Actions

Work Header

Baggins of The Shire

Chapter 16: Chapter 15 - Thorin's Bargain

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo could scarcely believe his eyes, Thorin had awoken! He drank the dwarf’s visage greedily, soaking in the tender look Thorin gave him. Fresh tears fell from Bilbo’s eyes.

 

“Am I still dreaming?” Bilbo asked, “Because if I do then I would rather not wake up.”

 

Thorin wiped Bilbo’s tears from his cheeks with his broad hands.

 

“Do not weep bunnanunê , this is no dream.” said Thorin.

 

Bilbo could not hold himself any longer, he climbed on Thorin’s cot and embraced the dwarf. Thorin’s arms wrapped around Bilbo in return. They held each other close for a long moment and Bilbo felt all of his grief and worry melted away. When they finally parted, Bilbo’s eyes were dry and a bright smile once again graced his face.

 

“How long have I slumbered?” Thorin asked.

 

“It has been a week since the battle was won,” Bilbo answered.

 

“So we did win,” said Thorin to himself.

 

Thorin tried to sit up straighter but he winced as he pulled at the wound on his side.

 

“Please stay still, you were grievously injured.” Bilbo fussed at him, “I should call Óin!”

 

“Aye, I think that will be for the best.” Thorin agreed with him, “Something happened to me when I was unconscious… and I do not know what to make of it.”

 

Bilbo looked at Thorin worriedly. However, it became apparent that the dwarf would not explain any further. With a last look at Thorin Bilbo left the chamber. Bilbo walked with lighter feet as he searched for Óin. Finally he found the old dwarf in the kitchen. Some members of the company were there with him. Bombur was stirring a pot, Nori and Glóin were eating from a bowl on the small table, and Óin was examining the herbs.

 

“Óin!” cried Bilbo, “Thorin is awake!”

 

The dwarves were heartened by the news and they hurriedly went with Bilbo to see Thorin. When they got to the chamber, Óin immediately went to Thorin to check on him. Óin went to undo Thorin’s bandages to see if he had torn any of the stitches with him moving around. However, by Óin’s surprise he found that the wound was much more healed than it was supposed to be.

 

“Tahmadi targmê! This is most unusual!” said Óin, “But I will not question good fortune! We need to take out the stitches so you may heal the rest properly.”

 

Thorin grumbled good naturedly at Óin. Óin was about to put the bandages away before he spotted something on Thorin’s chest.

 

“Thorin… you’ve got the mark of Mahal on you…”

 

Gasps was heard from the dwarves and Bilbo saw it. On the left side of Thorin’s chest, right above his heart, a spiky rune in Durin’s blue. The rune was shaped like two towers with a curved bridge between them. Thorin looked down at his own chest with bewilderment,

 

“It was not just a dream…” he said softly.

 

“Whatever you mean by that?” Glóin asked.

 

“Before I answer… Óin, could you please check on the lads?” asked Thorin.

 

Óin looked like he was about to argue but he relented and went to check on Fíli and Kíli. Much to everyone’s surprise, their wounds were also at the later stage of healing. However there were no unexplained marks on the young dwarves. Thorin didn’t look surprised at all and Bilbo started to be very worried of what may caused their miraculous recovery.

 

“Now would you care to explain?” asked Bilbo.

 

“I…” Thorin hesitated before he heaved a great sigh, “I met Mahal in my dream.”

 

This was met with various exclamations from the dwarves. Bilbo just looked at Thorin expectantly.

 

“I’m still trying to wrap my mind around it.” Thorin continued, “The lads should wake up soon, and when they wake up I shall know that what had happened to me was true and not just a fevered dream. I shall tell my story when the lads are awake.”

 

None of them was entirely satisfied with the answer but Thorin was unmoved.

 

“Keep your secrets for now!” huffed Óin, “Call for Dori! We should sort you out in the meanwhile.”

 

Off went Nori to look for his older brother, Bombur also excused himself to go back to his duties in the kitchen, and Glóin went to share the good news with the others. Not long after, Nori came back with Dori and Ori. Dori quickly went to work with Óin while Ori came to Bilbo.

 

“Is Fíli…?” asked the young dwarf hesitantly.

 

Ori’s hopeful look filled Bilbo with shame. He had been so blinded in his grief that he didn’t notice that he wasn’t the only one hurting? Ori had came in every evening when he can be spared from his scribing duties to tell them the going ons in the mountain, Dwalin had came in and sit silently with him on many nights, and Bofur had brought his meals with Bilbo’s, trying to coax Bilbo out of the room all the while they ate.

 

“He sleeps still.” Bilbo answered, “But you should not worry, Óin said he is much better and Thorin thinks he will wake up soon.”

 

Ori nodded at Bilbo’s answer and he sat back quietly, watching his brother as he worked on Thorin. Óin examined Thorin’s wound when Dori finished taking out all of his stitches.

 

“Good work Dori.” Óin nodded satisfiedly, “Now if you can stand, I rather you clean yourself before I put more salve on it.”

 

Hearing that Bilbo went to Thorin’s bedside to help. Thorin suffered Bilbo’s fussing with patience and slowly he managed to stand up unassisted. After Óin was convinced that the King Under the Mountain wouldn't slip and die a truly embarrassing death in the bathing chamber, he sent Thorin off to clean himself.

 

“Now lad unless you want to join Thorin in his bath, I suggest you go to the kitchen and get a bowl of broth for him.” said Óin to Bilbo with a smirk.

 

Bilbo blushed furiously, Óin looked too amused for Bilbo’s liking but he went off to do as told. When Bilbo came back with a steaming bowl, he saw that Thorin had finished bathing and fresh bandages had been secured on him once more. The dwarf was trying to brush out his hair but kept wincing as he pulled on his injured side. Bilbo set the bowl down on the table, next to the assortments of beads and clasps that usually resided in Thorin’s hair and beard, and went to Thorin’s side.

 

“Let me help?” Bilbo asked.

 

The prideful dwarf hesitated for a little bit but relented.

 

“Please.” said Thorin.

 

Bilbo took the comb from Thorin’s hand and started to work on his hair. He started by carding the wet hair with his fingers, scratching Thorin’s scalp gently and carefully detangling whenever his fingers were caught. Then Bilbo started to comb. He started from the bottom of the hair and slowly worked his way up. Eventually Bilbo could run the comb smoothly all the way from the roots to the end. Thorin had closed his eyes when Bilbo was done.

 

“Would you like me to braid it for you?” Bilbo asked.

 

“Yes.” sighed Thorin without opening his eyes.

 

Bilbo smiled at the content expression on Thorin’s face. He parted the hair and started to braid. He hummed softly while working, enjoying the feel of Thorin’s coarse hair between his fingers. Bilbo carefully weaved two braids leading away from Thorin’s face before joining it in one braid down the back of his head, threading the beads as he worked. He continued to add two loose braids down the side of Thorin’s face, just the way the dwarf always wore it during their journey. Bilbo secured the clasps at the end of the braid and stood back to examine the result.

 

“That’s a job well done, If I do say so myself.” said Bilbo.

 

Thorin ran his fingers through his own hair, gently tracing  the braids that Bilbo has done.

 

“It is very well done.” Thorin agreed with Bilbo.

 

“Thank you,” Bilbo smiled brightly, “Now, do you think you can stomach some broth?”

 

“I should try,” said Thorin.

 

Thorin sat back on his cot and Bilbo handed him the bowl of now-cool broth. Bilbo sat down in what he now referred to as ‘his chair’ and watched Thorin slowly sipping from the bowl. Bilbo was burning with curiosity for the dwarves’ miraculous healing and the mark on Thorin’s chest.

 

“The Valar rarely give without their due,” Bilbo gave in to his curiosity, “Will you be alright?”

 

“I..” Thorin hesitated, “The price asked was one I would gladly pay… if it's true. But I ask you for your patience amrâlimê , for I need to see Fíli and Kíli well before my eyes before I can truly believe.”

 

Bilbo accepted Thorin’s answer without much complaints. They proceeded to speak of other matters and Bilbo told Thorin about the going ons in the mountain while he was asleep.  Around nood, Fíli started to stir, he was followed closely by Kíli. Again, Óin was swiftly summoned and again he pronounced that the boys were well on the mend.

 

“Did you see anything while you’re asleep?” Thorin asked Fíli and Kíli.

 

“I was in a dark place though I do not know for how long. Then I saw a bright light before me and I woke.” Fíli answered.

 

“The same thing happened to me,” said Kíli.

 

Thorin took a deep breath and he said to Óin,

 

“Gather the company, I have a tale to tell.”

 

Soon enough the company came trickling down into the chamber, Dain and Gandalf came with them. Chairs were brought in but some of them still had to stand or sit on the floor, the room was small and there were many of them.

 

“I’ve been told that you have been marked by Aulë himself,” said Gandalf, “I’m most interested in this tale.”

 

“Aye. Listen well and try not to interrupt,” said Thorin to the room, “It is not an easy tale to tell.”

 

Everyone quieted down and listened with rapt attention.

 

“After I fell in battle I woke up in a great hall. It was the most wonderful hall I have ever laid my eyes upon, even the halls of Erebor in its height of glory paled in comparison. The pillars were wrought out of gold, silver, iron and bronze with skills unknown to dwarves. The ceilings were filled with magic webs woven of the light of Kaminzabduna  and the glint of great stars.

 

In the middle of the hall stood a man, he was taller than any men or elves, his eyes were like starlight, his hair and beard was long and they shone and flickered like fire. Behind him was a great forge and before him was an anvil made out of bright stone, brighter than any diamonds I have ever seen, brighter than the Arkenstone. It was that that I realized, I stood before our maker. He saw me and he called me by my true name.

 

“So I have died.” I said to him.

 

“That is yet to be determined.” he answered me. His voice was like the shifting of the earth.

 

“What do you mean?” I asked him.

 

“Your line has been tainted by The Corrupter, Thorin son of Thráin, son of Thrór  and I was ready to end it with you. But my wife heard the prayer of one of her children and reminded me of my love for you.” he said.

 

“Bilbo…” I whispered to myself for it was your prayer, child of the kindly west, that had stayed the hand of my maker.

 

“Come look.” he gestured to the forge.

 

I gazed into the fire and I see you Bilbo, deep in prayer by my bedside. I thought of the taint that was in our line. The reason for my grandfather’s gold lust, my father’s restlessness, and my own madness became clear to me.

 

“What about my sister-sons?” I asked, “Are they tainted too?”

 

“The corruption did not pass to your sister-sons but their life too is in precipice.” he answered.

 

The fire flickered and I saw them. Fíli was lying supine, his chest rattled with every belaboured breath. Kíli was so pale and wan, his breaths were barely there. And I wept for you my lads. 

 

“Please spare them!” begged the maker, “Take my life but please let them live.”

 

“But your life is no longer in your hand.” he told me.

 

“Then for all of the riches in Erebor, spare them!” I cried.

 

“Riches? You forgot that I am Aulë. I forged all of the lands and the mountains, mine are the gems that lie deep in the Earth and the gold that is fair in the hand. I taught the skills of your people to your forefathers.” he boomed out.

 

I was struck with fear and awe. I prostrated myself before him and asked for his forgiveness.

 

“Forgive me o Mahal for I am nothing before you!” I said, “But what could I offer you for the life of my kin?”

 

He looked at me with his bright otherworldly eyes and I felt judgement.

 

“You could offer me your deeds,” he said. “Will you bargain for your life so you may bargain your deeds for your sister-sons’ life?”

 

“For my sister-sons’ life I will.” I answered him, “But what can I offer you for my life? With nothing I was brought to this world and with nothing I stand before you now.”

 

“There is one thing you have carried from the day of your birth and forevermore that you can offer.” he said.

 

“What do you mean My Lord?” I asked.

 

“You can offer me your birthright , Thorin, son of Thrór, son of Thráin, descendant of Durin, the first of my children. The battle has been won, my children will once again prosper in the Lonely Mountain, but you will not be King . You must leave Erebor and let others sit on your throne.” 

 

I was struck silent by his answer for it is not a small thing that was asked. I will live but I will have to abandon our newly reclaimed home. But compared to your lives irakdashatumê , it was nothing.

 

“Then I offer you my birthright in exchange for my life.” I said, “And what would you have me do for my sister-sons’ lives?”

 

“The Great Enemy had seduced many of my servants and his darkness still lingers in the world. Even now he whispers in the ear of my people. I have grown weary in repairing the tumults and disorders of Melkor but it is the will of Eru that I continue to do so.” said he.

 

At that moment he looked ancient, older than the world, older than creation itself.

 

“How may I assist you in your duty?” I asked.

 

“Darkness will once again come to middle-earth and you will have a part in vanquishing it once and for all. Your part will be made known to you when the time comes and once you’ve done your part, should you survive your duty, you may once again return to Erebor.” he answered me.

 

His words were heavy on my shoulder for it was a great duty that he had given to me. But they also gave me hope.

 

“I shall do as my Lord Maker wished.” I gave him my word.

 

“For my love to you I shall give you a boon.” he smiled, “You shall know peace my child. Until it is time for you to do your duty you shall live in peace.”

 

He came to me and bid me to stand up. He placed his hand upon my chest and he pushed. Everything went dark and I woke up here this morning.” Thorin finished his story gravely.

 

A hushed silence fell in the room, they are not sure what to make of Thorin’s story.

 

“What a grand tale!” Gandalf broke the silence, “And full of dark tidings! But the mark on your chest tells me that it is true.”

 

As if Gandalf had opened a door, questions came from the dwarves.

 

“So you must leave Erebor?” asked Balin.

 

“Aye.” answered Thorin gravely.

 

“Thorin, you cannot do this. You're our king!” said Dwalin.

 

“Did you not listen, my friend?” asked Thorin, “By the will of Mahal I will not be king.”

 

“But who will be king?” asked Dori.

 

“Fíli is my heir.” Thorin answered.

 

“But uncle!” exclaimed Fíli, “I do not think I am ready!”

 

“I’m sorry to leave this burden upon your shoulder madtithbirzulê , I was only ninety five when my father was lost. ” said Thorin kindly, “You have shown me the marks of a great ruler, you shall be wise and just. And you shan’t be alone!”

 

Thorin turned to Kíli,

 

“Will you stand by your brother, protect his back from harm, and support him in all of his deeds?”

 

“Aye uncle, I will.” said Kíli with resolve.

 

“Balin my old friend, long have you offered me your wise counsel. Will you continue to do so for my heir?” Thorin asked Balin.

 

“Aye I will.” said Balin with tears in his eyes.

 

“Dain, I do not ask this lightly from you, but will you stay in Erebor and help him rebuild the mountain to its former glory?” Thorin asked Dain.

 

“Aye cousin, I will.” said Dain gravely.

 

“Dwalin, you have been their protector since they were a babe. Will you continue to do so?” asked Thorin to Dwalin.

 

“I am honoured, but I rather follow you where you go.” said Dwalin stubbornly.

 

“I’m honoured to hear that my friend. But for my sake, please stay and stand as the King’s guard. Protect them where I can’t.” Thorin pleaded.

 

“Aye.” Dwalin relented, “Aye I will.”

 

“And to all of you,” Thorin addressed the room, “Do you accept the claim of Fíli, son of Dis, daughter of Thráin?”

 

“Aye.” the dwarves answered as one.

 

“Then I name you Fíli son of Dis, King Under the Mountain!” declared Thorin.

 

“Shamukh Fíli Disnul! Uzband undu ‘Urd!”   the dwarves replied as one.

 

Fíli looked at the room with trepidation but he steeled himself and accepted his duty with grace.

 

“By the labour of many I have come into this inheritance and by the labour of many more the mountain shall be made home for our people.” said Fíli.

 

Bilbo never saw the young dwarf with such grim determination. Fíli would make a good king, he would value the welfare of his people above all. Then Kíli voiced the question that was niggling at the back of Bilbo’s mind.

 

“Where shall you go uncle?”

 

“I have thought of it and I shall go back to my anvil in Ered Luin, though the halls might be much emptier as our people came back here,” said Thorin.

 

The thought of Thorin alone in the halls of the Blue Mountains does not sit well with Bilbo. Suddenly a thought occurred to him,

 

“Ahem!” Bilbo cleared his throat. When he had the chamber’s attention he continued, “Thorin Oakenshield, you have offered me your courtship in the way of my people. Now let me offer you my courtship in the way of Durin’s Folk. Come stay at Bag End for a year and a day, and for as long as you wish afterwards.”

 

“Would you still have me Bilbo? Even though I’m no longer king?” Thorin asked disbelievingly.

 

“I didn’t fall in love with the king.” said Bilbo, “I fell in love with a strong, proud, and stubborn dwarf who had done everything for his kin.”

 

“Then I gladly accept your invitation,” Thorin smiled.

Notes:

Khuzdul translation:
bunnanunê = my tiny treasure
Tahmadi targmê! = Bless my beard!
amrâlimê = my love
Kaminzabduna = Earth queen (the dwarves' name for Yavanna)
irakdashatumê = my nephews
madtithbirzulê = my little golden heart
Shamukh Fili Disnul! Uzband undu ‘Urd! = Hail Fili son of Dis, King Under the Mountain!

So this is the chapter that prompted the rewrite! In the original version Thorin was supposed to die but my muse just would not work with that. I really hope that this chapter doesn't feel too 'out there'. I had fun writing Aule!

According to the LotR Wiki Aule was the Valar most similar in thought and powers to Melkor, but he strove to be true to the original intent of the Music of the Ainurs and submitted all that he did to the will of Ilúvatar. Aule had three Maiar (that we know of) that was seduced by Melkor: Mairon/Sauron, Osse, and Curomo/Saruman. So yeah...he was sick of the dark side stealing his shit and ruining them.