elves who’d left the impressions are alive. The itching, at least, has subsided, but the sensations weigh him down even farther. Nevertheless, he trudges along. He needs to make the most of the little time he can spare being visible to the world.
In those few hours he manages to sneak into a store room and finds many of the dwarrow’s personal effects: beads and hair clasps and Gloín’s locket and Orí’s journal Fíli’s knives and the little figurine Bifur had been working on. He takes a precious moment to soak up the familiar impressions of his friends, not knowing when he might next get the chance. He folds up as much of it as he can in a cloth sack and when he turns to leave he sees a smaller pile, separate from the rest, with two very familiar hair beads sitting on top. Thorin. Thorin is here, thank Eru! He hadn’t been caught by the spiders with the rest of them and no one had been sure what had happened to him. If his personal effects are here then he must be here somewhere, too.
Bilbo’s been careful, oh so careful since he’d realized that he’s given his heart away, not to learn any more about Thorin than Thorin is ready to share. He feels like it is cheating somehow, for all that Bilbo can’t generally help it, to know all of these intimate details of Thorin’s life without Thorin’s permission, But he’s just so alone right now, so weary and disheartened at the indignities heaped upon his friends, and the potential for this tiny bit of comfort is too much temptation to resist. His hand is shaking just a little bit as he carefully grabs Thorin’s beads and
thrum thrum, thrum thrum, thrum thrum, thrum thrum
pulses through him. A deep, powerful, unrelenting wave, the heartbeat of the line of Durin. An indomitable force driving ever-onward, generations of kings culminating with Thorin son of Thraín. He tears up, he misses Thorin so much , but after a moment of letting himself feel it he squares his shoulders. All’s not lost yet. Thorin is here, and the rest of his dwarrow are, too. They may not know it but they’re counting on Bilbo to get them out of here. He carefully tucks Thorin’s beads away in a separate pocket, puts his gloves back on, and braces to enter the shadow world of the ring once more. He’s got work to do.
