Actions

Work Header

Here Be Dragons

Chapter 3: Of Elves and Arguments

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“Indeed it has been a long time and it almost would have been longer too.” She agrees and then leans in towards him, a look of mischief in her eyes. “I was to leave for Lothlorien three days ago. I’m glad however that I did not.”

He blushes slightly at her words and then startles when he realizes that more than one member of the company is staring at them with a mix of suspicion and curiosity. “Oh! I suppose I should introduce you--this fair lady is Arwen Undómiel , Lord Elrond’s daughter.” he pauses and glances down at the little boy sitting next to her, surprised to find that he’s staring at the dwarves with evident distrust.

“I don’t believe we’ve met,” he says pleasantly and the little boy looks at him and some of the discomfort fades from his eyes.

The boy breaks out into a grin. “I am Estel.” He pauses and then glances at Arwen once before saying somewhat quietly so that the dwarves could not hear. “Arwen’s told me all about you.”

Bilbo raises an eyebrow at her but the elf-maiden simply stares back. He can still feel the company staring at him, tension thick in the air though he doubts that will fade anytime soon, introductions or not, and quickly introduces all the company members.

“Mister Boggins, how do you know an elf?” Kili hisses trying to be quiet and failing horribly. Arwen’s mouth twitched in mirth, and even serious Estel looks close to laughing, and he sighs. “We’ve been friends for a very long time.”

Arwen smiles at him and her keen eyes glanced down at the dwarves and their mostly untouched plates and she hides a frown. For whatever disputes there are between her kind and theirs, she has no desire for anyone to starve in her own home. “I can see that you are uncomfortable here, Master Dwarves. If you’d like I can find you a private place to eat, away from all this noise, where you may rest and eat food more to your liking?”

They look at her in surprise and Gloin speaks up for the group as he is prone to do in matters involving the stomach. “That’d be fine, Mistress Arwen.”

Arwen nods and stands up, her tall slender frame impressive compared to theirs. Estel looks back at Bilbo and the dwarves and then quickly stands up himself, sticking close to her side. “Bilbo, would you like to join us? You can tell me how you and the Shire have been.”

“Go on lad, catch up with yer friend.” Bofur says pleasantly, the dwarves in better spirits at the prospect of a place away from the elves and ‘real’ food. Bilbo glances at them once last time and then catches up to Arwen and Estel.

“I thought they had fangs,” Estel says sourly.

Bilbo almost stumbles and Arwen reaches out a hand to steady him before asking, “Why would they have fangs?”

The little boy looks uncomfortable and at last, he shrugs, avoiding both their eyes and looking resolutely at the floor. Her eyes narrow in return. “Did Elladan and Elrohir tell you a story again? Estel you know you cannot always believe what they say.”

He remembers Arwen’s older brothers; twins with hair darker than night and slate grey eyes. They had grim personalities which only became worse after their mother, Celebrian was attacked and tortured by orcs, she left for the west within the year and they still bore an understandable grudge against the creatures.

Clearly they’d lightened up since the last time he saw if they were telling little Estel such tall tales.

Estel still looks embarrassed and Arwen almost exasperated, so Bilbo quickly steps in, attempting to spare the poor lad more of her scolding. “Estel, those dwarves out there are probably some of the friendliest, nicest, fangless people I’ve ever met,” Bilbo says with such an air of absolute conviction that even Arwen looked at him with interest.

“Yeah?” Estel says with wide eyes though still distrusting, his foster brothers’ story running through his mind.

He nods, a smirk coming over his face. “I’ve seen tougher rabbits then that lot out there. Faster too.”

Estel looks at him with complete curiosity then. “Really?”

“Oh, completely. They have the best stories too. I bet better than even Elladan and Elrohir.” Estel looks even more interested at that and he looks up at Arwen with pleading eyes.

She laughs, the sound of tingling bells and prettier than any he’d ever heard. “Go on then. I can see there will be no stopping you.” Estel crows in joy and leans over to hug her before running back down the hall.

“He’s new.” The boy looks little more than ten though he often had trouble guessing the ages of anything bigger than a hobbit. He didn’t dare try to guess how old the dwarves were.

She hums in reply as they wander closer to the kitchen. “My father’s ward. He’s sweet though entirely too trusting of any word my brothers say.”

Bilbo laughs at that. “Take it as a compliment to how great stories tellers you and your kin are.” They came to the kitchens then and Arwen slips inside and he can hear hushed Sindarin and he waits patiently, watching as various elves walk back and forth, only a few glancing at him.

“Your dwarves will have their food shortly,” Arwen says the instant she came out and he frowns, looking her over.

“That’s very kind of you, and I’m sure they’ll appreciate it, but we both know you wanted more than company when you asked me down here,” Bilbo says knowingly and the elf-maiden did not so much as blush or look guilty.

“I felt there was something important I needed to inform you of.” She says lightly and then her expression looks concerned. “Curunir is here, along with my Grandmother, they seek counsel with Mithrandir and my father.”

He feels something in him freeze at her words, kindly spoken as they were, and it takes everything he has to shrug it off. “Where Saruman the White goes and for what purpose doesn’t concern me.”

Arwen’s hand, smooth as silk, reaches down to touch his shoulder gently and he cannot contain the flinch. “I know you are afraid of him, my friend.” She says quietly, no judgment in her voice. “I know you always have been.”

“Can you blame me?” Bilbo says wryly and then shakes his head, leaning closer into her touch, trying to let it calm him down. “What do you suggest I do?”

“I suggest doing nothing. Your company seems ready to leave and I do not think Thorin Oakenshield will want to remain around long after he’s gotten whatever he needs.” Arwen’s hand tightens on his shoulder for a moment and then the touch is gone and he still feels icy-cold. “I was concerned and I thought you needed to know. I don’t believe they’re aware of your arrival.”

He tries to smile at her but it is strained. “Thank you, my lady.”

Arwen allows him one more moment of silence to calm his visible nerves and then suggests gently that they should head back. “Besides, if we leave Estel to it then he’ll drive your company mad.”

The company is already in a different seating area then the elves and true to her word Estel is there as well, listening eagerly as Fili and Kili told him story after story, cutting in occasionally to ask a question with wide eyes and open ears.

“I feel that may be worse than him listening to Elladan and Elrohir,” Bilbo tells her dryly and she laughs. “I have business to attend to. If it pleases you, do you think you could bring Estel back when he’s done?”

Bilbo swears he will and when she has left sits down by Bofur figuring the friendly dwarf would be the least judgmental. “So, you know a lot of elves then?” Bofur says a few moments after he’d sat down.

“Only a few,” Bilbo says and though he isn’t much in the mood for questions, not after what Arwen had told him, he’s glad the dwarves seem more relaxed. “I met them through Gandalf of course.”

Bofur laughs at that. “Aye, I bet you meet a lot of strange folks through wizards.” He frowns suddenly, looking over at the hobbit and noticing how pale his skin looks, how he glances around every now and then. “Ye alright, lad?” He’d been fine earlier, happier than he’d been on any other part of the journey so far the second he saw that elf.

His head snaps up startled and his eyes widen for a moment before a small smile comes over his face and he shakes it off by saying he’s just tired. “I’m still not entirely used to this.” He admits quietly and Bofur relaxes, smiling back at him.

“Don’t worry. Ye’ll get better at it, ye’ve been improving since the start.”

His smile turns wry at that and he laughs. “I doubt you speak the truth but I appreciate it nonetheless.”

Some time passes and Bilbo starts to relax, drawn into the conversation slowly by Bofur and the others. Thorin and Balin were still not back yet but since the rest of the company didn’t appear concerned he decided he wouldn’t be either.

“Bilbo?” Estel appears in front of the hobbit, looking dead on his feet, swaying slightly.

“Are you ready to go?” At his nod, he stands and tells the dwarves he’d be back shortly. Bilbo is mostly supporting Estel throughout the slow walk to Arwen’s chambers, the little boy leaning on his shoulder, and Bilbo tries not to be offended that he’s almost taller than him.

“Arwen told me about you, you know,” Estel says quietly and then lets out a yawn, blinking his eyes in a vain effort to appear more awake.

“Did she now?”

Estel nods. “Mhmm, well--Elladan and Elrohir told me first but I didn’t believe them but Arwen said that this time it was true.” His words start to slur together but are mostly understandable. “Can you fly still? Do you have a cave full of treasure? Elladan said you lived in a cave. Can you breathe fire still? Can you turn into a dragon still?”

Bilbo laughs suddenly and loudly, his voice echoing through the empty hall. Though he would not usually be in the mood for such personal questions he’s glad of it now when the thought of Saruman the White still hangs so presently in his mind. “I can’t fly, not anymore. I don’t have a cave full of treasure, I don’t even live in a cave. And I suppose I can still ‘breath’ fire though it’s not so much breathing anymore.”

Estel looks at him through half-open eyes. “Really? What is it then?”

Bilbo looks around the hallway and seeing that it is completely empty, he gently moves the boy away. “Perhaps it’s easier if I show you?” Estel’s eyes open fully at his words and he looks at him eagerly.

With one last check to see that the coast is clear Bilbo holds out his palms and pulls as much heat as he could forward until there are two tiny flames in the center of them. It isn’t much, especially in contrast to what he’d once been able to do but Estel watches him excitedly, overjoyed.

He wasn’t sure why some traits remained while others had left. He could no longer fly, no longer looked like he once was but still, he felt the call of greed and gold, still, he could pull flames, however small, from his skin. It wasn’t the same but often on the loneliest of nights at the worst of it, it brought him comfort knowing that some things from his past were still with him.

“That’s amazing!” Estel says loudly and then his eyes widen and he looks around hurriedly. “Can you do anything else?”

Bilbo smiles at him. “That’s for another time, my small friend. I believe our lady is waiting for us.”

Estel nods, face serious again though Bilbo has a feeling most of the seriousness he’d seen was simply an attempt at being seen as more mature. “Right. We shouldn’t keep her waiting.”

Arwen looks at them fondly when they arrive and Estel steps into her room, almost swaying on his feet. “Stay safe, dear Bilbo. The world is becoming more dangerous and I fear where this journey may lead you.” She says in a hushed tone as he leaves and Bilbo takes her words to heart, swearing to her that he’d be fine and he would visit on his return home to prove it.

He is heading back when something touches his shoulder and Bilbo yelps in surprise, turning around to find Thorin of all people. “What is the matter with you?” He hisses out. “Is this a thing with you? Skulking about and scaring people?”

Thorin looks almost apologetic. “I meant you no harm hobbit. I only came to tell you the company is leaving.”

“Good,” Bilbo mutters quietly, his mind once again focused on Saruman. Though he loves Rivendell and its inhabitants, he knew it would be best if they left quickly.

Thorin raises an eyebrow. “You don’t wish to stay with your elf friends any longer?” The word ‘elf’ is said with an especially vicious tone and Bilbo resists rolling his eyes.

“Do you have a problem in my friendship with them?” He asks instead, trying to keep his tone polite. The elves of Rivendell are among his closest friends. They had sheltered him after his changing, fed him, clothed him, gave him a name when he’d refused his old one.

“I have a problem with elves, ” Thorin says shortly and at that understatement, Bilbo does laugh, quiet as it was.

Thorin stares at him with such fierce heat in his eyes that Bilbo can do nothing but wince and hope that he has not made the leader of their company dismiss him even further with such a careless action. “I meant no offense Master Dwarf, I know of your feud with the elves, especially those of the woodland realm.”

“But?”

Bilbo hesitates and then decides he would not lie, not even to save himself from Thorin’s wrath or dislike. “Your expectation of this journey is to reclaim Erebor and you will be its King. Your city will be weak and your people weary, especially at the beginning. I don’t think it’d harm you to be nicer to the elves who live so close to your borders.”

It’s the wrong choice of words and he knows it the second he says it but he cannot take it back and the dark look on Thorin’s face deepens and he scowls, “Those elves abandoned my people the day Smaug attacked, they watched our city burn and then left without a word. I will not show kindness to those who have betrayed us and if you think I should then you are more of a fool then I thought.”

He flinches at the words but stands his ground.

“Then Erebor will fail.” He says simply. “You cannot survive alone, not at the beginning.”

Thorin scoffs, “What would you know of such things? A halfling who’s never worked a day in his life has never suffered and endured horrors beyond what you can imagine, safe with your books and a soft bed.” His voice is rough and full of scorn and it makes something in Bilbo’s blood burn with dragon fire, he means to hold his tongue but instead, he lets go of politeness.

Bilbo frowns at the slur and then shakes his head, starting to walk back down the hallway. “I’m no king, your majesty, as such I’m sure I’d have no insight in your pressing matters, but at least I’m not fool enough to presume I know people from the glimpses they show. I didn’t have to come here. I have no ties to you or your kin. There is nothing I desire at the end of this quest.”

He almost wishes he could take it back. He’d said the words in anger but that didn’t make them less true. Thorin Oakenshield is stubborn and clings to his opinions and he fears that his pride would harm him one day, maybe even get him killed.

Thorin brushes past him, hands balled into fists and anger evident from the tip of his tightly held head to his stance. Bilbo lets him and follow after at a slower pace, little desire to be close to the dwarf after that. The company is already packed up and waiting and surprisingly Bofur had packed up his things.

Bilbo takes them with a small smile though it falls away quickly. “Thank you.”

Bofur waves a hand, “It’s fine, lad. Are ye alright? Ye look troubled.”

He is unable to help his glance at the front of the company, where he knows Thorin would be. The dwarf king does not so much as look back in his direction once. Bilbo grits his teeth and pushes away the weird feeling in his stomach, an almost anxiety that he could not fathom the reason for. What did he care what Thorin Oakenshield thought of him?

“I’m perfectly fine.” He says at last and then they slip out of the Last Homely House without another word.

Stone Giants he thinks with some degree of disbelief and the vague thought of mentioning it to Estel on his trip back. The harsh rain is beating down on them, making the ground slick and he struggles with keeping on the path. Of course, there would be moving rocks.

Bilbo’s foot slips, his grip looser than usual as he is the only member of the company who did not wear thick boots, and he’s only saved from falling by Dwalin’s quick grab. Bilbo sends him a grateful look and the dwarf nods, opening his mouth to speak when they are cut off by half of their party is separated.

The giant moves and Bilbo clings to it as tightly as possible, unable to even scream as they move. Every second he expects them to fall and yet somehow they all hang on until at last they are sent crashing into the side of the mountain. Luck is with them for they all land on the rock and he thinks he could hear someone screaming over the rain and thunder.

It is only when the stone giant falls away that he realizes he isn’t on the path at all but hanging precariously off of. The company rushes past them and he wants to say something but he was once again frozen by fear. He expects to die, falling from the sky for a second time when he hears someone ask where he was.

They can’t reach him and he closes his eyes, heart still and painful--until someone’s hand wraps around his and heat blooms through his skin and he looks up to find Thorin. He hoists the hobbit up and Bilbo gets happily acquainted with the blessed ground.

“I thought we lost our burglar,” Dwalin admits, half out of breath from pulling Thorin up.

Thorin frowns, turning to stare at him and despite the rain, the thunder, and everyone’s questions happening all at once, he hears his words clearly. He hears Thorin say he was lost, says he should have never come, says he had no place among them.

The words have chilled him more than the rain and he gladly goes into the caves, feeling for what he thought was the first time a completely human cold, prodded along by Bofur. The rest of the company, tired and exhausted, fell asleep with an ease Bilbo envied as no sleep came for him. His mind was haunted by Thorin’s words and his own doubts, pushed along by the thought of Saruman.

He’d had his doubts from the very moment he left the Shire. He wasn’t fit for this that much had been proven already and Thorin had only confirmed it.

Bilbo packs quickly, still feeling numb and cold, and he creeps quietly with a skill of his own, almost away until Bofur notices him.

“Where do ye think yer going?” Bofur says in alarm and he pauses, a regretful look on his face. If he couldn’t be thankful of much of what this adventure had provided then he was thankful he’d gotten to know Bofur. The dwarf had been nothing but kind and helpful, cheering him up with his terrible jokes and positive demeanor.

“Back to Rivendell and then the Shire,” Bilbo says in just as quiet a voice.

Bofur shakes his head, getting up from his perch. “No, no. you can’t go--you’re a part of the company now. You’re one of us.”

He shrugs. “Thorin said I should have never come and he was right. I don’t belong here.”

“You’re homesick, I understand--” Bofur says somewhat desperately but Bilbo cuts him off. “No, you don’t. You’re dwarves! You’re used to this, used to this life. Never belonging anywhere.”

If there were any words he could have taken back then those would have been his choice. He’d said it badly without thought and he regretted them instantly. At the time he thought it hadn’t been the same kind of homesickness and he’d reacted badly, stressed, and anxious as he was. He’d foolishly thought that they wouldn’t understand. He’d lost his home and he’d been forced to find a new one. How could they understand that? Seeing the look of hurt and resigned acceptance cross over his friend’s face had made him realize how wrong he was.

Bilbo tries to apologize and Bofur brushes it off before asking about the strange glow on his sword. He looks down at it and tries to remember what Gandalf had said as a strange noise echoes through the cavern.

“Wake up!” Thorin barks out and that’s all he has time to say as the ground disappears and the company falls with it. Somehow the goblins don’t notice him as they swarm around the dwarves and Bilbo crouches down watching them with wide eyes. A goblin jumps down from somewhere as he tries to follow after and Bilbo fights, swinging the sword with all his might and hoping that he actually hit something. Then they fall, both of them tumbling down and down into the darkness.

Notes:

My awe is continuing at how much you guys like this!

1. Estel is about ten years old here and isn't aware of his 'destiny' for another ten or so.

2. I have the feeling that if Gloin had ever meet an elf like Arwen or Galadriel he'd be just as swoony as his son.

3. (I'm going to have to re-read the book soon to remember what comes next)