Chapter Text
Sorry that this is not a new chapter but this is something I wanted to bring up
So many seem to think Thorin was racist towards elves BEFORE Erebor fell...
But I disagree (and it seems it's just another "Let's make Thorin as evil as possible because we hate him for stuffs he did well SICK!" )
If you look at the scene where Thror (in GOLD SICKNESS, once again, I don't think I can stress this fact ENOUGH ) teases Thranduil and pulls a "Pretty woman" on him by snapping the lid down and Thorin looks CONFUSED at his grandfather
Now he most likely did not say anything because THROR IS THE KING, even as his grandson if he interrupted a political meeting, that might not be taken well by someone who is gold sick...
Not to mention we don't know how much time passed after the incident with the gems when Smaug attacked, it could have been as little as a week or even a few days (now some people do think that Thranduil planned to sack Erebor, but there are horns blown earlier in the scene by the people of Dale, they summoned the elves to come help using the horns (though it is kinda suspicious how they got an entire army dressed up that fast...only to turn around on not only the dwarves, but on the humans that called them there...)
anyway...
Thorin might have been planning to give the necklace to Thranduil later only for Smaug to enter before he managed it (Thorin is shown to be generous at times and does not just rush into things unless it involves his grandfather/fathers honor (the incident with Azog )
Him asking whose house they were going to more or less break into
Him telling Balin to offer Bard more (despite his illness perhaps starting at this point, I think the seeds of that nasty bug started the moment they got in range of the mountain at the end of the second film, hence Thorin's apparent de-characterization from hugging Bilbo to suddenly treating him in a slightly less negative way than before (not to mention the vines scene, yes it was Thorin's idea, but everyone else went along with it with no argument, and Thorin was RIGHT BEHIND Bilbo )
Anyway...
We see Thorin in the SAME outfit as the gems scene (with what looks to be a travel cloak to boot, or at least it is wrapped more around him than in the gems scene, which signals he might have been preparing to head out(he could have been informing Balin of what he was going to do, hence why he was on the battlements to begin with ), which means it is either the same day or Thorin got dressed up to do some politics (and who could that be ...yep Thranduil )
Not to mention Thrandy is not exactly in the right either just huffing off like that (he seems to know that there is a sickness in Thror and anyone with half a brain would have been all "ok, rude, but I'll come back later and talk with this kooks Son or Grandson to get what I want" )
But I guess no one really makes smart choices in these films...
So onto the next chapter then ...I love doing analysis, if anyone wants me to do more just ask, I kinda want to do one on how Thorin had every right to be pissed off and angry at both Thranduil AND Bilbo (since Bilbo DID betray his trust!)
