Chapter Text
Seven.
Frodo was up early-because it was Christmas Day and no matter what religion, tradition or belief system you adhered to, Christmas was an all-encompassing commercial juggernaut that meant food, presents and family, no matter if you understood the religious background or not. And Bilbo-whose childhood traditions of Yule were different-had always celebrated Christmas with Frodo because all his school friends did and he didn’t want the boy to miss out, no matter what else they couldn’t afford. Exiled from their homes, Frodo was always the outsider and sharing tales of Christmas was one way the boy could connect with his classmates. Tiredly, Bilbo opened his eyes to see the excited shape bouncing on his bed.
“It’s morning!” he whispered loudly, his face flushed with excitement. “Happy Christmas.”
Bilbo stifled a groan. He had slept poorly, his dreams wracked with guilt and scenes of the Quest, from the early days all the way through to the hideous climax and his own departure. He had tossed and turned, his mind running far too fast to allow his body to fall back into blissful rest and he had only slithered back into slumber an hour or so earlier. But Frodo was here and vibrating in excitement.
“Happy Christmas, my boy,” he said sleepily but forced himself to sit up and face the lad. Automatically, he checked his watch and saw the hands showing it was already half past seven. He blinked. “Is anyone else up?”
“Fili and Kili,” was the unsurprising reply. “I met them in the hallway but their Mom, Thorin and the others are still snoring.” He paused. “I’m…” He bit his lip.
“Hungry?” Bilbo guessed with a wry smile. “Can’t have that for a moment! Come on, m’boy. Let’s get you fed-and we could pick up those two rascals as well…as long as they don’t set fire to anything.”
“I’ll keep ‘em in line, Uncle,” Frodo promised and launched off the bed, scampering across the floor in his bare feet and sprinting out down the hallway. Pausing only to grab the old slippers he had refused to let go and the dressing gown he had preserved through a combination of sentimentality and practicality, he had followed and was greeted to the sight of the two Durin boys racing Frodo-all of them barefoot-along the carpeted hallway, shrieking at the tops of their voices. Bilbo groaned. There was no chance that Thorin would sleep through that-or anyone else, really. The Company were all in their ‘usual’ rooms-apparently they stayed over often enough to have rooms assigned to them, though Gloin also had an attic room for teenage Gimli, who was the only one likely to have slept through the children’s screeches.
“Sorry,” he whispered and trotted after the boys.
One pot of tea and a large plate of cinnamon and chocolate toast had the boys temporarily quiet as Bilbo contemplated what to do next. Filling the boys up with sugary treats probably wasn’t the wisest move but Bilbo knew that cinnamon toast was Frodo’s favourite and who was he to deny the boy his favourite breakfast this one day of the year? They had endured such lean times that a little treat wouldn’t kill him…though it would mean a sugar-high trio of boys for the next few hours. Contemplating the rod he’d made for his own back, he took a bite of toast and sipped his second mug of tea.
A slumped shape trailed into the kitchen, looking bleary. Bilbo blinked and then rose as the shape came to sit beside him.
“Morning, Bofur,” he said cheerily and poured a cup of very black coffee. The miner looked up, attempted a smile that approximated a grimace and then rested his head on the table.
“Is it?” the miner groaned. Smiling, the smaller man peered at the window.
“Well, night is over, the light is clear and bright and noon hasn’t happened yet so…yes, it’s morning. And good. Happy Christmas!” Bofur groaned and pulled his hat over his head.
“How can you be so cheerful?” he groaned.
“It’s easy-I don’t drink like a maniac the night before,” Bilbo told him, chewing his toast loudly. Bofur slammed his hands over his ears.
“I don’t,” he protested weakly. “But Dwalin’s challenges must be answered…”
“And he’s as useless as you in the morning,” Bilbo pointed out, rising and making some more toast. “If he emerges at all. Which, from what I can see, he doesn’t. Drink your coffee. You’ll feel better…” Grumbling, Bofur complied, his eyelids slowly opening as the caffeine kicked in and finally he sat up, watching Bilbo fry a couple of eggs for breakfast. Finally, the miner seemed to be more himself.
“So how are you doin’?” he asked mildly. “Not really had a chance to speak to you since you arrived.” There was a pause as Bilbo rested a plate in front of him.
“Eat,” he invited but sat down, attacking his own plate. The boys were playing some sort of complicated game with Kili’s action figures so he had a few moments to himself. Bofur took a bite and nodded.
“It’s good,” he mumbled, chewing. But his eyes were on Bilbo as he swallowed. “Are you alright?”
“Why shouldn’t I be?” he asked. Bofur sighed and laid his fork down.
“Thorin,” he said simply. Bilbo frowned. “You know how he is.”
Maybe better than you, the shorter man thought but said nothing.
“Oh?”
“Well, he overruled your wishes and kept you here, rather than letting you come home with us,” Bofur pointed out.
“But you stayed here,” Bilbo reminded him.
“Only because you were here.”
Bilbo stared.
“Thorin expects the world to fall in line with what he wishes,” Bofur grumbled, bisecting his egg pointedly. “Because he’s the Durin. The owner of Erebor. The hero who reclaimed the company. But everyone forgets that he only did that because of you-and he sent you away without a penny of what you were owed!”
“I hadn’t forgotten. And neither did he,” Bilbo reminded him calmly. Seeing Bofur clearly upset was unsettling since the man was almost preternaturally good-natured.
“But you have forgiven him, haven’t you?” Bofur asked him flatly. There was a pause and then Bilbo nodded.
“It’s that time of year,” he began lamely. “And though I’m still angry about some of it, I can see he’s genuinely sorry and…”
“And because it’s Thorin, you’ve let him off the hook. Just like everyone else.” There was definite bitterness in Bofur’s voice.
“I forgave him because I thought back and realised that I knew there was something wrong,” Bilbo replied, his tone hardening a touch. He was flattered that his friend was willing to be offended on his behalf but he knew he had the right to make his own determinations…and decide when and if someone had earned forgiveness. “I didn’t do anything about it-not really. It was obvious that Thorin was becoming more paranoid-signs of a mental illness, if nothing else. But instead of insisting that Oin intervened, I just sat back until it was obvious we would all die if we did nothing. And when I was thrown out, not one of you stepped up or spoke up for me.”
“I know. And it’s haunted me to this day-so I am determined that none of us should get off lightly,” Bofur said honestly. “But Thorin seems to get a free pass because of who he is. No matter how dreadfully he behaves, it is excused and forgotten. Yet he never faced the hardships you did as a result of his actions.”
He never faced my hardships…but most of you never knew what he faced after his family lost their home and wealth, he thought, recalling late night conversations with Thorin as one or other of them took a late watch. Thorin was a confusing mixture of contradictions, filled with pride and devotion to his honour and that of his line but willing to do anything if it would protect and support his family. A man brave enough to undertake a hopeless quest against impossible odds but who never got up the courage to confess his feelings for the burglar. A man who fussed and worried over any suggestion of wound to one of his Company but who refused help for his own injuries-including the poisoned one that almost killed him. A man who was capable of terrible anger and cruelty in his rage but who was tender and protective to those he loved.
… “There’s nothing worse than hearing the boys whimpering in hunger during the night. Nothing worse than seeing the misery in their eyes when there is nothing on the plate…or as near to nothing as makes no difference. And while I should be able to provide for them sometimes there is no work or pay is withheld or…or I am cheated.”
Bilbo recalled the crashing shame in his eyes and voice that had accompanied the words.
“Mahal knows, I would never want to cheat anyone working for me. But sometimes I wonder if the gods are out to make my life harder. And I have done everything I could to put food on the table and a roof above our heads. Work, legal and…less so. Serving men who are dishonest and cruel. I have gathered trash and picked rubbish. I have sold my blood to buy hot food when the boys were sick and needed warmth. I have sold every heirloom we possessed. I have done…many things I am ashamed of to ensure they survived, things that remain between Mahal and I and which Dis will never know. Because I promised I would protect and care for her and her children when Vili died…and that is the one vow I cannot break. No matter what else happens.”
“Thorin…?”
The smile in response to his words had been very sad and weary.
“I would sell the flesh from my bones if it would have kept them alive and there was no other way,” Thorin had told him softly. “Though I really hope it doesn’t become necessary. Because I would rather spend the remainder of my life with someone who cares for me once my family are secure-even though I know that this Quest may well cost me my life…” He paused and then had looked Bilbo full in the face. “But if that is what it takes, then I’ll gladly pay the price. Because at least Dis and the boys will be secure. And I will not have failed my promise.”
“Bilbo?”
He blinked and saw Bofur looking concerned. Wearily, he offered a smile.
“Just a memory,” he began but Bofur shook his head.
“Memories you shouldn’t have to deal with-if he hadn’t cheated you and reneged on his responsibilities,” he added sharply.
“And any one of you could have spoken up-or gone after me,” Bilbo told him bluntly. “But no one did-before, during or after the battle. I understand there was a lot going on but there were eleven of you-surely one person could have spared the time to locate the Company Burglar and apologise or ask me back? There was a time between my leaving you all and when I was driven from the Shire and declared dead when you could have found me…and maybe helped. But no one did. So though Thorin was to blame for my banishment, not one of you made any effort to help. So by that reckoning, all of you owe me any apology. But Thorin is the only one who has been on his knees, asking for forgiveness. The first thing he did was apologise…well, after I’d slapped him and he assumed Frodo was my son…” He glanced at the boy who was laughing with his new friends. Fili and Kili had made more toast (rather crispy around the edges) and were building a house of cards using toast. Bofur blinked and then nodded.
“Aye…he did do that,” he conceded. “And you said you’d consider it.”
“I have.”
“And you blame all of us?”
“To some extent,” Bilbo added, looking in his friend’s eyes. “Bofur-I’m not saying this to be unkind but you have to understand that Thorin has shown nothing but remorse since I arrived. I can read him and it is genuine, of that I am sure. I know you are my friend and I was incredibly grateful to see you when you and he others rescued me from those men in Esgaroth but I will decide who I am willing to forgive and when. And honestly, after the last few years, I am just happy to be warm and well-fed and be hearing Frodo laughing once more.” The miner glanced over at the boy, his face scrunched in concentration as he balanced a pair of pieces of toast on top of the tower.
“I can see how that is a blessing,” he mumbled. “But why…?” Bilbo sighed. He had guessed his friend would be hurt that he had chosen to stay with Thorin over Bofur’s offer…but there was one irresistible driving force to his decision.
“The boys,” he revealed. “Frodo has so few people he calls friend because we are moving often and he has so little. They made him welcome and he feels…happy with them.” He cast a fond look at the raven-haired boy, his laughter uninhibited as the tower of toast collapsed. “I would not take him away from his new friends. And you and Bifur live alone. I know Bombur has children but they live away from you-and you would be coming here for Christmas. From talking to him after we arrived, I know Thalia has taken them to her parents for this year. So if I came to stay with you, Frodo would be alone among adults. You understand?”
Bofur shrugged.
“I can only imagine, never havin’ had one o’ my own,” he mumbled. “But I can see how much he means to you.” He gave a small smile. “And seeing you smile when you see him happy warms my heart.” He gave a shuddering sigh. “I only ever wanted the best for you, my friend. When you left, I wished you all the luck in the world. Sadly, it wasn’t all good luck.”
Bilbo chuckled and emptied his now-cold mug of tea.
“It’s the thought that counts,” he sniggered. “And for the record, though I am hurt that none of you made an effort to find me when it could have made a difference, there are always going to be regrets. I am back now-and do I want bitterness to sour this reunion and ruin what friendships I still have? Or do I understand that some things remain in the past and that maybe some conversations need to be had over the coming days…but without rancour or blame?”
“You’re a better man than me, Bilbo Baggins,” Bofur conceded, finishing his coffee and scraping the last scraps from his plate. He rescued a piece of toast, only lightly handled, and smeared it with honey. “I’m glad you’re back.”
“I’m glad to be back,” Bilbo said, a weight settling in his stomach. “If only it can last.”
“Why wouldn’t it?” Bofur asked as the door to the kitchen opened and Thorin and Dis walked swiftly in, scanning the place for signs of catastrophe. Bilbo shrugged.
“I’ve learned not a trust any outcome until it has finally happened,” he said bleakly. “No matter what is promised. Sometimes, things happen that take away what you hoped through no fault of your own or others…” Then he chuckled and raised his voice to the worried newcomers. “They’re alive, all limbs intact and they have been fed-though with rather more sugar than average, I’m afraid. But the presents are unopened though I wouldn’t suggest trying to prolong that state for much longer. Coffee?” Dis smiled.
“You are an absolute treasure and if my idiot brother doesn’t snap you up, I will,” she said and slumped into a seat by Fili as he offered her a slightly mangled cinnamon toast. “This is divine.” Thorin, meanwhile, was definitely blushing under his neatly-trimmed beard, his head bowed forward and hand covering his eyes in embarrassment. Bofur rose.
“I can see this is family time,” he said stiffly and walked out, still chewing his toast. Thorin slumped into the warm, newly-vacated seat.
“I apologise,” he said in a low voice. “My sister has no filter. Or discretion. Or attachment to reality. Or filter. Or diplomacy. Or…”
“I get the idea,” Bilbo interrupted him, putting a mug of very strong coffee in front of him then offering Dis an identical mug. She promptly added cream and honey. Thorin took a sip of the scalding liquid.
“I never said anything…” he murmured. Bilbo grinned.
“I seem to have heard the terms ‘moping’ ‘sighing’ ‘pining’ and ‘yearning’ used more than once with regards to the last five years,” he said primly, watching Thorin’s broad shoulders tense. “And you really aren’t that hard to read, Thorin. Well, not if someone knows you. And you are a total drama queen…” The CEO grimaced, his eyes downcast.
“I know I surrendered all rights and expectations when I treated you so abysmally five years ago,” he said softly. “But it seems my heart refuses to listen. Please-do not be offended by my sister’s presumptions of thoughtless words. I would not have what truce we have brokered between us ruined by the words of my irritating and very pushy younger sibling…” Bilbo burst out laughing.
“Truce we have brokered?” he repeated, doubled up with mirth. “Thorin-I know you were brought up to be the CEO of Erebor but this is the kitchen table of your home on Christmas morning. We’re friends. I’ve decided to forgive you-though we still need that talk. But for now, drink your coffee and I’ll make you some eggs and bacon. And then we can finally allow these children to open their presents!”
