Chapter Text
When Bilbo was informed about the petitioners waiting outside the gates, he promptly walked to greet them and invited them inside, blatantly ignoring the outraged proclamations of Balin and Glóin, who were serving as gatekeepers.
“Do you not remember what it feels to be met with suspicion in every town you enter, and have to beg for any kind of work that would keep you and your families from starvation?” he asked the Dwarves.“Do they not have families too, who may not survive the winter unless we step in; and are we, sitting on a literal pile of gold, going to refuse our aid, like the Elves have done to earn your scorn for a century?”
The Dwarves eventually relented, telling Bilbo that it was his business to deal with both Dáin and Thorin about this matter and wishing him luck, though Glóin approached the hobbit in a hallway afterwards and slipped a heavy pouch into his coat pocket.
“For the… petitioners,” he said. ”I remember only too well what it was like to decide between spending your last penny on a log for the fire, or on a bowl of soup in a kitchen for the poor.”
Bilbo thanked Glóin profusely and called a special meeting of the entire Council together with their allies who were overseeing the rebuilding of Dale, including the new King of Dale and the ageless King of Mirkwood, who, if rumors were to be believed, barely ever left each other’s company.
Everyone readily agreed, though when they saw Bilbo walk in with the petitioners, their benevolent spirits evaporated in an instant. Everyone seemed to consider it their duty to jump to their feet and start shouting immediately, with Thorin and Dáin leading the throng.
Bilbo had to stand on the table to calm them down. At least he was rewarded by a sight of Thorin staring with his mouth open, the quarrel completely forgotten.
“Messrs. Ghashmog and Durbagund, from Gundabad, at your service and your families’” repeated Bilbo with great emphasis. His visitors stood behind him, clearly weighing their chances of being able to leave the Council chamber alive.
“You let these Orcs walk free inside my realm?” growled Dáin.
“Those filthy beasts inside my fortress?” Thorin seconded, sounding more confused than angry.
“One might say that their very visage smudges the beauty of this chamber,” pompously announced Thranduil.
“Well, what do they want?” Bard, as always, was the only one with an ounce of common sense.
Finally, Bilbo thought as he began the explanation. “These Orcs assumed the command of Gundabad after the Battle, and now have come to beg for peace and offer their help to rebuild Dale, and Erebor, for payment only enough to cover food and shelter for themselves and their families. There are about fifty Orcs in their retinue currently encamped outside, ready to start working as soon as possible, and a few thousand more in Gundabad. They are worried that they will not survive the winter, with most of their hunters and trappers having been recruited into the armies and then promptly killed in the war."
“Why should we care about a handful of Orcs?” sneered Dáin. Let them starve – serves them right for picking fights!”
“Don’t you remember who started the first fight in the Battle of the Five Armies?” retorted Bilbo. “Elves and Dwarves, if I recall correctly! Yet now you are back on friendly terms, despite the former enmity that had been at least as long-standing as your hatred of Orcs.”
“I see no reason to bandy words with an Orcish emissary,” Thorin concluded with an air of finality, walking out of the chamber, which effectively concluded the negotiations.
Bilbo made sure the Orcs left through the kitchens, where Bombur was perfectly happy to share some of his magnificent meals – not all Dwarves were unreasonable at the sight of people dressed in rags and clearly close to starvation, even if they were of a different kindred than themselves – but that left Bilbo no closer to achieving any sort of agreement.
In desperation, the Orc leaders asked for one last meeting, and Bilbo went right back to Thorin, where he mustered all his courage and told the Dwarf exactly what he thought about his ungentlemanly and poorly mannered behavior during the negotiations.
Bilbo stared Thorin down until he agreed to another meeting, to the great surprise of Dwalin’s, who later whispered to Balin that he had never seen Thorin give in so easily. Thorin still requested a two week delay, since he had to continue another set of negotiations, this time with Thranduil, about whether Kíli would be sent out as an emissary to Mirkwood or Tauriel would become one in Erebor. (They had long since given up on the idea of separating those two.) Now Bilbo had to somehow figure out how another meeting would persuade Dáin to change his mind, and what to do with the poor Orcs for the next two weeks.
On all accounts, it was time for desperate measures. After nightfall, Bilbo slipped the Ring on his finger, scuttled out of Erebor and walked straight into the main tent of the small Orcish encampment.
