Actions

Work Header

Dog and Butterfly

Chapter 2: Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

The note never left Bilbo’s hands all the time he studied it. He sat on his bench outside the steps of Bag End, his pack propped against him, and the slip of paper danced between his fingers, catching the light of the sun every now and then.

 

Without having looked at it Bilbo already had the words memorised, as if they were engraved in his very heart. Bilbo had held onto the ghosts of the past for so long, he had felt every imaginable way they would torture him, and a part of him had never left the frozen frame in time that was twenty years ago, when he watched Thorin die on Ravenhill. 

 

When it came to Thorin’s memory, he knew it like the back of his hand. He had mapped out every corner of it, reconstructed every manner of Thorin in his mind, and even when it came to haunt him and twist his heart he was glad, because that meant that he hadn’t yet forgotten. Thorin may have passed into legend, in books and soulless statues, but the memory of who he truly was — it was faithfully held the strongest in Bilbo’s heart. 

 

Which was why, as soon he saw the note, he recognised everything about it. The handwriting, the tone, and most importantly the name it had been signed off with. “T” stood for Thorin, as in Thorin Oakenshield, the very dwarf that Bilbo had loved and grieved over. By some way or other, he was alive , and out there, and he had been waiting for Bilbo ever since he placed the note at his door. 

 

But where? Where would Thorin be? He fumbled with the note in his hands, feeling as though he may wear it down to nothing but scraps. And how will Bilbo even begin to find him?

 

He could always write to Dís, send out search parties from Ered Luin. It would be far easier to track him down if there were more people on it. But then Bilbo turned to glance at his door, cracked ajar and worn out. Twenty years was a long time to not write to a sister, and if Bilbo knew Thorin as well as he did, he would have seen it done if he really wanted to. And if he had returned to Erebor, revealed himself to Fíli and Kíli and the rest, then he would certainly have heard about it, no matter how much they swore to keep it a secret. Dís easily sniffed out lies from miles away, and this was especially true when it came to her sons. And Bilbo would have heard from the rest of the company through their letters, eventually.

 

But for twenty long, hidden years, Thorin chose not to reveal himself to the dwarves. Instead, all that was left of him, the last hint of his existence, was sitting at Bilbo’s front door. It was a perplexing concept, and even now Bilbo couldn’t help but wonder why it was him that received this note. It was beyond a note of greeting -- it was an invitation, an extended hand to join him on an adventure of his very own -- of their very own. Surely that meant something, didn’t it? But still, there were more questions than answers in Bilbo’s mind, and as the sun began to climb the sky he found himself rather in need of a smoke. 

 

He cast his note aside on the bench and turned to his pack for his pipe. Just then, a gust of wind flew by, rustling his hair and making his toes tingle, and when he looked up the note had been lifted along with it.

 

“Wait, no, that’s mine,” Bilbo stammered, jumping to his feet. “Wait! Come back!” 

 

The note fluttered in the air, down the steps of Bag End and began to disappear down the road, as if it was a butterfly in the early Shire springtime. Without a second thought, Bilbo threw his pack over his shoulder and ran down the road, his footsteps loud and heavy against the path. 

 

As if it had taken a mind of its own the note flew down, down the Hill, over farmlands and fenced paths, and Bilbo pursued it like a dog chasing a butterfly. Over rounded roads it sailed, darting under trees, and past hobbits it went flying, flying, flying. Soon enough, Bilbo felt the eyes of the others on him, looking him up and down in a strangely familiar way, and as he tore past their forms he began to hear whispers of “Baggins” and “he’s back” from their mouths. 

 

But it wasn’t the time to stop for conversation or explanation. Bilbo’s gaze was fixed on the note that always seemed to flutter just out of arm’s reach. It was as if it was teasing him, leading him East, out of the Shire and to the rest of the world that lay ahead. Leading him out to the world where Thorin was. 

 

“Why, it’s Mad Baggins! It’s doggone Mad Baggins!” Bilbo heard the cry of Hamfast Gamgee as he looked up from the field, where he was smoking a pipe while leaning on a giant pumpkin. “Fancy having you back in the Shire, sir, we thought you were gone forever! Just where are you headed off to, sir?”

 

“I can’t talk now, Hamfast!” Bilbo cried as he leapt over the fence. “I’m in a bit of a pinch!”

 

“Whatever for?” Hamfast hollered, watching the note sail over his pumpkin, and Bilbo after it. 

 

“I’m going on another adventure, it seems!” 

 

-

 

My dear Bilbo,

 

I am beyond pleased to hear that you’re going off on an adventure of your own. You say you wrote to me from Bree? Then I expect you could be anywhere by the time this letter reaches you. 

 

If you will forgive me for saying so, Master Baggins, I have somehow always known that it was time for you to leave the Blue Mountains. Whether this parting will be temporary, I will leave up to fate. You are in the hands of the world now, and I pray that it will treat you with the kindness you deserve.

 

I wish you all the best in your endeavours, my friend! It will be a lie if I said that I did not miss you sitting at my right hand, but what truly brings me joy is the knowledge that you are pursuing your own happiness. Know that the Blue Mountains will always be at your service. Write to me if you are in need of provisions or aid. Anything you ask of us, we will see it done. 

 

-Dís

 

Postscript. It would appear that my court owes me a pretty penny for saying that you would go beyond the Shire. (Perhaps I know you even better than you know yourself.) If we are ever to cross paths again, I’ll share half my earnings with you. 

 

-

 

The leaves of Imladris took on another shade of brilliance in the high autumn moon, as if they were glimmers of topaz in the crystal-lit mines of the dwarves. This comparison was one that made his companion Elrond laugh softly as the two of them stood at a balcony which overlooked the hidden valley. 

 

Bilbo had two notes in hand now. One of them was a letter from Dis, which Garnet had delivered earlier this morning, to the joy and surprise of the hobbit. The other was Thorin’s note, which he had finally caught by the banks of the Brandywine River. 

 

“You know,” Bilbo said, tucking Dis’ letter inside his breast-pocket, “it’s awfully kind of you to host me here in Rivendell, Lord Elrond.” He glanced up at the elf and gave him a polite smile. “I always worry that I’ll overstay my welcome one way or another, I know you folk are awfully busy with your own matters.” He rocked on the balls of his feet. 

 

“As I have told you once before, Master Baggins, you are always welcome to stay in Rivendell, if that is your wish.” Elrond’s eyes were kindly as he spoke to the hobbit. “However, I sense that your stay with us will not be long this time.”

 

“Well, that’s not wrong,” Bilbo chuckled, fiddling with Thorin’s note in his hand. “It’s not for lack of the courtesy of your halls, of course,” he added quickly. “In fact, you have been wonderfully, wonderfully kind, and I’ve had a great stay so far. It’s just that… I’ve been going on a little adventure of my own. Heh.”

 

“Where will you go next?” Elrond asked kindly.

 

“Well, I haven’t really decided. I’m not usually like this, see, I do try to plan these things carefully, but well. Maybe I’ll see the mountains again. Maybe I’ll go down the Anduin until I reach Mirkwood. Or maybe I’ll just go wherever the road takes me.” He chuckled at himself. “I suppose I’ll retrace my old routes back in the days of the quest. That’s what I know, you see. So I’ll head to the Misty Mountains, and then the vales of Anduin…” 

 

“And eventually, your road would lead you back home.”

 

“Oh, Bag End’s not my -- I haven’t --” Bilbo began, but then he looked up and caught the sight of Elrond’s face, which had a knowing glint to it, and somehow, Bilbo could feel what he meant, even if he did not know it fully. “Ah,” he said, nodding to himself.

 

“You know, Dís said that it was about time that I went on another adventure. I’ve been in the Blue Mountains ever since I came back from my quest, and she knows me quite well, you see. But.... there was something I hadn’t really… erm... told her.” 

 

“I’m not sure if you would know, Lord Elrond, but have you ever seen… well, a dwarf, pass through Rivendell?”

 

“A dwarf?” 

 

“Yes, well. A dwarf that bears resemblance to… to…” Then Bilbo’s voice faltered, as if saying his name was still too hard for him. Twenty years of accepting that he no longer existed, twenty years of trying to shun the past, but now, he seemed to be alive and well, and he was no longer a mere figment of Bilbo’s imagination. The reality of him was, all at once, overwhelming. His name stuck on his throat, and for a moment Bilbo thought he may never be able to say it.

 

“To?”

 

“T-Thorin… Thorin Oakenshield,” Bilbo whispered.

 

A peculiar look came to Elrond’s face, something mysterious and wise, and he looked towards the valley. “How do you know of this?” he said softly.

 

“I-It’s true, then?” Bilbo stammered. “He’s really… alive?” 

 

“Who can say?” Elrond said, in the infuriating way that elves often replied both ‘yes’ and ‘no’ when answering a question. “Even the wisest cannot see all things.”

 

“But… you’re an elf, aren’t you? You can tell the future and all.” Bilbo felt his voice faltering once more as he glanced at the note again. He unfolded it and placed it in a spot where the moonlight hit the balcony, and the faded words faintly glowed in blue. At once Bilbo was reminded of the moon runes he had seen on the Map of Thror so many years ago, and he wondered if they were made of the same strand of magic, some distinct dwarven enchantment.

 

“Not all things come to pass,” Elrond reminded him gently, placing a hand on his shoulder. 

 

“But—“

 

“Know this, Bilbo Baggins. There is a note in your hand, one that is bound to the powers of the sun and moon, and it is revealed to you not by chance, but fate. Whether you will choose to pursue such truths, and whether you will succeed, is entirely up to you.”

 

“I do,” Bilbo mumbled. He laid the sheet out on the railing and smoothed it out with a hand. “I’ve felt like this… note… has some, well, magic of its own to it. It just… makes me feel like I should go out there. Look for him, I mean. If he really is, well. Alive. I just can’t… not, you see. I have to see it. See him. For myself. I’d do it, I think. For him.”

 

At that Elrond only nodded, and his lips curled into a gentle smile. “Of course. If at any time, you are in need of a brief respite in Rivendell, you will always be welcome in our realm.”

 

-

 

And so Bilbo passed through Rivendell and into the Misty Mountains, and for weeks he hiked the snow-dusted peaks and the icy roads until he reached the Vales of Anduin, where the beorning-lands lay. Then down, down the Anduin he trekked, staying close to the banks, setting up camp if he ever wanted a rest. He made feasts of lembas and salted pork, and once a while he would sit and write to Dís — “ Nothing too exciting to report, I’m afraid, just more river and road ahead of me. I suppose I’ll be near Mirkwood by Durin’s Day. Sending lots of love for the celebrations in the Blue Mountains!” 

 

It now took his poor raven a good few days to deliver these letters around — after all, Bilbo had put quite a bit of distance between himself and Ered Luin, and for a raven as small as she it was quite a long flight both ways. But, as disgruntled as poor Garnet may be when she descended upon Bilbo’s camp with a thick envelope from Dís, all was often forgiven when Bilbo brought out the collection of birdseed and breadcrumbs he kept with him in his pocket.

 

Garnet didn’t always travel alongside Bilbo — when she had nothing to deliver she would usually be set free to the wilds to fly and roam as she pleased. But with one steely, star-strung note of Bilbo’s whistle she would come flying. The loyalty of ravens was something that astounded him the most — they always knew to return when it was time.

 

Sometimes, if the raven felt like it, she’d loosely trail behind Bilbo as he set foot down the paths of the river, or she’d perch on the top of his pack, her gem-like eyes surveying the sights around the two of them, trained to the shadows within the trees. It was quite endearing, almost as if she was Bilbo’s own pet, and not just a borrowed messenger from the dwarves.

 

But most of the time when Bilbo walked, accompanied or not, he immersed himself in his own thoughts. As his feet steadily beat out a walking-rhythm he would finger the note in his pocket. It was like a question that needed an answer, and to it Bilbo could give none. What was he doing, really? Retracing old steps, just hoping that he would somehow, by some queer, ornate latticework of fate and destiny, bump into Thorin? And really, there was no saying that Thorin was still alive. Twenty years was a long time for anything to happen to anyone. He could have passed, truly passed away in the wilds with no name for his face, buried without glory. These thoughts made Bilbo’s heart race stronger and he found himself walking faster, feeling as though he was in a rush for something. But for what exactly, then? Even if he walked quickly, it would not be of use if he was walking in the wrong direction. In fact, it would be quite silly if he was walking in the opposite direction of where Thorin was! But how would he know where to walk, then? The note left no clue. Any scents it may once have carried, including that of Thorin’s smell, a warm musk of cedar and bear-fur, was long washed away by twenty years of rain and sun. All that was left was the damp fragrance of morning dew. 

 

At quieter times, when he sat poking a small fire he had made for himself at night, he would ponder the more difficult questions, even than that of where he was going and what he was doing. Bilbo thought of fate in the world, and how it would be so that this note would land on his doorstep. How Thorin was waiting, if he was still out there, for him. For him , and not another dwarf, or trusted friend, or even his sister. Bilbo wondered what he had done to deserve such a curious yet fitting destiny. 

 

For the longest, loneliest time he had felt like he was the only one in the Blue Mountains who even remembered what Thorin looked like anymore. If Thorin’s memory was a city left to ruin, then he was the sole guardian of it, refusing to let him go, to let him pass into legend. He had held onto the small, everyday moments he had shared with Thorin. The way his eyes softened when he smiled, the way he secretly dreaded waking up in the morning, and the way he fingered a small flower on the ground when he thought he was alone. The simple, hobbit-like parts of Thorin, the only Thorin Bilbo would ever want to remember. Not Thorin the warrior, Thorin the martyr, Thorin the king — just Thorin. 

 

If any of the others were ever to see Thorin again, they would be left in awe. Thorin would be a legend returned from the dead, and it would be a ballad sung by minstrels to the end of the age. But when Bilbo does see Thorin — if he manages to find him — then it would be like meeting up with a hearty, old friend. For that was all Thorin was to Bilbo, even in the memory he kept of him. 

 

Perhaps Bilbo was chosen to join Thorin for this very reason. Perhaps Thorin did not want to be a legend, encased in history books and ornate statues. Perhaps there was a certain sincerity in the simplistic lifestyle, and he hid himself in search of that. And somehow, Thorin knew, even back then, that Bilbo would see him as he wanted to be seen. 

 

In a way, perhaps Thorin knew that it would be Bilbo who knew him best. 

 

But this was all speculation, of course. Bilbo did tend to enjoy letting his mind wander, and sometimes it came to the most fantastical of places. Surely there would be some other explanation as to why the note had landed on Bilbo’s doorstep. Surely, he wasn’t that special to Thorin. 

 

-

 

A fell croak in the air woke Bilbo from his sleep. He looked to the skies with a frown, but it was clear and quiet with nothing in sight. “Garnet,” he muttered to himself, fumbling for the whistle. Had she run into trouble of her own? He gave it a blow and sat on his bedroll, waiting for her to emerge. Minutes passed, and even as the sun slowly began to climb the sky the bird was nowhere in sight. Bilbo chewed on his lower lip, and a feeling that something was very wrong indeed began growing in his belly. He tried the whistle again to no avail. 

 

“Oh dear,” he sighed. He slipped his hand into his pocket, but his heart stopped when he found that it was noticeably empty. “My note,” he cried to himself. “Where is my note?” Quickly he scrambled to peer underneath his bedroll and his pack, and he patted down all his pockets and trousers, but still it was nowhere to be found. He seized his folded map and gave it a good shake, hoping that the small sheet of paper would slip out, and his heart only sank deeper when he found that it hadn’t wormed its way there. 

 

A sneaking suspicion then came to Bilbo’s mind. It was one thing for one to lose an important note, but it was another thing altogether when the note was lost along with a winged messenger -- one who was skilled in delivering such notes. Had Garnet taken the note, then? But where would she go with it? The letter was one addressed to Bilbo, not from him. Panic began to rise in the hobbit’s chest. Surely she couldn’t have brought it back to the Blue Mountains! If Dis found out, then a double-betrayal would sit on Bilbo’s shoulders: one for revealing Thorin’s secret, that he was alive, and the other for keeping this very same secret from Dis, who trusted him like her own son.

 

When Bilbo decided that the situation was too curious to simply call it a coincidence, he packed his provisions up and began to travel again, this time with the whistle clutched firmly in his hand. Once in a while he would blow on it, in hopes that the bird would return to him, but she never did. He called her name, too, despite not knowing if she would even recognise it. It was a good few hours of walking before Bilbo spotted a gleam of red, tucked against the pebbly banks of the river. He rushed to examine it, and sure enough, it was a mottled feather that came from a small raven. Bilbo could never be sure, but he was almost certain that it was Garnet’s.

 

She was nearby, then! Then she surely would have heard the whistle, and the call of her master. What kept her from flying back to him? Bilbo waved the feather in his hand as he began to think. But then he saw another that laid on the ground away from the river, pointing towards the mountains. Whether it was deliberate or not, it would appear that Garnet had left a trail for him. So he began to venture towards the land. He knew fully well that it may take a long time for him to ever find the river again once he left it, but something within him spurred him on: a great curiosity of adventure, and some measure of desperation to ensure the safety of his bird. And the note from Thorin, of course. 

 

It was almost sundown when he found another feather resting at the base of a tall rock. When he bent over to pick it up, he found that the rock was carved in such a way that it made stairs leading all the way up to the top. Bilbo looked up, and his eyes lit up at a sight that he remembered from a long time ago. “Why, I know this rock! That’s the Carrock! Beorn’s very own viewing-stone!” he cried to himself. “Is she up there then, I wonder?” He cupped his hand to shield his eyes as he tried to look to the top of the rock against the glare of the setting sun. “Garnet? Are you up there, girl?” he called. 

 

And then, suddenly, a flash of mottled red flew before his eyes, so fast and furious that it almost knocked him down to his feet.

 

But the raven did not stop to perch on Bilbo’s pack. Up the winding stairs of the Carrock she swirled, sailing up, up, up, like a kite on a summer’s day, until her brilliant red form was nothing but a speck in the sky. “Why, that’s her! Garnet! Wait!” Bilbo leapt to his feet and began to scramble up the stairs.

 

“Where are you going? Come back!” Bilbo cried to the raven as he climbed the stairs. The steps were high, made for the wide stride of the Beorning, and much less so for hobbits -- every step reached his knees, and soon he was hauling, puffing, using as much arms as he did legs, dreading every step more than the last. It had been one thing to climb down the stairs of the Carrock, for all he had to do was to jump and land on his feet. He stared at the top of the cliff, so far away from view, yet he knew that something was there, waiting for him. Yes, there had to be. Ravens were smart like that -- the very best sort often got you into trouble if they were feeling up to it. Bilbo chuckled to himself. Oh, this would be one letter to write to Dis. Your lovely raven, my Garnet, while being of the very best sort, got into such mischief that had me climbing up the stairs of the Carrock! Oh, today would be a story to tell. 

 

Now this was adventure, Bilbo told himself as he continued to struggle up the stairs, feeling the familiar rhythm of thrill beat in his heart. Out here, climbing tall rocks, chasing ravens. Chasing answers to questions asked twenty years ago. 

 

Though he tried and tried with all his might, eventually the glare of the setting sun and the steepness of the steps were too much for him to handle all at once. He sat down on a flat step and took his pack off his shoulders, trying desperately to catch his breath. “Perhaps an afternoon tea is in order,” he said to himself, feeling his head spin as the exhaustion began to catch up to him. From his pack he retrieved a small brick of lembas bread which he had neatly broken off and wrapped up, and he began to nibble on it, pinching it between his fingers. 

 

“Oh, what am I doing?” he continued to say, to no one in particular. “Maybe this all meant nothing. Look at me, one flash of a raven and I go running up the most peculiar places. Now I’m lodged halfway upon a tall rock. Should I go up or down, then?” He chuckled. “Well, even if there’s nothing up there, I suppose it’ll make for a pretty good view.” 

 

He was about to take another bite of his bread when suddenly, he heard a brash cry which echoed through the plains, before dissolving into the gold-washed trees of the vales. “Garnet?” Bilbo stood up so quickly that his lembas dropped from his hands, and it fell from the edge of the step and out of sight. “Garnet!” He began to run up the stairs again, his pack left forgotten on the rock. The depth of the steps, thankfully, had begun to shrink as they neared the top, and without his provisions heavy upon his back Bilbo found himself more light-footed and suited for scaling the final stretch of the stairs. 

 

“Garnet?” At last, at long last, he had reached the top of the Carrock, washed aglow with the light of the setting sun. But it was then that he found that he was not alone.

 

His raven was there, but she was perched upon the arm of a man, and they both overlooked the sight beneath them. He wore a hooded cloak that fell to the floor, and his silhouette was so dark that Bilbo could not make out any colour, and barely the form of the man. But then,  he began to speak. 

 

“Ah, so you say your name is Garnet, mizimith ? Flown all the way from Ered Luin, you say! It must have been a long journey, then.” His voice was gruff and low, and the way he regarded the raven was almost fatherly, not unlike Dis and her manner of speaking with her beloved flock. But it also carried a gentleness that resonated with a voice that Bilbo knew all too well. His breath hitched, and he crept a step forward, careful to stay unseen. 

 

“Garnet, eh?” The man now said, chuckling softly to himself. “You have a most peculiar name for a raven, mizimith . It is not often that dwarrow would name their beloved pets after the jewels of the mountains. The naming habits of Halflings, on the other hand...” His voice drifted off then, first in fondness, and then it wavered slightly, faltering, as if uncertainty and suspicion had begun to creep into the very words he had left hanging in the air.

 

“Come again?” he said, slower this time. “You say you are loyal to a hobbit? Of the Blue Mountains?” And this time the words rang through the air until it reached Bilbo’s ears, like the sacred clang of the moment when the hammer met the anvil, forever changing the form of the metal it tended. It was as though something in Bilbo’s fate was sealed at the very moment in time. 

 

“ Mizimith …” From Garnet’s beak he plucked a folded note, and as it moved under the glow of the sun Bilbo saw that it glimmered, as if it had been coated with gold-dust. The paper was fragile, as if it had been rain-soaked and sun-baked, all while lodged in the gaps beneath a round, green door with a golden knob. 

 

“Where did you get this?” 

 

And for a moment Bilbo wanted to retreat. To sneak down the stairs, back the way he came, and then over the Misty Mountains, and back to his cosy little room in Ered Luin. For surely, it was a ghost and nothing more that fell before his eyes, and if he tried to catch it, it may crumble in his hand.

 

Bilbo had caught a butterfly once, down the Hill by the Brandywine River. He was a mere fauntling then, and in his excitement he had seized the poor creature with too much fervour and crushed its fragile wings in his chubby fingers. When he opened his fist again, the butterfly was no longer beautiful, but a crushed mess of crumpled colours and insect gut. And Bilbo feared that, if he pursued these ghosts with too much vigour, they, too, would disappear before his very eyes. A brief dream, and nothing more.

 

But there was a bigger part of Bilbo, one made of Tookish courage and good hobbit-sense. For the fact of the matter, he knew that he was witnessing something that was alive and real. He could feel the rock of the Carrock beneath his feet, he could hear perfectly well and see clearly, and if Garnet was real, then so, too was the man before his eyes. His senses never betrayed him, and surely, they wouldn’t fail now. So he took a deep breath and took a step forward. 

 

“I believe that’s mine, actually. The note, I mean. But you would know that.”

 

The figure froze. He whispered something to the raven, and the bird took flight, and disappeared from sight. Then he began to turn towards Bilbo in a slow, sweeping motion, until, beneath his cloak, he stared directly at the hobbit. 

 

“Wouldn’t you, Thorin?”

 

Then the figure raised his hands to his face and threw back the hood of his cloak. Dark, silver-tinged hair spilled onto his shoulders, and two blue eyes regarded Bilbo, wide with wonder.

 

And there Thorin was. 

Notes:

Mizimith -- jewel that is little. Quite fitting for Garnet, no?

I told y'all this would be raven ex machina. Now to see what happens next... ;)

C&C welcome, just leave it down there! Or hmu on Tumblr, I'm @/small-flower there.