Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

A Happy Birthday for Billy?

Summary:

The answers to where Billy's mom and Max's dad are, and how they relate to present events on Billy's Birthday. Neil Hargrove and Susan Mayfield are mainly discussed, but no actual appearance here.
Billy's 18th Birthday has a few unexpected twists and turns, but in the end, things work out the way they should. It's just too bad it didn't happen sooner! What's a little murder here and there for love?
Yes, this is a re-post since it is Billy's Birthday.... Maybe one day I'll write a new one but I really like how this came out!
I suck at summaries.

Notes:

I put this together for Billy's Birthday to answer a few things I always wondered but are only answered on occasion.

I did not run it by my beta since it's a short story, so any mistakes, crappy grammar, or crappy writing are all on me.

Work Text:

A Happy Birthday for Billy?

 

                Suddenly, he jerks awake on his 18th birthday to the sound of booted feet running up the stairs and yelling. He can hear pounding on his door, Max’s, Neil and Susan’s. The kids are asked to grab some clothes and escorted out. Billy did a little early celebrating last night at the quarry with a bottle of whiskey ‘borrowed’ from Harrington’s father’s collection of expensive liquor. Steve bought it when he met him there. He followed the directions of the black clad FBI agent as quickly as he could with the spike being driven into his skull at every loud noise and heartbeat.

                He has no clue what the hell is going on, but thinks if this is a prank for his birthday, someone will die. It isn’t funny since the sun hasn’t broken the horizon yet. Billy hates Neil with a passion. The man beats him any time he feels like it. Billy has become his personal punching bag, and target of a million slurs about what Neil assumes (correctly) is his attraction to men only. He and Steve had started dating over Christmas break, but that was a long time coming. Billy did not have a choice of where to live though. His mother left him late at night on his tenth birthday, and while he talked with her once or twice in the following weeks, she broke her promise to come back for him, and she stopped calling. She just disappeared off the face of the earth.

                Billy hates Susan too. The meek mouse of a woman with bony wrists and makeup covering her bruises and her lifeless red hair. It is the same color as Max’s, but while Max’s is like a raging fire, Susan’s is lifeless and dull, like the woman herself. She would just disappear the minute Neil starts yelling at Billy, though sometimes she would sneak in his room after with ice packs and painkillers often “borrowed” from her nursing job, though most often it was Max that took care of him. Little Max, whom he had briefly gotten along with when their parents met within a year of Billy’s mom leaving, a spitfire he got along with at first, but he started to resent when she became his responsibility. They even made him her legal guardian effective at 12:01 this morning. They get along much better now, but there was a really rough patch when they left the Cali beaches for the endless piles of cow shit and snow of Indiana.

                Once Billy realized she heard what Neil was doing to him and hid under her bed in case she was next, she started being his nurse. She was barely 14 now, and has been doing that for years. It disgusted Billy, but he is stuck. Yes, he has his own car. A blue Camaro he worked his butt off rebuilding from scrap for 2 years. But any money he earned now went to gas. Cigarettes, and fake dates with girls to keep Neil off his and Harrington’s tails. They are both dead if Neil finds out.

                Billy finds Max already out front by the time he got dressed, sitting in a van with a female agent and drinking hot chocolate. Someone hands him a cup of coffee, and when Max sees Billy she immediately goes over to him trying to find out what is happening. Neither one knows, though the agent promises Chief Hopper, who Max asked for, was on his way. Neil and Susan still have not come out of the small house on Cherry Ln, but most of the neighbors are up and watching, nosy sons of bitches, Billy thought. No one tells them anything that is happening but the kids were briefly separated and questioned. Billy is asked about his mother leaving, then ceasing contact, and Max is asked about her father, who died about the same time. They are individually asked what they know about their parents meeting, with Billy being far more informative. Max was only 7 to 8 years old during that period.

                While the kids are being questioned, a few things happen they would find out later. The biggest one being their parents are arrested for murder and conspiracy to commit murder. Susan and Neil were removed from the house and taken away while Billy and Max were being questioned, and the female agent accompanied Max to pack a few days’ worth of clothes and other items she would need, and Billy was taken to do the same by a male agent. They are informed that they are being placed in Chief Hopper’s custody temporarily while the FBI completes searching the house and Neil and Susan’s cars. Billy is allowed to take his, and as an 18 year old with legal guardianship of Max he will be the one kept informed by the Chief for the time being, and updated as things progress.

                They follow Hopper to his cabin hidden in the woods where he lives with Max’s best friend El. Max and El are sharing El’s room for now, and El is practically vibrating out of her skin waiting for Max to arrive. Billy is given a choice of the pullout sofa in the living room or Hopper’s room. He chooses the pullout so Max can find him easily if she needs him. Hopper nods approvingly. Hopper explains to Billy and Max, whom he has already had excused from school for the next 3 days, the FBI arrested Neil and Susan based on ‘alleged’ crimes in California. Hopper asks the shocked kids if they know of any crimes committed in Hawkins or Indiana. Billy asks if nightly DWIs count, and Hopper says no, not if he wasn’t caught at the time.

                Max says the one thing Billy had been praying she wouldn’t. “What about Neil beating Billy black and blue and Susan ignoring it?”

                Billy’s head drops into his hands. He really does not want anyone knowing about that now that he is 18.

                Hopper growls out the words to his question. “After everything we have been through, why didn’t you tell me sooner.”

                “Neil would have literally killed me if he found out I told you once he got a slap on the wrist from the court. It happened in California already when a teacher figured it out. That’s why they moved us here.” Billy answers without making eye contact.

                “Do you want to press charges? Do you have any proof?” Hopper asks.

                “Hospital records from California, one from here, and Harrington insisted on taking pictures just in case. I would go there a lot after a bad one.”

                “You kids are going to kill me with your secrets.” Hopper states, sounding fondly exasperated, but still exasperated.

                “I will think about it, but if I have to testify, no.”

                “Do you remember dates and hospitals?”

                Billy goes to his bag and pulls out a shoe box with six or seven hospital wrist bands in it as well as other memorabilia. “Will these help?”

                “I’ll see if I can get the files, as well as the pictures from Harrington. I need you two to stay here today until I know what is going on, but Billy, you can have Steve over, just have him bring the pictures.”

                Billy gives him a poor imitation of a salute. “Yes, sir.”

                “Walk me out to the car, would you Hargrove?”

                Max and El disappear into her room, knowing they have the time to do whatever they want. Max bought a bunch of comics with her.

                “I need you to keep a close eye on Max. This will hit her sooner or later. I will call or come back as soon as I know what Neil and Susan were arrested for. Call me at work if you need anything, and I will have Flo put you or Max’s calls right through, okay?” Hopper slaps Billy lightly on the back.

                Billy nods, watches Hopper leave, and goes inside to call Steve.


                Steve has taken today off from the video store since he had plans for Billy’s birthday. Most involved them both in their birthday suits and creative uses for cake frosting. That went out the window when Hopper called. Steve gathered up the cake he had baked, leaving the extra frosting behind, and stopped at the grocery store, after notifying a few people plans changed and the party has to be cancelled, and went out to the cabin. The girls mostly stay in El’s room, and the guys talk, watch TV, go outside to smoke, and make out once or twelve times.

                Steve makes Billy’s favorite for dinner, his 7 layer lasagna with homemade sauce and meatballs, garlic bread, salad and he bought over some wine. They was more than enough for the four kids plus Hopper, who came home at 5:00.

                Hopper sits the two boys and two girls down when he gets home, with Billy and Max okaying the others’ presence. Hopper explains Susan and Neil were arrested on two counts of murder and conspiracy to commit murder each. Susan had admitted they were guilty of both. They were having an affair before their spouses ‘left’. To clear the path to be together, when Billy’s mother got tired of the beatings and left, once Neil tracked her down, Neil beat her up badly, and Susan, a nurse at the time, previously gave Neil enough morphine to kill her (and several others) in a syringe for that specific purpose. He used the morphine to finish the job. She was unidentified and considered an addict until last week, so it wasn’t really pursued.

                Neil did some research and picked some extremely poisonous mushrooms for Susan to feed her husband. Since Max hated mushrooms, she knew she would be safe serving them in her husband’s salad only. She carefully cleaned up the kitchen and washed the dishes thoroughly afterwards, taking the scraps out to the compost pile, where they have long since rotted. When her husband passed away in his sleep, toxicology tests looking for drugs came back negative, though there was damage to his liver, assumed to be from drinking. Susan had no idea what Neil was really like, and deeply regretted helping them both get free and marrying, as well as collecting on a healthy life insurance policy on Peter Mayfield. Susan had put half aside for Max’s college education, and she and Neil kept the other half, buying their house in California then Hawkins with it. There is cash left over since Hawkins is much cheaper.

                Since the insurance legitimately paid out the money though the manner of death wasn’t natural, the house will wind up in Billy’s name, as well as the cash they have left, and Max’s college fund will be left alone. Billy is saddened, but not surprised his mother is dead, specifically at his father’s hands, but he has suspected she was dead after he hadn’t heard from her in several months. Billy’s mother had finally been identified by dental x-rays once they knew she might not be an addict, and samples saved at Peter Mayfield’s autopsy tested positive for toxins in certain mushrooms that grew near their home in a National Forest. A cold case detective had started checking due to the odd timing of everything. Steve apologizes to Billy several times, as does Hopper, for having to tell him this on his birthday. Hopper offers to convert a large smokehouse along the driveway to the cabin into a 2 bedroom cottage for Max and Billy so they don’t have to go back to Cherry Ln. and Hopper only expects money for utilities in return so they can stay together after Billy finishes school in about 6 weeks. This will allow Hopper to do the usual social worker drop-ins since he is licensed to do things like that and foster parenting. Billy agrees if Hopper also takes rent once they sell the house on Cherry Ln..

                Dinner is subdued, with Max and Billy pushing their food around more than eating it, though Billy did drink 2 glasses of wine. After everyone else has gone to bed, Billy and Steve stay up talking for a while. Hopper has already pulled out the sofa bed and made it up for Billy to sleep in, so the boys mostly talk at the table or outside while smoking. After some time just talking and holding hands on the table, or Billy getting birthday kisses outside, he is feeling much better. He has realized Neil is gone forever, as is Susan, and having some money is a freedom he never had before. Yes, he is legally responsible for Max, but he already knew that, just now it won’t be under Neil’s roof. Max said, before bed, that even though she was sad her mother killed her father, her mother has been dead inside for so long, she wasn’t really around anyway, and besides, she likes Billy more than Susan as her parent.

                “Well, Stevie.” Billy says once his mood is improved. “looks like you get to be an evil stepmother to Max now.”

                “Maybe I’ll be an evil stepfather.” Steve shoots back.

                “Oh please. The kids already call you mom.”

                “Point taken Hargrove. Does this mean you want to get married to me?” Steve teases Billy.

                “Let’s just leave it at I would love to have you move in if Hopper agrees. If not, we redecorate and move into Cherry Ln.. Marriage isn’t legal for us yet, but someday I hope.”

                “Is that your birthday wish?”

                “No baby.” Billy says softly. “My wish came true when I heard Neil is going to jail for the rest of his life and I can be with you.” He gives Steve a soft, chaste peck on the lips.

                Both are unaware of the eyes watching from Hopper’s bedroom door, with a smile on his face, owing Joyce $20 for having figured out things about the boys before they did.   

 

 

Series this work belongs to: