Actions

Work Header

All I want For Christmas...

Chapter 12: Twelve

Chapter Text

Twelve.

 

A sense of trepidation ran through Bilbo as Thorin walked into the Living Room and asked him to accompany him. And because Bilbo had decided to trust Thorin, he did. This wasn’t the man who had raged and shouted, whose hands had tightened around his neck and called him a rat and a traitor. No, this was Thorin who had talked with love and affection about his nephews, who had shared stories of his childhood and his siblings and who had known how devastated Bilbo had felt when he had discussed the deaths of his parents. So he followed the CEO along the corridor he realised he had walked before, five years earlier, in the dark and fear of avoiding Bolg and gathering the evidence from the concealed safe. But nothing prepared him for the figures waiting for him there: the elegant shapes of Legolas Oropher and Tauriel Silvani…and on the laptop screen, enclosed in the familiar outline of the ‘EntMoot’ meetings software, was the lined face of an old man with piercing blue-grey eyes, long grey beard and rather messy grey hair.

 

“GANDALF!” Bilbo exclaimed and took a step forward in shock. 

 

“Bless my beard-Bilbo Baggins, it is you!” the old lawyer said cheerfully. “I must confess I was worried about what had happened to you but I had every faith that your own resourcefulness would mean you would be fine.” Bilbo folded his arms and glared.

 

“Oh you did, did you?” he snarked. “Would it have killed you to maybe have checked up on me? Because there was a moment when you could actually have been of some use!” Gandalf looked taken aback for a moment before he regained his equilibrium.

 

“We’re not here to trade barbs,” he said more sternly.

 

“Aren’t we? Then I’ve been short changed!” Bilbo shot back. "I was promised extensive snarking and plentiful sarcasm. And maybe some answers…” There was an awkward silence before Tauriel spoke up.

 

“Perhaps we could all sit down and discuss why we are here,” she suggested. “I am Tauriel Silvani, Master Baggins, and though we have not met, I am very familiar with some parts of your affairs. My colleague is Legolas Oropher and we work as counsel for Erebor Commodities and the Durin family.” Reluctantly, Bilbo took the indicated seat and nodded greetings to everyone. Thorin folded his arms across his chest and stood back, allowing the lawyers to take the lead. Legolas leaned forward, his hands clasped in his lap.

 

“Perhaps you could start by telling me what happened when you returned to the Shire?” he invited as Tauriel picked up her pen. Bilbo stared at him.

 

“You really do look like your father,” he said suddenly. Finally, Legolas cracked a slight smile. 

 

“I am told you punched him in the face for how he…imaginatively reinterpreted the agreement you made,” he commented. “I believe you broke his nose.”

 

“Good,” Bilbo growled as Thorin chuckled behind him. Gandalf’s eyes widened.

 

“Bilbo Baggins! Have you been acting without thinking?” he asked pointedly.

 

“No, I weighed up all the relevant factors and decided that punching Thranduil was definitely the best response to his behaviour,” Bilbo snapped back. 

 

“I think most of us who know him can agree that my father deserved it,” Legolas commented. “In fact, my only negative is that I wasn’t there to see it.” Finally Bilbo relaxed and unfolded his arms.

 

“What do you want to know?” he asked more softly.

 

“What happened?” Gandalf asked. Closing his eyes, Bilbo let his head drop back as he forced himself to recall those days and the events that haunted his nightmares.

 

“When I returned to the Shire after the adventure, I found that my home was in the hands of my relatives,” he said. Then he sighed. “The Shire is a very insular and parochial. The people there are not so much set in their ways as congealed and view anyone who does anything out of the ordinary as suspicious. My mother, with her penchant for travel, was always viewed as an oddball. My father-the most dull, home loving man in history-was a bastion of respectability. I was already viewed as a little weird because I studied at Rivendell University before returning home-and when I vanished, I gave my venal relatives an opportunity.”

 

“What opportunity?” Thorin murmured.

 

“In the Shire, if you vanish from your home and you do not tell three people where you are going, you may be deemed to have abandoned your home and it can be passed on to your next of kin,” Legolas replied swiftly. Bilbo raised an eyebrow. Clearly, the man had done his research. 

 

“When I left-Gandalf not having given me any warning you and the Company were coming over or what you wanted-I only had time to let Hamfast, my gardener, and his wife, Belle, know that I was going away for some time. He kindly volunteered to tell the postman, cancel my paper and the milk and let the council know…so my house wasn’t abandoned by any rational manner. The bills were bring paid from my account and the rents were still coming in. My neighbours knew that I was coming back but that I was travelling. Except for one arcane piece of legal jargon that my evil shrew of a cousin’s wife dug up.”

 

“You are referring, of course, to Lobelia Sackville-Baggins,” Gandalf said with distaste. 

 

“That woman has had her eye on my home, Bag End, that my father built my mother when he married her,” Bilbo explained bitterly. “No matter that it was left to me when they died, that they wanted their son to live securely there amid their memories. No matter that my father worked all his life to build up a property portfolio so that I could have the options to pursue what I wanted in life. No matter that the garden was made by my mother. No matter that she was a damned Bracegirdle and had no right to put her sticky paws on it! She wanted it because it was better than hers, better than that lazy lump Otho could afford and she was-is-a greedy, cruel bitch….” Bilbo’s voice had risen and he was almost shaking with rage, his fists clenched in anger. In a gesture that surprised himself, Thorin gently rested a hand on his shoulder.

 

“I’m sorry,” he murmured.

 

“You are not responsible for the crimes of others,” Bilbo said, the anger leaving his voice slowly. “And no matter what you may imagine, I doubt an escort from Erebor would have altered things one jot.” 

 

“That doesn’t make me feel much better,” he mumbled. 

 

“Apparently Lobelia was so switched on to this ancient and arcane law because it was one of her ancestors, a Bracegirdle, who was the reason it was written.” He looked up and met Tauriel’s eyes. “His neighbour vanished but the ancestor claimed that he had told him that he was going travelling. After several months, the man’s relatives grew suspicious and insisted that an investigation was carried out. The neighbour was found murdered and buried in the garden while the ancestor enjoyed his wealth and his home. He was handed over to the Sherriffs for punishment while the law was written to ensure that anyone going away should tell three adults that he was going.” He gave a bitter smile. “The number three was chosen to prevent a married couple from murdering a vulnerable person.” 

 

“You took precautions that any reasonable person would take,” Thorin murmured.

 

“Except in the Shire,” Legolas said seriously. 

 

“Lobelia waited three months and then insisted that I must have abandoned my home or that some foul play had befallen me,” Bilbo continued. “She insisted they dig up Mum’s garden to ‘look for a body’ and tore the place apart. When there was no sign of me, she went to the courts to have me declared as having abandoned my home and then awarded to her. And that was when I arrived home, cheated and angry and horrified that I had been robbed by my own cousin.”

 

“That must have been a shock,” Gandalf murmured.

 

“But worse, when I arrived back in the Shire, I found that my favourite cousins, Drogo Baggins and his wife, Primula Brandybuck, had been killed in a boating accident, leaving their little son Frodo an orphan.” His voice faltered. “I was his godfather and no one had been able to contact me. I found that he was lodged with some of his Brandybuck relatives.”

 

“Was that not a good thing?” Legolas asked. 

 

“My people generally have large families, though not necessarily the resources to look after them as well as they should,” Bilbo sighed, seeing Legolas’s eyes widen in shock. An only child, he could not imagine a large family. “Frodo was lodging with Asphodel Brandybuck-Burrows and her seven children in a house large enough for three children. No one else wanted him. But no one wanted me to take him, even though it was explicitly stated in Drogo and Primula’s wills that they wanted me to take Frodo if I was willing, because they knew that I would love him as much as they did.” 

 

“And I suppose your ‘reputation’ was a barrier,” Thorin murmured.

 

“That and the fact I was possibly dead and penniless,” Bilbo said. “I went to see Frodo. He was in a terrible state, abandoned among cousins and subjected to the rough and tumble of a busy household amid strangers without anyone giving him any time or space to grieve. So he began to withdraw into himself. And then he saw me and he just burst into tears and clung to me. I was the only one who had even bothered to hug him and tell him it was okay and he begged me not to leave him there. Asphodel was mortified and wanted him gone. But Lobelia opposed me through the courts and wanted him not to be allowed to stay with me.”

 

“Did they want him?” Tauriel asked softly. Bilbo shook his head.

 

“Not at all,” he revealed with a sigh. “They just didn’t want me to have him. They didn’t care what happened to him, how upset he was or what he wanted. They just wanted me gone-and feared that if I was given Frodo, then I would have standing to try to reclaim my own goods and inheritance to support him. So they got together, planned and then the family ambushed me.”

 

“How?” Gandalf asked.

 

“They offered a deal,” Bilbo spat bitterly. “They offered to legally allow me to adopt Frodo and become his guardian through the courts-if I renounced all rights to Bag End and my properties. I argued that if I had my property back, they would have no bar to me getting back as well-but they pointed out that I had vanished for the best part of a year and that there was no evidence what I had been up to. And that was when I found that the entire Company had written me out of the story. Not one single mention, my name never said, nothing to prove that I had risked my life over and over to save them. And without any corroboration, I was sunk. Thranduil refused to talk to me, Bard was busy and the Company…” He looked up at Thorin. “Why?”

 

Thorin covered his face with his hands and ran his fingers through his hair wearily.

 

“At first, the Company didn’t want to say anything because they were not sure whether mentioning you would prejudice the case Thranduil seemed to be making against Smaug,” Thorin admitted slowly. “I believe they also didn’t want to give him any extra ammunition against me.” He looked embarrassed. “And I understand that they were not sure that all of Smaug’s people had been rounded up so if they revealed your part, there was a concern that they could hunt you down and harm you. So they kept your part confidential.” He looked guilty. “We had to explain it all in court-Thranduil and Bard were privy to that, though, of course, they already knew most. But Gandalf agreed to keep you a secret.”

 

“The only time it would have been useful to have publicised my adventure-and you lot go all camera-shy,” Bilbo grumbled, though he could understand the reasoning. He really could. And if he hadn’t met the unique circumstances he faced, he would have been deliriously happy at their actions. 

 

“So I had nothing to back up my claims and I was facing a prolonged battle in the courts,” Bilbo sighed, his tone bleak. “And during that, Frodo would remain with the family, unattended and feeling abandoned. They weren’t cruel they just…didn’t have the time to attend to a bereaved and distraught five year old as he needed. I had lost both my parents so I could at least support him through that. And he would suffer and fade more while I tried to get back my home. After one visit, where he was sobbing all the time, I knew what was important: Thorin had told me obliquely over all those evenings talking while one or other of us was on watch. Frodo was all that mattered-and if I had to give up everything for him, then there was no other choice. So I made the deal and allowed them to have my home and my possessions. They declared me legally dead so I couldn’t come back and challenge them at a later date but I was named Frodo’s legal guardian before then and we were allowed to leave the Shire. And when my cousin, Fortinbras, the Thain of the Shire, could have been useful, he was silent. So Frodo and I left-homeless and largely penniless-and tried to make our way in the world.”

 

There was silence when he finished his tale and Gandalf closed his eyes and rubbed his forehead.

 

“I should have been there,” he admitted, his voice filled with guilt.

 

“You were busy here,” Bilbo pointed out. “And why would you help me?” Gandalf looked genuinely winded.

 

“Bilbo Baggins-I am your friend,” he said in an offended voice. “Your mother was a dear friend and I owed you an adventure for her if nothing else. But I grew to admire and like you and if I had known of your troubles, I would have helped.” He sighed. “Had you contacted me, I would have helped you. I am so sorry…”

 

“It was appalling,” Legolas murmured, glancing over to Tauriel.

 

“It’s in defiance of all Eriador Human Rights Conventions of which the Shire is a signatory, current Shire Law which doesn’t permit living persons to be declared dead and by pressurising you to give up your fight by essentially holding the boy ransom, they broke the law and invalidated any deal.” Gandalf announced heatedly.

 

“The documents you signed waiving your rights to your goods and properties are invalid,” Tauriel translated. “The duress they placed you under is essentially blackmail. Now we have the story, we can file an injunction by the end of the week and reverse your declaration of being dead. And then we can fight to regain your properties.”

 

Bilbo sat back and felt a sudden weight lift off his chest that he hadn’t realised was there. They were offering to get back Bag End? His properties? His home?

 

And then he froze. His mother’s garden had been dug up and destroyed and anything that had been left would have been ripped out over the last five years by Lobelia. The properties were his-maybe he could regain them as an income. But Bag End…well, he knew that all his possessions had been thrown out and the place would have been altered beyond recognition. It was a house he had lived in with all the possessions and touches that had made it home taken away. All that was left were in the box…though maybe Lobelia would have kept a few of the more valuable pieces-and his grandmother’s silver spoons which she had always coveted. But was there anything else there? And did he truly want to return to the Shire, to people who abandoned him and who were happy for him to have everything taken from him, who used a grieving orphan as a pawn because he had gone off on an adventure? Did he want to embrace that hypocrisy once more just to regain what could never be truly replaced?

 

But did what he want truly matter? Maybe Frodo wanted to go home? To not be the outsider any more. To have cousins and friends and people who were related to him by blood (even if they hadn’t wanted him a few years ago.)

 

In his heart, Bilbo knew that he would do what his cousin wanted, because Frodo had lost so much, suffered so much over the last five years when he was wholly innocent. At least Bilbo had chosen his adventure. Frodo had chosen none of it-save to be with Bilbo. So whatever he chose-no matter how distasteful-Bilbo would comply.

 

“Please do it,” he said tonelessly. “I am alive. And while it is no longer my home, I’ll be damned if I let Lobelia keep my family home when she stole it from me.” Then he looked up at Thorin, seeing the pain in his blue eyes at the tale. “Thank you.” He looked up, his eyes filled with gratitude. “Even if it is late, this means more than I can express.” Thorin gave a shuddering sigh.

 

“You suffered a terrible price for helping me regain my home and my inheritance,” he said, his expression grave. “My home cost you yours. And I, of all people, can understand the pain of that loss, the frustration and despair in losing all and seeming to have no way to ever regain it. But you are no longer alone in that struggle, my friend. I will see all that and more restored.” He gave a slight smile. “It’s…”

 

“Yeah, I know-the least you can do,” Bilbo said and sighed. “But what happens after that depends on Frodo. If he wants to go home…I will go, Thorin. He’s lost so much. I could never deny him that.”

 

“I know,” the CEO said, his mask back in place. “Of course.” And then he gave a small smile, achingly sad that echoed the confusion in Bilbo’s heart. “But I really wish you would stay.”