Chapter Text
There’s a specific kind of loneliness that creeps in when your phone is fully charged, the room is quiet, and the person you want to talk to the most hasn’t replied in four days.
I know, because I’m living in it.
I’m curled up on my apartment floor — not the bed, not the couch, but the goddamn floor — staring at my phone like that’s going to make the notification pop up. Like if I blink hard enough, the “Jeno 🐾” contact will magically light up with a new message.
Nothing.
Just the same read receipt from Sunday.
I scroll up through our messages like they’re an exhibit in a museum. First are the silly ones — inside jokes about terrible webtoons, voice note reactions to café drinks, blurry cat pictures he’d send when he “missed me too much to think clearly.” Then the slower ones — typed late at night, half-asleep confessions like:
“You make me feel safer than real life.”
I don’t know when it happened. The fall. It wasn’t dramatic. There wasn’t a single moment where I said, oh no, I like him. It was just the slow build-up of too many things that felt too easy: the way he responded at the exact emotional frequency I spoke in, the way he sent me new Spotify playlists at 2 a.m. with captions like “for rainy mornings when you don’t want to talk to anyone but still want someone there.”
It felt real.
And now it feels like a trick.
I toss my phone onto the rug, rub my hands over my face, and groan into the stillness. My laptop is still open from earlier — I’d been editing a project for class, but all I’ve really done tonight is reread our messages and Google things like “signs your online boyfriend is ghosting you” and “how to find out if someone is catfishing you in Korea.”
I didn’t think I’d be that guy.
The paranoid one. The one who sends anonymous requests to TV shows or podcasts with titles like Ghost Signal or You Were Never There. The guy who gets exposed on camera, who says things like “But they told me they loved me” before the hosts gently tell him it was all a lie.
But maybe I already am.
Because here I am, hovering over the submission form for Catfish Korea, the tab open like a dare.
My thumb hovers over the mousepad. I hesitate.
Because what if I’m wrong?
What if something happened to him?
What if he’s embarrassed to face me?
What if he’s real, and I ruin everything by assuming the worst?
But then I remember the days — the exact number of them — that have passed without a single sign from him. Not even a meme. Not even a Spotify update. Just static.
And maybe worse than being wrong…
Is being right and never doing anything about it.
So, I exhale.
Click.
And start typing.
Hi, my name is Renjun. I’ve been in an online relationship with someone named Jeno for three months. He won’t video call. He disappeared for a week. And now I’m scared he’s not who he said he is.
I don’t think I expected anyone to actually respond.
After I hit submit on the Catfish Korea form, I slammed my laptop shut like it was going to explode. Then I went to sleep with a pillow over my face and prayed the Earth would open up and swallow me whole before I had to explain to anyone that I was dumb enough to fall for a voice behind a screen.
But two days later, the email came.
Subject line: “Let’s Talk About Jeno 🐾”
Now there’s a camera in my apartment.
And two strangers sitting on my tiny floor rug, sipping the crappy green tea I panic-brewed out of social obligation.
“Alright, spill,” Key says, clicking his pen with theatrical impatience. “Give us the whole story—from the very first ‘hi.’ No fluffy extras.”
I swallow hard. My throat’s dry. I’ve rehearsed this a million times in my head, but saying it out loud feels different. Like it makes it more real… and way more pathetic.
“I met him on Discord,” I start, avoiding their eyes. “Art server. We started talking after he complimented one of my paintings. He was smart. Funny. It wasn’t like… instant love or anything. Just—safe. Warm.”
Doyoung leans forward, resting his elbows on his knees, eyes soft but curious. “How long did it take before it felt like something more than friendship?”
I hesitate. “Maybe five or six weeks. It felt natural. We talked every day. He’d stay up late helping me with assignments, even though he had work the next morning. I didn’t even know what he looked like until week three.”
Key snorts, shaking his head. “Week three and still no FaceTime? That’s enough to make me suspicious. I mean, what was he, a ghost?”
I sigh. “He always had excuses—phone broken, Wi-Fi bad, not ‘presentable.’ At first, I told myself it didn’t matter. But then last week, he ghosted me completely. No texts. No calls. Nothing. And then yesterday, he just popped back in like nothing happened.”
Key raises an eyebrow, smirking. “So, the Houdini act was just a phase?”
“Yeah,” I say, pulling up the message and showing them.
Jeno 🐾: sorry. things were heavy. didn’t know how to talk to you. can we just pretend i didn’t mess it all up?
Doyoung hums thoughtfully. “That’s the classic ‘ghost-guilt gaslight’ combo. It’s like a bad rom-com script.”
“But he didn’t ask me for money,” I say, a little defensively. “He didn’t manipulate me. He just… disappeared. Like he panicked.”
Key and Doyoung exchange a look.
“We see this a lot,” Key says, folding his arms. “Sometimes it’s not about scamming. Sometimes people hide because they’re scared — scared of being found out, scared of being vulnerable. Fake profiles, real insecurities, complicated lives.”
Doyoung nods, voice softer now. “It’s hard to trust someone when you don’t even know their whole story. But that doesn’t mean what you felt was fake.”
I swallow hard. “So… what now?”
Key smirks. “We’re gonna find out what the hell is going on. No more hiding.”
Doyoung smiles gently. “Whatever happens, you’re not alone in this.”
Turns out, Jeno wasn’t that hard to find.
They traced his phone number through a secure database. The number was legit, and it was registered under the name Lee Jeno, age 22, currently living in Incheon. They found an Instagram account with the same name, same cat from the pictures, same sleepy eyes.
Real.
I should’ve felt relieved.
Instead, I felt sick.
Because if he was real — if the person I loved wasn’t fake — then he chose to hurt me on purpose. And somehow that felt worse.
“We contacted him,” Key says, leaning against the doorframe like he owns the place, a sly grin tugging at his lips. “He agreed to meet.”
I blink. “Wait—what?”
Doyoung nods, calm as ever. “In person. He said he wants to explain. Says he owes you the truth.”
I don’t realize I’m shaking until I try to zip my hoodie—and miss three times.
“What if he doesn’t like me in real life?” I whisper, voice barely a squeak.
Key snorts. “Please. If he can’t handle you in sweatpants and messy hair, he’s not worth your internet time. Honestly, I’ve seen people fall in love over potato emojis. You? You’re gonna be fine.”
Doyoung smiles softly. “The real world’s scarier than the screen, but that’s where the magic happens.”
We meet at a small park near Incheon Station. Public. Neutral. Safe.
He’s already there when I arrive, sitting on a bench with his hoodie pulled up and both hands shoved into his sleeves. He looks nervous. Just like his photos. Just like the sleepy-eyed guy who told me I made him feel safe.
I stop a few feet away.
“Jeno?”
He looks up — and when he sees me, he smiles. Not a fake grin. Not a performative YouTuber smile. Just soft. Familiar. Real.
“Hey, Renjun.”
My throat closes.
He sounds exactly like I imagined.
A little deeper, a little warmer.
Like coffee on a quiet morning.
I don’t know what I expected — stammering apologies? A long explanation?
What I didn’t expect was the way my body instinctively relaxed the moment I saw him. Like a string had been cut.
“You’re real,” I breathe. “You’re really you.”
He nods. “I’m sorry it took this long.”
Jeno’s POV
I’m early.
Of course I’m early. I’ve been sitting here for twenty minutes, pretending to scroll on my phone while my heart kicks around in my ribs like it’s trying to make a run for it.
I almost didn’t come.
When they contacted me — the Catfish team or whatever — I thought about saying no. About ghosting again, for real this time. Vanishing into the void I’ve spent years hiding in.
But then they said his name.
Renjun.
And I remembered the way he texts. Short and sarcastic when he’s trying to act cool, but secretly sweet under all the thorns. The way his voice goes quieter when he says things that matter. The way he told me, two months in:
“You don’t have to be perfect with me. Just be you.”
He was the most beautiful person I have ever seen and I think that is what made me so scared.
I wasn’t sure I knew how to do that.
Not with someone who looked at me like I was worth something.
So now I’m here. Hoodie up, palms sweating, knees bouncing. Waiting for the person I hurt more than anyone — and hoping like hell he doesn’t turn around and walk away the second he sees me.
And then—
He shows up.
Renjun.
Shorter than I pictured. Sharper in real life. That same focused expression, like he’s always thinking three things at once and judging himself for all of them.
He stops a few steps away. Says my name like a question:
“Jeno?”
I look up.
Smile.
Try not to look too terrified.
“Hey, Renjun.”
He stares. Long and hard. I think this is the part where he yells. Or turns around. Or tells the crew, “Yeah, cut it, I’m done.”
But he doesn’t.
He just exhales. Like something heavy finally let go.
“You’re real,” he says. “You’re really you.”
And I want to cry. Right there on the park bench like a loser. Because he sounds… relieved.
Renjun’s POV
We sit side by side on the park bench, with enough space between us to fit a secret. It’s late afternoon, that weird in-between time where the world is too golden to be sad, but I’m sad anyway.
I wait for Jeno to speak first.
But he doesn’t.
He just stares at his hands like they’re full of things he can’t say.
So I do it for him.
“You ghosted me.”
He winces like the word itself hurts. “Yeah.”
“I thought you were dead. Or fake. Or both.”
“I know.”
“You made me feel insane.”
“I know,” he says again, quieter this time.
The silence settles thick between us. Wind rustles the trees above like the universe is politely excusing itself.
“You want to tell me why?” I ask, finally turning to look at him.
Jeno bites his bottom lip, thinking. “I got scared.”
“That’s not an answer.”
He exhales, hands flexing once before curling tight again. “I liked you too much.”
That wasn’t the answer I expected either.
“You disappeared because you liked me?”
“No. I disappeared because I thought if you saw the full picture of me—if I couldn’t be the version you built in your head—you’d leave.”
I don’t say anything. I just listen.
“I’ve done this before,” he admits. “Gotten close to someone online. Gave too much, too fast. They found out what I looked like—my face, my job, my stupid cat fur-covered hoodie—and suddenly they were gone. No warning. Just… silence.”
His voice catches, and I hate that I recognize the sound. It’s what I sounded like in my apartment. Talking to ghosts.
“And then you came along,” he continues. “And you were so warm. So easy to talk to. You made me laugh when I didn’t even want to be awake. You called me ‘Jeno-ya’ like it meant something. And I thought, maybe if I can keep this going just a little longer, maybe if I don’t mess it up this time…”
“You didn’t mess it up,” I say.
He looks at me, surprised.
“I mean,” I correct, “you kind of did. Ghosting is, like, textbook red flag behavior.”
That gets a weak laugh out of him.
“But the part that hurts the most,” I continue, “isn’t that you lied or that you were scared. It’s that you didn’t trust me enough to be honest. Like I wouldn’t have accepted the real you. Like you decided for me.”
Jeno’s jaw clenches.
“I know. And I hate that I did that. I hate that I made you feel disposable. You’re not. Renjun, you’re—”
He breaks off, swallows hard, then finishes softer:
“You’re the best thing I’ve had in a long time.”
It’s not the perfect apology.
It’s not poetic or rehearsed.
But it’s real.
And after everything, that’s what I wanted most.
Real.
Jeno’s POV
When we sit down, I try to find the words.
He beats me to it.
“You ghosted me.”
Yeah. I did.
Every sentence after that hits like a stone. I want to take them all and put them in my pockets, let them drag me down like they should. Let the guilt settle the way it’s been waiting to.
I try to explain. I tell him about the fear. The past. The online conversations that crashed the second they touched real life.
But that’s not really the truth.
Not the full truth.
The full truth is:
I liked him too much.
I wanted to be someone worthy of his softness. His trust. His late-night voice notes and early-morning check-ins. But the more he gave, the more I panicked.
Because I’m not that person.
I’m anxious. I hide. I flake when things matter too much.
And I thought — if I ghost him first, maybe it won’t hurt as bad when he finally leaves.
But now he’s here.
And he didn’t leave.
And somehow that makes it worse.
“You didn’t trust me enough to be honest,” he says.
And he’s right.
I didn’t.
Not because he didn’t deserve it — but because I didn’t think I did.
When he tells me I didn’t ruin everything, I want to believe him.
When he teases me again — just a little — I know I’m not lost yet.
And when we part that night, no drama, no kiss, just a small wave and tired eyes, I still feel like I’ve been given something I didn’t earn.
A second chance.
Renjun’s POV
We don’t kiss right then.
This isn’t a movie. There’s no dramatic rain or swelling music.
We just sit there, shoulder to shoulder, until the sun sets and the shadows get longer. I don’t forgive him all at once. But I start to. Slowly.
We text again the next day. This time with voice notes.
Later, in my DMs:
Jeno 🐾: hey. i know i said it in person. but thanks for not walking away.
Renjun 🖌️: don’t make me regret it, idiot.
Jeno 🐾: promise.
A week later, we video call. He looks like himself, hoodie and all. I tease him about the nervous pimple on his chin and he fake-sulks for ten minutes.
Two months later, I move into a tiny studio fifteen minutes from his place.
He helps me carry boxes.
I let him alphabetize my tea stash.
And one morning, with our legs tangled on my bed and his face half-buried in my pillow, he murmurs, “You know I’m not gonna disappear again, right?”
I nod, sleep-heavy and soft around the edges. “I know.”
And this time, I believe him.
The email subject line makes me drop my phone into my cereal bowl.
CATFISH KOREA — UPDATE REQUEST: “Jeno 🐾 & Renjun 🎨”
I fish the phone out, oatmeal dripping onto my sleeve, and shout toward the bathroom:
“Jeno! What the hell did you do?”
There’s a thud, followed by muffled swearing and a very wet, very confused voice: “What?! I’m literally shaving??”
“You’re gonna wanna rinse fast. We’re about to be famous again.”
Fifteen minutes later, we’re sitting cross-legged on the floor with two mugs of cinnamon tea between us, both reading the email like it might explode.
They want us back.
For an update.
A throwback episode.
“Successful reconnections.”
Their words, not mine.
I glance at Jeno. His face is unreadable — which is terrifying, because this is the same man who once cried over a dog in a dumpling commercial.
“You good?” I ask.
He nods slowly. “Yeah. I just… forgot that people saw all of that. You know?”
I do.
Because that episode wasn’t just a cringey memory of me tearing up on camera and calling strangers to investigate my maybe-boyfriend. It was a snapshot of everything raw and real and messy about how we started.
Still, I say, “We should do it.”
Jeno looks over. “You think?”
“We lived through the awkward part already. Might as well show people the soft part too.”
He snorts. “We don’t have a soft part. You roasted my outfit this morning before I even opened my eyes.”
“That was a soft part. I only roast people I love.”
He blushes.
I win.
Jeno’s POV
When the camera crew shows up again two weeks later, everything feels… different.
Last time, I was terrified—heart pounding like it was trying to escape my chest.
This time, I’m casually brushing Renjun’s hair out of his eyes while he grumbles about the lighting and settles onto my lap like it’s the most natural thing in the world.
They start with the easy questions first.
“How’s life now?”
“Are you still together?”
“Any fights?”
Before I can even answer, Renjun grins and shoots back, “Only when he eats all my yogurt and lies about it.”
I laugh and shrug. “Love means never admitting guilt.”
Key chuckles from behind the camera, the corners of his eyes crinkling with amusement. “Classic couple move right there.”
Doyoung smiles softly, his voice calm and gentle. “It’s the little things that show how real it is.”
We all laugh. And for a moment, it’s just that—warmth, easy smiles, and small jokes. The kind of closeness that only makes sense after late-night headaches, quiet mornings where neither of you says much but everything is understood anyway.
Then Key leans forward, a more serious look settling over his face.
“So, would you say going through all that— the ghosting, the lies, the fear—was worth it?”
We both go quiet.
Renjun looks at me, and I look at him, and I think we both feel the same thing in that moment — how strange and rare it is to look back at something painful and feel gratitude instead of regret.
“Yeah,” I say softly. “It was worth it.”
Renjun nods. “It made us honest. Brutally, horribly honest. And I think that’s the only reason it worked.”
I squeeze his hand under the table.
Because he’s right.
The version of me from six months ago would’ve run the second that email hit my inbox. But now? I’m here. Next to the boy I ghosted. The boy who gave me a second chance. The boy who now eats all my fries and drools on my pillow and still calls me “Jeno-ya” like it means something.
Because now, it does.
Doyoung’s eyes soften. “Sometimes the hardest journeys lead to the most honest destinations.”
Key smirks, raising his eyebrows. “Alright, romance aside, I’m just glad you two made it through without killing each other.”
Renjun laughs, pulling me closer. “We’re still working on that part.”
And in that moment, with the cameras rolling and the world watching, it feels like home.
After the crew leaves, we’re curled up on the couch, watching reruns of something dumb with no real plot. Renjun’s half-asleep on my chest.
“You know,” he mumbles, “if we ever break up, we’ll have to fake it for the camera.”
I laugh. “We’re not breaking up.”
“You sound confident.”
“I’m confident in you.”
He hums, satisfied. Then after a pause: “I still think you lied about the yogurt.”
“I absolutely did.”
He swats my chest without opening his eyes.
I kiss the top of his head.
Offline, online, cameras or not —
We’re real now.
And that’s all I ever wanted.
🎥 Scene: Studio Interview – CHENLE (Renjun’s longtime best friend)
Producer: “So, Chenle-ssi, when did you first hear about Jeno?”
Chenle (grinning like the devil): “Oh, you mean *‘J,’ the mysterious internet boyfriend’? Renjun told me about him in pieces. Like, suspiciously vague pieces. ‘He’s really sweet,’ ‘he lives kind of far,’ ‘we haven’t video-called yet.’ I was like, okay, babe, so you’re in love with a wallpaper image.”
Producer: “What did you think when he called Catfish?”
Chenle: “Iconic. I was in the group chat like, ‘Yes, hunt him. Expose him. Drama!’ I didn’t think the guy would actually be real, much less hot.”
(he winks at the camera)
“Jeno, you’re lucky you’re cute. That’s the only reason I didn’t throw hands.”
🎥 Scene: Couch Interview – JAEMIN (Jeno’s best friend & unofficial therapist)
Producer: “Were you surprised Jeno agreed to meet Renjun in person?”
Jaemin: “I was surprised he didn’t pass out the second they made eye contact.”
(beat)
“I mean, Jeno’s the type to panic if someone likes his Instagram story too fast. And now he’s living with a guy he ghosted. Character development.”
Producer: “Do you like Renjun?”
Jaemin: “He’s weird, which is exactly what Jeno needs. Anyone too soft would’ve just let him spiral forever. But Renjun? That man argues for sport. Keeps Jeno grounded.”
🎥 Scene: Split-screen Zoom – HAECHAN (everyone’s chaos agent)
Producer: “You’re friends with both of them, right?”
Haechan: “I’m everyone’s friend. Except yogurt. Yogurt is Jeno’s enemy now.”
(winks)
Producer: “What’s it like seeing them together now?”
Haechan: “You ever watch two cats fight and then curl up in a sunbeam together? That’s them. Equal parts petty and disgusting. I’ve seen them argue over a sock and then fall asleep holding hands on the sock.”
Producer: “Do you think they’ll last?”
Haechan: “They better. I’ve already committed to being the flower boy at their wedding. And I’m wearing pink crocs. Non-negotiable.”
🎥 Scene: Cafe Interview – MARK (Renjun’s calm friend / Jeno’s secret hype man)
Producer: “How do you think being on the show changed them?”
Mark (thoughtfully): “I think it made them grow up. Not just romantically — like, emotionally. It’s hard to be vulnerable, especially in front of cameras and strangers. But they did it. And they still choose each other, even when it’s boring or annoying.”
Producer: “What’s something you’ve seen between them that people might not?”
Mark (smiling): “Jeno carries Renjun’s sketchbook in his bag when they go out. Even if they’re just going to the store. I don’t think Renjun even knows. That’s love, right?”
🎬 Closing Montage
🎶 Soft music playing. Cut between friends laughing, footage of Jeno and Renjun teasing each other on a couch, and behind-the-scenes clips of them cooking, bickering, and sharing sleepy smiles.
📹 On-screen text:
“Four months later: Still together. Still roasting. Still real.
