Chapter Text
* * *
Meanwhile, the world goes on,
Meanwhile, the sun and the clear pebbles of the rain are moving across the landscapes,
Over the prairies and the deep trees, the mountains and the rivers,
Meanwhile, the wild geese, high in the clean blue air are heading home again.
~From Wild Geese by Mary Oliver
* * *
Light turns the view behind Bilbo’s eyelids red and yellow. The familiar indication of morning fills him with a sense of calm. Because if he is waking with the sun, he must be back in Bag End, or back on the road somewhere—anywhere but Erebor. That means the excruciating jumble of memories flooding his mind through the night were all part of a very vivid nightmare.
When his eyes open, he sees a ceiling made of stone.
Panic suffuses him. Bilbo sits up too quickly and suffers greatly for it, his breath coming in short, labored pants. He is dying, surely.
His subsequent moan alerts the attention of a mustachioed dwarrow with kind brown eyes and a fuzzy hat. “Oh, there you are, thank Mahal! Yeh stirred so little in yer sleep, we thought yeh’d gone to—wherever your people go. Y’know, when they cross over.”
Not dead, then. That fact relieves Bilbo far less than it should.
“Name’s Bofur,” the dwarrow says cheerfully, offering Bilbo a glass of something purple and dreadful-smelling.
“Bilbo,” he responds reflexively. The hobbit gulps the liquid down to ease the sensation of his throat closing up. Whatever substance Bofur has given him works wonders. “Please,” he begins, his voice rough but intelligible. “There’s been a grave mistake. Myrtle, my pony, she—”
“Oh,” the dwarrow exhales sadly, removing his hat. “I’m sorry lad, must’ve been a terribly hard decision. Bif brought ’er out to the fieldhouse for ye. It’s only proper.”
“Alive?” Bilbo asks feverishly. He needs to know, needs to stop this before it’s too late.
“Eh… no,” Bofur says uncomfortably, fiddling with the hat in his lap. “I meant her head, lad. To hang on the door in the old girl’s memory.”
“You—what…?” Bilbo chokes out.
“She didn’t suffer, if that’s what worries ye. Well… I cannae say an axe to the head is without pain, but on my brother’s honor, I promise ye he made it quick,” the dwarrow swears soberly.
There is no air. He cannot breathe, and now he really may be dying.
“Whoa, whoa, easy there, easy!” The hobbit’s overwhelming panic spills over into Bofur’s voice as he calls out, “Oin? A little help over here!”
Bilbo doesn’t understand anything they say to him in the following moments; half of the words aren’t even in Westron. But there is a warm, gentle hand rubbing soothing circles into his back. Someone holds a sprig of lavender up to his face and eventually places in his hands to hold onto. It is the familiar scent that allows him to finally take in one deep breath, and then another.
The healer grunts and sets aside his ear trumpet, the small device he has been using to listen to Bilbo’s woes. “I’ve never seen anyone in such a state over a mount.” He shakes his head, murmuring darkly to Bofur, “the lord-prince said he was a bit touched, but this?”
At the mention of his evil, traitorous cousin, Bilbo snaps. “He’s a monster!”
He begins to sob uncontrollably. His entire heart has been scooped out, leaving an empty, gaping hole. He is utterly inconsolable, rocking back and forth until he runs out of tears.
“Leave the lad,” Oin says at last. “He needs his rest.” Bofur hesitates and lingers at his bedside until the healer forcibly shuffles him out of the room, leaving Bilbo alone with his thoughts.
His awareness is heightened, taking in every sensation in the name of self-preservation: the feel of cotton against his skin, the swath of dust settling in before him in sunlit air, the sound of dwarrows talking in hushed tones outside Oin’s door. He jumps at the soft click that signals its opening.
Instead of Bofur or Oin, a different dwarrow enters the healing chambers. “Hello,” he says softly. The timber of his voice is as deep as it is imposing. “I came to see how you fare.”
“Terribly,” Bilbo answers bluntly. His words are still garbled and he looks a mess, no doubt. The evidence of his grief is written plainly in tear stains and puffy red cheeks.
His mystery visitor’s lips settle into a contrite frown. “Your arrival was not well-met, and for that I apologize.”
“You don’t know the half of it.” Bilbo winces and draws his knees up to his chest, cradling his aching head. “I just… I can’t believe she's gone.”
“Who is gone?”
“Myrtle, my pony,” the hobbit answers, his mouth set in a flat line. “By all means, enlighten me—what wicked sport is it to place an animal’s head upon a door, like some macabre holiday decoration!?” He cannot be bothered to keep the venom out of his voice.
The dwarrow pauses and nods. “It is common practice among my people to honor the lives of their most noble steeds by preserving their faces, that their spirit may watch over us and guard the door. Please forgive Horsemaster Bifur; I’m sure he would not have done so if we were aware of existing differences in hobbit customs regarding your dead.”
“Common practice or not, it is horrifying and cruel,” he bites out sharply. To look upon the dead each day until what is left of them rots away and turns to dust… that sounds much more a nightmare than a blessing. Bilbo can’t bear to dwell on that image. He reaches for the lavender on his bedside table and clutches it tightly, attempting to counteract the oncoming fit of distress.
“I am sorry. If it disturbs you so, I will have it removed.” The dwarrow shifts his weight to the other foot, searching for something to say.
“No—I should say goodbye in person. Bury her properly.”
“As you wish.” His eyes linger on Bilbo’s small frame. “Oin is our very best healer; he assures me you will recover before the week is out. I will trouble you no further this morning, but… I hope you feel better soon.”
Bilbo’s hands fall into his lap. “Thank you,” he whispers. He has been so wrapped up in his own thoughts, he never learned the dwarrow’s name.
The silence is stifling. Grief and overwhelm both have Bilbo exhausted yet unable to sleep. He can do little else in his state besides take stock of his surroundings.
Oin’s quarters are tidy and comfortable, if a tad stark. His bed is dressed with clean white sheets while all the others are empty. A pleasant, herbal smell emanates from the jars and poultices on the healer’s table and shelves.
It takes considerable effort, both mental and physical, to crawl to the window in back of his bed and look outside. This room is located fairly low to the ground, on the face of the mountain rather than further inside. Bilbo is exceedingly grateful not to be shut away in total darkness. Most of his view is blocked by what appears to be a giant green toe. The shape of it startles him for a moment, until he realizes this must belong to one of the famous statues that border Erebor’s main facade, a colossal pair of generals. That he missed them completely on his first view of the mountain speaks to the dire state of his illness upon arriving.
Bilbo does fall asleep eventually, napping fitfully on and off long into the afternoon until Bofur returns with sustenance and more medicine. The kindly dwarrow dabs at his chin with a cloth napkin and pats him on the back when he struggles to eat his soup. Bofur babbles about his main line of work—carpentry—as well as his friendship with Oin. Apparently, he is only here by coincidence, extending a personal favor to the healer while his regular assistant is on leave.
The hobbit is charmed by his temporary caretaker’s voice and easy smile. Bofur makes it easy to forget his woes for a little while, at least until the topic of Myrtle is broached once more. The dwarrow apologizes profusely for having upset Bilbo earlier with his careless wording. “You cared for her dearly,” he drawls sympathetically. “I’m sure she was a wonderful friend.”
“She is,” Bilbo whispers, shaking. “She was. She belonged to my father.” The knowledge that he will never again hear that voice haunts his waking hours. “Now I have nothing left of him.”
The friendly dwarrow peers at him, his mustache twitching slightly. “That cannae be true.” He pulls from Oin’s table a looking glass and presses it into Bilbo’s hands. “Yer eyes, yer hair maybe? Something of ’im in the jaw? Not his beard, I imagine,” he chuckles. “Is it true ye hobbits can’t grow none at all? Not even a wee bit o’ scruff?”
Yes, he certainly does have his father’s honey curls, his cleft chin, his button nose. His lips and eyes and pointed ears are all his mother. “No, no beards, except on Stoors.” Bilbo cracks a tentative smile. “I see your meaning; they live on in me.” He thanks his new friend softly and sets the mirror aside.
Bofur is right, of course. If there is any proof to be had that his wonderful parents had walked this earth, it is Bilbo himself. They are with him still, in this one momentous way, and they always will be. The heartwarming sentiment does not fix anything that has happened to Bilbo during this rotten adventure, but he takes far more comfort in the stranger’s words than expected.
There is a knock at the door, and in comes the mysterious dwarrow from earlier this morning. Bilbo’s improved state enables him to observe much more about him this time around. Long, raven hair flows loosely save for a few simple braids; it is flecked with elegant strands of silver that hints at the dwarrow’s age. His beard is cropped relatively short, and it suits his handsome face and prominent nose. The tunic he wears is elegant yet simple, the cloth from which it is cut a rich shade of midnight blue. The blue of his eyes is a different shade altogether, the shade of the lake and the sky and the sea all in one, so deep one could drown in them.
A twinge of pink sets into Bilbo’s cheeks as it occurs to him that he has all but yelled at the man, who has done him no wrong. Bungo Baggins would be rolling in his grave on account of his son’s lack of manners. “Hullo again! I’m terribly sorry about earlier,” he ekes out, voice cracking a little but stronger than before.
“The fault is mine; I caught you in a bad way. I should have known better than to press.” His silky mane shakes with his head, effortlessly graceful as a raven in flight, and Bilbo’s eyes follow the movement.
The hobbit’s flush deepens; he will not allow himself to silently wax poetic about this stranger. “I’m Bilbo,” he says as he remembers himself. “And you are?”
The blue-eyed dwarrow hesitates. “Thorin.” He and Bofur both stare expectantly at Bilbo as if the name should mean something to him.
“Thorin.” He tests the dwarvish name on his tongue, but it doesn’t ring any bells. “Well, it’s lovely to meet you. Do you work for Oin too?” he asks.
A sly grin slowly works its way onto Thorin’s lips; it has an immediate and astonishing effect on the pit of Bilbo’s stomach. Oh dear. Must be the lingering sickness on his brain. “I serve all of Erebor.”
Bilbo takes that to mean he is a steward of some kind, not a personal servant to any particular dwarrow. The position sounds like a daunting one. “Then you must be terribly busy. I’m honored that you’ve taken the time to check in on me. Twice now.”
For some reason, Bofur is poorly concealing a grin in his coat sleeve. His shoulders shake with silent mirth. If Thorin’s stern look is meant to quell him, it fails spectacularly; if anything, the woodcarver laughs even harder.
“It’s not every day that two hobbits wander into my city,” Thorin says wryly. “As for your kinsman—Fili is quite taken with him. I dare say the feeling is mutual.” The tone of his voice suggests a massive understatement.
Bilbo freezes the moment he realizes that Thorin is talking about Lotho. Never in his wildest dreams had he imagined the lad to be capable of such treachery. Snark and hurtful barbs, certainly, but violence? Murder?
All pretenses of trust or kinship lay in broken pieces. He has no idea what to expect. Would Lotho go so far as to make him share in Myrtle’s fate?
The hobbit’s breaths come in shallow and short. His knuckles fly up to clench protectively in front of his neck, catching his caretaker’s attention. “Is yer throat hurting again? I’ll fetch some hot tea, that should do the trick.” Quick as a wink, Bofur runs off, leaving him in this strange limbo with Thorin.
“Has he—” It takes all of his courage to utter the traitor’s name aloud. “—has Lotho mentioned me?” Bilbo hazards, wheezing a bit. “I need to speak with him. Please.” His voice is tight and fraught with fear and distrust.
Thorin’s answering tone is apologetic. “That will be difficult at the moment. He and Fili are getting acquainted; they have much to discuss before the wedding. I’m afraid they will both be detained for some time.”
“Fili? Er, right. The prince.”
“Yes, Fili is the eldest, and no less of a rascal,” the dwarrow explains fondly. “He and Lotho are touring the forge today—with a chaperone,” he adds emphatically. “Durin’s beard, those two have no sense of propriety.” Thorin winces as though the topic at hand is either very painful or embarrassing, or both. “I’m afraid I don’t understand the youth of today.”
Bilbo blinks. Lotho... and the Prince?
It was his cousin who had written the letter and fawned over the prince’s portrait from the beginning. He had understood the dwarrow’s double-entendres and inappropriate gift right away. Not to mention his reaction to the second letter.
Of course—Lotho had wanted Fili all this time. How could Bilbo have been so blind!? He had told Lotho, in so many words, to marry the prince. Well now he feels like a massive idiot. And his cousin is posing as the Thain’s selected ambassador, to be the prince’s consort.
Bofur returns and he is pushing a steaming mug of chamomile into Bilbo’s hands. The hobbit takes a sip with stiff, jerky movements, a thousand questions plaguing him all the while. The soothing scent calms him somewhat and makes room in his buzzing brain to begin weaving together threads of logic bit by bit.
If Lotho wanted him dead, he would have had Bilbo executed already, not treated by Erebor’s healer. But that doesn’t mean he bears his cousin no further ill will.
Bilbo has gained but one small part of the answers he seeks, but it isn’t nearly enough. Why—why would he kill Myrtle? What does it all mean? He cannot make heads or tails of it.
“What will happen to me now?” he whispers.
“Don’t worry, ye won’t be out of a job!” Bofur assures him, and Bilbo wants to laugh hysterically because, yes, that’s what he was worried about. “Ye’ll be workin’ with me,” he announces, his face the definition of delight.
Thorin hums in confirmation, folding his arms. They look very strong for the life of a valet, and Bilbo wonders if they have known the strain of the forge, or even battle. Then again, perhaps dwarrows are just built that way.
“Your kinsman no longer has need of your services,” he tells the hobbit apologetically. “He has expressed a preference for all-dwarrow attendants; I do believe he means to immerse himself in Khuzdul to learn our language faster.” Bilbo does not feel a twinge of jealousy at the impressed tone in Thorin’s voice, because that would be ridiculous and completely unfounded. “Oin has advised only light duties, since you are still on the mend. Once you are back up on your feet, Bofur will show you around to survey the arable land at our disposal. He and Bifur have plenty of space to put you up—if that is amenable to you.”
“Right,” Bilbo says slowly. That was originally supposed to be his job here, after all: overseeing Erebor’s farming project.
“If you wish to return to the Shire, that is understandable,” Thorin says gently. “But such a long return journey will last long into the cold months. You are welcome to remain here in Erebor’s employment until Spring, and we will pay handsomely for your trouble. I underestimated the time it would take for Fili’s intended to arrive; with all the wedding preparations and alliance arrangements, he will have little time to address both matters of state and agriculture in person before the end of the growing season.”
“We could reeeally use the extra help,” Bofur adds, hitting Bilbo with his most winsome smile.
Bilbo fists at the hem of his sheets. He has hit an inner crossroads. Part of him clambers to object to being made a servant. He could have done with it now; if he tells them what really transpired, there is a small chance they will believe him. Perhaps he might even get an audience with the royal family to set Lotho straight. He should march up to the palace and demand to give that slimy maggot a piece of his mind!
Or... He can let it lay.
Lotho’s actions, despicable as they are, have given Bilbo an out. If he stays silent, he will no longer be bound in marriage to a stranger. As long as someone upholds the alliance to ensure the Shire’s safety, he will have done his duty.
“Alright,” he finds himself saying. Let that abominable ninnyhammer have his fancy wedding and royal status and precious jewels; Bilbo could hardly care less. But Myrtle…
He will never forgive his cousin, nor call him kin, not after what he did to her. Lotho will pay for this. By Aüle, he will pay.
Bofur cheers and flails so enthusiastically, he nearly knocks Bilbo off the bed, and Thorin’s quiet smile says that he is equally pleased. “It is settled then.” He makes his bid to leave so that Bilbo may rest. Bilbo feels inexplicably sad to see the enigmatic dwarrow go, and sadder still when Bofur follows him.
“Wait!” Bilbo objects, reaching out instinctively, then pulls back with an embarrassed flush. “Will I see you again?”
Thorin pauses halfway to the door. He dips his head decisively and leaves from whence he came. Bofur chuckles and tells him not to fret; he will be back in the morning.
Bilbo sighs as the door shuts behind them both; the presence of potential friends had given his heavy heart a brief respite. Thankfully, the physical toll of illness and sorrow chooses this moment to hit him again, letting him sink into a night of much-needed rest.
Tonight, he mourns for Myrtle. Tomorrow will dawn a new chapter in his never-ending journey.
* * *
What was supposed to be a formal tour of Erebor’s outermost grounds has turned into story time, and Bilbo isn’t upset about it in the slightest; now that panic is no longer consuming him every other second, he is quite happy for the company.
Bofur makes for an exceedingly patient tour guide, letting Bilbo lean on his arm for support and stopping whenever he needs to rest. After a few days’ recovery he still feels weak, but fresh air and time outside do him a world of good.
Looking at the grand, bustling kingdom of Erebor from the outside, it is difficult to tell that a dragon had laid waste to this very land not fifty years past. The hordes of gold and dragon dung have long-since been cleared out, the mountain’s wealth dispersed to break the tainted curse of dragon-sickness. There are dwellings etched into the mountainside, old and new, and its halls and markets and forges teem with life.
Bilbo had intentionally avoided discussing the dwarven kingdom at length with his hosts during the trip here. It was easy to deflect with his own questions about elven culture. Still, watered down versions of the grand tale had trickled their way to Bilbo’s ears over time. It was another thing altogether to hear the story from someone who had been there. Four years ago, Bofur had joined the king’s campaign to retake the Lonely Mountain. As he spoke, Bilbo found himself blown away, goggling at the dwarrow’s story like a child listening to one of Gandalf’s tales.
Long ago, their ancestors were driven from their home in Khazad-dûm by an accursed balrog. But dwarrows are a strong and steadfast people; they forged ahead to the north and created a marvelous city in the mountain, the likes of which no one in Middle Earth had ever seen. They traded with men and elves both, and soon grew to be the envy of all seven dwarven kingdoms.
Durin’s folk had already suffered much, and they would continue to do so. The discovery of a cursed gem in the heart of the mountain garnered the attention of Smaug, the fearsome fire drake, who rained fire on Erebor and Esgaroth both.
Driven from their home, the men retreated to Laketown, while the dwarrows of Erebor were left to roam and perish at the hands of Smaug or be picked off by goblins in the harsh wilderness. Their kin would have surely perished had it not been for the elven king’s intervention. Thranduil agreed to an alliance between their two kingdoms, but only to shelter and feed their people within the safety of the Greenwood. He refused to sacrifice a single soldier to their scaly cause.
The dwarrows’ then-king raged against him furiously, demanding an army to charge and retake the mountain, while his son cared only for their people’s safety. Try as he might, he could not dissuade his father from following through on his half-baked attempt to retake Khazad-dûm in the south, leading to his death at the hand of the orc chief Azog.
For those of Durin’s folk who remained, there was only so much that the forest could provide; over the years, many of their people took refuge in other dwarven cities. Some remained loyal to their true king, but they had hardly the strength or numbers to take on Smaug.
One small group of brave dwarrows—comrades and friends from all walks of life, who numbered but a mere thirteen—vowed to follow their king. They allied with the men of Laketown, who had grown sick and tired of suffering at the hand of their greedy Master, and led one final assault against Smaug on the last light of Durin’s Day, defeating him with courage and bravery and luck. And no small amount of magic, either.
Bofur’s wild tale is peppered with Bilbo’s unwavering questions and dramatic reactions at the appropriate moments. He ends the tale with a little flourish and a bow, and Bilbo reciprocates with hearty applause.
Bilbo learns more about Bofur himself as well. The dwarrow is as charming as they come; he seems to be one of those people who worms their way into others’ hearts without even trying. Bofur grew up as a humble toy-maker in the Blue Mountains. He and his brothers lived in poverty before emigrating to the Greenwood and, eventually, playing a key role in Erebor’s rebirth.
For his contribution to the kingdom, shouldn’t he be filthy rich now? Bilbo ponders this, confused by his simple clothing and modest lodgings. Bofur laughs and explains the conundrum of the Arkenstone’s curse: the more gold the dwarrows take, the harder they suffer. In order to end the curse, the king had to return the mountain’s heart and divest Erebor of its treasures. The more he gave away, the more avarice lessened its grip on their kin.
It was a hard-won lesson, Bofur explains; he suspects that the only reason their king was able to overcome such blinding greed was for the sake of his two young nephews. Today, dwarrows, humans, and elves alike take fair shares of the profit. Now, it seems, hobbits too will join their fold.
Of course, that doesn’t mean Erebor has no wealth to be seen, Bofur tells him cheekily. The king could have easily set him and Bifur up with lofty quarters in the palace, but he and his brother (who Bilbo discovers is actually his cousin. Good to know that dwarves have just as complicated familial relations as do hobbits) prefer the wide open swath of land after living for so long in a forest. Other dwarrows think them mad and insist that they’ll lose their stone-sense, but neither of them care. Their cozy cabin on the hill is a far cry grander than their humble origins. And, well, free meals for life and all the fine lumber that Bofur could ever want for carving certainly don’t hurt.
Once Oin approves his discharge from the hospital wing, Bofur and Bifur invite him into their home. Their cabin smells of fresh pine and has a well-loved, lived-in vibe. Bilbo can tell which corner is Bofur’s right away; the drafting table covered in wood shavings is a dead giveaway. Bifur’s is tidier simply because he owns less things: a few books here, a lantern there, and a set of meticulously well-kept brushes and combs. There is also a simple stove and a gorgeous wooden dining table just big enough for four, along with all the odds and ends to meet basic kitchen needs.
Both dwarrows swell with pride for the small but happy space they share. Bifur gestures to a small, empty bed in the remaining corner and then sets a stack of clean linens on the mattress.
“That there’s yours,” Bofur says, “Plenty o’ room to put yer things. I reckon it ain’t much compared to a fancy hobbit hole, but it’s home!”
A lump forms in Bilbo’s throat at that last word. He has thought of the Shire many times over the past hours. Despite his tentative agreement to help Thorin and Bofur, the temptation to go home is still strong. They have made it clear that he is no slave; he is free to leave at any time. Perhaps they would even lend him enough supplies to brave the wilderness alone.
And if he succeeds—to what end? Supposing he does make it, at least he will be able to see Drogo and Primula’s first child come into the world. But after that, after a few happy reunions, what will he do then? Bilbo could tell the Sackville-Bagginses in person what a miserable, nasty, traitorous cur their son has turned out to be, but it wouldn’t matter; they have the deed to Bag End. Lobelia will fight tooth and nail to keep it. Even if Bilbo somehow won it back somehow, it would be an empty vessel devoid of all of his worldly possessions. They lay desecrated somewhere in the Misty Mountains. Worse still, he is without his mother’s handkerchief and without Myrtle—valar, the pain still flickers through him every time the voice in his head speaks her name.
“I don’t have a home,” it occurs to Bilbo. Not anymore. “...I don’t have anything.”
Bofur and Bifur exchange a look of understanding. They gather the hobbit into a comforting group hug and assure him that they will do all they can to help. Since they have the king’s ear, they might even be able to arrange an upfront allowance for a bit of his pay, that way he may buy a few things to make this little corner his own.
Their fast and furious kindness shakes Bilbo to the core. These dwarrows had known squalor for most of their lives, yet they would share everything they have with him, a total stranger? Humility replaces Bilbo’s moping and he resolves to be a properly-gracious roommate. He will strive to repay them by helping out as much as possible to help run the place.
Besides, he is staying through the next two seasons; he can worry about repairing and refilling Bag End when he crosses that bridge next Spring. Perhaps he can write to Gandalf and ask for help recovering some of the items he had lost in the mountains. And if not, the lack of furniture will make it easier to make large-scale renovations to his smial. Maybe he’ll add a larger dining room, go out and about and make more friends, invite people over for gatherings. Yes, a warmer, fuller house like this one sounds ideal.
That beautiful dream of normalcy carries him through the next few days and into full recovery. He continues to survey the city and its surrounding lands with Bofur. Now that Bilbo knows where to look, he can pick out some of the hallmarks of the Lonely Mountain’s ruin: some scaffolding where a few of the larger statues are still being repaired, other new pieces being slowly erected. Scorch marks that could not be scrubbed away or were purposely preserved as a reminder of Erebor’s sordid past.
For further evidence of Smaug’s desolation, one need only look out to the barren fields. What few trees live are young, and none that he sees can yet bear fruit. The remainder consists mostly of tall grasses and brush.
“So where are the planting beds?” he asks Bofur on his third day out.
The dwarrow’s wavy braids bob up and down as he shrugs. “Wherever yeh think we should put them?”
These will be Erebor’s very first farmlands, Bilbo learns; in the time before its reckoning, the Men of Esgaroth took care of all planting. Then, during their exile, Durin’s folk simply traded their wares for imported goods and hunted the rest, thus their people are wholly unfamiliar with the practice of growing food.
For now, their neighbor Men sow just enough crops to feed both cities with careful rationing. However, with both populations growing larger by the day, their yield is highly unsustainable. There is also a shortage of wild game in the surrounding mountains and the forest beyond Thranduil’s territory, thanks to years of poaching by dragon and goblin alike. Bofur says their king fears for the winters to come.
“The lord-prince gave us a list of supplies but not much else. I s’pose his royal highness won’t have time to come out an’ do the dirty work himself with the alliance an’ all.” Bofur’s nose wrinkles in distaste as he examines the scroll in question. “Too many vegetables.”
Bilbo’s heart climbs into his throat at the sight of that familiar, meticulous script. He knew to whom Bofur referred, of course, but it doesn’t stop the physical evidence of Lotho’s presence here from smacking him in the figurative face. He has still seen neither hair nor hide of his cousin, and he isn’t sure he wants to.
“Is he helping?” he prods carefully. “With the alliance, I mean?”
“I dunno. Ye’ll have to ask Thorin for the details,” Bofur answers. “All’s I heard is that the king and the princes are all in, but the lord-prince has to get Dain and the other nobles on his side. He’s got one heck of a job convincin’ the them that yer Shire is worth protectin.’”
Bilbo swallows. For their people’s sake, he hopes that the younger hobbit is taking the political part of this farce seriously.
In terms of actual planting, Bilbo certainly has his work cut out for him. Thankfully, he is far from alone in this massive project; Bofur has rounded up a team of strong dwarrows for Bilbo to oversee, delegating them to the tasks of tilling and planting. He is surprised to be given so much leeway, but, as Bofur explains, his very presence on the field is a boost to their helpers’ morale. Apparently, the dwarrows’ little knowledge of hobbits’ planting skills has taken on a massively-exaggerated lens. True enough, they are people of the earth, but in the eyes of his field hands, Bilbo’s talent for farming might as well be the stuff of legends. He advises them to manage expectations, for no one can develop an entire orchard in a day!
His first inkling is to test the soil in different areas and figure out which supplies they need. At a cursory glance, Bilbo feels outraged by the lack of diversity in vegetables and spices on Lotho’s list, and a few of the things he has included might not fare so well in the Lonely Mountain’s climate. Upon further inspection, he must admit that his cousin’s list is adequately thought out, for the short-term. It relies heavily on crops that will grow quickly and will last through the earliest of winter’s chill, as well as staples that Erebor’s people will willingly eat—potatoes, carrots, fruit—while also introducing a few new things. Bilbo is learning, as he takes meals with his roommates, that they are not used to greens in the slightest.
It is already late summer, so Bilbo focuses his time on planning layouts for fields and storage structures as efficiently as possible. He will also have his recruits plant the strongest starts for new orchards and other crops that will take longer than the current growing season to cultivate. They start by outlining the appropriate field spaces and sending his amended supply list to the royal court for approval. He has added some crops that Lotho had never considered and struck a few of the original ideas; his additions will have myriad uses for both Erebor’s kitchens and Oin as well, for low upfront cost.
The next step is to reap the tall grasses and till the soil. Not one to waste viable resources, Bilbo suggests that the drying plants be boiled and processed into paper. It will make for more brittle stock than leaf-based parchment, but it is usable nonetheless. Bofur is mightily impressed by his ingenuity and says that a close friend of his will know just what to do with it.
For the first time in a long time, Bilbo feels the kind of pleasure that only comes from consistent hard work. It leaves him a little achy but altogether more satisfied with himself than the bits of idle gardening he had settled for doing in Bag End—and even then, Hamfast had done most of the heavy lifting. Idle hands do not a happy hobbit make. His duties provide a welcome distraction; he is still reeling over the loss of Myrtle, but he is also beginning to cope with the topsy-turvy mess of chaos that life has thrown at him.
The three of them resume work until Bofur calls time. Bifur tells him the story of his infamous injury—nasty business with a few stray orcs—in a combination of Khuzul and Iglishmêk. Sadly, Bilbo understands neither, forcing Bofur to translate until he can get a better grasp on the hand signals.
Bifur rubs the back of his head and signs something to his cousin.
“He says: '‘m sorry about your pony. Do you want to see her?’ ” Bofur translates. He has to catch Bilbo in a dead faint, only just preventing him from hitting the ground. Everyone takes that as a resounding ‘no’ and the subject is not brought up again. A wise decision.
It doesn’t stop the images, twisted and harrowing, from invading his dreams that night: Lotho, eyes bright yellow and slitted like a warg, standing over Myrtle with the headsman's axe. Her mangled corpse, rotting and frozen in a pose of agony. The worst is when she speaks, crying out for Bilbo to save her.
By the end of Bilbo’s first week in their shared home, he is utterly exhausted. He has disturbed his poor roommates more times than he can count; thank Yavanna that Bofur is such a sound sleeper.
This time, Bilbo is sure they’ll kick him out, and he’ll have to to sleep on the ground outside. But Bofur snores and falls back asleep in seconds, while Bifur only stares at Bilbo thoughtfully.
Bilbo whimpers, slipping out of his bed and onto the floor. “I’m sorry,” he moans, shaking, trying to make the torturous images disappear. “I’m sorry, I’m sorry.”
The dwarrow gets up from his bed and lights a candle. He grabs parchment and a quill from his bookshelf and comes over to Bilbo’s corner, plopping down beside him. He places the candleholder between them and faces Bilbo. Don’t worry about Bo, he sleeps like the dead, Bifur writes with a soft snort.
He signs a few words in Iglishmêk and then motions for Bilbo to imitate them. “‘Dream,’” Bilbo murmurs, at the sight of the first word. Bifur repeats the signs. “‘Not,’ that’s the second one.” Bifur nods enthusiastically. Try as he might, he does not remember the third, so Bifur writes it down for him: Real.
“‘Dream not real.’ Dreams aren’t real,” Bilbo repeats, keeping his voice low. The hobbit sighs. “I know they’re not, but… They feel as solid as you or me. I can’t get her out of my head.”
Bifur writes and asks him to concentrate on things that are real. They go through many of the signs that Bilbo does know: sky, sun, moon, stars, grass, earth, trees, flowers. They practice some of the phrases Bifur taught him yesterday. He is starting to get the hang of very basic grammar. Then Bifur adds new words for Bilbo to practice, and by the time he stops, Bilbo has forgotten all about his nightmare.
“Fill your head with pleasant things before bed, and they will fill your dreams," Bifur signs at last, and Bilbo understands the gist of it, if not the entire sentence. They are both yawning, eyelids drooping, and they fall asleep against the side of Bilbo’s bed. Not the most comfortable position, but Bilbo still sleeps better than he has in days.
Bofur wakes them in the morning, lamenting for their poor, abused backs. “Can’ we ask Oin to give ’im one o’ those sleeping tonics?”
“Not good for the long-term,” Bifur counters. Bilbo excitedly repeats his signs, along with most of the ones they practiced last night. He and Bifur can’t have entire conversations without writing yet, but it’s coming along. He remembers the words so much better after learning them right before bed.
“Well, I’ll be darned,” Bofur whistles, grinning.
Bifur teaches him a few more signs over breakfast. Bilbo tries to remember them while he is working. He also discovers that pushing himself in the field helps; a sufficiently tired body wins him dreamless sleep.
Within a mere fortnight, they accomplish far more than Bilbo had originally projected. Bofur tells him that the king will be chuffed indeed when he arrives to assess their progress, and that he should be proud. He also adds in an unnecessary comment about hobbits having far greater constitution than their appearances suggest, to which Bilbo rolls his eyes.
Thorin has yet to make an appearance to their humble abode. A fond grin appears on Bofur’s face when the hobbit plucks up the courage to ask after him. Bilbo learns that Thorin is a close friend of the cousins Ur. He visits when he can, popping in for impromptu musical jam sessions and conversation from time to time. “I expect he’ll be by veeery soon,” he drawls. “Ready my flute, Bif!”
The taller dwarrow flips him a rude gesture, and Bilbo doesn’t need to speak fluent Iglishmêk to know he means: “Get it yourself.” Bofur cackles while Bilbo imagines what Bifur’s voice must have sounded like in Westron: deep, gruff, and warm like unfiltered honey.
When stretches of days pass without a word from Thorin, Bilbo sulks, and Bofur reminds him with amusement that the raven-haired dwarrow is very busy. That he devotes time to visit them at all, Bofur insists, is a very remarkable thing indeed.
To Bilbo’s delight, he arrives at their door the very next morning. “Shall we tour the fields, Master…?”
“Baggins. But just Bilbo is fine,” he insists, flushing slightly.
“Baggins,” Thorin echoes. “The same as Lotho’s, is it not? A common surname amongst your people, I presume.”
Bilbo could smack himself on the forehead for having let slip such an important detail, and it looks as though Thorin has noticed. “We’re—distantly related.”
Thorin’s regal brows climb his forehead, thick and arched. “He never mentioned you. I find it odd that he does not visit his own kin.”
Alarm bells ring in Bilbo’s ears. “That’s perfectly alright! I’m sure he’s far too busy with—things,” he insists in a rush. “We’re not close anyway. Not at all,” he finishes flatly, hoping against hope that Thorin will drop the subject.
No such luck. “You are markedly older than Fili’s intended. How came you into his service?”
Funny story, that. Bilbo waves it off with a muttered half-truth, some excuse about favors owed and their family feud. By the affirmative tone of his grunt, Thorin accepts his explanation for now.
Bofur’s cheerful whistling pivots them back to their forgotten purpose. The three of them roam across the fields; Bilbo and Bofur explain their plans and Thorin takes down detailed notes.
When they have finished the overview, Thorin tarries a while. “You have done exceedingly well, Bilbo. Are all hobbits so educated in the ways of planting?”
At this, Bilbo lets out a huff of laughter. “You’d think so, wouldn’t you? There are so many of us to feed after all.” Being a dabbler of many random talents, Bilbo has little experience in feeling like an expert in anything, and it makes his head swell with a healthy dose of pride. He goes on to elaborate the different specialities that different families in the Shire have taken on: the Greenfields produce unparalleled root crops, and a connoisseur of mushrooms need look no farther than Farmer Maggot’s field in Eastfarthing. But no one’s orchards could compare to Great Uncle Ponto’s. To this day, their apples remain the envy of all hobbits, the secrets of success guarded well by Rosa and Polo both.
Thorin smiles at Bilbo’s impassioned monologue and shares a similar memory. “I taught my sister-sons to forge. The eldest took to it right away, but his brother never did. He prefers the hunt, and weapons of elvish make.”
The hobbit chuckles at his companion’s dismay. “Is that what you do—make weapons? I thought you were a valet of some sort.”
“...Among other things.”
Bofur snickers from his spot by the newly-seeded cabbage patch and Thorin shoots him a dark look.
Before he takes his leave, Thorin reiterates his promise to visit his friends again soon—next time with music. Bifur threatens that he had better keep his word, or else. Something soft and sweet flutters in Bilbo’s chest as he watches Thoin disappear into the mountain.
Since they have nothing left to do until the afternoon, Bofur asks Bilbo if he would like to go with him to visit the market. “I’d love to!” Bilbo’s face lights up. The crown has kindly granted his request for an advance—much more readily than Bilbo had expected. His nearly-empty corner could use some love, and he is curious to see what a dwarven open air market looks like.
They comprise more jewelry than any practical person could ever use, as it turns out. That, along with weapons and tools and various metal goods that shine in all sorts of shapes and finishes—a feast for the eyes if ever Bilbo saw. But for the most part, the main stalls contain goods that the hobbit cannot afford, and neither will they make for useful pieces in his small, shared space.
There are a few craftsman who share in Bofur’s trade, having picked it up from their time in the Greenwood. The only thing that stands out to him is a gorgeous mahogany cheeseboard, but Bofur dissuades him from buying it; he’ll make Bilbo a far superior version if he really wants one.
Empty-handed, Bilbo backtracks through the metalworkers’ wares in search of simpler goods—journals, quills, and books. He stops by a sheet metal stand to let a passing merchant roll by with his cart. There are more buyers around here than the other stands and it doesn’t take long for him to see why.
Not three feet away from him stands the Crown Prince of Erebor. The shopkeeper hands him a parcel wrapped in paper, for which he thanks her. And then, because of course Bilbo’s luck would fail him now, Fili turns to look straight at him.
Bilbo would gladly melt into the ground if it meant escaping the prince’s curious gaze. What a stupid idea it had been to come here. Of all the people he could encounter, he can only think of one worse candidate.
Bofur is his savior; he steps in to chat with the prince. Bilbo doesn’t stick around to hear whatever they are saying, turning tail for the safety of the cabin.
His roommate catches up to him eventually, bewildered by his disappearance. “Why’d yeh do that? I was going to introduce you!”
Bilbo pants to catch his breath. “I—” He cannot think of a single thing to say that won’t give him away, so... “I thought I saw a goblin,” he deadpans.
Bofur’s face contorts from confusion to pure mirth. “He’s not that ugly.” His laugh is long and loud. “Ye’r stark-raving mad, you are!” The woodcarver assures him that Fili is a good lad and a personal friend. How many people does this dwarrow know ?
“They’re just people like you an’ me,” Bofur points out, and Bilbo lets him assume that the fit of nerves had to do with royal status alone. They leave empty-handed and continue to go about their routine as usual.
Days melt away into weeks, and Bilbo busies himself with his work. He has come to enjoy the scenic beauty of Erebor and takes solace in his simple daily pleasures. When he isn’t busy running around planning to feed an entire kingdom, Bilbo continues Iglishmêk lessons with Bifur, to the point where they can have longer and more complex conversations. The horsemaster proves to be quite hilarious once Bilbo begins to understand his wisecrack humor.
Lodging with roommates proves to be an unexpected boon so late in Bilbo’s bachelor life. The three of them fall into a companionable routine, and a few pet peeves here and there are more than made up for by their companionship. Although, Bilbo could certainly do without the running joke that he is barmy. Nothing he says or does manages to successfully quell this notion, so eventually he gives up and starts to play along. After all, there are far worse things than being Mad Baggins.
Bifur is careful to avoid the topic of Myrtle. Although his nightmares have died down somewhat in the coming weeks, it is hard to know exactly what might trigger another for Bilbo. Despite the fact that Bilbo does not blame him for Myrtle’s death, their friendship carries the shadow of latent guilt. Bifur’s occupation is a constant reminder of his loss. He hates walking on eggshells, and he knows it is completely infeasible and unfair to expect Bifur never to mention his work. Yet he cannot ease Bifur’s mind completely without explaining Lotho’s betrayal, and that is a risk Bilbo is unwilling to take.
A little over a month after Midsummer, Bofur presents a more effective solution to the hobbit’s nightmares. He gifts to Bilbo a handsome cuckoo clock (so that’s what he was hiding under the tarp out back!). Bilbo lavishes him with praise for his work and kisses his temple in thanks for the thoughtful gift. Pink-cheeked and bashful, the artist helps hang it up on the wall behind Bilbo’s bed.
Meanwhile, Bifur explains that the crystals set into the clock are meant to help ward off bad dreams. He has to spell out a few of the stone names that Bilbo does not yet understand in Iglishmêk, and Bilbo knows whose brilliant idea this really was.
“Thank you both,” he says and signs, “for everything.” He pours all of the words he cannot say into one great big hug. Bifur seems to understand, and a bit of that underlying hurt between them bleeds away.
His friends are eager for Bilbo to test out the clock charms this evening. But first, it is time to celebrate their latest successes. Bofur even manages to rope in Thorin for the occasion—the more, the merrier!
Bilbo serves mead and homemade shortcake, recieving compliments all around—apparently, Erebor’s head chef himself would approve of this dessert. The hobbit quietly sips at his mead, warm and honeyed, soaking up to the sound of Thorin’s voice.
He has only been able to see the enigmatic dwarrow a handful of times since arriving here in Erebor, but each and every time, he learns something new: another piece of the evolving puzzle. Thorin is incredibly knowledgeable about the goings-on of Erebor, including its history and political affairs. Bilbo ascertains that he tends to nobles of high rank, though the dwarrow never answers which ones directly.
Thorin absoultely adores his family, even though his nephews drive him mad and his sister could make the bravest of dwarrows shake in their boots. Bilbo leans forward slightly, hanging onto every word, until Bifur smirks and signs for him to stop drooling.
Bofur rattles off the budding farm’s newest accomplishments and relays Bifur’s progress outfitting the stables. Thorin describes a frustrating day at court while his friends listen and offer advice where appropriate. Afterwards, all of them listen intently to Bilbo’s working theory that Smaug’s dragonfire has acted as a catalyst to rejuvenate the soil. It has to be, otherwise the potatoes would not be doing nearly as well.
“He’s a miracle worker, this one,” Bofur chuckles, looping a friendly arm around Bilbo. The hobbit flushes and vehemently denies his overstated praise.
Thorin’s eyes narrow ever-so-slightly, moving to a point over Bilbo’s shoulder. “A hobbit of many talents,” he murmurs in agreement.
Gracious—they’ve been talking for so long, there is precious little time to squeeze in a quick tune. Bifur has barely finished his clarinet solo before is Thorin making a mad dash back to Erebor proper. The dwarrow cousins shout something after him in Khuzdul; their tone sounds a little harsh (then again, every word in the dwarven language sounds as such to Bilbo), but they are wearing matching smiles all the same.
“I’m knackered!” Bofur declares. Bilbo agrees, and for once he allows them to put off the washing. He certainly feels tired enough to sleep well.
Dear Yavanna, he hopes that the clock will work, that tonight’s sleep will be dreamless. Bilbo fidgets in his bed, pulling the covers tight around himself. He tosses and turns, until he remembers what Bifur said the other day, when their best tiller broke: Always have a back-up plan.
That’s right; he can do this. He can cope. If magic charms should fail to ease his sleep, Bilbo will look up and name the stones, practicing the hand signals that he remembers for them. This way, he can soothe himself to sleep without waking anyone.
Selenite. Quartz. Danburite. Moonstone… Amethyst…
Strange. Not so very long ago, Erebor and all its many minerals had embodied Bilbo’s greatest fears. Yet, in both his dreams and waking hours, this land of stone has slowly become his sacred refuge.
Here, a thousand miles from home, it feels as if time has slowed to a halt. It pulls Bilbo full-force into the present, battering against his will. Ever since he arrived, he has been forced to confront change with each and every moment. Thus, he is unable to escape into the comforting cloak of time’s ephemeral passage.
Everything prior to now will be known to him as ‘before’ the Lonely Mountain; there is no going back to the way things used to be. Though the thought is a daunting one, it is not, in fact, a bad thing.
Whatever comes next, Bilbo does not know. He remembers nothing from this night.
* * *
One sunny afternoon, when Bilbo returns to the cabin, he is stunned to find a freshly-picked bouquet of flowers on his bed. White calla lilies, a bit late in the season. They are beginning to wilt.
He remembers seeing some of them grow by the stream and asks Bifur offhandedly if he picked them, to which the dwarrow answers with a wrinkle of his nose. No, he can see neither Bifur nor Bofur as the flower-loving type, and besides, whoever sent them left them on Bilbo’s bed specifically. But the list of people he knows here is a small one.
An image of Thorin proffering the freshly-picked bouquet flashes through his mind. Bilbo is disquieted by his own imaginings as he tries to pour his afternoon tea. But he laughs it off easy enough because, frankly, the idea is silly and a little presumptuous. If the dwarrow had made such a gesture, it was certainly not with romantic intentions; perhaps Thorin had left them as a friendly gift, thinking they would brighten up the room? Whatever the reason, Bilbo would hardly expect him to know the meaning of these particular blooms.
The dwarrow in question arrives shortly to take tea with him. Thorin’s visits have grown longer and more frequent. Most days, he leaves in a rush, but occasionally he tarries, like today. It is just him and Thorin for now, as Bofur is running late and Bifur has gone to water the ponies. Bilbo savors the rare gift of catching a moment alone with him.
After his second cuppa, Bilbo musters the courage to ask Thorin about the bouquet, albeit with a bit more fumbling of his words than he would like. To his great relief—perhaps streaked with the tiniest hint of disappointment—Thorin answers in the negative as he pours Bilbo’s third.
“Ah, your kinsman requested that these be delivered. I overheard him place the order this morning.”
Bilbo goes dead still. Lotho, of whom he has seen neither hide nor hair for over a month, sent them himself, which leaves no room for misinterpretation of their meaning. White lilies stand for sympathy: a classic hobbitish apology.
For weeks, not a single word to threaten Bilbo or otherwise—and now he’s sorry? No note, no explanation. No answer to the burning question why?
His blood is boiling, and he is standing and slamming both hands on the table. Thorin’s pouring is ruined, and liquid chrysanthemum drips down onto Bofur’s hand-carved tabletop. Bilbo growls and the noise that ripples out of his throat is halfway to murderous. “That mangy, miserable, rotten little slinker! If this is his idea of an apology—I ought to—”
Thorin is staring at him. Perhaps, Bilbo thinks in retrospect, he is not exactly discouraging the others’ assertion that he is unhinged. Lovely. Just when he was starting to make a decent impression, too.
The dwarrow’s unreadable face settles on heated concern. “Did he abuse you when you were in his service?” Swallowing thickly, Bilbo responds with a curt shake of his head. “Then he has wronged you in some other way?”
“I can’t tell you that,” Bilbo murmurs cagily. “It’s complicated. The dispute between us is a private family matter.”
Storm blue eyes narrow dangerously. “You will tell me at once if his intentions here are dishonorable. If his own kin eyes him with such distrust, there must be a reason. I will not put the line of Durin at risk.”
Bilbo clenches and unclenches his fists. “He is no threat to them,” the hobbit sighs. He would like to comment further that his cousin’s honor is indeed questionable, but he dare not escalate things beyond this point. “Cur that he is, I believe Lotho’s feelings for the Price Fili are real,” he admits, running a hand through his haggard curls. “They exchanged letters on the road and fell in love. I think he was gone the minute he saw that portrait.” Under different circumstances, the whole thing could be considered sweet… sans the part where he murdered an innocent, sentient animal and left his own kin in servitude.
“Swear to me that what you say is true.”
The hobbit pauses. The lilies speak of guilt, but nothing else. He can’t be sure that Lotho has no other angle here, besides marrying Fili. If he does, can Bilbo justify hiding his secret?
Then again, what damage can a single hobbit do? Against an entire kingdom of dwarrows, no less. “I do not believe he will not harm the royal family,” Bilbo says at last. “I ask that you respect my decision to withhold the details.” The dwarrow’s grumbling settles into a reluctant frown and Bilbo knows that Thorin believes him. “Yes, he has committed a grievous wrong and he knows it. But this—” Bilbo says, gathering up the lilies in hand and spitefully chucking them to the waste bucket, “—is the coward’s way. An earnest apology is made in person and with words.”
Anger gives way to grief and bitter disappointment. Bilbo releases the majority of his consternation in a gust of exhaled air and sits back down. “Though it matters little; he can never undo what he’s done.”
Thorin’s expression has become unreadable again, but a thin smile plays on his lips. “Mahal’s mercy to those who earn your ire, Bilbo Baggins.”
Only now does Bilbo realize that his fists are shaking; he stills them at once. “I’m so sorry! We were having such a nice time before I spoiled the mood.”
“On the contrary,” Thorin says, his eyes glittering with poorly-hidden mirth. “I find your candidness refreshing. You are—unusually expressive.”
“Happy to entertain,” Bilbo snorts, reaching over to stack Thorin’s empty plate on top of his own.
Thorin’s hand stills the movement. “I mean not to make light of your troubles. My hope is that you will share them openly with me one day. It’s just… You show what you feel with such honest depth; it is a rare and welcome sight for one who spends their days at court.”
He pulls back to reach for something beneath the table and Bilbo feels bereft at the sudden loss of his touch. From its green velvet wrapping, Thorin produces a lyre stringed with gold. “Now, it seems only fair that I entertain you in return. I believe I have yet to deliver on a certain promise of music.” He sets the instrument firmly on top of his thigh, leaning it into the crook of his shoulder, and begins to ♪ play . ♪
The tune begins as a series of playful, jaunty notes. One two three, one two three. The strings vibrate with bright clarity, both uplifting and soothing at once. Thorin’s notes dance back and forth, up and down like a pony prancing.
Bilbo’s eyes close as the music washes over him. He loses himself in that imagery: Myrtle and his father appearing over the hilltop after a day at the market. His mother attempting to ride side saddle, wobbling as she holds his father’s shoulder for support. The three of them laughing over a picnic in the meadow, his mother dragging them both to their feet for a dance.
Bilbo abandoning his parents as they sway to their own romantic music, babbling nonsensically to Myrtle as he weaves daisies into her hair. Myrtle running, unbidden, through an open field. Beorn’s field.
He is crying, the evidence steadily streaming down his face. Why, why did he not leave her there? Had he not clung on so selfishly, she would be there now, happy and healthy. Alive.
No. He knows it does no one any good to keep blaming himself. Myrtle would want him to carry these happy memories of her with him, not the imagined horrors that don’t exist.
Thorin’s fingers strum their last and Bilbo shudders in a breath. “It thought to make you smile—it was supposed to be a happy tune,” Thorin murmurs, perturbed by yet another turn in Bilbo’s mood.
Bilbo laughs at the bizarre company he must make, given his recent tidal wave of emotions. No wonder Bofur and Oin still think he is completely mental. “It was lovely,” he says weakly.
Bofur, who must have returned to the cabin some time during the song, assures him that there is nothing to be shy about; Thorin’s playing is infamous for bringing even the mightiest of warriors to tears. He should hear what this dwarrow can do with a full harp!
“I enjoyed your song very much, Thorin, really,” Bilbo assures him, once he has composed himself. “I could listen to you play all day,” he continues emphatically. “It’s just—you reminded me of something I need to do. I’ve put it off for long enough.”
Thorin grips Bilbo’s upper arm in a way that leaves lasting heat. “Another time, then.” He dips his head slowly and rises to make his exit. He can feel the ghost of his hand long after its presence is gone.
“Whatever you do, don’t try flowers,” he mutters to Bofur.
“Duly noted,” the toy-maker replies drily, wiping up the spilled tea before it can stain his handiwork.
As the door to their cabin closes, Bofur remarks on Thorin’s increasing appearances; this is the third time this week. “What are we, chopped liver? ” Bifur signs with a snort. Bofur readily agrees. He confesses that, while he is glad for Thorin’s company, this is all rather strange and unusual. There is a trace of something like annoyance in his usually-full-bodied smile, and Bilbo imagines he feels put out by having to entertain on the spot.
Much as he would love to jump at the chance to delay his task by discussing their grievances, he has to do this now—before he loses the courage that Thorin’s song revived in him. He mumbles an excuse about needing to check on something, grabbing a shovel and heading outside. His final respects to Myrtle are long overdue.
The field house he seeks is quiet and empty in the fading light of sunset. He lengthens his steps to prolong the inevitable. For a long while he cannot bring himself to look upon the door; he fears whatever condition he may find her in after all this time. Then again, it can be no worse than the horrors conjured in his nightmares. Whatever the case, he will honor and bury Myrtle as soon as possible; he owes her that much.
When he finally rounds the corner, he is surprised to find her head well-preserved and free of any lingering scent, aside from the mild acidic wash of whatever they used to keep her flesh in good condition. He can’t decide whether this reality is more disturbing than the grotesque, rotting skull he had imagined. She looks like a remarkably-realistic work of art rather than something that had once been part of a living, breathing creature.
But Bilbo knows better; Myrtle was real.
“Oh, sweet girl. What have they done to you!?” he cries out. “I am so sorry; it’s all my fault.” He bows his head and tips it against her white-striped muzzle. “I should have let you go that day.” Her beautiful chestnut hair tickles his shoulder as he weeps. The notes of Thorin’s lyre replay in his head and he hums the few bars he can recall to her.
After the notes run dry, he instead imagines the voice that Gandalf gave her, the one that sounded so like his father. Perhaps he imagined a little too hard, because he can almost hear it ringing in his ears…
If this your mother knew, how her heart would break in two.
He pulls away at once to look at her face and he could swear he saw her blink. “Myrtle?!” He cups either side of the head’s long muzzle and stares. Yes, that knowing light is there, just as it was when she spoke to him before. “Gandalf’s spell! Can you still hear me?” She does not speak, yet he knows, knows in his heart that she is listening, and the thought is morbid yet comforting all at once. “But—you’re dead.”
It’s insane. It’s as wonderfully preposterous as a wizard enchanting a pony to talk. Beyond all rhyme or reason, he has regained this one small piece of his treasured friend. One single reminder of home.
All intentions of burying Myrtle’s remains disappear; instead, he tells her all that has transpired since his arrival in Erebor, from waking up in Oin’s chambers to making three unexpected friends. And, most of all, he recounts Lotho’s inexplicable crimes.
Facing his fears with Myrtle gives Bilbo the fortitude to confront Lotho at last. No longer will he bury his anger and pretend to be content with this flux state of living. He will march up to his cousin and demand answers, even if he has to force them out of him.
“He won’t get away with this, I promise you,” he says firmly, stroking her soft muzzle one final time for the evening. “I am going to make him answer for what he did to you.”
Actually following through on his vow is more of a challenge. The cowardly half of him wishes he could avoid this altogether and chalk it up to logistical difficulties. As friends of the crown, Bifur or Bofur could put in a word royal family, even introduce him outright, but he can hardly air his grievances in their presence. He mentions this to Thorin, wondering if a servant of the palace might have the appropriate connections to get a message to Lotho. To both his gratitude and his dismay, Thorin guarantees them a meeting in person, and in private.
He has no idea how Throin managed to pull such strings; he sincerely hopes the dwarrow isn’t risking his job by doing him such favors. Thorin laughs at this and tells him not to worry. Sadly, he cannot accompany Bilbo personally, which is a shame because his presence would have lent Bilbo a great deal of moral support. Instead, one of the dwarrow’s contacts will deliver him to his appointment.
This is how Bilbo finds himself in Oin’s quarters once again, after the healer has gone home for the night. It feels so strange to be here after all this time. Memories from his first fateful night in Erebor return in waves. Instead of the pain and fear, they are laced with anger and confusion. Bilbo stretches his fingers out onto the wall to collect himself. He focuses on the stone, at where he is in the mountain, just scratching its surface. It serves to calm him a while, until a youthful-looking dwarrow with ginger hair arrives to collect him.
“Hello, Mister Bilbo! My name is Ori, son of Miri. I am so excited to meet you,” he says, quite unnecessarily; Bilbo could tell as much from the sheer enthusiasm of his handshake. “When Thorin told me there was a second hobbit, I couldn’t believe it. But here you are! I simply had to meet you.”
Bilbo flushes as the dwarrow surveys him and takes notes in the behemoth of a notebook he carries on him. He wonders vaguely how Ori stores it on his person. “Fascinating. You’re a much more exemplary hobbit, aren’t you? All proper and planting, I mean, not like Lotho. Not that he’s bad,” he amends deftly. “He’s sort of like any other dwarrow around here, actually. I just thought he’d be different. Fi adores him though, and that’s what matters,” he concedes with a blithe shrug.
The mere mention of Bilbo’s cousin makes it feel real; he is truly going to face him. Emotions he has not let bubble past a light simmer since that day rise to the surface and they are fierce . On second thought, Bilbo is glad that Thorin isn’t here to witness this whole encounter. He can’t be liable for whatever he is about to unleash.
Ori leads Bilbo further into the mountain, the closest he has been to the palace since the day of his arrival. “I’m told he’s been avoiding you on purpose,” the dwarrow comments in a hushed whisper.
“Of course he has, the coward,” Bilbo mutters furiously. Ori appears taken aback, but he doesn’t comment on Bilbo’s strange mood.
They arrive in a small courtyard, sheltered by tall stone columns and vines. It is completely deserted, save Lotho and the golden-haired prince. Bilbo is torn between the urge to walk right up to the other hobbit and slap him stupid—or to hide behind a column so that the prince won’t see him (again). He need not worry for long; the elder royal says something inaudible to Lotho, kisses his hand, and then retreats in the opposite direction.
Bilbo isn’t sure if he’ll ever have another opportunity; this could be now or never. “If you please,” he tells Ori, “I would like a moment alone to talk to my dear cousin.” Bilbo’s voice is colder than the Fell Winter, its malice foreign to his own ears. Ori shrinks back and complies without another word.
It is all Bilbo can do to keep in his rage until they are alone. He reveals himself to Lotho, savoring the stricken look on his face. All this time, he has waited calmly and quietly, bottling up everything. He has protected these dirty secrets and swallowed down the pain that they have wrought.
“LOTHO AINSLEY SACKVILLE-BAGGINS,” he roars, his vision clouding with red, “WHAT DO YOU HAVE TO SAY FOR YOURSELF!?”
Lotho is cowering before him, despite being a few inches taller than his cousin. “I’m sorry,” he says lamely.
“You think some half-arsed apology is going to cut it?” He hisses, deathly soft. Bilbo’s rage has him trembling feverishly. “No. You owe me answers, and you had better start talking. Now.”
The younger hobbit’s face is pale, his tone pleading. “She was old, Bilbo! You ran her half to death across Middle Earth. Her legs looked about ready to give out—she would have died within the year anyway. Did you expect her to live forever?”
Bilbo screams, his voice piercing through the night. “Her name was Myrtle. And you had her slaughtered!”
In all his life Bilbo has never wanted to hurt someone so badly. If he had a weapon, no one could hold him responsible for what it might rend.
“I had to!” Lotho cries out. “If she talked, it would have ruined everything!” He reaches up to shield his head and face, shaking and expecting a blow, if not several.
Bilbo had not even realized his position, arm poised to strike. His limbs had moved of their own accord.
He can see the trajectory of his strike, and he knows in that moment that Lotho will take it with nothing more than a whimper. He isn’t even trying to stop Bilbo; perhaps that knowledge is what stays Bilbo’s hand. It hangs suspended in midair until he is shaking, until…
His fingers coil into a fist and swing back down to his side. “I saved you!” he spits out. “That day at Beorn’s house, I saved your ungrateful bloody life, and this is how you repay me—by having my friend killed and her head hung up on a door!?”
“I didn’t know.” Lotho sobs like he means it. “I’m sorry. I didn’t want to do it, I swear! They would have sent me away. And Fili—”
Bilbo’s teeth grit tight together. Finally, the excuse he expected to hear for Lotho’s treachery. “I get that you love him, alright. But that’s no excuse! How do you think your husband will feel if he learns that this is how you treat your own family?”
There are tears pouring down Lotho’s face, hewn of guilt and sorrow and anger. “We’re NOT family,” he grounds out, his voice hoarse with unfounded anguish. “You don’t understand. You could never understand.”
No. No, he really doesn’t. Because what right does Lotho have to be angry in all this? He is making no sense, talking as if Bilbo is the one who hurt him, not the other way around. As if he did not just verbally disown his cousin without a second thought.
Lotho lets out a choked cry, his eyes cinching shut. He shakes his head and gives Bilbo one last loaded glare before running away.
The courtyard is too silent, too empty. That privacy that Bilbo had so desired to confront Lotho is now stifling. Ori returns to collect him, and not a moment too soon. He winces at Bilbo’s dark mood but asks how it went anyway.
“It solved nothing,” he mutters bitterly. “I don’t know why I tried.” Bilbo has no idea what to make of his cousin’s outburst.
“Oh. I’m sorry to hear that.” Ori gives him a sympathetic frown. “My brothers and I used to fight all the time. They had their reasons, especially Dori. He’s always been overprotective,” he recalls wistfully. The ginger dwarrow’s face is so young , Bilbo thinks. Not nearly as young as Lotho, all tween angst and dramatics and stupidity.
A fraction of Bilbo’s anger bleeds out of him and slowly contorts into shame. He is Lotho’s elder by two decades; it is his responsibility to take the higher road and to model the appropriate behavior. Worst of all, Bilbo had been too busy imagining Lotho as nightmare fodder to think beyond his own self-centered preoccupations.
This goes beyond their own personal conflict; what matters most is protecting the Shire. There is a vengeful, spiteful stripe in him that would very much like to see his cousin fail, but not in this. Lotho’s immature manner of handling everything so far makes Bilbo feel less certain than ever about the fate of their people.
The hobbit follows Ori back to Oin’s chambers in uncomfortable silence. To his pleasant surprise, Thorin is there to meet them. He and the ginger dwarrow chat amicably until Bilbo clears his throat to cut them off. “I’m terribly sorry, but this is important—Can either of you tell me about the kingdom’s alliance with the Shire?”
Thorin hums in acknowledgment. “It fares well. Soon we will be able to start setting up defense outposts at points of interest and cover any areas exposed to goblin attacks.”
“That is good to hear,” Bilbo sighs. “Bofur mentioned that the alliance is more fragile than I’d been led to believe. Do you know... Is Lotho doing his part?”
“Fili’s consort has the makings of a promising statesman,” Thorin confirms. He goes on to explain that the loss of Shire maps during Bilbo and Lotho’s travels caused some initial delays. Ori cuts in then, supremely impressed by Lotho’s intimate knowledge of the land’s geography and layout; he has helped the court cartographer recreate them— from memory! —and provides the council meetings with invaluable information.
“Indeed,” Throin agrees, taking back the reins of conversation. “However, he must also succeed in his proposal to Dain. I—” He pauses abruptly and exchanges a curious look with Ori. “I... assure you, Erebor honors its promises; troops will be sent to protect your land. However, our forces in the far west may be spread too thin if the war worsens in Ered Luin. Our mightiest general is there right now, and while I trust her tactical maneuvering with my life, even she cannot fight two armies alone with one small diplomatic battalion. Lord Dain’s aid would be invaluable for everyone.”
His words grip Bilbo’s heart like ice. He knew that the situation in the Blue Mountains was worsening, but he had not bothered to ponder the consequences to other dwarven kingdoms. The Thain had all but declared Erebor to be their savior, and this alliance one instant and miraculous solution to their problems. He had never been told to worry about what would happen should it fail.
This burden is far too important to leave to Lotho alone. He will not stoop to Lotho’s level or ruin his marriage to Fili—if he can help it. But if his cousin does not sway Lord Dain, Bilbo may have no choice but to reveal himself and attempt some kind of damage control for the sake of hobbitkind.
Even if things are never mended between them personally, he has to find out if Lotho knows what he is doing. The idea of confronting him again so soon makes Bilbo’s skin crawl. His cousin’s apologies give him whiplash; he sounded sincerely contrite, and yet he turned the entire thing around on Bilbo in the end. How is he supposed to believe anything his cousin says? No, he cannot not let this conflict go unresolved.
He doesn’t care if he has to wait over a fortnight—he will have his meeting with Lotho. Bilbo asks of Thorin this one additional favor, and his friend solemnly swears to make it happen. The date is set.
* * *
As harvest time rolls around, Erebor’s fields draw in the most splendid bounty that a kingdom of dwarrows have ever seen. Even the Esgarothians, who have been in the business tending land for way longer, are impressed by their yield.
There is still work to be done in the field, but once the harvest is fully underway, Bofur’s field hands take over most of the heavy lifting. Bilbo’s duties lighten considerably—that is, until Bombur, Erebor’s famous lead chef, begs for his assistance in the palace kitchens, eager to test the culinary prowess of hobbits.
Bilbo soon finds himself as busy as before and then some, run practically ragged by the third of the brothers Ur. (Or are they cousins? Bilbo still doesn’t know). The jolly redhead proves most capable when it comes to creating dishes from practically nothing, but a few of the crops Bilbo planted are completely foreign to dwarven palates, including the herbs that have begun to flourish for harvest. He wants to learn every hobbitish recipe there is and train all of his sous chefs to make them. Erebor’s upcoming Durin’s Day celebration will, without question, be a feast to remember.
They are making savory pies today, with mushrooms and peas. Bilbo works his dough flat with vigor and converses with the head chef to calm his nerves. He is ready to finally meet with Lotho again later today; the wait has been long and tenuous.
Bombur is quite put out by the fact that Bilbo is denying him access to certain Baggins family secrets, but he can appreciate the sentiment as a fellow culinary artiste. They do strike one small accord, a compromise: Longo’s huckleberry tart recipe for Bombur’s exquisite almond-cinnamon buns, Bilbo’s father forgive him. He has blown through enough of them when his roommates’ share their goodie stash to know that the trade is well worth it.
When Bombur casually announces that Bilbo has a visitor, the hobbit’s dough falls to the stone counter with a soft plop . This early? He hopes nothing is wrong. He throws his smock up on its hook and quickly brushes some of the flour from his legs before dashing right out of the kitchens.
Instead of Ori, Thorin is waiting for him, and Bilbo couldn’t be gladder for the sight of him. He is dressed up a little more than usual, looking extra regal in his green velvet tunic with silver buttons. Honestly, the dwarrow is so handsome he could wear naught but a potato sack and still attract suitors like flies. If Bilbo’s cheeks grow hot, well—it is midday, and warm for the middle of autumn.
Their conversation starts off with the usual niceties, then lapses into the usual topics, namely work. Bilbo does not wish to squander precious time alone with Thorin. They talk to each other more often now, yes, but most of their interactions transpire in a party of four. “Let us speak of other things,” he suggests. Bilbo flushes, realizing that he has lapsed into Thorin’s overly-formal speech, as a result of hearing and thinking about it so often.
“Very well. Have you any thoughts on the royal family?” Thorin asks, his tone searching.
Bilbo blinks, taken aback by the dwarrow’s random choice in topic. “I’m not sure why you’re asking me; you’re the one who sees them on a regular basis.” he deflects. “I hardly know anything about them.”
Thorin shrugs. “I find the opinions of all Erebor’s subjects to be enlightening and valuable. Indulge me?”
“Fine. I suppose... They have done a wonderful job rebuilding all of this in so little time. And from what I gather, they love their people and are loved in return.”
“Yet you flee at the sight of our Crowned Prince,” Thorin counters. He cites Bilbo’s disastrous interaction (or lack thereof) with Fili at the market, which Bofur must have let slip. They’ll be having words about this when he gets home.
Their conversation is heading dangerously close to the territory of Bilbo’s secret. “I—I just felt awkward, is all. Clammed up and, erm, didn’t know what to do in the presence of royalty.”
“Fair enough. What say you about the King Under the Mountain?” Thorin presses.
“The king?” Bilbo fondly remembers the gift that he had received in Lord Elrond’s halls. “Well, he’s very generous, and he clearly cares about his people. And he has excellent taste in gifts,” He laughs. Thorin stares and waits for him to elaborate. “I mean, he sent armor to the prince’s betrothed. Mithril, I think it’s called.”
His friend nods. “Exceedingly rare and expensive. The definition of extravagance. It is the favorite metal of most every dwarrow.”
“I’m sure Lotho appreciates it,” Bilbo snarks. “He’s obsessed with that sort of thing.”
“Your kinsman does not wear it,” he notes, taking the hobbit by surprise. “Would you like to have such a gift?”
Bilbo sighs. “It is beautiful,” he concedes. He supposes he’ll never touch the starlit metal ever again. “When we were attacked, I felt safer just to have it near. I think it made me feel braver than I ever thought I could be.” Unstabbable. He laughs internally at the memory of his drunken self. “The king could have sent armor made of tin, for all I care—it’s the thought that counts.”
“He should have sent a squadron of personal guards,” Thorin grumbles hotly. “At the very least, a second set of mail for you.”
“That's hardly fair; we never told him we were bringing along an extra person,” Bilbo points out. “Anyway, I doubt he knows I exist, and I’d prefer to keep it that way,” he mutters tightly. “Besides, it was all Gandalf’s idea not to bring bodyguards.”
“Hang that blasted meddling wizard!” Thorin curses. “The king should have overruled him.” It doesn’t surprise Bilbo; who doesn’t have a bone to pick with the most infamous wizard in Middle Earth?
When the dwarrow finally stops his fussing, he turns back to Bilbo, his churlish mood softening to one of deep concern. “Your safety is worth more than a mountain full of Mithril.”
Bilbo forgets to breathe. He has to fight the urge to kiss Thorin then and there. Well. That is an interesting development. One he shall have to tell Myrtle all about.
As per usual, he and Thorin are parted early by their respective duties. As soon as Bilbo is done helping Bombur for the day, he rushes out to the field house to share the news with his confidante. He unloads everything in nonsensical freeform, from the droll happenings of these past few days to thoughts for the future: his budding attraction to Thorin, Bombur’s recipe for walnut sticky buns, which songs he should pick to sing for the next mini concert with his roomates. His pending second meeting with Lotho.
“I think I’m the happiest I’ve ever been,” he sighs to Myrtle’s hanging head. She listens on with ever-knowing eyes.
There was a time when his books and armchair had been enough. His childhood fantasies of running off to lands unknown had quieted to a low simmer; he had a place, he had a purpose. He helped his father tend the land until his passing, then he had to make his mother comfortable through her twilight years. He had neither time nor reason to leave, nor had he wanted to. The Shire had been his safe and serene little world, perfect as a dream.
These past few months have turned Bilbo’s entire life inside out. They have forced him to open his eyes, to make changes he never knew he needed. He had spent so much time focusing on what he had lost, instead of the treasures that lay right before his eyes.
If only he could be sure that the Shire was in safe hands, then he wouldn’t have to lose this. But if the royal family found out… “What if they made me marry Fili after all?” he wonders aloud, morosely stroking Myrtle’s mane. He doesn’t want to even entertain the idea, but there is still a very real possibility. “I don’t know if I could go through with it.” He needed to work things out with Lotho, he had to—
A soft swear in Khuzdul captures his attention. Uh-oh. Bilbo looks over his shoulder and Bifur is standing there, eyes wide as saucers. A pail of feed lays spilled on the ground at his side. He has heard more than enough. “It was you. You’re the one who’s meant to marry Fili.”
Bilbo’s mouth works uselessly; how could he have been so careless with his words!? “... Yes,” Bilbo sucks in a breath and signs back. “The Thain sent me, not my cousin.”
“The lord-prince lied. He betrayed you!” A colorful strand of insults, peppered with threats against the deceitful young hobbit’s life follows. Bilbo winces and shakes his head, but it falls on blind eyes. “He has committed the most grievous of insults, acting in your stead! ”
“What you need to understand about that is—”
“—I’d do it myself, but I’m sure the king will demand the first crack at him.”
Bilbo squeaks, horrified by both the prospect of bloodshed on his behalf and Bifur’s idea. “No, Bif, you can’t tell anyone, especially not the king! Please —It would ruin everything!”
Something in Bilbo breaks because he knows where he’s heard those words before. He is beginning to understand, on some level, just how easy it was to get caught up in all the lies and fear when you have so much to lose. He recounts the entirety of Lotho’s scheming, up to and including their pending second meeting tonight. It feels incredible to be able to talk about this with someone other than Myrtle.
“Don’t you see?” he whispers. “I’d have to get married and live in the palace. I’d have to leave you all.”
“I’ll keep your secret, cross my heart.” Bifur follows the vow with a clear motion, alleviating Bilbo’s worries. “You should never be forced to do something you don’t want to do.” Then he scowls low into his wiry, two-toned beard. “I still want to throttle him.”
“I nearly did myself,” Bilbo confesses with a soft snort.
Something other than anger darkens Bifur’s soulful eyes, a pinch of sorrow and a dash of remorse. “He made me hurt you.” Now there is the heart of it.
“None of this is your fault!” Bilbo swears fervently. “I never once blamed you for what happened to Myrtle,” He reaches back to pat the deceased mare’s hair. “Strange as it is, I’m actually glad you kept her for me after all. She’s a wonderful listener.”
“Madcap, you are.” Ah, right. Bilbo was using a decapitated head in lieu of a diary, so he supposes the assessment is rightly fair this time. “Bilbo. You can always talk to me about anything.”
“I know.” Bilbo releases a breath he didn’t know he was holding. “I’m sorry I didn’t trust you with this before. I was afraid, and stupid.”
Bifur clasps Bilbo’s forearm, and the hobbit answers his familiar, comforting gesture. It tells them both that things are right between them. Better than before, in fact. “I’d sooner die than cause you pain. ”
“And I you, Bif. You’re my best friend.”
The words leave his mouth before he is able to comprehend their significance. They feel… right. He may not have known Bifur for very long, but even so he cannot imagine life without him. Laughing together, growing together, learning new things. Who else can riff his own version of ♪ Morgoth’s epic disaster of a musical solo ♪ off the cuff in one moment—reducing Bilbo to a puddle of hysterical giggles—and soothe him through the worst of his nightmares in the next? Who told him that he is strong and capable and you will get through this as many times as needed to get the message through his thick Took skull? Yes, he will forever treasure his old friends from Hobbiton, and perhaps even return to them, but Bifur will always hold a special place in his heart.
“...Best friend? ”
“Yeah,” he half-laughs, half-sniffles. “You’re my favorite. Don’t tell Bo?”
Bilbo joins Bifur up at the stables for the rest of the afternoon and helps brush and water the rest of his equine charges. He regrets having avoided them for so long because they are beautiful creatures who deserve nothing less than to be admired day and night—Yes you are! If only he had a few ripe apples to spare; pity it’s too early in the season.
As the hour of his meeting with Lotho draws near, Bifur lends some much-needed moral support and walks with him back up to Oin’s chambers. A dark-haired, bright-eyed dwarrow is waiting in the healer’s doorway, waving at them and grinning impishly. “Hullo Bif,” he chirps. “And this must be Mister Boggins!”
Bifur says something in Khuzdul that makes the mischievous dwarrow’s grin widen further. “Nah, Ori couldn’t make it this time. He’s stuck going over the council meeting notes with Balin. I don’t envy him,” he adds with a grimace.
There is something familiar about him, his dark hair and fine features. The quiver of arrows slung over his shoulder slots the last puzzle piece into place. “You’re Thorin’s nephew!” Bilbo guesses. “He’s mentioned you and your brother loads of times, but I’m afraid I didn’t catch your name.”
“Yup, I’m Ki—” He stops short, the sound catching in his throat. “...Er?” The dwarrow fidgets and pops the last syllable like a question.
Bilbo blinks owlishly and looks at Bifur for answers. The horsemaster is glaring at the young dwarrow as though he is the worst kind of imbecile. “...Kir?” Bilbo annunciates slowly, trying not to sound overly-condescending. He can’t possibly have forgotten his own name, can he? How on earth does one even manage that?
“Yup, that’s me. Kir, son of—Bir. At your service!”
“Riiight,” Bilbo says, eyes narrowing dubiously.
Bifur says his goodbyes and wishes Bilbo luck with a comforting pat on the back. Then, the hobbit is left alone with this strange archer, much to his chagrin. “Thank you for coming in Ori’s place,” he murmurs, his stomach gurgling with nerves. He hates confrontations. “Let’s make this quick,”
“No problem! I can’t stay long meself,” the brunette concurs. “My wife and I are going on an epic night hunt!”
“How romantic,” says Bilbo drily.
Kir answers in the affirmative, not taking the meaning of the hobbit’s tone. “I’ll never match her for speed or aim; she is heaven to watch in her craft,” he sighs, starry-eyed, “and a good sport to boot. She always leaves something for me to catch.”
“Well, come this harvest, you won’t need to harass any defenseless animals come winter! There will be enough food to feed Erebor’s army thrice over.”
“Then I’ll hunt goblins instead.” Kir grins, unperturbed. “They make for better sport.” Bilbo hates the idea of harming anything or anyone, but he supposes it is fair game when the opposing party is constantly trying to kill you.
The young dwarrow leads him to a different place this time, a small nondescript alcove. Better this than outside, since it is still daytime. “We had to trick him into coming around last time, but this one was a cinch. He wants to talk to you too—I think.” His voice is far too eager and anticipatory, as through Bilbo’s argument with Lotho is an entertaining theatrical performance.
Lotho and Prince Fili are waiting for them, and to Bilbo’s horror, the blonde walks right up to him, and for one split second Bilbo thinks he knows. “You have until the next bell rings,” he proclaims before promptly dragging Kir away to give them some privacy.
The seconds tick by without a word. Lotho’s eyes are trained on the marble floor, and Bilbo doesn’t know where to begin. He should concentrate first and foremost on the alliance, but all sense flies away in the face of this unbearable tension.
“…”
He doesn’t expect his cousin to break the silence first, let alone to look him in the eye. “I shouldn’t have done it. I’m sorry,” he says, much firmer than the last time. “It was completely unfair of me.”
That’s rich. “Unfair? ” Bilbo parrots incredulously.
“It was—wrong,” the younger hobbit admits. “I know that now.”
“But you don’t regret what you did, do you?” he mutters bitterly. “You don’t care about Myrtle, or me. You don’t care about me or anyone but yourself,” Bilbo accuses.
“Please, Bilbo, I never meant for it to be like this. I only did it for Fili.” He bows his head and whispers another apology, and a plea for forgiveness. “I didn’t know how much your pony’s death would hurt you. If I could take it back, I would in a heartbeat.”
“You didn’t come here to apologize; you just want to make sure I keep my mouth shut!” His fingers are shaking worse than last time, itching to move from coiled fists.
A beat passes. Whatever Bilbo had hoped to accomplish with his harsh words, it wasn’t the sheen of tears on his cousin’s face. He doesn’t trust those wide, grey eyes, so young and so lost. He cannot allow himself to fall for the gleam of remorse, no matter how believable its apparent sincerity.
Even if Lotho truly means his apologies, what difference does it make? Myrtle is dead, and all Bilbo has left is a macabre piece of her. Never again will he ride with her through the green pastures of the Shire. She will never feel the wind on her fur, never speak to him in that hauntingly familiar voice. How can he forgive and forget, and walk away like nothing happened?
Yavanna help him, Bilbo cannot fathom how to feel. He has built the stirrings of a deep and lasting happiness here in Erebor, thousands of miles away from home. However, its very foundation remains tainted by Lotho’s deeds, the nightmare that refuses to vacate his life completely.
He is not yet ready to let go of his hurt and his anger. “You’re a slimy, smarmy, selfish git,” he grounds out. “You cost me a dear friend, and the only thing I had to remember my father by. I can’t go home—your parents took over Bag End, in case you’ve forgotten—I can’t think or breathe without swallowing your family’s lies!”
Lotho pales and casts his eyes back down to the floor. “You’re right about me. I don’t deserve to be here; I don’t deserve Fili or any of it.” He doesn’t even move to get away from Bilbo’s wrath. “I can’t fathom why you ever saved me.”
“Some of us don’t require a hidden motive to do the right thing.” A low blow, but well-deserved. Bilbo whips his hands about in nonsensical gesticulation, if only to release some of the tangible frustration. “It’s what you do for family,” he grounds out. “Or maybe you’re unfamiliar with the concept!”
He has hit a sore spot, given his cousin’s blotchy, angry flush and backward flinch, but when Lotho speaks his voice is quiet and unvexed. “We’re not related.”
Again with this utter nonsense! “Since when do cousins once removed not count?” Bilbo snorts. Sure, they don’t exactly have a weekly Sunday brunch together or exchange birthday gifts, but still.
“We’re not,” Lotho repeats shortly. “The man my mother married—he’s not my father.”
Bilbo is immobilized, as are all questions of retribution or forgiveness.
Of all the possible explanations he had expected this hobbit to conjure for his words, he had never entertained one quite so literal.
He listens, transfixed, as Lotho explains the ‘arrangement’ his parents made to ensure his begetting. Lotho’s very existence is tied up in status and self-loathing; Otho could not sire children, and neither could Lobelia remain in her parents’ favor without granting them at least one grandchild. Years of caving to external pressure had put such a strain on their marriage to the point where they couldn’t stand the sight of each other.
Otho and Lobelia surface to the forefront of Bilbo’s imagination, cold and beady-eyed as he has come to know them. But if he delves back into the deepest recesses of memory, there are long-buried moments from long ago. The vague outline of his cousin-in-law, the once-spirited and beautiful Bracegirdle lass who stole young Otho’s heart with her mother’s famous river dance. Cousin Otho himself had always been quiet and gruff, unapproachable until Lobelia came into his life.
They were happy, weren’t they? They had looked at each other the way that Bilbo’s parents looked at each other, he was sure of it. Every bit the portrait-perfect couple they were supposed to be.
Until they weren’t.
When did she become so unhappy, so consumed by lusting after the ancestral Baggins home? When did his timidity devolve into a spirit so cold and thin that, on his worst days, he looked as though he could crumble into the wind? Bilbo knows not how or when. But now he knows part of the reason why.
His childhood assumptions are catching up to him now. The interloper who sired Lotho—a vague, shadowy figure in Bilbo’s mind—fades and leaves in his wake a ruined marriage, a broken home. A cracked glass smial blown of pretending.
“Now you know,” Lotho exhales, “for all the good it does. Fili said I should tell you. So there; you don’t have to hold back for the sake of shared kinship.”
Instead of the strike Lotho is anticipating, Bilbo gathers him into a hug. He can feel the palpable shock coming off the younger hobbit in waves. And then Lotho is sobbing into Bilbo’s shirt as the elder of the two croons nonsensical words of comfort and endearment.
Bilbo stares blankly over his cousin’s head, overcome but the shock of it all. He doesn’t even know what to say about Otho. But Lobelia? Given her overbearing and covetous attitude, he doubts that she gave Lotho her blessing to come here.
“Your mother—have you written her at all? She must be worried sick.”
Lotho’s answering laugh is hollow and cold. “She doesn’t give a damn. Probably glad to be rid of me.”
Bilbo rests his chin atop Lotho’s head and smooths the younger hobbit’s dark curls. He can’t recall the last time he saw her smile, let alone show any emotion in public but contempt. “I’m sure she loves you, in her way,” he murmurs, trying to offer what little comfort he can.
“Easy for you to say; you were wanted,” Lotho retorts. “You could dress in rags and be the world’s most terrible farmer and still make everyone love you.”
He is right about one thing; Bilbo will never be able to truly understand. He can try his best to empathize, but he has no context for his cousin’s pain; the lonely years after his parents’ deaths pale in comparison to a lifetime of emptiness. He can’t begin to comprehend what it feels like to be so alone. To feel so undesirable that a single scrap of affection from a stranger’s written words has him leaping like a dog to its master. So desperate that he would kill for a single ounce of kindness.
But Bilbo does recognize the sound of deflection when he hears it. “Lotho… Did they hurt you?”
His cousin flinches through his tears. “I-I don’t—”
Bilbo’s stomach bottoms out. He backs off and soothes the lad back into a calmer state, assuring him that he need not verbalize old wounds and memories. Bilbo does not want to be the instigator of more nightmares.
But Lotho takes a shaky breath and continues. “After Mimi died...” His grandmother, Primrose Boffin, rest her spirit—Bilbo knew her mostly by her famous variation on an old circle dance, passed down and still performed during festivals to this day. She had been taken by the Fell Winter not long before Bilbo’s father. Which means Lotho has suffered all these years without her protection. “...and a few times, when the main plot got flooded. Those were the worst spells.”
He needn’t continue for Bilbo to get the picture. Everything about Lotho starts to make a great deal more sense. His withdrawn nature—not an inherited trait at all, but one learned—his constant fear and self-doubt, his lack of love for the Shire.
Why he would dive head-first to drowning for a scrap of affection from someone he had never met. Why he would sit here, waiting to be struck and ready to take it.
“If I ever see those—those nasty, abominable cretins ever again—!” He shakes in his fervor, rocking the younger hobbit with it.
“It was a long time ago,” Lotho murmurs. This does absolutely nothing to stem the tide of questions, shock, and rage Bilbo now feels. ‘When’ and ‘why’ don’t matter; that it happened at all is unacceptable!
Dear Eru, how had no one ever noticed? Or worse—if they had, but chose to do nothing. Bilbo’s anger, no longer directed at Lotho himself, turns toward every other hobbit that had ever known those miserable Sackville-Bagginses—including himself.
“I’m sorry. Lotho, I’m so sorry,” he whispers. “I should have noticed—I should have been there for you.”
“Don’t—please.” Lotho’s dark curls shake as he pulls back, distraught. “You barely knew me.” He looks miserable, and Bilbo doesn’t want to make him relive this, but neither can he not respond.
“It doesn’t matter. You never should have had to go through that—it shouldn’t have been allowed to continue!”
“Mother caught him, when I broke the cellar door. He never laid a hand to me after that.” Bilbo is about to interject that she is just as guilty as anyone, but then Lotho is speaking again. “I think what I hated the most isn’t anything she did exactly. It’s just…” He bites his lip and Bilbo can practically see the spark of a happier memory come to life in his eyes. “Remember that time your mum told us the story about the woodcutter and the fairy?”
Bilbo recalls it easily, mostly because Lotho begged her to tell it three times over. The two of them, Bilbo in his tweens and Lotho a little fauntling, sat huddled in Belladonna’s lap by the fire entranced by the cadence of her voice. It was a story about being rewarded for one’s honesty. Bungo made them honeyed teacakes and they stayed up into the wee hours of night. Bilbo helped his little cousin sneak extra helpings when they thought no one was looking. Lotho grins at the mention of the cakes. “I thought ‘this is what it’s supposed to be like,’” he sighs. “I never wanted to leave.”
A shadow overtakes that fond vision, twisting it back into discontent. “All Mother ever talked about was getting your wretched smial. I think she deluded herself into believing that if we lived in a place like Bag End, it would magically fix everything. Well, she’s got her wish now,” he mutters darkly.
A vengeful smirk pulls at the corner of Bilbo’s lips. “We should set it on fire, just to spite them.”
That startles Lotho into an incredulous guffaw. “Wouldn’t that be something?” He pulls away from Bilbo’s embrace to lean against the windowsill. “I expect I’ll be back there before long.”
“I am not making you go back there!” Bilbo swears fervently, and Lotho sags against him with a relieved exhale. “I’m not going to ruin your marriage to Fili either, if I can help it.” Bilbo assures him. If all goes to plan with the alliance, neither of them have to lose the foundations they have built here.
They have so much more to discuss and not nearly enough time, chiefly the impending fate of their homeland. Lotho manages to convey the gist of his progress, some of which Bilbo has heard secondhand from Thorin. So much rests on the lad’s shoulders; he has exactly two weeks left to prepare his presentation for the lord of the Iron Hills.
The bell rings loud and clear from the eastern tower. They agree to meet again in two days’ time to discuss and strategize, hobbit to hobbit. Things aren’t completely right between them, not by a long shot. But Bilbo can feel the knots in his heart beginning to unwind, satisfied by answers if not full closure.
“What you did to Myrtle is still completely desperately wrong,” he admonishes softly in their parting hug. “And the lying.”
“I know.” Lotho’s voice is guilt-laden and muffled against his shoulder.
“But—I also know that I wouldn’t give up a single minute here either.” Erebor is not and could never be the Shire, but there is something about this place—something to which Bilbo can’t quite put a name.
He looks on fondly from the shadows as Lotho reunites with Fili; their mutual adoration is as clear as cut diamond. How can Bilbo blame him for seizing a chance at happiness? The lad could have done far worse, and for lesser reasons. In all honesty, as someone who had been close enough to do something about Lotho’s situation but never did, his trivial problems feel something like just desserts.
Bilbo will need the aid of his dream charms tonight; his head clamors with so many thoughts, so loud that surely someone in the palace can hear them churning. With one last glance at the hobbit and the prince, he turns around and slips away in the night.
* * *
