Chapter Text
Sometime after the Troll incident, there was a smaller, less life-threatening and more embarrassing incident involving the young princes of Durin and Bilbo’s shirts. It had happened in the confusing mix of uncontrollable excitement on Bilbo’s part to finally wash the remnants of troll mucus off his body, and a poorly planned prank from Fili and Kili; they had tried to steal their burglar’s clothes and hide them somewhere far from the bathhouse, and wait to see if the hobbit would dare to streak across the Last Homely House in search of them or if he would rather drown himself in the bath. Instead what ended up happening was the clothes were found not one minute after being hidden by Thorin, who promptly threatened the brothers for a record amount of time and charged them with returning the clothes with an apology from both of them.
Bilbo, who normally would have been infuriated to learn he had almost fallen victim to a prank, let alone one that involved nudity, laughed when the boys explained themselves and apologized. His good mood from the relative safety and the bath and the food would not be ruined so easily by a harmless, failed joke. No, instead it would be ruined by Fili and Kili’s insatiable curiosity.
“Master Boggins, we were wondering about your shirts,” Kili began after Bilbo had accepted their apology, and Fili finished his question,
“Why do you embroider the color of the cloth into them, instead of your name?” The question had the blood draining from Bilbo’s face in a second, and had him rethinking the “harmlessness” of their prank. Unfortunately the boys were as stubborn as their uncle, so that added two more dwarves to the list of People Who Know Things They Shouldn’t Know. Fili and Kili were not as good at hiding their distress when Bilbo told them he probably didn’t have a soulmate, so Bilbo had faith that they wouldn’t betray his secret. In fact, the boys had volunteered to be his personal “color-identifiers” for the rest of the journey.
“Just point, and we can tell you what color it is. Simple, easy, no one even has to know about it! Watch, we’ll give you an example,” Fili cut himself off abruptly to point at one of the convenient water pitchers placed in each of the guest quarters they had been shown to. Fili doesn’t even have to look at his brother for Kili to catch on.
“Ah, yes dear brother, that light blue vase on the dark brown table in the corner is almost exactly the color of the water running through the white marble fountains these pointy-eared pansies are so fond of!” he said, emphasizing each color with overt winks thrown in Bilbo’s direction. The boys went on in that fashion for much longer than Bilbo thought they could, considering that the descriptions of almost everything in the room was either tan or white. As childish and playful as it was, Bilbo couldn’t help the sudden rush of emotion that knocked his breath away while he listened to the princes list off colors to him, exactly the way his mother used to. He knows Fili and Kili probably wouldn’t understand what’s got him so choked up, that filling in colors for someone who can’t see them is something so kind and intimate, done between family members and loved ones usually, not business-acquaintance-strangers you’ve only known for not even three weeks, that he just accepts the offer in exchange for sworn secrecy on their behalf.
Once Fili and Kili have made their oaths, they insist on showing Bilbo all across Rivendell, never once ceasing to describe, in much more detail than necessary, the colors surrounding them. Bilbo has to remind them both several times that colors like “teal” and “cerulean” and “sapphire” all look gray to him, so Bilbo has no way of knowing that all three of those colors are shades of blue. It was a nice distraction from the deep-seated and constant anxiety Bilbo had felt since he joined this ridiculous quest, just a fun game to play while they wait for a decision to be made by someone in charge, until the three of them stumbled upon the gardens.
Bilbo’s mother had told him so often about the gardens at Rivendell, always granting her son’s wish to hear about them again, no matter how many times she had told him before. No other tale of Belladonna’s had so much color in it as these gardens did. Bilbo knew, even as a child, this was no view to see in black and white. Yet, here he was: standing in his mother’s favorite spot in all of Middle Earth, looking around at what he must assume are the “blue lilies like no other garden in Arda, green ivy with leaves the size your you hand, vines dotted in the tiniest pink blooms you could ever see,” and the world is still grey.
The lighthearted mood of their earlier escapades dimmed quickly as the brothers watched their burglar’s eyes turn watery and shoulders fall as he reached out to touch a bright magenta dahlia. They shared a look, realizing maybe they had a bigger problem on their hands than previously thought.
It is that scene that Thorin walks by; he sees Fili lay a protective arm around the hobbit’s drooping shoulders and turn in toward the rest of the garden, walking through the greenery and pointing occasionally at some plant or another on their way. He sees Kili going deeper into the garden, picking up every fallen blossom, petal, or even leaves off the ground and returning triumphant to his brother and the burglar to show off his treasures. A few times, Bilbo would reach out and take one of the flowers Kili had found and keep it with him. Whenever he does that the brothers shoot each other a quick glance over the burglar’s head, some sort of secret communication taking place without any acknowledgement from the hobbit between them.
Thorin was too far away to hear what they’re talking about, but simply watching the scene gave him incredibly mixed emotions. Rationally, Thorin was happy to see Bilbo get along with his nephews, but the warm feeling of affection for his boys is quickly overtaken by jealousy. Totally unwarranted and unreasonable jealousy turned Thorin’s muscles to stone and almost tainted his vision red as he stared at the arm around his Heartsong’s shoulder, an arm that clearly is not Thorin’s, therefore had no place on that shoulder.
When rational thought decides to return to Thorin, the only emotions left are concern and confusion. He was ready to rip Fili’s arm out of its socket to keep him from touching the burglar that Thorin does not even like, for no logical reason whatsoever! Thorin beat a hasty retreat away from the gardens without being seen by any of the three inside and returned back to their guest rooms. For the sake of everyone involved, Thorin was ready to forget he ever even saw or felt a thing and return his attention to the task at hand.
At least, he tried to return his attention to the task at hand. But later that evening, when Fili, Kili, and Bilbo rejoined the group for a rebellious bonfire dinner, rather than eat the rabbit food the elves so “generously” prepared for them, the unchecked jealousy and possessive fire came back. The three of them were seated by the fire, the halfling squished between the two princes, hands still full of petals and leaves, and all of them laughing like they were children. It looked as though they had gotten into an impromptu flower fight, judging by the dusting of ripped petals and pollen stuck their hair. Bilbo himself had at one point put a great white flower behind his ear, the wide petals contrasting against his curly hair that seemed to glow with firelight. He was laughing breathlessly between Fili and Kili, his cheeks coloring with joy, and Thorin had never seen him so relaxed as he seemed there. He looked beautiful.
When that little thought flicked through Thorin’s mind he nearly crushed the bowl of stew he was holding, his knuckles having turned white in his grip without ever realizing. He set the bowl down with more force than necessary, garnering the attention of most of the company, three flower boys included. When he coughed out Khuzdul in their direction, not asking but ordering his nephews to follow him, he turned and walked away from the company before seeing the wide, confused, slightly terrified looks perfectly mirrored on the brothers’ faces. Thorin was going to end whatever was happening, and he planned on ending it tonight.
Bilbo had no idea just what Thorin had said to his nephews before rudely stomping off in the middle of dinner, but by the looks on Fili and Kili’s faces, it was nothing good. If Bilbo hadn’t been quite so concerned for the boys he would have laughed at the way they sprung up in tandem the moment after their uncle’s back turned the corner, quickly brushing off all the loose petals from each other’s clothes and hair, letting it all haphazardly fall onto Bilbo in their panic.
The brothers steeled themselves before joining their uncle away from the company. The rest of the dwarves turned back to their dinners, a much quieter affair than it was just a minute ago. When the palpable tension in the air diffused somewhat and light chattering began again, Bilbo made his way from where Fili and Kili had abandoned him over to sit with Bofur and Bifur.
“I know I probably shouldn’t even ask, but what just happened?” Bilbo leaned in towards Bofur, knowing that out of the dwarves present, Bofur was least likely to give him a hard time over his naive question. But Bofur just glanced over Bilbo’s shoulder to where the three Durin’s had went off to before replying,
“Honestly, I’m not quite sure myself. Wouldn’t be so surprised if it had something to do with the way you had the boys dressed up like fairies, with the flowers in the hair an’ everything.” Bofur made his point by picking a few scattered leaves off the ground and throwing them over Bilbo’s head with exaggerated arm waving included. Bilbo opened his mouth to say how he wasn’t the one who started that and not to blame Bilbo for the excitability of the two brothers, but the words died on his lips as he snapped them closed. If Thorin’s problem was with the flowers, which hopefully it wasn’t, but if it was that would mean either Fili and Kili are going to lie right to their uncle’s face about what they all were doing in the gardens, or they are going to give up his secret within 5 hours of learning it!
Coincidentally, just as Bilbo was hurtling himself into a self-inspired panic attack, the object of his anxiety decided to return as if on cue. Thorin was yet again stomping, this time towards the company, and this time also angrier if the look on his face was anything to judge by. And Bilbo was judging by it, since the burning look was directed solely and unerringly at Bilbo. He barely registered the rapid, flustered Khuzdul following from behind Thorin, coming from Fili and Kili. Bilbo couldn’t tell what they were trying to say, but their tone of voice was bordering on frantic, each of them trying to step in front of their uncle to no avail.
Thorin halted right in front of the makeshift fire, anger illuminated by the orange glow, fists clenched at his sides, a terrifying and regal picture if Bilbo ever saw one. Quite fitting too, since right there is where Thorin decided to carry out his, very public, interrogation.
“Burglar! Do you care to share what secret you have sworn my nephews to keep from me?”
Despite the incredibly terrible situation Bilbo now found himself in, he couldn’t help but feel touched that the young princes did not give away his secret. Of course, that little glimpse of positivity was inevitably short lived, as now Bilbo was the one who had to lie right to Thorin’s face. Looking up at the dwarf towering over Bilbo who was still sitting on the ground, lit up by fire and rage, the hobbit wasn’t so sure lying was his best option. Even if he could come up with a convincing lie, Bilbo was almost certain the repercussions for lying to the company leader and king were somewhere along the lines of death.
While the problems in the hobbit’s head were growing exponentially larger by the second, Bilbo realized he still hadn’t even responded to Thorin’s wild accusation. He barely squeaked out a, “What?” before Thorin was speaking again.
“What exactly are you hiding, Burglar? I would like to know just what you three were discussing in the gardens when you collected all of that ridiculous garbage!” Thorin’s face was absolutely thunderous at that point, and Bilbo could practically feel himself begin to drown under the pressure of his anger, feeling like a fool, just sitting on his arse covered in flowers, taking this verbal lashing as though he deserved it when he most certainly did not. “Whatever it was, it must be some secret, for even my sister-sons to keep it from me! In the favor of a halfling! Tell us all, Burglar, before you lose your place in this company.”
At that, Bilbo could see the other dwarves begin to grow visibly uncomfortable with the weight of Thorin’s threats. Bilbo even saw Nori shift towards them and open his mouth to interject, but a murderous look from Thorin kept him quiet. No, this was Bilbo’s fight, whether or not he wanted to fight it.
Bilbo took a shaky breath before looking away to Thorin’s boots, the weight of Thorin’s eyes still on him making his shoulders draw even closer to Bilbo’s ears. He couldn’t even look at Thorin when he stuttered out, barely over a mutter, “I don’t have my colors yet.”
“Speak clearly halfling, what are you-”
“I don’t have my colors yet.” Bilbo was still staring at Thorin’s boots, but the dwarves could all see the twisted expression on his face.
“We were in the garden because Fili and Kili were telling me the colors of the flowers. That’s it, I swear. Nothing that important,” Bilbo mumbled the last few words, saying them out loud in hopes that they might come true. Thorin and the rest of the dwarves were quiet for a moment. Thorin thinking about what had been said while Nori, Fili, and Kili looked between the three of them and silently wondered if they could all just leave it at that without any further explanation, thus saving their hobbit from further humiliation. But of course, Thorin was not satisfied.
“There is not reason to keep that a secret, Burglar. There must be more that you have not-”
“What do you want me to say?” Bilbo interrupted again, though this time, his head was lifted and he met Thorin’s stare with a thunderous one of his own. He stood abruptly, loose petals falling to the ground at the movement; his own hands were gripped into tight fists, and behind the anger morphing his face the pain from his confession was still visible.
“What do you want me to say? That I can’t see colors and I probably never will? That your nephews are the first ones to show me colors since my mother died? That I am utterly alone in this dull, dead, grey hellscape, surrounded by dwarves who have seen color their whole lives? Or maybe you want me to tell you that there is not a single hobbit left in the Shire who still believes that there is a soulmate out there for me, that not even I believe it, and that my missing half is either long dead, or they never existed, is that a good enough answer for you, Master Dwarf?”
Bilbo was breathing heavily by the end, standing toe to toe with Thorin, looking directly into his eyes despite the tears threatening to spill over at any moment. The anger was still there in his expression, but not just at Thorin, there was a deeper, older anger that Bilbo had obviously long since locked away. Bilbo took one deep breath and as he let it out he straightened his hunched shoulders and stiff back, raising his chin to keep eye contact with Thorin. Then, in a voice only audible to Thorin, “I knew you were rude and unkind, but I never realized how cruel you are.”
With that, Bilbo took the white flower from behind his pointed ear and tossed it to the ground at Thorin’s boots, watching it hit the stone beneath them and wilt. He turned around, and with a barely audible, “Goodnight,” to Bofur as he passed, went off to bed.
Thorin was frozen in his spot, at a complete loss of what to do next. Fili and Kili looked equal parts shocked and furious at their uncle and left Thorin's side before he could turn and face them. The rest of the company had mirroring looks of shock, still absorbing everything the hobbit had said. There was no more chattering as they all found their way to bed, just the sounds of bedrolls being laid out and packs being shifted.
That night, as Thorin laid to sleep, he felt again more than ever before, that he truly did not deserve the beautiful voice that sung in his dreams.
